TERRIFYING! Train Crashes After Landslide (Stonehaven Derailment) - DISASTER BREAKDOWN
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 чер 2024
- This video went out to my Patrons on Patreon Two Days before going out publicly. Consider joining here from £1 per month: / disasterbreakdown
Twitter: / chloe_howiecb
Want to hear more of those HST Engines?
• Valenta HST! WARNING 6...
At 9:38 in the morning on August 12th, 2020. A train derailed in Scotland, precisely here near to the town of Stonehaven. On that fateful day, a nation received the news that had a fatal train accident took place on the railway line that runs between Aberdeen and Dundee. For the first time in over a decade, a train not only derailed in a devastating accident but induced fatal injury.
Railway accidents have become exceedingly rare in the United Kingdom in recent years, coinciding with this, deaths related to the railway have also drastically decreased to nearly zero. Most deaths related to rail accidents in the UK after 2004 have mostly been linked level crossing incidents. But this never really involved a train going off the rails, with one notable exception in 2007. Needless to say that rail travel in Britain, despite its many flaws, is incredibly safe.
Which may be why so much attention was drawn to the 2020 derailment at Carmont in Scotland. It immediately became headline news across the country. It was the first major rail accident in years. It should be noted right off the start, that this could have been far greater tragedy than it already was. Occurring in 2020 at the height of the Pandemic, the number of rail travellers at that time were limited in numbers. This is the story of the Stonehaven Derailment. We’ll explore what happened here and the events leading up to that fatal accident.
00:00 Intro
01:43 Train Background
07:36 Weather Report
10:04 Carmont Drain
12:26 tf is a Carillion
18:58 The Accident
#trains
#scotland
Sources:
assets.publishing.service.gov...
assets.publishing.service.gov...
• Report 02/2022: Derail...
/ 1293313295433302019
www.metoffice.gov.uk/binaries...
• Severe Thunderstorm ov...
• Report 02/2022 - Derai...
www.sepa.org.uk/media/536333/...
web.archive.org/web/202008171...
news.sky.com/story/stonehaven....
www.railwaysarchive.co.uk/doc...
www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/sc...
• Tributes paid to the v...
www.theconstructionindex.co.u...
Disaster Breakdown - Written and Produced by Chloe Howie
Disaster Breakdown is an aviation disaster documentary series. Focused on dissecting and analyzing the causes of a plane crash. Air Disasters and accidents is my focus but occasionally, we look at rail accidents too.
THERE HAS BEEN A UPDATE!
September 7th 2023. from the BBC...
"Network Rail has admitted a series of failings which led to the death of three people in a train derailment near Stonehaven in 2020. The company pleaded guilty to criminal charges at the High Court in Aberdeen".
Network Rail admitted failing to impose a speed restriction, warn the driver that part of the track was unsafe, or ask him to reduce his speed. It also admitted a number of failures over the maintenance and inspection of drainage in the area, and in adverse and extreme weather planning".
You can read more here: www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-north-east-orkney-shetland-66731023
I don't know the legal implications of this in Scotland or the UK (I'm American), but this sounds like very good news, and something you'd never hear this side of the pond - a corporation admitting responsibility. Thanks for the update, and I always love a Chloe weather report!
I've been watching your videos, and enjoying them, but I do have a bit of content suggestion for you:
Can you please do a video on this train accident (en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eschede_train_disaster), I think your viewers will find it interesting.
Overall, I really like your content :)
When the weather is bad even by Scotlands standards then you just KNOW its going to be a BAD day
Well, i bet you don't get many Snowstorms or hurricanes in Scotland. No droughts, no big forest fires, not too many floods. Weather in Scotland isn't that bad, imho.
@@gehtdianschasau8372 No,they get rain,some deep snow,and freezing temperatures wet summers and limited sun
@@jameshowe6057 just like ireland
@@jaws666 i know,my mums from ireland and im a Yorkshire lad with nordic descent so i feel the pain
@@jaws666And England.
