Reacting to A2K ep.17 "Individual Performances continue"

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 96

  • @pir209
    @pir209 Рік тому +47

    Camila...is an absolute ACE. You can tell she checks all the requirement boxes in JYP's mind. She is also trilingual [EN,FR,SP]...quite helpful when promoting in the Americas. All of these ladies should be commended for their efforts. This is monumentally tough to survive and excel in this performance journey. Thanks for your reactions and time, Pierre.

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому +1

      Thank you very much. She surely has star qualities. She's got the looks, the voice, the dance and the stage presence.

  • @upmwinston
    @upmwinston Рік тому +77

    hope KG shows her dancing skills in the next 2 challenges; we already know she can sing.

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому +5

      That would be really nice

    • @darien4969
      @darien4969 Рік тому +12

      Many people underestimates the singing while playing instruments. It is equally if not harder than dancing while singing. Buy yeah i really hope she worked on her dancing.

  • @vanthadoun1
    @vanthadoun1 Рік тому +55

    KG has always had the 'Fighting' spirit. Even when she was called the worst dancer, she took that criticism head on. She keeps working on her skills and improving. I know this song required a guitar and we don't get to see her dancing. But I do hope to see more of her dancing in the future.
    Gina should've performed to her strengths and performed "Mr Roboto" and JYP would've said "wow, you were very robotic and captured the essence of a true robot, I don't know how any human can be so precise and unemotional"=== I'm just kidding. I know Gina has had problems with expressing herself.
    Cristina was awesome, and so much energy. I love seeing her perform.
    I think everyone agrees that Camila is a natural, she is an all rounder and has great leadership. I really think Camila is unstoppable and she will debut. Out of all the girls, Camila has no glaring weaknesses. 🤩

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому +4

      Yea, Camila is proving to be absolutely amazing.

    • @Prettyfunny40
      @Prettyfunny40 Рік тому +3

      Mr Roboto! 😂. You made me laugh so hard. You are so funny. But seriously I feel bad for Gina. How can she be so unemotional? She is young and maybe she hasn’t had much life experiences yet. She might need some time to even understand what she is lacking in her performances. Not sure if she will be able to do it for this competition. That will be unfortunate because she dances and sings so well.

    • @vanthadoun1
      @vanthadoun1 Рік тому +2

      @@Prettyfunny40 I feel bad for her too, at this point her being a JYP trainee is working against her. She is following the prototype of what an k-pop idol is supposed to be instead of letting her guard down and being original. The same formula for creating girl groups for the past 20 years isn’t going to work on A2K. JYP is looking for something special and I feel Gina is going to rank low this week. When Gina presented her talent as a faux News Anchor; I was really impressed. She needs to show her creativity and cut loose.

  • @aenitoYT
    @aenitoYT Рік тому +17

    KG in her room with the guitar brings me memories of Chaeyoung's solo at the world tour. And as Chaeyoung is the underdog of Twice, i believe KG would be the underdog of this A2K project.

  • @wannabe7598
    @wannabe7598 Рік тому +22

    Can't wait for yuna performance

  • @aminaamara6657
    @aminaamara6657 Рік тому +19

    if you listen carefully you can hear that camila is the one singing" i wanna see the world does the world wanna see me" and also the outro you can hear kendall's voice. i'm pretty sure of this theory it's literally their voices. i also think i can hear KG but i'm not sure

    • @FishHipster
      @FishHipster Рік тому +8

      I've been trying to pick them out for the past few weeks and I'm convinced I hear Camila, Kaylee, and Kendall in the outro hahaha

    • @ailuria
      @ailuria Рік тому +2

      I hear KG in the beginning! I agree with the rest@@FishHipster

  • @Lyra94forever
    @Lyra94forever Рік тому +14

    I am waiting for these reactions as much as the episodes every week hahahaha

  • @aiahkinssss
    @aiahkinssss Рік тому +3

    I really love watching people's reaction videos to some videos that I love. Like it makes me so happy that we have the same opinions about the girls. Camila rocks!!❤

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому +1

      I'm happy you liked it. Camila is really really good, I am wondering how much more she will improve with half a year of training. thanks for being here!

