Dr. Jordan Peterson Questioned on 'Message to Muslims'
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 жов 2022
- DONATE NOW: www.saveiman.com/fb?affiliate... ⬅
The Prophet ﷺ said: “𝙒𝙝𝙤𝙚𝙫𝙚𝙧 𝙗𝙪𝙞𝙡𝙙𝙨 𝙖 𝙈𝙤𝙨𝙦𝙪𝙚 𝙛𝙤𝙧 𝘼𝙡𝙡𝙖𝙝, 𝘼𝙡𝙡𝙖𝙝 𝙬𝙞𝙡𝙡 𝙗𝙪𝙞𝙡𝙙 𝙛𝙤𝙧 𝙝𝙞𝙢 𝙖 𝙨𝙞𝙢𝙞𝙡𝙖𝙧 𝙝𝙤𝙪𝙨𝙚 𝙞𝙣 𝙅𝙖𝙣𝙣𝙖𝙝.”
If you support this project, you will in sha Allah get a house in Jannah and share in the rewards of all the people:
✅ Praying in the Masjid!
✅ Making Dhikr!
✅ Memorizing the Qur’an!
Please donate and help establish this Masjid and earn your reward ➡ www.saveiman.com/fb?affiliate... ⬅ - Розваги
DONATE NOW: www.saveiman.com/fb?affiliate_id=3414212 ⬅
The Prophet ﷺ said: “𝙒𝙝𝙤𝙚𝙫𝙚𝙧 𝙗𝙪𝙞𝙡𝙙𝙨 𝙖 𝙈𝙤𝙨𝙦𝙪𝙚 𝙛𝙤𝙧 𝘼𝙡𝙡𝙖𝙝, 𝘼𝙡𝙡𝙖𝙝 𝙬𝙞𝙡𝙡 𝙗𝙪𝙞𝙡𝙙 𝙛𝙤𝙧 𝙝𝙞𝙢 𝙖 𝙨𝙞𝙢𝙞𝙡𝙖𝙧 𝙝𝙤𝙪𝙨𝙚 𝙞𝙣 𝙅𝙖𝙣𝙣𝙖𝙝.”
If you support this project, you will in sha Allah get a house in Jannah and share in the rewards of all the people:
✅ Praying in the Masjid!
✅ Making Dhikr!
✅ Memorizing the Qur’an!
Please donate and help establish this Masjid and earn your reward ➡ www.saveiman.com/fb?affiliate_id=3414212 ⬅
At 7:50 Jordan Peterson is wrong and ignorant. There are accounts of British Military Generals purposefully spreading disease in the Americas in order to wipe out the population.
At the time of the Pontiac rebellion in 1763, Sir Jeffrey Amherst, the Commander-in-Chief of the British forces in North America, wrote to Colonel Henry Bouquet: *'Could it not be contrived to send smallpox among these disaffected tribes of Indians? We must use every stratagem in our power to reduce them.' The colonel replied: 'I will try to inoculate the [Native American tribe] with some blankets that may fall in their hands, and take care not to get the disease myself.'*
It has been alleged that smallpox was also used as a weapon during the American Revolutionary War (1775-83). During the winter of 1775-76, American forces were attempting to free Quebec from British control. After capturing Montreal, it looked as if they might succeed. But in December 1775, the British fort commander reportedly had civilians immunised against the disease and then deliberately sent out to infect the American troops. A few weeks later a major smallpox epidemic broke out in the American ranks, affecting about half of the 10,000 soldiers. They retreated in chaos after burying their dead in mass graves.
This is probably one of first recorded use of a Bio-weapon in modern human history.
You should have dragged him on visit to Al-Aqsa accompanying Ben Shapiro and illegal settlers.
bruh
Jordan Peterson is the prime example of Qur'an 28 Vers 56: "You surely cannot guide whoever you like ˹O Prophet˺, but it is Allah Who guides whoever He wills, and He knows best who are ˹fit to be˺ guided."
I would write that statement.
@@adejaya1692 إن شاء الله
He may be silent Muslim like Nijashi.
@@adnanleo3096 In Sha ALLAH' Azzawajal, always assume the best out of people.
@@adnanleo3096 we can't see what's in the heart, we can only judge what the facts have shown so far.
We Muslims should stop pipe dreaming.
Weather JP becomes Muslim or not, matters nothing, JP, you, me and everyone living needs Islam, Islam needs nobody.