Chloe you were born for this type of work. You are truly gifted in your ability to research these complex issues and then your gift of delivering what you learned. I also applaud you for your weather bulletins. They are quite helpfull in understanding how all these factors come into play and good for you for personally going on camera, as others dont have the confidence to appear in their videos. Very well done! 😊
Thank you for your kind words :)
Well said there, Laddie.
Truly an artist
Nice voice, easy for non English as 1st language to understand, not too fast or slow. No bullshit, clickbait or obvious bias, keep going Chloe.
I second everything said here! I love your ‘weather reports’. They give brilliant insight into what is happening that affects the situation you discuss. Thankyou!
I’m a railway incident responder and signaller, this shook me. Really showed just how fragile our systems can be if we don’t keep up the hard work. Great video
Hi michael,Always takes an incident like this to happen to highlight the failure that costs lives, so sad, but hopefully the industry will learn from this and avoid this kind of thing in the future by correct working procedures
@@jameshowe6057 If I've learned anything from watching disaster documentaries, it is that negligence is only ever temporarily eradicated; it always returns. People get lazy, greedy, overworked, underfunded - the reasons are many. And because the results of negligence are not immediate, it always gets worse until the sudden shock of a disaster causes people to toe the line again... until the next cycle of negligence begins. Human nature, alas.
It seems very weird that given the existing known landslides the train wasn't told to run at reduced speed - if this was at 30MPH there may have been no deaths :(
The accident and fatality statistics she began the video with tell me that you and your colleagues working on the railways in Britain are doing an incredible job, and you deserve to be commended. And yeah, one lapse has the potential for tragedy, but I assume you have redundancies built into the system to protect against single-fault errors becoming catastrophes. Your safety record amazes me. People do have lapses because we're human, but a good robust system can handle that. Now if you have a lapse at the same time someone else has a lapse... best not to have any lapses I guess. But congratulations on your tremendous safety record! That tells me the system is excellent, and the individuals who work to keep that system running safely are doing their jobs with diligence.
Just keeps getting better and better. Chloe the weather presenter is great - but don't think of switching careers! We need you here.
Thank you!
?
haha I came here to make a similar comment ❤
@@Diptera_Larvae Her videos are so intelligent, and they usually involve many deaths, so it's hard to be light about anything, but when I see her on camera doing the weather again, she makes me smile! 🙂 I feel so conflicted, but maybe I'll just accept there are two powerful reasons to watch this amazing video.
Who is Chloe?
Thank you for doing such a great job on this video. I am from Stonehaven and have lived here for many years. I remember this day. The shock echoed through the town when this happened. I regularly use the route and met the conductor that was killed on a few occasions. He was always a lovely man and it’s really sad that this accident took him and the other 2 victims away from their family’s and loved ones. May they rest in peace.
wasn’t this known as carmont derailment?
@@jameshowe6057to my knowledge everyone has always called it the Stonehaven derailment as it was only a few minutes outside Stonehaven and carmont isn’t a well known place and is very rural.But it probably should be called that.
Railfans and rail workers call it “carmont derailment” im ex rail and call it carmont,maybe the media linked it to the nearest town
@@jameshowe6057 yeah I suspect that was the case
I used to live in Stonehaven as a kid (Greenkeepers Cottage), can't remember much about it apart from the enormous Olympic open air swimming pool (Brrr)
Left Scotland in 88 so I haven't heard about the derailment.
You have a magical ability to tell these stories in a way that makes them feel important and impactful. It's natural to be desensitized to tragedies and go "oh, just another derailment, well, at least just 3 people died", but watching your videos reminds viewers that tragedies shouldn't be seen as mundane. Safety isn't mundane. Thank you Chloe!
She's done it again!
I don't know nearly as much about trains as I do about aircraft, and videos like these give me new rabbit holes to dive down, which is always exciting.
As always, keep it up!
Who's she?
@@johnennis4586 The person who makes these videos is a woman! Her voice is deep though, so that may have puzzled you a bit, it did me too, but as we saw in this video, she makes amazing videos!
