Seeing my game featured scared me half to death. But shoot yeah, looking over the trailer for my game I do realize that I added WAY TO MUCH glitching effects for transitions xP but it's interesting about adding in game audio as "flavor crystals" definitely like that one. Also need to just show pure gameplay or pure text so it's not to overstimulating, and then the last bit about just showing one or two social media channels is a God send. I'll take it all to heart and work on making my marketing skills better! :D
Wow thank you for so much for checking out our trailer Jonas! We appreciate the feedback a whole lot and will use it to the best of our ability. It's an honor to be featured on your channel along with these other amazing indie games! Thanks, Not a Sailor Studios 👻
Oh yeah! I got lucky to get in, was worth waiting until the end. Thank you so much for featuring and the kind words. Some really great advice too, I think the thing I personally miss the most from indie game trailers is the SFX. Sound is 50% of the experience and devs seem to forget that way too often. Thanks again Jonas for inspiring us, can't wait for the next video.
Thanks for the feedback! (Mine was Anchor Up) I’ll definitely implement all of your suggestions in the next trailer I release! Really interesting video too, and the points about sound effects were useful too! Thanks!
Hmm, it's a little more like, "Imagine the people watching only have a fraction of a second to understand what's going on in a shot before the trailer starts a new idea."
Toveri yeah, you don’t want to talk down to your audience or explain things they’ll easily understand. It doesn’t feel good to be on the receiving end, and by calling out the mundane as worthy of calling out, it makes the game seem very very generic.
I've been a fan of Dani before he even started developing karlson, he inspired me to code but now i dont feel like doing it, but everytime i see him in a random video it makes me feel happy and makes me want to code again
Great video and an amazing surprise to see Derek involved! I was anticipating this Trailer review, but the inclusion of the Trailer-King makes it even better!
Actually in the Firewatch trailer, the beggining part was the worst one for me, it felt like he is playing with us and after he threw the fireworks, nothing really happent... They just tumbled aside. But the rest of the trailer was amazing, it had a form and the story and gameplay was nice.
Thank you so much Jonas and Derek for showing Mr Pips and giving feedback. Your video publishing timing was perfect, got to see and react to this live on stream this morning. Such an epic surprise! 😁 We will take this to heart! ♥️ Derek, we watched your channel for tips when making the video, made all the difference! 😁
At 39:50 he uses Untitled Goose Game as an example of a game that doesn't look really pretty but succeeded, and this was to explain that that was rare and not to expect it. I have an issue with this thinking because Untitled Goose Game does look appealing visually despite it's low poly style. The reason being that your graphics don't need to be the prettiest thing your audience has ever seen. Your graphics simply need to be visually appealing for the gameplay you're trying to make. It's a question of cinematography. Untitled Goose Game's graphics are gorgeous for a cartoon concept like playing a goose thief simulator which is what this game is designed to be. If you're not making a game that suits a lower poly visual style, then absolutely the art will hold your trailer back. The low poly and bold color aesthetic of Untitled Goose Game is not bad art or visuals. It's perfect art for that game concept and immediately sets the tone for the trailer. If you want to use low poly graphics, you need to match your gameplay to that same aesthetic.
Although my trailer didn't get featured, I can still learn from the feedback Jonas gave the other people and use these tips when I'm making the trailer for the game that I'm currently developing! :-)
33:00 This reminded me of a great GDC talk I saw about how you should "make the trailer before the game." At first it sounded ridiculous, but then when I tried it I realized how much it helps to focus on trailer content as early as possible. It gave me a small, concrete goal to work toward when it felt like there was so much to do as a solo dev. And more importantly, it helped take my disjointed ideas about the game and really solidify them into a coherent plan. Even if you never end up releasing that original draft of the trailer, I think every developer should at least plan it out at some point during pre-production. It makes you dial in on the most important aspects of the game, and can complement a GDD as a tool to keep you focused on the right stuff.