I have never heard of Najashi calling Muslims haters of others people of the book "especially jews" as JP put it.
Many JP-s have gone before and many may come after, they come and go.
Only one Muhammad, saws, came with revelation from Allah, swta.
If JP or anyone goes against what Allah and the prophet taught, we reject him, as simple as that.
Selamu alejkum wa Rrahmetullah!
"The idea that Western ideology can fix all the world's problem is not reasonable" ✌️👍❤️
They cannot even deals with covid & follow simple precaution from infection 🤫
TBF, it is the restrictive conservative and fascistic elements of western society that mire it in the mud and cause the bloodshed and division. It's the liberal elements that drive society forward, often with people like Jordan Peterson loathing to be brought along for the ride and decrying the progress. Blaming liberalism for the failures of the west misses the point. It's nationalism, or any the belief that you are better by virtue of the tribe you were born (be it nation or religion) that causes the hubris required to turn a sword on your fellow man. Though I have no qualms about picking up a sword to defend myself from tyrants who have that hubris.
If we can get through crises and improve the education system such that voters are not taken in by con-men (like Jordan Peterson), then genuinely... liberalism and secularism is the best system we have currently, with democracy working at its best as a method to hold corrupt politicians to account. Religious pluralism also to ensure systems of thought don't remain closed, and that religious persecution can't take place in a legal way. The idea that there is one religious ideology or lifestyle that is one-size-fits-all and should apply to every human being, regardless of their background, or their various wishes for their life, is on the face of it, so absurd, you can hardly believe anyone can take it seriously. But it's what all religions seem to proclaim.
I agree though, western ideology can't fix all the world's problems. Though I don't know anyone who thinks it can. It just is better to other systems like theocracy that lead to religious persecution, or monarchy or imperialism which lead to the persecution of subjects.
The west cant fix even it's own problems, in fact theirs are increasing in number and gravity day by day... Yet they love to act as the perfect example to follow for everybody.
"Fix all the world's problem"
More like "create problems for the world"
@Hh Kk cope , seeth , whine liberal
He is not being asked to take responsibility for the western colonial past. But he can't and shouldn't speak disparagingly to a community who are affected by such oppressions. He has teamed up with the shameless advocates of one of the biggest modern-day settler colonization and native population displacement project. Will he unequivocally condemn that?
Very well said
Exactly
Exactly. If he is so opposed to those past mistakes why not take the same strong stance against this modern apartheid.
@@sephatu6521 yes, and why stay silent about the suppression of free speech regarding this matter? instead of wagging fingers at Muslims and lecturing them.
Are you talking about Jordan or Mohammed?
I feel that we should be thankful to Allah for people like you who stand up always for Islam and Muslims .. Alhamdhlilaah
❤
Alhamdulillah
Alhamduli'Allah
Evey time Peterson talks I forget the question he is answering. He talks sometimes for the sake of talking
He does it as a strategy to avoid answering questions. I find him insincere because of it.
@@fara7406 I'm getting a sense of this too
Loves the sound of his own voice
@@fara7406 your analysis is spot on
@@mummybey534 🤣🤣🤣😂👍🏻👍🏻
Jordan Peterson has a habit of evading the question perfectly. He overly confuses the question by going into minute details and sometimes taking the question to a philosophical side, completely confusing the person asking the question. Some questions are straight forward and does not require much to answer. But I guess that's why he got famous in the first place.
Hes been giving generic advice like fix ur bed etc etc in a manner that sometimes bit pretentious
i agree. I am certain he knew what Hinab's asking, also he was certain he'll get asked about that video, but he played ignorance.
He’s loyalty his Zionist buddies. And support for Abrahamic Accords
@@koplak9809 that advice is specific, not generic.
@@MD-01sort of like your comment?
Lol this conversation landed well with JP's audience, people are praising Hijab in the full video on Jordan's channel
@Samil Cetinkaya right! we can't force truth but we can convey it
I respect that considering Peterson has a right wing audience
It actually didn't land that well if you check the most recent comments
Not that it matters of course
@TheGoldenQueen yep
But if the message reaches more people, I guess that's fine..?
Allhamdulilah.
It is the beauty of TRUTH that it affects right at the heart. Even the disbelievers are dazed by it even if they then chose to not believe in it.
We're rather glad that Peterson was asked about the condescending piece. The line of questioning from Mohammed Hijab seemed accurate in assessing what Peterson's aim was.
