Should You Buy Persona 5 Tactica?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 гру 2023
- Review code provided by Sega & Atlus.
Patreon: / namscomp
Discord: / discord
Twitter: / namscompendium
#persona5 #review #sega
Persona 5 Tactica is the latest entry in the Persona series and is the 4th spinoff featuring the Persona 5 cast. The game was recently released worldwide and I know that a lot of people are on the fence about this one due to its dramatically different art style and gameplay. I myself was pretty unsure about Persona 5 Tactica going into it however I came out pleasantly surprised with what’s on offer here. While I usually make videos going into detail about my experiences surrounding these games, I figure that today I’m going to do something a little bit different and see if the game is right for you. Is Persona 5 Tactica something you should bother trying out or is it something you’re better off skipping out on it. I’ll also be doing this with as little spoilers as possible and will only be showing footage from the first two areas of the game. Don't worry, I’m still going to make a full breakdown on this game in the future, but since Tactica is new I just wanted to strike while the iron is hot, you know? However, before we get started I want to disclose that I was provided with a review copy of this game by Sega and Atlus. To a lot of people, this will immediately put wherever I say, both positive and negative, under scrutiny and I don’t blame people for thinking that way.
The most I can do is assure people that my words cannot and have never been influenced by the prospect of getting review codes. I’m pretty sure my previous track record is more than enough proof of this. However, regardless of those previous reviews, it’s impossible to deny that we all have our own personal biases. Sometimes people will like something and others won’t so do yourself a favor and don’t just take my word for it and look at other reviews too to see if this is something that you’ll like. Games are pretty expensive nowadays and the last thing we want is to drop a bunch of cash on something we end up hating. Or in Tactica’s case, a bunch of cash plus a tip if you want to get everything on offer but I’m getting a little bit ahead of myself here.
Should You Buy Persona 5 Tactica? Persona 5 Tactica has recently been released worldwide and in this Persona 5 Tactica Review, Persona 5 Tactica Critique, and Persona 5 Tactica Analysis, we're going to find out if You Should Buy Persona 5 Tactica. This Persona 5 Tactica mini-review will feature a lot of Persona 5 Tactica Gameplay and will contain no Persona 5 Tactica spoilers to help you decide if Persona 5 Tactica is worth it. As always with these Persona 5 Tactica reviews, try to not make this the only Persona 5 Tactica you watch before deciding if the game is worth it. if you were to ask me, I think You Should Buy Persona 5 Tactica, but that's just me. there will be a full Persona 5 Tactica Review, Persona 5 Tactica Analysis, and Persona 5 Tactica Critique in the future but not right now. Should You Buy Persona 5 Tactica is the last Persona video for this year. - Ігри
Are you going to buy Persona 5 Tactica? Have you already played it? Let me know your thoughts down below!
I kinda just want to wait for a sale. I am a FE fan that loves P5 dearly, but I don't know how I feel about buying a 70$ spinoff, especially because I know my ass is buying the DLC for Sumi and Akechi. Side question: are either of the party members accessible in the main campaign?
Nah, I like Persona and all but the spin offs are rarely of a good quality enough for me to play them as a story gamer so I just stick to the main series.
prob not, MAYYYBEE on a sale, not in a age where i spend on soso games
I liked it more than Persona 5 Royal
If you liked how P5Tactica played, I get the FEELING you’d like Valkyria Chronicles; it’s similar gameplay-wise in many ways, just without the grids. As a person who PLAYED VC, the main game of P5Tactica kinda grew repetitive faster than you it seems, which made the freshness of the dlc hit ME more than you (at least that’s my guess).
honestly I know people are tired of persona 5 spinoffs but I'd rather they give us a bunch of fun spinoffs so persona 6 has the most development time possible so it can really blow us away
More dev time doesnt mean better game.
@@lckfan3696 and less dev time hasn't shown to be any better either
I don’t. I’d rather get another mainline SMT game.
We just had the 30th anniversary and didn’t get anything for it. It’s cool to not be tired of persona 5, but me personally I’m really hoping to be done now. And I notice myself becoming more of a bitter SMT elitist the more and more P5 there is
@itsallenwow Same. I think since the release of Persona 5 Royal is where my interest towards Persona 5 went from fatigue to hate. Mainly due to the overwhelming amount of non-stop persona 5 spin-offs
Facts no rush games just use resources good
I think my favorite part about this game is that no one character is insanely over powered, there's reasons to change up your party in my experience which is really cool to see in a game with this many characters. I enjoyed Tactica a lot more than I thought I would, I think I would be OK if it was the last Persona 5 spin off. (It wont be though cause Atlus likes money). Great video bestie keep up the great work!
well there is P5X so, one more.
