EoE as a twist with only one person re-entering at the merge is infinitely better than someone returning at F6 with a damn idol. If they made that adjustment i'd probably be fine with it.
Bring back Tree Mail. Bring back “When it Rains, It Pours”. Bring back the auction. Bring back Exile Island. Bring back Rites of Passage. Bring back the old jury format. Bring back water challenges and night challenges. That’s my list of demands and I’ll be interested to see if Survivor 40 does any of these.
Once again Jeff Probst needs to know that idols aren't the problem but the *abundance of idols* and *safety advantages* _are_ the problem. Remember the final 6 in _Game Changers_ when Cirie was eliminated by default? We don't want to see anything like that again.
@@blackwidowbrigade5042 that's the most talked about tribal in survivor. Like it or not it's the biggest survivor moment to date. Add the fact that it was overrated Cirie. BEST. TRIBAL. EVER!!!
They probably put it in so that if someone's favorite player gets voted out early they can still see them for a while longer...not saying I'm a fan of it though
To me fire tokens is a great idea! It's the natural evolution of the game and it fits with the island theme, think about pirates and treasures... I can't wait to watch season 40 and all the seasons after it!
I'd be more on board with edge if they put the return challenge 2 or 3 rounds earlier. I had no problem with the Chris win, I just think final 6 is too late for someone to re enter with an idol, because it makes it kinda easy to make it to the end, being that the person that re-entered in most likey good at challenges already.
Rob just announced he's coming back for season 50. Started playing in season 4. That man really does have survivor running through his veins! Will be interesting to see if his kids play. I've already seen him teaching one of them how to start a fire with flint (on his Instagram acct)
Once again, Jeff Probst needs to know that idols aren't the problem but the *abundance of idols* and *safety advantages* _is_ the problem. Remember _Game Changers,_ when Cirie was eliminated by default? That was the problem.
Honestly wish they would do an og season of survivor so no idols and slower gameplay. Watching how people think is way better than watching people find idols(in my opinion) which are now at this point, probably given the location to them by the camera crew.
Jeff just can't stop talking in general. Watch any of the challenges, he does not shut the F up. I'm so glad we have Australian survivor. It's what the show used to be.
@@metrickarma But, do you and @Aris Ray Bangalore have the same vibe as what the first few seasons were about? Good things don't last forever unfortunately.
I’d be fine with eoe if it was only at the merge. It gives us more time with the whole cast and it doesn’t break the game and makes a fun little twist. Like the battle back
Not sure that Jeff Probst would really like me as a person, because I am extremely conservative, but one of my top five bucket list things would be to be stranded with him for a few hours and get to ask him hundreds of questions. I love the guy.
She’s adorable but definitely not a winner. I love her to death but she’s a female ozzy, he can be a great guy if he’s not being a dick to John C. But he’s only good at challenges his social game isn’t there. She’s a mix but she rides the good horse too far, shows she’s not just the hot girl and boom gone.
They should do idols where you have to use them in someone else. That'd force BIG IDOL MOVES like what Natalie did instead of just playing it for yourself
BULLSHIT this show would go on forever even if there are none of these stupid twists. We love the game as a core and we want to see people navigate it in different ways and you don't need stupid twists that ruin the game in order to see that happen
idols are fun and add a lot to survivor strategy but i mean a whole season of everyone looking for idols and being paranoid of someone else having an idol... and then there's no idols at all... SURVIVOR: ISLAND OF NO IDOLS... that sounds fun
The EOE is terrible it just takes time away from the people in the game, last season the only people you knew anything about was devins, Chris and the returning players
They should make one season soon that goes back to old school survivor with no idols or anything like that just to switch it up a little bit also I miss the old intro and music and all that
Take a bunch of new school players and make it returning players they're going to go back to old school survivor no idols no advantages just straight making relationships winning immunities and making it to the final two yes I said final two now that would be great season I think people who got bored of the show or never really liked it in the first place would come watch that
Jeff removed them because the advantage strategy in S30 broke it. Jeff could have just taken out the advantages and have it like the authentic auctions, but Jeff just got rid of the whole thing.