Peterson should be called out for supporting lsrael and Abrahamic accords
Pp
@@HK00088
P
P
Pp
@@HK00088pl
P
Peterson spoke a lot but was incoherent to the question
This J Peterson storm Masjid Al Aqsa this month with Ben Shapiro - The Quran warned us about such fake Christians - they make alliances with Zionists and normalise crimes against Muslims - Oppose him!
JP didnt even answer the question
Yeah idk what he's talking about 😂
Of course. What did you expect 😔
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Alhamdulilah, my sister here is sharp, no smoke screen can fool her.
As always, no answer, confused, lots of unnecessary explanation, no solutions... well that sounds exactly like JP.
May Allah swta, increase you and all the ummah!
He supports lsrael
He likes playing with words 😆
Watched your discussion br on JP's channel. It seems he is so lost in minute details of every question that forgets or ignores the fundamentals of asking that question. This was apparent when you presented him the proofs of Quran and Prophecies to consider revisiting his christian believes but he questioned "what is the PROOF". He is sincere but a bit messy in his thoughts at times. But I pray may Allah guide him to islam. Ameen
İ sure do hope that's not him intentionally getting things muddy so he doesn't have to confirm or deny anything and take the risk and responsibilities that getting off the fence would put upon him.
@@dronoid4659
I think that’s the reason why. He’s got two audiences and it seems he’s trying to keep them cool.
He thinks he's too intellectual for his own good so tries to look beyond the lines of the question rather than understanding and answering the fundamentals of it thus he confuses himself whereas it's so much simpler
Why do you waste your time praying for this fame seeker, pray for your family members pray for all the Muslims who arent praying their salah, we have other big problems in the Ummah right now. Pathetic how Muslims behave in the internet seriously.
@@Kimeikus that’s why I don’t get how Muslims can say he is sincere, someone who neglects the truth you call sincere? Who just says something so his audiences don’t walk away from him? May Allah forgive you and me and guide us to the real sincerity, Amin.
Let's be honest, Jordan evaded brother Hijab's questioning, slithered into a tangential discussion, and took no accountability for his video.
Teqiyya
YOU are a slitherer
Weird that he didn't make a video on critiquing the smallhats
im christians and christian belivers always do that . christian dont believe in rationalaty
It was great asking him about this. He wouldn't have answered in any other way.
The biggest elephant in the room was still not addressed. On the day Petersons "message to Muslims" he joined a particular group/organisation with an ideology we are all familiar with. I am highly suspicious of Peterson and that his goal might be to normalise Muslims to that group/organisation/country agenda. I hope Hijab addresses this.
@@fara7406 Especially that Peterson broke into Al-Aqsa masjid with the settlers the other day, had a panel with Shapiro (a proud zionist) and an ex-American ambassador for Zionism. In my opinion, it's crystal clear, he's not even lowkey about it.
He didnt answer jack sh*t
Do you know what is happening in China.
When will Muslins wake-up. China is commiting genocide against Uighur Muslins. Over 2 million Muslim men and women have been put in separate concentration camps and their children have been put in orphanages. The Chinese Communist party is torturing the Muslims to convert them into atheists .
@@Midgethunter07 exactly, I stopped watching after I was midway through the video, peterson is so full of mental gymnastics and semantics that I cba with him anymore; he used to be "good to listen to" but his points are strange and barely connect to the answer he is trying to build, in the end, it just looks like a poorly-built house, I wish he was more transparent and clear with his response.
Is the strategy not clear yet? He appears open-minded to make way for the bombshell later. First it was the live stream followed by the message to Muslims video. Now it's have a good discussion inside a mosque only to invade the alaqsa complex without invitation a little while afterward with the protection of Zionist colonialists. Engaging with him from now on is a shame to Muslims and the Palestinians especially. He's categorical about Zionism (maybe because it's a state that resonates with his own cultural and historical background). But Islam, it's 'complicated'.
Couldn't agree more. You are absolutely right!
The comment I was looking for, AlhamduliLlah I found it.
THANK YOU
I don't understand the leniency with him when he hasn't even touched the Quran. Hijab literally read all of his bibliography...
The intentions are clear from that alone
What I always noticed about Peterson from the get go whilst everyone was amazed by him, was that he uses flowery in depth vocabulary which on the surface sounds highly intelligent however it only sends a simple point across when you actually deconstruct it.
