What is AFSPA | Why it got extended in Nagaland | Armed forces special powers act
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 жов 2024
- In this video we are going to understand what is AFSPA. And why it got extended in Nagaland.
#afspa #armedforces #nagaland
/ amitsengupta01
/ amitsengupta01
www.kooapp.com...
Hindi Channel
/ @amitsenguptahindi
-- Geography playlist
• Geography terms and de...
-- Economy playlist
• Economics
• Indian Economy - UPSC ...
-- Current Affairs playlist
• UPSC Current Affairs v...
-- Indian history playlist
• Modern History for UPS...
-- Govt of India schemes playlist
• Government of India Sc...
-- Map based learning
• Map based learning
-- Climatology playlist
• Climatology
-- Previous year solved question paper analysis
• Solved Question Papers...
-- Environment & Ecology playlist
• Environment and Ecolog...
-- International relations playlist
• International Relation...
-- Check the other playlists of NCERT Geography videos
Class 6 - goo.gl/DDFtIF
Class 7 - goo.gl/ppPK05
Class 8 - goo.gl/OD3Gwh
Class 9 - goo.gl/AIEXxQ
Class 10 - goo.gl/inWIAR
Class 11 - goo.gl/Pn5EIE
Class 11 (Part 2) - goo.gl/X4zY9K
Class 12 - goo.gl/Kszpz5
@Amit Sengupta. We are happy to hear that you have a clear and narrowed down picture regarding the recent incident in Nagaland. But allow me to clarify two things: Firstly, being in a Democratic country we are entitled to have our own opinions regarding any subject or matter, but that doesn't make the wrong- right or vice versa, so speaking on behalf of what Nagas want was not correct because we strongly disagree with your statement of us Nagas wanting to keep AFSPA and continue with it. You may not know the history of how much our Grandparents and parents have suffered during their time, but let me remind you that innocent civilians suffered a lot. During those those times no one had phones and internet connectivity, otherwise if those incidents were to happen today your narration and take on AFSPA will surely change.
Secondly, in order to make you understand our past and history it would mean for us to sit and discuss long hours, which is not possible, So my humble request is, while AFSPA may have had the right motives to start with but it has harmed innocent civilians all the more. Human life is just a one time and we cannot count it as a mistake or error in terms of people's life's. One lost soul may not affect you much but to those going through the grief it's unthinkable.
Jai Hind! Innocent lives matter#Repeal AFSPA.
They don't give a shit, they are just showing fake sympathy without any real concern about the plight of our land. No Naga wants a law that empowers mainland Indians to shoot us like they are hunting chickens, cause that's the reality, they can shoot at will. Pathetic video.
!!!
Your emotions are definitely respectable, but after repel afspa the insurgents will not allow peace, because it is of sure funded and being provoke by the enemy nabour.
Repeling suddenly is not a good solution, like former afspa imposed state tripura etc. It will automatically be felt that now its time for #repel
कहते है न, जल्दी का काम शैतान का🙏
DUMB
@@GauravKumar-tc8hz insurgent aren't terrorist get this the insurgent are the nagamese who aren't happy with the govt and want more freedom they usually common civilians turned insurgent not terrorist they aren't killing the innocent civilians the army has killed more civilians and the point is we deserved the same right as you aren't we indian and if we can't have it why be part of india at all
Beautiful explanation. To read the pain and suffering our brothers from NE had to go through, I think it needs to be looked upon and critical changes need to be made, at the earliest.
Thank you
Thank you Sir , we get very clear viewpoint from your videos...I request you to be more frequent with the current issues, really helpful for us...
Thank you sir... most of your videos are really helpful.
But today's video on AFSPA seems to be a shallow explanation. The recent Oting massacre is not the only reason , we need to look back into the history of AFSPA since its implementation. Much damaged have been done than good by AFSPA , in the name of hunting down insurgencies many innocent people have been killed, raped, tortured by our own Indian Army. People of northeast are also evolving as the world evolved so you can't still implement 1958 Act. we love Indian Army ,many young people are aspiring to become one of them. I strongly believe that in a country like India there can be better law in place of this DRACONIAN LAW (AFSPA) to wipe out insurgencies from NE India.