@@hgmd3284 There's also the party game that was leaked but that seems to be more of a full series crossover (with P1 and P2 characters!!)
@@athoremWait, what? A Persona party game? Is it trying to be some sort of Mario Party knockoff?
Yusuke is cracked, though
@@tbnwontpop8857 You say that as though it isn’t tradition.
Minor correction: There actually is exactly enough GP to completely max out everybody's skill trees. If you complete all the quests, talk episodes and reach level 99, you'll have exactly the required number of points to learn all the skills.
Other than that, great review; I enjoyed this game more than I thought I would.
Thanks for pointing it out for me
Correct
This game is somehow both surprisingly great and disappointing at the same time. I really really wish the game could be expanded on, but that's probably asking too much of a spin off.
I'd also like to mention the animations in the cutscenes look almost uncannily clean. The persona fusion animation in particular is one of my favorites.
6:20 I noticed that about all the Persona 5 titles after the original came out, not just this one. They advertise a new waifu (Kasumi, Hikari , Sophia, Erina) only for the plot to really be about a more interesting character (Maruki, Nagi, Ichinose, Toshiro).
It's nice to see that you warmed up to the game after being bored by it in the Livestream lol.
Me personally am just not in the mood to play another P5 game, especially since I'm not a fan of Tactical RPGs.
I'm in the exact same boat. I've definitely hit that P5 burnout, and tactical RPGs aren't exactly my thing either, so I totally get that.
I felt the exact same way "I ended up enjoying it way more than I thought I would"
I LOVED the combat in this, a 3d battlefield was exactly what p5 needed to not be as repetitive
Have you played that one mario x rabidds game on Nintendo switch? I have played tactica but it looks like it’s exactly like that game
I'll be finishing P5 and Strikers before considering picking this up. That said, given how much I love tactical games like the classic Fire Emblems... well, I hope I get to it eventually.
Between Reload, Vengeance, Metaphor ReFantazio later in the year, and just my massive backlog, I don't know when I'll get to P5T, but it's definitely something I want to check out. It being on Game Pass--or rather, it eventually leaving Game Pass--might be what I need to get around to it.
I found it funny that P5T continues the trend set in Strikers where my favourite characters (Ryuji and Makoto) are kinda trash, but Yusuke and Haru are both absolute godless monsters.
You can spec both Makoto and Ryuji to shine quite a bit with Melee knock back builds, or being more tanky than the others. I think Ann and Yusuke are the best Nukes though with Agidyne and Bufudyne respectively.
Haru's low mobility kinda hurts even if she is a melee/gun powerhouse with built in hypnosis tech. What wierded me out is some of the ultimate attacks are worthless, while others are broken, kinda wierd.
@@sherrdreamz7232 tbh I've not found Haru's movement a problem. It's so easy to set up 1-Mores for her and give extra moves, and once she gets going she can just go on a rampage and wipe the map single-handedly, or at least maul it so much that the rest of the team can easily mop up. Agreed on the special attacks though, Joker's and Erina's are the only semi-decent ones imo.
@@sherrdreamz7232 Not at all. Haru's movement issues can be negated by the inclusion of Yusuke, as well as giving her ranged passives. She can hit things basically half the arena away from her. Even her gun is really good. She's almost as broken as Yusuke.
I'm kinda glad P5T goes the Q route in being technically canon (I assume) but not in a way that actually matters for continuity. It means I don't have to worry about rushing to play another P5 spinoff in a genre I don't really play and can wait until I finish the other spinoffs I haven't played yet (and other games too of course) without worrying about not being up to date on the P5 story. Though the game seems fun, the semi-canon Persona spinoff formula (if you can call it a formula) is getting a bit dull by now. I'll probably wait until after I finish Reload to give it a shot.
As a person who beat the game and it’s dlc, it’s a solid Valkyria chronicles-like in terms of gameplay with a P5 coat of paint. Story wise it’s meh, very basic for the most part, but it has one or two good moments. I’d probably say it’s a 7.5/10 at most…BUT it has a dlc story mode that’s about 3-4 hours, and it was SURPRISINGLY good for how short it was, which opens my mind to the idea of shorter persona spin-offs or side stories🤔 8/10 from me for the dlc.
12:17, there is though, you just have to do every quest and hideout conversation
Great review Nam 🔥🔥
Thank god for online guides, I have no idea how you are supposed to figure out some of the quests, especially the 1 turn ones on your own. I especially hated Quest 12 took me forever to find the right combination of personas on fox to 2 round the enemy that just refused to get caught up in the triangle attack.