"Environments are only interesting if we know what's happening in them" This is very interesting. Because I've made similar arguments for films and film making. You see, without the characters and the plot of the film, what are we looking at exactly? An environment with some interesting events? World building is good, but only if you can do so while impacting the story you're trying to tell. So it seems that video games are not much different. Except in this case, your characters and stories equate to your gameplay. Fascinating.
@@DerekLieu Yep, just as some people forget that world building is only a part of what should be communicated in films. That's the very reason i ever even made that argument, because someone was arguing that the new starwars films are bad souly because there wasn't really any world building. And that is simply an incorrect perspective in my own opinion. But hey man i really appreciate you responding to my comments. :)
This was pretty informative, big thanks to Jonas and Derek. I'll check out his channel. :) And thanks to everyone who sent in trailers. It's much more helpful to see what can improve trailers when the trailers aren't all high budget productions. But seriously, how is that last game made by one person?
trailers are like the flavor packets on those little noodle cups where it gives a little bit of flavor to what the final product is and thats why i like video game trailers :)
I feel like some of the criticism of Buddy Simulator come from a perspective of a trailer judge that has seen way too many trailers and kinda wants them to be quicker and more blunt. My only criticism was text pacing. My perspective is skewed in the other direction. I don't watch ads or trailers. I watch movies and tv series sometimes. I don't seek trailers for movies I am planning to watch. I enjoyed the trailer on its own and that made me want to wishlist the game. Just my two cents. I'm not a trailer editor or a trailer enjoyer(?) so... Yeah. I respect the dude though. Good guest :] He made clear criticisms and made a good case for them.
@Jonas Tyroller In The room of 2 monsters trailer. The forest name means suicide in Slovenian (samomor = suicide). So, it's suicide forest. Maybe tell that to the dev, if it wasn't their intention.
*What will you do?* a) Applaud Callan for using his time wisely, +3 intelligence b) Scold Callan as that was time he may never get back, -1 willpower c) “Bonk” Callan on the head with your juice box, -2 intelligence +2 thirst [Destroy’s “Juice Box”]
That is awesome that you recognized it! It's the Dystopian Lead synth in the Flex plug in that comes with FL Studio. I thought it sounded nice for a Boss Theme so implemented it into that :)
OMG I remember playing a very early version of buddy simulator, didn't get far, got stuck early on in the text adventure part, it also was just text, no graphics, yes it had the emulation of a CRT but it was still just 100% text
The elevator thingie going down for the whole of the aterna trailer was really good! It shows the importance or mystery of the mechanic and is very cool'
NOO JONAS HE WASNT TALKING ABOUT THAT JUMP! He was talking about the second and third shotgun shot in the whole video. Also why is every section called buddy simulator 1984.
@@ManorLords Well good luck! It was a good trailer too! I only wish it had more details on gameplay. Because i noticed you seem to have a combat system taking inspiration from that of the likes of total war, or perhaps strongholds. Which is really what this game reminds me of the most by the trailer alone. In any case damn well done sir. :)
Super interesting video Jonas, enjoyed it a lot (except for the part where you exposed me for my 2-frame fail)
Hi Dani its my first time to be first
you are very hardworking. I like that about you Dani
DANI!!!! RESPOND ME PLS
Hi dadi
He is the real one, just click on his icon thing
Good game trailer: exists
Ads in the middle of it: I’m about to ruin this mans whole career
Ads were automatically placed by YT. Did it manually now so should be fixed I hope. Sorry about that :)
@@JonasTyroller oh ty for that lol there was one inside of dani's trailer before but thanks for fixing :D!
Jonas Tyroller it’s no problem, I was just joking lol. Love ur vids
@@spacecadet_01 I was on mobile lol and I have an app that doesn't have apps but I like to support jonas:D
ad in an ad. ADSEPTION
Game trailers are so essential to helping get games out there and I'm glad to see all the different styles of presenting games!
Yeah, it's insane how no trailer is like the other.
