Why isn't Puerto Rico a state?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 лют 2025
  • Puerto Rico has been a United States territory for more than 120 years. Why hasn't the U.S. made it a state?
    Support my channel by becoming a member: / @biancagraulau
    Follow me on IG, TikTok, Twitter, Facebook: Bianca Graulau

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,9 тис.

  • @arieo.5873
    @arieo.5873 3 роки тому +157

    The government divided the puertorricans so in that way they can build a Puerto Rico without puertorricans. That's the reality of the island today,sad but true.

    • @nunocolon
      @nunocolon 9 місяців тому +3

      😢

    • @anthonygordon9483
      @anthonygordon9483 7 місяців тому +8

      doesnt matter. The Puerto Ricans are only moving to mainland U.S. now. So they got to deal with minority voters one way or another. Puerto Ricans are born U.S. citizens so unlike mexicans and other latinos. Puerto Ricos dont need a Visa or Passport to come in the U.S.. They can move to the U.S. like a typical american moves to another state.

    • @carlitosortiz2870
      @carlitosortiz2870 5 місяців тому +1

      You don't know what you're talking about skippy not even close.....lol

    • @anthonygordon9483
      @anthonygordon9483 5 місяців тому

      We also got to look at the bigger picture here. Lets look at that trend. In Hawaii most native Hawaiians are moving to mainland because of the billionairs and millionairs buying up homes that not even that native can afford to live there anymore. This is the same thing happening to Cuba. The U.S. is denying Cuba state hood yet there are Millionairs and billionairs moving to Cuba buying second homes and driving the cost of living up. They are literally trying to genderficate both islands into mostly white folks. Sorry to break it to you.

    • @elbohike3500
      @elbohike3500 3 місяці тому +3

      Divide and conquer

  • @Scray1
    @Scray1 3 роки тому +320

    I have learned more about Puerto Rico from your videos than I ever learned from school or college. Thank you Bianca.

    • @jesusrivera577
      @jesusrivera577 3 роки тому +9

      sad but true

    • @ourladyofsorrowschurchnyc9890
      @ourladyofsorrowschurchnyc9890 3 роки тому +5

      Yes so true

    • @AngelRamos-kn9bx
      @AngelRamos-kn9bx 3 роки тому +4

      Los gobiernos de PR, PPD , y de USA no quieren que se sepa la verdad de como USA invadió a PR ,robo y mato a miles de gente .

    • @AngelRamos-kn9bx
      @AngelRamos-kn9bx 3 роки тому +3

      El PPD , PNP y USA no quieren que la gente sepan la verdad de que pasó en PR desde 1898.por eso no enseñan mucho o nada en la escuela.

    • @davidvasquezcalero1053
      @davidvasquezcalero1053 3 роки тому +1

      You have only learned Liberal and Communist BUllshit... She paints a picture only of those that are always talking Division... Everyone on this planet lives under a Oppressive system.. Take those living in the 50 states they are over taxed, Their Dollars have been devalued, and the media is always feeding them BULLSHIT.. Must like this Wannabe..

  • @BiancaGraulau
    @BiancaGraulau  3 роки тому +30

    Here's the link to support my channel with UA-cam memberships. Thank you! ua-cam.com/channels/FY_1ZN5Sn4fMFNmQgj6X9Q.htmljoin

    • @107chewy
      @107chewy 3 роки тому +2

      👏🏽 👏🏽👏🏽

    • @gravis00
      @gravis00 3 роки тому +2

      What memberships?

    • @DI.ANGEL4YA
      @DI.ANGEL4YA 3 роки тому +2

      Te quiero mucho gracias por ser tu

    • @jerseyboy7422
      @jerseyboy7422 3 роки тому +1

      I'll think about only after communist Biden Joe is out of office, 🇵🇷🇺🇸 LET'S GO BRANDON 🇵🇷 🇺🇸 FJB 🇵🇷🇺🇸💯🍻

    • @Apchestangenightout
      @Apchestangenightout 3 роки тому +1

      America is quick to say we want you to fight for freedom , democracy and Liberty but when it comes to asking the US that Puerto Rico would like to become a State it's a kick in the rear-end. I think I probably know why those who don't want Puerto Rico as a state is probably because fear of losing their property the land they own . But those who want Puerto Rico to become apart of the US , I understand now after listening to you why that 52%of Puerto Rico wants to be apart of the US equality , which I agree 1000% with you . I'm poor but rich in the blood that runs through my body because my father is 100% Puerto Rican 🇵🇷 Thank you for teaching and telling us about what's going on in Puerto Rico 🇵🇷 🙏 Peace love and much respect to all of Puerto Rico 🇵🇷 , USA 🇺🇸 and the world 🌎 ❤

  • @ccr4375
    @ccr4375 2 роки тому +38

    Your videos are quite an extension of my one Puerto Rican Studies class I took in College.. Your reporting is succinct, clear and valuable to someone like me. My mom was born there and I got to visit my family many summers there. Hoping to get back there soon with my children. Your videos are a fantastic historical reference that I will share with my family, so they can learn more about their Mom’s culture. Kudos to you Bianca!

  • @vintageart13
    @vintageart13 3 роки тому +72

    If Puerto Rico becomes a state, all you will see is Puerto Ricans living in projects. the rest of Puerto Rico will have people from other countries living in all the best places.Puerto Ricans will be second class citizens in their own island.

    • @SALSAKID49
      @SALSAKID49 3 роки тому +1

      Good point but we can remedy that with a strict exception Federal Ownership laws with no loopholes of any said lands and/or properties by which only Puerto Ricans by blood line and inheritance can only obtain and/or purchase. And that any foreigners or by marriage cannot buy via any representative and/or agents or local residents will be able to assist in the purchase outright of any plot of land and/or properties. Something to that affect and It can set for one hundred years.

    • @vintageart13
      @vintageart13 3 роки тому +5

      @@SALSAKID49 That is a good point and good ideas.what will hurt Puerto Ricans, will be the cost of property taxes. the property taxes will be too high for the average Puerto Ricans to pay. that’s how they always end up getting the land. The cost of the land goes higher and higher until the people that lived there can’t pay. The cost of property tax will put Poor Puerto Ricans in projects.

    • @TMBnVegas
      @TMBnVegas 3 роки тому +8

      @@SALSAKID49 That's xenophobic and racist can't exclude people.based on ethnicity from buying houses ? What if new York said no Mexicans or Puerto Ricans can buy property come on now

    • @SALSAKID49
      @SALSAKID49 3 роки тому +2

      Born and raised in New York City, and traveled parts of world while serving in the US Navy. I've never been raised as a bigot and/or as a xenophobic Puerto Rican. Point being that residents of the Island SHOULD be earning first rights of their properties and lands as rights of ownership. I still own my parents house in Puerto Rico right now there are buzzards with crypto currency seeking to buy out the local community due to the current state @@TMBnVegas

    • @SALSAKID49
      @SALSAKID49 3 роки тому +2

      Look up the NY Times article dated January 31st 2022 "The rush for a slice of Paradise in Puerto Rico"

  • @wilcoisfrancois2479
    @wilcoisfrancois2479 3 роки тому +62

    Hi Bianca,
    I am really loving this series on the discussion about independence (or lack thereof) of Puerto Rico. Even though I'm not Puerto Rican, I can relate, as a very similar scenario is being played out in my twin-island Republic of Trinidad and Tobago (albeit to a lesser extent).
    I especially like, and agree with, the contributions of Senator María De Lourdes Santiago and historian, Emilio Pantojas García.
    It's unconscionable/amoral to deliberately retard the development of a country for another's benefit or because of racial, social, cultural or other prejudices or for some colonial agenda.
    Keep up the great work with the videos, which keep getting better by the way 👍🏽

    • @Jay92master
      @Jay92master 2 роки тому +1

      Yes facts it’s happening to Puerto bro I’ll become a country the only way is they need a presidents official living office polital house in Puerto Rico where they live for few years like example 6 or 7 then another PR president and Vice President takes over the office. Plus having a passport that will represent the country

    • @carlitosortiz2870
      @carlitosortiz2870 5 місяців тому +1

      Dude we've had 4 fair referendums on statehood and statehood has never gotten 50% of the vote.

    • @CKNICKERBOCKERS
      @CKNICKERBOCKERS 17 днів тому +1

      That Is Wrong Carlito Ortiz. We Have Had Eight Referendums And While The First Four Wanted Commonwealth The Last Four Have Wanted Statehood. Statehood Is The Way To Move Forward Rather Than Independence. Puerto Rico Is Too Small To Be Independent And Nobody Needs Another Cuba 🇨🇺 Especially Not The Puerto Ricans. We Deserve Better And Statehood Is The Way. If We Become A State We Will Be Members Of A Powerful Union. We Will Become Strong Immediately. Venezuela Or Colombia Will Not Try To Invade Us.
      Puerto Ricans Are Peaceful Beings That Only Seek To Be Great And Great We Must Be United With The U.S. We Are What We Are Thanks To The U.S. And Not Thanks To South America. South Americans Want Us To Be Independent But We Need To Be United With The U.S. We Must Be Smart And The U.S. Will Give Us That Freedom And Empowerment.