I’m mixed on the game, I found the beginning boring in terms of gameplay and story. Then it really picked up in area 2 with follow up attacks then area 3 was a bit dull and then I hated the final area
It makes no sense was the start of the high school since Atlus hadn’t had the time for more history.
Keep up the great work bro ❤
I already preordered day 1 for the Southeast Asia Collector's Edition, but i have to play it yet, only tested the game. I'm just finishing up the last 2 months in p5r.
Amazing video!
I feel Persona 5 Tactica should have been the SMT and Fire Emblem crossover game we could’ve got but the timing just wasn’t there 😅
I would love a Persona 5 Strikers 2!
The first one was so GOOD i hope so
Honestly, after hearing your view on this game i can compare this game to borderlands 3, A game that was fine tuned to be a better experience from it's prior games and it's best seller 2. But narratively falls flat, but the gun-play and how fun the gameplay itself can be is what makes these games a hard sell, as if you want both, you can't get it, if you're a gameplay guru you'll get something for your buck, but when the story is what attracts me and others it's annoying to have a game where because it *feels* like a whole heep of nothing we just speedrun the dialogue to get to the gameplay again. I have played borderlands 3 alot, but even still idk if I'd play tactica, but considering I haven't touched strikers I guess I'll start on a lower p5 spin-off end to a higher one.
Also on the dlc note I do genuinely think it sucks, but as you said if it's starkly different from the main story and adds splatoon elements to it, then it makes sense to be different. but since this is non-spoiler view. I can't really gauge whether it's worth anything, like idek if I can play the 2 outside the dlc.
Doesn't sound like Tactica sold that well from what we know. I'm hoping that won't effect the chances for a future Tactica game. The game does feel pretty low budget so maybe they weren't expecting it to sell that well
SMRPGR also had a low budget yet sell very well. Atlus is so bad at timing at their spinoffs competing against themselves.
I really hope for DeSu3 one day. It’s the perfect SMT SRPG series. ❤
I pre-ordered P5T because I was really excited for it. I only stopped playing because my Switch started dying and sent it to be fixed. Unfortunately, I feel like everyone disinterested in the game won't play it because they were already disinterested for one reason or another. Besides, Reload exists.
Here, what I noticed about the game and its story by extension, is that it feels like a game that was NOT meant to be a Persona (5) game, but rather a game that was then made to be a P5 game. Various aesthetics seemed to stray from what was traditionally P5. Not to mention that the P5 cast does end up feeling like they're just there. This is the same with the DLC's story.
Speaking of the DLC, I don't like that Akechi and Kasumi are NG+ only. Definitely should've been an extra story after beating the main game at that point.
i love persona 5 tactica it was really awesome
I guess they wanna have an answer to Fire Emblem?! I’m actually a huge fan of SRPGs so this may be right up my alley.. Strange people would complain as though there’s something wrong with the P5 cast not to mention trying something different
Thank you
For me, it's ok. But im kinda disappointed it wasn't devil survivor 3. It feels like with P5T, it's the last nail in the coffin for any hopes of that happening
The tactics gameplay in P5T is a lot better than Devil Survivor, which is pretty much a Tactics game in name only. Story is more interesting in DS though
I vastly preferred Devil Survivor 1 and 2 in every way. I kinda like a more somber tone with high stakes, over the typical shounen/JRPG hijinks. That might be down to taste though.
The Monster and character builds were also far more dynamic and interesting. The combat also always kept you guessing whether you were going to decimate the enemy or get decimated due to a mix of luck and tactics from one battle to another.
It's a good game but the content is short. It took me less than 40 hours to beat the game and there's day 1 DLC. This is definitely a game to buy when it's on sale, but not something I'd recommend for full price. I played through Xbox Game Pass.
40 houers does not sound short to me.
My favorite JRPG is just 20 houers long. Although that one costs just 40€ in the Nintendo Eshop.
Still 40 houers sounds like a solid amount of content. I have not really payed attention how long it took me to beat it but it did not feel to short.
Considering I'm almost finished with persona q2, I think I'll wait on tactica, lol
get it on sale.
not because it's bad, but because it's overpriced beyond parody.
edit: I give persona Q1/2 a little slack on the writing, they did have to juggle a literal army of characters.
Considering how often the Persona games go on sale, and when it came out, its price isn’t that bad. Just got P4 for 10 bucks.
So you’re a fan of tactical rpg’s huh?
