I used to watch and read the Bangsamoro struggles and compare it with the GAM movement in Indonesia when I was a kid. Now as an adult, I've met a lot of Bangsamoro people from my travel in PH, some are Maguindanao, Tausug, Bajau, and one is curiously Molbok - an ethnic group I did not know before. They all speak different mother tongues, but all of them are proudly Bangsamoro. No disrespect to other Filipino, but Bangsamoro I met in my travel are the most courteous and friendly strangers that i've met in all of my travels in the whole PH. All of them invited me, a Catholic Indonesian, to their house one way or the other. So happy that finally in the last 10 years, peace and hope seems to be flourishing in Mindanao without needing the intervention of the biggest tsunami in modern times.
Wow nice one my friend, as well I know, Filipino and Indonesian are friendly each other in different religions so they respect them, sharing cultures and good bonds 😊😊
As a Filipino, i hope for peace between muslims and christians in the philippines and the world. We are all Filipinos, one country and one goal. Muslim or Christian must strive for success for his family, and country. God bless the Philippines
@@apartparisDon't make us laugh, please. Even Dimaporo or Alonto did not ride on the Alvarez-Duterte secession call. Same goes with the majority of BARMM. Why? Because they know they will be sidelined, again.
It wasn't difference of Ideologies or religious beliefs that caused the insurgency in the southern Philippines. It was Economics & apparent LACKED of logistics, infrastructures support from Malacanang Palace; regardless who's in there. Add to that the ignorance of the Catholic Christians on the way of the Moslems!
Thank you all to the people that made this peace and unity happen may peace and harmony as long us improvement in the community within the bangsamoro region long live the the Philippines
I grew up in the northern, Ilocano speaking region in the Philippines in the 1980s. Through media in print and on TV, Muslims in Mindanao were stereotyped as terrorists like the NPA(Communist rebels). However, during every annual Easter Sunday, all the Muslim merchants who set up at the market were the kindest people I ever met as a Filipino. Us Filipinos are masters at pretending to be kind. The Muslims' kindness is genuine, though. I'm a Christian pastor's son and I have a lot of respect for the legacy of Sheikh Karimul Makhdum. Basically.
Not all who call themselves Christians are truly Christians at heart. Christ's name has been profaned through the centuries. True Christians are taught that coveting is wrong and is a sin against God - a sin against fellow men. When Jesus Christ comes back to judge the world, all forms of injustice shall be no more and all the guilty who do not submit to the lordship of Christ shall be punished without end, in torment.
As an Ilonggo I feel sorry for what happen to my brother Muslim in Mindanao. Ilaga are use only by Marcos admin as paramilitary because of high casualty of Ilokano troop. Day by day truck were loaded with dead troops taken to Ilocos. Phillipines troops are only compose of Ilonggo and Ilokano troops because tagalog ang cebuano are afraid to be assign in Moro land
This part of the video only focused on AQUINO Regime, even tho his government would not be able to create a better framework without the efforts of previous Presidents. ALSO, the Aquino's frameworks was even re-drafted itself, because it was not final. lol Here is the actual summary. - The PEACE DEAL first begun in 1996, during Ramos. - The Memorandum of Agreement on Ancestral Domain (MOA-AD) was made in 2004 (Gloria Arroyo). - The framework of Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro was negotiated in 2014 (Aquino). But you have to remember that it was still in a constant negotiation. And you have to remember that Negotiation is based on Trust, and - BBL was drafted and finally signed into Bangsamoro Organic Law in 2018 (Duterte). --- Meaning ang FRAMEWORK during Aquino was not also enough. - Plebiscites happened in 2019 (Duterte). - The inauguration of BARMM and the inaugural session of the Bangsamoro Parliament took place on 2019. - The current applied framework of the Parliament can be mostly traced down during Duterte. - As much as I don't like Marcos, I think he is doing good also with continuing it. But again, you have to remember, from RAMOS, all Presidents tried their best and most of the framework that they have created are either ratified, amended or re-drafted. Now we are following the Framework agreed under Duterte, which his administration can only achieve thanks to the efforts and mistakes of previous drafted frameworks of previous Presidents. But, still we should watch out for 2025, because their election for their Parliament might be BL00dy. In short, despite this is a law, this is still a work in progress.
So many people, like you, do not know history of Mindanao, MILF and MNLF. You always associate it with your preferred President. Let me give you as summary: - The PEACE DEAL first begun in 1996, during Ramos. - The Memorandum of Agreement on Ancestral Domain (MOA-AD) was made in 2004 (Gloria Arroyo). - The framework of Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro was negotiated in 2014 (Aquino). But you have to remember that it was still in a constant negotiation. And you have to remember that Negotiation is based on Trust, and - BBL was drafted and finally signed into Bangsamoro Organic Law in 2018 (Duterte). --- Meaning ang FRAMEWORK during Aquino was not also enough. - Plebiscites happened in 2019 (Duterte). - The inauguration of BARMM and the inaugural session of the Bangsamoro Parliament took place on 2019. - The current framework of the Parliament are can be traced down during Duterte. - As much as I don't like Marcos, I think he is doing good also with continuing it. But again, you have to remember, from RAMOS, all Presidents tried their best and most of the framework that they have created are either ratified, amended or re-drafted. And NEGOTIATION is a very very long process, hindi ito business deal lang na 1 talk or 1 administration lang ay SOLVE na. lol. Basa basa din tayo about NEGOTIATION - DIPLOMACY. Now we are following the Framework agreed under Duterte, which his administration can only achieve thanks to the efforts and mistakes of previous drafted frameworks of previous Presidents. But, still we should watch out 2025, because their election for their Parliament might be BL00dy. In short, despite this is a law, this is still a work in progress.
My ancestry has migrated here in Mindanao started in 1913 to 1960. They describe it as peaceful and the relationship between both culture is good.but until 1970s that rebels of both side started to rise and this cause casualties in both side ,some of them migrated to other places as they fear for there own lives ,it was called by my parents as chaotic place, where you can here gunshot everyday , ambush and gun fighting,until now conflict between moro and Christians is still here but not that harsh as in 1970s.