  • @seff-g1e
    @seff-g1e 3 роки тому +75

    My concern is if Puerto Rico becomes a state, what will happen with property taxes. My fear is the natives who have land from generations will be forced to lose their land because they will not be able to afford the taxes that will be imposed by being a state. No one seems to be discussing this. Why?

    • @mitty2575
      @mitty2575 3 роки тому +11

      Yup… people tend to forget that nothing is free! 💡

    • @radrook7584
      @radrook7584 3 роки тому +2

      They trust that the noble Anglo-Americans will never allow that to occur to their supposedly beloved, Puerto Rico. So they don't worry about it.

    • @ChristhianGT
      @ChristhianGT 3 роки тому +3

      It’s already happening though…

    • @radrook7584
      @radrook7584 3 роки тому +8

      Most of the land has already been appropriated by USA Companies and foreign companies and very few Puerto Ricans own any land in Puerto Rico at all. Many of the Puerto Ricans who arrived during the early immigrations were former landowners who had sold their lands to such companies.

    • @JoeVirella
      @JoeVirella 3 роки тому +6

      Honestly there are so many abandoned buildings that a bit of property purchases would be welcomed.

  • @puertocool
    @puertocool 3 роки тому +73

    The present situation in USA is not good, nor are the controls of the military-industrial-banking complex that promote dissention and war as acceptable US policy. For Puerto Rico to accept any closer relationship with USA, particularly through statehood, would be a sad disasterous decision. As the civil war demonstrated, there is no option to reverse a statehood acceptance. On the other hand the corruption, patronage, and irresponsibility of Puerto Rico's internal governments at all levels would also make a decision for independence disasterous. These reasons are why the majority of people on the island do not wish for any major adjustment in status at this time. I favour a scrapping of the US style of government and replacing it with a European style parliamentary system. There is no easy answer, and only Puerto Rico residents should make status decisions, not Washington and not people of Puerto Rican heritage living in USA.

    • @opr59
      @opr59 3 роки тому +4

      A good analysis and a good recommendation for an alternative form of government. Living in Germany I see how well the parliamentary system works where all parties receiving 5% or more of the vote is represented in parliament as opposed to the majority, winner-take-all form of the US system which now accounts for the deep division and mess in Washington. Perhaps it is time to look at amending the US Constitution since the system appears to be broken ...a much bigger problem than the status of PR.

    • @jove507
      @jove507 3 роки тому +2

      Nearly four hundred thousand votes were obtained by the sovereignty ( Lugaro ) and independence ( Dalmau ) party and the year 2020.

    • @robertolopez391
      @robertolopez391 3 роки тому

      Ramos, this is the end for everybody, we have to start
      studying the situation of
      the the entire world
      NWO vaccines and viruses
      for ever.Covid,Omicron
      and there is a new one
      since 3 days..

    • @robertolopez391
      @robertolopez391 3 роки тому

      The new variant has up to 46 different selections.
      In the midst of the Omicron explosion, scientists are already studying IHU, the new strain of Covid-19

    • @riogalicia9448
      @riogalicia9448 3 роки тому

      Yep, I agree...this is pure neo-liberalism plus new era colonialism through the financial institutions. This is why I support China.
      As a Puerto Rican, I have visited China 4 times and I have realized that the Chinese communist party will NOT allow the US/UK dictate their country. Say what what you will about the communist party of China, I personally don't love them but they do many many many things right in pushing back Imperialism while modernizing their own society IN THEIR OWN TERMS.
      Something as Puerto Rican, I wish we do the same.

  • @CptFugu
    @CptFugu 3 роки тому +96

    The promise of Statehood is based on the threat of starvation.
    While most Puertorricans have a strong sense of their cultural identity, the leadership of Puerto Rico's major political parties have pushed the island into a situation of mutual exploitation with the United States. The Island is used and exploited, and they in turn, remain in power by exploiting the US Welfare state.
    Would Puertorricans vote for statehood if we had a decent economy? Would we be willing to surrender our cultural identity if we were not faced with the prospect of starvation? Would anyone?
    The irony is that by pushing local businesses and industries out of business with predatory taxation, intrusive intervention, and a decidedly hostile and convoluted bureaucratic process, the pro-US lobby has made the island unattractive to the US Political leadership. Once we lost our strategic importance as a military camp they lost any interest in the territory and assumed an "absentee management" posture that has led to the current financial and corruption crisis.
    Freedom for the Puertorricans can't come as a handout. We need a decent economic project and a transformation that would insert us into the global economy and make us solvent. Only then can any sort of vote about status be free of coercion.

    • @johnnytorres398
      @johnnytorres398 3 роки тому +8

      I could not put it any better......." Mas claro no canta un Gallo". The plebiscite votes that were taken in Puerto Rico for status preference only took place among a small percentage of Puerto Ricans!

    • @robertolopez391
      @robertolopez391 3 роки тому

      Ramos, this is the end fir everybody, we have to start
      studying the situation of
      the the entire world
      NWO vaccines and viruses
      for ever.Coviid,Omicron
      and there is a new one
      since 3 days..

    • @LordMysticalBeast
      @LordMysticalBeast 3 роки тому +4

      Más lindo se daña.

    • @heru-deshet359
      @heru-deshet359 3 роки тому +2

      A Singaporean economy comes to mind.

    • @biancareyes3871
      @biancareyes3871 3 роки тому +19

      How do you purpose a better economic system? Especially when many Puerto Ricans choose to fight for U.S benefits. I’m Puerto Rican who lives in New York and God knowing that the majority of Puerto Ricans want statehood is a huge contradiction. One minute you complain the gringos are taking our land and buying all our property. The next we want statehood so we can have free benefits from the US government.
      Let me enlighten you with what you guys are gonna get with measly statehood. Working for the gringos in your country while you’re making minimum wage. Being put in projects while you’re beautiful houses would be own by the very ‘colonizers’ you so much dislike. While everything skyrockets in price, the more you’re going to want.
      Instead of standing up and fighting for a better educational system, and health care. Most importantly understanding the U.S laws since Puerto Rico is its territory, knowing owners rights, knowing land rights, knowing voters right in Puerto Rico. Coming together as a country to fight against the corrupted political party that you also dislike so much. Educating yourselves on what’s happening in the U.S market and what can you contribute. Instead of sitting around and blaming everything on everyone else. Living in victimhood leads you to being bought out.

  • @xavier3241
    @xavier3241 3 роки тому +36

    I give you props!!! You’re a valued reporter and we need more people like you to get the truth out there.

  • @marionmarcetic7287
    @marionmarcetic7287 Рік тому +2

    As An American Woman Who'd Love To Visit Puerto Rico! I Think That Your Country Is So Beautiful.🥰🥰🥰🙏🙏🙏🇨🇦🇮🇱♾️🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🗽🦅🦅

  • @MrNckissfan
    @MrNckissfan 3 роки тому +95

    If Puerto Rico were to become a state it’s outcome would be no different than Hawaii’s with only one exception. That these new "Haoles" would be referred to as “Gringos.”

    • @jesusrivera577
      @jesusrivera577 3 роки тому +16

      Well not that true, The Island would adquire 2 senators and 6 representatives thas a lot of political pull more than more than 21 states. But if you understand American politics Republicans think, well most of them, latinos are Democrats except Cubans wich the majority vote Republican. But really most Puerto Rican will be consider conservative, even Reagan once said Puerto Ricans are Republicans by heart but they don't know it. Like Bianca was saying on the video until The Insular Cases aren't overthrow, there will be no equal rights under the USA flag in Puerto Rico. Only Congress have the authority to decide for the millions of US citizens in the Island without representation on Congress vote. They don't teach you in school that the constitution doesn't follow the flag, to fully benefit from the constitucion you need to be in one of the fifty States of the Union. Even me, a Jibarito from Comerio, does know that.