@@mackiahhenry6261 people of suggested ways to fix it and here are the ones that I like the first one being that the advantage or the idle clue be the first thing to be auctioned up the second idea was to make it so the max bid for an advantage is $250 so you can still have money to put on other things and the last idea and my favorite is hide clues and advantages in the food items so say I win a steak dinner put an extra vote in my silverware roll or say I win a nice big bag of candy for myself to bring back to camp just straight up hide an idlol in my bag of candy
The problem with eoe is that the returning player has built a relationship with members of the jury basically outside of the game (the firsts shouldn't even be on the jury) and did not even play the game. Let him back at the merge maybe and no idol, but this?? He didn't survive nothing.
"You have people you like out there Reem and Devens, who wouldn't have been popular if they left early" SO WHAT?! I liked Natalie in DvG, Stephanie in Ghost Island, Ali in HHH, Malcolm in Game Changers, Mari in M v Gen X. But if they go early then that's it. Just the nature of the game. Enough of the bullshit Probst. You can't make us like something we dislike
@@freddy7gl They had great potential, but the game is an unforgiving game, and only 1 can win. Keeping a twist just to keep everyone around is a load of shit
@@milesbrad9975 Depends on the viewer. While it is a pretty tough game, people still have their favourites and get sad when they get voted out and aren't seen again until the reunion. For a season like this with all returning players, some of whom haven't been seen in over a decade, it would upset most if someone like Ethan got voted out first and then wasn't seen again until the reunion. From what I've read/heard some people only came back because of Edge of Extinction. Sandra implied as much in her interview.
@@fianle I am pretty sure Rob only agreed for the same reason. For some of these, they know full well they won't last long in the standard format, a chance to return to the game is a different story.
I agree with Jeff. There's a reason we are at the 40th season and that the show didn't end after 8 seasons.. everything happens for a reason. if EoE is brought back, it is meant to be.
Actually i was just as annoyed by Devons' return as i was about Chris U's. Get rid of EOE please. Get creative though, fine. Just within the framework of outwit outlast outplay. EOE is not "outlast".
Survivor 60... Amber and Rob's kids are on the show.. let's keep this series going lol
I unironically expect them to do a season with only children of former Survivors 10 years from now
Survivor: Legacies, with cast consisting of children of former players would be amazing
@@mysterywarriorcat4750 Survivor: Ancestors 🤣
Survivor has announced the final season will be the 50th, sooo, there is that.
@@Hotpielooking no they haven't, sooo, there is that.
EoE as a twist with only one person re-entering at the merge is infinitely better than someone returning at F6 with a damn idol. If they made that adjustment i'd probably be fine with it.
I completely agree. That fact that we had a winner who literally played 12 days of actual survivor is insane to me
I agree, that ruined the season for me. The timing definitely needs to be changed for EOE.
Bring back Tree Mail. Bring back “When it Rains, It Pours”. Bring back the auction. Bring back Exile Island. Bring back Rites of Passage. Bring back the old jury format. Bring back water challenges and night challenges.
That’s my list of demands and I’ll be interested to see if Survivor 40 does any of these.
Owen Gette most important is auctions for me... I remember watching them as a kid and just being so excited !
Also intro music
Adam S Yes yes yes yes yes
also bring back Ben the marine every season.
aus survivor has a lot of that
Once again Jeff Probst needs to know that idols aren't the problem but the *abundance of idols* and *safety advantages* _are_ the problem. Remember the final 6 in _Game Changers_ when Cirie was eliminated by default? We don't want to see anything like that again.
Well said. That was even worse than Paschal drawing the purple rock in season 4. 😡
True. If they had fewer I think it would be kinda cool though.
It's not a problem at all, that was the best tribal ever
@@phillipconte1205 objectively incorrect
@@blackwidowbrigade5042 that's the most talked about tribal in survivor. Like it or not it's the biggest survivor moment to date. Add the fact that it was overrated Cirie. BEST. TRIBAL. EVER!!!
Probst: Edge of Extinction. Some people love it. Some people hate it.
Reality: Edge of Extinction. Little people love it. Most people hate it.
True reality
Chris Underwood: loves it
Every single person on earth: Hates it.
Why do midgets like Edge of Extinction?
They probably put it in so that if someone's favorite player gets voted out early they can still see them for a while longer...not saying I'm a fan of it though
rannierunsfast Chris in an article with Dalton Ross said that while he benefited from EoE, as a fan he never wants to see it again
Jeff’s rob impression is spot on
Jeff’s impersonation of Rob is comedy gold!
To me fire tokens is a great idea! It's the natural evolution of the game and it fits with the island theme, think about pirates and treasures... I can't wait to watch season 40 and all the seasons after it!
