I like the Jim Carrey Grinch movie but I would definitely take the Chuck Jones animated version over it any holiday. Also it's so strange how they all picked the Jim Carrey version when at the time critics hated that movie.
Is this whole video a remake? I swear I've already seen it! Also, Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle is a sequel, not a remake. It starts with the board game turning itself into a videogame so Alex will play it; inside the game, Alex acknowledges that the hideout he's using was built by Alan Parrish, Robin Williams' character in the 1995 movie.
Jamanji with the Rock is not a remake, its a continuation of the series. The film is the third installment in the Jumanji film series and a stand-alone sequel to Jumanji.
Jumanji Welcome to the Jungle is a sequel not a remake, and we know this for sure because Bebe Neuwirth reprises her role as the aunt from the first movie in Jumanji The Next Level which came out in 2019.
How could anyone choose the new Grinch? So sad... And yes, the remake was good. (Just think they worked too hard to stretch it to a full movie) But the original Grinch!!! The song! Boris Karloff!!! Perfect!!!
Jumanji 2017 was not a remake pople, do your research. There is a scene in the 2017 movie when they are in the tree house that Alex lives in and you see a carving of Alans name from 1995s Jumanji that he was there which makes 2017 a continuation.
Yeah If they had called it a Reboot then that would be closer. Definitely not a remake as you say the treehouse and a few other things clearly shows this is a continuation of the original story.
don't think the Jumanji's are a remake just a continued story years apart due to them having the board game turn into the video game and Alan Perish being mentioned
you are right. It's the sequel that they call the remake in this. You can clearly see at the end of the first movie that they dump it in the ocean and at the start of the second one it is found at the beach.
You people are confused. The 1954 A Star is Born with Judy Garland was not the original, it was a remake. The original was 1937 with Janet Gaynor. And there was a second remake in 1976 with Barbra Streisand before the third one with Lady Gaga.
Jumanji is a sequel not a remake, so you can't give it a fair comparison. Both are great movies, completely different from each other. Robin Williams is always iconic. But the sequels have a "Freaky Friday" body switching element, which they all do a great job with (but especially Jack Black). Of the ones I've seen: Parent Trap - Original Freaky Friday - tie - this one is really too close to call The Grinch - original Charlie's Angels - remake I haven't seen the remake of Willie Wonka, but there's no way it beats the original. Haven't seen either of the rest of the movies.
The original Parent Trap was _mostly_ Haley Mills. However during over the shoulder shots there was a body double. She has a recent video talking about it on UA-cam, it's a really sweet video, talking about how great it was and I loved how Walt Disney was called Uncle Walt by all the kids.
2 things to take away from this video. 1 Jumanji is not a remake it's a sequel. 2 Star Wars was not inspired by Dune. George Lucas had 4 inspirations when he made Star Wars, Akira Kurosawa movies, WWII airplane dogfights, John Carter of Mars , and Flash Gordon.
Technically, the 1954 version of "A Star is Born," starring Judy Garland, is NOT the original. There was also one from 1937 (and another from 1976, starring Barbra Streisand).
Charlie's Angels the original movie (which they should have mentioned was a remake of an older show) was so fun. If anything you gotta give it to Sam Rockwell dancing 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
When it comes to Charlies Angels, I prefer the original tv series with Kate Jackson, Farrah Fawcett and Jacqueline Smith. As a child of the 70's I the actual originals
Adaptation. A remake has to be with the same culture. An adaptation is taking a movie from a certain culture and transform into the new culture,changing half of the OG or even most parts !!!
I chose the Original for the ones I saw: "Parent Trap", "Jumanji" (Robin Williams?!! Come on!), "Freaky Friday", "Mean Girls", "Willy Wonka" (Gene Wilder is way better.)
Facts! I mentioned this before the original was from the 30's and they also remade it in the 70's with Barbara Striesand. I swear these guys never learn or read the comments or do proper research.
Jumanji and Charlie’s Angels are NOT remakes they’re long distance sequels because in Jumanji you see “Alan Parrish was here” meaning that’s the jungle Alan had to wait 26 years in in the 1995 movie and in Charlie’s Angels when retiring Bosley they’re showing old photos of him with the 2000 movie cast. So how about creating a video to do with movies that have a long distance sequel.
