Thanks for very informative vlog. Despite few aberrations as well as omissions and commissions it may be helpful for the beginners. Wish to inform that Indian Universities have been able to retain several historians of international repute like Prof.R.S.Sharma, Prof.Romila Thaper,Prof.Irfan Habeeb, Prof.Bipin Chandra and many more who are considered authorities on ancient,medieval and modern India respectively. Your viewers/subscribers may go through books and articles by these stalwarts in due course and get true picture of the history of Indian subcontinent.
Dear Prof Zanjan, I have pinned your comment on top! I claim no mastery on the subject, and there are many generalizations in my broad sweep in this video, but I wanted to point out towards change of power dynamics between North and South with the arrival of European arms, tactics and knowledge etc! And I am glad at the quality and depth of comments on this video! My goal was to provoke a debate! which is happening but once again overall interest in the subject is much less! Most viewers are obsessed with the daily events and treat Vlogs as reporting sites! Moeed Pirzada
Read about chola empire and it's navy that had marriage alliance in modern day Singapore Thailand. Such uneducated man. Typical half educated Pakistani
Communists masquerading as professors! Guys don't read a single historian this guy has mentioned they are a laughing stock in India if u quote their funny ideas. People just laugh on Thapars n chandras and some advice for pakistanis, these so called historians are actually the same elites from past, some are sons n daughters of Indian zardaris then some are relatives of Indian sharifs n bhuttos
@@GVSNEWS dr. Pirzada, I do understand when you complain that your viewers are only interested in Pakistan’s geopolitical developments. I partly agree with you but to be fair with your viewers, if one’s house is on fire he/she don’t cares what new colour his neighbour is painting his house with. On the same note, majority of your viewers are overseas Pakistan. Considering the current news embargo in Pakistan, you vlog is one of the few resources for any reliable news. I can turn on the CNN to see what’s happening around the world. Food for thoughts.
The ancient city of Pataliputra is not in South of India and not in South of River Sutlaj, but located in North Eastern India. It's present name is Patna, which is the capital city of Indian Province of Bihar. This may kindly be got corrected.Furthermore Chandragupta Moria dynasty later on taken over by Ashoka had ruled India except South of India, and ruled part of Afghanistan and Iran also.
Some correction The Mighty Indian Maurya Empire not only ruled upto eastern part of Iran and Central Asia, but the actual boundary of maurya empire is - Major Rock Edict 13 inscription clearly talks about the expansion of Maurya Empire - It mentions victory & influence of Maurya Empire over Selucid Empire, Egypt, Macedonia, and to as far as Magas of Cyrene , Alexander 1 of Epirus and to victory over Ceylon (Sri lanka) in the south. By the way this is the same inscription which talks about Kalinga War, but in the very same inscription ahead , it mentions about victories of Maurya over other parts. But people ignored that. i would suggest you to read a book - Book : Bharat's Military Conquests in Foreign Land. Author : Venkatesh Rangan. Regarding Indian History,which unfortunately we r not taught correctly bcos of distortion by British which was designed in such a way that to make us feel inferior. As George Orwell said - “The most effective way to destroy people is to deny and obliterate their own history'. There is a proverb that says, “Until the lion tells the story, the hunter will always be the hero.” No wonder instead of reading History of Indians, We read history of outsiders. And till now we read history which was designed by british. And it is a big shame for all of us. Like for eg - one fact that over 1380 years have been deleted from the Indian history in order to adjust it into biblical timeline which is limited in nature i.e 2000-4000 years. Prof Vedveer Arya has written books on this & has given challenge to western historians on this.Vedveer Arya has given his talks on UA-cam. OR Aryan Invasion Theory, which was designed to create animosity between North India Vs South India. Infact it has been proven wrong by many people. And this theory now has been debunked many people now. So, there are plenty of things like this. Its only now slowly a lot of things are being unearthed and debunked and they are coming to limelight. When I am talking about India (it includes pakistan also as both Indians & pakistanis are the same people. Some Indian Empire who influence went beyond India ( Modern Day India + Pakistan) : 1. Maurya Empire - influence of Maurya Empire over Selucid Empire, Egypt, Macedonia, and to as far asMagas of Cyrene , Alexander 1 of Epirus and to victory over Ceylon (Sri lanka) in the south. 2. Samrat Vikramaditya - Legends says that his empire reached as far as arab peninsula to Mid-Europe. No wonder why the traditions before islam and christianity in these areas are very much similar to Hinduism/Santana Dharma/Dharmic traditions.Infact Arabic Poet Bintoi, who lived 165 years before Mohmad, endorses the fact that Samrat Vikramaditya ruled over Arab to East-Europe & he praises Vikramaditya for bringing prosperity to them. I hope someday Arab Govts allow the research for this. Indian Calendar is also based on Vikram Samvat Era.*For those who dont know that over 1380 years have been deleted from the Indian history by british in order to fit into biblical time period which is limited in nature i.e. 2000- 4000 years.Infact Professor like Vedveer Arya has explained this & has given open challenge to western historians on this. 3. Rajendra Chola : Great King of Chola Empire. Control over the land & seas.He established his supremacy over Arabian Sea to Bay of Bengal and conquered land upto Orissa & Bengal to whole south east asia upto Indonesia & Philippines with his influence reaching as far as East China Sea. By the way Chola Empire lasted for ATLEAST 1500-1600 years whereas Roman Empire lasted for only 1000 years 4. Lalitaditya Muktapida : His empire extended right from Bay of Bengal to Caspian Sea. He defeated the Arabs, Turks(Turkmenistanis), Tibetians, & others. Defeat of Arabs by Lalitaditya was a humiliating defeats for Arabs. He inflicted extraordinary humiliation on the Arab armies. Lalitaditya ordered the arabs, who were left behind to shave off half their heads as a symbol of their submission. 5. Kanishka - His empire extend from Northern India particularly from Bihar (state in India) in the east to Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, some more parts of Southern areas of Central Asia to Khotan areas(western areas in China) to Khorasan (Eastern areas in Iran). 6. Bappa Rawal : He defeated the arabs and he thrashed & chased them upto Iran and made check posts all the way from Iran to India. 7. Deva Raya II : Deva Raya II (r. 1422-1446 CE) was an emperor of the Vijayanagara Empire. The greatest of the Sangama dynasty rulers, he was an able administrator, warrior, and scholar. Defeated Gajapati Kingdom and annexed areas from them . Deva Raya II's empire included Kerala where he defeated the ruler of Quilon as well as other chieftains in the region. He later on invaded Ceylon and collected rich tributes there. The Zamorin of Calicut and even the kings of Burma ruling at Pegu and Tanasserim paid tribute. This information was obtained from the writings of Nuniz. 8. Samudragupta : Samudragupta is undoubtedly one of the Greatest Emperors of Indian History . He belongs to Gupta Dynasty. And according to me, if we consider all the factors, Samudragupta is probably, the Greatest Emperor in the world. Prayag Prashasti inscription talks about Samudragupta Extent of his influence - His capital was Pataliputra. At peak, his influence extended from Bihar and Bengal & Bangladesh in the east to parts of Rakhine areas of Myanmar to Assam & North East India to Nepal in North to Afghanistan and parts of Southern Central Asia in the North west to Tamil Nadu in South & to Sri Lanka & other Island Nations like Java,Sumatra & Malaya Islands.His authority over Java,Sumatra & Malaya Island proves that he also maintained a strong Navy. Gupta Empire had regular maritime contacts with Persia, Arabia,Byzantine Empire, Africa, and even further. 9. Ranjit Singh - His dominance was from western part of Delhi upto Kabul 10. Maratha Empire - At its peak Maratha Empire stretched from Attock to Peshawar in the North West to Tanjore(Tamil Nadu) in the south & to Cuttack to influence reaching Bengal in east with Nawabs of Bengal handed over Orissa & agree to pay Rs 1.2 million of chauth(annual taxes) from revenue of Bengal & Bihar to Maratha Empire. Some books recommendations to read 1. Book : Bharat's Military Conquests in Foreign Land. Author : Venkatesh Rangan. 2. Book : Unbreaking India. Author : Sanjay Dixit 3. Book : India that is Bharat. Author : J Sai Deepak 4. Book : India, Bharat & Pakistan. Author : J Sai Deepak 5. Book : Maharanas. Author : Omendra Ratnu 6. Book : Revolutionaries. Author : Sanjeev Sanyal 7. Book : Ocean of Churn. Author : Sanjeev Sanyal 8. Book : The Hindus of Hindustan. Author : Meenakshi Jain 9. Book : Flight of Deities & Rebirth of Temples. Author : Meenakshi Jain 10. Book : Chronology of India: From Mahabharata to Medieval Era - Vol I. Author : Vedveer Arya 11. Book : Chronology of India: From Mahabharata to Medieval Era - Vol II. Author : Vedveer Arya -> Book number 10 and 11, talks about missing years from Indian History. Over 1380 years have been deleted from indian History in order to adjust them to Biblical timeline of 2000-4000 years by British. Thats why there a lot of confusion fron the times of ancient Indian era to 12th century AD. Vedveer Arya have exposed that. And he has also given talks regarding this on UA-cam platform. 12. Book : Brainwashed Republic. Author : Neeraj Atri 13. Book : Savarkar Part 1. Author : Vikram Sampath 14. Book : Savarkar Part 2. Author : Vikram Sampath 15. Book : Bravehearts of Bharat. Author : Vikram Sampath 16. Book : A Brief History Of Science In India. Author : Sabareesh P.A 17. Book : Understanding Mohmad. Author : Ali Sina. -> Its available on internet for free as PDF by the author himself.