Mindanao are thriving business and development. The key is peaceful, rules and regulations. I hope those good religious in our neighborhood pls don't bother our Muslim to becoming like you.. Let them in peace and be prosperous...
Huge THANKS to PNOY and his administration, and everyone involved in the peace process for so many years. I grew up in Surigao City and hope one day to be able to travel in all of Mindanao.
Hay naku. Copy paste ko nalang Summary ng history. My god ganon ba kayo ka ignorante sa PEACE Process dito? Why do you always associate it with your preferred President. Let me give you as summary: - The PEACE DEAL first begun in 1996, during Ramos. - The Memorandum of Agreement on Ancestral Domain (MOA-AD) was made in 2004 (Gloria Arroyo). - The framework of Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro was negotiated in 2014 (Aquino). But you have to remember that it was still in a constant negotiation. And you have to remember that Negotiation is based on Trust, and - BBL was drafted and finally signed into Bangsamoro Organic Law in 2018 (Duterte). --- Meaning ang FRAMEWORK during Aquino was not also enough. - Plebiscites happened in 2019 (Duterte). - The inauguration of BARMM and the inaugural session of the Bangsamoro Parliament took place on 2019 (Duterte). - The framework of the Parliament can be mostly traced down during Duterte. - As much as I don't like Marcos, I think he is doing good also with continuing it. But again, you have to remember, from RAMOS, all Presidents tried their best and most of the framework that they have created are either ratified, amended or re-drafted. Now we are following the Framework agreed under Duterte, which his administration can only achieve it based on the efforts and mistakes of previous drafted frameworks of previous Presidents. But, still we should watch out 2025, because their election for their Parliament might be BL00dy. In short, despite this is a law, this is still a work in progress.
@@snarveien1853, you are right. It has taken over decades of work, perseverance, courage, etc. from all.sides and thru succeeding administration. It is okay to highlight a preferred administration.
@snarveien1853 you call yourself an expert because you can copy and paste? You're more knowledgeable now? I'm not taking a history lesson from the likes of you. Thanks for showing me your true colors. ✌️ ☮️ 🕊
@@snarveien1853 no need for your copy paste lecture...as long as all people live peacefully and in harmony that's only matters..so shut up ass$&&&$ole
We, the people of Sarawak, Sabah, want to be independent like Singapore, Brunei. We are the people of Sarawak, Sabah, not from Malaysia. We are our own nation, namely the independent nation of Sarawak, Sabah.
Taga mindanao din ako, pero, hindi ko alam yong issues na yan dahil sa surigao ako lumaki at labas na BARMM, ngayon ko lang nalaman ang malalim na alitan.
Filipino women, like my mother, are the peacemakers of the home and nation. One of the few countries which has elected 2 women president's in modern times. Also highlights how Southeast Asian Muslim communities give importance to women.
The MNLF were never a terrorist organization, they were a rebel group seeking their rightful independence from the oppression felt by the Moros and the centralized government who starved Mindanao of development
Lol. What y’all talking about. MNLF kidnapping tourists and other Filipinos for ransom and other illegal activities in the island speaks huge terr0rism problem running for decades. These plus corrupt Muslim leaders like Ampatuan and more makes progress in the region more impossible. Tourism is low, no investors interested results to high poverty rate and more.
Even when given independence through BARMM, corruption and incompetent leadership is still rampant. There’s nothing a government can do for such people. They just never learn.
i pray to my God in the Heavens that the Philippine government will have a political will to finally and literally build bridges and tunnels that will connect all islands in luzon, visayas and mindanao as far as the distance of palawan, with the present technology it can be done, in doing so, my people, and my motherland will be finally become one people, one nation and with one God in the heavens...the internet is helpful to make my country one nation but we still need the roads and bridges from luzon to mindanao so we will be finally progress to first world country and will no longer be a housemaid, construction worker and nurses to foreign countries, this is my dream and prayer in my lifetime. God help us please.....
Yaaaaaaaahhhhhh, what hell are you talking about that "when the christian settlers came into the philippines"? Are you telling us that we filipino christians are not native to our philippines archaepelagos? Do we look like vietnamese or taiwanese or chinese or japanese to you?
Christianity was brought to the Philippines by the Spaniards as they conquered and settled most of the islands. The people who were already living in the islands before that were NOT Christians (and technically nor were they Filipinos because the political Philippines didn’t exist until way later when the Spanish called the archipelago Filipinas), hence them saying that Christianity was not native to the islands.
@@mauvemaven in one of indonesian video, i notice a man that i can say we both 90% look alike. And even my whole family cannot believe at first. If we are not native here, then, the hell part of galaxy are from? 😂😂😂😂😂. Ok. Then, we christian filipinos are spanish? 😂😂😂😂😂. Probably we filipino christians are aliens. 😂😂😂
@@Habaek02 No one is saying that you are not native here. It merely says that Christianity is not native to the original peoples of these Austronesian islands. If the Spaniards did not occupy the archipelago then you and your whole family would not have been Christians because of the lack of Catholic influence. Tayo lang ang majority Catholic nation in a sea of Buddhists and Muslims. Kung wala ang mga Español, malamang either naging Buddhist ka or Muslim or even pagan or polytheist dahil yun ang mga nananaig na relihiyon noong mga panahon na yun. Sinupil kasi ng mga Español ang pagkakakilanlan ng mga katutubo noon. The fact na Katoliko ka means na produkto ka ng panunupil na yun.
