Will Purple Haze Feedback Be Animated?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 сер 2019
  • Going over the facts for and against a PHF anime.
    Patreon: / hamonbeat
    Join The Discord: / discord
    Twitter: / hamonbeat
    Picture from: / 1159586337424433152
    Songs Used:
    Intro: Crazy My Beat
    Spiritoso
    Serenamente
    Puro
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 970

  • @TheeNero
    @TheeNero 4 роки тому +4602

    The complete Purple Haze Feedback story, and a proper epilogue to part 5
    DP: i sleep
    Rohan goes to the fridge to get a glass of apple juice
    DP: r e a l s h i t ?

    • @joshshrum2764
      @joshshrum2764 4 роки тому +139

      David pro will be my epitaph.

    • @francescolombardi3438
      @francescolombardi3438 4 роки тому +125

      Rohan: (exists)
      DP: It's free OVEstate

    • @mattyp3183
      @mattyp3183 4 роки тому +86

      Imagine they skip PHF and go straight to the Jorge Joestar and over heaven

    • @TheeNero
      @TheeNero 4 роки тому +55

      @@mattyp3183
      I would commit not alive

    • @droplemmy
      @droplemmy 4 роки тому +23

      Purple haze feedback isn’t canon get over it

  • @pajamapantsjack5874
    @pajamapantsjack5874 4 роки тому +3917

    It would be a challenge for DP, especially them having no actual manga panels to adapt. Either way it would be an incredible thing to see animated.

    • @KaveMan_
      @KaveMan_ 4 роки тому +129

      shut up boomer its gonna happen i swear :((

    • @jeremiah4627
      @jeremiah4627 4 роки тому +140

      Kaveman stop with the false hope

    • @romusa10
      @romusa10 4 роки тому +97

      Dont do that,dont give me hope

    • @maximuffin6395
      @maximuffin6395 4 роки тому +33

      Haven't LNs been animated before?

    • @romusa10
      @romusa10 4 роки тому +25

      @@maximuffin6395 yeah,overlord for an example

  • @Magnet_Chaos
    @Magnet_Chaos 4 роки тому +1633

    Is it going to happen? No. No. No. No.
    Do I want it to happen? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

    • @PsychicCatTCG
      @PsychicCatTCG 4 роки тому +33

      It honestly should. Fugo was sadly shafted and i feel like animating this will kind of make up for them missing out on fugo's character

    • @simple834
      @simple834 3 роки тому

      I wanted to like this comment but I see the like number is 888 so I didnt

    • @swargpatel7634
      @swargpatel7634 3 роки тому +4

      The people at David Production said they would do it if Araki let them. And why wouldn’t he.

    • @TheDigitalApple
      @TheDigitalApple 3 роки тому +3

      I really want PHF to be animated along with the manga being stated as officially canon mostly so Fugo can have a proper ending than just not going with his friends in the manga or sensing something was wrong after Narancia died in the anime.

    • @angryboi595
      @angryboi595 2 роки тому +1

      It has a 20% chance of happening

  • @reminicex
    @reminicex 4 роки тому +1998

    Remember when people said part 5 never? PHF never, no joke.

    • @dogdoggson6844
      @dogdoggson6844 4 роки тому +112

      Part 6 never

    • @jayjay86443
      @jayjay86443 4 роки тому +204

      @@dogdoggson6844
      Part 8 never.
      Not unless half of us die from old age and our great grandchildren watch JoJo for us.

    • @brandonyanosky2953
      @brandonyanosky2953 4 роки тому +13

      reminice why is your profile picture dio crying

    • @dogdoggson6844
      @dogdoggson6844 4 роки тому +2

      Bruh

    • @lob674
      @lob674 4 роки тому +1

      your pfp is very fitting lol

  • @shuumatsunojoshua
    @shuumatsunojoshua 4 роки тому +1551

    I would cry tears of joy if my boy Vladimir got animated

    • @soarel325
      @soarel325 4 роки тому +79

      Him and Volpe...

    • @jackofaces107
      @jackofaces107 4 роки тому +28

      Soarel I just remembered volpes death that will be brutal

    • @Subscribersnodignity
      @Subscribersnodignity 4 роки тому +3

      joshy the scrub what’s all this about

    • @daxxonah13
      @daxxonah13 4 роки тому +8

      may your Rainy Days Dream Away lol

    • @godabove8901
      @godabove8901 4 роки тому +4

      I just really wanna see Zucchero again and the convo between the Volpe’s, as well as Angelica and Sheila E in general

  • @yoshikagekira659
    @yoshikagekira659 4 роки тому +1081

    Everyone talking about PHF makes me wanna get a Dead Mans Questions OVA

    • @noname8354
      @noname8354 4 роки тому +15

      Yoshikage Kira tbh I didn't really like DMQ.

    • @pyrojack8230
      @pyrojack8230 4 роки тому +110

      @@noname8354 Say sike rn

    • @abuhashbrown4347
      @abuhashbrown4347 4 роки тому +71

      Yoshikage Kira yeah that would work so much better as an ova cause it’s a one off chapter with pictures rather than purple haze in its light novel format

    • @joshshrum2764
      @joshshrum2764 4 роки тому +11

      We really need that because I love Rohan, but hand kink boy is the best~.

    • @GrizonII
      @GrizonII 4 роки тому +18

      Grayson Torrez It’s not a part of Thus Spoke Kishibe Rohan, they’re completely separate. However, it was featured alongside the first one-shot of TSKR in the compilation Under Execution Under Jailbreak, which was released before TSKR was even a series.

  • @nothisispatrick4644
    @nothisispatrick4644 4 роки тому +1467

    Anyone picking a fight with Fugo
    *"So you have chosen death"*

    • @thesaltwizard3212
      @thesaltwizard3212 4 роки тому +47

      Pretty much how op purple haze is

    • @enoumpeluck9935
      @enoumpeluck9935 4 роки тому +10

      No this is patrick there are dozens of stand users who could defeat him

    • @arthurdavaze1575
      @arthurdavaze1575 4 роки тому +53

      @@enoumpeluck9935 like the emerald splash

    • @finjaquetemumnomeaqui4838
      @finjaquetemumnomeaqui4838 4 роки тому +1

      @@enoumpeluck9935 Could you name a few?

