Best Budget Mini Crawler Shootout - Axial SCX24 vs Carisma vs Hobby Plus CR-24
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 жов 2024
- Best Cheap and Budget Crawler Shootout - Axial SCX24 vs Carisma vs Banggood or Hobby Plus CR-24
Axial SCX24 2019 Jeep Wrangler (white) - snp.link/3f44297a
Axial SCX24 2019 Jeep Wrangler (yellow) - snp.link/e24b02f9
Axial SCX24 Deadbolt 1/24 - snp.link/59aad795
*New Axial SCX10 III with portals and 2-speed - snp.link/e57b59e9
Axial SCX24 UPGRADES - snp.link/db341e07
Carisma MSA-1E - amzn.to/2LAroTO
Buy your kits and upgrade parts from this Amainhobbies link to support RC Review: snp.link/6640d084
Join the RC Review Facebook Group here: / 302319827122846 for early videos and extra footage.
Excellent review, I love the Axial SCX24, it is such a fun rig. Great looks on all of those little crawlers 🤘🏼🤓👍🏼
Love my Scx24. Looks like the taller tires of the Scx24 is helping get up the ledges. Love your informative and entertains videos, thank you. Just pulled the trigger and ordered the Capra, can’t wait to try it out too.
Is the deadbolt the same as the jeep? Or no
Civicman1975 they are the same.
I am new to the crawling hobby and I am really enjoying your channel. I currently have a SCX10 ii and have a SCX24 (the new gray truck) on order. My wife wants to get into crawling as well so I am contemplating which SCX10 iii I want to get (and pass down the ii to her since it is almost brand new.) Your videos make everything pretty clear and concise and you make a number of common sense suggestions that help guide us newbs down the right path. Thanks for taking the time to shoot, edit and post all the content. I really appreciate it.
Love your channel and jump back and forth through many videos at the moment! Thank you so much for your efforts!
My SCX24 will be showing up tomorrow but the wife says I have to wait tell Christmas to play with.😭 hopefully in the mean time you will do a upgrade video for it. As always love your reviews!
Wait til Christmas? That will be hard!
Excellent shootout. I've been looking at the CR24 and the SCX24. You've made my choice easier, TY👍👍
Right on bud. Happy to help. The SCX24 is good enough to upgrade. So the upgrades are in mail already! :)
At 4:00, the Scx24 doesn't have a drag brake and worm gears can't operate as a drag brake as the gears don't roll. However it does have 3 speed settings and the low speed setting makes for a good crawl gear downhill being controlled by trigger input.
3 speed settings ??????????????
Gears don't roll. Two words dude .. Throttle control
Great vid, cheers! Would love to see axial vs rocksta and hbx 2098B. These are the 3 I keep looking at.
Can't speak for the hbx. But I have the Rocksta and a SCX24. The SCX24 barely gets used. I just personally have more fun with the Rocksta.
Good video. If I personally had the option of paying as much for a no name or off brand as a name brand product, I'd obviously by the Axial due to parts availability.
Very good review style. I own a 1/24 Team Losi crawler. I don’t know if they are still available but I like the worm gear drive.
I've noticed that most videos that include the SCX24 use the yellow body, (I'm new to rock crawlers so don't roast me on this,) but is there any difference between the white and yellow bodies, and if there is then which would you prefer of the two
None I don't think
I think it’s simply cosmetics and which one you personally think looks better
A big thank you for your teaching. I'm brand new in this hobby. I've just completed the WPL B1 kit and have been interested in the small crawlers for some time. I believe you've cleared up which direction I will go!
Best wishes,
Edward
Great video man! Scx24 was driving circles around the other micro cralwers! 🤣
Scx24 is best micro cralwers out hands down! 👍👍👍
Exactly. We understood how good it was only after running with its peers.
People have been saying it breaks down, and the charger gives out after a couple of uses.
Chris V If your talking about the scx24 keep in mind all rtr and blinky light chargers are garbage don’t matter the rc same with rtr servos. For $109-$120 its the best 1/24th scale crawler you can get. The motors fail because they are tiny it’s not hard to over heat when running on soft blankets and pillows.
Dirty water will kill the motor quick to. I’ve had 3 first 1 my buddy has now and it’s still fine other then his kid burnt up the stock motor. I have 2 now and no issues deadbolts servo had lasted months with brass wideners and over weights. The c10 servo only quite because water got in it.