You can't say that Jumanji from 2017 is a remake of Jumanji 1995, a remake would have the same story line with just a few things different and both of the Jumanji's have a different story line in my opinion.
YALL remember when they made a Sci-Fi version of Jumanji with Josh Hutcherson and Kristen Stewart. I feel like no one takes about Zathura. Nor do I think people know it’s in the same universe as Jumanji
Okay the 2017 Jumanji wasn't a REMAKE it was like a sequel to the original. If you look it up it's not a remake it's a sequel. There was a Disney Channel Original Movie that was Freaky Friday as well. I wouldn't count 2023 Mean Girls as a remake, because it was a movie based on the broadway musical so it's not a remake.
Yes! The new movie is an adaptation of the Broadway musical, not a "remake" of the movie from the 2000s. The same with The Color Purple that came out recently
U guys clearly dont pay attention to the movies cyz Charlie's angels is not a remake its a continuation. They clearly connect that film to every Charlie's angels show and movies together so its not a remake
I know this is old, but can't belive i didn't comment on this before. Original or remake, for Charlie's Angels it's a series yes, but i think it should've been there. It's the ultimate OG.
14:05 I really liked the cgi remake of the grinch. No matter how much I love the musical aspect of the new version, the OG mean girls is where it's at. OG tv show of Charlie's angels 😊
I have to write that if you're comparing Willy and charlie, you have to take into account that tim burton's actually had more of the book in it than the original, but I'd still side with gene wilder
The actress that plays "aunt vive" in tthe 1998 remake of Parent trap plays the evil "stepmother" in the original parent trap. Just a littel fun fact for you guys.
Parent Trap -- the mom on the original played the mother-in-law in the remake. Dune -- the 1984 version was bad, 2021 version was good, 2000 version was better.
Despite the Jumanji sequels being scene as sequels, tonally they’re very different from the 1995 original which feels very much like a fantasy coming of age adventure vs the more comedic leaning sequels.
Only thing is with Jumanji the 2017 version was a continuation not a remake cuz it references the original. Then changes the board game into the vid games to fit modern times. Cool reations though.
Jumanji isn’t a remake!!!!! It is a continuation. The place nick jonas lived in was Alan Shepard’s. It was supposed to be a continuation of the story because every time someone gets the game it evolves. Plus I feel like I saw this video already. If not someone else reviewed all these videos in the same order
Unpopular opinion: I actually liked Wonka. I went into Wonka hearing a bunch of people saying they hated it and it was horrible so I went in with zero expectations and I absolutely loved it, the colours, the performances, the candies being wild and zany, the songs. It reminded me so much of watching the original movie for the first time. Sure, the original is better, but I can 100% see Wonka being the origin story for Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory. Timothy just seemed to be having so much fun and seemed like he was enjoying himself in the role. It FELT like Gene Wilder's Willy Wonka but younger to me.
The Parent Trap, the Remake because i haven't seen the Original Jumanji , obviously the Original but the Remake is still good in it's own way Dune , haven't seen Both but plan to A star is born, haven't seen Both and don't plan to Freaky Friday, only seen the remake but Original still looks good The Grinch, the Remake because Jim Carry Mean Girls, didn't care Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, remake because Jhonny Depp and Tim Burton Charlie's Angels, Original
Interesting to me. You are the first person I’ve ever heard say they would choose the Charlie and the Chocolate Factory remake but I’m 47 and grew up with the original.
I said that under original video, i'm gonna say it here too. Original animated Grinch was supposed to be compared to animated movie by Illumination studio, not the life action one. Or you coukd show them all 3 options.
First off, the OG parent trap was better as it had sequels Secondly, Jumanji shouldn't be on here as it was a sequel (soft reboot). As for A Star is Born, your OG was NOT the OG as that was from 1937 with Janet Gaynor. Yes, I love Judy Garland, but that was not the OG version. And why was the 2018 (the most recent version) not used for Freaky Friday?
The Grinch comparisons are not fair. The OG was made as a hand drawn animated, thirty minute tv show on a very limited budget. The remake was designed as a full length feature film with multi-million dollar backing. If they are going to compare things at least have the two in the same ball park.