He is referring to the NorthWestern region and the SouthEastern region as a whole. Geographically, Bihar is South and East of Punjab, even if the two regions are not continuous.
@@numerologysecrets7705joker😂😂 tum wo kutti kaum ho jisko koi ghr m jgh dede to tum ghr p apna naam likha lo,,,ek br aa tu india krayenge raaz tujse😂😂😂
First of all really liked your analysis. Very coherently put. But when you say north is north of Sutlej and south is south of it, then you are saying ti from a person who is sitting in present day Pakistan (or North-West of erstwhile undivided India). But when you think as a person sitting in undivided India, south is south of Vindhyachal mountain and north is north of it. Now within this north region, you of course have the western region with places like Peshawar, Lahore, etc and then eastern region with places like Patliputra (today's Patna). So when Chandragupta Maurya, Ashoka, etc defeated kings ruling in Lahore, Peshawar, etc it was basically East dominating West within northern India. But later on when Marathas conquered a large part of northern and north-western undivided India, they did originate from South-West of undivided India. So in this case you can say South defeating North. From undivided India perspective even Raja Ranjit Singh was northern. So his taking over Peshawar from the Afghans was basically north defeating north. The above is where I have slight difference from your points. But your main thrust that South of undivided India got modern education and institutions much earlier than North is true. And within North too, East and Central parts got is before the west. So that way present day Pakistan had the misfortune of getting them much later.
Well-done doctor, I as a history "buff" and from my ancestral stories found it all out long time ago, when I used to be in school, in my ancestral city of Lahore. I've been living in US, for a long time, and aware of these both subjects, you discussed in this vlogg. Well done 👍
In the last millennium (1000 AD to 2000 AD), anything north-west of river Indus, came to be considered as non-India and was referred to as "wilayat" and its people as "wilayatis".......a term they used in the meaning of foreigner and later used it for Angraiz. The people of modern-day Punjab were by all essence Indians, and they viewed (and still view) Afghan expeditions in their Punjab as foreign invasions. But the Maratha incursion into Punjab, was not viewed as foreign invasion by Punjabis. Adina Beg (an Arain Punjabi) invited Maratha to expel Afghans from Punjab and stated (according to Tahmas Nama) that we Indians first have to remove Afghans from our soil.
Lol all saints in Punjab came from North lol I don't know what kind of Punjabi you are Martha never reached Punjab lol and who is Adina Beg lol BTW beg are turks lol
How come none of you are talking about KPT being sold to UAE ? All irrelevance news being mentioned , no talk about selling of 4 ports of Karachi to UAE ??? Are you oblivious?
Pakistan Ke Parks, Highways, Motorways, Clubs, Golf Courses, Airports, Railway Stations, Ports, Sab Kuch Bikk Gaya Bhaiii😂😂😂 Just Relax And Drink Beer 😎
Certainly a new perspective. One can agree or not is a different thing but certainly food for thought. I'd say a great effort Dr. Moeed in analysing. Anyone with an open mind open to a discussion and NOT argument will enjoy this. I certainly did. Thanks.
Brilliant. A very detailed research based lecture on South Asia. I loved every moment of it. Its very mismerizing and well narrated. Well done Dr. Moeed.
Lesson of this era of history can’t get better via a ‘v-log’ than this one, great job. This ‘North-South’ paradigm is such an important subject that it needs deep study to guide us towards a better future. Well done Dr Moeed 👏 and thanks a lot.
Thank you for informative Vlog. Let me summarize this as follows: 1. Trading was established in Bombay, Delhi, Calcutta, etc. 2. Military was established in Rawalpindi, Peshawar, Gilgit, Multan, Quetta. By these two points, we can easily see the difference.
ماشااللّہ اپ تو معلومات کا دریا بہا دیتے ھین مین جنرل ھسٹری کی طالبعلم تھی۔ وہ ہسٹوریکل پائنٹس ancient Indian his اس وقت clear نئی تھے جو آج سمجھ مین آئے۔ اپ کو سلامت رکھے۔اس وقت اپ بہت زبردست روک پلے کر رھے ھین
Doctor Sahab, AOA, excellent study and transfer of knowledge. I think you are doing an amazing job, keep it up, and continue with this great work. 👍 Pakistan Zindabad
Very fine presentation. .....yes education and modern scientific knowledge are the decisive factors for bringing about the desired change in the future and fate of a nation or country. .
Amazing,❤ The bottom line is..exercise of power isnt the sustainable solution instead to human prospirity,trading,is through education. Knowledge is power.
This is a very interesting take. Interestingly in India in recent times many data points whether be it about diet, or political choices, women empowerment, various attitudes it is seen that the difference is not so much between northern India and southern India as generally conceived but axially between north-west on the one hand and South-east on the other. And this south-east got hold of European knowledge first and remains even now inclined to progressive ideas whereas north-west is comparatively conservative in spirit. One further point which perhaps also needs to be added is that Indian elites started anglicizing but they didn't just anglicise they somehow tried infused (for good or for bad) revivalism within that anglicization. So they both wanted past glory as well as modernity! And this is seen in India. Though there is a tension between modernity and revivalistic tendencies but they also somehow fuse together to create a synergy of sorts. Pakistan on the other hand sitting on the laps of Mohenjodaro and Harappa somehow succeeded in neither taking modernity, nor past but became fixated on just one aspect of Identity - the religious identity. I think you are right that Pakistani expats from the West can play a significant role if you can take que from how significant role the Indian expats are playing for India.
Ironically, Indian intelligentsia is becoming increasingly fixated on religious identity of Sanatan Dharma, while Pakistani intelligentsia is increasingly becoming critical of the concept of statehood solely reliant on faith for its legitimacy. The two countries will see the consequences of these reversals in the future.
I've been watching your vlogs for some time now especially for my own education, I wish more people would benefit from it like me. The fact is that such vlogs are needed so that we can eliminate the unnecessary bias within us and understand the need for healthy competition with India, I cry like a baby when I realize that India has developed so much as a country and institutions that people like Modi are highly respected in those countries where he was considered a professional gangster, this understanding was not achieved before these vlogs. The historical background of the subcontinent you painstakingly presented to us is very important and especially insightful, I will watch this vlog again. What has been clearly understood is that we must now understand that Pakistan has fallen far behind India as a nation, now we have to remove these weaknesses from within ourselves and put ourselves on the path of development. It has to be done, my heart wants me to say here while speaking the dialogue of the film, O rulers, give us back those fifty years of ours, which you people took away from us because of your lust.
It is okay brother, don't be sad. I am from India, and i can understand you. You should compete with Afghanistan and Nepal because they have $9 Billion and $10 Billion Forex Reserves, while Pakistan now has only $3.5 Billion. It will be best if you forget India and Bangladesh and focus on Nepal, Sri Lanka and Afghanistan.
Of course your "elites" are responsible for your pathetic condition .. but don't excuse yourself, the common people of pakistan & its society from your own responsibility too. Your problems are more 'fundamental' .. but it would be 'blasphemous' to talk about them in pakistan. Nothing good can happen with Pakistan until they 'renounce' their 'fundamental' problem. Kucchh samjhe biraadar ?
Your prejudice of our PM itself is telling You people run for the Elite's needs and narrative until this continues there will continue to search for a messiah who make a better pakistan and that will lead to your Establish control The day when you people make your narrative the real pakistan will born
Dear Pakistanis if you want to understand the land of your Hindu ancestors then start reading more about the cultural history of Bharat! The only nation which had never lost a cultural war!
Dr Moeed I fully support and agree with your vision and way forward. I always tried to convince the community to work on knowledge/ education / learning/ utilisation of energy of younger people for their development to benefit the community to exploit the untapped potential of younger generation in modern world
On one hand these Pakistanis take pride in Islamic invaders for destroying kafir temples, naming mountains as Hindukush, forcing jaziya on Hindus, converting people in mass, making harems out of Hindu women, breaking India on communal lines. Andon the other hand he is saying it was never about battle of religions bcoz Hinduism was never a religion.🤣🤣 Muslims from India have written letters to Afghans asking them to attack Delhi. It's well documented that Aurangzeb gave Hindu kings options to either die or conver to Islam. Yet this man is claiming it was never about civilizational battle (Islam vs Hinduism). He is saying Maratha had muslims in ther armies and Afghans had Hindus in their army. So what? Modi and RSS has also kept some Muslims in his party. Will you now accept Modi is not anti-Islam? Islam has taken refuge of kaffar's secularism for far too long. Hindutva has risen after 1000 years to not only end the evils (like Caste System, Gandhism) within Hinduism but also to end the enemy of Dharma. All scores will be settled. Moeed you must know Hinduism is not at the loggerheads with Islam only but Christianity as well. You will witness us engaging in a long battle against Missionaries in India mass-converting people with the power of Vatican Wealth. Hidutva will prove development does not need minority appeasing secularism. Hindutva will show the world how to teat Islam on the basis of Mutual Respect. Game is ON.
Reading through the comments I observe that almost all Pakistani viewers commend Dr Pirzada on his intellectual prowess and his knowledge etc while the Indians try and correct or add value to the “knowledge transfer”. We already know this as we have learnt this in school.