In this hobby any rc can be dead out of the box and any other micro has way more issues then a crappy servo and cheapo charger.
Horizons will just send me a replacement servo. There customer service is great.
Watch my channel to see what the scx24 can really do! 😂
Move the upper shock mounting locations and the scx24 will have tons of travel
Love to see them mini crawlers, for my personal joy i would like too see you guys try out The haiboxing devastator and also The new rgt 1/24 v2 😀
Thank you for that info.
Yeah, I'am already informed about the two. At the moment due to lag of time and money I'am planning to buy an Axial 1/24. The rgt V2 doesn't win against it for me. The Devastator is always on my list and very sexy with the metal parts and little scale view and options to 4 wheel steer. It's a little to slow for me atm and after many videos I feel getting attracted to the scale side. 80€ is cheap for it anyway. There are different names/versions of it too, not so easy to find the right at bangood and co.
You should try the RGT 136240 V2 with the front mounted motor/transmission next to the servo and center transfer case.
Will take a look!
Definitely V2
The mini crawler game is on fire right now! Have you tried the AutoRc Geko Gk-24, or the Orlandoo Hunter ?
It seems that I'am a metal fetishist. Short before ordering the Axial I found the Gecko and boom I'am again fighting with my budget and timewindows.
Same story before at 1/10 with this one here banggood.app.link/XKeKpoclv7
But adding a nice remote and a brushless and full metal servo and a nice esc and lipo and again it's very expensive. Also don't wanna buy so high value things on bangood and also pay tax on top.
Will calculate the gecko but think my first crawler will be the axial 1/24. If I'am getting addicted I can buy the others anyway and try to sell some stuff before, like my TAMIYA Vanquish '88.
Love the review! Probably pick up an Axial at some point....but just ordered one of the new WPL CK44M 1/16. Interested to see how it does. Also looking forward to your Gen8 Axe review.......maybe a 3 way shootout...Gen8 Axe vs. Vs4 Pro vs. trx4 sport Modded? 😁😁😁
We should have the Gen8 by Wednesday!! Oh what fun it is to drive.
Can’t wait!! Hoping it really is as good as I am hoping. Will definitely buy one if it is👍
Ordered the scx24 before i watched this vid...i made the right choice👍
At least the Carisma has optional OIL filled Shocks, that can be added to the other two! 😜
Carmine ✈🚂🚙🎄🎅
love it
@@derrickwilliams2903 ANYTHING could use a little less bouncy, and better control...
But this is a Hobby, and individual choice is key.
My 10th scale Kyosho Rock Force has axles like the scx 24. That thing is stuck where you leave it. Nice in depth review bro!
Ahh... worm drive. It is so stiff when turned from the tires we thought we broke it. :)
Awesome ride there, dude! Looks like a fantastic track! 😃
About the URUAV, it's a pretty new brand even on Banggood. The best thing I ever got from them is a stick mat to help hold batteries on quadcopters. And I have a pretty nice carbon filter frame from them as well. 😊
Anyway, in my case Banggood is my only option. Because I'm from Brazil. 😕
Brazil for the win!! Thanks bud for the recommendations.
@@RCReviewChannel Thank you for all the tips you always give! 😊
I picked the scx24 Aldo I actually bought one yellow too!!! Yup hank you for your information
Nice! Didn't know you're from the bay?? I live near Sheldons! Thanks for the reviews!
Are there aftermarket shocks with oil that will fit the Axial?
Would be VERY interested to see you review the Panda Hobby Tetra X1 1/18.
I have heard good things but have yet to see a through trusted review. You all do a great job at RC Review, thanks!
RC Review - I would love to see you cover the Panda Hobby Tetra X1 1/18...features on paper sound amazing - oil shocks, leds system etc....
@@keepingitonehundred yes, I would like to see also . I had the deadbolt axial 24 . Traded it . I kind of miss it.
Looks pretty good. Pricey though. Body does not look good and the throttle seems jerky. Amain has a great video on it. ua-cam.com/video/b83b7Qeug5I/v-deo.html
i just picked one up, and at $129 now, there is a lot of value in this very capable machine. it is very well made and the design is great with options to customize. using a 2s lipo i agree it is a bit jerky, but on medium throttle setting it has decent power and torque to crawl most obsticles well. im going to drop in a higher turn motor to get more bottom end, but overall it is a great vehicle and would love to see how it stacks up against the scx24. keep uo the good work, fellas!