At least i think it is amazing and VERY informative. I love these channels.
*I'm now further in the video. I think you can clearly see this is a woman, so your comment now confuses me.
@@johnennis4586 ?
he's obviously talking about Chloe@@johnennis4586
@johnennis4586 She is Chloe Howie, the writer, producer and presenter of this video, the creator of this channel, a constant source of excellent quality content, the possessor of one of the most soothing narration voices on UA-cam.
Being a pilot I tend to be mostly interested in aircraft accident investigations however well researched train accidents, such as in this video, are interesting as well. Both aircraft and train accidents do in fact have one thing in common, major accidents occur due to a series of things going wrong before hand and not just one simple thing. Well done.
The RAIB reports are always worth reading. So much of what they highlight would be applicable to aviation too and it's always worth learning from.
The same for AAIB reports in the rail industry
Swiss Cheese model always holds.
i love that youve become so comfortable that you’re so able to add humour while still taking the incident itself very seriously
kudos as always!!!
Call me crazy, but I don't think tragic incidents involving the deaths of people are the right places for "humour". I also don't quite see what "comfort" has to do with anything? Its just poor writing, and immensely disrespectful.
Also, I don't quite see the need for the lazy all-caps clickbait in the title, as well as the weather portion of the video which had absolutely zero reason to be "performed" and comes across as more of a self-driven excuse to come on camera for personal reasons rather than for the benefit of the video and viewer, or the story itself.
If this is the way this channel is heading, ill be seeing myself out to be honest. Pretty noticeable drop in quality, as well as a clear shift in attitude (For the worse), as far as I'm concerned.
Geezers felisha
i get where you’re coming from but please remember that this is a free video made by someone who is just sharing their passion for videomaking and an interest in disasters. :) I’ve been following chloe on twitter where she shows her own personality more and maybe thats why i like her showing it more in videos too :)
Okay you're crazy
How is this bad writing? Please enlighten me, you won't find a better written, more detailed channel than this one. Unless reaction channels are your thing. Then i understand why you're so bitter.. @@null_nihility
There was 1 piece of information that you missed.
The driver & Conductor unfortunately passed away. The signaller did not know that the accident had happened. It was the off duty conductor that walked about 2 miles down the track to call for help because the nearest line side signller phone was broken.
Apart from that, fantastic video
I lived in Aberdeen at the time, I had never seen a thunderstorm like the one we got that day. Torrential. Totally torrential rain. I ended up not being able to get into work (I worked in a medical lab) because I had to wade out of my apartment building. My friend at the time had been seconded to the lab in Dundee, I've never rang someone so hysterically before, literally screamed "tell me you weren't on that train" and their response, "the bus couldn't get to the station with the flooding so I missed the train." Never felt so much relief. As a born and bred Scot I'll tell you, it was BAD that day. Our hospital was put on alert, we were getting mass transfusion packs ready if they had to be sent at short notice etc. Then no one came. I remember standing there thinking "I can't tell if it was bad or good" thank christ we were in lockdown or that train would have been packed and many more people would have died.
So happy to see you explore other types of incidents. Keep up the good work!
Thank you!
@@DisasterBreakdownI agree with this. You do a really fantastic job on all of these. It kinda reminds me of Seconds From Disaster, only without the needlessly dramatic voice. I've really enjoyed these weather reports you've added in too. Oftentimes I will already know the details of what happened as I've taken a lot of deep dives into air crash investigations, yet still I'll watch your vids on them because there's always a little more to them, and even when there's nothing new from what I knew, I still think they're really well done. As for rail, sea, and structural disasters, my knowledge is little to none so it's great to learn more from you. Thanks for doing these in such a great way and keep up the fantastic work.
The return of Meteorologist Chloe! You look lovely as always, and I love the subject material! As a former train-obsessed child, railway accidents are super intriguing to me.
Keep it up!