This is a diversion from the content of what a person says in their argument so you are confused and overwhelmed if you are not receptive enough.
He’s just a clinical psychologist at the end of the day and while he does possess some skillful knowledge, let’s not inflate his ego by giving him more credit than he’s due.
Mohammad definitely dissected that illusive argument he always gives about non western civilisation. They do not take accountability for more than hundred years worth of colonialism and then proceed to criticise Islamic civilisation today which is not at an equal comparative level to begin with. Yes there are issues all over the world, is that a by product of religion or of ideologies infiltrating Muslim countries who do not even follow shari’ah correctly?
Nice comment.
this is true. like Sadhguru.
That's a fact. He uses unnecessary complex words to make a simple point.
Especially after Hijab asked him if he enjoys giving Christian lectures more than the greek pagan lectures, his long answer was unnecessary
Shahid Bolsen said Peterson is articulate and verbose, but his thinking skills are mediocre at best, maybe he is right.
Not impressed by him whatsoever. In fact very underwhelmed
Wow, production quality is up there with the large TV Networks. You and Zeeshan are upping the level. Maa Shaa Allah.
@Hh Kk stop trolling
Dear Dr Hijab,
Thank you also for your great great work and becoming the voice of the ones who have feelings but no words.
May Allah swt protect you.
Amen / Ameen
It was very important to open the discussion with this question.
@Hh Kk Iran are oppressive, Islam is peaceful
The fact that this man addressed the Muslims as though he is a voice or a leader to the Muslims is a sign of the hour. Allah musta'aan
JP is a better example of a true believer than hijab
I mean my friend he helped converting so many new Muslim helping so much revering back to islam hes even talking to one of the most followed Christians/free think youtuber out there and hes making him retract statements about for examples the warlord comment in part1 the this video is a great example hes doing hes best to kill all the misunderstandings around islam and muslims and even invited him to islam by giving so many examples of our prophets prophecies without mentioning all his conversations at hyde park / speakers corner who helped millions of muslims with defending islam sharing islam intellectually if this isnt leader material to you idk what is my friend
@@sawan9561 lol in your dreams maybe
@@sawan9561 Don't be stupid, kid.
@@sawan9561 in your dream are you even muslim??
Bro!!! I had no idea who you were before your conversation with JP. You're smart AF and I think opened some eyes and it really made me want a part 2. I felt it was really honest and constructive. I want more. Please make it happen!!!
Much love and respect from Uganda.
Respect to ugandan people
@@ahmadsarr4277 Is it difficult to watch?
@@Redhotlugnut I don't think so.
I found another interview posted in December 2021
@@LauraNStout Yeah I found that. It was a podcast I guess. Audio was awful as the signal was hot so sounds terrible. Lots was discussed in this original video that was talked about again in this newer video.
ما شاء الله أخي حجاب ..
ندعو الله أن يحفظك و يرعاك و يمدك من علمه المزيد و المزيد و يوفقك إلى ما فيه مرضاته ..
كما نحتاج للترجمة العربية .. لتعم الفائدة ..
بارك الله فيك ..
He is not beating around the bush.
He is thrashing around the forest.
Edit: It is hard to delineate whether he is sincere or playing a game. But I am well aware of his content and most of the time he seems sincere and Allah guides the sincere.
ahaahaa😭could not agree more.
😂😂
😂😂😂😂
loooll خخخخ
That made me laugh out loud 🤣😂
Whenever i hear Jordan peterson talk i feel like he is like that One student who writes a composition for 10 marks And ends up writing a composition worth 50 marks according to length but gets 2 points from the teacher
Lol I was thinking the same thing. Haha
😂😂😂😂😂
This is preciously accurate. You said it!
Amazing discourse between these intellectual gentlemen. I think it's important to continue such discussions, please be mindful of your words dear Muslims not to burn this bridge. This was a "MashaAllah" discourse keep it up gents...I wish it went on for longer 🕯🙏💐🧿
I watched the full video and I really liked the joke you mentioned about Ali Dawah 😅😅😅
May Allah bless you and grant you Jinatul Ferdaws, Ameen.
Jordan Peterson was more smart when he was only 13 years of age.
The "Mohammed Hijab" I knew in 2017 is back! Alhamdulillah. This is your forté brother. May Allah Subhanuhu wa'ta'ala continue to bless you mightly in this area of your life, ameen.