  • @sayurioffenborn4960
    @sayurioffenborn4960 Рік тому

    your comments are very on point. Hope for more castingshows with your commentary.

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому +1

      Thank you so much... just started watching the first season of the Nizi Project :)

  • @margolitapnina6716
    @margolitapnina6716 Рік тому +12

    Camila and Cristina are really precious. I really love also Cristina's voice honestly❤️❤️❤️

  • @yuniethao
    @yuniethao Рік тому +1

    I'm always looking forward for your reactions after watching the episodes hehe❤

  • @lenanicole2837
    @lenanicole2837 Рік тому +11

    Both gina and Kaylee are so worried about being perfect on stage it's like they can't even be a person...kaylee has improved and imo I'm seeing her mentality has improved and gotten stronger since the LA Boot camp because she isa very high strung almost to the point of being neurotic type of personality but I'm very worried about gina at this point I do think she needs to talk to someone neutral and get a good cry and laugh out and really break open this stone wall she's in emotionally, speaking from experience I'm very worried for her not just in this but in general she needs to talk to someone because she can't talk to her parents it seems or like brother I think she said that she loves a lot so she needs emotional support

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому +1

      Thank you. Gina needs to start having fun. She is always in "practice mode" trying to please the coaches... She said she feels good when she is around the girls and she did good and had fun while performing with her group. She is not a solo artist because she falls back into that practice mode and forgets to have fun.

    • @enzo-br7iu
      @enzo-br7iu Рік тому

      @@NeonReactionsPierre she's only 14!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!how do you expect her to behave like an 18 year old???????????????????

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому +2

      The problem is - she is acting like an 18 year old who is overthinking everything and not having fun in the process...

  • @Mika-pd9jw
    @Mika-pd9jw Рік тому +2

    Gina is the best ! She looks older than her age but she is still sooo young, excellent dancer and singer among others tbh she is the best

  • @ahyeonii.i
    @ahyeonii.i Рік тому +9

    WAITING FOR YUNA
    💗💗💗💗💗💗

  • @jeff2do
    @jeff2do Рік тому +14

    I think Gina is great and that song selection wasn't really for her to perform. It doesn't show case her as well as maybe a newer song?

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому +2

      Yes the song choice was not that good. I agree.

    • @vanthadoun1
      @vanthadoun1 Рік тому +6

      I have a theory that Gina performs better with the girls than when she is performing in front of JYP, I think she goes into ‘perfection mode’ and afraid to make mistakes in front of him- she can’t cut loose!

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому +1

      Yes she is not a solo artist. She needs the group around her

    • @Paul-qp7mq
      @Paul-qp7mq Рік тому

      This song was not Gina's choice. She couldn't express all her talent. The choreography was not her choice. Her jeans outfit before a blue cutain was not her choice. Even no make up. She is a strong girl to stay straight. Some say "stiff"

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому

      @@Paul-qp7mq we don't really know about who chooses or suggests what

  • @Panorama-memory
    @Panorama-memory Рік тому +9

    Gina is not worried at all. If she performs in front of a real audience, it will resolve itself.
    For Gina, Park Jin-young can never be an audience member. It's a little different from the other members. Because she is an official trainee.
    In her view, Park Jin-young looks much bigger. To put it simply, other trainees can easily talk to Jinyoung Park, make jokes, laugh, and make jokes. But Gina can't do that.
    It’s not because Park Jin-young is a scary person. If you belong somewhere and be at the bottom, you won't dare to go to the top.
    I can tell President Biden as many jokes and shake his hand as I want. But can government officials do the same? That's the story.

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому +3

      Thank you, I get what you mean. And you could really be correct here.

