Hi Ilhem Bench Journal editors look at every aspect of reviewers' comments as well as their recommendations (reject, major revisions required, etc.) But since they are responsible for everything their journals publish, editors must take the final call based on all relevant factors. However, it is common for editors to accept reviewers' recommendations if they find their review comments detailed, constructive, and justifiable. Best, The Editage Insights team
So finaly, what is the part of reviewers comments (or scores ) in the editor's final decision ?
Hi Ilhem Bench
Journal editors look at every aspect of reviewers' comments as well as their recommendations (reject, major revisions required, etc.) But since they are responsible for everything their journals publish, editors must take the final call based on all relevant factors. However, it is common for editors to accept reviewers' recommendations if they find their review comments detailed, constructive, and justifiable.
Best,
The Editage Insights team