Sometimes answering a question in a straight forward manner is actually more intellectual than dressing the answer up constantly and shows wisdom, also I do not agree that separating indigenous children from their families to forcefully integrate them into the colonisers society had any positive aspects to it, let’s just call a spade a bloody spade please, it’s so easy to talk on these subjects when the people who experienced genocide, ethnic cleansing etc do not look like you!! Just because someone is educated to a certain level it really doesn’t mean they entirely know what they are talking about
@Hh Kk hahaha what an absolute random comment, like the west ever gave a damn about Iran!!! Anything that will support the pursuit of negative propaganda against Islam. Just shows your insecurity, honey if Islam was a cult you wouldn’t have almost 2 billion people voluntarily following it!!!!
Exactly. What good could have come from erasing a people's culture? I wonder what good. What a pretentious man he is.
@@Reem-ne7nn I would have loved Mohammed hijab to ask him to elaborate, because I was wondering the same, and if so would he be comfortable with what was done to indigenous communities to be done to White communities also??
@@Asha-gf4mq It did have positive aspects to it, bringing them to Christianity instead of pagan spirituality.
@@Asha-gf4mq Stop with the ludicrous hypocrisy. The ottomans seperated children and used them as soldiers for centuries, the same with every other empire. Its insane to think the west is special in any way in regards to its cruelty.
Loved this discussion. Brother dont shy away from symbolism when approaching dialogue with someone like Jordon peterson. Its not always bad.The pilgrimage of Hajj and its constituents are also symbols but they are pointing towards truth.
Hijab is too dogmatic and literal in his conception of theology
What truth?
On point
May Allah guide us all. Aameen.
Please come to Cape Town South Africa for a visit
Peterson says he doesn't find the rational stuff interesting because he wants to subordinate rationality to something higher.
This is just total nonsense, he's sitting there saying he aspires to be irrational.
He may be trying to reconcile his academic background with his faith.
@@rimacalid6557 Seems he threw his academic background out the window with that comment.
God gave us rationality to know him with it too, the Quran is studied rationally before it is felt with the heart
I don't understand how all these times he's been involving himself with Muslims, he still hasn't found the time to study the Quran when Hijab read all his books and content
He understands that once that's established, it's game over! the tone of conviction in his response is comical.. kinda like when he gave a resounding "Hell!" when asked regarding the purpose of Life..lol, even left Hijab stunned for a sec like "wtf is this geeza on about?" .. his own subreddit was goin in on him.
It's not a complicated argument, he doesn't deny the utility of rationality, he just points out that it must be subjugated to a higher theological or archetypal conception. Rationality alone is not enough.
The thing about life is that issues can't be solved really. They can only be traded in for other issues. Utopia or paradise can't exist on earth.
The way in which Islam is the solution to all issues is not by making problems go away. It is by giving you the objectively ultimately true and correct perspective regarding that which you perceive to be a problem.
Awesome 1!!!
We need the full video!
May Allah guide Jordan Peterson and his compagnon to the right path
ego is the biggest sin
Br Daniel Haqiqatjou had brought up very direct and strong points against JPs Message to Muslims video. Br Hijab could have pulled a few points from there, to not allow JP to beat around the bush.
MaaShaaAllah Hijab Sahib.. I LOVE the way you reframed his condescending attitude with the hypothetical “white Canadian” argument.. you continue to hit the mark bro Baarak Allahu Feekum.. also when he says youre disagreeable thats a signal of respect in his psychological parlance
i think this is like the discussion/debate of 2022!
Allaahumma Baarik
These are the types of discussions we like to see of you Mohammed Hijab! May Allah guide Jordan Peterson.
He can give dawah.guidance is in the hands of Allah only
المجد والخلود لشهدائنا الأبرار🇩🇿💪🏻
ههههه
May the sincere ones be guided and those with hate be lead astray. Amen.