Yes
@@JonasTyroller hi
@@JonasTyroller Hi I'm Seth and I'm making a superhero smash bros like fighting game called xenomon and you can react to trailer if you want
Seeing my game featured scared me half to death. But shoot yeah, looking over the trailer for my game I do realize that I added WAY TO MUCH glitching effects for transitions xP but it's interesting about adding in game audio as "flavor crystals" definitely like that one. Also need to just show pure gameplay or pure text so it's not to overstimulating, and then the last bit about just showing one or two social media channels is a God send. I'll take it all to heart and work on making my marketing skills better! :D
Glad I could help!
Pog
Wow thank you for so much for checking out our trailer Jonas! We appreciate the feedback a whole lot and will use it to the best of our ability. It's an honor to be featured on your channel along with these other amazing indie games!
Thanks,
Not a Sailor Studios 👻
Not a Sailor Studios Buddy Simulator Low key looks sick, I might pick it up when it releases, congratulations!
I've seen Mark and Game Theory play it, looks good!
You know, Buddy Simulator 1984 can use a bit more spookiness because it is a *S P O O K Y M O N T H !*
Absolutely amazing trailer! Just started making sprites with intent of making a game. Definitely taking notes 📝
really impressed that Derek kept all critique focused exclusively on the trailers, not the games themselves. truly a master of their craft!
I was really thinking that. Really shows that no matter the game you can make a great trailer or an awful one
21:14 is when karlson trailer starts
Already in the description
*yes*
@@jnether0 lets be honest. Nobody uses the description unless they list the music.
@@ctrl_x1770 Boy I'm not sure you know the new feature in youtube but on mobile and maybe PC you get to split a video in parts using the description.
@@Exc4Iibur no like what music they used.
I liked Buddy Simulator 1984's trailer
Yeah. So did we. :D
I didn't like when the screen went full purple pinky with that rough sound
@@UnderfundedScientist yea, it was a bit weird.
@@UnderfundedScientist yeah that was a bit of a rough transition
@@UnderfundedScientist I quite liked it, actually. It reminded me of the couple times my DS Lite crashed, it would do exactly that.
He looked kinda sad when he reviewed karlson and found basically no mistakes
Oh yeah! I got lucky to get in, was worth waiting until the end. Thank you so much for featuring and the kind words. Some really great advice too, I think the thing I personally miss the most from indie game trailers is the SFX. Sound is 50% of the experience and devs seem to forget that way too often. Thanks again Jonas for inspiring us, can't wait for the next video.
Does it actually look (mostly) photoreal during gameplay, instead of just during the trailer?
The Karlson trailer was amazing. I VERY rarely ever feel any impact from one, even AAA stuff, and was quite impressed by the end of it.
He also makes games for android
Thanks for the feedback! (Mine was Anchor Up) I’ll definitely implement all of your suggestions in the next trailer I release! Really interesting video too, and the points about sound effects were useful too! Thanks!
Tl;dr: Imagine as if the people watching your trailer are toddlers
Exactly
Hmm, it's a little more like, "Imagine the people watching only have a fraction of a second to understand what's going on in a shot before the trailer starts a new idea."
Toveri yeah, you don’t want to talk down to your audience or explain things they’ll easily understand. It doesn’t feel good to be on the receiving end, and by calling out the mundane as worthy of calling out, it makes the game seem very very generic.
Same thing with menus
I've been a fan of Dani before he even started developing karlson, he inspired me to code but now i dont feel like doing it, but everytime i see him in a random video it makes me feel happy and makes me want to code again
Super useful tips and love seeing the breakdown. Definitely coming back to this when I'll be making a trailer!
Great video and an amazing surprise to see Derek involved!
I was anticipating this Trailer review, but the inclusion of the Trailer-King makes it even better!
lets just say it everyone was here for dani's trailer
*Yes*
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
This was awesome. I’ve been following dereks newsletter for quite some time. Great to see some in depth video content from him!
Actually in the Firewatch trailer, the beggining part was the worst one for me, it felt like he is playing with us and after he threw the fireworks, nothing really happent... They just tumbled aside.
But the rest of the trailer was amazing, it had a form and the story and gameplay was nice.