Lol massacre ? Btw Thanks for referring it as Holocaust.
I dont know a lot about the north east but afspa is needed in j and k because many in kashmir (not all but still many) are relgious extremists and dont wanna live peacefully and co exist with people of other religion. They want a relgious state. Dont know a lot about north east but unlike kashmir many in north east dont hate india and many even fight for India in our army.
@@aryan5593 just read about the fake encounters happened in Manipur bro
@@arunstalii3666 what are you talking about . You are saying Kashmiris do not fight for India? Have you heard of j&k police , SOG , who are they then ? They are present in every encounter .
@@arunstalii3666 "I don't know a lot about the North east", yeah you can stop there. If you don't know enough, stop poking in and giving half baked arguments. You don't know a tiny but of the terror that people of the North East have to go through for several decades now because of this draconian law which empowers devils to create hell in our region.
Repealing AFSPA doesn't mean there won't be military presence, it actually means taking away the rights of the army to do whatever they want. Yes, mistakes do happen but if it happens repeatedly, it can no longer count as a mistake. There are Several cases of the army abusing the civilians, girls taken advantaged, etc. Also, NSCN Khaplang was considered a terrorist group and they are not allowed in the Naga region of India too. The army in the Naga region is the NSCN IM who are actively in dialogue with the Indian Government.
Actually this is one of the difficult problems the world is facing. Violence in such region due to whichever the reason might be pulls in law enforcement. Law enforcement is under pressure generally because of the asymmetric nature of the conflict. Imagine a scenario where a terrorist goes and hides among kin. Terrorist can hit soldiers without regard to fellow citizens and take refuge among kin but a soldier is only supposed to hit a terrorist without harming others. As the provocations from both sides escalate, the line between 'soldier' and a 'terrorist' blurs gradually and both get increasingly indiscriminate (However we still need soldiers but not terrorists). It is the duty of responsible adults to pull their children away from separatist and domestic insurgent movements. They are attractive because such aspirations appear noble and easily accessible. It is much more difficult to make a real career when this type of 'fatal attraction' is close by. I feel bad for border areas where they need lot of abstinence to avoid joining the 'noble' causes (whichever they are) and focus on making a career and building a sane society. This is particularly important because building real careers is not easy even in those areas that are not affected by insurgencies. May all be blessed with enough strength to overcome the stressful times and build safe and peaceful societies.
You know the ill effect of AFSPA only once if you have lived in a place under which it comes because I've lived back in the 90ties when Tripura was considered disturb due to insurgency. Army shot dead quite a number of innocent people whom I personally knew are indeed innocent just because of suspect, including one mentally ill person because he criticized them. You have to fear for your life every second either from insurgents or army. This is just one incident in my village alone. Male earning members are picked out of their house at night suddenly and beaten black and blue infront of wife and children who became permanently disabled just because the family provided food to the insurgents. If he didn't do the insurgents will kill the family.
If you experience this law with your family, I'm sure 💯 percent you'll also not support AFSPA.
AFSPA in any form is draconian and cruel law. It is undemocratic as it violates the right to life under article 21 of our constitution. It's a British era law still in use.
But now there is peace in manipur tripura assam meghalaya but why not in nagaland? Why don't naga terrorist wanting separate country just give up their arms and ammunitions?
AFSPA must not be repelled until and unless NSCN k and IM completely dissolve
It's just lose - lose situation for commoners
That's why these insugencies should be settled asap so that they don't grow and civilians can take a side. Otherwise there's no choice for civilians than calculating each move.
I feel sorry for you, but North East including Nagaland is an inalienable part of India, it will not be allowed to be used by Chinese as proxies. So until and unless these secessionist give up their arms and surrender AFSPA will not and must not be repealed.
Now, if Tripura had never been imposed with AFSPA, and the insurgents would have got their way, do you think it would be a more peaceful/ democratic situation? Since the govt went full throttle over the insurgents, now there's peace, and there's no AFSPA now. I knw it sounds insensitive. I wish I could feel your pain, but I can imagine those years would have been horrible. But there are bad people, there's enemies to nations, there's political opportunists, there's utterly selfish separatist groups who only care about themselves. What else could we have done? I am happy that the future generation of Tripura does not have to go through such a hell again and peace stays there as in other parts of the country. Again, I am very sorry for your experience.