Same as me, ive been into rail accidents since i read STANLEY HALLS “Red for Danger” book in the early 1990’s..probably what led me on to a career in railway’s many years later
@@jameshowe6057 You mean LTC Rolt's book "Red for Danger" I think. It's the most comprehensive review of the evolution of rail safety in the UK driven by accidents, and excellent book.
That train sounds like a 747 spooling up for takeoff. Geez.😂
the valenta used a single stage, high pressure turbo-supercharger to attain a high power to weight ratio, the turbo is so large that it produces a whining sound akin to that of a small jet engine
@@Trainman10715 what's a turbo-supercharger, does it have both a turbo and a supercharger?
@@mipmipmipmipmip it's the non-automotive word for a turbocharger, technically a turbo is a type of supercharger as "supercharger" actually just refers to anything that forces air into an engine whether it's turbine or belt driven. In automotive colloquialism the terms have become mutually exclusive so as to aid differentiation between belt and turbine driven superchargers, but outside the context of cars "turbosupercharger" is the proper term for a turbo
Chloe, great to see you in the video and put a face to the voice. Love the new "DB Weather Report" segment you've included. Please keep this as a regular feature. Plus, "snaps" to your plaid outfit, you look great!
I thought she was a dude lmao
@@FELIPEFODAOBR12
She's a woman with a deep voice like me. People have thought I was my brother on the phone.
Anyway, pretty lady! I wasn't necessarily expecting her to look a specific way but I think I have a soft spot for intelligent, well-spoken red haired women in plaid.😂
@@dahliacheung6020 lol I see
Excellent video! Diving into the failings of Carillion (and other substandard contractors in that period) could make for an extremely long rant, so you did well to condense that. I always hope no more of their lash-ups ever come back to bite us as this one did.
I have heard some crazy stories about Carillion's practices.
@@DisasterBreakdown So then you should know the accident occurred at Carmont…not stonehaven then (having done research of course)
Thank you a lot for this video Chloe, loved the chapter 'tf is a Carillion'
I am constantly and continuously amazed by your dedication and detective work. Very pleased to have found your channel. Thank you immensely!!
Your research and absolutely calming narration is excellent. Keep going. 👌
Thanks a lot 😊
You'll smash 500k+ by the end of next year. 🤗
Another fascinating video as always. You always provide such an in depth, yet easy to understand explanation of the chain of events that lead to such disasters
Thank you!
You have a natural talent for storytelling! Keep up the great work chloe! ❤
Thank you so much for your kind words!
Great video again Chloe. Well presented and super interesting. Thanks for your efforts to keep us entertained. Ps I loved the weather report should be a regular segment.
Fantastic video - I'm always floored by how well you structure and provide effective and accessible background information leading up to incidents, but I also loved the creativity with the weather segment! Glad to see another train video - I hope more are on the way
Thank you. I am a fan of your videos :)
@@DisasterBreakdown Oh wow! Thank you so much. I've binged your content very often.
I got into the topic because my grandfather died (long before I was born) in the crash of Nigeria Airways flight 825 at Lagos, but there doesn't seem to be much information about the accident out there. The really tragic irony is that as an engineer he was especially excited to fly in the VC-10 for the first time, and ended up in one of the few deadly accidents involving the plane. Maybe you'll get round to covering it one day... but either way, thanks for educating me so thoroughly about all the possible factors involved in aviation incidents!
A train desaster that cannot be missed in a channel like this is the Eschede train disaster in Germany. Although there are many documentaries about this disaster, there are some points where the desaster could have been avoided if someone had taken action, but this didn't happen, and no one has ever dug into this aspect as to why. Given your ability to delve deeply into the matter, I hope that one day you will address these questions and finally find satisfactory answers to that mystery.
