Hmm, actually the explanation is in this clip. I'm sure it was in the Playing By Heart documentary. He describes it as that journey of a young man who has left home in make his way in the world and then returned after some time. The home is the same, but his perception of it is made different by the journey.
I love Brahms Violin Sonatas, but Daniel has kinda ruined it for me. I can only listen to his recordings of these sonatas... so many violinists I never got to enjoy playing cause it's not him on the piano...
Whatttt??? Why such a laconic comment... Oistrakh was a great violinist, but so is Maxim! And Barenboim on the piano is not bad also!!! So, "worst version" - I think not, quite opposite, maybe one of the top versions!!
Actually, the reason I am here is that I've just heard the last movement of the sonata played by another violinist and remembered how I loved Vengerov&Barenboim's version!!
@@vladiinsky The Oistrakh and Richter version is great for comparison: ua-cam.com/video/7a7027n6Duw/v-deo.html However, Barenboim and Vengerov are great too.
This is the best I have come across. I wish the whole sonata was here!
With the experts. Enjoy...
ua-cam.com/video/7a7027n6Duw/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/xXeQeJqu5TA/v-deo.html
I found it. I really wanted it, too.
Brahms is so beautiful.
Barenboim's explanation of this piece makes it all the better.
at 1:56 you can see vengerov's first teacher in the audience.
Hmm, actually the explanation is in this clip.
I'm sure it was in the Playing By Heart documentary.
He describes it as that journey of a young man who has left home in make his way in the world and then returned after some time. The home is the same, but his perception of it is made different by the journey.
An excellent presentation !!
Vengerov playing this piece is exactly like Mario del Monaco singing Winterreise.
5:47
I feel like he has a lot of tension in his shoulder...
No. In his brain…because he is NOT a good musician and he has NO IDEA about what he is doing with the peace.
Its like Del Monaco singing Winterreise.
Thank you! I am indeed!
I love Brahms Violin Sonatas, but Daniel has kinda ruined it for me. I can only listen to his recordings of these sonatas... so many violinists I never got to enjoy playing cause it's not him on the piano...
5:19 pure gold
Vengerov is ALWAYS playing too late!!! And Barenboim doesnt notice it???? He did a reference recording with Zukerman!!!!! Terrible…decadent.
Worst version ever.... Listen David Oistrakh
Whatttt??? Why such a laconic comment... Oistrakh was a great violinist, but so is Maxim! And Barenboim on the piano is not bad also!!! So, "worst version" - I think not, quite opposite, maybe one of the top versions!!
Actually, the reason I am here is that I've just heard the last movement of the sonata played by another violinist and remembered how I loved Vengerov&Barenboim's version!!
Tibor Varga , best interpretation, and Heifetz.. oistrach is not in tone..
@@vladiinsky The Oistrakh and Richter version is great for comparison:
ua-cam.com/video/7a7027n6Duw/v-deo.html
However, Barenboim and Vengerov are great too.