    • @nothisispatrick4644
      @nothisispatrick4644 4 роки тому +29

      Notorius BIG
      Man in the Mirror
      Metallica
      King Crimson
      White album
      Grateful dead
      Rainy Day Dream Away- kinda?
      Soft Machine
      Dolly Dagger- kinda?
      Beach Boy
      Manic Depression
      Little feet- Maybe?
      Oasis
      Green Day
      Clash
      Sex Pistols
      Aerosmith
      Gold experience and its Requiem form
      Silver chariot and its requiem form
      And thats only in part 5 there are more stands who can defeat purple haze in previous and future parts as long as the stand could keep a safe distance or deal a fatal blow first at PH that stand would undoubtedly win

  • @IamJakeToo
    @IamJakeToo 4 роки тому +1107

    Having Fugo be an enemy that the boss sends after Giorno and them would’ve been so cool but definitely emotional. I can imagine Mista or someone having to kill Fugo in a battle.

    • @doublekey8931
      @doublekey8931 4 роки тому +142

      I think Giorno was meant to give the final blow... damn that would've been sad

    • @swiftswalow
      @swiftswalow 4 роки тому +219

      seeing how most likely he was replaced in the story for Chioccolata (you can see the similarities of his stand so probably Araki just toyed with some of the context and details of the "Mold" for the fight he had planned basing it on his ideas for the final battle against Fugo's virus) it's possible the seven page muda was directed towards him.

    • @doublekey8931
      @doublekey8931 4 роки тому +138

      @@swiftswalow Yeah I know, it would've been one of the saddest moments of Golden Wind instead of being the most badass one

    • @thesaltwizard3212
      @thesaltwizard3212 4 роки тому +90

      Especially if Fugo were the one to kill Abacchio that would break Narancia down and would be forced to kill Fugo while both of them holding back against eachother and crying

    • @GalekC
      @GalekC 4 роки тому +89

      @@thesaltwizard3212 He was meant to be the one to kill Narancia. It really ties together what Araki was originally going for

  • @janelletaboada6673
    @janelletaboada6673 4 роки тому +1723

    The number one reason I want PHF to be animated, plus the fact that it's Fugo's redemption arc, is that there would be more scenes of Boss Giorno.
    I mean, who wouldn't want to see Don Giovanna in his full glory.

    • @doggu7398
      @doggu7398 4 роки тому +149

      Also more scenes of the gang together, specially the end

    • @12171010011010
      @12171010011010 4 роки тому +162

      The ending scene with a Dio-esque Giorno reading Fugo like a book would be cool. I always imagined Dio recruiting his henchmen in the same way.

    • @ja1295
      @ja1295 4 роки тому +19

      POPE GIORNO

    • @daxxonah13
      @daxxonah13 4 роки тому +11

      not to mention Sheila E, WHO HAS A CRUSH ON THE MAN.....they're both 15

    • @umcaraqualquer3640
      @umcaraqualquer3640 4 роки тому +49

      @@12171010011010 I love how Giorno is portrayed in PHF. He's full DIO there, from start to end.
      That starting scene, with Mista being sent by him to kill Fugo sent chills down my spine.

  • @scooottbruh7849
    @scooottbruh7849 4 роки тому +674

    I want it animated because of the fights, I want to see Fugo using his 152 IQ in the fighrs

    • @mybodyisreggie2759
      @mybodyisreggie2759 4 роки тому +146

      *fucking yeets himself in air and falls and punches Vladimir*

    • @user-nx1du6zk9y
      @user-nx1du6zk9y 4 роки тому +83

      *bites his own virus capsule then spits on Volpe's face*

    • @aster_8284
      @aster_8284 4 роки тому

      How did you read it I can’t find it

    • @Did1k4
      @Did1k4 4 роки тому +1

      @@aster_8284
      Well, I read through this site:
      mangalivre.net/ler/hajishirazu-no-purple-haze-jojo-no-kimyou-na-bouken-yori-novel/online/161953/capitulo-1#/!page4
      But, the problem is that it is PT BR, I understand that language, so it was no problem. But I'm sorry I can't help.

    • @kadentam2946
      @kadentam2946 3 роки тому

      @@aster_8284 just search up a pdf and download it

  • @otakamerd1220
    @otakamerd1220 4 роки тому +978

    The real question should be will the absolute literary masterpiece: Jorge Joestar be animated

    • @moncay3238
      @moncay3238 4 роки тому +9

      Lol

    • @Th3Treasoner
      @Th3Treasoner 4 роки тому +164

      T H I R T Y S I X K A R S O N M A R S

    • @thatguy6577
      @thatguy6577 4 роки тому +53

      Allen Weaver Jorge joestar was mistake

    • @lekibolo8309
      @lekibolo8309 4 роки тому +34

      I thought Jorge Joestar wasn't Canon

    • @thatguy6577
      @thatguy6577 4 роки тому +9

      Leki Bolo shhhh

  • @alexplayer77
    @alexplayer77 4 роки тому +447

    I know it's not going to happen but a man can *dream*

    • @micheledibella
      @micheledibella 4 роки тому +20

      Alex Player said by SPEEDWAGON is surely true

    • @doublekey8931
      @doublekey8931 4 роки тому +33

      "Kono Giorno Giovanna ni wa yume ga aru"

    • @cestalia
      @cestalia 4 роки тому +7

      @@doublekey8931 damn, you beat me to make that comment

    • @taffmeister584
      @taffmeister584 4 роки тому +6

      As from an Aerosmith song, Dream on

    • @untiecries9174
      @untiecries9174 2 роки тому

      @@taffmeister584 do you mean Lil bOmbER

  • @fanofsimonpegg
    @fanofsimonpegg 4 роки тому +117

    I just want official colors for PHF's characters, man.
    Sheila E needs more love.

