Her argument is moot because the act violated fundamental rights. she is trying to argue on behalf of a certain groups rights being infringed upon (people of faith having difficulties getting exemptions based on their religious beliefs), when the entirety of the mandates were unlawful, making the argument moot. shes arguing that certain Canadians had a difficult time getting an exemption for an illegal mandate which she believes is an infringement on their rights. Its not an infringement, it was illegal all together, which makes her argument a waste of time. Moot.
What was even more disgusting as a country is, they discarded Canadian citizens stranded elsewhere in yhe world to suffer without any help to get them back, even third world countries had the regard for their citizens ti bring them back home. On top of it they forced people to pay $1200+ to self - jail themselves in a 3/4 star hotel @ 4 times the regular prices. Yakk about Communism, this is another level.
Let's remember that Newfoundland didn't even want to be a part of Canada... but now, 150 years later, their government wants to violate the constitution & get away with it.
@ScubaSteveCanada it's not about making money at this point. It's about standing up to the freaking bureaucrats and making sure that they can be punished for wrongdoing.
There isn't time for a class action right now! We need an instant president set so they can't do this! The court needs to rule in favor of what is right and just for the peoples God given rights protected! No more overreach
Never again? Guaranteed it will happen again. Look at how easily all citizens around the world gave up their freedoms and got in line, not once ,not twice but 3 or more times because they were told too. The writing is on the wall, people are weak and want to be told what, when, where and how to do things. Not all, but the not all part is much much to slim to do anything meaningful in the end.
I refused vaccine and ended up being trapped in NewBrunswick during mandates. Not only was my Prime Minister spewing hate at me , making my fellow citizens against me...i was also living with a very angry soul. I am trting to get tgrough the hatred i feel for tgose who condemed free will. 😢😢😢
I am now convinced that we need to have two “societies.” One for people who like big government & believe it’s the government’s job to look after them & the other who believes in small or minimal government & believes in the free market. Some people are perfectly OK with their rights being trampled because they fully trust the government & believe they must be doing for a reason. That’s MESSED UP IMO but I truly believe that as long as we live in a free country (LOL) they should have that right but so should we have the right to NOT have our rights trampled as long as we are not breaking the law. Of course I see the attempts to change the law so that “trampling” our rights IS the government’s right. MESSED UP!!!
I too met with angry people. I lost my family and some friends, literally and figuratively. The one thing that happened is their masks were dropped. I truly found out who they are. Freedom ❤
What was even more disgusting as a country is, they discarded Canadian citizens stranded elsewhere in yhe world to suffer without any help to get them back, even third world countries had the regard for their citizens ti bring them back home. On top of it they forced people to pay $1200+ to self - jail themselves in a 3/4 star hotel @ 4 times the regular prices. Yakk about Communism, this is another level.
“ Moot due to the Emergency act is no longer in effect”??? Any violation of our rights and freedoms supposedly guaranteed in our Charter should NEVER be considered “moot”! Whether or not the circumstances have changed! When I first that some court had declared a violation of rights was declared”moot” and dismissed in another province, I thought that was wrong and was a further violation of our rights and freedoms. I still think so and that some our judges are compromised by their political ideals, just as our government has been for the last 9+ years by Justin Trudeau’s activistic ideology. A violation of our rights and freedoms should ALWAYS take precedence, no matter what the circumstances on the political scene, and never be dismissed out of hand by ANY judge.
@@kennethmelnychuk9737Very well put. I've heard it referred to in terms of a store owner not being able to sue a thief who holds him up because the thief isn't robbing them _right now_
$800 dollar fine for walking across an empty soccer field during so called pandemic. Do Canadians have actual rights or just privileges that our master can revoke?
We are slaves. WHY do they get part of our earnings? What right do they have to our LABOUR? This has never been addressed, and by not doing so, we are tacitly owned by them.
@Demmie-nl2qh Exactly. When people tell me they are public servants, I always ask them since when do servants make more and have more privileges than their masters.
Our head of state is still a guy in a UK crime family. We get our intelligence from others with the same head of state. Land is owned by "The Crown". The head of state has the power to dissolve governments. Do the math.
I hate when judges argue that something has ended, so to litigate over it is pointless, aka moot. Can I use that defence in a criminal trial and argue the crime has already been committed, so to jail me is a moot action?
Yes I am a Canadian. A Canadian is a Canadian. We all have a right to be free to travel to and from any and all Provinces and Territories without restrictions these rights can not be impede on.
The Notwithstanding clause says different. In fact Section 1 of the Charter, the very first section, states the government can revoke any right it so chooses as long as it can justify it. To whom it must be justified is unclear.
if you are a man or a woman, how can you be a canadian? think about what you are saying plz consider it. you're one or the other, can't be both simultaneously it's impossible. a "canadian" IMO is a fiction of the mind that has been planted there by a nefarious agent of CANADA INC. plz see this
Restored? Nothing changed. Section 1 was there from day one and it is necessary to deal with conflicting rights. Despite all the belly aching, no rights were removed or permanently modified. There were temporary restrictions due to a pandemic. Nothing more, nothing less.
@@CRuM770the right to movement is an internationally recognized human right. If you can’t see that governments all over the world pushed us to see how many of our rights they could take away in so called ‘extreme’ circumstances, than you need to wake up.
BC borders may have been open, all Except the airports...I couldn't return home for not months, but years, literally, because no-one could enter or leave BC without having the vx. My doctor strongly advised me not to get the vx, due to specific health conditions, and to sit it out instead. It took a very long time - nearly 3 years, before entry was again possible.
One couldn’t even argue a health angle, as NWT residents could freely travel in and out of the territory to surrounding provinces. They literally had police at the road borders. Sheer insanity of govt overreach.
Killed my little brothers new buissness aswell,he lost his successful restaurant,then his wife,then he took his own life,🌸💜💜this has had a horrible effect on my family’s lives
I agree with you and it does remind me of the movie Logan’s Run (the dystopian society Trudeau wants to create runs parallel to the carousel the runner etc). They want to remove the right to citizens to move freely and if you want to get out of your cage, you will have to pay tarifs.