I was thinking this, there was a Grinch animated movie that was fairly recent tho, so they could've used that for comparison instead of the Jim Carrey one
The newer Jumanji isn't a remake, it's a sequel.
What how? Did I miss something?
Edit: idk that seems a little loose going off the start but I guess it is? Idk I prefer thinking of it as seperate
Yeah the new one shows the old board game in references is Robin Williams's character from the original.
Yup. They even visit the “house that Parrish built” in Jumanji.
Yes sequel. Not a remake.
I think everyone has forgotten about Zathura
Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle is NOT a remake, it's meant to be a sequel. It doesn't belong on this list.
It is a requel, part remake, part sequel.
I like the Jim Carrey Grinch movie but I would definitely take the Chuck Jones animated version over it any holiday.
Also it's so strange how they all picked the Jim Carrey version when at the time critics hated that movie.
Charlie's Angels is originally a TV show and ran between 1976 and 1981.
Is this whole video a remake? I swear I've already seen it!
Also, Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle is a sequel, not a remake. It starts with the board game turning itself into a videogame so Alex will play it; inside the game, Alex acknowledges that the hideout he's using was built by Alan Parrish, Robin Williams' character in the 1995 movie.
it start where it left off from the 1st one
Jamanji with the Rock is not a remake, its a continuation of the series. The film is the third installment in the Jumanji film series and a stand-alone sequel to Jumanji.
Jumanji Welcome to the Jungle is a sequel not a remake, and we know this for sure because Bebe Neuwirth reprises her role as the aunt from the first movie in Jumanji The Next Level which came out in 2019.
I keep wondering why they keep doing this?! They should know by now that it's a squeal and not a remake.
How could anyone choose the new Grinch? So sad...
And yes, the remake was good. (Just think they worked too hard to stretch it to a full movie)
But the original Grinch!!! The song! Boris Karloff!!! Perfect!!!
@@desiv1170 Perfection indeed!
"It" really deserved a spot on this list.
I dispute jumangi. It's not a remake, it's a continuation. That's why the hut had Robin's characters name on it.
Jumanji 2017 was not a remake pople, do your research. There is a scene in the 2017 movie when they are in the tree house that Alex lives in and you see a carving of Alans name from 1995s Jumanji that he was there which makes 2017 a continuation.
Yeah If they had called it a Reboot then that would be closer. Definitely not a remake as you say the treehouse and a few other things clearly shows this is a continuation of the original story.
don't think the Jumanji's are a remake just a continued story years apart due to them having the board game turn into the video game and Alan Perish being mentioned
you are right. It's the sequel that they call the remake in this. You can clearly see at the end of the first movie that they dump it in the ocean and at the start of the second one it is found at the beach.
@@Excanda Alans name from 1995 movie is also carved in the tree house showing its a sequel
*Alan Parrish 😁
@@ExcandaI agree
Jumanji is not a remake
Not even a single mention of ROBIN WILLIAMS in Jumanji? Shame!!!
You people are confused. The 1954 A Star is Born with Judy Garland was not the original, it was a remake. The original was 1937 with Janet Gaynor. And there was a second remake in 1976 with Barbra Streisand before the third one with Lady Gaga.
Should have showed scene for scene. In the Dune comparison, both movies have that same fight scene.
Jumanji is a sequel not a remake, so you can't give it a fair comparison. Both are great movies, completely different from each other. Robin Williams is always iconic. But the sequels have a "Freaky Friday" body switching element, which they all do a great job with (but especially Jack Black).
Of the ones I've seen:
Parent Trap - Original
Freaky Friday - tie - this one is really too close to call
The Grinch - original
Charlie's Angels - remake
I haven't seen the remake of Willie Wonka, but there's no way it beats the original. Haven't seen either of the rest of the movies.
I wish they had matched scenes so the comparisons would be more equitable.
The original Grinch will always be the Best in my opinion..... 💯💯💯💯💯💯
The original Parent Trap was _mostly_ Haley Mills. However during over the shoulder shots there was a body double. She has a recent video talking about it on UA-cam, it's a really sweet video, talking about how great it was and I loved how Walt Disney was called Uncle Walt by all the kids.