  • @margolitapnina6716
    @margolitapnina6716 Рік тому +9

    I paste something I wrote on reddit today that someone downvoted too 😂😂😂😂 The whole point was KG exibition not being fair for someone (not me!) because she didn't dance. I wrote: She reminded me the system is kpop, but the group is american.she took a big risk so it wasn't that unfair imho, and making a different thing maybe would be a bit fake for her. We all thought "omg JYP's gonna be pissed". I think she is genuine in challenging herself with a new genre and made me smile because she didn't think it was strange for a kpop show 😂😂😂😂
    Probably she also wanted to show she is unique and valuable in the group as very different from the others. For example when Cristina was rapping I thought for a second she and Savanna would play a similar role as very solid dancers and rappers. They also have the same hairstyle 😂😂😂😂
    Then I think this evaluation was made to highlight their strengths and show what they came up with in half an year; what they value most and so on. She wants to be the songwriter or the group and will work hard on the dancing while in Korea with them.

  • @muanpuiaart9818
    @muanpuiaart9818 Рік тому +4

    Camila gana be group leader

  • @margolitapnina6716
    @margolitapnina6716 Рік тому +4

    Gina's song was my anthem when I was at university in 2010, but the Chinese version (best one!❤❤❤❤ hate the kor and eng versions)~ I think she express herself better in group, when she is really solid and reliable but can relax.
    this cus she is really talented but also really young and used to keep m emotions to helself so...
    yes, was super stiff 😅

  • @사나마나-t2g
    @사나마나-t2g Рік тому +4

    당신은 나이도 많은데 편집도 잘하시고 멋지네요 존경합니다^^

  • @Rashawnp24
    @Rashawnp24 Рік тому +1

    I love your reactions to this series! Very objective and positive, I feel like some people are going SO unnecessarily harsh on these girls 😭
    I definitely agree with what you said about Gina's performance, I didn't feel much emotion in it either (especially watching it between Christina and Camila's performances). But I really do hope she can get that. I think in a group she does better at being natural, because that is what seemed to happen with the final performance of the LA Boot camp.
    Some people may thing that JYP is being extra hard on Gina and giving the other girls a pass, but I really don't think so. They all have their strengths and weaknesses, and he does a good job at pointing those out. People just see that she's good at the singing/dancing and assume that's all it takes, but he's made it clear a bunch of times already that he's looking for more factors than that.

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому +1

      Thank you very much. I really appreciate that. I always try to stay objective and positive. Positivity is the essence of getting along and being constructive and creative. Thee are haters everywhere, especially in these "faceless social media comment section" times.

  • @HG-if6pc
    @HG-if6pc Рік тому +3

    if you enjoy this show, you will really like Nizi Project season 1 - it's the same but with Japanese girsl, i personally prefer it over this

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому

      I've heard of that. First I thought its for boys... and didn't look into it, but then someone told me that season 2 is for the boys and 1 was girls..... So I'll look into that although I don't really know because its already over and ppl know who will win already.

    • @HG-if6pc
      @HG-if6pc Рік тому

      well i don't think that matters cause the show is very enjoyable@@NeonReactionsPierre

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому +1

      @@HG-if6pc I'öö take a look into the first episode of season one.... and as Mr. Schwarzenegger would say - I'll be back

  • @Lesmu
    @Lesmu Рік тому +1

    오디션 초반에는 Gina가 긴장해서, 감정표현이 미숙한 것으로 생각했으나.. 지금 돌아보면, 그녀의 성장과정과도 관계가 있는거 같습니다.
    이제 같은 나이인 Kaylee는, 가정에서 사랑을 많이 받고 자란 듯이, 기쁨과 슬픔 등 감정표현이 자유로운 것에 비해...
    어린 시절, 여러 나라를 옮겨다녀야 했고, 아픈 것도 숨기고 강한 모습을 보여야 했던 과거처럼..
    나이 어린 Gina는 감정을 숨기고 마음을 닫고 살았을 가능성이 크다고 생각합니다.
    연습생 생활도 가족같은 분위기라기 보다는, 혼자 연습하고 훈련하는 시간이 많았을 것이니.. 외로운 시간이었겠지요..
    지금은 참가자들과 어울리며, 웃고 떠드는 것을 보니.. 시간은 조금 걸리더라도 마음을 열고 자신을 표현할 때가 올 것으로 기대합니다.
    34:48 JYP의 평가에서 무언가 알아차린 거 같은 표정을 보면, 다음 무대가 기대됩니다..