  • @Existgoth
    @Existgoth 4 роки тому +154

    "napples"

  • @chadkensington7953
    @chadkensington7953 4 роки тому +254

    It would be so cool if it was a movie

    • @doublejp9093
      @doublejp9093 4 роки тому +49

      That's what I was thinking trying to adapt a novel into a ova wouldn't work for tv time especially for a novel like phf and it would be the first movie for David production involving jojo so it would be nice and a great way to make some money from jojo and all around a fun golden experience for jojo fans

    • @Twitchems
      @Twitchems 4 роки тому +28

      I like this idea.
      The novel would turn out much better with the long run time. Plus you don't have to risk the whole noncanon thing since movies can be noncanon.

    • @iiirdvii840
      @iiirdvii840 4 роки тому +4

      YES YES YES YES

  • @Dragwhite
    @Dragwhite 4 роки тому +158

    **ROHAN FINDS THE REMOTE FOR HIS TELEVISION SO HE CAN CHANGE THE CHANNEL**
    An all new JoJo OVA.

  • @Laxhoop
    @Laxhoop 4 роки тому +212

    Everyone always says “Canolo not being the one to actually get them the photo means his involvement in the story can’t happen”. Dude, it’s as simple as this:
    Rather than actually getting La Squadra the photo, he simply tells them that it exists, and points them in the direction to go. The anime never specified HOW La Squadra learned about the photo, or about Trish’s existence. Canolo can be behind both of these things, and unlike in the book, where he took an active role in sabotaging the boss for the fun of it, now, he gets the exact same outcome, without even having to lift a finger. That’s less work, to get the same outcome, which fits with Canolo’s characterization perfectly.

    • @Hamon_Beat
      @Hamon_Beat  4 роки тому +75

      The anime added the scene of Risotto finding the burned photo next to Pericolo's corpse in Naples Train Station.

    • @jeremiah4627
      @jeremiah4627 4 роки тому +44

      Spencer Whiteway I can feel the desperation in this comment.

    • @SunderlandAlexis
      @SunderlandAlexis 4 роки тому +42

      @@Hamon_Beat Canolo also assisted Sorbet and Gelato with their investigation of the Boss, so even if they can't manage to keep the photo plotline, they can still fall back on that because nothing in the anime contradicts it.
      Fugo's anime backstory is the bigger problem.

    • @swiftswalow
      @swiftswalow 4 роки тому +29

      @@SunderlandAlexis Actually the backstory could be added changing it a bit: give him the backstory with the grandmother but set it BEFORE the events of the flashback and change it a bit: make him have the grandmother, instead of a teacher make it be another kid that mocks Fugo, Fugo responds violently, but the teachers split it off before things escalate... later the shit with the professor happens and Fugo gets sent to trial.... yes it's a big change, but it sets up Fugo's character in the same way: he loves her grandma, and he has a violent outburst over her death not being treated with respect. It doesn't need to be a replica of the original, it just needs to have an impact and serve the same purpose.
      also, PHF is rather long, so i would be fine if DP shortened it by erasing the scenes that contradict the anime and just move forward with the main plot.

    • @Laxhoop
      @Laxhoop 4 роки тому +9

      Hamon Beat
      Yeah, and how did he know to go there?

  • @lob674
    @lob674 4 роки тому +214

    Phf will most likely never get animated, but i love it to much to give up hope

  • @cestalia
    @cestalia 4 роки тому +73

    I WANT TO SEE MUROLO IN ACTION BRUH.
    His stand is really cool and he is informant of Passione too.

  • @kokochydaios
    @kokochydaios 4 роки тому +50

    Stone Ocean: Oh hey, How've you been doin.
    Purple Haze: Ah, Imm doing fine. I can't wait to get my anime.
    Stone Ocean: Oh that's impossible.
    Purple Haze: ....

  • @svolozhanin7627
    @svolozhanin7627 4 роки тому +333

    Probably no. As much as DP is faithful to JoJo, they will have to animate scenes from the lines of a book and not panels from the manga, which will probably not look like what many PHF fans want to see.

    • @PapaBearIsHere
      @PapaBearIsHere 4 роки тому +75

      well if theyre smart and use the current part 5 style, it can work, they have shown to animate scenes not just from the panels or atleast a different angel

    • @christopheribarra1170
      @christopheribarra1170 4 роки тому +60

      There are many anime based off light novels. And who cares what the fans "want." Those who read the novel. It's about what people who watch anime and but the product would like. Like me who has a subscription to watch anime.
      The way I see it. There is neither a reason nor a reason not to animate it. There is just a lack of incentive.

    • @12171010011010
      @12171010011010 4 роки тому +19

      The changes made in the anime could be written around without sacrificing any of PHFs main story. Outside of the parts mentioned in the video, there aren't any other contradictions.

    • @hithere7080
      @hithere7080 4 роки тому +3

      Anyone mad about a character looking different from the headcanob they created are babies

  • @kingkrool_gx_6030
    @kingkrool_gx_6030 4 роки тому +286

    What If You Wanted Purple Haze Feed Back But God Said
    *HEAVEN'S DOOR*

    • @1000tlt
      @1000tlt 4 роки тому +2

      Underrated comment

    • @dammyitch1569
      @dammyitch1569 4 роки тому +1

      I laughed so hard at this

    • @KMGC9
      @KMGC9 4 роки тому +6

      But God said
      *ZA HANDO GA KESU*

    • @randoviewer9363
      @randoviewer9363 3 роки тому +1

      *HEAVEN'S DUAA

  • @bleyshock5630
    @bleyshock5630 4 роки тому +396

    Nah.
    How about “Rohan goes to the Louvre” instead?