Haha oh well. I’m glad you liked the rest of it 😅
It would've been funny if the trailer right before was that FIreworks Mania game.
Yes, agree with this. Didn't really connect with the first part, it's kind of wasted space. After that though it's great.
Thank you so much Jonas and Derek for showing Mr Pips and giving feedback. Your video publishing timing was perfect, got to see and react to this live on stream this morning. Such an epic surprise! 😁
We will take this to heart! ♥️ Derek, we watched your channel for tips when making the video, made all the difference! 😁
I’m so happy to hear that!
Bro 69 likes N I C E.
I hope there will be more trailer reviews. Really useful video. Must agree that glitch effect on trailer #2 was too much.
At 39:50 he uses Untitled Goose Game as an example of a game that doesn't look really pretty but succeeded, and this was to explain that that was rare and not to expect it. I have an issue with this thinking because Untitled Goose Game does look appealing visually despite it's low poly style. The reason being that your graphics don't need to be the prettiest thing your audience has ever seen. Your graphics simply need to be visually appealing for the gameplay you're trying to make. It's a question of cinematography. Untitled Goose Game's graphics are gorgeous for a cartoon concept like playing a goose thief simulator which is what this game is designed to be. If you're not making a game that suits a lower poly visual style, then absolutely the art will hold your trailer back. The low poly and bold color aesthetic of Untitled Goose Game is not bad art or visuals. It's perfect art for that game concept and immediately sets the tone for the trailer. If you want to use low poly graphics, you need to match your gameplay to that same aesthetic.
the buddy trailer was a trailer that makes you want to play it to figure out the story and those kinds of trailers are really nice
Watched all the trailers and commentary. Wow, thanks for great analysis and awesome ideas, this video is extremely useful!
Although my trailer didn't get featured, I can still learn from the feedback Jonas gave the other people and use these tips when I'm making the trailer for the game that I'm currently developing! :-)
33:00 This reminded me of a great GDC talk I saw about how you should "make the trailer before the game." At first it sounded ridiculous, but then when I tried it I realized how much it helps to focus on trailer content as early as possible. It gave me a small, concrete goal to work toward when it felt like there was so much to do as a solo dev. And more importantly, it helped take my disjointed ideas about the game and really solidify them into a coherent plan.
Even if you never end up releasing that original draft of the trailer, I think every developer should at least plan it out at some point during pre-production. It makes you dial in on the most important aspects of the game, and can complement a GDD as a tool to keep you focused on the right stuff.
4:02 In my opinion the glitching is amazing. It fits so well with the transitions.
i absolutely hated it
Hahaha thank you man xD yeah I definitely should've toned it down though. But you live and you learn!
Thank you so much for this video. I'm glad I was able find Derek Lieu
I love how Derek didn't say that sound effects are highlights to background music, but they are.... and I quote.....
"Flavour Crystals"
lol, all my analogies are food related.
@@DerekLieu you sure do love your crystal "food" huh
Crab Game Trailer: *exists*
3:31 For one moment I thought that Derek Lieu was going to review the trailer for ,,Will you Snail?" because of that Font and Sound Effect.
Did you drink milk for the permission to use The legend's trailer?
No, I simply asked.
@@JonasTyroller for milk?
He a little confused but he got the spirit
@@JonasTyroller u probably do not understand what was Johni meaning,
*CRINGEE*
@@blk9365 he has perfectly understood what he meant.
That cat had my attention 100%
everything I was thinking watching the trailers they pointed out, so thats really cool to see how in touch with the audience Derek Lieu is
"Environments are only interesting if we know what's happening in them"
This is very interesting. Because I've made similar arguments for films and film making. You see, without the characters and the plot of the film, what are we looking at exactly? An environment with some interesting events? World building is good, but only if you can do so while impacting the story you're trying to tell.
So it seems that video games are not much different. Except in this case, your characters and stories equate to your gameplay.
Fascinating.
Yep, pretty much! Except some game trailers forget that character and story are only a part of what needs to be communicated.