YES!!!! YOU'RE NOT NATIVE IN MINDANAO!!!!! WE BANGSAMORO ARE NATICETSA MINDANAO TANGA AT HINDI NAMAN TLGA PARTE NG PILIPINAS ANG MINDANAO AT PALAWAN, ISINALI LANG ITO NANG MGA AMERIKANO NOON PANAHON NANG NATALO ANG MGA SPAIN SA AMERICA TANGA!!! ALAM MO BA YONG TREATY OF PARIS BUBU!!!! OO ALIEN KA SA MINDANAO AT HINDI LUGAR NG MGA BISAYA AT LUZON ANG BUONG KAPULOAN NG MINDANAO AT PALAWAN PARA MAINTINDIHAN MO TANGA PALIBHASA KASI WALA KANG ALAM SA KASAYSAYAN PURO ALAM MO YONG MGA POLPOL MONG MGA BAYANING TINALONNG MGA DAYUHAN, TSKA PINANOOD MO BA BUONG VIDEO PALIBHASA KASI PURO KA REACT WALA KANG ALAM TAPUSIN MO MONA ANG VIDEO AT KALAMIN MO ANG BUONG KATOTOHANAN WAG KANG ONESIDED BUBU PALIBHASA PRODUKTO NG BRAINWASHED
The Christianity is not native, not the people who became converts. My lolo was (nominally) a Catholic who settled in Basilan and married a Tausug. But he got along great with the other Muslims, perhaps because my lolo never went to church, would occasionally go to the mosque, and treated everyone as equals. I wonder if you know that Islam, Hinduism and Buddhism was in the Philippines before Christianity?
@@sionc1372 nah as in you want Bangsamoro to still be part of the whole Philippines? Or nah kasi you just a hater. Wala akong opinyon sa mga presiden, gusto ko lang malaman. Well, my only opinion is that peace is good…
Nice one-sided reporting. The Ilaga was originally formed to fight the abusive land owning families in Central Mindanao. But when mulsim rebels began harassing Christian farming communities, the Ilagas were hired to counter them. And also, Mindanao doesn't belong to the Muslim population only because even before the Spaniards came, a huge part of it has been populated by non-muslim natives, many of which allied themselves with the Spaniards.
Mga paniniwala yan sa Muslim dahil sa religion,nag,tangatangahan sila dahil sa religion walang religion Mindanao maraming tribe na ang naka tira sa Mindanao walang karapatan ang religion ang,kinin ang Mindanao,ang Mindanao para sa mga pilipino hindi para sa Muslim at christian.
the name itself tells, "Land Grabbing". Bottomline, whatever side you're on never forget that ILAGA are from VISAYAS/LUZON. So it means settlers, so it means land grabbers.
Nope. Ilaga just means "rat" in vernacular, referring to the field rats that feed on palay and mais, a perfect representative of poor farmers who were just seeking a good and peaceful life. These farmers had to defend themselves from continuous harassment from land-owning clans from Maguindanao and Cotabato. The "land grabber" moniker was given to them by the pissed muslim rebels, who came later into the picture, when they found out that the settlers and some natives such as the Teduray had bonded together to defend themselves.
Perhaps FILIPINOS should also know MORO HISTORY way before 1521.. Here’s what we have: MOROS in Sulu | The ORIGIN STORY ua-cam.com/video/C7zMHoCIf0E/v-deo.html
The documentary is educational and well done. The resource speakers are good especially Mastura. The women are the best part. But it looked suspicious as promo for Pinoy Aquino. The major players in history of peace were not mentioned - Misuari, Fr Mercado. The Jabidah Massacre like what happenef in Manili during Marcos was the worst in history of conflict. The best president who came closest to peace was not Cory, not Pinoy, it was Fiidel Ramos. The documentary is only one small window. Hence not significant.
As a Filipino. It is better for us to have prime minister in every main islands. Luzon, Visayas, Mindanao and Bansangmoro region. Because us from Luzon shouldered so much money and resources just to develop Mindanao. Imagine no investors wanted to make business there. Mabuti pa sa Visayas andyan ang Cebu-iloilo na center ng kalakalan.
Ferdinand Marcos pushed for Christian Settlers from Luzon & Visayas to move to Mindanao.. This was a very big error as it created tension & killings between these 2 communities.
Nope. Christian settlements already happened before that. Don't tell us that Vicente Duterte, Gaudencio Antonino, Romeo Jalosjos, Jose Zubiri just moved to Mindanao during the First Marcos Presidency. Know your facts first.
Christians are already in Mindanao since the Spanish Era. Muslims fought for resistance as the Spanish with its Christians soldiers tried to expand its foothold in Mindanao Island capturing muslim territories and displacement of muslim population. The muslims managed to hold its last stronghold due to support of muslim sultenates such as the Ottoman Empire who has its diplomatic support to contain the spread of Christianity in the island led by the Spanish Crown. It was the Americans who let the resettlement of Christian Filipinos after they successfully contain the uprisings and strip local rulers like the Sultan of Sulu of its power does cementing American sovereignty in moro lands. It was then continued with the succeeding administration.
This documentary is one sided. Even before this attack of the afp there, during cease fire moro rebels are bombing police station, Christian villages, markets even during Christmas not only in Mindanao but the rebels brought these crimes in Luzon. Intercepting and ambushing army troupe and those who survived were being beheaded during cease fire. MILF recruitment yes but you fail to include the massive abduction of young boys in villages and coercing to join the rebel groups. All of these can easily be obtain if you just did your research. You even left out the part that moro rebels resort to kidnap for ransom to fund their rebel army. That's the very reason why until now many local and foreign tourist are still reluctant to go in Mindanao. You would argue that these atrocities are done by Islamic terrorist well it was proven they are incahoots with MILF. The real turning point why these learned Muslim leaders cooperate was when they take seat in government they saw the disparity in progress in Luzon and Mindanao. That is their rebellious mentality will not gain them investments. Another vital person you left out is Nur Misuari the founder of MNLF and why Iqbal break away from MNLF and formed MILF, And the reason you did this is because you'll have to present real purpose of MNLF and MILF. You failed also to include the reason why these people made an agreement with the government, is due to the fact that all Muslim/Islamic rebel groups in Mindanao are declared nothing but a terrorist groups by all international agencies.