  • @BS-se4yg
    @BS-se4yg 4 роки тому +89

    It makes me really sad that Fugo wasn't exploded more as a character. Specially having so much potential to grow and improve. And I loved that the novel focused a lot on Fugo realising why he didn't get on the boat, what really happened to him and actually learning why he stand is the way it's and almost accepting his most primal side. And not gonna lie, makes me sad that it will probably never happen because it's not technically cannon. Because overall the novel is great. It gives you more information about how Passione worked and why they were so successful, it shows you the state of Italy after Giorno became Capo and even expands the story of other lovable side characters from other arcs. Like Massimo Volpe being Tonio's brother. And it has some of the most interesting characters in any season of JoJo. Angelica, VIttorio, Massimo, Vladimir, hell even Cannolo. And I love Rohan as much as the next guy but I do believe some of his stories are a bit..... Shallow. But hey, animating a good story that has character growth, an actual story, lovable and interesting characters and that also expands on the existing world while also giving more context to other lovable characters? Nahhh, let's animate Rohan investigating his grandma's bag for 16 pages. CONTENT.

    • @seemoore9175
      @seemoore9175 4 роки тому +18

      the way you misspell explored as exploded is hilarious.

    • @dna9095
      @dna9095 4 роки тому +12

      you know i'd rather NOT explode fugo XD

    • @raandomplayer8589
      @raandomplayer8589 3 роки тому +4

      Yeah he needs to blow more

    • @flaviomonteiro1414
      @flaviomonteiro1414 3 роки тому +1

      Exploded? Maybe Fugo meet Kira somehow

    • @ghostraptor1741
      @ghostraptor1741 2 роки тому +1

      KILLER QUEEN!!!!!!!

  • @weatherreportthestand6221
    @weatherreportthestand6221 4 роки тому +41

    there is one detail that i have noticed while rewatching golden wind that may or may not be another clue or a reference at phf.
    around the black sabbath arc (i don't remember if it is before or after) bruno explains to Giorno how passione works, and a hierarchy table is shown where the gang is split up into a bunch of groups with rather generic silouhette. if you pay close attention to this screen, you will be able to see the silouhette of la squadra, and be able to identify all of them. the thing is, one of the higher groups on that screen has 4 members with different silouhette, at first i tought it was the elite guards, but by looking closely the silouhette doesn't match and one the guards is missing. i havo not taken the time to actually translate what the name of the group is, but since they were so high up in passione i think it might be the drug quartel. i'm gonna try to go translate it and edit this comment for the results. (also sorry for the grammar).
    edit: so i've translated most of what's on that hierarchy table, and sadly, what i tought was the drug quartel is actually ''Bodyguard shere'', i also noticed that one the the silouhette was hidden by the text. those silouhette don't really looks like the guards tho.
    i also looked at the other groups, and the one that is named ''drugs section'' has 6 members with generic silouhette to my disapointment...

  • @Dogelele
    @Dogelele 4 роки тому +90

    gotta watch new hamon beat videos at 2 times speed to finish it before anyone else :^)

  • @duckIife
    @duckIife 4 роки тому +33

    I absolutely love PHF but it’s definitely not getting adapted. I think I kinda prefer that though, a lot of the charm of it comes from the author’s writing style that wouldn’t translate well to animation. The fan-made screenshots and storyboard animations are enough to hold me over but I still highkey wanna see the canon color palettes for Sheila, Murolo, and the narcotics squad lmao. More than anything else I’d just want an officially published English translation

  • @aerodynamo4874
    @aerodynamo4874 4 роки тому +107

    hear me out:
    if it gets made, the OVA should have strawberry Fugo and blue Giorno

    • @lob674
      @lob674 4 роки тому +14

      Yes Yes Yes
      Yes Yes YES

    • @TheWeedIsland
      @TheWeedIsland 4 роки тому +12

      Only if he's still blonde

    • @user-nx1du6zk9y
      @user-nx1du6zk9y 4 роки тому +25

      🅱️LACK GIORNO WITH DIO THEME
      🅱️EST GIORNO

  • @eViLPaCcc
    @eViLPaCcc 4 роки тому +93

    The real question is:
    Are they going to animate Jorge Joestar?

    • @diobrando7774
      @diobrando7774 4 роки тому +5

      Jorge

    • @ElDuquedelaNuezNimura
      @ElDuquedelaNuezNimura 4 роки тому +6

      The novel is very bizarre..... VERY VERY BIZARRE

    • @comicstrider4851
      @comicstrider4851 4 роки тому +5

      Hell No!

    • @diegolaradiaz8948
      @diegolaradiaz8948 4 роки тому +7

      The only reason I would it want it animated is to see the STUPID brokeness that is Kars in that novel,oh and the whole 36 kars on mars

    • @user-zl7os7wr7c
      @user-zl7os7wr7c 4 роки тому +1

      Absolutely No
      Jorge joestar isn't jojo

  • @TheAlison1456
    @TheAlison1456 4 роки тому +141

    3:55 I also find it annoying. Don't Bite Za Hando that feeds you.

  • @soap8049
    @soap8049 4 роки тому +22

    "Imagine how Buccarati would feel" ouch that one hurt. I think Buccarati would have to Kill Fugo if it was that way. But Im glad that did not happen.

  • @altEFG
    @altEFG 4 роки тому +37

    DP clearly loves Vento Aureo, and PHF not being canon is an opportunity for them to change it further to be in sync with their own alterations to Vento Aureo.

  • @brub3395
    @brub3395 4 роки тому +13

    Fugo's body shape in Purple Haze Feed is basically Soft and Wet disguised as Fugo

  • @whistlepunkz
    @whistlepunkz 4 роки тому +12

    I want it animated for those last pages especially. The whole novel was incredible and I love the fights but god,,, that was some poetry at the end.

  • @FF-hv9pn
    @FF-hv9pn 4 роки тому +18

    Hamon beat: it's legal I guess
    UA-cam: COPYRIGHT STRIKE

  • @jeremiah4627
    @jeremiah4627 4 роки тому +40

    I appreciate this video man, when people keep begging for PHf I will recommend them to watch this video

    • @Magnet_Chaos
      @Magnet_Chaos 4 роки тому +9

      I still want it though.