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому +1

      Yes that is correct. Thank you. Gina is still putting herself under lots of pressure when performing solo. She feels more comfortable with the group around her.

  • @이일한-p1p
    @이일한-p1p Рік тому +1

    난 KG가 데뷔 하길 바래요
    다음 에피소드에서는 멋진 댄스 실력 보여 줄꺼라 믿어요

  • @rinoa-rina
    @rinoa-rina Рік тому +1

    I thought the same about Gina's performance... I even thought maybe she has a depression? Like i couldnt feel or see any emotions even when she smiles

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому +3

      I think she does not really know how to handle the pressure, even though she has the skills... That makes her shut down emotionally and only rely on functioning with the technics of singing and dancing. And - as I said in another comment - she is not a solo artist. She said she is happy and comfortable around the girls and that shows in her performance. Back in LA when she was in a group it was great.

    • @rinoa-rina
      @rinoa-rina Рік тому

      @NeonReactionsPierre oh now I see this point! Maybe u are right, and this is just because of solo/ 121 performing

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому

      @@rinoa-rina we will see. I hope she can make it click in her head

    • @Paul-qp7mq
      @Paul-qp7mq Рік тому

      You're right. It was a great group composed with Gina, Lexus, Melissa, and Yuna.
      Melissa the best singer of the LA group is already out.
      Gina is about to be kicked out. Which is a waste.
      Yuna didn't get the dance stone (but KG did)
      Who will be in the final group ?@@NeonReactionsPierre

  • @Withyouonce
    @Withyouonce Рік тому

    That's Squier Strat.
    Budget version of Fender guitar.

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому +1

      Oh ok... I never get those two right. Had a Fender and a Squier myself. Both are good. I never really saw much quality differences. Both were sold though. I did get a Squier Butterscotch Telecaster in the meantime. Thats the only electric guitar I have left atm. There are also four acoustic guitars though that keep me company.

  • @BaemonRora_LeeDain
    @BaemonRora_LeeDain Рік тому +3

    my 5 fav kaylee kendall camilla lexus and yuna pls debut kaylee lee

  • @jpar12
    @jpar12 Рік тому

    Is it just me? I see Chaeyoungesque performance from sixteen on Cristina's performance? Chaeyoung performed Honey by JYP, wrote a rap verse and wore red suit.😅

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому

      I just checked that ... nice connection there :)

    • @bLuGhOsT_
      @bLuGhOsT_ Рік тому

      Could be due to the fact that Chaeyoung literally performed Swing Baby during sixteen together with Momo and Jiwon

  • @ashkirk-kramer8423
    @ashkirk-kramer8423 Рік тому

    Do we know if they chose the songs themselves? I assume they did, but I'm just curious.

    • @LailaCheyenne
      @LailaCheyenne Рік тому +1

      i would assume that they chose their own songs based on what they were saying in their interviews 🤷🏾‍♀️

    • @ashkirk-kramer8423
      @ashkirk-kramer8423 Рік тому +1

      @LailaCheyenne that's true. I think I was just surprised by some of the choices and thought maybe they were given a list and had to choose from that. But I doubt blue would've been on that list as a country song.

    • @LailaCheyenne
      @LailaCheyenne Рік тому

      @@ashkirk-kramer8423 i agree

    • @CindiBoard
      @CindiBoard Рік тому +3

      It is suggested what they perform. Kg said she has never sang country before. The difficulty of the song speaks volumes.

