This incredible performance "takes off" already after a few seconds,when Carrington and Miller sets the groove..then.. it´s just to sit back and enjoy for 12 minutes!! And as I figure.. ,,this is not an easy piece of music to deliver with such a "flow" as they do here!! Thank you Herbie for all the fabulous jazz-funk-music!!!
except for the ending.. which must've really bummed her way out. It would've me. Once they lock in at the top otherwise stellar performance bringing this incredible piece of music. Roy's look over says it all.." where are you baby?"
This is a real good "live" rendition of Actual Proof ... the best I've seen. However, it's still a cover of the masterpiece created by Herbie Hancock and his Headhunters in 1973, which can't be improved upon. The band was comprised of Hancock (keyboards), Bennie Maupin (reeds), Mike Clark (drums), Paul Jackson (bass), and Bill Summers (percussion).
Anybody who knows this really appreciate The history you're sharing on Herbie Hancock and this particular tune "Actual Proof" thanks for educating people. Being a late teen(and a early musician) when it came out, my ear immediately matured.
Ah course it can be improved upon. Versions in the last ten years take this tune to places they couldn’t have imagined back then. This isn’t one of the best live performances imo and it’s still insanely killing
As a guy who’s never had much money (and has spent a lot of time in the “hinterlands” of America), I’ve never had a chance to catch Herbie live. I’m making up for lost time on UA-cam. One of the things I’ve noticed is that, over the years, Herbie played more and more piano during his live performances, even when he was doing his electric stuff from the 70s (like this tune). I would have thought that the Rhodes would sound better in this kind of context, but I’m really digging the piano.
Wow...what an amazing performance of this all time fav by this all star cast of great musicians... while I will always b a tad partial to the original I would not b disappointed if this was all I had left of the two...Marcus Miller is an absolute beast and he kept Paul Jackson’s bass line to this cut just as funky...can’t get over all the fantastic artist that cam 2gether for this performance but damn how I wish I had been in attendance...😭
That bass line is extreme, if you think its easy, ask the bassist for the Roots: Herbie guested on Jimmy Fallon and the played "Actual Proof" and the bassist was LOST! Marcus Miller = DON DADA of the bass.
Spoiler alert: the roots are hacks, not real players. They coast on their fake names and cool guy friends. But put them onstage stage with any of these people and they get eaten alive and exposed as the frauds they are, like you saw.
@@stanley-fghijk441 ... The Roots are NOT HACKS!!! they are a hip-hop, funk band!. you will be hard pressed to find ANY musician that can play this tune short of real JAZZ musicians!!!
@@cDTeVe You literally proved my point. Hahaha!!! They're hacks, not real players. Real players can crush any style. And actual proof? That's a funk/fusion classic. The roots couldn't hang cuz they're frauds and all real players know this. But white boys loooooove them 🤣🤣🤣
I like this version but the original version on Thrust (if that is the original...please correct me if I am wrong), will always be the penultimate version of this song as it just flows and has a crazyness about it that I haven't heard in any other ensemble with Herbie. So far that is the best version for me.
+rspexperiment THANK YOU FOR THAT TAD BIT HISTORY....THIS SONG IS JUST DOPE...JUST FUCKING DOPE...THE HORN PLAYER REALLY GETS OFF INTO THIS SONG AND SOLO...HE REALLY FELT THIS SONG...AND MARCUS....