    • @takodacorliss5838
      @takodacorliss5838 4 роки тому +1

      Jeremiah Only reason I think Golden Heart, Golden Ring And Purple Haze Feedback has a possibility is because of Part 6’s Bohemian Rhapsody and probably wanting some deals to get the Arc right.

  • @da_pikmin_coder8367
    @da_pikmin_coder8367 4 роки тому +7

    0:28 This is why I love series like JoJo or One Piece: The fact that these characters the author's created are such brain-childs of their creators that the author actually has mental and physical responses to the scenes they create. It's why I hate directors obsessed with "subverting expectations" because they can just kill off anyone or make it turn out someone was secretly evil without a second thought. At fist Araki might seem like this since half the cast dies by the end of most parts, but he does it with a lot more craft and care than most people. It's not merely a "death" but a "sendoff".

  • @sumadreii839
    @sumadreii839 4 роки тому +10

    Dead mans questions is the real question here...

  • @kwableguy9795
    @kwableguy9795 4 роки тому +175

    broke: adapting PHF
    WOKE: adapting jorge joestar

    • @johnny_my_penls_is_small_but
      @johnny_my_penls_is_small_but 4 роки тому +61

      Over here at the jojo fandom we do not speak of ťhĕ føřbīđďêń őñë.

    • @JoelGarcia-lu3tw
      @JoelGarcia-lu3tw 4 роки тому +10

      Jorge Joestar is so Terrible though. It's literally a fan fiction.
      I want 4th Another Day, GHGR and PHF 🤷

    • @joshshrum2764
      @joshshrum2764 4 роки тому +11

      Please I need to 13 kars, on Mars. but after part 7 is done, because of funny valentine, nobody would know who he is yet. Unless they read steel ball run.

    • @vovabars1234
      @vovabars1234 4 роки тому +7

      @@JoelGarcia-lu3tw purple haze feedback is also fanfiction

    • @iiirdvii840
      @iiirdvii840 4 роки тому

      we should get a rewrite thou in order to get rid of bad writting

  • @ZekeFreek
    @ZekeFreek 4 роки тому +14

    I listened to the fan Audiobook a few weeks ago and I have to say, while I do like the novel a lot, I think it might be a bit underwhelming to people who have been hearing about it for so long.
    In my opinion, the framework for a great story is definitely present but it suffers a lot from being a single novel, there is a lot of buildup and imo a pretty rushed payoff.
    The ending while extremely cathartic, is incredibly anticlimactic for all the buildup it gets. The new characters, while interesting, exist purely to facilitate Fugo's redemption and really don't get to do much.
    Personally I think it would make a better film than an OVA series unless DP really wanted to expand upon the material. I do want an adaptation to happen, but I'm not going to cry a river if it doesn't because honestly the book isn't *that* amazing, it's just pretty good.

    • @smackdownbeef9490
      @smackdownbeef9490 4 роки тому +4

      Thank you. People are honestly out here crying because this isn't getting animated and acting as if DP has betrayed all their expectations when it's just a fun little spin-off. There's definitely some good stuff in PHF (Canolo is pretty based) It's definitely more liked for it's concepts than it's actual content.

    • @nineteenseventyfive6709
      @nineteenseventyfive6709 Рік тому

      @@smackdownbeef9490 I totally agree. Also, it might just be me but I don’t really like how some of them are characterised, mostly Giorno. Some other things that I also thought were a little hamfisted, like Volpe being Tonio’s brother. Overall it’s a fun read but not the definitive conclusion to part 5 like a lot of people make it out to be imo

  • @smackdownbeef9490
    @smackdownbeef9490 4 роки тому +80

    This is the slowest I've ever seen a fanbase go through the 5 stages of grief. PHF fans just can't get past bargaining.

    • @janelletaboada6673
      @janelletaboada6673 4 роки тому +15

      VA just recently ended though. Give it time lol.

    • @noname8354
      @noname8354 4 роки тому +17

      We...we can still have hope...right? *cries in never gonna happen*

    • @c-tibayjohnmichael1775
      @c-tibayjohnmichael1775 4 роки тому

      @@noname8354 shhhhhh

    • @cosmosofinfinity
      @cosmosofinfinity 4 роки тому +1

      Let the desire be known, and it will eventually get made. That's how part 4 and 5 happened. Never say never, or you'll just look dumb in the end. Also, Duke Nukem Forever and Final Fantasy XV and Devil May Cry 5 and Kingdom Hearts 3 eventually did come out, so all these arguments are immediately invalid.

    • @smackdownbeef9490
      @smackdownbeef9490 4 роки тому +2

      @@cosmosofinfinity Fuck no, ALWAYS say never. Because if the thing you want never happens, then you will never be disappointing, and if it does, then you can still be hyped about it. Pessimism is a win/win way of life.

  • @th0rrrrr
    @th0rrrrr 4 роки тому +131

    answer: no it won't happen
    thats why im illustrating riverdude's audiobook

  • @adamhercik581
    @adamhercik581 4 роки тому +1

    Great video, I knew nothing about PHF, very informative.

  • @pinkpiplup7230
    @pinkpiplup7230 4 роки тому +4

    Actually, Golden Heart Golden Ring has been fan translated! Here's the PDF if anyone's interested: drive.google.com/open?id=1d6-si33RRmQuYQGz9gy-kBIzRHI6UEKf

  • @soupchewer9213
    @soupchewer9213 4 роки тому +44

    Animating it would get dp lotsa spag- i mean money

  • @ifyoureadthisv1
    @ifyoureadthisv1 4 роки тому +13

    Y’all want PHF but we need to be concerned about Bohemian Rhapsody and how the hell DP is going to deal with that

    • @Hamon_Beat
      @Hamon_Beat  4 роки тому +23

      Why would it be an issue? Almost all of the characters in it were public domain or other shonen jump characters.