I remember reading about this years ago and was intrigued (shame about the loss of life) Another one D.B. should cover is Colwich Train crash in 1986 two trains collided head on and only one person was killed (unfortunately) that accident is on wikipedia
I really hope she makes a video about this! I grew up very close to Eschede in Celle, my parents always talked about how they remember being in the garden one day and suddenly heard all the fire engines, ambulances and saw helicopters and didn’t know what was going on :(
Going into Twitter for the comments was a step beyond! Absolutely outstanding video yet again
No matter how good the weather presenter, weather 'bad even for Scotlands standards' is definitely a storm. And no blonde is distracting us from that fact. Thank you for the video I remember being stunned and relieved. Thinking it was the one thing we could thank the pandemic for as I dread to think the toll had it been regular travel numbers. 'enter carillion' Uh oh.
Hello from the US. Thanks for sharing your perspective of this event
Chloe your research and presentation skills get better and better with each episode. I love the way you break down complex subjects and discuss them in an easy to understand and engaging way. Also loved seeing you present the weather! Thank you!❤
Glad you like them!
Thank you Chloe for another awesome upload. Your work is well researched, and you are great at it.
Keep up the good work.
Much ❤ Love from Nairobi, Kenya
Thank you so much for watching. Good night :)
Thank you Chloe for another upload! I start my Saturdays watching your video in the morning ☺️
Thank you! I never would have thought a few years ago I'd be such a part of people's day! Thank you.
Great video as usual, I love your content for the factual depiction of events, without dramatization. Plus, it's always a delight to see your face! Love the plaid dress, you ROCK IT.
Another top quality video! Love the way you narrate each video you make it so easy to understand and follow the full scope of the incident your easily one of the best on UA-cami 👏👏
Thank you!
UA-cam suggested me this video (probably because I'm a train enthusiast). What a well researched work, thank you for producing it. Also, I must add, as a Spanish speaker your accent and tone are incredibly clear and beautiful, I could literally listen to audio books with you!
Thank you!!!
I was looking for another video like this. Good job Chloe!
Thank you!
Chloe, great work as always, never a boring video, you always put so much effort into every one.
This video was so well done….Thank you, Chloe!
Excellently researched and produced video. Thank you.
Watched this vid on my lunch, was a little late getting back to work, totally worth it!!
Thank you for making our lives better ❤!
Thanks for watching, hope the rest of your afternoon is good :)
@@DisasterBreakdown Thank you! Hope yours is good too!
Thank you for the response!😊
One of the best yet, love the more documentary style, giving us context around what injustices have occurred that lead up to the point of disaster, giving us a better idea why these things happen. Keep up the excellent work. 💜
Ive watched almost every video of yours and i just wanted to say im obsessed with them and how you break down the details ❤ and i truly love how youre working more of yourself into the videos ❤❤❤
Also idk what kind of exposure therapy this is but watching your videos made me MORE confident to fly with WN 😅😅
Thanks for another great bit of content. I always look forward to new episodes. 👍🏻
Glad you like them!
You've won a new subscriber, finally someone who can describe and present a video about what interests me clearly and concisely. Do not change......
Chloe, I'm a big fan of your work! The amount of detail you undertake in your videos is simply awe inspiring.
always happy to see more weather sections, and the details of this were explained really well! great video, as always!
Thank you :)
Once again, you did an incredible job! Thank you for drawing attention to the dangers of contracting out. It's a very troubling trend worldwide that is causing all sorts of serious problems. I'm so glad that very few people were on that train, and that the incident led to ScotRail being transferred to public ownership. However, we shouldn't have to wait for disaster to strike to deprivatise things that should have been public all along. Also, you are now officially my favourite weatherwoman! 💙
Absolutely amazing. Solid work as always. Love the work you do on the aircraft disasters which makes understanding everything about it very clear and concise. Trains are more my interest look forward to more videos on train disasters down the line. (no puns intended)
Good to know you like them :)
You had my attention through the whole episode Chloe. Excellent narration as ever, and the graphics were very helpful! Trains fascinate me, let's have more stories if possible. RIP to the 3 lives lost.
Excellent video and great to see you in the weatherforecast section. Well done and I am looking forward to the next video already.
