7 years after the review this game is still excellent and content is still being released for it. Solo or co-op, it is exciting. The scenarios are replayable and difficult enough to feel a sense of relief and accomplishment when you finish alive. Just buy it. Every game is a new story. (Often tragedy)
I just played this game today. Second edition. It was one of those games that I loved playing and the fact that we didn't win (i.e. DIED) 3 times just made us want to play it even more.
Hey Tom! When reviewing games with tons of different tokens and cards and so on - like Robinson Crusoe - Could you please quickly make a point about the game box too? Some games are great with their inserts, some have almost nothing at all so you're forced to put everything in bags or make your own system (Descent 2nd edition, I'm looking at you!), and for a lot of people the latter is quite annoying. I personally would love to know what the boxes/inserts look like, thanks. :)
Question for you Tom: How do you teach a game of this complexity and know which gaming group would have the patience and sufficient attention span to hold on to the very end of game explanation? Maybe a video on the subject would be cool.
It's honestly nice to know in advance when I order a game, if I need to order a bunch of little fish-bait boxes and foam inserts aswell. It's not as much about whether it would affect my decision of whether or not to purchase the game, as it is about the overall impression.
12 років тому
I agree, not necessary for everyone, I just said that strictly from my point of view :) No one has universal tastes, no one thus is entitled to any universal truth. I take that as a self evident
I enjoy coops and Euros and this looks like a good game that I would play. One aspect I do not enjoy in coops is the "Leader"(one person) taking over the game. I can see this happening in this game.
I'm kind of new to gaming so watched the instruction video about the game. My god, 45 minute video and I'm completely lost, I think this is better suited to experienced players to be honest! I was looking for a single player game but it's back to Ticket To Ride with the girlfriend for me!!
furstyferret81 watch the actual game being played. I got halfway thru 45 min vid and I was so lost. Watching the game being played by Watch It Played videos totally made the game so easy to understand.
MAC ARMS LLC lord of the rings if you love the movies/books. Its fairly cheap to buy second hand. One to look into. Its a collectible though. The art is awesome.
This game is great fun :) Was lucky enought to get it a couple of weeks ago, but now I see it's out of stock many places. But it will probably be printet again next year(?), and a new scenario (free downloadable) is coming before Christmas.
awesome work! The guy also designed Stronghold and Pret a Porter. Can't wait for him to designing something simpler and with less text (less language dependency). The ideas are great, the implementations could be even better if he makes them more "family type" and mainstream.
Haha that part in me that has to always clean up after game night cringes when I see it, but i enjoy how they show pretty much everything in the box...I just wish it didn’t mess with my ocd. 😆
The game sounds interesting to me. I read through the designer diary and it sounds like in the original versions it was basically just a guaranteed way to die. The event cards coming back and reacting to your choices is an interesting mechanic. It's on my "to play" list, though I doubt I'd get a copy for our family and group.
So I've been waiting to get this game. Does anyone have any idea where I can purchase this game for a decent price ($50-$70).? I see it on Amazon for $90 + which is way out of my price range. If anyone could be of assistance it would be most appreciated! Thank you for your time, and Tom I enjoy all your videos! Keep it up.
bradymccann their are individual vp's for each scenario to judge who played the best. This game is also up there with Mage Knight and Hornet Leader as a brilliant solo experience.
My friend bought this game and I have played it twice, I did the first and second scenario... I wasn't a massive fan (at least of those 2 scenarios) but am going to play out all the scenario's because Tom and Zee like it so much... I'm assuming it gets alot harder on the later scenario's.
I'd love to have this game, ecpecially after watching RickRoyal's playthrough. However, not only is it very expensive, but also not very widely available. I've had zero success of finding a European online store which actually sells it. Too bad... =(
...my god, did you just say 'The Witcher'? From the same designer, really? Okay, that's going to be a must buy, no matter what... can't get much more exciting than that. =)
I love how the game looks, but find the market of this game a little too small. Most hardcore eurogamers hate coop, and most coop players I know hate complicated and/or long setup.