ang dami mong dada TAE!!!! KAYO ANG ONE SIDED STUPID!!!! KAYO NANG AGAW AT MARAMING PINATAY NAG AAKUSA KAPA KAMI PA MASAMA PUNYETA KA BABOY!!!! PA ISRAEL KAPA ACT KAPA PUNYETA KA KAYO ANG MGA MASASAM PUNYETA NANG AAGAW HINDI NIYO PAG AARI POKE INA MONG BABOY KA ASO!!!! PAKITA MO SARILI MO SA AKIN OARA MAISAMPAL KO SAYO ANG TOTO PUNYETA KA PATI ISLAM DNDALA MO SA KABUBUHAN MO POKE INA MO BABOY!!! ANUNG KINALAMAN NG PAGIGING MUSLIM AT ISLAM NAMIN POTA KA KAYO NAG SIMULA LAHAT NG MGA GULONG ITO HINDI KAMI POKE INA BABIY
Ha ? Tanga ka? Sino ba nanggulo dito dati diba mga spaniol? Muslim ba sila? Pinagtanggol ng mga Moro ang Mindanao hnd tulad ng mga taga Luzon at Visayas na nagpaka puta sa Spaniol.
Mag basa ka ng history ng Pilipinas wag Kang Tanga dahil sa Marcos nayan na buo Ang mga grupo Dito tapos Sabihin mo magulo mga Muslim eh Anong dapat Gawin namin papatayin nalng ng walang laban bubu kaba
This film should be shared in classrooms, diff arenas of learning instead of all these nonsense HOR/Senate hearings broadcast. Its about resolving conflicts. Coming together for peace in the Country. We are all Filipinos.
As a Christian, I am disgusted on how our government treating our Muslim brothers & sisters. What make the situation even worst is that how military are brainwashed by Americans. Our Muslim brothers and sisters deserves to have an autonomous government in order to have peace in Mindanao.
When Muslims defend their own land its automatically called Terrorism, you failed to mention also when Ilagas or Ilocano's migrated in Moroland during FEM days, they relentlessly killed and stole many local moro lands.. you should study history and the root cause of everything..Moro land was never part of Philippines to begin with, they never surrendered to the spanish.. and forced to be part of the Philippines
The war was imported to us by the foreign occupation. And we inherent it, by debiding us tru religion. Im belong to millinials generation of Christian and im from Mindanao..but when i go around, i will go as Filipinos or simpling Mindanawon .making friends and talking to others faith with respect.
They have their own definition of injustice. All those against their goals and plans are injustice. MNLF and MILF have the same membership. They only made two seemingly different terrorist organizations to confuse the public and lobby support.
Hindi siya ang nagdala kabayan; pero Hindi mapag kaila ang genuine intention and pagpapakumbaba nya. Remember some of his military advisors felt uncomfortable with the meeting. He was the one to set his foot down to say (from malacanang) “this is the way to peace”
Quran chapter 47 verse 35, So be not weak and ask NOT for PEACE ( from the enemies of ISLAM ), while you are having the upper hand. ALLAH is with you and will never decrease the reward of your good deeds...please help us to understand this verse?
Chapter of Anfal Verse 61 But if they incline towards peace, then incline towards it [also] and put your trust in Allah. Indeed, He is the All-Hearing, the All-Knowing
I used to watch and read the Bangsamoro struggles and compare it with the GAM movement in Indonesia when I was a kid.
Now as an adult, I've met a lot of Bangsamoro people from my travel in PH, some are Maguindanao, Tausug, Bajau, and one is curiously Molbok - an ethnic group I did not know before. They all speak different mother tongues, but all of them are proudly Bangsamoro.
No disrespect to other Filipino, but Bangsamoro I met in my travel are the most courteous and friendly strangers that i've met in all of my travels in the whole PH. All of them invited me, a Catholic Indonesian, to their house one way or the other.
So happy that finally in the last 10 years, peace and hope seems to be flourishing in Mindanao without needing the intervention of the biggest tsunami in modern times.
Wow nice one my friend, as well I know, Filipino and Indonesian are friendly each other in different religions so they respect them, sharing cultures and good bonds 😊😊
@@darwinqpenaflorida3797 it is a big fat lies! Quran chapter 5 verse 51, O you believe! take not the Jews and the christians for friends...
@@GasoyGasang I pray Jesus Christ will enlighten your mind hear and soul ❤🙏
As a Filipino, i hope for peace between muslims and christians in the philippines and the world. We are all Filipinos, one country and one goal. Muslim or Christian must strive for success for his family, and country. God bless the Philippines
@@apartparisDon't make us laugh, please. Even Dimaporo or Alonto did not ride on the Alvarez-Duterte secession call. Same goes with the majority of BARMM. Why? Because they know they will be sidelined, again.
It's not about religion brother it's about injustice and rotten idiology...
@@apartparisDDLIS SPOTTED😂😂
Big tourism potential. More beautiful than thailand
It wasn't difference of Ideologies or religious beliefs that caused the insurgency in the southern Philippines. It was Economics & apparent LACKED of logistics, infrastructures support from Malacanang Palace; regardless who's in there. Add to that the ignorance of the Catholic Christians on the way of the Moslems!
I wish I had seen this 20 years ago. There is so much I didn't know about what was going on. This is priceless journalism and historical education.
Thank you all to the people that made this peace and unity happen may peace and harmony as long us improvement in the community within the bangsamoro region long live the the Philippines
Im from Maguindanao and this people just made it worst
I grew up in the northern, Ilocano speaking region in the Philippines in the 1980s. Through media in print and on TV, Muslims in Mindanao were stereotyped as terrorists like the NPA(Communist rebels). However, during every annual Easter Sunday, all the Muslim merchants who set up at the market were the kindest people I ever met as a Filipino. Us Filipinos are masters at pretending to be kind. The Muslims' kindness is genuine, though.
I'm a Christian pastor's son and I have a lot of respect for the legacy of Sheikh Karimul Makhdum.
Basically.
thanks CNA for this documentary.