That goes with the start of the constitution.. It shall be lawful for the Queen, by and with the Advice of Her Majesty’s Most Honourable Privy Council and not forgetting the famous section 33! Notwithstanding! I love our stupid toothless charter of rights! lol
@@lynnewilliams542 we had lockdowns and passports. Did you have the stuff in your bingo card? Can’t believe any socialist morons want the government controlling us so give me a break I really honestly cannot believe the NDP did as well as they did. They should be non-party status in my opinion because they’re disgrace. But people are waking up.
I was trapped in NB 😢 I moved there oct 2019 to start a new adventure after raising kids. Sold everything and drove across Canada 🇨🇦 4 months later covid hit . I refused vaccine which trapped me. At least that's how I feel 😢
I really hope this is won. I cannot believe how easily our populous fell in line and asked zero questions after these awful measures. Okay, give freedom to authority in scary times, unwise, but I can understand. However, where is the pressure to look back with critical, humility and demand answers so we don’t repeat this. Over half of Canada completely complicit with corporate greed and government corruption like we’ve never seen.
I didn't get vaccinated and any employer that inquired about your medical vaccination statess did so ILLIGALLY. As for the other mandates they to infringed apon Canadians rights and were mandates, not laws!!!
As a Canadian, I can honestly say, "JUST TRY AND STOP ME FROM TRAVELLING ANYWHERE I WANT TO WITHIN THE CANADIAN BORDERS!" Canada is the most free country in the world. Try pushing your own political views onto me and see where that gets you. Our forefathers fought, and some died, so that we could be free. If you disagree, go back to whatever close-minded country you came from. This is OUR country. We will remain free, even if we have to take back the country and run it ourselves. Who needs a corrupt government anyway? We can run a much better democratic government ran by people, not politicians. They seem to only be interested in what the country can do for THEM instead of the other way around. Time for change I guess!
Change needs to come with clearer laws. Less laws and less government. More community. More power at lower government where citizens have more say for their area.
@@cathycurrie6305 I agree. That's why I decided that if Pierre P cannot, or does not, make the necessary changes to our political, judicial and education systems, I will form a new party with people like you and I who believe that Canada doesn't need a politicial-ran government, it needs a people/citizen ran government. One ran by the people, for the people, representing only the people and not the individual politician's best interests. We have a political system only because it was handed down to us. That doesn't mean we have to endure a painfully bad and outdated system - we have the ability to change it accordingly, and change is absolutely necessary. The one thing Trudeau has done good was prove just how bad our system is, how easily corrupted it is, and how power can be abused. We must make changes, no, scrap the old one altogether and create a new one. One that fits our modern time. There is no reason why, in this modern day and age, we cannot create a system where all citizens get to cast their vote and let their voices and opinions be heard DIRECTLY through secure polls done on a newly developed political platform, which would be created with the best encryption and safety protocols on the planet. Right now the government does have a safe system, so safe in fact, that once you forget your password you can never get back in... That's another issue altogether... This system would allow us to cut the number of MPs on the citizens' dime to a minimal number of crucial Minister positions to run the country, however they would be acting according to the majority of Canadians' wishes, not whatever the "party" decided. There will be many opposed to "electronic" voting, claiming it can be tampered with, but I say no, if it is properly programmed and monitored, independently checked and verified to be uncrackable, then it is far safer than paper voting, and especially more accurate than electing MPs who only vote according to their leader's wishes, not the people they are representing! If 80% of Canadians want an election now, why are 60% of MPs voting against a motion of non-confidence? Because they are listening to and voting according to the PM, not those that elected them. Why do you think they are being replaced in byelections? Because if you won't represent us, we will replace you But this is slow and antiquated. We should be able to have immediate responses and action, which would happen with the new E-Politics system I would have developed. Hopefully there are enough ticked off Canadians who agree and woud love to join this new party, should it become necessary. Go Pierre, do us good! I don't want to enter politics, but will if I have no other choice. My children's future and their children's future depend on it!
My friend was not permitted to leave PEI when her father was dying in New Brunswick. What would you suggest she should have done ... swim the Northumberland Strait? THIS WAS REAL
From you’ve said about the Charter should be read an entire document, I hope the Supreme Court should end up deciding for the claimant and ‘slap the hands’ of the provincial government.
You could even have a funeral in Ontario we had a niece who past away too and it was brutal treatment for her mother not to be able to have a funeral until almost a year later just appalling evil and many suffered this way!
@@roartary Canada did not stop her from going. If she lived in the east, she can blame her conservative government but the rest of us were free to travel . So many incorrect statements in here. The Canadian border was never closed to citizens. Not even for 10 minutes. I hate Trudeau too but can’t blame him for that
@@lynnewilliams542 Nice to see that estrog:?n keeps the stupidi?y working. Why don't you get a job refilling those little dispensers in men's bathr?oms.
You go get them don't let them get away with any of that I think you're very correct and i'm glad that we have someone like you Fighting for us. Go bless you
It should be an open and shut case. But the court hedges it in any way, that court needs to be replaced and the constitution needs to be amended to clear all these questions of basic human rights in Canada. 🇨🇦 keep it up.
I watched as my Constitutional Rights of security of person, right of assembly, right to travel, right to religious freedom, right to safety and security of person all considered "moot" by our Federal government. Not a single word from our politicians, police, medical officers, lawyers, judges, attorney generals. They all stood by and watched, complied, and continued to get a paycheck. How many Canadians lost their jobs ? Their livelihood? Corporations all remained opened. Mom and pop shops were decimated. How many Canadians "coerced" into taking the jab by all levels of government and businesses. Where were the feminists screeching "My body: My choice" ? Their collective silence was defeaning. How many Canadians were denied access to health care because of "jab status". Father's who couldn't be there to see the birth of their children. Husbands and wives sitting in parking lots as their loved ones were alone, many dying in hospitals. How many of those suffering demetia only got worse as they were held hostage by "the system". Our children in school are still suffering silently. Another hostage taken by "the system" I watched in shock and awe as 1/3 of Canadians, watched, another 1/3 of Canadians, go full arthoritarian on the remaining 1/3. Pure Cult of Personality and Psychosis in action. I had no idea how many of my countrymen preferred their chains to freedom. I had no idea how many Canadians sold their freedoms for "travel-vacations", "going to restaurants", etc. The Trucker Convoy: not a single policitian stood in line against the police on that final day. Not one. Not a judge. Not a lawyer. Not a doctor. Not a teacher. Not a professor. Not a single member of the damned "elites". Not single attempt at negotiation. A great crime was committed in this country. I will never forget. I will never forgive. Nuremberg 2.0 God Bless
Mobility simpliciter can be inferred from the absence of the need for any travel documents within Canada and the existence of a Canadian passport, rather than a provincial one. Canada is a country, not an EU and a single nation not a Shengen zone. I agree with your reading of the French version, the use of deplacer vs demenager is relevant and correct. I would also argue that it would be reasonable to require mitigating actions in cases of an epidemic or other emergency but not an outright ban on travel, unless the emergency is something like a forest fire. Even in that case is the restraint of a damn fool reasonable?