". . . and nearest among them in love to the believers will you find those who say, 'We are Christians,' because amongst these are men devoted to learning and men who have renounced the world, and they are not arrogant" (5:82).
i am really happy that you asked that question insha Allah that question will lead him to Islam
Jordan Peterson is a smart person? Prophet Muhammad (SAW) says something else:
It was narrated that Ibn ‘Umar said:
“I was with the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) and a man from among the Ansar came to him and greeted the Prophet (ﷺ) with Salam. Then he said: ‘O Messenger of Allah, which of the believers is best?’ He said: ‘He who has the best manners among them.’ He said: ‘Which of them is wisest?’ He said: ‘The one who remembers death the most and is best in preparing for it. Those are the wisest.’” Sunan ibn Majah Nr. 4259
Its about believers and not Disbelievers
@@Sayyedalhindi The fact that they are disbelievers, means that they failed to use their mind and decided to use their inclinations, ALLAH (SWT) says in many verses of the Qur'an that he gave them a mind and they failed in using it, rather they follow their inclinations, they do not believe. if you woke up on a moving train, you wouldn't be wondering, "Who brought me here? Where does the train stop? When does it stop?" And wouldn't you question the passengers on the moving train? In your opinion, is a person who does not act smart? Or someone who just wants to enjoy the ride? The fact is that we are tested on earth and only the smartest will pass this test - that is the believers.
@@Sayyedalhindi And in some other translations it is translated as "which among creatures". In this regard it doesn't matter if "believer" or "creatures", since believers already proved they are smarter than anyone else who didn't believe, so it makes sense that it mentions believers in this translation.
this is gooood stuff
@Hh Kk never, cope
@Hh Kk ya but that's like 0.1% of the people, so cope
@Hh Kk they can attack with their sticks all they want, the Basij Islamic forces in Iran are 10 million strong and armed to the teeth, good luck overcoming them. Cope.
May Allah accept this.
@Hh Kk
If you are so desperate then you should go there and throw over the regime.
sincere searches for truth and truthful sincerely cares about truth , and not for fame or fortune..
He went on a tangent unfortunately
Of course he did, and it seemed on purpose.
As always.
You could tell he has more than met his match. Infact I think this interview has unraveled him. Not so confident now.
Yeah brother Hijab is a powerhouse. He’s gathering a lot of haters recently as well which proves that he’s going through the skies.
Not really you guys are heavily biased
@@isaiahd5396 The truth hurts kid. Accept that your boy Peterson is outclassed. Instead he runs away from the question like the insincere coward he is.
@@999legend8 You Muslims are a little over the top not every conversation is a jihad with a victor he didn't run he just didn't say what you wanted to hear I recommend listening to the whole conversation on Peterson's channel instead of this twelve minute cherry picked video it was a good conversation that needs to happen more often your boy is a smart guy but don't act like he's out of Jordan Peterson's league it shows your bias man has written three books that I know of and went to one of the best schools probably on the planet
@@isaiahd5396 Not really you are heavily biased.
I really hope that he has a discussion with sheikh Uthman inn Farooq it would be interesting
Algerien here and i completely agree with huim
Assalamu’alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh
السَّلاَمُ عَلَيْكُمْ وَرَحْمَةُ اللهِ وَبَرَكَاتُهُ
May Allah allow us entry into jannah through that door for brothers who love each other n praying for each other for the sake of Allah. I love you I hope you prayer for me too.
May The Peace and Blessings of The Almighty be with you ❤️ to all reading this.
I once saw a vedio of how a lion target it's pray then lurk around it n then grab it. May Allah bless our brother more. N may Allah open JP's heart, eye N ear.
I like them both. They have eloquence in how they talk.
Mashallah
What about Marsh Bradey?
JP is what you get when you end up believing that seeking truth ultimately is more about the path rather than actually reaching any destination whatsoever.
100%
Yep. And he is hesitant to take sides and would rather sit on the fence. Sophistry is a useful tool to circumnavigate difficult and straightforward questions.
@@junayedmustofaghalib4683 I guess it’s also to do with the underlying religious pluralism he can’t let go of
@@junayedmustofaghalib4683 and perhaps he has this false narrative that becoming Muslim is equal to adapting Arab culture
@@IbnThabitVerlag Yes. You are right sister. I have observed this. I watch a lot of his videos and also bought his book. Whenever religious discourse comes in, he almost all the time speaks in abstractions and conveniently divorces mythos from the logos and is predominantly fixated on the mythos part in most biblical studies and other 'religious' matters. I remember in his video when he was asked whether he believed Jesus existed, and he again resorted to complex wordings to divert the question. And he is trying to find a way for perennialism, as you said - a naively optimistic project.
I’m afraid Jordan might have sold out after joining Daily Wire, I hope I’m wrong
Allah guide us all
I feel like his energy has shifted. Idk he just seems off.