The original "Star is Born" is from 1937 not the fantastic 1954 (first Remake).
That is what I was trying to say and need to show that version & all the other ones to show how many versions of “A Star Is Born” there is
2 things to take away from this video. 1 Jumanji is not a remake it's a sequel. 2 Star Wars was not inspired by Dune. George Lucas had 4 inspirations when he made Star Wars, Akira Kurosawa movies, WWII airplane dogfights, John Carter of Mars , and Flash Gordon.
Hayley Mills all the way!
Technically, the 1954 version of "A Star is Born," starring Judy Garland, is NOT the original. There was also one from 1937 (and another from 1976, starring Barbra Streisand).
@@italianviking80 I'm not sure if they were saying that one was the original since they mentioned there were several versions.
@@3DJapan the video is called 'original vs remake' - guess they think it is.
Jumanji 2017 was a sequel
How do I remember watching this but it was uploaded 4 hours ago and I didn’t watch it today
Everyone is right Jumanji is a sequel.
The Grinch remake can't hold a Christmas candle to the original. Sorry, Jim.
Charlie's Angels the original movie (which they should have mentioned was a remake of an older show) was so fun. If anything you gotta give it to Sam Rockwell dancing 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
I have to say, on the Parent Trap, Lindsay Logan’s Characters came up with some REALLY inventive things!
Jumanji was technically a sequel, not a remake.
looking for this comment. thanks
When it comes to Charlies Angels, I prefer the original tv series with Kate Jackson, Farrah Fawcett and Jacqueline Smith. As a child of the 70's I the actual originals
That’s not the original A star is born,the original is from 1937.
Came here to say this!!!
@@MaireGraves I am probably not the only one.
I have told them before
Yeah, you can't beat the original Grinch.
"The Parent Trap" from 1961 was already a remake of the original "Das doppelte Lottchen" from the German children's book author Erich Kästner. 😂
Adaptation. A remake has to be with the same culture. An adaptation is taking a movie from a certain culture and transform into the new culture,changing half of the OG or even most parts !!!
I chose the Original for the ones I saw: "Parent Trap", "Jumanji" (Robin Williams?!! Come on!), "Freaky Friday", "Mean Girls", "Willy Wonka" (Gene Wilder is way better.)
Again this _Star Is Born_ is not the original, but it is often seen as the original.
Facts! I mentioned this before the original was from the 30's and they also remade it in the 70's with Barbara Striesand. I swear these guys never learn or read the comments or do proper research.
Jumanji and Charlie’s Angels are NOT remakes they’re long distance sequels because in Jumanji you see “Alan Parrish was here” meaning that’s the jungle Alan had to wait 26 years in in the 1995 movie and in Charlie’s Angels when retiring Bosley they’re showing old photos of him with the 2000 movie cast.
So how about creating a video to do with movies that have a long distance sequel.
You can't say that Jumanji from 2017 is a remake of Jumanji 1995, a remake would have the same story line with just a few things different and both of the Jumanji's have a different story line in my opinion.
They even referred to Robin’s character in the treehouse
YALL remember when they made a Sci-Fi version of Jumanji with Josh Hutcherson and Kristen Stewart. I feel like no one takes about Zathura. Nor do I think people know it’s in the same universe as Jumanji
Hot take: I like Zathura more than the OG Jumanji 😬 I used to be so in love with Josh Hutcherson as a kid!
Zathura was another book by Chris Van Allsburg (who also wrote Polar Express)
Okay the 2017 Jumanji wasn't a REMAKE it was like a sequel to the original. If you look it up it's not a remake it's a sequel. There was a Disney Channel Original Movie that was Freaky Friday as well. I wouldn't count 2023 Mean Girls as a remake, because it was a movie based on the broadway musical so it's not a remake.
Let’s talk about how there is no understanding that the original Mean Girls was cinematic and the new one is more like the Broadway musical 😩
Yes! The new movie is an adaptation of the Broadway musical, not a "remake" of the movie from the 2000s. The same with The Color Purple that came out recently
Yeah, a lot of people don't seem to realize that.