    • @MrNckissfan
      @MrNckissfan 3 роки тому +27

      @@jesusrivera577: Everything you’ve just described is no different than the outcome we’ve seen in Hawaii.
      I myself am a Puerto Rican born in Ohio. But even I have enough sense to never get involved in Puerto Rico’s politics as it is not our place as spoiled mainlanders to have political influence over the islanders. Especially when all 3 options carry consequences. For example: if you leave things as they are, you’ll remain a territory but at least you’ll have dual residency. If you choose statehood then you can count on being treated like second class citizens since the Gringos have the money to gentrify the hell out of the island. However, if you choose sovereignty not only will you preserve your culture…but you’ll also be able to govern your lives as you see fit.
      Unfortunately, Puerto Rico may not have enough natural resources to sustain itself given their lack of minerals and oil deposits. Not to mention the fact that there isn’t much real estate to work with. Especially once you start subtracting for land preservation, agriculture, solar panels, infrastructure, military, etc. The truth is, the Caribbean islands were never meant to be countries. Which explains why all of them are so poor. Instead their original purpose was to serve as military outposts for the European colonists whose objective was to expand their nations on the other side of the Atlantic. Which btw was going according to plan until future generations of colonists had decided to use the healthy buffer zone between themselves and the kings and queens who funded them to their advantage. They literally bit the hand that fed them.

    • @MrNckissfan
      @MrNckissfan 3 роки тому +6

      @Dustin Stich: The Democratic Party targets Latinos much in the same way they do the Black Community. However, in order to push their agenda they need to keep them in a submissive state so that they’ll become dependent on the government. Notice how the Black Community overwhelmingly votes blue by no less than 90%. That’s no accident when you take into account that it is now a gynecocracy who happens to be very pro big government. The reason why the Democrats have been toying with the idea of giving Puerto Rico statehood is because doing so would give them more power to govern. Cubans and Valenzuelans are the only Latinos who can read right by through them.

    • @hibiscushoney3759
      @hibiscushoney3759 3 роки тому +2

      😆I laugh because I had said the same thing before. Refreshing to read your comments. Intelligence is so impressive.

    • @hibiscushoney3759
      @hibiscushoney3759 3 роки тому +2

      @@MrNckissfan Very concise and factual. Well said. Yes sir you got it. Agree 100 percent.

  • @dieselhound84
    @dieselhound84 3 роки тому +49

    Recently moved to Puerto Rico your better off seceding. Puerto Rico should be an independent sovereign Caribbean Nation.

    • @radrook7584
      @radrook7584 3 роки тому +1

      Territories don't have the right to secede. Territories are property whose ultimate destiny is in the hands of the owner. That's why Trump smugly considered selling Puerto Rico.

    • @donstephens4232
      @donstephens4232 2 роки тому

      Where are the resources to be an independent nation. Its not easy. Best wishes. DonJr.

    • @anonymoususer8895
      @anonymoususer8895 Рік тому +3

      Who’s gonna clean up San Juan when a hurricane hits? Yeah, nobody.

    • @CasperChicago
      @CasperChicago 5 місяців тому

      What you said is why Puerto Rico is not a state and why the US is not in a hurry to help them in any way. If you want independence then stand on your own and do not expect someone to come to your defense when you get in a bind. Either you ARE part of the US or you are NOT 👈🏾

    • @bigwill6089
      @bigwill6089 7 днів тому

      Yes! Independence!

  • @chiefxcell
    @chiefxcell 11 місяців тому +3

    Love your journalistic work for educating me about Puerto Rico. May your work be amplified and compensated. Freedom for Puerto Rica and beyond.

  • @BoriPR82
    @BoriPR82 5 місяців тому +3

    If Puerto Rico becomes a state, people will lose their home, because property tax on a tropical island will be too much

  • @markfletcher4605
    @markfletcher4605 3 місяці тому +2

    I love your journalism with someone covering the issues of Puerto Rico in depth. I believe that Puerto Rico deserves to be an independent country. The fact that it is a territory of the United States is a product of imperialism and colonialism. To allow it to become a state would just continue to perpetuate the imperialism and colonialism. However, the United States has extirpated vast amounts of wealth and culture from Puerto Rico. Thus, to provide the new country with the ability to survive, the United States should immediately pay vast reparations to the country.

  • @arseniocruz1381
    @arseniocruz1381 25 днів тому +3

    No, I don't think that Puerto Rico will become a state. I lived in the states for 60 years and saw all the prejudice while growing up and I still see it in the states.

    • @CKNICKERBOCKERS
      @CKNICKERBOCKERS 17 днів тому +1

      Puerto Rico Will Not Become A State Only Because The PPD Has Always Wanted A Commonwealth. The PPD Is (El Partido Popular Democratico) And They Only Want The Commonwealth Status. They Are Brainwashed That This Is The Best System But Obviously Is Not. It Is Better Than Independence But Not The Best System.
      Puerto Rico Needs To Be Part Of The United States And We Puerto Ricans Need To Want That. The US Will Not Grant Us Statehood If We Keep Voting For The Commonwealth Status Or Independence. We Need To Unite And Clearly Vote For Statehood. Statehood Is Not What The South Americans Countries Want But They Are Not Us.
      Sure The People With A Lot Of Money Want Independence But That Is Because They Can Live Well Under Any Type Of Government. We The Poor Seek The Commonwealth Because We Think That Is The Best System But It Is Not. Sure It Was Better Than Independence But It Will Never Be Better Than Statehood.
      With Statehood We Will Get More Money, More Programs, More Benefits, More Healthcare, More Jobs, More Education, More Universities, A Higher Living Wage, And Everybody Will Be Better.
      Why Five Million Puerto Ricans Live In The US? Why Only Three Point Two Million Puerto Ricans Stay Behind In The Island? The Answer Is Simple And Obvious: The US Offers Greater Benefits. Why Not Then Decide To Join The US? It (Statehood) Will Be Better For Puerto Ricans And We Should Become A State.

  • @happierabroad
    @happierabroad 10 місяців тому +3

    Bianca, that document you showed said that Puerto Ricans are different than Americans. Being different is a fact. It's not racism. That's jumping to conclusions on your part. It's using a label to explain away something, which isn't logical. Again saying that people there are different isn't racist. It's simply a fact.

    • @ivonnemontijo8461
      @ivonnemontijo8461 Місяць тому

      I agree with you . The main reason Puerto Rico had not been made a state has to do with tax haven laws for corporations. I think Clinton did away with those and the effect was that many American corporations like the pharmaceuticals left the island which caused high unemployment. It’s never been about racism it’s Jesus been about the money and Puerto Rico’s very own corrupt government officials.

  • @zuleykavalentin6014
    @zuleykavalentin6014 3 роки тому +32

    The United States does not have better health services, they are very expensive, but not necessarily better. If PR becomes a state, we would be in extreme poverty and unemployment. More than we are now.

    • @radrook7584
      @radrook7584 3 роки тому +1

      If you gain independence, then you would be in extreme poverty and unemployment. More than you are now. So your only option is clear.

    • @Daddy-Saxon
      @Daddy-Saxon 9 місяців тому +2

      The US has amazing Healthcare in the quality of the care. But it's also one of the most expensive for someone to afford. Both statements can be true at once

    • @CasperChicago
      @CasperChicago 5 місяців тому

      Right now Puerto Rico does not hae JACK! You speak of "we". The" we" you talk about are impoverished natives who have no hope and not future other that their pride,...PRIDE 👈🏾

  • @angelmercado0223
    @angelmercado0223 2 роки тому +7

    I love these videos i was born in puerto rico but raised in orlando florida where we dont really learn the history and you put it in a easy way to understand the timeline and all perspectives thank you

  • @backyardcigars8670
    @backyardcigars8670 3 роки тому +33

    Lets be real here
    Puerto Rico will not be granted statehood
    The game is to make the people believe they will

    • @BoricuaNyc
      @BoricuaNyc 3 роки тому +2

      Many Puerto Ricans 🇵🇷 were assassinated because they wanted independence 🤦🏼‍♀️. Boricuas 🇵🇷 need to learn the truth and cut loose from the USA. USA=UNITED SATAN'S AUTHORITY 🤷🏼‍♀️

    • @owencollazo3355
      @owencollazo3355 3 роки тому +4

      Statehood will be granted. Just wait and see!!!!!!

    • @backyardcigars8670
      @backyardcigars8670 3 роки тому +2

      @@owencollazo3355 that is what people and many politicians have been saying since the 1960s

    • @DannyCruz-ll2cw
      @DannyCruz-ll2cw 10 місяців тому +2

      ​@owencollazo3355 you really have to have self hate if you want Puerto Rico to be a state

    • @homeshall9299
      @homeshall9299 9 місяців тому +2

      @@DannyCruz-ll2cw no it not self hate…. What you talking about ?

  • @VivaBoricua93
    @VivaBoricua93 Рік тому +3

    Lol @ 9:47 “The day the United States ceases to be a democratic nation” as we are all watching a slow decline into extreme right wing politicians gaining power

  • @Jay92master
    @Jay92master 2 роки тому +4

    It shouldn’t be statehood it should be independence

  • @mikerosario8198
    @mikerosario8198 3 роки тому +11

    I live on the island and I believe that the government has to first fix our economy better our living statues before talking about the status quo.