Glad to see I'm not the only one to notice a change in his attitude.
ALLAH Blesses Guidance...who deserves it....
The person oh his right seems to be like his handler in case things goes off rail. Lol
Whos right ?
@@koplak9809 do you see someone on Hijab's right?
@@koplak9809 "the person on his (Jordan Peterson's) right"
@@MuhammadHosny0 Hamza was ok Hijab right
@@koplak9809 he was on his left lol
So logical, so precise , so straight forward yet not understanding over the most logical , evidently proven .The Quran.
*Quran 58:22*
"You will not find a people who believe in Allāh and the Last Day having affection for those who oppose Allāh and His Messenger"
My 2 favorite people in the Same 😵 never imagined it...
❤️❤️❤️
Jazak Allahu Khayran for the constructive debate, my brother Ustaz Mohammed Hijab 👍
la ilaha illal Allah
@Hh Kk muslim conquest of Iran was necessary
Sitting in a Mosque, Ma Sha Allah
I'm from Oslo and don't even know where u guys will establish a Dawah center/masjid. I think it is close to Hagerud which Is just less than 40 minutes from my apartment!
JP answers the question at 12:05
Meanwhile Peterson off walking around Al Aqsa with settlers
GOD BLESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS
Justice for Aafia Siddiqi
I'm smiling while watching them with their socks on. I hope they felt cozy.
👍🏻👍🏻
Brother great discussion. However Peterson wont be convinced by hard evidences. He is already monotheist by heart. He is now more intrested in examples set by Islamic personalities and sainthood that caused such a profound impression on people that they had no option but to embrace this religion in particular. Please make that focus of your discussions in future.
Wow.. ya,
I noticed thia too from the last sir MH & JP virtual podcast, i surmise from what he stated that it seems he is pursuing to be somewhat a Prophet himself, for the Current World..
He seeks divine charisma & prophet miracles /whatnot, that is relevent/acceptable/most effective for this Era to spread his (JP) own pseudo-prohetic messages towards,correcting the World................ screwed the in head man. Slow descend to his intellectual madness
@@zdelivery7573 i dnt think thats fair to say it like that, he is a very smart individual, and has alot followers, which kinda make him abit afraid to jst change religion, its something we have to acknowledge, and maybe find a different approach, he can secretly change his religion.the important thing is that he gets saved.
@@atiqaly6567 yes i wish for him all his & His (Allah) best, regardless of my temporary opinion on his temporary current/on going states
@@zdelivery7573 yeah i just think we have to be more polite to him, and invite him to our religion, cause am sure if he does become muslimhe is gonna change a mass of individuals to be muslim he got alot of followers , and the end of the day its not abt us its about Allah.
@Mike J there was no evidence she was 6 and also there was reason he married her one of them seem to be so that she could preserve the hadith as it was a devine instruction. Also you cant hold ppl accountable for a rule that is not present at the time. Read the Bible first. We dont hold those that commited strange things in the bible because it was normal then.
Leave him, let him go. If he is worth it and his heart is opened enough to receive divine guidance, nothing will escape him before his last breath. Islam is not for the half hearted ones or those who wonder about what others will say. At least this should give him some deep thoughts and ideas to ponder over, and he will not be able to contest any of this dawah on Yawmul Qiyamah. Still we pray for the misguided and ourselves.
i don't think it's about JP personally but his overall audience.. Hijab pretty much exposed him by having him say he believes rationality is subordinate to something higher which is quite a profound thing for someone of his stature to reveal especially in the current times..
❤️❤️❤️🌹🌹🌹
I think the conversation went very good
MashAllah brother Hijab
Islam is the True Religion ❤️
Could you put out the full talk. Please without any editing
Everytime I see Peterson, I remember Prophets letter to Khalid bin Waleed. "How can an intelligent man like you hasn't accepted Islam ". May Allah guide Peterson too
There is also a great hadith which indicates the prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) was a truthful person.
Usually religions are associated with superstitious beliefs. Eclipses are famous for being so.
In the life time of prophet had a son named Ibrahim. Ibrahim died at a young age of two or three. The same day when the son died. There was an eclipse.
The muslims started saying that look, the son of the prophet died and the sky went dark. The sky is grieving. When the prophet Heard this he became angry with the muslims.
He said that the sun and the moon are signs of God and they don't worry themselves about the birth of a man and death of son of Muhammad.