    • @phillemon7664
      @phillemon7664 4 роки тому +5

      @@Hamon_Beat Spiderman

    • @ifyoureadthisv1
      @ifyoureadthisv1 4 роки тому

      King Cah and Superman

    • @Hamon_Beat
      @Hamon_Beat  4 роки тому +7

      @@phillemon7664 Yeah he's one of the two. Only him and Mickey could be an issue.

    • @TheSaharay1
      @TheSaharay1 4 роки тому +1

      @@Hamon_Beat not really Mickey either, since he isn't really shown

  • @kuruma2023
    @kuruma2023 2 роки тому +1

    I noticed these when part5 was on, thanks for the review. Really hope they used that novel's setting, It's literally the best jojo novel in my opinion.

  • @part6never655
    @part6never655 4 роки тому

    Love the crazy my beat my man! Very underrated

  • @pyrojack8230
    @pyrojack8230 4 роки тому +55

    Jojo is a major series worldwide, and I feel like an adaptation of PHF would just freaking PRINT money for DP.

  • @eldragon9815
    @eldragon9815 4 роки тому +4

    Keep the good work man, what about a "clearing famous JoJo missconception" video?.

  • @Casllisto
    @Casllisto 4 роки тому

    A small correction: Golden Heart, Golden Ring does now have a fan translation and from what I’ve read it’s pretty damn good. BTW another fantastic video, keep up the great work!

  • @Aziruf
    @Aziruf 3 роки тому +5

    I wish

  • @titaniumsalmon3238
    @titaniumsalmon3238 4 роки тому +29

    People are asking way too much of dp. They just finished part 5 give them a break

    • @noname8354
      @noname8354 4 роки тому +10

      Titanium Salmon yeah I want it done, but over the course of a few years (like 1 OVA next year or something). I want them to take time on Part 6, cuz if they do, it'll be better for the employees and be higher quality.

    • @Brawlfan98
      @Brawlfan98 4 роки тому +17

      Nobody wants it done immediately. They just want a confirmation or a firm "no" Leaving things up in the air leads to people naturally wanting more.

    • @kappamin3133
      @kappamin3133 4 роки тому

      @@Brawlfan98 outright saying no may be bad PR so that probably why tey refuse to say anything

    • @residentgrigo4701
      @residentgrigo4701 4 роки тому +3

      @@noname8354 We are getting 2 Rohan OVAs this year.

    • @tigervalley62
      @tigervalley62 4 роки тому +3

      To be fair... I love them and am a bit of an impatient brat. Jojo anime is everything I wanted as a manga reader. But yes, you are right. They need to rest. I am pretty sure they are more concerned with planning out Part 6 to finish the saga rather than doing OVA adaptations.

  • @LoopZoopler
    @LoopZoopler 4 роки тому +7

    Well now get Rohan and Tonio go fishing for some yummy Oisters Vol. 2 Electric Boogaloo

  • @garron2939
    @garron2939 4 роки тому

    I love your intro

  • @OccuredJakub12
    @OccuredJakub12 2 роки тому +3

    Honestly, I want for them to adapt both Golden Heart:Golden Ring AND Purple Haze Feedback as two separate but connected OVAs. They can do it. They can change stuff around with Fugo's backstory, take a dip in the animation, I don't care. Both of those stories deserve to be adapted.

  • @user-nx1du6zk9y
    @user-nx1du6zk9y 4 роки тому +7

    I really love purple haze feedback.
    I read the novel borrowing from the library
    canolo is the one who spilled the information about the boss to sorbet, so I'm counting on that.
    his grandmother? nah, dp already made their choice.
    however, the biggest problem about the novel is the SHAMELESS.
    in the anime, the gang respected fugo's choice and fugo was worried about the gang's future.
    THIS SCENE IS DESCRIBED COMPLETELY OPPOSITE IN THE NOVEL. this is why i kinda gave up my hope on phf.

    • @yojosuke761
      @yojosuke761 3 роки тому

      What library has fan translations?!

  • @zanrakey4140
    @zanrakey4140 4 роки тому +10

    Coming in before watching the vid.
    I HIGHLY doubt it, but good lawd do I wish it would.

    • @joshshrum2764
      @joshshrum2764 4 роки тому

      I was hopeful, but all my hopes and dreams where all destroyed by the god of hyperdeath, lmao.

  • @TheTestoyer
    @TheTestoyer 4 роки тому

    I have similar thoughts on this as you, but it would be nice if at some point dp did animations of the fan novels since they are liked and give us content with some of our favorite characters. I would completely understand and accept if we don't get any adapted but it'd be nice to see some of the phf group actually moving

  • @azadrahulp
    @azadrahulp 3 роки тому +2

    I just want the Rainy Day Dream Away fight animated.
    Koqaci is still, one of the most developed and sympathetic minor villains in all of JoJo. And the character growth in the fight is fucking awesome.

  • @BustThatNutChallenge
    @BustThatNutChallenge 4 роки тому +6

    I doubt they can do PHF but they can DEFINITELY do Dead Man’s Questions

  • @gee_kaz
    @gee_kaz 4 роки тому +20

    i don’t think it will. like they never even animated other JoJo light novels, besides no manga panel to work on makes thing harder to animate

    • @goat_sama8239
      @goat_sama8239 4 роки тому +4

      I mean it could happen cause PHF is the most popular jojo light novel and is canon in the JoJo games.

    • @maninham1
      @maninham1 4 роки тому +4

      Goat_ Sama Sure, it’s canon in the JoJo games, but the JoJo games are not canon, therefore PHF is not any more likely to get adapted

  • @zombrexgame6670
    @zombrexgame6670 4 роки тому

    Not gonna lie but your intro is pretty sick, very good intro. niceu niceu.

  • @hooeythegreat1987
    @hooeythegreat1987 4 роки тому +2

    As someone who recently read it all, it’s definitely a good read. I hope that one day they might make an adaptation, but I’m not expecting it.