  • @TheBoricuaGamer
    @TheBoricuaGamer 8 місяців тому +4

    Just look at how he treats the Native Americans. Statehood? ha..ha..ha I don't want it.

  • @AbrahamIsaacMucius-d7z
    @AbrahamIsaacMucius-d7z 24 дні тому +1

    Bianca, you should post a video about Dr. José Celso Barbosa Acala. Dr. Barbosa was born in Bayamon, Puerto Rico to Afro Latino parents. His father, Hermongines Barbosa was an overseer on a plantation and his mother was Carmen Acala.

  • @raymondcarire5676
    @raymondcarire5676 Рік тому +3

    We should be independent from the United States otherwise it going to get worse for all puerto Ricans young and old ,first drop the Jones act so we can live proud

  • @michaelhalsall5684
    @michaelhalsall5684 Рік тому +3

    The US has Puerto Rico and the UK has Northern Ireland!

  • @skk175
    @skk175 Рік тому +4

    Puerto Rico no es un Estado de los Estados Unidos simplemente porque somos el Territorio mas Pobre de los Estados Unidos.
    En adición Hawaii es Estado, porque los Gringos tenían miedo de que Japón los Invadiera.
    A diferencia de Puerto Rico que es el Territorio de Estados Unidos con el peor ingreso per capita.
    Alaska también temió que Rusia los Invadiera .
    Un botín de Guerra es lo que Puerto Rico es .

    • @GardenStateNJ27
      @GardenStateNJ27 6 місяців тому

      Never saw it like that… 🤔 but makes sense cause of Cuba being right there

  • @DgVet
    @DgVet 3 роки тому +2

    Who ever feels that the US doesn't owe Puerto Rico the same rights as a person living in the US must not be a Veteran, How many Puerto Ricans have served in the U.S. military since 1917?
    WW I - 18,000
    WW II - 65,000
    Korean - 61,000
    Vietnam - 48,000
    Gulf - 10,000
    Enduring & Iraqi Freedom - 25,000
    National Guard in 2014 - 8,400+
    Veterans in PR - 100,000+

    • @radrook7584
      @radrook7584 3 роки тому

      The Gauls fought and died by the thousands under Hannibal against Rome and were never thought to deserve Carthaginian citizenship.

    • @DgVet
      @DgVet 3 роки тому

      @@radrook7584 Typical Racist view from someone who has never has sacrificed anything for this country! "God Bless"

    • @radrook7584
      @radrook7584 3 роки тому

      @@DgVet I am not approving of such a policy towards Puerto Ricans. I am merely pointing out that serving in an army doesn't always guarantee citizenship.
      yourself
      In any case, giving ones life in a field of battle is not the only thing that can be sacrificed. My entire life has been a sacrifice .
      I sacrificed a proper education since I knew no English and was thrust into school not knowing what the teachers were saying, sacrificed not growing up in a non racist environment, sacrificed being persecuted because of being Puerto Rican, sacrificed being paid a starvation wage because of the selfish Capitalist USA policy. There were many other things that I had to sacrifice simply because the USA decided to invade my island and hold it under colonial status.

    • @DgVet
      @DgVet 3 роки тому

      @@radrook7584 well at least we agree on something, I’m 50 years of age my mother was born on the island and my family is from Bayamon, I have never agreed with the policy’s or treatment that the US has shown over the years to our Island but the people have to speak out and continue to discuss reform. I served with the Army 246th Mortuary Affairs Company Aguadilla, Puerto Rico In Iraq, 1990-1991. It will always be my opinion that if Puerto Rico can send there children to fight in a War then then Puerto Rico should always have a seat at the table.

    • @radrook7584
      @radrook7584 3 роки тому +1

      @@DgVet I am 75 years old ad was born in Coamo Puerto Rico. The problem is that they are willing to die while being deprived of proper representation.
      They have been very happy to do so for approx. 100 years. So it really doesn't seem to bother them to the extent that it bothered the USA founding fathers who decided to fight England over it
      participating

  • @MagicSnapO
    @MagicSnapO 3 роки тому +5

    Spain was about to grant Puerto Rico autonomy right before the US attacked. Not many know this. I don’t statehood will ever happen without a civil war in PR. Right now there is a big objection to the gentrification going on in the island. That will only increase as it becomes a state.

    • @CasperChicago
      @CasperChicago 5 місяців тому

      I say let Puerto Rico eat cake 👈🏾

  • @SF-my2ym
    @SF-my2ym 20 днів тому +2

    Greenland will be a state before Puerto Rico is. 🤣🤣 PUERTO RICO LIBRE! ✊🏽🇵🇷

  • @hgonzalez1334
    @hgonzalez1334 2 роки тому +7

    La estadidad es solo un sueño, un engaño para aquellos que quieren la vida fácil y depender de completamente de otra nación. Hay que descolonizar muchas mentes… #VivaPuertoRicoLibre

  • @CoachRasul
    @CoachRasul Місяць тому

    I'm from NYC and grew up with Puerto Ricans and this is so thought provoking. I'm gonna watch the other videos before I comment whether I'm for or against it. You remind me of the old days when despite their biases (we all have them) the reporters at least made an effort to be somewhat objective. Thanks for being courageous and standing on the principles you believe in.

  • @thefpvlife7785
    @thefpvlife7785 Рік тому +9

    I find it ironic that Hawaii was immediately made a state because of its location in the Pacific. I believe now the main reason is what’s best for the military.

  • @atlanticgun
    @atlanticgun 29 днів тому

    Thank you for bringing a new view to not only the problem but what it's owed to the people. We need more of you and whomever can joy. Bless your journey!

  • @yeche1202
    @yeche1202 Рік тому +3

    Puerto Rico should be it’s own country, like the Philippines. It just give power to the people to become a government that will look after its own and be able to trade with other countries.

  • @robertmorcate846
    @robertmorcate846 Рік тому

    Good morning Bianca, another excellent documentary and information. Thank you for the Supreme Court case regarding the position of Puerto Rico. I am from Santurce, PR, but I am limited in our history. I’m so proud of you for what you do. Keep up the work and educate the Puerto Ricans about their history. We need you!😊

  • @JuanMaldonado-ik8lg
    @JuanMaldonado-ik8lg 11 місяців тому +3

    Im an old man, and I have watched news and documentaries all over the world, and you, my friend, are one of the best. You are concise, clear, and direct, and you have excellent eye contact and manerism. Wow.
    You are up there with the best, and at such a young age; it is a blessing and a natural talent. Use it with respect.
    Congratulations, Taina.
    I wish you the best in life.
    I will donate later to your endeavors.

  • @josecolon3265
    @josecolon3265 4 дні тому +1

    Yes I support I am a Forma marine, I'm proud to serve the u. SI am from Puerto Rico. I am from biga Baha.

  • @LoneWolfj11
    @LoneWolfj11 3 роки тому +6

    Puertorico deserves self-determination, the people must decide, but it's no secret that we deserve the same rights and equity Americans get in the states. We have been abused, oppressed, and taken advantage of for far too long.

  • @margaretcampbell1471
    @margaretcampbell1471 Рік тому +2

    Eisenhower gave US Companies a tax break to set up in Puerto Rico.
    Puerto Rico became a powerhouse.
    Bill Clinton repealed this tax break and that sent Puerto Rico into an economic tailspin
    You should discuss this

  • @justinroig5858
    @justinroig5858 3 роки тому +51

    I appreciate how your videos help many Diasporaricans learn and better understand the deeper socio-political aspects of our Madre Patria. I very much appreciate your last three videos as they are probably the most accurate and fair representations of Puerto Rico’s political history in the past century and to its present. As an Independentistas myself, our views are often not taken as seriously as the other two status options. Showing the history of the PPD and working class Puerto Rican’s relationship with it and why it still gets support today was also appreciated. For me it helped me understand why my grandfather had always spoken so highly of Luis Muñoz Marín, which had baffled me. And thank you for not falling into the “all Puerto Ricans support statehood or desire to be American” trap and showing the nuisances and complexity of Puerto Rican politics. The respect as a journalist you’ve shown to the people you interview and the work put into these videos is very clear. The work you do as a Puerto Rican journalist reporting on Puerto Rico is critical. Often times our stories are told by American or Latin American journalists not from Puerto Rico. Thank you so much for doing this work and inspiring young Boricuas to learn more and care for our home both on the Island and in the Diaspora. Keep up your inspirational work. Pa’lante🇵🇷❤️!

    • @radrook7584
      @radrook7584 3 роки тому

      Most Puerto Ricans born and raised in the USA nowadays are the product of mixing culturally and genetically with African Americans. So they very usually identify with African Americans and only give a passing interest to things that pertain to island political status issues.