Take care and stay safe,
Joe
I left the UK and Network Rail in 2008. As soon as you mentioned Carillon I cringed!!
Your presentation really highlighted the cowboy outfits that were entrusted to maintain the Railway. It used to be Safety First, since privatisation it's all about profit and shareholders.
I think it was Chiltern Railways that coined the phase "Safe Performance ". ie meet your PPF and hope nothing goes wrong.
Weather terrible, flooding everywhere, 2 hours late already.
So let's drive around blind bends at 75mph to save a few minutes.
these weather girl segments better never end! i literally gasped and clapped when we got another weather explainer 😆 love seeing your face, Chloe
I loved it ! Chloe as the weather girl. So sweet.
@@SunBear69420ok?
@@SunBear69420 Huh? Weather reports make you uncomfortable? That's weird. 🤨
@@TheRealNatNat thank you for that correction!
I've been following the channel for a long time, and it's been great to see it grow. Your success is thoroughly deserved, keep it up!
Wow, HOW did I not find this channel beforehand?! I love long-form/semi-long-form content covering train/airplane disasters, and the way you cover them so respectfully with so much detail (seriously you make 30 minutes feel like 10) is great! Your voice is perfect for the narration, and I love the little weather report segment and the chapter titled 'tf is a Carillion' lmao
Keep it up, Chloe!
A bit surprised to see Chloe in person, as my expectations were somewhat different after listening to the voice alone. A great work!
Exactly, I agree. I admire his work and awesome videos, but I wish he kept them how they were before.
@@McAlexCP A lot of creators get tired of doing the same thing day in and day out after a while. It's inevitable, just like people making a mountain of a mole hill about a content creator being transgender.
@@McAlexCP No, trans people shouldn't have to hide their faces just because bigots are offended by seeing them. Go lock yourself up in a bubble if you can't stand seeing people different from you.
That's because the voice belongs to a man because that's what he is. The picture only confuses you because it has only been normalized in recent years for men to dress up as women and demand to be treated like women and referred to as feminine.
@@McAlexCP I'm quite sure Chloe goes by she/her, not he/him.
Chloe I love these amazing contents you're always doing please keep them coming ❤❤❤❤
Thank you for watching!
You're welcome ♥️😊♥️
Fantastic investigative skills Chloé ! great video 😍
Another magnificent video!
Thank you for your hard work, Chloe!
Super interesting. Thanks for another great breakdown.
Love the weather report format! Great work.
I love your videos so much, thank you! 💜
Your extended analyses and presentation of events is superb. Thank you.
Chloe, I am so proud of you. You are an amazing documenter and researcher. I love seeing you coming Into your videos I love your confidence. Your facts captivate me and your voice soothes me. I have been following you and supporting your channel for years now and I love seeing you grow.
The voice sooths you?
I thought it was a dude.
@@1joshjosh1 Why does that matter?
@@1joshjosh1it is. The gushing comments exist because some people support absolutely everything that a member of the Alphabet Mafia does. Facts are facts and one fact is that the guy who makes these videos is a dude.
This was an amazing video breaking down a complicated accident in to understandable bites. I love the way new generations of UA-camrs are using modeling software to better visualize accidents for lay people to understand. Keep up your great work!
Thank you!
Well done Chloe. Excellent video. I live in Australia and these accident vids on air and rail disasters plus your excellent fire video are really interesting and very professional. Thankyou!.
Obsessed with the weather report. Love your videos so much Chloe!
Thanks so much 😊
Wow, there is so much awesomeness in this video, I don't even know where to start! The weather report - absolutely top content! The graphics - brilliant! The research - stellar craftmanship! And to top it off, your plaid was on point! Amazing work, this is everything I need a Saturday afternoon! (Yes, I am also an infrastructure geek lmao)
Wow, thank you!
Great video as always.
Glad the weather segment has made a return !
If you make more train crash breakdowns the Great Belt Bridge rail accident would be an interesting one to cover.