  • @Guyinthehat
    @Guyinthehat 4 роки тому +5

    purple Haze feedback will probably not get an ova but Golden hearts golden wind has a better chance since it's a follow-up originally from Arakis original plan

  • @DealsFS
    @DealsFS 4 роки тому +21

    I'd prefer dead man's questions

  • @maxlol4873
    @maxlol4873 4 роки тому +2

    i would really like to see an purple haze feedback ova but i there are some things that were changed in the anime. i'm not sure if they would change his past or won't bother.

  • @nutsandbolts1264
    @nutsandbolts1264 4 роки тому

    Thus spoke hamon beat

  • @jackofaces107
    @jackofaces107 4 роки тому +11

    I just want it to get animated to see translation names for all the stands

    • @lob674
      @lob674 4 роки тому +1

      voodoo child? No it’s [Creepy Child]

    • @jackofaces107
      @jackofaces107 4 роки тому +2

      best BOI I mean I had some ideas for names here they are
      All along the watchtower- all throughout the watch tower
      Voodoo child- voodoo youngling
      Manic depression - manic anxiety
      Night bird flying- moon bird drifting
      Rainy day dream away- cloudy day wish away
      Dolly dagger- lil slasher(I had to throw in one completely different one)

  • @westide3050
    @westide3050 4 роки тому +3

    I feel like if they are gonna animate those, I bet they'll animate the light novels to give Araki time to write part 8 and 9. Not only this but I bet Baoh will be reanimated as well, because I think that Americans are interested.

  • @kingman450
    @kingman450 4 роки тому +1

    I'm still praying for a Dead Mans Questions adaptation.

  • @somewierdoonline2402
    @somewierdoonline2402 4 роки тому

    Damn, that intro never gets old

  • @TheMegaregister
    @TheMegaregister 4 роки тому +3

    I don't really want a adaptation of PhF, I would rather have the Canon one shots made by Araki animated, as they really contributed to something. But if we are taking about novels, Golden heart golden ring makes me curious about it, even tho i don't know if it is worth the animation

  • @polantcrumbosh3848
    @polantcrumbosh3848 4 роки тому +6

    MANIC DEPRESSION

  • @joshshrum2764
    @joshshrum2764 4 роки тому

    I talked about this on the episode just before the finale on kickass anime. and I was hoping the hour special would be purple haze feedback, but I was wrong of course, and the last two episodes where the hour finale, but it was still amazing. but I'd like to see it animated, but still hamon beat, I'll just buy the fan manga really, since I'm getting the manga, and I'm about to have all of phantom blood so by the time I get to part 4's hardcovers I'm pretty sure part 5 will have all it's hardcovers made by then, since I'm taking a break for the hardcover to catch up, with the anime. also I'm going to love the risotto, and doppio, cover when they get to the Metallica fight. Still I'm hoping for purple haze feedback to be a ova, like the Rohan one shots, so I'm staying determined.

  • @inowshark3977
    @inowshark3977 4 роки тому

    0:22 well he well never be forgotten in my heart when i first saw him he remind me of kakyion which is the reason why i hated it when he gets hurt or something like fugo falling onto trish that time or when he left

  • @octorama
    @octorama 4 роки тому +23

    Short answer: no.

  • @Blastertronus
    @Blastertronus 4 роки тому +3

    I got a feeling that the guy who help Risotto find Trish was a friend or pawn to Cannolo.

    • @12171010011010
      @12171010011010 4 роки тому +3

      If you read PHF he specifically said he had no friends and that he was the only member of the intelligence team. That was the point of his character development.

    • @Blastertronus
      @Blastertronus 4 роки тому +2

      12171010011010 so the guy is most likely a pawn then, and probably from a different faction of Passione anyways.

    • @12171010011010
      @12171010011010 4 роки тому +2

      That's possible but it feels like a stretch. Honestly there are a lot of ways to interpret his position.

  • @mansurislamov9595
    @mansurislamov9595 4 роки тому +2

    I guess that PHF and GHGR can be still animated, if contradictions of novel with anime are changed in favor of anime as an official source.
    Fugo's backstory from the anime could be extended to his granny, which would give his character more depth.
    Fugo might be not the one to recruit Abbachio but to be the one, who could help Abbachio to become accustomed to Passione. There is also a potential to show, why Abbachio is so scared of Purple Haze, as he could be actually the one who saw its effects unlike Narancia and Mista.
    The guy who was forced by Risotto to restore the photo could be killed for trying to contact other Passione members and calling for help or simply for disobedience. As a photo was still not restored completely or deleted by the killed Passione member, Risotto would have to contact Cannolo Murolo.
    Unlike PHF, I don't know much about GHGR, as I haven't read it yet but extra story about battle in Venice and more of Fugo's screentime would be awesome. Both PHF and GHGR have interesting characters and stands I would love to see animated.
    Additionally, I would love to watch prequel series about La Squadra and their missions within Passione. Anime did a lot to make La Squadra team members more than faceless one-time foes like most of Part 3 ones. Their own prequel series could give more depth to hitman team members, as well as give us a look at stands of Sorbet and Gelato, more funny scenes with Formaggio (I absolutely LOVED his battle with Narancia), more dreadful charm from Risotto Nero and, most of all, to show a huge contrast of La Squadra with Bucciarati's team.
    I am not expecting DP to animate anything (besides SBR and DMQ lol) but everyone has a dream. And who knows, maybe one day a dream will come true.

  • @Ragiroth
    @Ragiroth 2 роки тому

    I had no idea this was a thing. As much as I enjoy the Rohan OVA, I'd be WAY more into this. Fugo is one of my favorite part 5 characters

  • @kamalalsb7292
    @kamalalsb7292 3 роки тому +3

    Is it weird that hearing Araki's reason for NOT having Fugo come back made me feel really bad for Araki? I know this was a while ago and hopefully he's okay since then, but it sucks that he was clearly in a bit of a fragile state of mind for a while there. The manga industry can be pretty demanding.