    • @amyt2400
      @amyt2400 Рік тому +2

      @justinroig5858
      🇵🇷 Dearest Mr. Roig,
      I love the term “Diasporarican” and never heard it before, will look into it and until I know more I’ll attribute it to you 💙. I truly enjoyed your post! Be well and think of me the next time you have a cup of Puerto Rican coffee ☕️. I’ll do the same for you. Salud! ¡Y Bendiciones! Amy

    • @justinroig5858
      @justinroig5858 Рік тому

      @@amyt2400 Igual Igual ❤️🇵🇷❤️

  • @jessiesoto
    @jessiesoto Рік тому +2

    Why is that Puerto Rico is not a state, it is a simple question, I all comes down to the people, because the majority of the citizens do not want it...

  • @mr.ronaldgonzales2300
    @mr.ronaldgonzales2300 3 роки тому +54

    "Bitcoin is a remarkable cryptographic achievement and the ability to create something that is not duplicable in the digital world has enormous value"

    • @Maricel_oronan
      @Maricel_oronan 3 роки тому

      The bitcoin world is this new ecosystem where it doesn't cost that much to start a new bitcoin company, it doesn't cost much to start owning bitcoin either, and it is a much more efficient way of moving money around the world."

    • @elizabethtwomey681
      @elizabethtwomey681 3 роки тому

      Everyone has the mind set of investing but getting in contact with a legit broker and account manager is the problem everyone's facing instead the end up losing their hard earned money investing on wrong platforms

    • @marcuswalkerjr.2756
      @marcuswalkerjr.2756 3 роки тому

      For trading aspect I don't panic I earned maximum profit investing every week through the help of Mrs Pamela Kay Weaver. I really think she's good

    • @marcuswalkerjr.2756
      @marcuswalkerjr.2756 3 роки тому

      Many have become Millionaire through investing in ma'am Pamela K. Weaver trading platform

    • @JoreDEJuan
      @JoreDEJuan 3 роки тому

      @@marcuswalkerjr.2756 I'm really a newbie in this system and I have certain doubt and fears in crypto stock an trading I really need to have brief conversation with Mrs Pamela Kay Weaver to guide me on this😩😩😩

  • @Native2Earth
    @Native2Earth Рік тому

    After the civil rights movement PR should have went hard to become a state, the culture won’t be cleansed, yes property will go up but the infrastructure will drastically improve.

  • @DomrealtyGroup
    @DomrealtyGroup 3 роки тому +35

    I will not see statehood for PR in my lifetime and I’m 50

    • @787aida-rivers.a
      @787aida-rivers.a 3 роки тому +9

      And thank god for that :)

    • @radrook7584
      @radrook7584 3 роки тому +2

      I have often imagined myself in a time machine skipping along at a pace of 100 year intervals, and always finding one thing that doesn't change, the Puerto Rican political status in relation to the USA.

    • @radrook7584
      @radrook7584 3 роки тому +1

      That is approx a twenty five or thirty year period of it still not attaining statehood. To be honest, I don't think that it ever will because of the electoral vote factor that will ensue if statehood is granted.

    • @allanbacon2977
      @allanbacon2977 2 роки тому

      Puerto Rico would be a huge experience to become a state. There are thirteen nuclear/chemical dumps that would need to be cleaned up, the population of Puerto Rico has to many adults over the age of sixty so more medical care and money needed for the aging population also the islands crumbling infrastructure. 🇵🇷

  • @adaptiveplexus
    @adaptiveplexus Місяць тому

    you are a real reporter. It's refreshing to see that although you might have a strong opinion on this subject because it is personal to you, you present it in a completely unbiased way

  • @AngelVelez31
    @AngelVelez31 8 місяців тому +3

    No State hood for Puerto Rico, island is very valuable island to the Puerto Ricans detach from usa

  • @budvibes3367
    @budvibes3367 4 місяці тому +2

    Either be completely independent and don’t ask for help or join and become a state and then ask for help. Stop playing both sides

  • @jorgesantiago9230
    @jorgesantiago9230 2 роки тому +3

    Why be a state to become like Hawaii now, doesn't 😕

  • @alsantoshsantana8803
    @alsantoshsantana8803 20 днів тому

    Great job, Bianca! Especially liked the way you covered the Insular cases and compared them to the reversal of cases upholding discrimination against Black Americans (e.g. Plessy v Ferguson, Brown vs Board of Education).

  • @oldcrook510
    @oldcrook510 3 роки тому +3

    Puerto Rico should be freed and let go. We don't need another welfare state with our empire in decline & you don't need more Americans moving there. It's best to part ways and just have friendly relations and trade.

  • @JohnNunez-b5m
    @JohnNunez-b5m 6 місяців тому +1

    I feel like you made a better version of what I was trying to say in my video. There's so much that plays into why Puerto Rico isn't granted statehood and I feel like racism is a big part of that reason. The independence movement has definitely been attacked by U.S. I heard from friends that a lot of people boycott the status referendums making support for statehood look stronger than it is in reality, just hearsay so it could be biased. I made my video because I'm surprised more people aren't talking about Puerto Rico's status.

  • @williamrapien6071
    @williamrapien6071 3 роки тому +38

    I have been in Puerto Rico since I was stationed at Ramey AFB in the Air Force. I met a beautiful girl from Moca and married her. I have been here for over fifty years and consider myself Boricua even though I have no Puertorican blood.
    People always seem to assume that I am pro-statehood because I am a gringo. I am pro getting the status resolved one way or the other so we can concentrate on the real problems Puerto Rico is facing. As long as the status issue is the main issue of the Puertorican people, there can be no real progress for the island.
    One thing I have always noted is that most Puertoricans identify as Puertoriqueno first and sometimes as American. There is always a distinction made between Americans and Puertoricans even though I have the exact same limitation of rights as everyone else while I reside on the island. I identify with both.
    I doubt that Puerto Rico will truly identify as being American unless all political entities recognize that we are American first and Puertorican second. This does not diminish our identity as Puertorican but does accept our identity as free members of the nation call the United States of America. So, choose. Be American or be Puertorican. Statehood or Independance... just choose! Mas de lo mismo no vale na.

    • @bpassion4fashion581
      @bpassion4fashion581 3 роки тому +11

      Puertorriqueña hasta la muerte !!!

    • @opr59
      @opr59 3 роки тому +2

      @@bpassion4fashion581 Texans seem to consider themselves Texans first. Ever think of that? In any case, Puerto Rico has its own strong and proud identity ... and language...from that of the mainland, thank God!

    • @ckself
      @ckself 3 роки тому

      @@opr59 I don't think all Texans identify that way but many do. When we moved to Houston 8 years ago, we couldn't help but notice how many large Texas flags there were. I remember reading a study that showed that patriotism in Texas is lower than one might think because of the Texas first mentality. The Texit movement is big enough to be noticeable. But it's still a minority, though a sizeable minority.

    • @radrook7584
      @radrook7584 3 роки тому +2

      What exactly is Puerto Rican blood? Blood from black people of Luiza Aldea. Or is it blood from the while families who govern the island? Or might it be perhaps the blood of those who are a mix of the two?

    • @radrook7584
      @radrook7584 3 роки тому +1

      That is the delusional condition under which most island Puerto Ricans exist. They think that most Anglo Americans want or will happily accept Puerto Rican statehood.

  • @edwarddavila5898
    @edwarddavila5898 3 роки тому +2

    Looking at these corrupt politicians in Puerto Rico makes me sick it’s like looking at a bunch of politicians in Arkansas the people of Puerto Rico have no idea what Oregon needs to be a free independent nation.

  • @ClementePR21
    @ClementePR21 3 роки тому +9

    Statehood would mean the end of Puerto Rico as we know it.

  • @koltoncrane3099
    @koltoncrane3099 Рік тому +1

    Puerto Rico will never be a state unless if another territory becomes a state at the same time.
    The issues like slavery which divided the north and south really was a power issue between the north and south and balancing the power between the two. We essentially have modern slavery today and the same power force at play. It’s just not between the north and south but between the democrats or leftist states like California and New York or the coastal states really and republicans or the inner rural states mainly. There’s some exemptions like for some weird reason Florida is republican or more pro business.
    Anyways if Puerto Rico became a state that would mean there’s 51 senators in the senate. That’s not going to happen because there’s no balance of power. You’d need 52 states.

  • @lennybrewster4673
    @lennybrewster4673 3 роки тому +3

    Because paying taxes like the rest of us sucks. Simple as that. That's reason enough to NEVER do it.