+ManiK MIKE CLARK IS A FUNKY BOY ON THE ORIGINAL FOR SURE...BUT HEY THIS VERSION KICKS AZZ...AS IT SEEMS THE MUSUCIANS PLAYED IT FROM THE HEART...THATS THE ONLY WAY YOU CAN PLAY THIS SONG IS BY FEEL AND SOUL....AND ITS ALOT OF HEART AND SOUL ON THIS STAGE
Even though Marcus Miller probably gets closer than the others, no one does this song like Paul Jackson. I'm guessing it's a question of style. Somehow Jackson makes the line sound very nimble and light.
in this tune, in my opinion, the bassist is the one with the bigger chance of screwing everything. the bassist must be creative even with the written bassline, besides doing all the breaks. is hard to keep the time and groove and be aware of the structure. im studying this piece now, and fews version of this tune in youtube are good. the best ones besides the indefectible original with mike clark and paul jackson are from tribal tech, chris dave and this one where marcus is killin. he missed the coda though. hehe
Bartosz Borzeszkowski yeah, ive seen that one... definitively not my favorite. master collaiutta (whos im a HUGE fan) is fuckin everywhere. tal looks not fully confident to me. and herbie doesnt look confortable like he looks here. haha im sorry, im a fan of the outstanding work of tal wilkenfeld. shes amazing! i just think that not everyday is a good day. :)
Bartosz Borzeszkowski and believe me: get this groove right AND in the right feel is just plain fuckin hard. paul jacksons original with mike clark is just mind fuckin blowing.
Herbie Hancock - Actual Proof (Experience Montreux) ~1080p HD please dont take so serious my opinion. they are all world level top notch musicians. i just did a plain cold analysis and you can freely disagree.
Attorney Ben Crump J.D. what is the chance of South African Dr. Ed Jones PhD and Susan Jones M.D. a kinfolk? How did Susan matriculate at Washington University School of Medicine. White Arab Muslim. Grace Jones description of Susan backwards.
And how is that overplaying compared to Mike Clark's original drumming? Unless you never listened to the original... if anything she's underplaying compared to Mike.
THIS IS JUST A BADDDD ZZZ VERSION OF THIS SONG...THIS BAND GROOVES THE FUCK OUT OF THIS SONG... THE HORN PLAYER KICKS RAW ASS ON HIS SOLO...SO MUCH FEEL....
Honestly not that impressed with Terri Lyne...I thought she good go off a little and go outside the groove a little. Maybe bounce off of Herbie a little more. I don't feel the pocket. Vinnie Colaiuta killed it in my opinion.
+Joseph Lopez Vinnie Colaiuta is also Vinnie Colaiuta. I love the guy but to expect that level of interaction from everyone is a little absurd considering Vinnie is the only guy who can do what he does the way he does it. If you could pick a person to not be impressed by I'd pick Roy for attempting to start the head of the tune way too early.
Wah Wah Watson is my uncle and he is that dude on rhythm guitar!!! Check his credits!!!!!!!
djcoolcliff aye he grooving though
royalty
Holy geez, that guy was on some serious records.
Dude when I think of swaggy rhythm guitarist, I think of your uncle in this video hahahaa the hat is 100% V I B E
lionel is not your uncle dude lol
THIS SONGS ROCKS WITH MARCUS MILLER
HE IS TRULY AMAZING....
Teri Lynn Carrington is Smokin' !! Pushing the Groove, along with Herbie, while riding with Marcus Miller.
This is so good. Thanks for uploading. Should have been on American television in 2005.
Really miss Roy. He was amazing to watch. Marcus is the MAN hands-down kids.
dude Roy's story makes me SO sad. saw Marcus and Herbie (separately) at SJ Jazz, life complete. Long live Roy
This incredible performance "takes off" already after a few seconds,when Carrington and Miller sets the groove..then.. it´s just to sit back and enjoy for 12 minutes!! And as I figure.. ,,this is not an easy piece of music to deliver with such a "flow" as they do here!! Thank you Herbie for all the fabulous jazz-funk-music!!!
Agreed 💯 couldn't say it any better.. yes!
Also don't forget the inimitable sound of Wah Wah Watson with his guitar.
Terri Lynn Carrington is excellent , throughout. Fantastic.
except for the ending.. which must've really bummed her way out. It would've me. Once they lock in at the top otherwise stellar performance bringing this incredible piece of music. Roy's look over says it all.." where are you baby?"