in Quebec, a guy and his girlfriend went to see his mom in her last hours in France. when they came back, hell broke totally loose, cost them a fortune, the stupid civil servant didn't find that it was a good enough reason
I doubt that happened. All Canadians have the right to enter Canada at their pleasure. They might make you test and quarantine until negative comes back but that is all. Certainly not any hell breaking loose
@@lynnewilliams542call it as you wish and I will continue to call it hell breaking loose: I saw him in an interview back then. whatever happened to them that was very hard on them when you are grieving, and very cosrly, my point is that the heartless civil servant couldn't care less about his desire to see his dying mother and should have applied a special treatment but didn't
@@lynnewilliams542 What kind of a pig would deny someone else's experience? Who do you think you are? Obviously an arrogant self-entitled leftist ignoramus. Go back under your hole.
CVG: you have so many supporters. This one offers a huge Thank You. During 2020 I accepted what was happening... Until....my turning point. Specifically, when I heard that travel between Ontario and Quebec was being limited to VaxPass persons by police at checkpoints. I said to myself, "ya sure... they can't do that". When I found it was true - that was my moment of awakening and I found your work. Thanks !
“Canada allows” is the problem. “Allowing” anyone to do anything isn’t upholding rights, it’s ingraining the idea that it is a privilege and can be revoked at any time for any reason.
@@lynnewilliams542 Yes, there were federal restrictions. Air and rail transportation are federally regulated. The federal government imposed mandates on air and rail passengers. Mandates were imposed that ignored one's constitutional charter rights.
@@ricknash3055 true. There were some restrictions, but I found ways around it. But I never had a problem leaving or entering Canada in 2020 and 2021. I agree that the Covid vaccine to fly was over reach. But you could fly out of US city. I do hope the woman wins her court case. The Newfoundland government acted in the wrong
I was born in NL. Therefore, I am a Newfoundlander. I also was born in Canada, therefore I am a Canadian. As a Canadian I am free to travel anywhere in MY country. Seems pretty simple to me!
I would have loved to read your book but ,ordered it (and paid for) from Optimum Publishing, Nov. 3, 2023 and still have not received it. I really enjoy your posts and the information they contain.
We really appreciate what you guys do and I know you don't get the credit for it I was one of those people that was banned from society and it completely ruined my life and my family's
This case is very important to me. During the pandemic, I had ongoing litigation in Ontario, but was unable to travel there from Nova Scotia. As it turned out, my lawyer has worked so unbelievably slowly, that my case has made little progress 😢. During the pandemic, a friend of mine in Nova Scotia was prevented from being with her disabled son in New Brunswick when he underwent a serious surgery. Fortunately it turned out well, but she suffered a lot of worry and still feels guilty that she could not be there for him. Thank you for your efforts in challenging government over reach.
That's funny because the workers compensation board of British Columbia had no problem sending me to medical appointments in the Lower Mainland and Kelowna... During lockdown... there was sometimes on Highway 97 where I was the only one driving for 100 km.. yeah just me and the RC...
This case highlights why I have lost all respect for our judges. Every time we needed them to stand up for OUR RIGHTS during covid, what did we see? They deferred to the gov'ts wish. Absolutely disgusting, either we have democratic Rights and Freedoms as per our constitution or we don't.
Thanks for the update on this issue. This is what Dmocracy is all about where the Laws of any nation Governs and takes precedence within our Constitution guidelines. Keep up the good work for Cabada.
I was stranded in the Phillippines for 2 years during covid because the govt wanted me to quarantine in hotel at the cost of $300 to $400 a day for 14 days which I didn't want to pay this since my brother lived 1 kilometer from the Vancouver airport, where I could quarintine for free. It cost me at least $1500 a month to stay. in the Philippines. This is when I learned to hate my govt, I don't want to hate my country. What is so stupid about this is they were telling people traveling to return to Canada. Also both me and my brother had all our covid shots plus the booster shots.
So why didn’t you fly into Seattle and take a bus to the border. That is what I did. The hotel quarantine was only for 3 days max and it wasn’t 2 years. You were not stuck anywhere. You can always come back to canada
If "move to" was indicating the ability to take up residence then the "take up residence" text would not be required. By saying both means that "move" means to travel freely.
Thanks for all you do. I bought and read the book. You must win this case. In July 2021 I wanted to visit my 2 grandchildren in Ottawa. I could not fly without vax proof, so decided to drive, Van - Ottawa, but Manitoba had closed it's borders and driving into the US would not be an option. Very reluctantly I did get the 2 jabs, bought a ticket to fly but when I boarded, no one asked to see any vax proof either in Van or Ottawa. It was clear to me that this was control and had nothing to do with health
You could have driven in the US. They didn’t require vaccination until February 2022. I agree that it sucked requiring you to be vaccinated. I am vaccinated. My choice. I believe that makes me safe from you. That was over reach.
When i traveled to PEI during that time, i was AGAST that i needed a 'travel passport' to enter the province. I had to apply online and reveived it from the Provincial government. I then needed a nose swab before being let past the checkpoint. To add insult to injury, we were free to go after the test, without knowing the results, they said they would call me if I was positive to ask me to self quarantine. I asked the medic, ok, lets just say i am positive and i go right from here to a busy public place and interact with people.... you've essentially allowed me to leave a testimg area and possibly infect an unknown number of people before you phone me. Just absolutely clown world.