Not all who call themselves Christians are truly Christians at heart. Christ's name has been profaned through the centuries. True Christians are taught that coveting is wrong and is a sin against God - a sin against fellow men. When Jesus Christ comes back to judge the world, all forms of injustice shall be no more and all the guilty who do not submit to the lordship of Christ shall be punished without end, in torment.
As an Ilonggo I feel sorry for what happen to my brother Muslim in Mindanao. Ilaga are use only by Marcos admin as paramilitary because of high casualty of Ilokano troop. Day by day truck were loaded with dead troops taken to Ilocos. Phillipines troops are only compose of Ilonggo and Ilokano troops because tagalog ang cebuano are afraid to be assign in Moro land
afraid? speak for yourself. How about those people don't want to be settlers and killers ?
good to know "my kind" don't have moro blood in our hands
Salamat PNOY 💛
Salamat ABNOY
@@CarlosJohnTorres Mas Abnoy pa IDOL mong Kawatan.
@@CarlosJohnTorres
Gustong gusto sa peace and order pero galit kay Pnoy?
dahit kay Pnoy nagkaroon ng zamboanga at marawi siege nung binalik yung mga base sa mga rebelde
@@CarlosJohnTorres ikaw ang abnoy
Thank you so much for this. Being a pure Filipino hearing of this and that, knowing the truth is such a blessed gift. Kudos to all of them.
Im from Maguindanao and this people just made it worst.
"the Philippines is my country. I was born here. I will die here, Inshallah."
Malaysia supported this so the Phillipines forget the claim in Sabah.
So happy to have been reminded of this...one of Ninoy Aquino's very important legacy to this nation. He being dead, yet still speaks. Mabuhay!
This part of the video only focused on AQUINO Regime, even tho his government would not be able to create a better framework without the efforts of previous Presidents. ALSO, the Aquino's frameworks was even re-drafted itself, because it was not final. lol
Here is the actual summary.
- The PEACE DEAL first begun in 1996, during Ramos.
- The Memorandum of Agreement on Ancestral Domain (MOA-AD) was made in 2004 (Gloria Arroyo).
- The framework of Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro was negotiated in 2014 (Aquino). But you have to remember that it was still in a constant negotiation. And you have to remember that Negotiation is based on Trust, and
- BBL was drafted and finally signed into Bangsamoro Organic Law in 2018 (Duterte). --- Meaning ang FRAMEWORK during Aquino was not also enough.
- Plebiscites happened in 2019 (Duterte).
- The inauguration of BARMM and the inaugural session of the Bangsamoro Parliament took place on 2019.
- The current applied framework of the Parliament can be mostly traced down during Duterte.
- As much as I don't like Marcos, I think he is doing good also with continuing it.
But again, you have to remember, from RAMOS, all Presidents tried their best and most of the framework that they have created are either ratified, amended or re-drafted. Now we are following the Framework agreed under Duterte, which his administration can only achieve thanks to the efforts and mistakes of previous drafted frameworks of previous Presidents. But, still we should watch out for 2025, because their election for their Parliament might be BL00dy. In short, despite this is a law, this is still a work in progress.
by episode ito tanga!
not all president try thier best ungas some are traitor mga lahi niyo yan
I am honored to personally meet Ma'am Irene!
Thank you LORD for guiding us and have Peace 🙏🙏💪💪🇵🇭🇵🇭 # UNITY.
One of the legacies of former president Pnoy Aquino.
So many people, like you, do not know history of Mindanao, MILF and MNLF. You always associate it with your preferred President. Let me give you as summary:
- The PEACE DEAL first begun in 1996, during Ramos.
- The Memorandum of Agreement on Ancestral Domain (MOA-AD) was made in 2004 (Gloria Arroyo).
- The framework of Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro was negotiated in 2014 (Aquino). But you have to remember that it was still in a constant negotiation. And you have to remember that Negotiation is based on Trust, and
- BBL was drafted and finally signed into Bangsamoro Organic Law in 2018 (Duterte). --- Meaning ang FRAMEWORK during Aquino was not also enough.
- Plebiscites happened in 2019 (Duterte).
- The inauguration of BARMM and the inaugural session of the Bangsamoro Parliament took place on 2019.
- The current framework of the Parliament are can be traced down during Duterte.
- As much as I don't like Marcos, I think he is doing good also with continuing it.
But again, you have to remember, from RAMOS, all Presidents tried their best and most of the framework that they have created are either ratified, amended or re-drafted. And NEGOTIATION is a very very long process, hindi ito business deal lang na 1 talk or 1 administration lang ay SOLVE na. lol. Basa basa din tayo about NEGOTIATION - DIPLOMACY.
Now we are following the Framework agreed under Duterte, which his administration can only achieve thanks to the efforts and mistakes of previous drafted frameworks of previous Presidents. But, still we should watch out 2025, because their election for their Parliament might be BL00dy. In short, despite this is a law, this is still a work in progress.
@@snarveien1853Dutae, dami pa dada kunwari
I love This Story 100%
My ancestry has migrated here in Mindanao started in 1913 to 1960. They describe it as peaceful and the relationship between both culture is good.but until 1970s that rebels of both side started to rise and this cause casualties in both side ,some of them migrated to other places as they fear for there own lives ,it was called by my parents as chaotic place, where you can here gunshot everyday , ambush and gun fighting,until now conflict between moro and Christians is still here but not that harsh as in 1970s.
Thank you for this CNA! Great work.
Mindanao are thriving business and development. The key is peaceful, rules and regulations.
I hope those good religious in our neighborhood pls don't bother our Muslim to becoming like you..
Let them in peace and be prosperous...
Huge THANKS to PNOY and his administration, and everyone involved in the peace process for so many years. I grew up in Surigao City and hope one day to be able to travel in all of Mindanao.
Hay naku. Copy paste ko nalang Summary ng history. My god ganon ba kayo ka ignorante sa PEACE Process dito?
Why do you always associate it with your preferred President. Let me give you as summary:
- The PEACE DEAL first begun in 1996, during Ramos.