That is exactly Dr Pirzada tried to explain, the knowledge penetration in the areas now called Pakistan not at the level as on Indian side. Correction and addition can only come from knowledge, many on Pakistani side are listening this kind of info for the first time thus they are commending DR Pirzada for doing this great vlog.
@@javaidiqbal6361 This is really a sad state of affairs. How many years before things improve for the common Pakistani then ? Humans all live on hope. Is there no hope ?
This was a brilliant session, shedding light on the most important factor that I've heard for the first time: the factor that can be considered a defining element of our current behavior, vision (lack of vision as to say) and bit of rigidness. You should be doing more sessions on global power play as well. Cheers!
Delhi was Inderprastha in Mahabharta time and it was the capital of Pandava. So it's delveloped around 5000 year ago. I know, can understand that you don't know and has very little knowledge about ancient India.
@sameerahmed1853i t is not a myth BTW. The geographic locations have all been identified. Kurukshetra, dwaraka, hasitnapur, gandhar etc etc. Bhai please enlighten yourself Sir
@@sameerahmed1853 After passing 5000 years everything looks like mythology. Even you don't know your forefathers were Hindu, have you remembered anything when you and family converted to Islam, I'm sure you don't know, then how can you know and understand history before 5000 years ago. I can understand it's not your fault brother.
Interesting analysis. From my experience, a major challenge when viewing Pakistan in historical context is of classification. You have classified Pakistan as Northern in North/South divide. Is this classification correct ? considering that majority of Northern conquerors that succeeded till 1761 used to come from Persia/Central Asia and not the lands of modern day Pakistan. Now I understand that Pakistan inherits the culture created by these Northern conquerors and their descendants do live in Pakistan. But there is considerable Southern influence as well owing to the Sikh and British rule specially in Central-Southern Punjab and Sindh. I think Pakistan is a very hard nation to characterize. I faced similar problem while reading 'Study of History' by Toynbee. Our identity is mainly ideological and lacks a concrete base. This could be a blessing or a curse. Nevertheless, the story of Pakistan is exciting and hopefully it will be long and glorious !
It’s very unfortunate that a large population of even educated Pakistanis don’t see what’s happening outside Pakistani “s politics. Sadly, our politics is like a soap opera which our people follow and awaits next exciting episode We don’t realise what is at stake ? Our youth is so demoralised My neice has just became a medical doctor at the age of 23 and now there are no jobs no future.
Thank you 💕 dr.moeed bhai for taking on a subject hardly youth of Pakistan is interested i.e development of Asian countries from 17th century onward. You have very eloquently described the war strategies of kings and religious authorities and afghan forces. Let me give a short sports activity taking place in a small town Dina and that is a cricket match organized by cricket fans. The matches between few villages around mangla and Dina took place from 8pm to 4am.
Dear Nazia Jehangir sahiba: it's pretty well-placed that the masses are getting torpid,disillusioned and lethargic day by day. I remember, a few years ago when I graduated in engg, how there was a climate of hope,idealism and ambitions in Pakistan. Maslaw's hierarchy of needs model fully portrays our sad state of affairs. When our basic needs of security and livable conditions are getting harder and harder to be fulfilled, expecting a scholarly view about world affairs becomes a distant dream.
You rightly pointed out historically we were not 'Hindus', but we were Rajputs, Maratha, Bengali, Tamil and so on. Again you are right, if we were united as Hindus, the muslim/turks/persian invaders would not have conquered India/Bharat.
We Pathans and Punjabis of Pakistan took pride for centuries as military race like Gorkhas and Sikhs of India, but actually we were less littrate than Central and South Indians; who refused to get abused by British as their mercenary forces. I agreed with you, North of Sutlaj can not be compatible with South of Sutlaj in western democracies.❤❤❤
Doctor. India’s progress is something to be envied for the neighbouring countries. How long Pakistan will continue to stew on its own juices.?? Woe to the enemies of the state. 😡
internal disquiet in Pakistan, including the unsustainable and unconstitutional interference of the military in civilian affairs, the incompetence of its policy elites, and its dysfunctional economic affairs are the reason why your country is doomed.
Thanks for initiating this kind of debate. I have one question regarding this debate: why did British focus only upon Southern side of India while coming for trade via maritime route? Why didn't they choose Sindh too for trade purpose? as Arabian sea is along the coastal side of Sindh and this coastal area has geo strategic and geo economical potential from date back of history?
Thanks to the Muslims of India who sacrificed their mothers and sisters to the Mughal invaders in the past , we respect u.. Talwar ke darr se salvar pehen liya..
پچھلے ستر سالہ انڈو پاک سیاسی تناظر میں یہ ویلاگ بہت سے سوالات کے جواب دیتا ھے۔۔ علم میں اضافہ ھوا اور حالات کو سوچنے سمجھنے کی نئی راہیں ملی ھیں۔ ایک اچھے اور ہمہ جہت لیکچر پر اپکا شکر گزار ھوں۔ نیک تمنائیں ❤
Doc, I watch your v logs very attentively for educational purposes being a teacher of pak studies . I must share with you that I was giving a realistic view to my students ,which was quite contrary to what was being depicted in our books .But since regime change , we are also under pressure and fear to talk about realities ..
Hello! Sir, you are doing a lot for this poor nation. I wish to be a part of your struggle. Carl Marx has done this before. No doubt that south has done alot in education but at the same time north was prepared for producing soldiers in the same way as now iin Pakistan. Salt belt is fixed for better soldier, their culture their stories their loves are all for soldiers. // if we insist repeatedly that like other world our leaders must be honest like angel. And repeat this statement frequently we may be able to achieve this, that people should not vote to dishonest. Your statement will be a great help in the regard that "discuss this everywhere "that don't vote to Dishonest. That's all for this thanks
Tell ur son to type modern indian history , medieval history on youtube he will get so many playlist for history lectures he can watch lectures and learn original history pakistanies shows forged history
Excellent I salute you for your beautiful presentation of history. In joint India Lahore was main Education centre and Dhaka was main commercial Center.
There was NEVER any country called "India" or "Bharat" until August 15, 1947. One has to go all the way back to Mauryan Empire to come anywhere close to what is now India. But the boundaries of Mauryan Empire are simply based on names mentioned in ancient texts and it's not clear if those place-names were actually part of the empire. That is why there are many different maps of the extent of the Mauryan Empire, none of which include southern India. The word "India" is derived from the Sindhu, the Indus River, and for Persians who named it "Hind," it simply represented a region around the Indus River and beyond. This was later adopted by Arabs who then distinguished Sindh from Hindh because Sindh had become part of the Omayyad Empire. The word "Bharat" was also some region in India, like Siberia in Russia, which never had any boundaries. Even when the British ruled the Subcontinent, it was called the British Raj, Burma was part of it, and the Viceroy of India also handled affairs of the Trucial States which are now UAE, Bahrain and Qatar. The Subcontinent was always a region, like Europe, which consisted of various kingdoms, the Western regions of which were often part of the Persian Empire, Greeco-Bacterian Kingdom, Omayyad Empire, and later Afghan kingdoms, all of which left their mark (and progeny) in this rich cultural mix. Since the area that is now Pakistan was closer to Afghanistan and the Middle East, it was more influenced by them, both culturally, religiously and ethnically. India always has had dozens of ethnic groups, just it had many kingdoms. To say that there was some "Hindu" ethnic group would be historically and scientifically wrong. Because of conquests and migrations (mostly due to Mongol invasions in Central Asia) ethnic makeup of the Muslim population in the Subcontinent began to change around 1000-1200 AD. It was also state policy among Muslim rulers of India to encourage Muslim immigration from Central Asia and sometimes the entire armies consisted of Mamluk soldiers. Immigrants and soldiers were given land grants, so they could survive in their adopted homeland. [This has been recorded in my own family history which goes back to hundreds of years]. Over time, these immigrants married locals and were so fully assimilated into the local culture that it was hard to distinguish them from the native population. Thus the "ethnic mix" among Muslims was not the same as among the "ethnic mix" of the larger Hindu population. Since Islam rejected the notion of "caste," "Muslim" became an identity by itself. I know that both Indians and Pakistanis try to create an Indian or Pakistani identity but make a terrible mistake by confusing religion with ethnic and national identities. Each person has many MANY identities. One can be Hindu and be American, British, Indonesian, Surinamese or Guyanese. It takes hundreds or perhaps thousands of years for national identities to develop. Hardly any country now has just one ethnic or religious group. National identities are lot more complex and have to do with commonality of purpose, ideals, and culture rather than ethnicity. This is why even the UN speaks of "self-determination" rather than imposition of an identity on any group.
you must have come by the news that indian aviation industry has ordered 500 plus commercial flight from both boeing as well as Airbus while your PM is begging for $1 billion dollar 💵 to save punjab from being default. Yes I intentionally said Punjab becaue Sharif's jurisdictions is upto Punjab only
Yours is a typical islamist pov .. & hence easily debunkable. India has always through out its history of thousands of years been a civilastional nation. Country is a relatively new concept the world over. Pakistan may be a new country today .. but it is still a part of Indian civilisational nation. Your unease with this fact is none of anybody's concern. You may keep reciting your islamist pov & insecure pakistan studies style assuaging of personal humiliation in which ever way you feel comfortable with. You have already witnessed where it has taken pakistan to, in the past 75 years since it was manufactured. But lage raho bhai. Jo apni mitti ko bhoolta hai .. mitti bhi usse bhula deti hai.