Good luck you was not quarantined, but yes you make a point the mandates was made by evil people with evil methods and big business also guilty because they welcome all this madness which is against all humans' rights!!! Same as WW2, against humans will by cheating and lies through MSM!!!
My husband was basically a couple hours from death in the hospital and they specifically told us( my mother my son and myself )that only 2 of us could sit by my husband while he died in front of us.
My question is, where were all the lawyers while this lockdown was in progress? Why didn't they sue? Why sue now, when things have already come and gone?
There were cases. The court system is very very slow. Some might say selectively so. Lots of bad actors filed poorly written cases too, that were inevitably tossed.
I guess the supreme court will rule if the charter rights are rights or just privileges. We are only as free as we think we are. Think of it as we are in a cage which is really a vice. As our rights are whittled away or new laws enacted is another turn of the vice. Years down the road as the cage or vice gets smaller you are crushed. Thankyou for keeping up the good fight.
did we not build the Trans Canadian Highway to "facilitate" the freedom of travels across the country, why wouldnt this idea apply to other methods of movement??
French Canadian here with a little background in Law ( two years and 61 credits done in Montreal university) I can say easily that ´´se déplacer et déménager ´ are not the same at all as Christine said it with her nice English accent 😊. Deplorable or déplorable have the same meaning in both languages and what have done the province of Terre-Neuve is disgusting as the others provinces too. Ok we have the law but if we cannot count on judges anymore I predict to you that there will be blood!
A rights violation is NEVER moot, and is fully deserving of being heard, investigated and punished.
This govt is grossly overusing and misusing NDA's and mootness in order to enforce their totalitarian whims and desires.
Her argument is moot because the act violated fundamental rights. she is trying to argue on behalf of a certain groups rights being infringed upon (people of faith having difficulties getting exemptions based on their religious beliefs), when the entirety of the mandates were unlawful, making the argument moot.
shes arguing that certain Canadians had a difficult time getting an exemption for an illegal mandate which she believes is an infringement on their rights.
Its not an infringement, it was illegal all together, which makes her argument a waste of time.
Moot.
Honk!
What was even more disgusting as a country is, they discarded Canadian citizens stranded elsewhere in yhe world to suffer without any help to get them back, even third world countries had the regard for their citizens ti bring them back home. On top of it they forced people to pay $1200+ to self - jail themselves in a 3/4 star hotel @ 4 times the regular prices. Yakk about Communism, this is another level.
Canadians won't know we never had any rights in the first place
If the government can limit your rights, you don't have any rights.
Seriously. The whole point of rights is to restrict what laws and rules government can create or impose.
That’s the reason for 10 minute cities.
@@alanj9978: the government has trampled on the Canadian Bill of Rights and Freedoms when they dismantled the Freedom Protest.
Let's remember that Newfoundland didn't even want to be a part of Canada... but now, 150 years later, their government wants to violate the constitution & get away with it.
That’s why a 2nd amendment is so important
This should be a class action law suit
The lawyers are the only ones that make the money when a payout is granted.
@ScubaSteveCanada it's not about making money at this point. It's about standing up to the freaking bureaucrats and making sure that they can be punished for wrongdoing.
There isn't time for a class action right now! We need an instant president set so they can't do this! The court needs to rule in favor of what is right and just for the peoples God given rights protected! No more overreach
Couldn't agree more.
Easily
Heath Canada what a joke
Got that right!
It should be called DEATH Canada
the Royals are the real Nazis !!!!!!!
Dumbass
CCP Tam for Prison !
you don't know how to spell?
You folks are my heros!! Thank you for standing up for the average Canadians!!!
They are Canadian Super Heroes. Its great to see
BC banned travel from one part to another, thanks for your efforts, never again should people have their freedom stripped away like that.
Com mu ism at its best, get rid of dic ta tor trudy
Quebeckistan did the same.
I live in BC. I didn't comply with any of it. Nobody tells me what I can or can't do
@@johnwilliams6063 exactly, they can't force that on you.
Never again? Guaranteed it will happen again. Look at how easily all citizens around the world gave up their freedoms and got in line, not once ,not twice but 3 or more times because they were told too. The writing is on the wall, people are weak and want to be told what, when, where and how to do things. Not all, but the not all part is much much to slim to do anything meaningful in the end.
I refused vaccine and ended up being trapped in NewBrunswick during mandates. Not only was my Prime Minister spewing hate at me , making my fellow citizens against me...i was also living with a very angry soul. I am trting to get tgrough the hatred i feel for tgose who condemed free will. 😢😢😢
FORGIVENESS IS THE KEY.
@@magma9138 So is restitution to those who were wronged.
I am now convinced that we need to have two “societies.” One for people who like big government & believe it’s the government’s job to look after them & the other who believes in small or minimal government & believes in the free market. Some people are perfectly OK with their rights being trampled because they fully trust the government & believe they must be doing for a reason. That’s MESSED UP IMO but I truly believe that as long as we live in a free country (LOL) they should have that right but so should we have the right to NOT have our rights trampled as long as we are not breaking the law. Of course I see the attempts to change the law so that “trampling” our rights IS the government’s right. MESSED UP!!!
I too met with angry people. I lost my family and some friends, literally and figuratively. The one thing that happened is their masks were dropped. I truly found out who they are. Freedom ❤
What was even more disgusting as a country is, they discarded Canadian citizens stranded elsewhere in yhe world to suffer without any help to get them back, even third world countries had the regard for their citizens ti bring them back home. On top of it they forced people to pay $1200+ to self - jail themselves in a 3/4 star hotel @ 4 times the regular prices. Yakk about Communism, this is another level.
Glad this is happening. However still terribly disappointed Peckfords case was rejected.
“ Moot due to the Emergency act is no longer in effect”??? Any violation of our rights and freedoms supposedly guaranteed in our Charter should NEVER be considered “moot”! Whether or not the circumstances have changed! When I first that some court had declared a violation of rights was declared”moot” and dismissed in another province, I thought that was wrong and was a further violation of our rights and freedoms. I still think so and that some our judges are compromised by their political ideals, just as our government has been for the last 9+ years by Justin Trudeau’s activistic ideology. A violation of our rights and freedoms should ALWAYS take precedence, no matter what the circumstances on the political scene, and never be dismissed out of hand by ANY judge.