    • @Tainowarrior-js3cj
      @Tainowarrior-js3cj 3 роки тому +2

      Yup 👍🏻 imagine paying the taxes we pay in the states I’ll ruin 3/4 of Puerto Rico imagine paying taxes for your fincas and you haven’t been able to find a job because there’s none the government will keep your finca and kick your a$& out.

  • @harryfloresalonso3457
    @harryfloresalonso3457 Рік тому +1

    The United States only wanted Puerto Rico for strategic reasons and that is the distance between PR and Cuba especially during the Cuban Missile crisis Puerto Rico's location was beneficial to the U.S. and to those who want statehood and think things are going to change you're wrong it's like a freed slave moving into his former masters home and expecting to be treated like family. The racist views will continue and laws will be passed that will take more land from the people

  • @hekturo8761
    @hekturo8761 3 роки тому +28

    I was born at raise in Puerto Rico, then live 21 years in the U.S.. I learned more outside the island about the relationship between USA and Puerto Rico than in the puertorican classrooms. While growing up here I was pro statehood today and forever I’ll say the worst thing that could happen to Puerto Rico it’s to become a state. We are better off independent. We have gone thru enough since we were colonized. Puerto Rico todavía tiene un pueblo durmiendo en falsas promesas

    • @ginoandsusie
      @ginoandsusie 3 роки тому +4

      Muy de acuerdo. Saludos

    • @hekturo8761
      @hekturo8761 3 роки тому +4

      @@boricuadepuracepa7628 Saludos gracias por comentar. No conoces mi historia ni mi envolvimiento he impactos que hice mientras estuve en los Estados Unidos para con el pueblo puertorriqueño para que trates a un desconocido como hipócrita. Para tu información me mude hace dos meses a la isla. Estoy de acuerdo contigo muchos Boricuas se van de la isla a vivir y más nada. Pero yo me involucré, me instruí y me desarrollé en tornos, históricos, políticos y sociológicos y económicos en relación con Estados Unidos y Puerto Rico. De que haya pasado el tiempo que pase pues cosas pasan y hasta ahora no eres nadie para yo explicarte. Pero si quieres hacer algo productivo que beneficie a Puerto Rico instrúyete y conéctate conmigo para trabajar juntos para un mejor futuro en nuestra isla.

    • @hekturo8761
      @hekturo8761 3 роки тому +3

      La verdadera Hipocresía proviene de los Estados Unidos de hacerse pasar que verdaderamente le importa el bienestar de Puerto Rico y sus habitantes. Instrúyete primero antes de atacar al que no conoces

    • @hekturo8761
      @hekturo8761 3 роки тому +4

      @@boricuadepuracepa7628 jajajaja futuro? Enserio ? 🙄 El futuro está delante de mi no atrás. Pásala bien hermano borincano ✌🏼

    • @ginoandsusie
      @ginoandsusie 3 роки тому +1

      @@boricuadepuracepa7628 No me preguntes a mi, pregúntales a los originales que quedan en Hawaii y Alaska , que son muy pocos.

  • @edwarddavila5898
    @edwarddavila5898 3 роки тому +2

    I want to say thank you for producing your video you are doing a great job of bringing awareness about the situation in Puerto Rico. Continue doing your great work

  • @Troy-nc5br
    @Troy-nc5br 7 місяців тому +3

    If you became a state right now your home prices would double and all good and services would also the inflation would sink pr overnight don't do it I love pr it is affordable

  • @CaptainMyCaptain33
    @CaptainMyCaptain33 5 місяців тому +1

    ❤ PR and all my wonderful friends there!

  • @107chewy
    @107chewy 3 роки тому +11

    Can you do a report on the Jones act? The Jones Act, an obscure 1920 regulation that requires that goods shipped from one American port to another be transported on a ship that is American-built, American-owned, and crewed by US citizens or permanent residents. The overall effects of protectionism and exploitation of the island need to end.

    • @deathfire096
      @deathfire096 3 роки тому +2

      Aren't Puerto Rican U.S. Citizens? that means that the Puerto Rican ports won't be outsourced to 3rd world countries and cheap labor. How is this exploitation?

    • @BadLuckDez
      @BadLuckDez 3 роки тому +1

      @@deathfire096 this means PR can't choose who they want to use for shipping. The use of US ships is enforced because it's very profitable for the US while making it too expensive for PR. An islands bread and butter usually is imports and exports. The US took that away to keep PR dependent.

    • @deathfire096
      @deathfire096 3 роки тому

      @@BadLuckDez why would PR choose who they want for shipping using the American routes, American merchandise, American economy, and American ports when the 50 states don't either???? It's like telling Amazon that I want your products and service but I want you to use the materials from this other country to lower your prices and profits that I want not you the business owner picking. P.R. can buy directly from other countries that can come directly but it won't come from the American market which is #1 and endless choices for the consumers, so choose, you can't have both. So stop with the B.S., You have a choice to buy from the American market or a Latino Market or Asian. By the way, all islands in the world are more expensive than any mainland and it has nothing to do with the U.S. domestic routes. Do what Cuba does, they use other countries other than the U.S. for their products and see how is it working for them, It's crap for our standards. but good luck.

    • @BadLuckDez
      @BadLuckDez 3 роки тому

      @@deathfire096 PR isn't a state. It has an international identity so holding it to the same standards as a US state without any representation like a US state, is dumb. The Jones act cost PR millions a year with no benefits whatsoever. Something the US wants to keep going because it's money for them, and it's a place to stash Navy ships.
      It's very telling that people such as yourself call this BS, are almost always white.
      There's countless articles and studies that prove the Jones act hurts PR but I guess that's all BS, huh gringo?

    • @deathfire096
      @deathfire096 3 роки тому +1

      @@BadLuckDez You can't use the American economy, American routes , American credit and tell them you don't want to follow their rules. You can always refuse buying from the American economy, don't use their credit and use another country and pay cash. I'm not white, I'm Puerto Rican that understands economy and world order. If you are going to buy from my economy, use my merchandise, use my credit to buy my things and use my routes then you don't tell me the rules. You can get it from somebody else. Puerto Rico doesn't have an embargo or blockade. You can buy and trade with any country you want but you are not using American credit, you buy it cash. If you don't like the American economy and rules then go independent get your own credit and you buy from whoever you like. Pidan la independencia.

  • @tavelewisirizarry5727
    @tavelewisirizarry5727 2 роки тому +18

    Identity is more important than statehood

    • @osvaldoraya1122
      @osvaldoraya1122 8 місяців тому

      That will lead you to poor outcomes.
      Identity will always be there; it’s important to get of the that opportunity given. This opportunity of statehood will provide the Puerto Rican people am opportunity to unveil their culture and receive.

    • @Jay92master
      @Jay92master 25 днів тому

      Well Puerto Ricans learn to be identify as Puerto Ricans as their original identity not as Americans.

  • @Thedumestyoutubechannel.2024
    @Thedumestyoutubechannel.2024 Рік тому +1

    Why does racism exist why can't we be treated the same were all humans 😡

  • @rauljosegarcia
    @rauljosegarcia 3 роки тому +10

    Jamaica is independent. Why can't Puerto Rico be independent? I know everyone wants to be affiliated with "the rich one" but what's wrong with living modestly and independently in paradise?

    • @radrook7584
      @radrook7584 3 роки тому +1

      Whenever you mention independent New World countries such as Jamaica, Haiti, or Cuba, to Pro statehood Puerto Ricans, they claim that such countries are literally starving to death and that their citizens secretly ENVY Puerto Rico's STATUS and desperately desire to become American citizens just as Puerto Ricans are.

    • @rauljosegarcia
      @rauljosegarcia 3 роки тому +3

      @@radrook7584 I can't speak to what those citizens secretly feel, but it's no secret that the Caribbean islands share something in common, and that's the economic difficulty of being an island and in that particular location. An independent Puerto Rico will have similar isues, yes, but would be free to go on without this pointless internal struggle.

  • @wainber1
    @wainber1 Рік тому +1

    From where I come (Canada), the House of Commons, the lower House of the federal Parliament, has one seat for each of its territories (Yukon, NWT, and Nunavut). Voting rights don’t change just because a person who is a citizen of Canada moves from a province to a territory or vice-versa. I see no reason why Puerto Rico shouldn’t have the same voting rights for American citizens, who live there as Nunavut already has for Canadian citizens who live in that northern territory. Nunavut after all is as predominantly indigenous as Puerto Rico is Hispanic.

    • @anonymoususer8895
      @anonymoususer8895 Рік тому

      This video is for Americans. Not Canadians. You Canadians need to understand that not everything that goes on in Canada needs to go on in the US.

    • @wainber1
      @wainber1 Рік тому

      @@anonymoususer8895 I won’t apologize whatsoever for having commented on Puerto Rico or Nunavut thank you very much.