@@DerekLieu Yep, just as some people forget that world building is only a part of what should be communicated in films. That's the very reason i ever even made that argument, because someone was arguing that the new starwars films are bad souly because there wasn't really any world building. And that is simply an incorrect perspective in my own opinion.
But hey man i really appreciate you responding to my comments. :)
Can't help but get hyped just by looking at the time codes and seeing what games you're going to review together with Derek Lieu.
Great video as always, really interesting to see some thoughts behind trailers in general! Thanks for taking a look at my game Scoot Kaboom :)
Your game looks awesome
I'm rewatching this for pointers. Thanks a lot!
This was pretty informative, big thanks to Jonas and Derek. I'll check out his channel. :) And thanks to everyone who sent in trailers. It's much more helpful to see what can improve trailers when the trailers aren't all high budget productions. But seriously, how is that last game made by one person?
Glad you enjoyed it, and I hope you like my channel! 😃
trailers are like the flavor packets on those little noodle cups where it gives a little bit of flavor to what the final product is
and thats why i like video game trailers :)
He has a great GDC talk! I gotta make a trailer for my devlog game someday XD Awesome tips!!
I feel like some of the criticism of Buddy Simulator come from a perspective of a trailer judge that has seen way too many trailers and kinda wants them to be quicker and more blunt.
My only criticism was text pacing. My perspective is skewed in the other direction. I don't watch ads or trailers. I watch movies and tv series sometimes. I don't seek trailers for movies I am planning to watch. I enjoyed the trailer on its own and that made me want to wishlist the game.
Just my two cents. I'm not a trailer editor or a trailer enjoyer(?) so... Yeah. I respect the dude though. Good guest :] He made clear criticisms and made a good case for them.
I was looking at the thumbnail and, i saw karlson so i watch it
lol same
same
Extremely helpful video!! This video will definitely help me through my journey in the future!
Thanks to this video, i'll surely be able to improve my game trailer ! And maybe one day, i'll get featured in a Jonas' video !
As if that were the ultimate achievement... :P
@@JonasTyroller it probably is!
@@JonasTyroller it really is :D
28:00
Jonas low key asking for a quote to make a trailer for will you snail
I love how this guy is confident about how normal it is to spend thousands of dollars on a game trailer
@Jonas Tyroller
In The room of 2 monsters trailer. The forest name means suicide in Slovenian (samomor = suicide). So, it's suicide forest. Maybe tell that to the dev, if it wasn't their intention.
there wasn’t a drum hit on the beat like every other part. There IS dissatisfaction on my end too.
dani: karlson out 2020/2021
2022: *is less than 3 months away*
dani: *chuckles* in in danger
The only thing I don't like about the karlson trailer is that the narrator says "meet billys brother" and then that's it
ZiggyZeg 2005 that isn't the narrator that is billy
What else is there to say about it
@@-loarado idk, like...Guns?
It just feels a bit abrupt
@@nikel1623 the narrator isnt named yet but Billy is the smell robot and Billy brother is big robot I dont want spoil the lore tho
Shut SHUT SHUT SHUT
Super helpful video, thanks a lot! Bookmarking this video as a resource when I will be making some trailers.
I know the exact synth and preset the "aeterna: into the void" trailer music was made on
*What will you do?*
a) Applaud Callan for using his time wisely, +3 intelligence
b) Scold Callan as that was time he may never get back, -1 willpower
c) “Bonk” Callan on the head with your juice box, -2 intelligence +2 thirst [Destroy’s “Juice Box”]
@@Alex-ih9lclol, I actually use the synth, and could just recognize it from using it often.
Wat synth is it and is it compatible with FL Studio?
That is awesome that you recognized it! It's the Dystopian Lead synth in the Flex plug in that comes with FL Studio. I thought it sounded nice for a Boss Theme so implemented it into that :)
Callan receives the following buff: +3 intelligence
What I want to know is, why is a trailer called a trailer, when the game is what trails the trailer?
You know... I was thinking about this video today and then it released.