Agreed, this is akin to not trying the nazis and Japanese leaders for crimes against humanity because WWII ended.
And yet, these nine ring-wraiths in their Santa Claus suits will do exactly the same thing.
These nine will do exactly the same thing.
Tried to reply but once again PravdaTube goose steeped all over my comment.
@@kennethmelnychuk9737Very well put. I've heard it referred to in terms of a store owner not being able to sue a thief who holds him up because the thief isn't robbing them _right now_
Put them in jail
$800 dollar fine for walking across an empty soccer field during so called pandemic. Do Canadians have actual rights or just privileges that our master can revoke?
Clearly .gov believes the latter.
We are slaves. WHY do they get part of our earnings? What right do they have to our LABOUR? This has never been addressed, and by not doing so, we are tacitly owned by them.
@Demmie-nl2qh Exactly. When people tell me they are public servants, I always ask them since when do servants make more and have more privileges than their masters.
Again that was your conservative Ontario govt that had the stupid rules. Same as Quebec.
Our head of state is still a guy in a UK crime family. We get our intelligence from others with the same head of state. Land is owned by "The Crown". The head of state has the power to dissolve governments. Do the math.
I hate when judges argue that something has ended, so to litigate over it is pointless, aka moot.
Can I use that defence in a criminal trial and argue the crime has already been committed, so to jail me is a moot action?
The court must side with the woman. Must
Yes I am a Canadian. A Canadian is a Canadian. We all have a right to be free to travel to and from any and all Provinces and Territories without restrictions these rights can not be impede on.
The Notwithstanding clause says different. In fact Section 1 of the Charter, the very first section, states the government can revoke any right it so chooses as long as it can justify it. To whom it must be justified is unclear.
Yep as well as leave and enter any time I please
All First Nations people could travel. AFAIK, they were the only ones whose rights were not taken away.
No you are not
and you are very selfish
you have no idea what a Canadian is
if you are a man or a woman, how can you be a canadian? think about what you are saying plz consider it. you're one or the other, can't be both simultaneously it's impossible. a "canadian" IMO is a fiction of the mind that has been planted there by a nefarious agent of CANADA INC. plz see this
Don’t give up the fight for freedom fight fight fight
Good luck - it's time Canadians' basic rights and freedoms are restored! Without freedom, we have nothing!
Restored? Nothing changed. Section 1 was there from day one and it is necessary to deal with conflicting rights.
Despite all the belly aching, no rights were removed or permanently modified. There were temporary restrictions due to a pandemic. Nothing more, nothing less.
@@CRuM770 It started out that way that’s for sure , But it did not end that way …. I find it hard to defend what happened to Canadians.
@@CRuM770the right to movement is an internationally recognized human right. If you can’t see that governments all over the world pushed us to see how many of our rights they could take away in so called ‘extreme’ circumstances, than you need to wake up.
Without mass civillian enforcement you have nothing.
@@moldbrain660 we have NO RIGHT to enter any country but our own
Let’s hope our Supreme Court doesn’t have any idiot woke judges sitting.
AND IF THERE IS WE WILL ALL KNOW THEY ARE. NURENBURG 2.0
All 9 are
They have women on the court. Women are inherently woke.
They openly brag about being vaccinated .
If any of them are still wearing masks then this case is dead in the water.
My Dad died in this time and I couldn't go to burial. I am still very affected about this i don't know what to do.
I lost my little brother 🌸💜🙏🏼🍀
That is horrible. We attended an outdoor funeral summer 2020
@@eileencameron1510 sorry for your loss 😢
@@lynnewilliams542 sorry for your loss 😢
I lost my sister 😞
Thank you for your hard work and great coverage Christine.
From Alberta I couldn’t enter Northwest Territories, though I had a business and staff housing there. Yup , the govt killed the business.
I’m sorry that happened to you. 😢
But you were welcome to enter B.C. We never closed our border to any Canadian
BC borders may have been open, all
Except the airports...I couldn't return home for not months, but years, literally, because no-one could enter or leave BC without having the vx. My doctor strongly advised me not to get the vx, due to specific health conditions,
and to sit it out instead. It took a very long time - nearly 3 years, before entry was again possible.
One couldn’t even argue a health angle, as NWT residents could freely travel in and out of the territory to surrounding provinces. They literally had police at the road borders. Sheer insanity of govt overreach.
Killed my little brothers new buissness aswell,he lost his successful restaurant,then his wife,then he took his own life,🌸💜💜this has had a horrible effect on my family’s lives
I'm so glad everyone is sticking up for themselves. Thank you. Freedom is the best❤
Perfect. I’m so glad you’re fighting for our freedoms. Thank YOU!!
Thank you for continuing to support and fight for our rights!
Thank you so much Christine. We really need and appreciate your work. We the people need to know this stuff. 👍
Giver Christine!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Thanks CCF from our family!!
Anything that destroys the WEF Agenda. The 15 minute City concept is straight out of the movie
LOGAN'S RUN!
I agree with you and it does remind me of the movie Logan’s Run (the dystopian society Trudeau wants to create runs parallel to the carousel the runner etc). They want to remove the right to citizens to move freely and if you want to get out of your cage, you will have to pay tarifs.
Nailed it. I've been thinking that since 2020. With a dash of Children of Men.
Like my life is limited to a 15 mins walk! lollll
So, Hollywood is in on it?
@je-freenorman7787 Hollywood is Woke, because Objectivity (1+1=2) is Racist 🏴☠️,but Logan's Run was a 1976 film 🎥 🎞
Thank you Christine for everything you do greatly appreciated 💪🏻👍🏻🇨🇦🏁
Thank you all for your hard work for Canadians. ❤
Good news, and we need way more court cases, justice must be done.
Thank you Christine ❤
Good ole section 1. You have rights buuuuuuut only if we say. Joke.🤬
Yes, if they can suspend your rights for up to five years, you pretty much don't have any.
That goes with the start of the constitution.. It shall be lawful for the Queen, by and with the Advice of Her Majesty’s Most Honourable Privy Council
and not forgetting the famous section 33! Notwithstanding!
I love our stupid toothless charter of rights! lol
And yet dummies keep voting NDP, like in BC. What a joke this whole thing was.