Have you ever played Marvel’s Midnight suns? If you did, what did you think? Personally I thought it was way better than it had any right to be and it had much better writing and characterization than your average superhero game (and I know this is part of one of the game’s dlc stories but Midnight Suns has like…the best adaptation of Venom/Eddie Brock in recent memory because he’s just straight out of the comics)
Hey, Nam. One of the most prominent channels in the MegaTen community, BuffMaister, was hacked and terminated yesterday. I hope you can help get his channel back online.
I need to say how much the dlc mixes up the gameplay and has lotus juice writing all the music for said dlc!
Love your vids bro
I’d rather play a polished Persona 5 spin-off game than play a broken and rushed release of Persona 6.
Why are people acting like the series will evaporate if they're not constantly releasing games for it?
Dude going to be honest if persona 6 came out this year an was broken and felt rushed than that would say more about Atlus than anything
@@petergriscom3431 Because mainline Persona games take a long fuckin time to make. Also, the games being experimental with each spin off keeps them fresh. Also, it's nice to have nice things. I don't understand people who "get tired" of these things and then turn around to buy Mario for the 50th time.
@@tbnwontpop8857 Experimentation is good, but they keep doing the same thing with the plot over and over again. Even with Tactica people are wondering if it was originally going to be a new IP before getting the Persona spinoff treatment.
2:30 You spelled Best Girl wrong.
I wasnt crazy about the game but I found the ending really beautiful
At least it sounds like the DLC has a unique gimmick that makes it more worth the asking price. I for one am so sick of The Royal Trio being in everything ever, and I wish the characters would stay as they are at the end of Royal.
As someone who didn't really vibe well with the original Persona 5, I am highly impressed with this game. IMO this is one of the best Strategy RPGs in a long time, if not the new Goat. The map design and how you active switches to open doors and trigger elevators is very intriguing. This is very different from Fire Emblem or even XCOM, but I absolutely have been addicted to this game. I'm just about to beat it, so no spoilers please. And the music pushes this to becoming a 10/10 for me.
I liked the story and how toshiro was built up throughout, but I guess this is my first time experiencing this sort of trope story and I'll get sick of it fast.
You got his name wrong. It's Tofuro
12:15 herrrrr... Yes it is?
Still waiting for a price sale
Hey Alright!
Does DLC worth 14 bucks. I got the game from gamepass
Great game, I played it on Gamepass
I would say yes, if you want to the timeline this game takes place, it is between the p5r and before striker takes place, because the metaverse is already destroyed in this timeline, the myster in this game why is the metaverse is active if they already destroy it and who is behind this metaverse, and why this metaverse effect the phantom thief different mostly thee power of the wild card this are the mystery the phantom thief is solving.
ATLUS milks P5 like Square milks FF
The game is good but its no full price day 1 dlc good
Thid game reminded me of how bad I suck at strategy RPGs.
With Gamepass and the Repaint your Heart DLC it’s awesome for $20. It’s almost built for remote play.
Yes I’d prefer more for $60+ and there’s design directions I wish they took, the core gameplay hooked me and brought me back to my Band of Bugs days.
We just need custom maps and maybe a Strikers Sophia/Zenkichi character DLC.
Heck, even a character or story DLC for some of the P3 (SEES) and/or P4 (Investigation Team) crew would be nice to see.
My biggest gripe about the game, is that it's too easy, even on the higher difficulties. I am not even that experienced with Tactical games - only Fire Emblem Shadows of Valentia and South Park: The Fractured but Whole, it just didn't really have a challenge and feels like a beginners Tactical game. Also the fusions didn't do that much for me, I just went with whatever had the best stats with only slight accounting for my party - ie bruisers for party members like Haru - and everything worked out fine. It's not terrible - still prefer Strikers as the Best spinoff - but it is not particularly great.
I really liked the game the only problems I had with it was that Sumire was dlc and the story was mid overal
I dont need to see the whole video. I played it and see the thumbnail?
It is worth
No.
I've been spoiled for a higher class of tactics games. It's a PC, CRPG game from the 90s so that a hard log of shit that cannot be bested today.
game is Jagged Alliance 2.
Why is Haru even bustier than Ann?
It's a solid gamepass title, but 50 or 60 bucks is a bit much for it.
I I don't like Persona 5 that much but I fucking loved Persona 5 tactica 100% worth buying, If you think it's too expensive, buy xbox game pass, you can beat it in 3 weeks or less
I liked him n the game was fine, its alright.
Nam's Persona videos >>>
I have one major problem of this game and it’s the simple fact there’s no exploring like how you do in p5 and I mean in palaces.even p5s had it and for it to not be in here feels trash especially to me it feels like a core of persona
every quest involving yusuke is stupid. it's always him going "i wanna experience being brainwashed again" or "i wanna know what it's like to fall off a building".
why? .... for art i guess?