    • @ashkirk-kramer8423
      @ashkirk-kramer8423 Рік тому +2

      @CindiBoard definitely! I grew up listening to that song, and she sang it beautifully. Very difficult.

  • @kessiareis7007
    @kessiareis7007 Рік тому

    KG seems to know the least about Kpop

  • @Official-OpenAI
    @Official-OpenAI Рік тому

    love the XG mic

  • @Paul-qp7mq
    @Paul-qp7mq Рік тому +1

    I knew since ep 6 that Gina would be kicked out.
    Easy : JYP is always unfair with the same girls.
    Positive with the girls he wants : Kendall, KG, Kaylee
    Negative with the girls he doesn't want : Gina, Yuna
    The scam of EMOTIONs
    It's all about emotion (sometimes plural) in this episode.
    JYP never feels the emotion when Gina is performing.
    Easy : nobody can say "Yes you do".
    Nobody dare say : "You're not sensitive enough".
    I notice he never tells what emotions he is expecting. Neither do the trainers. Too bad that would have been so helpful.
    Look at Wonder girls and tell what emotions they deliver that Gina didn't.
    JYP requires from Gina spontaneous expressions, spontaneous movements. How could she do that in a group choreography. Trainees are trained to do the exact opposite: all the little fingers must have the same angle!
    Enough to be depressive, no ?
    Bad idea to be trained at JYP's if you want to be hired by JYP.

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому +1

      You might have a point there but in the end he sure does have a lot of good groups and idols in his company

    • @Paul-qp7mq
      @Paul-qp7mq Рік тому

      Her has had@@NeonReactionsPierre

  • @소주한잔-z2r
    @소주한잔-z2r Рік тому

    A2K는 신인 그룹을 만들기 위한 오디션이 아니고
    연극이다. 카밀라의 공연에서 마이크의 위치가 왼쪽 오른쪽 계속 바뀐다 .
    참가자들의 리엑션도 이렇게 말하고 이런 행동을 해라~ 미리 녹화전에
    대본을 받고 촬영 하는거다. 우리가 생각하는 실력자를 뽑는게 아니고
    연기를 잘하는 사람들을 뽑는것이다
    ep3 에서 JYP는 KG에게 컨트리한 목소리를 지적 했다.
    이번회에서 KG는 컨트리송을 불렀다 ~
    KG는 이번 무대를 준비하면서 언어에 대한 어려움이나, 새로운 춤에대한
    어떠한 어려움 없이 3주일(D-21)을 준비하고, 손가락만을 걱정 했다
    연습실 처음들어가서 (2:54)악보도 없이 노래와 기타연주를 보여준다 ~
    이것은 평소에 수도없이 부르던 애창곡을 가지고 준비 했다는것
    다른 친구들의 3주일의 노력과 KG의 3주일의 노력은 불공평한것이다~

    • @HOGOHI
      @HOGOHI Рік тому +1

      컨트리송을 지적했고 자신의 단점 컨트리송을 연습해온것 아닐까요
      춤도 없이 한국어 가사도 없이 다른친구들 과 달리 했지만
      아마 kg 의 재능만 믿고 뽑아준것 같은데 요
      La캠프에서 초반과 다르게 KG 저평가 되었으니 지켜봐야죠

    • @이일한-p1p
      @이일한-p1p Рік тому

      마이크 위치가 바뀌었다고 노래 못한다는 말은 아니죠?

    • @NeonReactionsPierre
      @NeonReactionsPierre  Рік тому

      Yes, it is a "tv / online show" and they will most likely make two or three takes of the performance to get all camera shots and angles right, and then they'll mix the best shots together in editing... The mic placement was probably just a rushed mistake that they missed.

  • @읍내오빠-n2l
    @읍내오빠-n2l Рік тому

    지나 댄스 트레이너가 부족함 맞았다