History in Five: Tom Clavin and Bob Drury on Red Cloud, An American Legend
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 лип 2024
- Learn more about THE HEART OF EVERYTHING THAT IS at books.simonandschuster.com/Hea... Tom Clavin and Bob Drury, the authors of THE HEART OF EVERYTHING THAT IS, present five things that you should know about Red Cloud, the only Indian war chief to defeat the U.S. in battle.
I am only a few hundred pages into your superb book.
In this video you appear to attribute the savagery of the Sioux to all "Indians." Even Eastern Sioux were more pacific than Red Cloud's (Western) Oglagla Sioux according to your book.
And it isn't as though Small Pox was a pleasant way to die either. Or starvation. Or simple humiliation.
Genocide? Europeans never ever did that did they?
We are all "Killer Ape," a fatally flawed species.
Red Cloud was a peaceful man. That's why he won his "war". He took care of the women and children. He also had concerns about the Sisseton tribal unit. Little known fact. This came down as verbal tradition. He was a cousin to Sitting Bull. My birth Father, Marvin Campbell is a Vietnam vet buried on the Sisseton tribe. He is a Wind-Talker. He is buried with other people who deserve honor and dignity, but got none, because of race.
I don't know how much my birth Father, Marvin Campbell who is half Sioux and a Red Cloud descendant and my stepdad both Vietnam Veterans fit in to this work of Miracle. Red Cloud is a Great Chief and a Great peace maker in the world. May his descendants find a way to reach out to see that the Black Hills is protected from those who want to destroy its natural resources. I work as Railroad driver for BNSF. I'm union. I only hope that I can drive again one day after a nasty car accident 5 years ago. Healthy now 👌 though. Going to school. Back on track. Let me clarify: I am driving. Class B provisional passenger endorsement. Just don't have the passengers yet because nobody has hired me yet and nobody wants to properly train me through school. Education is all I have at this point in time.
Outstanding book gentlemen!
I finished reading this and it's excellent. I would highly recommend it if you're a fan of that era or subject in history.
We're glad you enjoyed it!
Such an illuminating book, thank you.
Wow... a true American hero. Thank you for informing us about Red Cloud!
American? He’d hate to be called that, he would hate America, for ripping everything away from his people, and also many other tribes, we may have killed our own prior to your invasion, but that doesn’t come close to the brutality and bloodshed caused by America
@@jasoncano527 Thank you. Couldn't have said it any better.
...i'm related to Red Cloud...
you've got to be kidding me with the opening remarks
I purchased your book for my brother who likes the Indians.
I am reading this book right now. I am glad that is exposes the atrocities of both sides. This book is not politically correct, this book is true. Should be in history class.
Thanks for the feedback!!
Agree... best read I’ve had in awhile. Really enjoyed the book and feel it provides an honest view of both sides. Both spared no kindness when it came to taking land and resources...
we're is the history notes at ?
is it in a Museum ?
we're did u find it ?
is it own back by the Lakota people ?
May you do a document video of it so we as indigenous people may see it forever on UA-cam!.
thank you
from
city horse comanchce
R.I.P ah CO ha ne
Quanna Parker
may your soul rest in peace old one and every other Nation Native American ancestors every bother and Sister's someone lost in those old day
ah CO ha ne.
All that they took they will have to restore. The Law of Karma states that All must be restored to it's💔 original 📯 position of glory to the Original American🌎 People!🕊️ 🇺🇸
💛
Red Cloud's Folk by George E. Hyde was published in 1937. It is still without peer, and so well-written that modern historians seem dull by comparison. These gentlemen have added to the western archive but to get it right, absolutely right, one must read Hyde's book.
These men’s ignorance regarding “the reasons why” behind Lakota traditions and fear of being eliminated by such a deceptive and conniving culture was why they did what they did.
The Wašíču is the evil behind the world due to their greed and desire of power and rule.
The Wašíču is “as far from himself as a
Hawk is from the moon”.
Holy smokes the amount of vids is crazy
I'm the best ghost a friend can have.
Red Cloud had lost political power for being a mediator and ambassador for Peace. As a result he decided "If you can't beat em join em."
Very interesting and very well narrated. The expression "noble savage", used in all languages to refer to indigenous peoples all over the world is a myth. Nobility and savagery don't belong in the same sentence. I am glad you addressed this misused and out of place expression. My thinking is that it was often used out of guilt by those who had committed massacres and atrocities against indigenous people only to discover that in spite of their savagery they were very human. I could be wrong but it is such a contradiction with reality that it seems like an after thought.
Thank you so much I’ve listen to the episode they were amazing. I just have one question whatever happened with Samuel Deon the French trader that became friends with Red Cloud and eventually married into the Lakota tribe. I have tried my best to figure out who Samuel Deon actually married.
(I am a (Deon)
I am a tribal member of the Oglala Lakota)
I’m trying to track down my family tree. Any help would be awesome. Thanks I hope to here from you soon. 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
An elder telling an old wize tale.
Hey - start with naming the Lakota People right !
Bob, Tom - Great to watch your video, thank you.