QabilAGhor, *You may still have to go back many millennia to know why India is called Bharat. Indus-Sarswati culture also called Indus valley civilization during 6000 BCE to 1900 BCE was so vast encompassing 1.5 million sq.kms. From Mehrgarh (Balochistan) to Shortugal in present Pakistan and Kalibangan, Rakhigarhi and other Saraswati sites near Delhi to Lothal and Daimabad(submerged ruins in gulf of Khambhat - Gujarat ) in south western India. According to Vedic chronology many great Bharata kings and others of equal prominence ruled in India had close contact with the cities in the Indus valley civilization area.*
Pakistani politicians are much better entertainers. Most of the country in general are born entertainers and clowns. The only thing they hate is logic🤣
@@a.a1594 counter argument seriously🤣🤣do you know what is critical appraisal? Reading 1 book and giving narratives will work with Pakistanis not Indians. Modern history is mix of epigraphy, epigeneticist, paleontologist, philogists to archeologists to epigraphists to many more. Example of a 'gas' South was NOT developed until Westerners came🤣🤣 while you people were learning to wipe your backside, kings of South India were capturing Myanmar to Bali with full developed maritime navy. Atleast read history of 'Largest temple in the world'-Angkor Wat'🤣🤣or read where your Abbu China learnt Kungfu from or Bodhidharma is🤣🤣
Meanwhile Indian scholars have flooded the social media like flies, but not one of them has the intellectual capacity to come up with a reasonable rebuttal to his 'comedy'. Spamming emojis and incoherent rants seems to be the limit to their ''contributions''.
Why do u not consider haider sir a journalist???it is not good to be arrogant for a TRUE journalist, he has written more than 400 column columns columns in newspapers, aur kya journalist ke singh hote hain
Why you have neglected Pushayabhuti Empire , Gupta Empire , Shunga Empire Palas , Rastrakutas , chalukyas , marathas , Ahoms , Kharvela Empire , Cholas , Pandayas , Palavas Vijaynagar empire , Sikh Empre etc , All these empires/Kingdom some way to other extended towards north , Your Analysis was based on a specific location but India sub continent was much bigger in size , by Contemplating all , it was not always right to say North always pushed the south by neglecting the mentions
Don't Take This Pirzada Seriously Brother Just watch for entertainment like Kapil Sharma Show, or don't watch if you want to preserve your brain cells 😂😂
@@آوارہمانندِہوا Nalanda university , Mahabalipuram temples , Jain temples , Sanchi stupas , Kailash temples of Ajanta and Elora , Elephanta caves , Hampi City , Bodh gaya Boudh temples and millions more , Kisne banaya tha bhai "Arbo ne "🤣🤣
Excellent. 😲 Stay Stuck in your version of the Past. 🙂 What else can a Pakistani Do, where a Foreign Supported Government and has been imposed on the Citizens 😂 What a Pity 🥰 Focus on your country, and don't dig the past. These are artificial methods to raise your morale when there is nothing good going for you or your party. 🤗 Try and live in the real life. 😊
Great Overview Of North Vs South Perspectives But There Is Also Another Angle Which Is Khurasan Civilization In The West & Indic Civilization In The East As River Indus Is Its Boundary!
Excellent bread, In all coming vlog plz add 10/15 mini.should be discuss around the world important issues & Our area History also. Thnx Sir, Regards, tc
Imran khan body language during his visit to White House was confident….he talked with eye in eye …..this is pirazadas analysis..someone shud teach him journalism….😂
I am from india 🇮🇳🇮🇳 I just want to ask one question to all the pakistanis.... Question :- can you name a single king who fullfill 3 conditions.. 1. Born in Pakistan 2.ruled over Pakistan 3. Todays Pakistani respect him.
Excellent , absolutely loved it. Pakistan is a state carved out of the frontier of India , Jinnah and Muslim league were blinded by their greed for a separate state and didn't realise that they were carving out an extremely poor and difficult country
Looking at the Indian comments, it seems they are also taught history their own controlled ways. Most of Moeed's contents refer to Western literature but they think it is a comedy.
It is most of it. Geographical referring is wrong maurya was from present day Bihar which is in north not south, South india had other empires like cholas marathas n all so he researched it but he researched selfishly
@@VickySharma-oz3vp You have to give him some leeway about his bearing. His origin is Kashmir. Everything below him is south. In Punjabi, south direction is called Deccan (modern day Telangana) and north is Parbat (means mountain). It does not mean there are no mountains south of Punjab. He did mix Mauryan and Gupta empires though. He is right about the word Hindu as a single religious entity. Looking at the millennia of history of "Bharat", it is a very recent phenomenon taken from British colonial literature.
@@VickySharma-oz3vp Good thing you mentioned about his intention. We should all correct his telling of the facts. No one can fully judge or control someone's intention. Allow me to assume he offends many Indians. You might be surprised, he offends even more Pakistanis because they are not taught what he is telling them. A typical Pakistani does not listen to such "disinformation". That was the gist of my first comment of this thread. Delighted to interacting with you.
@@abrmuni569 appreciate your response. Well if he is doing it knowing that the mentality of pakistani ppl then it becomes worst thsn what their establishment is doing to them. Half knowledge or you can say "disinformation" can do more damage to a society.
Dr sb just to correct one small point, the Morias were also Aryans from the north. Original inhabitants of these areas were Dravidians of South India and they never conquered the north.
Thanks for very informative vlog.
Despite few aberrations as well as omissions and commissions it may be helpful for the beginners.
Wish to inform that Indian Universities have been able to retain several historians of international repute like Prof.R.S.Sharma, Prof.Romila Thaper,Prof.Irfan Habeeb, Prof.Bipin Chandra and many more who are considered authorities on ancient,medieval and modern India respectively.
Your viewers/subscribers may go through books and articles by these stalwarts in due course and get true picture of the history of Indian subcontinent.
Well those Marxist historians and their view of history has got increasingly exposed. More will happen in coming years.
Dear Prof Zanjan, I have pinned your comment on top! I claim no mastery on the subject, and there are many generalizations in my broad sweep in this video, but I wanted to point out towards change of power dynamics between North and South with the arrival of European arms, tactics and knowledge etc! And I am glad at the quality and depth of comments on this video! My goal was to provoke a debate! which is happening but once again overall interest in the subject is much less! Most viewers are obsessed with the daily events and treat Vlogs as reporting sites! Moeed Pirzada
Read about chola empire and it's navy that had marriage alliance in modern day Singapore Thailand. Such uneducated man. Typical half educated Pakistani
Communists masquerading as professors! Guys don't read a single historian this guy has mentioned they are a laughing stock in India if u quote their funny ideas. People just laugh on Thapars n chandras and some advice for pakistanis, these so called historians are actually the same elites from past, some are sons n daughters of Indian zardaris then some are relatives of Indian sharifs n bhuttos
@@GVSNEWS dr. Pirzada, I do understand when you complain that your viewers are only interested in Pakistan’s geopolitical developments. I partly agree with you but to be fair with your viewers, if one’s house is on fire he/she don’t cares what new colour his neighbour is painting his house with.
On the same note, majority of your viewers are overseas Pakistan. Considering the current news embargo in Pakistan, you vlog is one of the few resources for any reliable news. I can turn on the CNN to see what’s happening around the world.
Food for thoughts.
The ancient city of Pataliputra is not in South of India and not in South of River Sutlaj, but located in North Eastern India. It's present name is Patna, which is the capital city of Indian Province of Bihar. This may kindly be got corrected.Furthermore Chandragupta Moria dynasty later on taken over by Ashoka had ruled India except South of India, and ruled part of Afghanistan and Iran also.
Some correction The Mighty Indian Maurya Empire not only ruled upto eastern part of Iran and Central Asia, but the actual boundary of maurya empire is - Major Rock Edict 13 inscription clearly talks about the expansion of Maurya Empire - It mentions victory & influence of Maurya Empire over Selucid Empire, Egypt, Macedonia, and to as far as Magas of Cyrene , Alexander 1 of Epirus and to victory over Ceylon (Sri lanka) in the south. By the way this is the same inscription which talks about Kalinga War, but in the very same inscription ahead , it mentions about victories of Maurya over other parts. But people ignored that. i would suggest you to read a book - Book : Bharat's Military Conquests in Foreign Land. Author : Venkatesh Rangan. Regarding Indian History,which unfortunately we r not taught correctly bcos of distortion by British which was designed in such a way that to make us feel inferior. As George Orwell said - “The most effective way to destroy people is to deny and obliterate their own history'. There is a proverb that says, “Until the lion tells the story, the hunter will always be the hero.” No wonder instead of reading History of Indians, We read history of outsiders. And till now we read history which was designed by british. And it is a big shame for all of us. Like for eg - one fact that over 1380 years have been deleted from the Indian history in order to adjust it into biblical timeline which is limited in nature i.e 2000-4000 years. Prof Vedveer Arya has written books on this & has given challenge to western historians on this.Vedveer Arya has given his talks on UA-cam. OR Aryan Invasion Theory, which was designed to create animosity between North India Vs South India. Infact it has been proven wrong by many people. And this theory now has been debunked many people now. So, there are plenty of things like this. Its only now slowly a lot of things are being unearthed and debunked and they are coming to limelight.