We need ancient and medieval history crash course sir
its there search it was done in 2018 but its clear cut
ua-cam.com/channels/_6fF053kwx-Cy15Qv7kgyQ.html
Famous saying - you will find paradise under the shade of sword.
5000 साल के इतिहास में 5000 युद्ध हुए , कब स्वर्ग बनी धरती ???
@@raya_ashok Acha sa Ghar baithe, maa baap ke saat rekhe, haat pe mobile, mobile be unlimited data, jo chahe wo movie dekho, jisko jo marji wo comments karo. Is kalyug me isse jyada swarg apko kaha milega bhai saab. Tera comment ko dobara padle bete tuje tho North Korea ya Myanmar me paida hona tha... Jai hind 🇮🇳
@@chandrasekharreddy6605 savage reply 😂😆
My saying: People can't really empathize with victims until they themselves experience the same.
Standing on shore and instructing the ones who are drowning seems a very noble job.
@@arnabphonglosa1147 see you have to choose the bigger picture
Thankyou for providing us with such great Content Sir! 🙏
The demand for revoking afspa is not only a byproduct of the recent killings of Konyak civilians in Oting. Nagas (and all everyone under afspa) have collectively suffered under the act foe years; a history that brings tears and sadness to us when our grandparents narrate their sufferings to us. Though the sufferings were great, people were finally trying to move on in prospect of a peaceful future and willing to make amends with the Armed forces that oppressed us for so long. However, the Oting incident clearly indicates that the sentiment is not shared and the people are not ready to allow these "human errors" or "mistakes" to destroy lives and pull us back to the dark times.
The motive behind the demand for the revoking of afspa is far more humanitarian and civil rights grounds than it is political as people may assume.
While looking at it from a bird's eye perspective, it might seem like a genius way to "united the nation and keep it peaceful " but what is peace if the cries of the people in small provinces are it's price?
agreed
The fear left behind by them will never be understood by someone who never heard the true stories or lived under afspa
i support it was never made for long time purpose
U r right.
Without AFSPA the rebels will only grow stronger. There isn't really a simple exit from this conflict. AFSPA has permanently ended separatism in other north eastern states. It's better to weed out rebels completely than to keep generations drenched in this conflict.
Sir with due regards i have learnt from you so many things but I disagree some points you have mentioned in this. Paying the highest respect to Indian army for thier sacrifice to our nation.... but Afspa has actually damage more than good. In ground reality people like us are suffering from two ways from our own insurgence and the army... there is a history of oinam village massacre and I believe all humanity have par it’s limit and the incidents still carry on by the army. We have many armies from north east too and we want to get rid of insurgency but the act of damage can never be justified. So I won’t agree when you said many support afspa... people have seen the outcome and it did not really help but brought more damage. The trust deficit has been developed by the people and without the cooperation of locals there wont be desired outcome to both the people and government.
Thankyou so much sir 🙏
The best part is when you speak some lines in Hindi .. really that connect us deeply with the topic
And gives insights views of Topics 🙏🙏🤗🤗
Information & presentation superb...
It would have been great if you would have had mentioned IROM SHARMILA.
Worth watching your videos..!👍🏿
Thank you Sir.
Love from Nagaland 👍🏿
In order to undertand the history of AFSPA in Nagaland, why don't you make a video on Naga Peace Accord 2015 between GOI and NSCN IM.
I love your videos sir your videos are so much informative in such a detailed way . Sir please make more frequently videos on knowledgeable contents ❤️❤️❤️
Thanks sir 😊 eagerly waiting for your valuable class 😊 ....... Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳❤️
It's a draconian law. Many innocent people lost their lives because of AFSPA.
Brilliantly covered the topic and every aspect of it. Thank you
Ur video featuring goosebumps for the nation 🙏
very much informative video.. thank u sooo much sir.
and support from Assam❤️
Thank you so much sir for such videos. God bless you and keep making such videos ,it's very helpful.
I have been in nagaland for 3 years such a beautiful place.. I have so many naga friends too.... But I have seen lot if horrible things too... Seen by friend and his family killed and people with swords running in market and People running in horror..... My naga friends say that AFSPA is mostly needed and mostly people support it but don't show because of fear ..