Lol. Random Christian and Rick showing up out of nowhere
*Literally says, question for season 40*
Jeff impression of Boston Rob was perfect.
Exile island needs a comeback
I'd be more on board with edge if they put the return challenge 2 or 3 rounds earlier. I had no problem with the Chris win, I just think final 6 is too late for someone to re enter with an idol, because it makes it kinda easy to make it to the end, being that the person that re-entered in most likey good at challenges already.
They should make it to having only two people return at the start of the merge
My lord this season gonna be crazy
In a perfect world Ozzy, Cirie, Joe, Russell, Andrea, Rupert, Wentworth and Aubrey all competed on Survivor 40
Joe, no way. Just search up Julia Carter novel and get back to me.
If Ozzy won final immunity in South Pacific, he probably wins
Russell does not win survivor in a perfect world he's a goat
Rob just announced he's coming back for season 50. Started playing in season 4. That man really does have survivor running through his veins! Will be interesting to see if his kids play. I've already seen him teaching one of them how to start a fire with flint (on his Instagram acct)
Once again, Jeff Probst needs to know that idols aren't the problem but the *abundance of idols* and *safety advantages* _is_ the problem. Remember _Game Changers,_ when Cirie was eliminated by default? That was the problem.
Jeff is amazing!!!
👍👊🙏
Nice to see Andrea somewhere. Could get used to seeing her :o
I actually appreciate the explanation on the fire tokens
Honestly wish they would do an og season of survivor so no idols and slower gameplay. Watching how people think is way better than watching people find idols(in my opinion) which are now at this point, probably given the location to them by the camera crew.
Jeff just cnt stop talking about rob goodness ☠️☠️
Jeff just can't stop talking in general. Watch any of the challenges, he does not shut the F up. I'm so glad we have Australian survivor. It's what the show used to be.
@@metrickarma But, do you and @Aris Ray Bangalore have the same vibe as what the first few seasons were about? Good things don't last forever unfortunately.
1:15 his impression of Rob was on point
I’d be fine with eoe if it was only at the merge. It gives us more time with the whole cast and it doesn’t break the game and makes a fun little twist. Like the battle back
We got totally robbed of a reunion for Winners at War!! Damn you COVID!!
Not sure that Jeff Probst would really like me as a person, because I am extremely conservative, but one of my top five bucket list things would be to be stranded with him for a few hours and get to ask him hundreds of questions. I love the guy.
I really liked Andrea's recap show from a few years ago. I wish they would bring that back
I wish Andrea won so she could be on the show :(
She’s adorable but definitely not a winner. I love her to death but she’s a female ozzy, he can be a great guy if he’s not being a dick to John C. But he’s only good at challenges his social game isn’t there. She’s a mix but she rides the good horse too far, shows she’s not just the hot girl and boom gone.
They should do idols where you have to use them in someone else. That'd force BIG IDOL MOVES like what Natalie did instead of just playing it for yourself
BULLSHIT this show would go on forever even if there are none of these stupid twists. We love the game as a core and we want to see people navigate it in different ways and you don't need stupid twists that ruin the game in order to see that happen
Jared Stegman I enjoy the twists, and respect them wanting to spice things up. You may feel differently, but you don’t speak for everyone.
daaaaaamn andrea :D
I think I’m the only person who enjoys EOE with season 40
The video is great but daaaaaaamn! Need to wait a year or two for the next video. Keep the video coming..
Andrea and I are from the same state and she still hasn’t replied to my tweet. She was my survivor crush to. I sure know how to pick them
idols are fun and add a lot to survivor strategy but i mean a whole season of everyone looking for idols and being paranoid of someone else having an idol...
and then there's no idols at all...
SURVIVOR: ISLAND OF NO IDOLS...
that sounds fun
It took me 5 mins to notice it's Andrea
The inclusion of fire tokens may have saved the edge of extinction twist.
Omg, How could they not see that they invited Pennywise to the group ??? 0:49. Thats crazy !
Alright Jeff, you got me there with Devens making it back from Extinction too. But needs to not be coming back so late in future
The EOE is terrible it just takes time away from the people in the game, last season the only people you knew anything about was devins, Chris and the returning players
Who's Chris?
They should make one season soon that goes back to old school survivor with no idols or anything like that just to switch it up a little bit also I miss the old intro and music and all that
Take a bunch of new school players and make it returning players they're going to go back to old school survivor no idols no advantages just straight making relationships winning immunities and making it to the final two yes I said final two now that would be great season I think people who got bored of the show or never really liked it in the first place would come watch that
Cutie. Andrea aint bad either.