When I am talking about India (it includes pakistan also as both Indians & pakistanis are the same people.
Some Indian Empire who influence went beyond India ( Modern Day India + Pakistan) :
1. Maurya Empire - influence of Maurya Empire over Selucid Empire, Egypt, Macedonia, and to as far asMagas of Cyrene , Alexander 1 of Epirus and to victory over Ceylon (Sri lanka) in the south.
2. Samrat Vikramaditya - Legends says that his empire reached as far as arab peninsula to Mid-Europe. No wonder why the traditions before islam and christianity in these areas are very much similar to Hinduism/Santana Dharma/Dharmic traditions.Infact Arabic Poet Bintoi, who lived 165 years before Mohmad, endorses the fact that Samrat Vikramaditya ruled over Arab to East-Europe & he praises Vikramaditya for bringing prosperity to them. I hope someday Arab Govts allow the research for this. Indian Calendar is also based on Vikram Samvat Era.*For those who dont know that over 1380 years have been deleted from the Indian history by british in order to fit into biblical time period which is limited in nature i.e. 2000- 4000 years.Infact Professor like Vedveer Arya has explained this & has given open challenge to western historians on this.
3. Rajendra Chola : Great King of Chola Empire. Control over the land & seas.He established his supremacy over Arabian Sea to Bay of Bengal and conquered land upto Orissa & Bengal to whole south east asia upto Indonesia & Philippines with his influence reaching as far as East China Sea. By the way Chola Empire lasted for ATLEAST 1500-1600 years whereas Roman Empire lasted for only 1000 years
4. Lalitaditya Muktapida : His empire extended right from Bay of Bengal to Caspian Sea. He defeated the Arabs, Turks(Turkmenistanis), Tibetians, & others. Defeat of Arabs by Lalitaditya was a humiliating defeats for Arabs. He inflicted extraordinary humiliation on the Arab armies. Lalitaditya ordered the arabs, who were left behind to shave off half their heads as a symbol of their submission.
5. Kanishka - His empire extend from Northern India particularly from Bihar (state in India) in the east to Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, some more parts of Southern areas of Central Asia to Khotan areas(western areas in China) to Khorasan (Eastern areas in Iran).
6. Bappa Rawal : He defeated the arabs and he thrashed & chased them upto Iran and made check posts all the way from Iran to India.
7. Deva Raya II : Deva Raya II (r. 1422-1446 CE) was an emperor of the Vijayanagara Empire. The greatest of the Sangama dynasty rulers, he was an able administrator, warrior, and scholar. Defeated Gajapati Kingdom and annexed areas from them . Deva Raya II's empire included Kerala where he defeated the ruler of Quilon as well as other chieftains in the region. He later on invaded Ceylon and collected rich tributes there. The Zamorin of Calicut and even the kings of Burma ruling at Pegu and Tanasserim paid tribute. This information was obtained from the writings of Nuniz.
8. Samudragupta : Samudragupta is undoubtedly one of the Greatest Emperors of Indian History . He belongs to Gupta Dynasty. And according to me, if we consider all the factors, Samudragupta is probably, the Greatest Emperor in the world. Prayag Prashasti inscription talks about Samudragupta Extent of his influence - His capital was Pataliputra. At peak, his influence extended from Bihar and Bengal & Bangladesh in the east to parts of Rakhine areas of Myanmar to Assam & North East India to Nepal in North to Afghanistan and parts of Southern Central Asia in the North west to Tamil Nadu in South & to Sri Lanka & other Island Nations like Java,Sumatra & Malaya Islands.His authority over Java,Sumatra & Malaya Island proves that he also maintained a strong Navy. Gupta Empire had regular maritime contacts with Persia, Arabia,Byzantine Empire, Africa, and even further.
9. Ranjit Singh - His dominance was from western part of Delhi upto Kabul
10. Maratha Empire - At its peak Maratha Empire stretched from Attock to Peshawar in the North West to Tanjore(Tamil Nadu) in the south & to Cuttack to influence reaching Bengal in east with Nawabs of Bengal handed over Orissa & agree to pay Rs 1.2 million of chauth(annual taxes) from revenue of Bengal & Bihar to Maratha Empire.
Some books recommendations to read
1. Book : Bharat's Military Conquests in Foreign Land. Author : Venkatesh Rangan.
2. Book : Unbreaking India. Author : Sanjay Dixit
3. Book : India that is Bharat. Author : J Sai Deepak
4. Book : India, Bharat & Pakistan. Author : J Sai Deepak
5. Book : Maharanas. Author : Omendra Ratnu
6. Book : Revolutionaries. Author : Sanjeev Sanyal
7. Book : Ocean of Churn. Author : Sanjeev Sanyal
8. Book : The Hindus of Hindustan. Author : Meenakshi Jain
9. Book : Flight of Deities & Rebirth of Temples. Author : Meenakshi Jain
10. Book : Chronology of India: From Mahabharata to Medieval Era - Vol I. Author : Vedveer Arya
11. Book : Chronology of India: From Mahabharata to Medieval Era - Vol II. Author : Vedveer Arya
-> Book number 10 and 11, talks about missing years from Indian History. Over 1380 years have been deleted from indian History in order to adjust them to Biblical timeline of 2000-4000 years by British. Thats why there a lot of confusion fron the times of ancient Indian era to 12th century AD. Vedveer Arya have exposed that. And he has also given talks regarding this on UA-cam platform.
12. Book : Brainwashed Republic. Author : Neeraj Atri
13. Book : Savarkar Part 1. Author : Vikram Sampath
14. Book : Savarkar Part 2. Author : Vikram Sampath
15. Book : Bravehearts of Bharat. Author : Vikram Sampath
16. Book : A Brief History Of Science In India. Author : Sabareesh P.A
17. Book : Understanding Mohmad. Author : Ali Sina.
-> Its available on internet for free as PDF by the author himself.
Agreed, but on the other side of Sutlej
Ashok was grandson of Chandragupta Maurya. He did not take over per se
He is referring to the NorthWestern region and the SouthEastern region as a whole. Geographically, Bihar is South and East of Punjab, even if the two regions are not continuous.
یعنی ہم سے سائوتھ میں ہے۔ ڈاکٹر صاحب آئیڈیا بتا رہے ہیں۔
Thanks moed for showing the correct map of India..😄
U r madrsachaap teacher therefore u have build this narrative that there was no bharat before 1947😂
yes and hindustan Muslims ka mulk ha 😊😊😊😊😊😊
@@numerologysecrets7705😂 yahi soch ki wajah se aaj ye halat hai musalmano ki
@@numerologysecrets7705joker😂😂 tum wo kutti kaum ho jisko koi ghr m jgh dede to tum ghr p apna naam likha lo,,,ek br aa tu india krayenge raaz tujse😂😂😂
@@priyadarshi8548 don't waste time bro by commenting bro..dogs tail can never become straight..
First of all really liked your analysis. Very coherently put. But when you say north is north of Sutlej and south is south of it, then you are saying ti from a person who is sitting in present day Pakistan (or North-West of erstwhile undivided India). But when you think as a person sitting in undivided India, south is south of Vindhyachal mountain and north is north of it. Now within this north region, you of course have the western region with places like Peshawar, Lahore, etc and then eastern region with places like Patliputra (today's Patna). So when Chandragupta Maurya, Ashoka, etc defeated kings ruling in Lahore, Peshawar, etc it was basically East dominating West within northern India. But later on when Marathas conquered a large part of northern and north-western undivided India, they did originate from South-West of undivided India. So in this case you can say South defeating North. From undivided India perspective even Raja Ranjit Singh was northern. So his taking over Peshawar from the Afghans was basically north defeating north. The above is where I have slight difference from your points. But your main thrust that South of undivided India got modern education and institutions much earlier than North is true. And within North too, East and Central parts got is before the west. So that way present day Pakistan had the misfortune of getting them much later.
All Pakistani Army Generals past and present are HARAMI and MOTHER FUCKERS.... YEH Fauj aik HARAMI Fauj hai
Great history lesson. The book Anachary by Dalrymple is a must read if you want to understand British conquest of India.
Dr Moeed Thanks for your service 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
You have a gift of communication skills
very impressive always hit the dot💯
Excellent vlog. It’s good to know the history so you can understand the past. Thank you very much!🙏
Well-done doctor, I as a history "buff" and from my ancestral stories found it all out long time ago, when I used to be in school, in my ancestral city of Lahore. I've been living in US, for a long time, and aware of these both subjects, you discussed in this vlogg. Well done 👍
All Pakistani Army Generals past and present are HARAMI and MOTHER FUCKERS.... YEH Fauj aik HARAMI Fauj hai
In the last millennium (1000 AD to 2000 AD), anything north-west of river Indus, came to be considered as non-India and was referred to as "wilayat" and its people as "wilayatis".......a term they used in the meaning of foreigner and later used it for Angraiz. The people of modern-day Punjab were by all essence Indians, and they viewed (and still view) Afghan expeditions in their Punjab as foreign invasions. But the Maratha incursion into Punjab, was not viewed as foreign invasion by Punjabis. Adina Beg (an Arain Punjabi) invited Maratha to expel Afghans from Punjab and stated (according to Tahmas Nama) that we Indians first have to remove Afghans from our soil.