I shall look into it :)
I love your content! Keep going! This is very informative and respectful to those whom are lost. Keep up your amazingly work! ❤❤❤
Excellent research and explanation! Thank you so much for sharing.
I live in Aberdeenshire, around 30 miles north of where this accident happened. It always feels weird watching videos that discuss crime or disasters in the area, mainly cause I always suspect no one gives a shit about anything that happens here, even if it is a crime or disaster like the Stonehaven derailment. So seeing this video pop up was a huge surprise, I distinctly remember the news coverage surrounding the accident after it happened on the news and newspapers. Thank you for the very informative video and commentary!
I remember seeing this on the news. When I started to do rail videos I knew I'd eventually want to do this one.
Could be something to do with the fact the media is obsessed with big cities only Ross
I live in Aberdeen and I’m the same. Was shocked to see it on here and just had to watch. You did so well in portraying it and the amount of research! I’m glad you focused in on Carillion too, I remember the driver was blamed for speeding for so long, it must have been awful for his family.
Hey Chloe, i was wondering if you could take a look at the 1998 Eschede railway disaster someday. I know its a quite well documented and pretty popular one, but i would love to hear your take on this. Not only because its my home country but also because it could‘ve been prevented so easily.
Keep up the amazing work on this channel, cheers!
Excellent as always Chloe. You can tell you put in a great deal of research on these sensitive pieces of work.
This is my first visit to this channel; I liked what I saw and you've earned yourself another subscription
This video went out to my Patrons on Patreon Two Days before going out publicly. Consider joining here from £1 per month: www.patreon.com/DisasterBreakdown
Twitter: twitter.com/Chloe_HowieCB
i remember hearing about this
Your weather forecaster character is back!😁
it’s actually the “Carmont derailment”
Regardless of the state of the train simulations, that was a very informative and enjoyable video.
It made me think of the Watford train crash (I looked it up and was very surprised it was waaay back in '96. I thought it was much more recent.)
Also the 1975 Watford crash, that I believe was also caused by landslip\poor drainage, although I could be wrong. But I remember there were bogeys from the wreck on the side of the track for many years afterwards.
RIP to all lost in this accident, it is a crying shame that Carillion will get away with their poor work practices.
“…..you see the thing is” ?????
Didn’t expect to see one local to me, I’m just up the coast a wee bit. This one really shocked us all, the media spectacle leaving a bad taste in a fair amount of our mouths as they all sorta rushed to the site to go on about how much of a tragedy it was, that royalty came up, when what folk really needed was sympathy, families lost loved ones and it just felt like a media circus. That’s how it felt for friends in Stonehaven, media could’ve been more understanding tbh.
There’s a memorial plaque at Stonehaven railway station if anyones ever in the area.
Thanks so much for another brilliant episode
Thanks for watching!
Thank you for an excellent and detailed, if sad analysis of this incident.
All delivered in your usual calm manner.
Worth noting that no previous directors of Carillion have ever been called to account in court.
Yay a new DB! Happy Saturday everyone.
Thank you dearly 😘
Chloe gets to talk about trains! And weather!
Carillion sounds strangely familiar, I have a feeling they've been mentioned on WTYP :P
WTYP?
@@railfandepotproductions "Well welcome to Well There's Your Problem, a podcast about engineering disasters, with slides." Leftist commentary, breakdowns, jokes, and wild tangents about a very broad definition of "engineering disaster". I believe Chloe's mentioned one of their episodes before when she made a video about an airplane accident that they had also covered.
@@marinary1326 thx for clarifying
This was an awesome video! By the way I was the Nick The Goat person that commented on your tweet about the rain. By the way the F40PH here in the states was known as the screamer as it also screamed at about notch 6 to 8 or full throttle. So I'm used to loud and screeching trains.
Great video Chloe! I love your content, can’t wait for a new one. As for your new schedule, it is fine as now its a nice surprise for a new vid! 🎉
Well done weather explanation, visuals and story execution. R.I.P. Train Driver
Brett McCullough, Conductor Donald Dinnie and Passenger Christopher Stuchbury. My sincere condolences are extended to your loved ones and friends.