As army doesn't know who is with them it's greatly needed that people come in support with army so they can differentiate between INDIANs and MILITANTs...... .
@@lkikhi8629 excuse me did I say that nagas are not supporting...... Plz read it once again... Before replying
I have been to Hindi speaking belt of India... They region is highly urbanized but too much pollution... I have so many friends their... But I have seen horrible things too... People their get robbed, ragged and looted in broad daylight... Women are unsafe... Crime rate on women is high... Even a mother is not safe inside his own home... People would not tolerate couples holding hand in public but public lynching is tolerated and people would choose to ignore if any crime takes place in open public... Most of the people are uncivilized... My mainlander friends say that the region need more stronger law to control the savages their.... As administration cannot solve this problem as they have to deal with anpar gawar people their so while India need to come out in the support of administration...
@@pariwanglen2860 I really understand what you want to say strict laws need to apply every part of the India as there are lots of issues all around... I live in Delhi and everyone knows how it is... But the thing is can you say by looking at people face that are criminals or a good person... So army is doing there work according to information they are getting and there very less people whom they trust so it's our duty to support them so they can differentiate between Indian and militants .....we can't lose parts of India and Indians as we have to pakistani and china....and about crimes and other things it's all over the world. But It doesn't mean that crime is OK and these crimes doesn't need army.....it need good humen power its about how we react to it ...we sitting and talking about it and that strict laws should be made why are not we stand up to make strict laws.... Ghar tavhi saf ho skta hai jab bahar se kachada na aaye or ghar ki gandgi bahar nikali jaye....
@@sangeetnanda6163 So you mean if army can't differentiate public and insurgents than they can kill anyone including children, rape or molest women, beat up the old elderly people, burn down houses and villages??? You should know that, insurgency is not the problem but result of the problem and AFSPA is not the solution but part of the problem... You are a mainlander and it's obvious that you will take side of colonial hegemony of central power over NE... You have never known and you will never know what NE have went through in last 60 years... All you want is our land and resources... The coast of our lives is worthless to you people... You people don't have any right to kill our brothers... If you are so much concern about ending of insurgency in NE than support us in restoring our political rights.... And I don't understand what you just wrote in Hindi...
@@pariwanglen2860 sorry if you misunderstood me I didn't say that if army cannot differentiate then it gets power of killing any one... I just want to say we can atleast help them... And secondly you said your resources and your land..... I know that you are extremely unhappy about the loss but atleast respect the people who died or our unity..... Being now living in delhi doesn't make me main land.. People... I come from a state who gets shadowed by popular state.... And dear you want army to go away.... And do you have any alternative to army.... If yes then propose it to government at least at any cost it must be solved..... It's not about insurgent but about using your rights as well as doing your duties......in hindi ...i wrote we have to clean our house by not letting dirt come inside as well as throwing inside dirt out... Because it's our home not your not mine it's our.....
Thanks sir for this informative video... eagerly waiting for it from you. Keep it up Amit sir 💯❤️
This Magical Voice is Therapy .....Sir we demand Current Affair video everyday please
I am a fan of Amit sir
I like the line "If you want peace then be prepare for war"
Thank you sir👍🏻
Very good video. You have very good voice of a teacher. You keep things clear and crisp. Amazing job, Amit! I think we need a video on what is going on with Pakistan, Afghanistan and China.
Guru devobhava 🙏🙏 I was waiting for this video. Thank youu very much for the video
Bring video on regular basis as we're addicted.
Sir ur geography NCERT is very good ,i noted down for my optional
Your Way Of delivering the content is the reason for watching your videos again and again.... Great Efforts sir
I was not aware that i can get addicted to voice!🔥🔥
Nicely explained with clarity of thoughts!! Amazing👌👌
Amit Sir👌🏻
Learned more about my state Nagaland and Konyak tribe
From the South of India i request all people of India to follow the rule of the land. Everyone can overcome poverty from your good efforts. Our peace and prosperity are the result of our good deeds only. Keep your area free from militants and smugglers. Now kerala is also breeding terrorism. If central govt have no otherway to save citizens, there will be a chance to impose afspa with military controlled law and order. Keep peace and save ourselves
Thanks sir for the unbiased analysis
Thank you so much sir.. 🙏 ..u are an inspiration for us along with teacher and guide... 🙏🙏
Rahul
Thankyou dear sir
We need more videos related to other topics
Thankyou
Thank you ❤️ eagerly waiting your lecture 🙏🏿🙏🏿
The beautiful bitter truth 2:09 - 2:29. Wonderfully summaries how to run a country.