Election was rigged, yes was some who voted NDP but I do believe was not that many as the voting result
Oh stop it. B.C. did well during Covid. We had NO travel restrictions. Ontario and Quebec, conservative provinces, had big shut downs and restrictions
@@lynnewilliams542 😂 What was those quarantine things and that stupid fascist app? Oh and the COVID (CERTIFICATE OF VAGZINE ID)
@@lynnewilliams542 we had lockdowns and passports. Did you have the stuff in your bingo card? Can’t believe any socialist morons want the government controlling us so give me a break I really honestly cannot believe the NDP did as well as they did. They should be non-party status in my opinion because they’re disgrace. But people are waking up.
@@lynnewilliams542 Canada was the most restrictive country in the world. What the hell are you talking about?
FREEDOM
HONK HONK
In NB they said you couldn't travel between cities
Higgs even said you couldn't go to the grocery store until public outcry.
In BC too!
I was trapped in NB 😢 I moved there oct 2019 to start a new adventure after raising kids. Sold everything and drove across Canada 🇨🇦 4 months later covid hit . I refused vaccine which trapped me. At least that's how I feel 😢
@@tammyraby7630 Well you were trapped. Not by your own actions but by the government's experiment. Rat in a maze.
We could run into the same issues again if the government attempts to restrict people's rights to travel between their 15 minute ghettos
My rights are God given and no one can take them from me. NOT you, not a court, not a government! GRANTED TO ME BY GOD!
🙄
💯
Then you have no rights because there are no gods.
I really hope this is won. I cannot believe how easily our populous fell in line and asked zero questions after these awful measures. Okay, give freedom to authority in scary times, unwise, but I can understand. However, where is the pressure to look back with critical, humility and demand answers so we don’t repeat this. Over half of Canada completely complicit with corporate greed and government corruption like we’ve never seen.
I didn't get vaccinated and any employer that inquired about your medical vaccination statess did so ILLIGALLY. As for the other mandates they to infringed apon Canadians rights and were mandates, not laws!!!
That scared me. I live in B.C. people wanted to restrict ferry travel and I was dead against it. All Canadians are welcome on Vancouver island imo.
As a Canadian, I can honestly say, "JUST TRY AND STOP ME FROM TRAVELLING ANYWHERE I WANT TO WITHIN THE CANADIAN BORDERS!" Canada is the most free country in the world. Try pushing your own political views onto me and see where that gets you. Our forefathers fought, and some died, so that we could be free. If you disagree, go back to whatever close-minded country you came from. This is OUR country. We will remain free, even if we have to take back the country and run it ourselves. Who needs a corrupt government anyway? We can run a much better democratic government ran by people, not politicians. They seem to only be interested in what the country can do for THEM instead of the other way around. Time for change I guess!
Change needs to come with clearer laws. Less laws and less government. More community. More power at lower government where citizens have more say for their area.
Well they arrested Chris Sky for travelling so good luck with that
@@cathycurrie6305 I agree. That's why I decided that if Pierre P cannot, or does not, make the necessary changes to our political, judicial and education systems, I will form a new party with people like you and I who believe that Canada doesn't need a politicial-ran government, it needs a people/citizen ran government. One ran by the people, for the people, representing only the people and not the individual politician's best interests. We have a political system only because it was handed down to us. That doesn't mean we have to endure a painfully bad and outdated system - we have the ability to change it accordingly, and change is absolutely necessary. The one thing Trudeau has done good was prove just how bad our system is, how easily corrupted it is, and how power can be abused. We must make changes, no, scrap the old one altogether and create a new one. One that fits our modern time. There is no reason why, in this modern day and age, we cannot create a system where all citizens get to cast their vote and let their voices and opinions be heard DIRECTLY through secure polls done on a newly developed political platform, which would be created with the best encryption and safety protocols on the planet. Right now the government does have a safe system, so safe in fact, that once you forget your password you can never get back in... That's another issue altogether... This system would allow us to cut the number of MPs on the citizens' dime to a minimal number of crucial Minister positions to run the country, however they would be acting according to the majority of Canadians' wishes, not whatever the "party" decided. There will be many opposed to "electronic" voting, claiming it can be tampered with, but I say no, if it is properly programmed and monitored, independently checked and verified to be uncrackable, then it is far safer than paper voting, and especially more accurate than electing MPs who only vote according to their leader's wishes, not the people they are representing! If 80% of Canadians want an election now, why are 60% of MPs voting against a motion of non-confidence? Because they are listening to and voting according to the PM, not those that elected them. Why do you think they are being replaced in byelections? Because if you won't represent us, we will replace you But this is slow and antiquated. We should be able to have immediate responses and action, which would happen with the new E-Politics system I would have developed. Hopefully there are enough ticked off Canadians who agree and woud love to join this new party, should it become necessary. Go Pierre, do us good! I don't want to enter politics, but will if I have no other choice. My children's future and their children's future depend on it!
I travelled freely in the west and to the US all during Covid. Never a problem
My friend was not permitted to leave PEI when her father was dying in New Brunswick. What would you suggest she should have done ... swim the Northumberland Strait? THIS WAS REAL
From you’ve said about the Charter should be read an entire document, I hope the Supreme Court should end up deciding for the claimant and ‘slap the hands’ of the provincial government.
Love you girl! Your close people must be proud of you.
You could even have a funeral in Ontario we had a niece who past away too and it was brutal treatment for her mother not to be able to have a funeral until almost a year later just appalling evil and many suffered this way!
We had a family funeral outside in September 2020 in BC
@@lynnewilliams542I’m sure your comment made BW feel much better about not being allowed to attend a loved one’s funeral.
We had a funeral. July 2020 outdoors.
@@roartary Canada did not stop her from going. If she lived in the east, she can blame her conservative government but the rest of us were free to travel . So many incorrect statements in here. The Canadian border was never closed to citizens. Not even for 10 minutes. I hate Trudeau too but can’t blame him for that
Thank you Christine
These are dark days under the soy boy and his minions.
Scambag knot-c 💩²
Of for Christ sake, get a grip. Trudeau had nothing to do with this. This was the government of Newfoundland. Canada had no travel ban
@@lynnewilliams542 Nice to see that estrog:?n keeps the stupidi?y working. Why don't you get a job refilling those little dispensers in men's bathr?oms.