Hi! I haven't tried the game myself, but check out Ricky Royal's playthrough here on UA-cam (.../user/rickkcroyal). It´'s very informative and entertaining to watch.
This is my kind of game. Fresh smt. new COMPLEX. I hate playing a similar game with one that already I own (because I don't have the time to play every game so it should be good and not borrows me and fun). I think that this one seems to go into my collection in the future.
7 years after the review this game is still excellent and content is still being released for it. Solo or co-op, it is exciting. The scenarios are replayable and difficult enough to feel a sense of relief and accomplishment when you finish alive.
Just buy it. Every game is a new story. (Often tragedy)
One of my favourite new buys. Brings everyone together and gives off the sense of urgency and teamwork.
Do you know of any other games like that? Or have any other suggestions? I know it's been three years but still... :)
@@vesper7750 Spirit Island
That shirt is on point.
I just played this game today. Second edition. It was one of those games that I loved playing and the fact that we didn't win (i.e. DIED) 3 times just made us want to play it even more.
My favourite game this year. We bought it at the games comvention in Essen. It' also great for two players which I love.
Hey Tom! When reviewing games with tons of different tokens and cards and so on - like Robinson Crusoe - Could you please quickly make a point about the game box too? Some games are great with their inserts, some have almost nothing at all so you're forced to put everything in bags or make your own system (Descent 2nd edition, I'm looking at you!), and for a lot of people the latter is quite annoying. I personally would love to know what the boxes/inserts look like, thanks. :)
Back in the days of UA-cam when people made videos from their passion, not trying to get paid. Well done 👌
I would argue that even though I get paid now, it's still all passion for me.
Question for you Tom: How do you teach a game of this complexity and know which gaming group would have the patience and sufficient attention span to hold on to the very end of game explanation? Maybe a video on the subject would be cool.
I could swear i had that exact same shirt about 10 years ago. Purchased in Thailand.
It's honestly nice to know in advance when I order a game, if I need to order a bunch of little fish-bait boxes and foam inserts aswell. It's not as much about whether it would affect my decision of whether or not to purchase the game, as it is about the overall impression.
I agree, not necessary for everyone, I just said that strictly from my point of view :) No one has universal tastes, no one thus is entitled to any universal truth. I take that as a self evident
great review! i have the game and i love it!
thanx for a great channel tom!
2024! Still the best of the best!
I like that shirt.
I enjoy coops and Euros and this looks like a good game that I would play. One aspect I do not enjoy in coops is the "Leader"(one person) taking over the game. I can see this happening in this game.
I'm kind of new to gaming so watched the instruction video about the game. My god, 45 minute video and I'm completely lost, I think this is better suited to experienced players to be honest! I was looking for a single player game but it's back to Ticket To Ride with the girlfriend for me!!
furstyferret81 watch the actual game being played. I got halfway thru 45 min vid and I was so lost. Watching the game being played by Watch It Played videos totally made the game so easy to understand.
Thanks, I'll try that!
I was told this was a great solo game. Would you recommend it solo? I was looking for the top 5 or 10 best solo games video. What would your best be?
MAC ARMS LLC lord of the rings if you love the movies/books. Its fairly cheap to buy second hand. One to look into. Its a collectible though. The art is awesome.
best solo game ever: Mage Knight. You don't even need the expansions
Mage knights by far. In my opinion any single adult that loves puzzles should buy this game
you can pre-order it at miniaturemarket's website
i cant find this game anywhere i really want it. all website have no set release date but will gladly take my money. where can i get a copy
This game is great fun :) Was lucky enought to get it a couple of weeks ago, but now I see it's out of stock many places. But it will probably be printet again next year(?), and a new scenario (free downloadable) is coming before Christmas.
Was given this as a present recently but haven't had a chance to play yet. Really looking forward to it. Nice work, Tom!
have you played it yet?
awesome work! The guy also designed Stronghold and Pret a Porter. Can't wait for him to designing something simpler and with less text (less language dependency). The ideas are great, the implementations could be even better if he makes them more "family type" and mainstream.