Terry is killing it on the drums....awesome drummer!
Except for the ending which she totally blows. Roy gives her "the Look" the WTF look..she keeps smiling, but nope.
.
Con una mostro como terry lynn🙇🏼♂️🙇🏽♂️🙇🏽🙇🏾🙇🏻♀️🙇🏾♂️🙇🏿♂️🙇🏻♀️🙏🏼🙇🏼♀️🙇♀️🙇🏼♀️🙇🏾🙇🏼🙇🏽♂️🙇🏾♂️🙇🏾♂️🙇🏽♂️🙇🏽♂️🙏🏽🙇🏾♂️🙇🏾♂️🙇🏼🙇🏼🙇🏾🙇🏿♂️🙇🏾♂️🙇🏿🙇🙇♀️
This is a real good "live" rendition of Actual Proof ... the best I've seen. However, it's still a cover of the masterpiece created by Herbie Hancock and his Headhunters in 1973, which can't be improved upon. The band was comprised of Hancock (keyboards), Bennie Maupin (reeds), Mike Clark (drums), Paul Jackson (bass), and Bill Summers (percussion).
yes i thought so to...very good version...
Anybody who knows this really appreciate The history you're sharing on Herbie Hancock and this particular tune "Actual Proof" thanks for educating people.
Being a late teen(and a early musician) when it came out, my ear immediately matured.
Ah course it can be improved upon. Versions in the last ten years take this tune to places they couldn’t have imagined back then. This isn’t one of the best live performances imo and it’s still insanely killing
As a guy who’s never had much money (and has spent a lot of time in the “hinterlands” of America), I’ve never had a chance to catch Herbie live. I’m making up for lost time on UA-cam. One of the things I’ve noticed is that, over the years, Herbie played more and more piano during his live performances, even when he was doing his electric stuff from the 70s (like this tune). I would have thought that the Rhodes would sound better in this kind of context, but I’m really digging the piano.
could watch miller jam all day long
ALWAYS lifts my spirits!!!!!
Great rendition. Loueke has a fascinating style.
the smile roy had after solo explains how killin these cats are!!!
YES I LOVED THAT LIKE HE JUST CAME DOWN OFF OF A HIGH!!
this band is stack wit Legends
A monster, some donuts, a cigarette, and this is a excellect way to start my day
Herbie is the only part of that picture that’s healthy....but he might just be good enough for you to balance out the rest 😂
Herbie Hancock, Terri Lyne Carrington & Marcus Miller & Roy Hargrove will be part of the #Jazzday webcast April 30 live from Osaka on jazzday.com
respect to marcus . thats how you groove.
Here they go again, just" jamming Again" Awesome!
Wow...what an amazing performance of this all time fav by this all star cast of great musicians... while I will always b a tad partial to the original I would not b disappointed if this was all I had left of the two...Marcus Miller is an absolute beast and he kept Paul Jackson’s bass line to this cut just as funky...can’t get over all the fantastic artist that cam 2gether for this performance but damn how I wish I had been in attendance...😭
I wish MM played more stuff like this.
Je vous adore musique très exceptionnel ,vous êtes des vrai pro, bravo !!!
Fantastic .Polyrhythms amazing !
Those solos ... are from another dimension 🤯🤯
even Daniel ponce !!!!
THE SINGLE MOST IMPORTANT MESSAGE YOU CAN EVER GIVE ANYONE IS SOUL EXIST BECAUSE OF GODS LOVE FOR IT...1 800 LOVE GOD AND 1 888 I SING HU
...HU AM I...HU ARE HU 🐝🌈💫
RIP roy RIP wha wha!!!! they played together they left together !!may the force be with you
Killer groove love all the musicians great great upload
Terri, seriously....wow. SO MUCH GROOVE.