Haha. Nice. :D
Buddy simulator 1984 trailer gave me goosebumps
OMG I remember playing a very early version of buddy simulator, didn't get far, got stuck early on in the text adventure part, it also was just text, no graphics, yes it had the emulation of a CRT but it was still just 100% text
I would have loved to see Derek review the Islanders Trailer, still super nice and informative Video!
Be honest, all of us only watched the Karlson review
I love the track at 7:22 for Palindrome Syndrome!
Can he review the new crab game trailer ?
My trailer wasn't shown but that's ok i learn more by watching the video!
Wow, the Fireworks Mania Trailer Looks Good!
Willy: faceplants
also willy: OI YOU! INTRUDER
Buddy Simulator 1984's trailer was really cool! Whoever made it should be proud!
Yup I agree
Watching critique is super helpful, thanks for sharing the knowledge!
3:37 LMAO that sound is literally the default preset from the Flex VST in fl studio
I Knew It
Wow this is a great video surprised you dont have that much subscribers you should get way more!
No worries. UA-cam is treating me quite fairly so far. I appreciate the kind words, though. Thank you. :)
@@JonasTyroller wow didn't expect you to answer also no problem
Manor Lands looked like The Settlers using Google map + streetview. Interesting game.
amazing job! i enjoyed the tips as well as the trailers :)
This video need a Part 2 ;)
The elevator thingie going down for the whole of the aterna trailer was really good!
It shows the importance or mystery of the mechanic and is very cool'
Dani crab game is triple A lol but karlson is serious
Karlson starts at 21:18
What can I say except your welcome
You need to make new video for the grab game trailer by dani. It's epic!!!
yes do the crab game trailer
Thank you for sharing all these game trailer tips! :D
21:17 for you legends
Him reviewing the karlson trailer makes me go *YES*
and physics make me go Y E S
heard nothing when the kitty was on screen....literally in one ear and out the other. Gotta pet the toe beans!
This is the correct response 😸
Dani's shotgun sound was actually a quarter note after the beat. I thought it was a nice changeup and sounded cool
Fair enough. :D
everyone came for karlson
including me
Yes
Yaaaa
Yesh
no
That last trailer. Solo developer? WOW!
NOO JONAS HE WASNT TALKING ABOUT THAT JUMP! He was talking about the second and third shotgun shot in the whole video. Also why is every section called buddy simulator 1984.
Ikr
lol the buddy simulator really is like a playable version of perscop! nice!
we all know crab game has the best new trailer
Great video!! Learned a lot from this thank you for sharing insights
Imagine someone asks him to do a trailer to his bad game.. Lmao
which one
@@dooda9566 just imagine
@@MineBloxStudios_ i’ll check it out
The glitch one triggers epilepsy
(Third one)
React to Crab Game trailer
OKAY WHAT?!?
That last tralier is a game and a tralier made by a solo dev?!? WHAT
O_O
Aight I'm interested.
Yo :) Three years in, many more to go...
@@ManorLords Well good luck! It was a good trailer too! I only wish it had more details on gameplay. Because i noticed you seem to have a combat system taking inspiration from that of the likes of total war, or perhaps strongholds. Which is really what this game reminds me of the most by the trailer alone.
In any case damn well done sir. :)
WATCH CRAB GAME TRAILER!
Jeez this feels like the Journalists Competition I experienced in my Elementary days
Fun fact, no one has technically finished the video at normal speed, I'm here early lol
True. :D
@@JonasTyroller now people have finished it! Including me, great video
Great Video. Another name for my Gamedev reference book. "Game Trailers - Derek Lieu"
Please react to the farty rocket trailer by Dani next time! 😄😂
Plot twist: Jonas is doing this for material for his trailer on his game.
my trailer is not here 😭
oh wait...
i didn't even submit 🙄
not even making a game 🙄🙄
The most interesting trailer here for me was the buddy trailer because it makes me want to figure out what's going on
"We're all here for Karlson."
Will I be arrested if I said that I came here for the others too? 😳
These are the single 40 min videos that i watch. I love them.