Doesn't sound much like a liar does he? Source:Book of Eclipses from Sahih Bukhari.
Why is this Jordan guy so popular? He says nothing of value, just rambles on. The man is a clown
I don´t get it. He just rambles
ALHAMDULILLAH. That's why i am a muslim
Loved the discussion. Jordan is a decent guy, just a little confused. May Allah guide him.
He clearly knows what he's doing, hijab confront him for it,peterson chickened out
The other guy was pointless coming on panel & a liar when he 1st opened his mouth ( I watch the full interview). No respect for someone who lies he was obviously told by the journalist who made the lie about u
J Peterson exposed would be a much appropriate title
@Hh Kk fanboy detected
👍
Assalamualaikum, it's good you confronted him in this topic, but it was not fruitful I feel as the discussion seemed very divergent to the topic, more precisely the answers made no sense or had almost all the time nothing to do with the original question, like what brother Hijab says is pretty direct and straight forward for any intellectually inclined person to grasp, but people will know about it and conceal it in their hearts, or maybe he's just in a weird confused state. Whatever it is, I hope, Allah SWT gives him hidayah Ameen.
Brilliantly handled by brother Hijab. but that sudden ending was very annoying. what happened 😕
@Hh Kk I am not a Ayatullah lol
He was in al aqsa mosque storming in with the settlers
We pray for all to embrace Islam. Islam doesn't need us , we need this beautiful religion to feel peace within us and to have sense why we are here.
After this interview I saw peterson as lost missguided confused person with too many questions without answers !
SAD .. it's was honsity sad
"it's complicated" "what do you mean by (as) and (lost)?" "Oh I know"
Can anyone enlighten me as to why Jordan Peterson is so revered? Don't get me wrong, it's clear he's a thoughtful and intelligent individual with decent credentials, but I find I struggle to really connect with a lot of his work. I feel there's a lot of rambling and going off on tangents without clear or specific points being made. Almost like a lack of structure in what's being alluded to? Don't know how else to explain it. But I find him very, very overrated. Just my opinion.
He's just someone a common voice in the west, if he speaks what is common sense to any Muslim, about the flaws of West, he's praised and hyped because they think it's time to have a revolution, with all these isms and schisms taking place in the West. And that's why he's overrated, and I think he deliberately evaded this question, because maybe out of fear of being called out, either that or he's just speaking without thinking, but then it would contradict what Brother Hijab said, he claims he thinks before he tells something, and the so called "message" he had to the Muslims, was clearly him promoting the nonsense he believes in. It doesn't apply there, so basically it cannot apply here as well. He was just stalling and evading questions, and as if nobody would notice. It's kind of disappointing for someone like him as the West hails him to be. It's a joke of him lol. May Allah SWT give him hidayah Ameen.
I'm with you. Plus, he seems to be ignorant and bias on my topics outside of psychology
@@AbdAllah_54564 agreed. Ameen!
@@irene-bz2yq yes I would agree he's biased
Older, articulate gentleman in the mainstream w/ some conservative beliefs that naturally align w/ most men's instincts which have become rarer by the day on mainstream platforms.. Similar to the Andrew Tate effect.. now, combine that w/ alot of Joe Rogan which instantly multiplies anyone's popularity which compounds over time!
The Torah , Bible and Quran is a TRILOGY
I haven't found more appropriate verses describing the state of Jordan Perterson than these:
27. On that Day, the wrongdoer will bite his hands, and say, "If only I had followed the way with the Messenger.
28. Oh, woe to me; I wish I never took so-and-so for a friend.
29. He led me away from the Message after it had come to me; for the devil has always been a betrayer of man."
The Holy Qur'an, chapter: [The Criterion] Al-furqan
That's the reason why he didn't accept Islam till now after the all the facts and signs and miracles have come to him, it's because of the Friends of evil. but if wants to see the light then he must replace those friends with good ones who actually want him to get to paradise and want good for him.
Is JP really intelligent? Or just overated!
Intelligence is defined in Sunan ibn Majah Nr. 4259.
Overrated.
@@ayeshapyesha7301 I too think so
Heavily overrated
Lack of better.
Just because you dont agree with him it doesnt mean he is overrated. He is intilligent and has alot experiances.
Allahu akbar!
where is the full conversation ?! its frustrating to end in the middle of a conversation 🥲
On yt channel of jordan peterson
@@huesna61 jazakallah khair, i will check!