I became particularly fascinated with he disparities between Red Cloud's & Sitting Bull's stances whilst reading Dee Brown's books 'Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee' & 'The American West'. I subsequently read your book to further my knowledge of Red Cloud, and Nathaniel Philbrick's 'The Last Stand' to further my knowledge of Sitting Bull.
I'm watching from my camper home in Clanton Alan a with my 2 dogs
Where was the native encampment during the battle of the Fetterman fight.
Was that not the halo reach soundtrack at the beginning?
Super objective appraisal, thanks guys. One issue left out was that along with the continuing Black Hills war, there is still inter-tribal conflict; if you are a member of the Crow Reservation you definitely don't want to go to a Sioux Reservation, you might not live very long.
The path of the righteous man is beset on all sides by the iniquities of the selfish and the tyranny of evil men. Blessed is he who, in the name of charity and good will, shepherds the weak through the valley of darkness, for he is truly his brother's keeper and the finder of lost children.
And I will strike down apon thee with great vengeance and furious anger those who attempt to poison and destroy my brothers and you will kno I am the lord when I lay my vengeance apon u
All makes for a good rugby game.
are you kidding me? shocking of how the Indians waged war on each other. the civil war war was noble and not horrific?
these people are perfect example of how every white person justified slavery and killing of millions of Indians.
@@shivanibala8299 Yup. Glad someone else picked up on that. Civilized East my ass.
Yep - thank you for saying this. I do not recommend this video.
You guys are all a bunch of delusional crybabies if you have a problem with this description. Red Cloud once saved a man from drowning, only to scalp and kill him on shore. Was he condemned or punished for this? No, because it's how it was.
The Civil War was brutal, imagine being torn apart by a lead ball that shatter bones and shreds your insides, but they never scalped or did anything cruel like natives did.
If people did what natives did back then today, it would be a war-crime.
yeha noha..brule lakota
chamber hmmm!
Chief Redcloud is my ancestor me and my mom think hes around the cousin to uncle part but he is my ancestor im related to him.
leg
I have been listening to Legends of the Old West by Chris Wimmer, Red Cloud’s War. It’s entirely relevant it seems to me.
- And then the harassment started…Attacks happened almost on a daily basis.
- The psychological toll inflicted on the [soldiers] was almost as bad as the physical toll…
- Nothing seems to have ever been done about the attacks.
“The white man made me a lot of promises but they only kept one. They promised to take my land and they took it.”
Ep 4 - Red Cloud had been chipping away. I am reminded of today’s GOP chipping away, running off qualified or principled congressmen, and pledging to take away voting rights, abortion rights, Medicare and Social Security, and any other social safety programs…and by God they are going to do it.
Chris Wimmer, Red Cloud’s War.
Legends of the Old West, Season 4, Ep 3.
Such a generic Wašíču point of view 🤯🤯🤯
Remember the quote “History is always written by the winners. When two cultures clash, the loser is obliterated, and the winner writes the history books-books which glorify their own cause and disparage the conquered foe. As Napoleon once said, 'What is history, but a fable agreed upon? '”
Indians are from India. Natives is the term if we’re being politically correct. How did they know what people were doing before they got here? 😂
This guy said “scalped ofcourse”
To the Americans coming west , it was horrific, but to the Indians , it was natural”
Bad aftertaste after that convo. A’ho!
I think the myth of the 'Noble Savage' has been oversold by historians in terms of how pervasive it is in our culture, in their characteristic eagerness to overturn misconceptions about the past (not that I am in any way criticizing the authors of this excellent book for doing that). As far as I can tell, only a minority of people have ever believed the story that native Americans were inherently any more peaceful than anyone else, mostly members of the counterculture in the 1960s - 70s and a scattering of academics.
I personally bought into the myth to some degree for a few years when I first started learning about natives, but further exposure quickly put paid to it. Interestingly, Hollywood, which had a role in starting the image of the Noble Savage, probably helped to dispel it with highly popular films such as Dances with Wolves and The Last of the Mohicans depicting brutal warfare between native tribes having been released 25 years ago now.
Last of the Mohicans yeah, but not Dances with Wolves. It portrays them as peace-loving hippies who were victims to the white man and did no wrong.
chamber
NATIVE AMERICANS NOT INDIANS!!!!
proof
Finished this book today. Amazing book that shows how Natives were with one another and how the US government treated them. Showed the injustices the natives did to one another and the injustice the US did to the natives through broken treaties. The natives were not angels either though...
Because we fought against each other doesn’t mean we deserved to be Massively murdered. NOTHING can justify what your ancestors did to my people. NOTHING!
we never scalp people we got that from the white people one day the red nation is gunna rise again and its going to be a blessings for the people
Go live on the Rez before you write a book us natives,
weren't
oh a gop tea documentary, i refuse to watch garbage
I know where you live 💩head😇
You Americans lost and pulled out of Vietnam, Iraq, Syria and Afghanistan..!! It's time you Americans pull out of the Black Hills..!!! NATIVE INDEPENDENCE!!