Pronam neben Sir🙏
Thank you so much sir....🙏🏻😊🙏🏻
Sir we want more videos on current issues in details as you always provide in very short and crisp way
Your Hindi touch in videos are really very nice to hear.
Sir please make videos on polity,and CURRENT AFFAIRS...
In many decades ASFPA was done inhuman act in Nagaland liked,torture,burned down property and rape etc. that we Nagas demanding to repeal ASFPA immediately without delay.
AFSPA or no AFSPA
" Nagalim" will remain a dream
🙄
If some army men did wrong they have to go through punishment
For that ensure no insurgency in your state otherwise Centre has to intervene.. no forceman want to be in insurgent area.. they are also human working 24 hrs in worst possible conditions opposed by public as well.. what you expect their psyche in this situation!!? Human error is very much possible atleast in this condition.. see your own state of mind that you hate them they must also be fed up of working for ungrateful population away from their home..don't know will survive or not!
If you don't want AFSPA, Nagas have to stop supporting terrorists
Good to see you back Amit sir✨💯
Really love your research... Sir..
2:05 our grandparents who lived under AFSPA would disagree with you on that
Yes sir ,we want more videos on current issues . Thank you sir🙏🏼🙏
Such a blessing u r 💖
Wonderful analysis
Couldn't we use drone surveillance systems or satellite imaging to prevent such casualties during operations. For example, monitoring an area with a live satellite feed. Could you please comment on this?
Additionally, we can use ARCAS assault rifles system Israel that are AI-enabled to improve aim on a subject and reduce errors during open fire.
Drones are can be ambush too...so totally can't rely on tht
why can't we use the Anaesthesia bullets, That are used on animals to make them unconscious, Anyway, we can capture foes alive ! : )
@@fabulousindian6582 too much anaesthesia may lead to person death, over this fact, anaesthesia are against the use of military rules if not permitted by commanding officer or high authority, since manpower is so strong and well defined, i think its use is limited.lets hope for further advance technology, as China is deploying robots at LAC ..lol
@@Maverick0111 *LAC ( line of actual control )
@@nirupomdey8738 sry, thank u for ur update ..🙏
Sir ur explanation is jst wow...
Thank you so much sir 💖😌. You are bestest sirji. One request sir... Why don't you try to put current affairs video daily analysis of the Hindu newspaper.😊😁❤️ thank you sir 💖😌
Excellent explanation....
AFSPA looks sexy when implemented in other states but when it comes to ur state then u will realise how suffocating it is..Though complete abolition of afspa is not a soln but reforms in the act should be there regarding accountability
But now there is peace in manipur tripura assam meghalaya but why not in nagaland? Why don't naga terrorist wanting separate country just give up their arms and ammunitions?
By removing AFSPA the Militant Terrorist Groups Will Flourish And Will Attack The people of that area Who'll Not Align with those Fringe Militant Groups And If Indian Forces Are Removed We Will Loose Our Territory and Will have More Problems and Border Issues Than We're Facing Today... Institutions Know There Work and They Are doing it Well and will keep on Doing it to Insure the Integrity of India
@@the.god.of.both.worlds underground groups are nothing more than small gangs . Just like mumbai underworld . Dont get concerned about them , usually police takes care of them
@@vaibhavsingh8361 By keeping Nehru as Prime Minister, you're very happy to lose to his sugar daddy People's Republic of China and losing Aksai Chin, huh? Fucking Nehruvian idealists.
Sir reaquesting you from the heart to plz start the 2 mint series, eagerly waiting for that .thnx in advance
Well said! Hats off 2 u 4 speaking about this 👍
A very nice explanation 🙂🙂.
Wow sir wow wow wow!!!!!! 🙌 you work so hard for these videos, the pictures are self explanatory. And the clarity of thought is just top notch. I'm a defence aspirant and the way you make these videos are nowhere else made.