Thank you Christine!! Great video.
Thank you for your involvement in fighting this.
YEAH.. about time!! … YES WE SHOULD NOT be held back to travel to a funeral … especially for family
You go get them don't let them get away with any of that I think you're very correct and i'm glad that we have someone like you Fighting for us. Go bless you
It should be an open and shut case. But the court hedges it in any way, that court needs to be replaced and the constitution needs to be amended to clear all these questions of basic human rights in Canada. 🇨🇦 keep it up.
I watched as my Constitutional Rights of security of person, right of assembly, right to travel, right to religious freedom, right to safety and security of person all considered "moot" by our Federal government. Not a single word from our politicians, police, medical officers, lawyers, judges, attorney generals. They all stood by and watched, complied, and continued to get a paycheck.
How many Canadians lost their jobs ? Their livelihood? Corporations all remained opened. Mom and pop shops were decimated. How many Canadians "coerced" into taking the jab by all levels of government and businesses. Where were the feminists screeching "My body: My choice" ? Their collective silence was defeaning.
How many Canadians were denied access to health care because of "jab status". Father's who couldn't be there to see the birth of their children. Husbands and wives sitting in parking lots as their loved ones were alone, many dying in hospitals. How many of those suffering demetia only got worse as they were held hostage by "the system". Our children in school are still suffering silently. Another hostage taken by "the system"
I watched in shock and awe as 1/3 of Canadians, watched, another 1/3 of Canadians, go full arthoritarian on the remaining 1/3. Pure Cult of Personality and Psychosis in action.
I had no idea how many of my countrymen preferred their chains to freedom. I had no idea how many Canadians sold their freedoms for "travel-vacations", "going to restaurants", etc.
The Trucker Convoy: not a single policitian stood in line against the police on that final day. Not one. Not a judge. Not a lawyer. Not a doctor. Not a teacher. Not a professor. Not a single member of the damned "elites". Not single attempt at negotiation.
A great crime was committed in this country. I will never forget. I will never forgive.
Nuremberg 2.0
God Bless
A lot of it was overkill but we didn’t know at the time. I live in B.C. our government did a great job
It is the time of vengeance and justice
I'll definitely support our canadian freedom under the constitution of Canada. W2G Christine. Thanks.
Keep up the excellent work.
I hope and Pray you win this court case for we the PEOPLE. Thanks for your continued hard work.
Signed by a retired blue collar pensioner!
Mobility simpliciter can be inferred from the absence of the need for any travel documents within Canada and the existence of a Canadian passport, rather than a provincial one. Canada is a country, not an EU and a single nation not a Shengen zone. I agree with your reading of the French version, the use of deplacer vs demenager is relevant and correct. I would also argue that it would be reasonable to require mitigating actions in cases of an epidemic or other emergency but not an outright ban on travel, unless the emergency is something like a forest fire. Even in that case is the restraint of a damn fool reasonable?
in Quebec, a guy and his girlfriend went to see his mom in her last hours in France. when they came back, hell broke totally loose, cost them a fortune, the stupid civil servant didn't find that it was a good enough reason
I doubt that happened. All Canadians have the right to enter Canada at their pleasure. They might make you test and quarantine until negative comes back but that is all. Certainly not any hell breaking loose
@@lynnewilliams542call it as you wish and I will continue to call it hell breaking loose: I saw him in an interview back then. whatever happened to them that was very hard on them when you are grieving, and very cosrly, my point is that the heartless civil servant couldn't care less about his desire to see his dying mother and should have applied a special treatment but didn't
@@lynnewilliams542 and both are unconstitutional
@@lynnewilliams542 You are either clueless, or a bot. You keep making erroneous statements.
@@lynnewilliams542 What kind of a pig would deny someone else's experience? Who do you think you are? Obviously an arrogant self-entitled leftist ignoramus. Go back under your hole.
Thank you for all your hard work, Canadians appreciate it very much!!!
A Castreau appointed judge for sure.
Get on with it!!!!!!
CVG: you have so many supporters. This one offers a huge Thank You.
During 2020 I accepted what was happening... Until....my turning point. Specifically, when I heard that travel between Ontario and Quebec was being limited to VaxPass persons by police at checkpoints. I said to myself, "ya sure... they can't do that". When I found it was true - that was my moment of awakening and I found your work. Thanks !
Agreed. I hated some of the provinces. The conservative ones were the worst.
Thought Canada allows the freedom of travel between provinces. Government overreach was the pandemic.
“Canada allows” is the problem. “Allowing” anyone to do anything isn’t upholding rights, it’s ingraining the idea that it is a privilege and can be revoked at any time for any reason.
There was no federal restrictions on travelling in Canada, some provinces imposed it. Mostly conservative provinces
@@lynnewilliams542 Yes, there were federal restrictions. Air and rail transportation are federally regulated. The federal government imposed mandates on air and rail passengers. Mandates were imposed that ignored one's constitutional charter rights.
@@ricknash3055 true. There were some restrictions, but I found ways around it. But I never had a problem leaving or entering Canada in 2020 and 2021. I agree that the Covid vaccine to fly was over reach. But you could fly out of US city. I do hope the woman wins her court case. The Newfoundland government acted in the wrong
I was born in NL. Therefore, I am a Newfoundlander. I also was born in Canada, therefore I am a Canadian. As a Canadian I am free to travel anywhere in MY country. Seems pretty simple to me!
I would have loved to read your book but ,ordered it (and paid for) from Optimum Publishing, Nov. 3, 2023 and still have not received it. I really enjoy your posts and the information they contain.
Thank you Christine. We need more like you in Canada. ❤
We really appreciate what you guys do and I know you don't get the credit for it I was one of those people that was banned from society and it completely ruined my life and my family's
This case is very important to me. During the pandemic, I had ongoing litigation in Ontario, but was unable to travel there from Nova Scotia. As it turned out, my lawyer has worked so unbelievably slowly, that my case has made little progress 😢. During the pandemic, a friend of mine in Nova Scotia was prevented from being with her disabled son in New Brunswick when he underwent a serious surgery. Fortunately it turned out well, but she suffered a lot of worry and still feels guilty that she could not be there for him. Thank you for your efforts in challenging government over reach.