Artist? More like. Fartist lmao
Tactica definitely has the worst version of Yusuke and he's the closest in this cast that falls into the flanderization trap. Though I'd be lying if I said I didn't find those quests charming in a way.
So Yusuke is Yusuke? Fun.
I gotta be honest… I didn’t like tactica. I felt like it was cheap. The music felt bland, some of the va’s felt off, no dungeon crawling sucks,and I just enjoyed strikers a lot more.
I didn’t love strikers, but I’m having a really good time with this one!
Saying there's a twist is a spoiler genius.
For 60 absolutely not, for 15? Maybe
It's a 30 hour game. $60 is more than fair.
@tbnwontpop8857 ok how much should mainline persona games cost then?
Id buy the game if it was like $30
Oversaturation or not, I’d rather have new games than not.
Agree
just play it w gamepass its amazing
“Should you buy tactica?”
Just play on gamepass
Great comment here
@@itsallenwow its not worth the full price 20-30$ game at best
i beat personal 5 royla 975/1000 gamerscore, only missed 2 small achievements but i wont play that long draggy game all over just to get 2 small achievements
with that said, tactics wise, i rather play valkyria chronicles 4, mario rabbids 1 and 2, or even mutant road to eden with the trenchcoat duck
persona wise, i rather play strikers
I'm rather annoyed that the party is only 3 strong instead of 4 now. But yeah I dont much like the silly art style or the new characters... also... "mah-ree-eh"? Really?... Marie. So dumb
should you play p5 tacDICKa 😂🎉
Looks like they too focused on milking persona 5 dry instead of working on persona 6
It may be the weakest P5 story, but they're far from "one-note" characters.
really fun game but no worth $60 its a $30 at best
To the point about the narrative - I found the dialogue to be so egregiously boring and pointless that 5 minutes in I turned on fast forward and never turned it off. I have almost no idea what this games story is but I enjoy the game thoroughly for the tactics gameplay. I feel like this game could have easily just been non-stop driven, like a series of Tetris puzzles and I would have had more fun because I'm not waiting for the pointless dialogue to finish so I can play the damn game.
Short answer: No.
This game is like my son, a total disappointment.
Did you just mention p5s in a positive way? 🤢🤢🤢
I played the game for 2 hours got incredibly bored and uninstalled. The game is below mid
Different strokes for diff folks
So you got a review code, and it still took you this long to make this video? Seems like Atlus is wasting their time.
Why does it matter how long it takes him to upload
Sorry but these characters look gross and it feels like a rip off of the original game
Japanese stuff is just unbearable.
The Persona 5 characters are as popular as Mario,Sonic,Snake,Kratos ect…
Removing them and going for new characters in P6 would be a huge mistake. P6 might be a good game when it’s released,but it’s not ever going to be as memorable as “P5 Royale” and it’s spin-offs.
Garbage story, annoying locks with the turn based system. Irksome reverse tone highlight with dialogue choices. Said dialogue takes itself too serious at the hollowest of payoffs n buildups. You know when an anime does the stupid determination friendship never givenup segment for 5minutes straight....thats 50% of the dialogue. Dear god does this game do the whole friendship determination spiel waaaaaaay too damn much. I felt like this was the latest rachet n clank with how hard they shove the powet of friendship and quirky coincidences down your throat.
I'd be waaaaay less angry if the stupid turn system let you HIT START- AND RETRY (PAUSE OR ANYTHING) during the enemy turn. For fck sake if one of your characters get snuffed you cant even hit retry immediately- you have to select another, do the transition animation and if you beg nice - THEN yhe game lets you have your damn pause button back.
The loadscreen is choppy and I just chauk that up to everything made on the unreal engine after 2015 at this point.
If you can suffer the hiccups and the corny one note jokes which none have anything to relate to the previous game (really sad tbh) then you can enjoy Phantom of the Kill on PS4 with persona 5 avatars.
For those of you who don't know phantom of the kill, or any old school gundam turnbase- ya missed out.
I will say this tho- since the art style is eh...not distracting for reasons I wont get into- I definitely was required to focus for the rewards. Like, both hands and no dreaming of Heartswitch allowed or you die- that's perfect run Merciless mode.
Ngl I kiiiinda regret paying 80ish for this but I won't even try to deny I've wanted to play one of the dreaded spinoff types forever- its not THAT bad but its just not amazing either.
I'd give it a 5 out of 10. Maybe a 6.
Diddn't you already talk about this game on your other channel, Nyarly? Seriously you both are the same person.