Lol all saints in Punjab came from North lol I don't know what kind of Punjabi you are Martha never reached Punjab lol and who is Adina Beg lol BTW beg are turks lol
How come none of you are talking about KPT being sold to UAE ? All irrelevance news being mentioned , no talk about selling of 4 ports of Karachi to UAE ??? Are you oblivious?
Pakistan Ke Parks, Highways, Motorways, Clubs, Golf Courses, Airports, Railway Stations, Ports, Sab Kuch Bikk Gaya Bhaiii😂😂😂
Just Relax And Drink Beer 😎
Certainly a new perspective. One can agree or not is a different thing but certainly food for thought. I'd say a great effort Dr. Moeed in analysing. Anyone with an open mind open to a discussion and NOT argument will enjoy this. I certainly did. Thanks.
Are lodu chand new perspective ka matlab jhooth bolna hota hai kya....gajab chutiye bhare pade hain😭🤣🤪
Brilliant. A very detailed research based lecture on South Asia. I loved every moment of it. Its very mismerizing and well narrated. Well done Dr. Moeed.
ووٹ صرف اس کا جس نے اقوام متحدہ میں کھڑے ہو کر کہا تھا
My Believe is
😘لَا إِلٰهَ إِلَّا اللّٰه😘
Lesson of this era of history can’t get better via a ‘v-log’ than this one, great job. This ‘North-South’ paradigm is such an important subject that it needs deep study to guide us towards a better future. Well done Dr Moeed 👏 and thanks a lot.
Thank you for informative Vlog. Let me summarize this as follows:
1. Trading was established in Bombay, Delhi, Calcutta, etc.
2. Military was established in Rawalpindi, Peshawar, Gilgit, Multan, Quetta.
By these two points, we can easily see the difference.
ماشااللّہ اپ تو معلومات کا دریا بہا دیتے ھین
مین جنرل ھسٹری کی طالبعلم تھی۔ وہ ہسٹوریکل پائنٹس ancient Indian his اس وقت clear نئی تھے جو آج سمجھ مین آئے۔ اپ کو سلامت رکھے۔اس وقت اپ بہت زبردست روک پلے کر رھے ھین
Doctor Sahab, AOA, excellent study and transfer of knowledge. I think you are doing an amazing job, keep it up, and continue with this great work. 👍 Pakistan Zindabad
We should spread this in our circle, Its a new way of thinking
Excellent analysis
Very fine presentation. .....yes education and modern scientific knowledge are the decisive factors for bringing about the desired change in the future and fate of a nation or country. .
بہت عمدہ معلوماتی لیکچر۔ پاکستانیوں کو ایسی تعلیم کی شدید ضرورت ہے۔
Amazing,❤
The bottom line is..exercise of power isnt the sustainable solution instead to human prospirity,trading,is through education. Knowledge is power.
It was absolutely amazing research and information.thanks
This is a very interesting take. Interestingly in India in recent times many data points whether be it about diet, or political choices, women empowerment, various attitudes it is seen that the difference is not so much between northern India and southern India as generally conceived but axially between north-west on the one hand and South-east on the other. And this south-east got hold of European knowledge first and remains even now inclined to progressive ideas whereas north-west is comparatively conservative in spirit.
One further point which perhaps also needs to be added is that Indian elites started anglicizing but they didn't just anglicise they somehow tried infused (for good or for bad) revivalism within that anglicization. So they both wanted past glory as well as modernity! And this is seen in India. Though there is a tension between modernity and revivalistic tendencies but they also somehow fuse together to create a synergy of sorts. Pakistan on the other hand sitting on the laps of Mohenjodaro and Harappa somehow succeeded in neither taking modernity, nor past but became fixated on just one aspect of Identity - the religious identity. I think you are right that Pakistani expats from the West can play a significant role if you can take que from how significant role the Indian expats are playing for India.
Ironically, Indian intelligentsia is becoming increasingly fixated on religious identity of Sanatan Dharma, while Pakistani intelligentsia is increasingly becoming critical of the concept of statehood solely reliant on faith for its legitimacy.
The two countries will see the consequences of these reversals in the future.
بہت بہت شکریہ،
Great observation and attempt to understand the psyche of people in north and south of the subcontinent. Thank you
Yes very excellent analysis Moaid Sb, please keep it up 👍.
Moed sahib you are good in connecting dots. Thanks for giving a guide line for analyses!
Dr Moeed Pirzada you are Great ❤❤❤❤❤
Just Brilliant. May Allah bless your Dr.Sahib
I've been watching your vlogs for some time now especially for my own education, I wish more people would benefit from it like me.
The fact is that such vlogs are needed so that we can eliminate the unnecessary bias within us and understand the need for healthy competition with India, I cry like a baby when I realize that India has developed so much as a country and institutions that people like Modi are highly respected in those countries where he was considered a professional gangster, this understanding was not achieved before these vlogs.
The historical background of the subcontinent you painstakingly presented to us is very important and especially insightful, I will watch this vlog again.
What has been clearly understood is that we must now understand that Pakistan has fallen far behind India as a nation, now we have to remove these weaknesses from within ourselves and put ourselves on the path of development. It has to be done, my heart wants me to say here while speaking the dialogue of the film, O rulers, give us back those fifty years of ours, which you people took away from us because of your lust.
It is okay brother, don't be sad. I am from India, and i can understand you.
You should compete with Afghanistan and Nepal because they have $9 Billion and $10 Billion Forex Reserves, while Pakistan now has only $3.5 Billion.
It will be best if you forget India and Bangladesh and focus on Nepal, Sri Lanka and Afghanistan.
Of course your "elites" are responsible for your pathetic condition .. but don't excuse yourself, the common people of pakistan & its society from your own responsibility too. Your problems are more 'fundamental' .. but it would be 'blasphemous' to talk about them in pakistan. Nothing good can happen with Pakistan until they 'renounce' their 'fundamental' problem. Kucchh samjhe biraadar ?
Your prejudice of our PM itself is telling You people run for the Elite's needs and narrative until this continues there will continue to search for a messiah who make a better pakistan and that will lead to your Establish control
The day when you people make your narrative the real pakistan will born
@@baazinews1027Not Sri Lanka 🇱🇰, it’s too far ahead.
Thanks Dr Moeed, I really like your historical vlog!
Dear Pakistanis if you want to understand the land of your Hindu ancestors then start reading more about the cultural history of Bharat! The only nation which had never lost a cultural war!
السلام علیکم :
جناب ذاکٹر صاحب ۔
شکر ھےآپ نےموضوع چینج کیا بہت اچہا لگا آپ اسی کو جاری رکہیں آپکی بڑی مہربانی ھوگی۔👍🏻
Simply brilliant. The depth of knowledge was amazing. This means because we got Rawalpindi we are doomed.
😂😂 😢
It's Kingdom of Bappa Rawal
Dr Moeed
I fully support and agree with your vision and way forward. I always tried to convince the community to work on knowledge/ education / learning/ utilisation of energy of younger people for their development to benefit the community to exploit the untapped potential of younger generation in modern world
On one hand these Pakistanis take pride in Islamic invaders for destroying kafir temples, naming mountains as Hindukush, forcing jaziya on Hindus, converting people in mass, making harems out of Hindu women, breaking India on communal lines. Andon the other hand he is saying it was never about battle of religions bcoz Hinduism was never a religion.🤣🤣
Muslims from India have written letters to Afghans asking them to attack Delhi. It's well documented that Aurangzeb gave Hindu kings options to either die or conver to Islam. Yet this man is claiming it was never about civilizational battle (Islam vs Hinduism). He is saying Maratha had muslims in ther armies and Afghans had Hindus in their army. So what? Modi and RSS has also kept some Muslims in his party. Will you now accept Modi is not anti-Islam?
Islam has taken refuge of kaffar's secularism for far too long. Hindutva has risen after 1000 years to not only end the evils (like Caste System, Gandhism) within Hinduism but also to end the enemy of Dharma. All scores will be settled.
Moeed you must know Hinduism is not at the loggerheads with Islam only but Christianity as well. You will witness us engaging in a long battle against Missionaries in India mass-converting people with the power of Vatican Wealth. Hidutva will prove development does not need minority appeasing secularism. Hindutva will show the world how to teat Islam on the basis of Mutual Respect. Game is ON.
Very good study and insight
Reading through the comments I observe that almost all Pakistani viewers commend Dr Pirzada on his intellectual prowess and his knowledge etc while the Indians try and correct or add value to the “knowledge transfer”. We already know this as we have learnt this in school.
That is exactly Dr Pirzada tried to explain, the knowledge penetration in the areas now called Pakistan not at the level as on Indian side. Correction and addition can only come from knowledge, many on Pakistani side are listening this kind of info for the first time thus they are commending DR Pirzada for doing this great vlog.
@@javaidiqbal6361 This is really a sad state of affairs. How many years before things improve for the common Pakistani then ? Humans all live on hope. Is there no hope ?
Salam i got many many answers about the correct and actual history of subcontinent
Thanks
Very impressive historical analysis of Indian history. You are a wonderful historian as well 😊❤️
This was a brilliant session, shedding light on the most important factor that I've heard for the first time: the factor that can be considered a defining element of our current behavior, vision (lack of vision as to say) and bit of rigidness.
You should be doing more sessions on global power play as well. Cheers!