Lmao.. is there a little gay in you?
Tony should build a hole spy mansion
I thought that Parvarti wouldn’t come back. She had a baby not too long before she went on the show.
Yeah she had a baby like 4 or 5 months before she went on the show
did Jeff do estetic surgery for his cheek dimples?
ANDREA!!!!!!! I LOVE YOU!!!!!!!!! (not in a creepy way)
I don't think anybody really thought about it in a creepy way until you pointed that out that just seems creepy
( BRING Back Richard Hatch the Original SURVIVOR!!! Pass it ON!!)
what ever happened to the survivor auctions?
Jeff removed them because the advantage strategy in S30 broke it. Jeff could have just taken out the advantages and have it like the authentic auctions, but Jeff just got rid of the whole thing.
@@mackiahhenry6261 thank you!
@@mackiahhenry6261 people of suggested ways to fix it and here are the ones that I like the first one being that the advantage or the idle clue be the first thing to be auctioned up the second idea was to make it so the max bid for an advantage is $250 so you can still have money to put on other things and the last idea and my favorite is hide clues and advantages in the food items so say I win a steak dinner put an extra vote in my silverware roll or say I win a nice big bag of candy for myself to bring back to camp just straight up hide an idlol in my bag of candy
Richard Hatch should be on season 40, no excuses.
Lakersdude7 Richard Hatch made a video about it himself on his channel
Juliana Frith I know he did
I wouldn't have tons of idols id have 2 on both sides and merge if found there would be 1 more if not found there would be 2
The problem with eoe is that the returning player has built a relationship with members of the jury basically outside of the game (the firsts shouldn't even be on the jury) and did not even play the game. Let him back at the merge maybe and no idol, but this?? He didn't survive nothing.
Should be question why jeff do you not like hatch
I bet u they're bringing back Reem for 42
Season 40 winners at war with Andrea. No problem to me!
Does Jeff Probst age???
"You have people you like out there Reem and Devens, who wouldn't have been popular if they left early"
SO WHAT?!
I liked Natalie in DvG, Stephanie in Ghost Island, Ali in HHH, Malcolm in Game Changers, Mari in M v Gen X. But if they go early then that's it. Just the nature of the game. Enough of the bullshit Probst. You can't make us like something we dislike
I still feel bad about Mari in _Millennials vs. Gen X,_ and I liked Gonzalez in _Ghost Island,_ too.
@@freddy7gl They had great potential, but the game is an unforgiving game, and only 1 can win. Keeping a twist just to keep everyone around is a load of shit
@@milesbrad9975 Depends on the viewer. While it is a pretty tough game, people still have their favourites and get sad when they get voted out and aren't seen again until the reunion. For a season like this with all returning players, some of whom haven't been seen in over a decade, it would upset most if someone like Ethan got voted out first and then wasn't seen again until the reunion.
From what I've read/heard some people only came back because of Edge of Extinction. Sandra implied as much in her interview.
@@fianle I am pretty sure Rob only agreed for the same reason. For some of these, they know full well they won't last long in the standard format, a chance to return to the game is a different story.
@@laurabadora414 Rob, Amber, and Parvati were all influenced by the Edge I think. They were all no until Jeff tried again the latest time.
Andrea you look insanely hot in this video 🔥
Andrea is nearly 31 can you believe that people? Still hot as fuck!!
Once an idol is used, it should be gone. I don't like it coming back right after being used.
I agree with Jeff. There's a reason we are at the 40th season and that the show didn't end after 8 seasons.. everything happens for a reason. if EoE is brought back, it is meant to be.
No. Just no.
@@MrCorky911 try telling the producers that, not me dawg
Jeff, us (fans) DON'T LIKE EDGE OF EXTINCTION!!! Never again! Season 40 should be the last.
What the fuck is going' on with Jeff's eyeballs?
Just me or does she look little bit like Andrea
Lol, she is Andrea.
Whether edge of extinction enhanced Devins’ story or not, it still sucks. I hope they never do it again.
Actually i was just as annoyed by Devons' return as i was about Chris U's. Get rid of EOE please.
Get creative though, fine. Just within the framework of outwit outlast outplay. EOE is not "outlast".
I wish Andrea won so she could be on the show :(