    • @anonymoususer8895
      @anonymoususer8895 Рік тому

      @@wainber1 You will because it only proves your ign0rance. And you left-leaning Canadians don’t want to be called ign0rant don’t you?

  • @miggz777
    @miggz777 5 місяців тому +4

    Puerto Rico better off being independent, theirs another smaller Island doing great for themselves. What is stopping us. The problem rely that most Puerto Ricans have the colonizer mentality. Afraid of putting on work.

  • @alcarasjosehiram3184
    @alcarasjosehiram3184 Місяць тому +1

    Nosotros los ciudadanos americanos por ley federal no tenemos que ser ni Penep ni popular ni independentistas ninguna de esas ignorancias

  • @suntzu05
    @suntzu05 3 роки тому +59

    Statehood is like giving your house away for free and then paying rent to live there.

    • @ramonrosa2525
      @ramonrosa2525 3 роки тому +5

      our house is not ours and we are paying the rent at an alarming rate as we speak, go look around.

    • @harrisonclifford3711
      @harrisonclifford3711 3 роки тому

      that sounds way more like a territory to me

  • @JoeVirella
    @JoeVirella 3 роки тому +1

    Love the reporting on both sides of the issue 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

  • @camilopadin7497
    @camilopadin7497 Рік тому +3

    Me alegra que hayas regresado con tus vídeos. Éste en particular llama mucho a mi atención por las implicaciones políticas.
    La razón por la cual Puerto Rico no ha logrado la estadidad que un grupo desea es sencillamente porque la mayoría de los ciudadanos no la quieren. Otra razón de peso en contra del movimiento pro estadidad es la corrupción existente en el partido político que enarbolaba la bandera en favor de esta.

  • @pumfeethermodynamics3286
    @pumfeethermodynamics3286 9 місяців тому +1

    To those who suppodt the current status quo; do you not recognize how backward it is for ouerto rico to have no representation in congress?

    • @jlm3744
      @jlm3744 8 місяців тому +1

      They vote commonwealth because they don't want independence and because statehood is near to impossible to happen and would be detrimental to both the US and Puerto Rico financially, politically, and culturally. Why do you want representation in a union that is so radically divided? You think statehood will somehow save Puerto Rico, haven't you seen what congress has been doing in the passed 4 years, both Republicans and Democrats? They are wasting all the money on foreign wars and paying for illegals to enter the country and putting them into 5 star hotels in New York and Chicago, and when disasters strike like in East Palestine, Maui, and Puerto Rico they give little help.

    • @GardenStateNJ27
      @GardenStateNJ27 6 місяців тому

      Because Puerto Rico needs to fix its economy first before any status change. Statehood AND independence *RIGHT NOW* would be absolutely detrimental to the natives

    • @crunkers_
      @crunkers_ 4 місяці тому

      ​​​@@jlm3744
      At first I thought you might be some kind of left wing Puerto Rican voice, even though some of the stuff you said about gentrification and statehood didnt really make sense with what I learned were the root causes of gentrification.
      Then I saw this post, they idea that americans are secretly bringing in illegals and putting them in 5 star hotels is something I know is right wing propoganda in America. If something sounds like an absurd lie about immigrants it usually is. Which makes me suspicious of everything you've said. It would be one thing if you asked for independance, but the "do nothing" solution is always the conservative solution. Thats all that conservatives know how to do, is nay-say and block progress.

  • @pedrofelicianovega4625
    @pedrofelicianovega4625 3 роки тому +14

    I just discovered your channel and it has a lot of fascinating topics that I can share with my students. Thank you!

    • @dcarof
      @dcarof 3 роки тому

      Me too. She's great.

  • @angelvelez2360
    @angelvelez2360 3 роки тому +2

    Repeal The Jones Act for a better Puerto Rico 🇵🇷.

  • @McMovesdotcom
    @McMovesdotcom 3 роки тому +11

    What do you think of the Jones Act?

    • @nunnie768
      @nunnie768 3 роки тому +1

      It kinda hurts imports, thoughout the U.S but help domestic shippers.

    • @bmaldonado41
      @bmaldonado41 3 роки тому +5

      Antiquated a way for the US government to keep its foot on the neck of the puerto Rican people.

    • @elia.almodovar9558
      @elia.almodovar9558 3 роки тому +3

      @@bmaldonado41 Read a book once in a while, dude. The Jones Act applies to ALL Overseas Territories: Alaska, Hawai'i, Guam, American Samoa American Virgin Islands and Puerto Rico. And it doesn't look like it's going anywhere in any of those places.

    • @bmaldonado41
      @bmaldonado41 3 роки тому +3

      @@elia.almodovar9558 AND how exactly does that minimize the impact it has on the island of Puerto Rico 🇵🇷. No colony should pay that much tax on anything. NO TAXATION WITHOUT REPRESENTATION. Give us liberty or give us death.

    • @peoplesrepublicofliberland5606
      @peoplesrepublicofliberland5606 3 роки тому +3

      It makes Puerto Rico have to go through the USA. That is unsustainable

  • @pit32s
    @pit32s Рік тому

    Best series of videos in the subject I ever found.

  • @dylanshaffer2184
    @dylanshaffer2184 3 роки тому +4

    The residents must have a binding referendum to decide once and for all if they want to become a state. I personally believe that PR should become the next state of the union, but the residents must vote for it. Do the residents want to remain US citizens or not.

    • @cristobalortizortiz
      @cristobalortizortiz 3 роки тому

      whenever the congress get serious and tell us we will make a decision based on your vote it will happen for now i don't believe they are not serious about making a decisions scare of the re precautions this could have in politics for booth party also the seats Puerto Rico representatives will get sadly its on the USA Congress hands no USA president have authority over this :(

    • @dylanshaffer2184
      @dylanshaffer2184 3 роки тому +1

      @@cristobalortizortiz well in a binding referendum, congress is responsible for responding to the majority vote of the referendum. So if statehood again is the majority of the vote, then congress will vote for whether or not PR becomes the next state. It only needs a simple majority votes in both houses of congress. If the representatives can work together on it in a bipartisan way, statehood can happen. Both previous Republican and Democratic presidents have supported statehood. So statehood can happen.

    • @cristobalortizortiz
      @cristobalortizortiz 3 роки тому

      @@dylanshaffer2184 agree but sadly the only thing they ever agree is to approve their own salary increse unanonimosly i will be more than happy if they ever prove me wrong but everytime they touch the status in congress i watch it andnits empty and taken as a joke :( cheers brother

    • @dylanshaffer2184
      @dylanshaffer2184 3 роки тому

      @@cristobalortizortiz cheers, curious do you want statehood?

    • @cristobalortizortiz
      @cristobalortizortiz 3 роки тому +1

      @@dylanshaffer2184 of course at this point in history will be unthinkable of something else.

  • @dng6121
    @dng6121 Рік тому +1

    Hey attractive woman with eyebrows lead instead of complain. Vote to stop taking my money! Throw your own paper towels at each other.

  • @axellis8333
    @axellis8333 Рік тому +11

    As a puerto rican living in the US I've been horribly undereducated on this subject for far too long. Unfortunately the more I learn about it, the more lost I feel on the topic.
    Over time I've generally been in the camp that statehood is a right and necessity for puerto rico but there are so many well intentioned and strong arguments against it.
    Series' like this have been incredibly helpful for me in framing how I think about this topic, and I think are important in general. Looking forward to watching your other videos going over pros cons and history of puerto rican statehood!

    • @amyt2400
      @amyt2400 Рік тому +2

      @axellis8333
      💙 G-d bless your beautiful soul. Wikipedia is an extremely balanced source for the long and complex history of Puerto Rico and its people. I personally can’t learn from sources that take sides. Take a moment, have a cup of tea and read about the late Librarian Pura Belpré on Wikipedia. Not everyone was meant to protest and march, 🇵🇷there are many ways to support and stay connected to the island. Ms. Pura Belpré did so for NYC’s diaspora community in a fun, highly creative and impactful way. I spend my days creating authentic opportunities for people on the island and in the diaspora to connect to one another, GaD. It’s one of the most meaningful things I’ve ever done! Find your own Puerto Rican passion, connect THAT interest to a group or cause on the island (or create one yourself) and “cash in” on your rightful inheritance, it brings immense JOY! After all, it is your birthright! 🇵🇷💙🤸🏽‍♂️🕎

  • @bpassion4fashion581
    @bpassion4fashion581 3 роки тому +2

    Nah! In general, people think it is ONLY up to the Puertotican ppl to decide …They don’t know that the US does NOT want Puerto Rico as a state !!!

    • @radrook7584
      @radrook7584 3 роки тому

      True. In the the island Puerto Rican mind, such a rejection of Puerto Rico by the noble entity called the United States is inconceivable.