Amazing performance!
i like thisssssss yeah ooooeehhh
That bass line is extreme, if you think its easy, ask the bassist for the Roots: Herbie guested on Jimmy Fallon and the played "Actual Proof" and the bassist was LOST! Marcus Miller = DON DADA of the bass.
carlton white it is ! Any bassist will tell you 👍🏿 It’s amazing how “easy” it sounds though
yeah im saw that they butchered the dayum song- i mean like it had a lost feel to it...lol
Spoiler alert: the roots are hacks, not real players. They coast on their fake names and cool guy friends. But put them onstage stage with any of these people and they get eaten alive and exposed as the frauds they are, like you saw.
@@stanley-fghijk441 ... The Roots are NOT HACKS!!! they are a hip-hop, funk band!. you will be hard pressed to find ANY musician that can play this tune short of real JAZZ musicians!!!
@@cDTeVe You literally proved my point. Hahaha!!! They're hacks, not real players. Real players can crush any style. And actual proof? That's a funk/fusion classic. The roots couldn't hang cuz they're frauds and all real players know this. But white boys loooooove them 🤣🤣🤣
so cool roy!!
hey guys that's music
Wah Wah Watson still hanging in WOW.
Mark S Malone Sr That’s my uncle!!!! He is a monster and has been killing it for years!!!!
Rest In Peace Roy
Terry Lynn Carrington-I want to meet you closer
Gold
Wah Wah Watson
Jeff D Wah Wah is my uncle!!! He is that dude...still!!!!!
May he RIP
Thank you !
I like this version but the original version on Thrust (if that is the original...please correct me if I am wrong), will always be the penultimate version of this song as it just flows and has a crazyness about it that I haven't heard in any other ensemble with Herbie. So far that is the best version for me.
+rspexperiment THANK YOU FOR THAT TAD BIT HISTORY....THIS SONG IS JUST DOPE...JUST FUCKING DOPE...THE HORN PLAYER REALLY GETS OFF INTO THIS SONG AND SOLO...HE REALLY FELT THIS SONG...AND MARCUS....
+ManiK MIKE CLARK IS A FUNKY BOY ON THE ORIGINAL FOR SURE...BUT HEY THIS VERSION KICKS AZZ...AS IT SEEMS THE MUSUCIANS PLAYED IT FROM THE HEART...THATS THE ONLY WAY YOU CAN PLAY THIS SONG IS BY FEEL AND SOUL....AND ITS ALOT OF HEART AND SOUL ON THIS STAGE
penultimate means second to last.
So true
Love you Terry Lynn🥰😘🫂🥁
this is band is stat with Legends
Most Excellent - great ensemble of players! Thanks for sharing!
Rip Roy Hargove
Good
Christian Scott and Ambrose Akinsmusire are awesome trumpeters, but Roy Hargrove is sooooooo smooth and pure. And Terry is great.
herbie you are are a fucking master at jazz..and you still look great man....are you like 40 or something...
Ever wonder why you've never seen him and Tay Zonday at the same time?
Suuuuuuper!!!!! Roy is a baaaad trumpet player!!!!
Muy bueno (cristina)
oh yeah
Secret Service mike feels good. OK Ben Crump JD?
O
🙌🏾🙌🏾
Even though Marcus Miller probably gets closer than the others, no one does this song like Paul Jackson. I'm guessing it's a question of style. Somehow Jackson makes the line sound very nimble and light.
So Hargrove doesn't age? Great show guys!
wauw...
RIP Wah Wah
kills....
é disso que eu to falando;;;
Τρέλα
If I can't get reply to Q i'd soon stop responding,thax
Giant bang
...and so there is a woman drummer!!!!!!! Brilliant Lyne Carrington...
Check version …. the original Thrust,,.
Roy at 7:21!!!
The old guard get it - Herbie, Miller and Carrington. Loueke and Hargrove don't make the changes. That matters.