  • @GodittoC
    @GodittoC 4 роки тому +3

    no.
    *Thanks for whatching*

  • @thecrimsonmeteor
    @thecrimsonmeteor 4 роки тому

    And im just waiting for the dead man's question adaptation that will never come

  • @Sheepy765.
    @Sheepy765. 4 роки тому

    It would be cool if at some point DP made a purple haze feedback movie, I enjoyed reading it and some of the stands like Dolly Dagger and Rainy Day Dream Away would be interesting to see animated. Even if it doesn’t line up with the anime.

  • @thegoldencrowbar6439
    @thegoldencrowbar6439 4 роки тому +3

    Remember Jorge Joestar?
    PHF is a good idea

  • @MIGU3L2K
    @MIGU3L2K 4 роки тому +3

    I’d rather just have all the parts animated instead, and then have the Gucci mangas and PHFB animated after.

  • @dreamerthief2216
    @dreamerthief2216 4 роки тому +2

    The is Audiobook Of PHF being made at the moment i suggest the one interested to search it.
    Its a work of the youtuber Riverdude and we are at the moment at Ch.3 and its really good

    • @12171010011010
      @12171010011010 4 роки тому +1

      Im pretty sure there was one made by another guy already if you search it. The VA is a little weak but it's not distractingly bad or anything.

  • @borjaarellano9966
    @borjaarellano9966 4 роки тому

    some points could still be rearange like the intel one
    they could make so that Cannolo led rissoto to the intel team on purpose
    or that fugo introduces passione to abbachio

  • @Patrick-bn5rp
    @Patrick-bn5rp 4 роки тому +56

    Ah, BUT if it DOES get animated in the form of a movie. It'll really make a ton of money.

    • @shapard555
      @shapard555 4 роки тому +13

      no it'll not.

    • @Josuh
      @Josuh 4 роки тому +4

      what kind of logic is that

    • @Patrick-bn5rp
      @Patrick-bn5rp 4 роки тому +17

      @@shapard555 Let me spell this out for you. Part 5 is Japan's favorite part. It is THE most popular part over there. And an anime movie is significantly cheaper to make then an anime TV series, all things considered. Because PHF is more or less a sequel to Golden Wind or almost a "second finale"... People are going to want to see it. Especially if Araki assists with writing the script... Based on that... Yeah... It'd rake in the dough. A lot moreso then the Rohan Ovas, to put matters simply.

    • @smackdownbeef9490
      @smackdownbeef9490 4 роки тому +4

      @@Patrick-bn5rp So you're argument is that PHF would likely make a lot money as an adaptation because it's a side material for the most popular part. Yet Rohan, one of the most popular characters in Japan, doesn't make money for his side material?
      Also, by this logic, Golden Heart, Golden Ring would also make a lot of money as a movie too, and that one was outright commissioned by Araki, so even more incentive for that one.

    • @Patrick-bn5rp
      @Patrick-bn5rp 4 роки тому +7

      @@smackdownbeef9490 For the record, the Rohan side stories don't really serve as a sequel to Diamond is Unbreakable or anything. That, and DP is doing separately sold OVAs and not the entirety of Rohan's adventures, which makes the purchase a lot more niche. Plus, PHF is the highest rated of all the side stories. And again, PHF is a sequel of sorts. Which means that it greatly enhances the narrative of part 5 and answers the question of "what happened after Diavolo's defeat.". My point is that it would fit into the format of a movie quite well, which in turn would make it an easier purchase then having to find each of the OVA DVDs for Rohan. It's one purchase versus several.

  • @alternativecomics2429
    @alternativecomics2429 4 роки тому +6

    *no*

  • @allucinations7017
    @allucinations7017 4 роки тому +1

    Im waiting for Dead Man's Questions for being animated

  • @GravityAqua
    @GravityAqua 2 роки тому +2

    Sad to know it has never happened

  • @summysailar
    @summysailar 4 роки тому +3

    5:55 Throughout the entirely of the Part 5 anime I was praying if they gonna add PHF scenes during certain scenes like when they got on the boat and the Illuso fight. Basically this entire video was my thought process as each episode came out. So yea, PHF when?

  • @boopdooq1743
    @boopdooq1743 4 роки тому +2

    The answer is simple:
    *Fan Animations*

  • @joveyspan1979
    @joveyspan1979 4 роки тому

    PHF is definitely a resource popular enough to have an anime adaptation, but I guess some scenes and developments would have to be modified to fit the part 5 anime, such as Fugo’s past story
    I personally want The Book to be adapted more, as there’s much fewer conflicts, and the mysterious vibe is damn cool. Seeing the living Takuma and Chiho on screen would definitely take me to heaven

  • @splat1399
    @splat1399 2 роки тому

    I think that fugo came back as an enemy it would be cool to see his and cioccolatas mold work toghter

  • @MrAhkmid
    @MrAhkmid 2 роки тому +3

    These are all nitpicks at best. David productions could just change all of these minor details to align with the anime.

  • @zanrakey4140
    @zanrakey4140 4 роки тому +5

    After watching the video.
    Yeah, I'm not certain I fully agree with your points. Araki ASKED Kadono to write PHF and it has NOT been confirmed NON-canon. Obviously this doesn't mean it IS canon but rather we just cannot say strongly. As for contradictions, they are all so insignificant and easily edited. None of them seem to be related to major story beats enough to make an adaption difficult.
    Now I still don't think it's likely PHF will get adapted, the rights are all over the place, and it would require some all new art since PHF is a light novel instead of a manga. I don't see the extra work and money needed getting put into it.

  • @8Cheddar8
    @8Cheddar8 4 роки тому

    Thank you, Dr. Piss

  • @deeztb484
    @deeztb484 4 роки тому +1

    What’s Napls? What country is Napls or where is it located? Is it related to the place called Naples?