U guys clearly dont pay attention to the movies cyz Charlie's angels is not a remake its a continuation. They clearly connect that film to every Charlie's angels show and movies together so its not a remake
you should have done the same character for the Dune comparison ... Kyle MacLachlan was excellent
A sequel is *not* a remake!!! Come on!
The fact that 3 Lindsey Lohan movies were in here
You should have shared the same scenes. You always showed the stars in the remake, which clearly influenced their choices
Jumanji (2017) was a sequel.
I know this is old, but can't belive i didn't comment on this before. Original or remake, for Charlie's Angels it's a series yes, but i think it should've been there. It's the ultimate OG.
THIS VIDEO IS THE REMAKE!!!
Haven't they put this out as a video before? Like on the main channel
I second that. I can't recall when, but I know they've uploaded it before.
Yep, I've seen this before.
jumanji 2017 is NOT A REMAKE.
14:05 I really liked the cgi remake of the grinch.
No matter how much I love the musical aspect of the new version, the OG mean girls is where it's at.
OG tv show of Charlie's angels 😊
The remake of Mean Girls wasn't that good. The original was so iconic!
The “remake” is just a movie version of the musical, so not really a remake
@@TheErnestoRos Ah I see.
Would have been better if you had shown similar scenes, cant make an educated descision on what was seen here.
Is this video a replay? I think I saw this last month.
I have to write that if you're comparing Willy and charlie, you have to take into account that tim burton's actually had more of the book in it than the original, but I'd still side with gene wilder
Jumanji 2017 wasn’t a remake, it played tribute to Robin Williams character.
Came to say this also!
@@MelissaWyatt-z2k I would say there is evidence it might be a sequel to the animated series rather than the movie.
People always mistaken it as a remake. It’s a rebooted sequel, there’s a difference.
The OG parent trap was so much better than the Lindsay Lohan one. I was so pissed when they remade it. Haley Mills FOREVER!
I quote "Oh, I'm like the cryptkeeper" RELIGIOUSLY
Star Wars "A New Hope" was a book also, and George Lucus wrote it himself. Also all of the movies and more have been turned into books and comics...
Not quite. It was ghostwritten by Alan Dean Foster.
It's a novelization of the movie.
The actress that plays "aunt vive" in tthe 1998 remake of Parent trap plays the evil "stepmother" in the original parent trap.
Just a littel fun fact for you guys.
On IMDB I saw that the actress Joanna Barnes played Vicky Robinson in "Parent Trap" 1961, and Vicki Blake in "Parent Trap"- 1998. Who's "Aunt Vive"??
@@jenniferhanson3671in the Lindsay Lohan one she tells Hallie (Annie in disguise) she can call her Aunt Vicky
@@savannahryan91 I saw that on IMDB quotes.. the original said "Aunt Vive" not Aunt Vicki, that's why I was confused.
jodie foster would have been 14 and she did taxi driver the same year
Parent Trap -- the mom on the original played the mother-in-law in the remake.
Dune -- the 1984 version was bad, 2021 version was good, 2000 version was better.
Omg…ok I cannot with the dune pick seriously the ammount of false info there 🤣🤣🤣
Despite the Jumanji sequels being scene as sequels, tonally they’re very different from the 1995 original which feels very much like a fantasy coming of age adventure vs the more comedic leaning sequels.
Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle was a not a remake, it was a reboot in the style of a sequel.
How come y’all never do Grinch 1966 , Grinch 2000 , & Grinch 2018??? Y’all never mention Grinch 2018!????
The original Parent Trap was sooo much better.
Actually the original Charlie's Angels is the one from the 70's with Farah Fawcett, Jacquelin Smith and Kate Jackson.
The television series.
They did a remake of Mean Girls? That is one of those movies that you should never remake.
it's an adaptation of the Broadway musical. The Broadway show is great but the film adaptation was pretty poor.
Only thing is with Jumanji the 2017 version was a continuation not a remake cuz it references the original. Then changes the board game into the vid games to fit modern times. Cool reations though.
I argue that "Zathura" is a "Jumanji" Remake... xD
I love Johnny Depp but I can't even watch the Charlie and the chocolate factory 😢
Jumanji isn’t a remake!!!!! It is a continuation. The place nick jonas lived in was Alan Shepard’s. It was supposed to be a continuation of the story because every time someone gets the game it evolves.