- The Memorandum of Agreement on Ancestral Domain (MOA-AD) was made in 2004 (Gloria Arroyo).
- The framework of Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro was negotiated in 2014 (Aquino). But you have to remember that it was still in a constant negotiation. And you have to remember that Negotiation is based on Trust, and
- BBL was drafted and finally signed into Bangsamoro Organic Law in 2018 (Duterte). --- Meaning ang FRAMEWORK during Aquino was not also enough.
- Plebiscites happened in 2019 (Duterte).
- The inauguration of BARMM and the inaugural session of the Bangsamoro Parliament took place on 2019 (Duterte).
- The framework of the Parliament can be mostly traced down during Duterte.
- As much as I don't like Marcos, I think he is doing good also with continuing it.
But again, you have to remember, from RAMOS, all Presidents tried their best and most of the framework that they have created are either ratified, amended or re-drafted. Now we are following the Framework agreed under Duterte, which his administration can only achieve it based on the efforts and mistakes of previous drafted frameworks of previous Presidents. But, still we should watch out 2025, because their election for their Parliament might be BL00dy. In short, despite this is a law, this is still a work in progress.
@@snarveien1853, you are right. It has taken over decades of work, perseverance, courage, etc. from all.sides and thru succeeding administration. It is okay to highlight a preferred administration.
@snarveien1853 you call yourself an expert because you can copy and paste? You're more knowledgeable now? I'm not taking a history lesson from the likes of you. Thanks for showing me your true colors. ✌️ ☮️ 🕊
@@snarveien1853 no need for your copy paste lecture...as long as all people live peacefully and in harmony that's only matters..so shut up ass$&&&$ole
Sarawak and Sabah will soon be independent. stand alone as an independent and sovereign country.
😂😂😂 in your wet 💦 dreams
Sarawak independent
We, the people of Sarawak and Sabah, are ready for independence. free from rotten agreements.
Sabah should be as rich as Singapore already.
We, the people of Sarawak, Sabah, want to be independent like Singapore, Brunei. We are the people of Sarawak, Sabah, not from Malaysia. We are our own nation, namely the independent nation of Sarawak, Sabah.
this is a 10 stars documentary. congratulations!
Taga mindanao din ako, pero, hindi ko alam yong issues na yan dahil sa surigao ako lumaki at labas na BARMM, ngayon ko lang nalaman ang malalim na alitan.
Filipino women, like my mother, are the peacemakers of the home and nation. One of the few countries which has elected 2 women president's in modern times. Also highlights how Southeast Asian Muslim communities give importance to women.
Blessed are the peacemakers, because they will be called sons of God.
The MNLF were never a terrorist organization, they were a rebel group seeking their rightful independence from the oppression felt by the Moros and the centralized government who starved Mindanao of development
Starve kang bobo ka.
Lol. What y’all talking about. MNLF kidnapping tourists and other Filipinos for ransom and other illegal activities in the island speaks huge terr0rism problem running for decades. These plus corrupt Muslim leaders like Ampatuan and more makes progress in the region more impossible. Tourism is low, no investors interested results to high poverty rate and more.
Even when given independence through BARMM, corruption and incompetent leadership is still rampant. There’s nothing a government can do for such people. They just never learn.
Nope, they definitely are
The ONLY TRUE TERRORISTS ARE THE CPP-NPA and The Aquino-Marcos oligarchy
Wow! This story should be heard all over the country. Thanks to the people who helped impossible things possible. May the peace be with us forever!
i pray to my God in the Heavens that the Philippine government will have a political will to finally and literally build bridges and tunnels that will connect all islands in luzon, visayas and mindanao as far as the distance of palawan, with the present technology it can be done, in doing so, my people, and my motherland will be finally become one people, one nation and with one God in the heavens...the internet is helpful to make my country one nation but we still need the roads and bridges from luzon to mindanao so we will be finally progress to first world country and will no longer be a housemaid, construction worker and nurses to foreign countries, this is my dream and prayer in my lifetime. God help us please.....
How about the Talipao Peace Mission that ended on October 2000? We want a documentary about it.
Yaaaaaaaahhhhhh, what hell are you talking about that "when the christian settlers came into the philippines"? Are you telling us that we filipino christians are not native to our philippines archaepelagos?
Do we look like vietnamese or taiwanese or chinese or japanese to you?
Christianity was brought to the Philippines by the Spaniards as they conquered and settled most of the islands. The people who were already living in the islands before that were NOT Christians (and technically nor were they Filipinos because the political Philippines didn’t exist until way later when the Spanish called the archipelago Filipinas), hence them saying that Christianity was not native to the islands.
@@mauvemaven in one of indonesian video, i notice a man that i can say we both 90% look alike. And even my whole family cannot believe at first. If we are not native here, then, the hell part of galaxy are from? 😂😂😂😂😂. Ok. Then, we christian filipinos are spanish? 😂😂😂😂😂. Probably we filipino christians are aliens. 😂😂😂
@@Habaek02 No one is saying that you are not native here. It merely says that Christianity is not native to the original peoples of these Austronesian islands. If the Spaniards did not occupy the archipelago then you and your whole family would not have been Christians because of the lack of Catholic influence. Tayo lang ang majority Catholic nation in a sea of Buddhists and Muslims. Kung wala ang mga Español, malamang either naging Buddhist ka or Muslim or even pagan or polytheist dahil yun ang mga nananaig na relihiyon noong mga panahon na yun. Sinupil kasi ng mga Español ang pagkakakilanlan ng mga katutubo noon. The fact na Katoliko ka means na produkto ka ng panunupil na yun.