Thank you 🙏💞🤗
Your English seems top notch. Good, Aastha. And all the best!
Very well explained
The best videos 😍 for UPSC CSE
Sir I was waiting eagerly your video...thank your for bringing this issue to analysis.
Thankyou very much sir please start to make videos on current affairs topic which are realted to upsc syllabus there is no any channel in UA-cam in English language.
I really like your way of expressing and forming sentences .
Please sir
Please sir 🙂
Keep continue to make videos like these for us
Love your videos bro, and my heartful thanks to you for taking this much efforts 🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳
Thank you for this informative video.
thank you sir😄
Sir use hashtags to increase the popularity of the video like #AFSPA bcz ur content is super awesome & needs much more popularity.
It feels wonderful when you speaks in hindi🥰🥰.. And your voice🔥🔥🤩🤩
Don't try on him , he only love bengoli boudi
@@aryan5593 😂Lol he's himself a bengali
Sorry.. many of us not understand both bengali and hindi
Lgta ha ldki pyaar ma hai
Very nice explanation..your way, voice is very nice ...
Sir , If possible please post videos on daily basis your videos are to the point and effective too...
I appreciate your work.
This guy is quite intelligent..
We support AFSPA from Arunachal Pradesh. I believed in my army. Jai hind🇮🇳
Just you?
Happy New Year Mr.Amit 🥳
The Rule is Simple :- "You have to be a soldier who is smart to protect the country from terrorists, No mercy for them"
Yes bro....
Russia-Ukraine-NATO crisis explain plzzzz
Very accurate and smooth ... 🙏
I Agree.
Bro , the question is miss-ussing of the AFSPA act,by the Indian Armed forces, against the Nagas and the north eastern people in general, you said that the NAGALAND police can't handle the law and order situation in Nagaland, what do you think and know about the great NAGALAND police, brother please do not do under estimate the great NAGALAND police 🙏
Please do not underestimate the china and it's intentions
Very informative
If i am not mistaken , the insurgency in Northeast time were all time low and many comission suggest to systematically remove AFPSA
We need to build capacity of police and border police instead of entangling army in insurgency. Army needs to put all of its energy in tackling external threats.
Making India a democracy right after the disastrous partition and independence was the most foolish thing to have happened . It should have given time to the country to stabilize properly and develop itself before making it a democracy in federal structure .
Those another 12 minutes i need for reading comments in Amit sir's videos>>>>>>
Thanks for the explanation sir .... If possible increase the frequencies of videos..
"Anyhow, I'm not trying to justify what happened in Nagaland.." Yes u r though. It's very easy to live in a place where these kind of things don't happen & lecture ppl (eg. Ppl from NE states where AFSPA is imposed on) who in reality r dealing with such issues everyday. But u r entitled to ur opinion & so r others who think dat d human rights violation like beating & killing d locals "mistakenly" & raping & preying upon d local women & even kids dat r happening under d guise of special arms privilege act must be stopped.
True, I live in Delhi but will never support a law like AFSPA which infringes on fundamental rights and sows distrust and hatred against govt.
This a colonial era law and this must be repealed.
what an explanation sir ...👍🔥🔥🙌🙌👏👏
Sir, let me Say One think.. I get distracted by hearing your voice... 😅 You have a Very beautiful n Sweet voice.🤩MashaAllah❣️Lots of love 💛 SHUKRAN SIR 😌
You wet?
Everytime your new video is released i can't wait a second to start watching 😀.
Wonderful explanation sir👌👌👌
it was awesome 👍
Great video sir.
Thank YOU ' Armed forces do everything to rectify their mistakes n takes actions against tos who r' guilty '...14 innocent lives lost in Nagaland due 2 tis draconian laws of AFSPA will tey ever get Justice'??Only time will tell😔
AFSPA is just doing their duty
Not just 14
Finally master piece has come
Please include Hindi more often your .videos are very informative.
Issi ka intzaar tha 🔥🔥
Sir can u pls make a complete video on the current Ukraine crisses
Nobody explains it better than Amit Sengupta ...
Sir make video on SRI LANKAN INFLATION AND ECONOMY