Plus I feel like I saw this video already. If not someone else reviewed all these videos in the same order
Hailey Mills was such a better actress than Lindsay Lohan, her smile shrug disney thing kept happening in this scene over and over (parent trap).
I totally agree with you
I also whole-heartedly agree
The original Parent Trap is better in my opinion...... And, the original Jumanji will always be the Best!! 💯💯💯💯💯
Unpopular opinion: I actually liked Wonka. I went into Wonka hearing a bunch of people saying they hated it and it was horrible so I went in with zero expectations and I absolutely loved it, the colours, the performances, the candies being wild and zany, the songs. It reminded me so much of watching the original movie for the first time. Sure, the original is better, but I can 100% see Wonka being the origin story for Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory. Timothy just seemed to be having so much fun and seemed like he was enjoying himself in the role. It FELT like Gene Wilder's Willy Wonka but younger to me.
I tried to watch the remake of Mean Girls, the original Mean Girls is better. I did not care for the remake being a musical.
Original Grinch for the win.
Seriously.. anyone voting for the remake has no taste.
I tried watching the remake once and ut gave me a headache. I much prefer the original with Boris Karloff.
Jumanji Welcome to the Jungle is a sequel not a remake.
The Parent Trap, the Remake because i haven't seen the Original
Jumanji , obviously the Original but the Remake is still good in it's own way
Dune , haven't seen Both but plan to
A star is born, haven't seen Both and don't plan to
Freaky Friday, only seen the remake but Original still looks good
The Grinch, the Remake because Jim Carry
Mean Girls, didn't care
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, remake because Jhonny Depp and Tim Burton
Charlie's Angels, Original
Interesting to me. You are the first person I’ve ever heard say they would choose the Charlie and the Chocolate Factory remake but I’m 47 and grew up with the original.
I love the new Jimanji movies but that og one is just what makes the series what it is and it’s so cool on its own I love the og so much
7:56 1954’s ‘A Star Is Born’ is NOT THE ORIGINAL version! The video acknowledges there are 4 versions but calls the 2nd one the original. 🙄
Also Lindsay Lohan sweeping with every version !!!!! Top tier.
Original on everything..except possibly Freaky Friday because the remake was funnier abd Jumanji because it was a sequel not a remake.
What about the original Charlie's Angeles (1976)?
I said that under original video, i'm gonna say it here too. Original animated Grinch was supposed to be compared to animated movie by Illumination studio, not the life action one. Or you coukd show them all 3 options.
straight up pausing intro .... if the Dune miniseries won't be mentioned... imma flip the table :D
Omg deja vu I thought I seen this video a few weeks ago!
Yeah they now reuplode any new video only after a few weeks
Hailey Mills in the OG Parent Trap
I totally agree with you & they need to watch the original The Parent Trap
1954 "A Star is Born" is itself a remake. Who make your list????
First off, the OG parent trap was better as it had sequels
Secondly, Jumanji shouldn't be on here as it was a sequel (soft reboot).
As for A Star is Born, your OG was NOT the OG as that was from 1937 with Janet Gaynor. Yes, I love Judy Garland, but that was not the OG version.
And why was the 2018 (the most recent version) not used for Freaky Friday?
There is another version of A Star is Born before the Judy Garland one.
There is also a remade version between Judy Garland and Lady Gaga starring Barbara Streisdand
DEFF OG Parent Trap
The original Dune is way better!!!
I am so disappointed that Hairspray was not on here that is my favorite movie
Charlie's angels original is actually a t.v show. Compare to the tv show
That is what I wanted & they should shown the Original version of “A Star Is Born” from the 30’s
You didn't compare the same scene in Dune where they are fighting with the shields on. How can you compare?
If he has really never seen anything with Julie Garland, you are now obligated to do a reaction to The Wizard of Oz, having them watch the full movie.
The Grinch comparisons are not fair. The OG was made as a hand drawn animated, thirty minute tv show on a very limited budget. The remake was designed as a full length feature film with multi-million dollar backing. If they are going to compare things at least have the two in the same ball park.
I was thinking this, there was a Grinch animated movie that was fairly recent tho, so they could've used that for comparison instead of the Jim Carrey one