Delhi was Inderprastha in Mahabharta time and it was the capital of Pandava. So it's delveloped around 5000 year ago. I know, can understand that you don't know and has very little knowledge about ancient India.
He's talking about history not mythology bro
@sameerahmed1853i t is not a myth BTW.
The geographic locations have all been identified. Kurukshetra, dwaraka, hasitnapur, gandhar etc etc. Bhai please enlighten yourself Sir
Pakistanis have very little knowledge or don't want to acknowledge proper past of india🇮🇳.
@@sameerahmed1853 After passing 5000 years everything looks like mythology. Even you don't know your forefathers were Hindu, have you remembered anything when you and family converted to Islam, I'm sure you don't know, then how can you know and understand history before 5000 years ago. I can understand it's not your fault brother.
@@KrishanVermaJi honestly bro, you aren't making any sense. Try to look at things in a logical manner, not the prejudicial way
Interesting analysis. From my experience, a major challenge when viewing Pakistan in historical context is of classification. You have classified Pakistan as Northern in North/South divide. Is this classification correct ? considering that majority of Northern conquerors that succeeded till 1761 used to come from Persia/Central Asia and not the lands of modern day Pakistan. Now I understand that Pakistan inherits the culture created by these Northern conquerors and their descendants do live in Pakistan. But there is considerable Southern influence as well owing to the Sikh and British rule specially in Central-Southern Punjab and Sindh.
I think Pakistan is a very hard nation to characterize. I faced similar problem while reading 'Study of History' by Toynbee. Our identity is mainly ideological and lacks a concrete base. This could be a blessing or a curse. Nevertheless, the story of Pakistan is exciting and hopefully it will be long and glorious !
Thank you for the crash course on the etymology of the word India, Dr. Sb!etymology...didn't know it!! Enjoyed the vlog today!!
ڈاکٹر صاحب زبردست تجزیہ ہے
میں اسکو بہت پسند کرتا ہوں
It’s very unfortunate that a large population of even educated Pakistanis don’t see what’s happening outside Pakistani “s politics. Sadly, our politics is like a soap opera which our people follow and awaits next exciting episode
We don’t realise what is at stake ? Our youth is so demoralised My neice has just became a medical doctor at the age of 23 and now there are no jobs no future.
Thank you 💕 dr.moeed bhai for taking on a subject hardly youth of Pakistan is interested i.e development of Asian countries from 17th century onward. You have very eloquently described the war strategies of kings and religious authorities and afghan forces.
Let me give a short sports activity taking place in a small town Dina and that is a cricket match organized by cricket fans. The matches between few villages around mangla and Dina took place from 8pm to 4am.
When your own home is in fire you don't notice what's happening around you.
Dear Nazia Jehangir sahiba: it's pretty well-placed that the masses are getting torpid,disillusioned and lethargic day by day. I remember, a few years ago when I graduated in engg, how there was a climate of hope,idealism and ambitions in Pakistan. Maslaw's hierarchy of needs model fully portrays our sad state of affairs. When our basic needs of security and livable conditions are getting harder and harder to be fulfilled, expecting a scholarly view about world affairs becomes a distant dream.
ڈاکٹر آپ نے اس وی لاگ میں سمندر کو کوزے میں بند کیا ھے۔ ایسی تفصیل سے تاریخ کو ایک آسان زبان میں بہت خوبصورتی سے بیان کی ھے۔ بہت شکریہ 😊
You rightly pointed out historically we were not 'Hindus', but we were Rajputs, Maratha, Bengali, Tamil and so on. Again you are right, if we were united as Hindus, the muslim/turks/persian invaders would not have conquered India/Bharat.
Agreed however nothing has changed we r still not hindus
Very informative and interesting!!! 🎉
We Pathans and Punjabis of Pakistan took pride for centuries as military race like Gorkhas and Sikhs of India, but actually we were less littrate than Central and South Indians; who refused to get abused by British as their mercenary forces.
I agreed with you, North of Sutlaj can not be compatible with South of Sutlaj in western democracies.❤❤❤
V. Informative . mashAllah. Thanku for raising our thought process.
Doctor. India’s progress is something to be envied for the neighbouring countries. How long Pakistan will continue to stew on its own juices.?? Woe to the enemies of the state. 😡
internal disquiet in Pakistan, including the unsustainable and unconstitutional interference of the military in civilian affairs, the incompetence of its policy elites, and its dysfunctional economic affairs are the reason why your country is doomed.
Well said👌
Pakistan should compete with Afghansitan.
There is a lot that Pakistanis can learn from the success of Afghans.
Forget About India.
_"Woe to the enemies of the state"_
What do you do when those are the very people supposed to be serving the state?
Ye UA-cam ka sabse achha video hai .. Thank you so much for explaining in such detail in a very simple way
Balochistan was always an independent state and will be inshaa Allah.
Pakistan with Generals is a Curse on humanity.
Balochistan was never a state. It was 4 princely state with quetta municipality.
Dr Sahib you got it explain perfectly,
Delhi ka real name ... Indraprastha tha.. You have a lake of knowledge about bharat
Illiterate indian its lack not lake.🤣🤣
Thanks for initiating this kind of debate. I have one question regarding this debate: why did British focus only upon Southern side of India while coming for trade via maritime route? Why didn't they choose Sindh too for trade purpose? as Arabian sea is along the coastal side of Sindh and this coastal area has geo strategic and geo economical potential from date back of history?
Brother Allah blessed you always❤
you gave a different perspective of the history ,thanks for enlightening your viewers ,keep going
Thanks to the Muslims of India who sacrificed their mothers and sisters to the Mughal invaders in the past , we respect u..
Talwar ke darr se salvar pehen liya..
پچھلے ستر سالہ انڈو پاک سیاسی تناظر میں یہ ویلاگ بہت سے سوالات کے جواب دیتا ھے۔۔ علم میں اضافہ ھوا اور حالات کو سوچنے سمجھنے کی نئی راہیں ملی ھیں۔
ایک اچھے اور ہمہ جہت لیکچر پر اپکا شکر گزار ھوں۔
نیک تمنائیں ❤
Doc, I watch your v logs very attentively for educational purposes being a teacher of pak studies . I must share with you that I was giving a realistic view to my students ,which was quite contrary to what was being depicted in our books .But since regime change , we are also under pressure and fear to talk about realities ..
Kya baat hay Moid Sahab, you nailed it. MashaAllah.
Hello! Sir, you are doing a lot for this poor nation. I wish to be a part of your struggle. Carl Marx has done this before. No doubt that south has done alot in education but at the same time north was prepared for producing soldiers in the same way as now iin Pakistan. Salt belt is fixed for better soldier, their culture their stories their loves are all for soldiers. // if we insist repeatedly that like other world our leaders must be honest like angel. And repeat this statement frequently we may be able to achieve this, that people should not vote to dishonest. Your statement will be a great help in the regard that "discuss this everywhere "that don't vote to Dishonest. That's all for this thanks
Excellent Sir explain very briefly. Absolutely amazing research 👏
Good presentation 👏 👌 my son got to learn a lot from history your presented Dr sb!😊👍
Tell ur son to type modern indian history , medieval history on youtube he will get so many playlist for history lectures he can watch lectures and learn original history pakistanies shows forged history
@@abhishekkumartiwari5191 thank you 😊 🙏
EXCELLENT COURAGE, THANKS.
Excellent I salute you for your beautiful presentation of history. In joint India Lahore was main Education centre and Dhaka was main commercial Center.
Rarely come across such elaborate research on Hindustan history. Keep it up.👍👍
Again a pakistani telling the wrong history to boast his PoV😂
Doc your analysis is very deep and intellectual
Islam... Convert, Zajiya or Fight,
Islam is conversion factory.
100 % right doctor sahib
Patliputra the modern city Patna capital of Bihar
As always your this lecture is full knowledge. Thank you Sir.
There was NEVER any country called "India" or "Bharat" until August 15, 1947. One has to go all the way back to Mauryan Empire to come anywhere close to what is now India. But the boundaries of Mauryan Empire are simply based on names mentioned in ancient texts and it's not clear if those place-names were actually part of the empire. That is why there are many different maps of the extent of the Mauryan Empire, none of which include southern India.
The word "India" is derived from the Sindhu, the Indus River, and for Persians who named it "Hind," it simply represented a region around the Indus River and beyond. This was later adopted by Arabs who then distinguished Sindh from Hindh because Sindh had become part of the Omayyad Empire.
The word "Bharat" was also some region in India, like Siberia in Russia, which never had any boundaries. Even when the British ruled the Subcontinent, it was called the British Raj, Burma was part of it, and the Viceroy of India also handled affairs of the Trucial States which are now UAE, Bahrain and Qatar.
The Subcontinent was always a region, like Europe, which consisted of various kingdoms, the Western regions of which were often part of the Persian Empire, Greeco-Bacterian Kingdom, Omayyad Empire, and later Afghan kingdoms, all of which left their mark (and progeny) in this rich cultural mix. Since the area that is now Pakistan was closer to Afghanistan and the Middle East, it was more influenced by them, both culturally, religiously and ethnically.