  • @semperverum
    @semperverum 3 роки тому +24

    With things as bad as they are in the United States we may be better off succeeding.

    • @chungusmaximus526
      @chungusmaximus526 2 роки тому +2

      No you won't. Believe me, you and us were cut from the same cloth and look how we turned out after immediate independence.

    • @semperverum
      @semperverum 2 роки тому

      @@chungusmaximus526 I hear what you're saying but they're being bled dry. Between the Jones Act and other shady deals they'll never get above board.

  • @anonydm
    @anonydm 2 роки тому +1

    Your series is amazingly educational and fascinating

  • @1AngryLakersFan
    @1AngryLakersFan 3 роки тому +18

    What has statehood done for the people of Hawaii? We will end up the same way. The flag has the colonized colors and country name. Our Taino ancestors would die again on the island. If we do that. Remember 1 people 1 nation. We are Borikens.

    • @radrook7584
      @radrook7584 3 роки тому

      The residents of Loiza Aldea identify with their West African ancestors instead of with the Tainos.

    • @hacienda2490
      @hacienda2490 3 роки тому

      "What has statehood done for the people of Hawaii?"
      Umm, greatly increased hdi, quality of life, economic and social opportunities, gdp per capita, wages and the overall safety of the place.

    • @Erick-xc7wx
      @Erick-xc7wx 2 роки тому

      I rather be a Hawaii wich is a paradise than a Mexico a Dominican Republic or even a Cuba or a venezuela, also Hawaiian culture have been known in the whole world thank to US it will be the same with Puerto Rico
      our culture would be known by whole world if it became a state

    • @becerraluisc
      @becerraluisc 7 місяців тому

      ​@@Erick-xc7wx dude mexico has it way better than PR😅

  • @tHebUm18
    @tHebUm18 Рік тому

    It is a grave injustice that PR is not a state while empty nowherevilles like Wyoming are.

  • @courcour7438
    @courcour7438 2 роки тому +10

    Awesome video! I would have really loved to hear an economic analysis of the implications of statehood on PR, the difference in infrastructure, school, hospital spending between PR & other US states, & how it affected the development of places like New Mexico, Hawaii, etc. but this was very informative!

    • @courcour7438
      @courcour7438 2 роки тому

      @clot shots Of course it can! My comment was about the economic implications of doing so. There are no fully developed Caribbean countries & if PR became a State it would become the most developed land in the region. It’s a hugely consequential variable worth considering & analyzing.

    • @courcour7438
      @courcour7438 2 роки тому +2

      @clot shots It would become as developed as every US state. Which is full development. Inversely, there sadly isn’t one example of a fully developed Caribbean nation. I understand the massive cultural pros for independence but as much as I wish it weren’t the case, economically, PR would most likely be no different to it’s neighbors. All my comment is saying is that I would really love a video covering that in greater detail than I know. Because it’s important!

  • @judahsamaria5250
    @judahsamaria5250 2 роки тому +2

    Bottom line to this question as to why isn't Puerto Rico a state is simple. The people of Puerto Rico are nationalist by heart. The people of New Mexico are not nationalist, they did not view their state as a nation, Puerto Ricans do. Puerto Ricans have their language Spanish, Judeo-Christian faith and their culture as unique. Prior to statehood in New Mexico and Arizona, Spanish was not the official language. The language of New Mexico and Arizona was English, Spanish, Navajo, Keres, Zuni. It was Michelle Obama when speaking to Puerto Ricans said that we must be willing to change our tradition, make sacrifices and change our language. Why would we do something like this, in light of what is going on today in the US? Why would we accept a "woke culture" that is in opposition to our core values? Second, all Puerto Ricans know that the US only wants our vote and Kenneth Mcclintock knows this. Lastly, Mcclintock falsely promotes an agenda that puts Puerto Ricans in a position where we have to be dependent on the US for all things, this is the current position of the US government today. Dependence and control is the hallmark of US policy towards Puerto Rico.
    ua-cam.com/users/results?search_query=michelle+obama%27s+speech+to+puerto+ricans

  • @yasminer3288
    @yasminer3288 Рік тому +4

    As a Puertorican I WANT INDEPENDENCE NOW!!!!!

  • @andrew8531
    @andrew8531 2 роки тому

    Thank you. Great video. Thinking of moving there. Good info.

  • @theavail2138
    @theavail2138 3 роки тому +24

    Thank you for this video. I do disagree with state hood for PR. Puerto Rico should be an independent country, taking charge of it’s own resources trade and education to say the least. Puerto Rico desperately needs to move in the direction of entrepreneurship, building it’s infrastructure and developing its youth to a business oriented mentality. Puerto Rico cannot depend on the US if looks to have a productive future.

    • @jaimealvarez8896
      @jaimealvarez8896 3 роки тому +1

      AMÉN!!!!!!!!

    • @angelnunez7376
      @angelnunez7376 3 роки тому +2

      I think the same but our government is way corrupt for us to be independent and move us in the right direction.

    • @radrook7584
      @radrook7584 3 роки тому +1

      The problem is that Island Puerto Rcans don't perceive that as being an urgent need.

    • @JuanOrtiz-ee5ln
      @JuanOrtiz-ee5ln 2 роки тому +1

      I love to know what's exactly those resources puerto rico have to become an Independent country? Because I don't see them.

    • @radrook7584
      @radrook7584 2 роки тому

      The nation's psychological dependence on being aided by a bigger brother mentality is too deeply ingrained to permit the development of that mindset that you describe. In fact, if given independence I predict a vast exodus from the island to the USA mainland even greater than those induced by the last hurricane.
      They will still produce good boxers though.

  • @miguelmorales9667
    @miguelmorales9667 3 роки тому +12

    You can't have both "Make Us a State" and "Yankee Go Home" at the same time.

  • @TheGonzedd
    @TheGonzedd 3 роки тому +9

    Yo pregunte lo mismo en las Naciones Unidas (Manhattan) y me dijeron que es por que No nos da la gana. Porque para ser estado tiene que aceptarlo Todo el pais en un referendum. Si no es 100% nunca van a conceder la estadidad. Ademas, le saldria demasiado cara a los EU. Por ejemplo, cambiar todas las banderas para que tengan 51 estrellitas costaria millones de dolares. Por ultimo, tendriamos demasiado poder en el Congreso, ya que, al tener mas poblacion que otros estados, tendriamos derechos a mayor cantidad de representantes. Etc,...

  • @jacquelynegonzalez4174
    @jacquelynegonzalez4174 3 роки тому +1

    Excellent summary, non-judgemental, just facts!

  • @MelRicanDePonce
    @MelRicanDePonce 2 роки тому +4

    Puerto Rico 🇵🇷 Independent and Sovereign

    • @Erick-xc7wx
      @Erick-xc7wx 2 роки тому

      statehood! 🇺🇸🇵🇷

    • @EmilioDayann
      @EmilioDayann 2 роки тому

      @@Erick-xc7wx Nunca, Por siempre Puerto Rico 🇵🇷.

  • @SeniorJohnQPublic
    @SeniorJohnQPublic 3 роки тому

    Great investigative journalism.

  • @cuffedpans
    @cuffedpans 3 роки тому +12

    Independence!!! We the puerto rican people of the island of boriken have been under colonialism since 1492, 600 years we’ve been under colonialism. Its time for independence.

    • @Erick-xc7wx
      @Erick-xc7wx 2 роки тому

      or you can just move to Cuba and live your dream

    • @Luizitoh09
      @Luizitoh09 5 місяців тому

      @@Erick-xc7wxQue ignorante lo mismo de Cuba Por Dios Ya dejen el mismo metodo de manipulacion Otros paises son republicas independientes y estan muy bien buena economía y muchas otras cosas mas que mejor ejemplo que Republica dominicana ya esta mucho mejor que nosotros 🤷🏾

  • @eroman10
    @eroman10 3 роки тому +1

    The USA is a constitutional representative republic, not a democracy. If you want to be a state, at least learn what you're asking for.

  • @heru-deshet359
    @heru-deshet359 3 роки тому +4

    I love the way she says "Puerto RRRico".

    • @radrook7584
      @radrook7584 3 роки тому +1

      That was one thing that began to grate on Trump's nerves, the way that the PR Governor kept pronouncing Puerto Rico.

    • @Erick-xc7wx
      @Erick-xc7wx 2 роки тому

      she should have respect to the language she’s speaking and pronounce it in English since she’s speaking English

    • @michaelhalsall5684
      @michaelhalsall5684 Рік тому

      @@Erick-xc7wx As an English speaker I was taught to say "pwertoh reeco". It not hard to say. English speakers don't mispronounce Colorado or Florida which are Spanish language names.