YES!!!! YOU'RE NOT NATIVE IN MINDANAO!!!!! WE BANGSAMORO ARE NATICETSA MINDANAO TANGA AT HINDI NAMAN TLGA PARTE NG PILIPINAS ANG MINDANAO AT PALAWAN, ISINALI LANG ITO NANG MGA AMERIKANO NOON PANAHON NANG NATALO ANG MGA SPAIN SA AMERICA TANGA!!! ALAM MO BA YONG TREATY OF PARIS BUBU!!!! OO ALIEN KA SA MINDANAO AT HINDI LUGAR NG MGA BISAYA AT LUZON ANG BUONG KAPULOAN NG MINDANAO AT PALAWAN PARA MAINTINDIHAN MO TANGA PALIBHASA KASI WALA KANG ALAM SA KASAYSAYAN PURO ALAM MO YONG MGA POLPOL MONG MGA BAYANING TINALONNG MGA DAYUHAN, TSKA PINANOOD MO BA BUONG VIDEO PALIBHASA KASI PURO KA REACT WALA KANG ALAM TAPUSIN MO MONA ANG VIDEO AT KALAMIN MO ANG BUONG KATOTOHANAN WAG KANG ONESIDED BUBU PALIBHASA PRODUKTO NG BRAINWASHED
The Christianity is not native, not the people who became converts. My lolo was (nominally) a Catholic who settled in Basilan and married a Tausug. But he got along great with the other Muslims, perhaps because my lolo never went to church, would occasionally go to the mosque, and treated everyone as equals.
I wonder if you know that Islam, Hinduism and Buddhism was in the Philippines before Christianity?
US play a significant role in this
Thank you for sharing an ICC/IPs of Kiamba Cotabato now Sarangani. We wish that our "Native Title" be recognize and respected now.
We love you Phillipines ❤
thank you Pnoy ❤
Nah
@@sionc1372 nah as in you want Bangsamoro to still be part of the whole Philippines? Or nah kasi you just a hater. Wala akong opinyon sa mga presiden, gusto ko lang malaman. Well, my only opinion is that peace is good…
@@user-fy7hx9gd6u nahh
@@user-fy7hx9gd6u nah
Nice one-sided reporting. The Ilaga was originally formed to fight the abusive land owning families in Central Mindanao. But when mulsim rebels began harassing Christian farming communities, the Ilagas were hired to counter them.
And also, Mindanao doesn't belong to the Muslim population only because even before the Spaniards came, a huge part of it has been populated by non-muslim natives, many of which allied themselves with the Spaniards.
Mga paniniwala yan sa Muslim dahil sa religion,nag,tangatangahan sila dahil sa religion walang religion Mindanao maraming tribe na ang naka tira sa Mindanao walang karapatan ang religion ang,kinin ang Mindanao,ang Mindanao para sa mga pilipino hindi para sa Muslim at christian.
Nah.
the name itself tells, "Land Grabbing". Bottomline, whatever side you're on never forget that ILAGA are from VISAYAS/LUZON. So it means settlers, so it means land grabbers.
Nope. Ilaga just means "rat" in vernacular, referring to the field rats that feed on palay and mais, a perfect representative of poor farmers who were just seeking a good and peaceful life. These farmers had to defend themselves from continuous harassment from land-owning clans from Maguindanao and Cotabato. The "land grabber" moniker was given to them by the pissed muslim rebels, who came later into the picture, when they found out that the settlers and some natives such as the Teduray had bonded together to defend themselves.
ilonggo vs moro, habol vs habol hahahah
Do they post this in Facebook?
Mindanao rich of natural resources
Perhaps FILIPINOS should also know MORO HISTORY way before 1521.. Here’s what we have: MOROS in Sulu | The ORIGIN STORY
ua-cam.com/video/C7zMHoCIf0E/v-deo.html
The documentary is educational and well done. The resource speakers are good especially Mastura. The women are the best part. But it looked suspicious as promo for Pinoy Aquino. The major players in history of peace were not mentioned - Misuari, Fr Mercado. The Jabidah Massacre like what happenef in Manili during Marcos was the worst in history of conflict. The best president who came closest to peace was not Cory, not Pinoy, it was Fiidel Ramos. The documentary is only one small window. Hence not significant.
This is just one side of the story. The second side is yet to be seen or created in a video like this. MILF came after the Marcos regime.
The problem is the government
The SC was right. You can’t divide our Philippine territory.
You didn’t know the whole story of the Buliok war.
Nope im from Maguindanao and this people just made it worst.
One sided report favoring Aquino Jr.
Malaysia actively supported this insurgency.
So what? They supported us because we are brothers in religion lol
As a Filipino. It is better for us to have prime minister in every main islands. Luzon, Visayas, Mindanao and Bansangmoro region. Because us from Luzon shouldered so much money and resources just to develop Mindanao. Imagine no investors wanted to make business there. Mabuti pa sa Visayas andyan ang Cebu-iloilo na center ng kalakalan.
Ferdinand Marcos pushed for Christian Settlers from Luzon & Visayas to move to Mindanao.. This was a very big error as it created tension & killings between these 2 communities.
Nope. Christian settlements already happened before that. Don't tell us that Vicente Duterte, Gaudencio Antonino, Romeo Jalosjos, Jose Zubiri just moved to Mindanao during the First Marcos Presidency.
Know your facts first.
it actually started during pres.Magsaysay administrstion
@@regorflora7915 Know your history. STarted in Spanish Era. Christians emerge in Spanish time occupation
Christians are already in Mindanao since the Spanish Era. Muslims fought for resistance as the Spanish with its Christians soldiers tried to expand its foothold in Mindanao Island capturing muslim territories and displacement of muslim population. The muslims managed to hold its last stronghold due to support of muslim sultenates such as the Ottoman Empire who has its diplomatic support to contain the spread of Christianity in the island led by the Spanish Crown. It was the Americans who let the resettlement of Christian Filipinos after they successfully contain the uprisings and strip local rulers like the Sultan of Sulu of its power does cementing American sovereignty in moro lands. It was then continued with the succeeding administration.
@@reinpinebook825check those people that you mentioned and tell me where they were born.
As a Mindanawon it was Duterte who change Mindanao fyi
at least give credit to Malaysia and ex prime minister Najib Razak effort toward peace in Philippines.