The east coast governments were awful. They had no right to stop you. No restrictions on travel in BC
thanks for this !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Hear hear. I hardly recognize this country anymore.
keep up the good work. thank you
That's funny because the workers compensation board of British Columbia had no problem sending me to medical appointments in the Lower Mainland and Kelowna... During lockdown... there was sometimes on Highway 97 where I was the only one driving for 100 km.. yeah just me and the RC...
B.C. wasn’t locked down. We travelled freely. I don’t know where people got the crazy idea we were restricted
Reasonable limit equals because the government said so. I want that gone or actually defined clearly in the charter
This case highlights why I have lost all respect for our judges. Every time we needed them to stand up for OUR RIGHTS during covid, what did we see? They deferred to the gov'ts wish. Absolutely disgusting, either we have democratic Rights and Freedoms as per our constitution or we don't.
To me this case is a no brainer. The woman wins. Government was wrong
Thank you for all the work you and your team, if you have one!
Thanks. Keep up the good work !!
Thanks for the update on this issue. This is what Dmocracy is all about where the Laws of any nation Governs and takes precedence within our Constitution guidelines. Keep up the good work for Cabada.
I was stranded in the Phillippines for 2 years during covid because the govt wanted me to quarantine in hotel at the cost of $300 to $400 a day for 14 days which I didn't want to pay this since my brother lived 1 kilometer from the Vancouver airport, where I could quarintine for free. It cost me at least $1500 a month to stay. in the Philippines. This is when I learned to hate my govt, I don't want to hate my country. What is so stupid about this is they were telling people traveling to return to Canada. Also both me and my brother had all our covid shots plus the booster shots.
You didn't have to go you can just say no,a lot of people did.
So why didn’t you fly into Seattle and take a bus to the border. That is what I did. The hotel quarantine was only for 3 days max and it wasn’t 2 years. You were not stuck anywhere. You can always come back to canada
Yet they put up the people that crossed at Roxham Road in hotels in PQ, NB and NS. HOTELS ... for free.
@@andrearobbins6081 yep. Not one single ticket issued in Calgary. Love it. I just flew into Seattle and walked across the border
Thx for the great job you are doing
If "move to" was indicating the ability to take up residence then the "take up residence" text would not be required. By saying both means that "move" means to travel freely.
Solid Channel
Thanks for all you do. I bought and read the book.
You must win this case.
In July 2021 I wanted to visit my 2 grandchildren in Ottawa. I could not fly without vax proof, so decided to drive, Van - Ottawa, but Manitoba had closed it's borders and driving into the US would not be an option. Very reluctantly I did get the 2 jabs, bought a ticket to fly but when I boarded, no one asked to see any vax proof either in Van or Ottawa. It was clear to me that this was control and had nothing to do with health
You could have driven in the US. They didn’t require vaccination until February 2022. I agree that it sucked requiring you to be vaccinated. I am vaccinated. My choice. I believe that makes me safe from you. That was over reach.
Why couldn't you drive to the USA
I'm so glad that these decisions are being heard in Supreme Court
very interesting nuance in language between English and French in Section 6 sub 2! Thank you.
Thank you for everything you’re doing for Canadians. To bad a mass majority of Canadians seem to not care what was done to them or their rights.
When i traveled to PEI during that time, i was AGAST that i needed a 'travel passport' to enter the province. I had to apply online and reveived it from the Provincial government.
I then needed a nose swab before being let past the checkpoint. To add insult to injury, we were free to go after the test, without knowing the results, they said they would call me if I was positive to ask me to self quarantine.
I asked the medic, ok, lets just say i am positive and i go right from here to a busy public place and interact with people.... you've essentially allowed me to leave a testimg area and possibly infect an unknown number of people before you phone me.
Just absolutely clown world.
Good luck you was not quarantined, but yes you make a point the mandates was made by evil people with evil methods and big business also guilty because they welcome all this madness which is against all humans' rights!!! Same as WW2, against humans will by cheating and lies through MSM!!!
The eastern provinces were a joke during Covid.
My husband was basically a couple hours from death in the hospital and they specifically told us( my mother my son and myself )that only 2 of us could sit by my husband while he died in front of us.
Get em girl
Biowarfare, bioterrorism, biocrime.
The "breach of rights" goes far beyond restriction of movement
Let's go!
The Charter is bonkers and so are these judges, we need a redo IMHO and no more vague language!!!
Good. Glad to see this.
The French version wins the case!!
Always appreciate this service you provide for Canadians. Always worth my time to listen to you. Thank you very much.
We need less Govt. power and more citizen rights, we people are the driving force in the country, most politicians are the problem to prosperity.
Thanks Christine much love from Powell River.
My question is, where were all the lawyers while this lockdown was in progress? Why didn't they sue? Why sue now, when things have already come and gone?
There were cases. The court system is very very slow. Some might say selectively so. Lots of bad actors filed poorly written cases too, that were inevitably tossed.
I think the Constitution should be opened and amended to include health/body rights, property rights and travel rights.
I guess the supreme court will rule if the charter rights are rights or just privileges. We are only as free as we think we are. Think of it as we are in a cage which is really a vice. As our rights are whittled away or new laws enacted is another turn of the vice. Years down the road as the cage or vice gets smaller you are crushed. Thankyou for keeping up the good fight.
Christine is quite pleasing on the eyes😊
is the right to free travel not posted on passports
Yep and I had that right and used it. Same as coming home during hotel quarantine. Flew into Seattle , bus to border and walked into canada
Jail our unconstitutional jailers
did we not build the Trans Canadian Highway to "facilitate" the freedom of travels across the country, why wouldnt this idea apply to other methods of movement??
It wasn’t the feds restricting travel.
really?? well i guess TruDolt saying u wont be able to travel without a vaxx wasnt the feds, ok!!
French Canadian here with a little background in Law ( two years and 61 credits done in Montreal university) I can say easily that ´´se déplacer et déménager ´ are not the same at all as Christine said it with her nice English accent 😊. Deplorable or déplorable have the same meaning in both languages and what have done the province of Terre-Neuve is disgusting as the others provinces too.
Ok we have the law but if we cannot count on judges anymore I predict to you that there will be blood!
Thank you for fighting on behalf of Canadians!