I like it when topics other than planes are covered; it gives some much-needed diversity.
Fantastic video Chloe. Very sad for the three people who perished.
Thank you for always being so diligent with closed captioning. It's one of the many things that really separates your channel from the rest.
I don't understand why such construction work does not have to be checked and approved by a state authority after completion.
I can't imagine that the UK of all places doesn't have such a regulation.
It was a great video. One of my favorits from your channel.
Please note that the current UK government is all about deregulation, and has been working at this viciously.
Thanks for always providing a very detailed explanations of any incident. Sometimes I wonder though for example one thing: trying to put all of our Nordic flights, trains 'treks', bus 'treks' and do a meta-analysis on the reliability on various parts of the world. It could be done now and would be interesting.
Absolutely love your rail videos, Chloe.
Thank you very much!
Remarkable research and presentation. Very much appreciate your content.
I was very happy with how this one turned out. Glad you liked it.
Finally a video which won't give me another thing to worry about in a plane
Thank you Chloe for another interesting and informative video! I particularly loved the return of the disaster breakdown weather report.
Also your makeup is on point, you look great!
Truly great video, thank you so much for this one and every other
Great breakdown Chloe, love your channel!
Thank you!
Amazing video Can you do The Hinton Train Collision? please
I should start making a new list for rail videos people want me to do. I'll look into it. Thanks for the request!
@@DisasterBreakdownwould you be interested in a lighthearted disaster averted video on a Netherlands incident where a metro was saved from destruction by a whale?
My Da was a GM for the ECML for British Rail, Network Rail, Babcock Rail, Scots Rail… it went under so many name changes and divisions. And I remember how devastated he was with this accident.
He retired a couple of years before this incident, but ended up helping for a couple of weeks with the incident.
Thank you for continuing to make these videos. As much as I don't really care about the incidents themselves, or the people involved - it's always a delight to get the entire package compressed to a session-length multifactor analysis. One thing I always get out of these, is _a method of thinking_ - of considering things from mutliple perspectives, expecting the proverbial unexpected, and of casting a much wider net than would seem to make sense based on the original project/design criteria. It really helps to see things unfold step by step - it gives you the experience (however silly that may sound, not taking part in the process yourself) that allows you to more naturally look for such event chains, because _you've seen this before._
We humans are notoriously terrible with seeing the wider implications of our actions - if for no other reason than the simple fact that having a general and _complete_ overview of the entire situation is a privilege only select few will ever have, in any given situation. _This is why oversight is so important,_ as it enables people to take a look at "the big picture".
But even then we miss a terrible lot. And I'd like to think that all of this content helps me notice more, and more quickly. It prompts me to ask questions that may seem silly, on the off chance that the answer might make someone go "hey, hold on a minute there - that doesn't sound right". As much as I may not care about the people, _I care about the reliability of everything I build_ - which translates to safety and security regardless. :D
Also, I'm glad to see you collaborating with John (Plainly Difficult)! Could you teach him to read more smoothly though? :D I'm always delighted to see my favourite creators working together - the sum _really is greater_ than all of its constituent parts. And it's funny, if you think for a minute - I'm deriving quite a bit of enjoyment from something someone, once upon a time, started on a silly whim thinking "eh, who'll want to watch these anyway". :D Well, as it turns out - plenty of people will.
Your channel had quickly become one of my favorites. Thank you for the little lessons contained within your videos. Please keep the great videos coming!
Love that it came out on the anniversary. What a wonderful remembrance.
Thanks for another very informative video Chloe❤❤👍
If possible then please try making a video on alliance air flight 7412 Patna crash as it is not covered very much.
hmmm If its not been talked about much, I'll have a look into it. Thanks.
@@DisasterBreakdown thanks
Nice video as always ❤️❤️❤️
Long time subscriber. Oh wow, a non-plane video. Nice to see it Chloe
I love this channel, really makes you think about life. ❤