If you cant beat them surrender, peace process lol, if not bang bang government wins
This documentary is one sided. Even before this attack of the afp there, during cease fire moro rebels are bombing police station, Christian villages, markets even during Christmas not only in Mindanao but the rebels brought these crimes in Luzon. Intercepting and ambushing army troupe and those who survived were being beheaded during cease fire. MILF recruitment yes but you fail to include the massive abduction of young boys in villages and coercing to join the rebel groups. All of these can easily be obtain if you just did your research. You even left out the part that moro rebels resort to kidnap for ransom to fund their rebel army. That's the very reason why until now many local and foreign tourist are still reluctant to go in Mindanao. You would argue that these atrocities are done by Islamic terrorist well it was proven they are incahoots with MILF. The real turning point why these learned Muslim leaders cooperate was when they take seat in government they saw the disparity in progress in Luzon and Mindanao. That is their rebellious mentality will not gain them investments. Another vital person you left out is Nur Misuari the founder of MNLF and why Iqbal break away from MNLF and formed MILF, And the reason you did this is because you'll have to present real purpose of MNLF and MILF. You failed also to include the reason why these people made an agreement with the government, is due to the fact that all Muslim/Islamic rebel groups in Mindanao are declared nothing but a terrorist groups by all international agencies.
ang dami mong dada TAE!!!! KAYO ANG ONE SIDED STUPID!!!! KAYO NANG AGAW AT MARAMING PINATAY NAG AAKUSA KAPA KAMI PA MASAMA PUNYETA KA BABOY!!!! PA ISRAEL KAPA ACT KAPA PUNYETA KA KAYO ANG MGA MASASAM PUNYETA NANG AAGAW HINDI NIYO PAG AARI POKE INA MONG BABOY KA ASO!!!! PAKITA MO SARILI MO SA AKIN OARA MAISAMPAL KO SAYO ANG TOTO PUNYETA KA PATI ISLAM DNDALA MO SA KABUBUHAN MO POKE INA MO BABOY!!! ANUNG KINALAMAN NG PAGIGING MUSLIM AT ISLAM NAMIN POTA KA KAYO NAG SIMULA LAHAT NG MGA GULONG ITO HINDI KAMI POKE INA BABIY
U better understand the title itself
MNLF SAY MINDANAO FOR EVERYONE
BUT
THEY WANT GENIUINE AUTONOMY
ITS A LOTS OF BS!!!!
Not entire Mindanao only in Muslim area
Epsode 3..
WHAT PEACE?
Filipinos and Moros are brothers
@@robzonefire without lies Islam will dies!
Bakit kasi naging Muslim yung Mindanao..nagkaroon tuloy ng conflict
Ha ? Tanga ka? Sino ba nanggulo dito dati diba mga spaniol? Muslim ba sila? Pinagtanggol ng mga Moro ang Mindanao hnd tulad ng mga taga Luzon at Visayas na nagpaka puta sa Spaniol.
@@abdulfatahpandita1565 tama namn kahit kaylan hndi nagpa talo Ang Mindanao sa dayuhan di katulan Luzon at Visayas tuta ng iBang bansa
Mag basa ka ng history ng Pilipinas wag Kang Tanga dahil sa Marcos nayan na buo Ang mga grupo Dito tapos Sabihin mo magulo mga Muslim eh Anong dapat Gawin namin papatayin nalng ng walang laban bubu kaba
Do documentary on cpp npa pls
Sayang yung Mindanao maraming gustong pumunta jan kaso nakakatakot dahil sa mga rebelde
cry harder
PNoy Legacy.
This film should be shared in classrooms, diff arenas of learning instead of all these nonsense HOR/Senate hearings broadcast. Its about resolving conflicts. Coming together for peace in the Country. We are all Filipinos.
As a Christian, I am disgusted on how our government treating our Muslim brothers & sisters. What make the situation even worst is that how military are brainwashed by Americans. Our Muslim brothers and sisters deserves to have an autonomous government in order to have peace in Mindanao.
When Muslims defend their own land its automatically called Terrorism, you failed to mention also when Ilagas or Ilocano's migrated in Moroland during FEM days, they relentlessly killed and stole many local moro lands.. you should study history and the root cause of everything..Moro land was never part of Philippines to begin with, they never surrendered to the spanish.. and forced to be part of the Philippines
They should be relocated to a remote island where they rule on themselves and separated from the rest of the world.
The war was imported to us by the foreign occupation. And we inherent it, by debiding us tru religion. Im belong to millinials generation of Christian and im from Mindanao..but when i go around, i will go as Filipinos or simpling Mindanawon .making friends and talking to others faith with respect.
Then you do not understand your faith and you are playing safe. Cowardice.
The muslims brought the war in Mindanao.
If you did your research, MNLF is not a terrorist organization. It's an organized military in mindanao that protects mindanao from injustice.
They have their own definition of injustice. All those against their goals and plans are injustice. MNLF and MILF have the same membership. They only made two seemingly different terrorist organizations to confuse the public and lobby support.
Sure kayo si Pnoy ang nagdala peace dito sa amin lupain mindanao?😂😂😂
Im a mindanaoan but viewing from episode its the governmemt who double the MNLF
Hindi siya ang nagdala kabayan; pero Hindi mapag kaila ang genuine intention and pagpapakumbaba nya. Remember some of his military advisors felt uncomfortable with the meeting. He was the one to set his foot down to say (from malacanang) “this is the way to peace”
without lies Islam will dies
Quran chapter 47 verse 35, So be not weak and ask NOT for PEACE ( from the enemies of ISLAM ), while you are having the upper hand. ALLAH is with you and will never decrease the reward of your good deeds...please help us to understand this verse?
That’s why islam doctrine is evil. They have written it to deceive people.
Chapter of Anfal Verse 61
But if they incline towards peace, then incline towards it [also] and put your trust in Allah. Indeed, He is the All-Hearing, the All-Knowing
Lol. Read with arabic. Not with translation
The traitor is PNOY father