I love your analysis! Thank you.
appreciate it.
great video. thx for it. i am driving actuel the scx24 green jeep. regards to USA!!!! crawler fans germany!
I like the minis and love my Losi Trail Trekker.
Love your reviews; glad to see all the mini crawlers coming out. ...Still curious about the Panda Hobby 1801 Tetra. Sounds like a possible upgrade from the Axial 1/24. It's a bit bigger, oil shocks, detailed body, nice third channel lights and priced dropped to $130. What do you think?
price dropped to $130? That is key. Body is kind of funky and modulation does not seem good. But we will purchase and take a look.
@@RCReviewChannel Glad to hear. I've been on the fence over best mini crawler choice. Was leaning toward the little Axial Deadbolt, then the nicer body of the Axial SCX24. But also the Panda Tetra with added features. I look forward to your impressions, many thanks!
Michael Edmonds Im also in that same dilemma whether or not to get the Axial or terra x1!
Thw hobby plus cr24 has a 40$ full electronics package with includes a bigger turn motor, servo and esc which supports 2s lipo. I have it on mine and makes the thing 50x more capable and torqy
interesting!!!!!!!
Derrick Williams yes on the 850mah zop power lipos. that thing rips now, super smooth throttle response but doesnt have the drag brake as good as the original esc
Any opinion on basher rocksta 1/24 crawler?
Not yet. Will look up.
@@RCReviewChannel ty!
I have two Rocksta Basher crawlers. They are awesome! Best micro crawler on the market imo.
Thanks for your great review and recommendation 👍👏👏
Our pleasure. Learned a lot and smiled a lot.
What do you think about the new Traxxas maxx ? Thanks for other awesome review. Just ordered the maxx😁
From what we've learned it's supposed to be impressive!
I just ordered the scx24 wrangler do you recommend any upgrades to start with? will you make a video on top mods for scx24?
we will!!!!
Another interesting mini crawler you should consider is the Partner Racing QX-4. It has been around for a while but I only just got one of these last month. It is described as a 1:18 scale rock crawler and it looks very similar in design and concept to the Axial Wraith 4WD Rock Racer. So if you are looking for a buggy style crawler rather than a SUV-body style then it might be worth a look. The space frame chassis provides great wheel articulation and ground clearance. Please see my channel, BlackSeaRC, for a full review including unboxing, testing in steep rocky terrain and an assessment of the good/bad points. Best wishes from the Black Sea!
Thanks for the comparison. Can the SCX24 bind with the rugged transmitter?
As far as we know, this one won't bind.
Where can I order the scx24 yellow jeep ? And I think it also comes in white
Great vid, are the scx24 wheels and tires compatible with the cr-24?
The SCX24 tires are quite a bit bigger. We hear the great upgrade is RC4WD tires and wheels in the 1 inch size. A hair smaller but money!!
Have you ever reviewed the Basher Rocksta 1/24 scale rock crawler?
no. how good is it?
I love it. I think you should check it out!
RC Review the only thing the stock setup lacks is ground clearance and sticky tires
Great review!!!!
Would it be correct to consider the SCX24 as a class 2 rig?
I’d like to see what upgrades you recommend and before and after runs.
For sure. we already have a few on order. Can't find good options for tires though.
Great review. Thinking of buying mini crawlers for my sons( and me as well) problem is there is no sellers here in the UAE for Axial SCX24
Controlled Freq.108 Amazon has them
Im very stuck with what to choose between scx24 and uruav. Amazon has them but i wonder if i upgrade the uruav with some good stuff maybe it can match the scx24
im purchasing the hobbyplus miniJ and I was watching your video and you stated that it might perform better with larger tires. Do you think that the 1/18 scale hobbyplus wheel will fit on it?
I don't think so. The Axial tires are oversized and should be perfect.
Cool now I know which one to get! Thanks..did you order your gen8 axe yet?
Yup. Coming our way.
@@RCReviewChannel
Awesome can't wait for your review!..I can't afford it now but I will get one.
@@1970scout800 We can't afford it either since we already have two. But the local hobby shop is letting us have one for a few days.
@@RCReviewChannel
That's awesome they are lending you one..sounds like a cool hobby shop..my local hobby shop is not that cool.
Hi!
Can you please do the comparison between axial and panda tetra x1.Thanks
Most definitely we have that nuclear show too but we should compare.