India always has had dozens of ethnic groups, just it had many kingdoms. To say that there was some "Hindu" ethnic group would be historically and scientifically wrong. Because of conquests and migrations (mostly due to Mongol invasions in Central Asia) ethnic makeup of the Muslim population in the Subcontinent began to change around 1000-1200 AD. It was also state policy among Muslim rulers of India to encourage Muslim immigration from Central Asia and sometimes the entire armies consisted of Mamluk soldiers. Immigrants and soldiers were given land grants, so they could survive in their adopted homeland. [This has been recorded in my own family history which goes back to hundreds of years]. Over time, these immigrants married locals and were so fully assimilated into the local culture that it was hard to distinguish them from the native population. Thus the "ethnic mix" among Muslims was not the same as among the "ethnic mix" of the larger Hindu population.
Since Islam rejected the notion of "caste," "Muslim" became an identity by itself. I know that both Indians and Pakistanis try to create an Indian or Pakistani identity but make a terrible mistake by confusing religion with ethnic and national identities. Each person has many MANY identities. One can be Hindu and be American, British, Indonesian, Surinamese or Guyanese. It takes hundreds or perhaps thousands of years for national identities to develop. Hardly any country now has just one ethnic or religious group. National identities are lot more complex and have to do with commonality of purpose, ideals, and culture rather than ethnicity. This is why even the UN speaks of "self-determination" rather than imposition of an identity on any group.
you must have come by the news that indian aviation industry has ordered 500 plus commercial flight from both boeing as well as Airbus while your PM is begging for $1 billion dollar 💵 to save punjab from being default. Yes I intentionally said Punjab becaue Sharif's jurisdictions is upto Punjab only
Yours is a typical islamist pov .. & hence easily debunkable. India has always through out its history of thousands of years been a civilastional nation. Country is a relatively new concept the world over. Pakistan may be a new country today .. but it is still a part of Indian civilisational nation. Your unease with this fact is none of anybody's concern. You may keep reciting your islamist pov & insecure pakistan studies style assuaging of personal humiliation in which ever way you feel comfortable with. You have already witnessed where it has taken pakistan to, in the past 75 years since it was manufactured. But lage raho bhai.
Jo apni mitti ko bhoolta hai .. mitti bhi usse bhula deti hai.
QabilAGhor, *You may still have to go back many millennia to know why India is called Bharat. Indus-Sarswati culture also called Indus valley civilization during 6000 BCE to 1900 BCE was so vast encompassing 1.5 million sq.kms. From Mehrgarh (Balochistan) to Shortugal in present Pakistan and Kalibangan, Rakhigarhi and other Saraswati sites near Delhi to Lothal and Daimabad(submerged ruins in gulf of Khambhat - Gujarat ) in south western India. According to Vedic chronology many great Bharata kings and others of equal prominence ruled in India had close contact with the cities in the Indus valley civilization area.*
Bharat was the son of Pururva thousands of years back who ruled India.
good preview ,but u should make note which is u used to do ,because it lack substance and have factual error
Guy peddling lies to prove his point. I stopped viewing halfway
Same even i stopped viewing him.😄
He's just another Zayid Hameeid 😄
Excellent talk.
Contribution of Pakistani scholars in comedy is unparalleled. From Pervez Hoodboy to this guy, great comedians. Mazaa aa gaya. Keep it up. 😂😂😂😂
Pakistani politicians are much better entertainers. Most of the country in general are born entertainers and clowns. The only thing they hate is logic🤣
when you have no counterargument, you will come up with these sorts of bullshit.
@@a.a1594 counter argument seriously🤣🤣do you know what is critical appraisal? Reading 1 book and giving narratives will work with Pakistanis not Indians. Modern history is mix of epigraphy, epigeneticist, paleontologist, philogists to archeologists to epigraphists to many more.
Example of a 'gas' South was NOT developed until Westerners came🤣🤣 while you people were learning to wipe your backside, kings of South India were capturing Myanmar to Bali with full developed maritime navy. Atleast read history of 'Largest temple in the world'-Angkor Wat'🤣🤣or read where your Abbu China learnt Kungfu from or Bodhidharma is🤣🤣
Meanwhile Indian scholars have flooded the social media like flies, but not one of them has the intellectual capacity to come up with a reasonable rebuttal to his 'comedy'. Spamming emojis and incoherent rants seems to be the limit to their ''contributions''.
@@alamgir5553 very well summarized.
Dr. Sahib, is this (GVS) your channel?
Why do u not consider haider sir a journalist???it is not good to be arrogant for a TRUE journalist, he has written more than 400 column columns columns in newspapers, aur kya journalist ke singh hote hain
It was very informative and it does make sense in terms of the present state based on the arguments presented by you. Great job.
TODAY PATNA (bihar) is modern day patliputra
Excellent historical vlog. Thanks Peerzada sahib. Aap nai samandar kozai mai band kerr diya
Why you have neglected Pushayabhuti Empire , Gupta Empire , Shunga Empire Palas , Rastrakutas , chalukyas , marathas , Ahoms , Kharvela Empire , Cholas , Pandayas , Palavas Vijaynagar empire , Sikh Empre etc , All these empires/Kingdom some way to other extended towards north , Your Analysis was based on a specific location but India sub continent was much bigger in size , by Contemplating all , it was not always right to say North always pushed the south by neglecting the mentions
Don't Take This Pirzada Seriously Brother
Just watch for entertainment like Kapil Sharma Show, or don't watch if you want to preserve your brain cells
😂😂
Because those are all imaginary empires 😂😂😂
He just trying to say Brit’s invented Indian civilisation
@@goodvibes6715 he literally ate the timeline from 300B.C to 1000A.D , Nearly 1300 years , What a dumb Analysis to come up with 🤣🤣
@@آوارہمانندِہوا Nalanda university , Mahabalipuram temples , Jain temples , Sanchi stupas , Kailash temples of Ajanta and Elora , Elephanta caves , Hampi City , Bodh gaya Boudh temples and millions more , Kisne banaya tha bhai "Arbo ne "🤣🤣
Dr sahib what a brilliant analysis, I agree with every word of your statement!!
Excellent. 😲 Stay Stuck in your version of the Past. 🙂
What else can a Pakistani Do, where a Foreign Supported Government and has been imposed on the Citizens 😂
What a Pity 🥰 Focus on your country, and don't dig the past. These are artificial methods to raise your morale when there is nothing good going for you or your party. 🤗 Try and live in the real life. 😊
And you stop fighting your past cause you can’t change it😂😂😂
Great Overview Of North Vs South Perspectives But There Is Also Another Angle Which Is Khurasan Civilization In The West & Indic Civilization In The East As River Indus Is Its Boundary!
Moria's and Ashok were of northern part. Geography can't be changed . One can't shift Taxla and today's Patna to south .
Patana is in bihar where chandragupta born and taxila where chanakya the stubborn Brahmin leader born.
Maurya*, Ashoka*
MashAllah very informative thanks
Excellent bread, In all coming vlog plz add 10/15 mini.should be discuss around the world important issues & Our area History also. Thnx Sir, Regards, tc
Imran khan body language during his visit to White House was confident….he talked with eye in eye …..this is pirazadas analysis..someone shud teach him journalism….😂
First video where Dr Moeed Pirzada talks sense. Kudos!
I am from india 🇮🇳🇮🇳
I just want to ask one question to all the pakistanis....
Question :- can you name a single king who fullfill 3 conditions..
1. Born in Pakistan
2.ruled over Pakistan
3. Todays Pakistani respect him.
Raja Rangit Singh
@@mtsardar
You didn't even spell his name right!😂
Hi, can u name one from India ???
Thanks
Ranjit Singh was born in Gujrawala
@@yarkhattak2997seriously… like seriously
Excellent report well done Continue education and training our presnt and future generations.
Excellent , absolutely loved it. Pakistan is a state carved out of the frontier of India , Jinnah and Muslim league were blinded by their greed for a separate state and didn't realise that they were carving out an extremely poor and difficult country
Yes totally agree with these sentiments
Doc - THIS WAS A MASTERPIECE!!!!!
Looking at the Indian comments, it seems they are also taught history their own controlled ways. Most of Moeed's contents refer to Western literature but they think it is a comedy.
It is most of it. Geographical referring is wrong maurya was from present day Bihar which is in north not south, South india had other empires like cholas marathas n all so he researched it but he researched selfishly
@@VickySharma-oz3vp You have to give him some leeway about his bearing. His origin is Kashmir. Everything below him is south. In Punjabi, south direction is called Deccan (modern day Telangana) and north is Parbat (means mountain). It does not mean there are no mountains south of Punjab. He did mix Mauryan and Gupta empires though.
He is right about the word Hindu as a single religious entity. Looking at the millennia of history of "Bharat", it is a very recent phenomenon taken from British colonial literature.
@@abrmuni569 its not about that he is right or wrong its about his intentions behind it and they are not right for sure
@@VickySharma-oz3vp Good thing you mentioned about his intention. We should all correct his telling of the facts. No one can fully judge or control someone's intention. Allow me to assume he offends many Indians. You might be surprised, he offends even more Pakistanis because they are not taught what he is telling them. A typical Pakistani does not listen to such "disinformation". That was the gist of my first comment of this thread. Delighted to interacting with you.
@@abrmuni569 appreciate your response.
Well if he is doing it knowing that the mentality of pakistani ppl then it becomes worst thsn what their establishment is doing to them.
Half knowledge or you can say "disinformation" can do more damage to a society.
I enjoyed your historical review.
Dr sb just to correct one small point, the Morias were also Aryans from the north. Original inhabitants of these areas were Dravidians of South India and they never conquered the north.