I'm probably the only one who gets really pissed off when they pour out all the components in the box all over the place lol
I also hate it 😉☺
me too, thought I was the only one.
It is weirdly annoying hey. I always try and skip it lol
I think it's one of the most brilliant things, no kidding.
Haha that part in me that has to always clean up after game night cringes when I see it, but i enjoy how they show pretty much everything in the box...I just wish it didn’t mess with my ocd. 😆
The game sounds interesting to me. I read through the designer diary and it sounds like in the original versions it was basically just a guaranteed way to die. The event cards coming back and reacting to your choices is an interesting mechanic. It's on my "to play" list, though I doubt I'd get a copy for our family and group.
Is this a great solo game? Looks like a pumped version of Friday at first glance.
Maybe because the theme is to survive on deserted island, and that's the most familiar element in Robinson Crusoe's story?
I just picked this up off coolstuffinc and then I checked back and it was already sold out. Excited to get it in and play it!
When will this board game be in stock?!
I already have this game on preorder and am anxiously awaiting its arrival!
I Know i am 6 years too late but how did it go?
Would that affect your decision on whether or not you were going to buy it?
So I've been waiting to get this game. Does anyone have any idea where I can purchase this game for a decent price ($50-$70).? I see it on Amazon for $90 + which is way out of my price range. If anyone could be of assistance it would be most appreciated! Thank you for your time, and Tom I enjoy all your videos! Keep it up.
Sounds like the Dark Souls of co-op games. Cannot wait to try it.
another great review that makes me wanna buy another game. and I just started
this game looks pretty badass, going to have to check this out..
I guess that's why Arkham, Horror is so popular!
I like the idea. cooperative though....... I like being able to have a single winner.
play solo ;p
no fun in that.
depends... but understandable
bradymccann their are individual vp's for each scenario to judge who played the best. This game is also up there with Mage Knight and Hornet Leader as a brilliant solo experience.
My friend bought this game and I have played it twice, I did the first and second scenario... I wasn't a massive fan (at least of those 2 scenarios) but am going to play out all the scenario's because Tom and Zee like it so much... I'm assuming it gets alot harder on the later scenario's.
Are you saying you played it twice and won both? :O
I'd love to have this game, ecpecially after watching RickRoyal's playthrough. However, not only is it very expensive, but also not very widely available. I've had zero success of finding a European online store which actually sells it. Too bad... =(
Try Ozone
Why Robinson Crusoe is So Expansive Board Game
i didnt know you could keep EGGS with you boardgames ... is it somekind of guru trick ?
...my god, did you just say 'The Witcher'? From the same designer, really? Okay, that's going to be a must buy, no matter what... can't get much more exciting than that. =)
maybe you die but sometimes i survive, because i play a lot, i realize that it's hard to survive
great review, and what a nice and chalenging game!
See everyone in march. :-(
i hope those eggs aren't going off. There's an "easter egg" for ya
Cool game. And nice shirt;)
I love how the game looks, but find the market of this game a little too small. Most hardcore eurogamers hate coop, and most coop players I know hate complicated and/or long setup.
Oh gosh. I am not the only one was thinking " how am I supposed to win this game"... Gosh. haha
Hi!
I haven't tried the game myself, but check out Ricky Royal's playthrough here on UA-cam (.../user/rickkcroyal). It´'s very informative and entertaining to watch.
Two cooperative games based on the Crusoe story came at the same time. The other one was by a Spanish designer I think. Awkward.
don't egg him on
AUTO...BUY! :)
Then you're playing it wrong
Iggrassil is not hard :/ I beat it with ALL the cards included almost 100% of the time.
OMG what is with the wooden tokens in al lhtese games??? BOOOOOOOOOORING!!!!
This is my kind of game. Fresh smt. new COMPLEX. I hate playing a similar game with one that already I own (because I don't have the time to play every game so it should be good and not borrows me and fun). I think that this one seems to go into my collection in the future.