Please! I was looking for a video on this today and couldnt find any!
Already picked ip the c10 a couple of weeks ago.then i found your channel and glad i went with the axial. They seem to be hobby grade and others seem like toys. I never was into crawling until i picked up the c10 and niw i have for of them.the betty b17 was great out if the box over my modded c10.love tgese little trucks. Thanks for the vids.
Thanks , good show
do you know of any upgrades for the 130 motor type? I'd love to get some more torque from my hobbyplus
Yeah you can order a mount on shapeways. The guys name is gamyrc and it let's you mount a 130 motor on a scx24. He has some UA-cam's videos too about it.
@@matthewmurray5168 thanks a bunch man!
@@ctsteve1967 no, i dont make youtube videos or anything. Do you need help with yours? If you have any of those rc cars theres Facebook groups for them that are really helpful
beautiful video illustrated very well thanks for the info
What are the tiny pumpkins you are talking abour? The diff housing?? Why is it called pumpkin tho? Thank you
Lol yeah 😁
Why most manufacturers don't add rear lights?
budget!
Rc review: we have a mini shootout with these three mini crawlers.
Who won this shootout ? The TRX4 sport 😂😂😎jk good job on this review now I really want a scx24
How about the RGT 136240 v2-90
What hobby shop was this at?
Should of added in the panda- tetra x1 or x2 against the scx24. Wonder who would be the winner.
We couldn’t get there in time but it does seem like a good addition just a little bit bigger.
Im not surprised that axial has made a better RTR 24th scale rig...but I am surprised that they pretty much matched the price of other rigs. I've had the losi and ecx models, but the low torque and low throttle control sapped the fun out of driving them as you couldn't drive scale.
Thank you for a great video!
Really appreciate it.
How would the Panda's hobby version do or compare?
Frank Dee it’s bigger than the other and has oil filled shocks so it would probably do better
I feel like the banggood truck would have made some of those obstacles with enough patience
perhaps. But then so would the others. Bangood has the best tire compound.
Great Reviews!
Thank you. We try to steer the enthusiast towards the right purchase for them.
What is the black car
Was this hobby store called sheldons hobbies
Literally the only reason the scx24 is "better" than the cr24 is because of those ridiculously giant non-scale tires...
i ?d get up there with my kyosho toyota tyre upgrade
. no question
great to hear.
Three big kids and one little kid.. True! I can’t even say anything about rc cars bc people thinks it’s a silly kid’s toy.. haha
Kids at heart.
Thanks for share!!
Right on bud. We gave it a serious effort. All work as you can see. :)
@@RCReviewChannel Thanks for share!! Excellent channel!! Wow!!
Is that a 10th scale course?
mini crawler course - 1/24 or 1/18
Is this Sheldon’s Hobby Shop?
Yes indeed! Right in the front lobby. Free.
I like the Mini crawlers I just hate the way they look when they Kerr all. They look like a matchbox car rolling down a concrete street. They always look like they have no suspension and they are way too light weight. For me it is all about the scale driving look
You Keep sayin taller tires on the SCX24 they dont even look close too scale, they look goofy the coyote and urav look Scale and are scale
no ecx barrage?
No. research, research from friends we trust and we heard it's not at this level because of torque and modulation issues.
Oh yes I found a good video
Conducted nice. Love it. Good jod. Guys... NC❤ MOUNTAINS back yard RC.AND MORE. 🌨🏞
Cool huh? We learned a lot.
Shout out Sheldon's!
we grew up with them
RC Review yea I raced there a lot in the 90s the Saturday on road races with big Ted Marquez
plain to see the axial is the best by leaps and bounds
quite true.
Tires main issue between them
Torque, clearance, issue, quality, etcl
Did u try any of the lower gears of the carisma for ur "review"? I dont think so. Maybe that option only comes on the f-150. But mediocre/one-sided review for sure. I.e. axial. It is dope but maybe u should do ur research before posting ur video next time.
Sorry but we stand by our review. The Carisma was awful and we have to call it like it is.
Anyone that would like to see how the scx24 handles out in the out doors in some really tough terrain check out my video here!
ua-cam.com/video/hHrUSFdxhYc/v-deo.html
I am the first
that's pretty good! Happy Monday.
@@RCReviewChannel no problem
Axial SCX24 is very horrible, his bigger wheel (not scale) it is a estupid item