Don't know what version you're listening to, but trust me: both Roy and Lionel are more than clear about the changes to this tune.
in this tune, in my opinion, the bassist is the one with the bigger chance of screwing everything. the bassist must be creative even with the written bassline, besides doing all the breaks. is hard to keep the time and groove and be aware of the structure.
im studying this piece now, and fews version of this tune in youtube are good. the best ones besides the indefectible original with mike clark and paul jackson are from tribal tech, chris dave and this one where marcus is killin.
he missed the coda though. hehe
Bartosz Borzeszkowski yeah, ive seen that one... definitively not my favorite. master collaiutta (whos im a HUGE fan) is fuckin everywhere. tal looks not fully confident to me. and herbie doesnt look confortable like he looks here. haha
im sorry, im a fan of the outstanding work of tal wilkenfeld. shes amazing! i just think that not everyday is a good day. :)
Bartosz Borzeszkowski and believe me: get this groove right AND in the right feel is just plain fuckin hard. paul jacksons original with mike clark is just mind fuckin blowing.
Yup
Would you happen to have a link for the Tal Winkelfeld version? I can't seem to find it.
Herbie Hancock - Actual Proof (Experience Montreux) ~1080p HD
please dont take so serious my opinion. they are all world level top notch musicians. i just did a plain cold analysis and you can freely disagree.
Did the horn or synth come in at the wrong time?
この時のROYはノってるなぁ！
the bass is outstanding, but all musicians that play Herbie, has to be
Lmao 3:12 Herbie look like he bout bust
i bout bust too
Did Roy start too soon?
UH OH!
Attorney Ben Crump J.D. what is the chance of South African Dr. Ed Jones PhD and Susan Jones M.D. a kinfolk? How did Susan matriculate at Washington University School of Medicine. White Arab Muslim. Grace Jones description of Susan backwards.
HA ha ha ha yeah man Herbie is like 40 or something ! ! ! ! Even 11 years ago back in the stone (age) day.
@ 7:24 get ready for all sorts of groove in your face
And how is that overplaying compared to Mike Clark's original drumming? Unless you never listened to the original... if anything she's underplaying compared to Mike.
Drummer?
Terri Lyne Carrington
I think part of it is that she's a bit high in the mix and Herbie's a bit low. In my opinion.
You need VIZCAINO ON CONGAS !!!!
A CUBAN ...OR PEDRITO THE YOUNG KILLER GENERATION...
FIRE THE CONGA PLAYER !!!!! WHY DoeS HERBIE ALWAYS DO THIS !!!?????
Sooooo many GREAT cuban congueros !!!!!
WHERE ARE THE REAL CONGA PLAYERS,,,, GIOVANNI , PEDRITO , YOSVANI , CHANGUITO ETC ....PUT A FUCKIN' KILLER CONGA PLAYER !!!!
THIS IS JUST A BADDDD ZZZ VERSION OF THIS SONG...THIS BAND GROOVES THE FUCK OUT OF THIS SONG... THE HORN PLAYER KICKS RAW ASS ON HIS SOLO...SO MUCH FEEL....
Flugel
blazers starten het thema te vroeg.. lelijk op dit niveau.
Honestly not that impressed with Terri Lyne...I thought she good go off a little and go outside the groove a little. Maybe bounce off of Herbie a little more. I don't feel the pocket. Vinnie Colaiuta killed it in my opinion.
+Joseph Lopez Vinnie Colaiuta is also Vinnie Colaiuta. I love the guy but to expect that level of interaction from everyone is a little absurd considering Vinnie is the only guy who can do what he does the way he does it. If you could pick a person to not be impressed by I'd pick Roy for attempting to start the head of the tune way too early.
+Chris Hicks I would have to agree with u on that. Good point
Roy plays his ass off on here! Miscommunication happens sometimes, it'd be silly to write off his entire performance because of a miscue.
You're either deaf or just hatin' on the sistah.
Joseph Lopez can you play better than her though ?
Always the worst Conga players !!!!!
Que pena
If I can't get reply to Q i'd soon stop responding,thax