Mann gegen Maschine - Ulf Hoffmann Tischtennis Roboter (UHTTR-1)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 бер 2014
- German:
Nach ca. 2 Jahren Entwicklungsarbeit habe ich mit meinem Freund Michael nun unseren selbst gebauten Tischtennis Roboter soweit fertig gestellt, dass man mit ihm schon ordentliche Ballwechsel spielen kann. Die Entwicklung war nicht ganz einfach und mit sehr vielen Hürden verbunden. Die Entwicklungszeit haben wir auf meinem Blog festgehalten: ulfhoffmannroboter.wordpress.com
Es ist übrigens reiner Zufall, dass die Firma Kuka an einem ähnlichen Projekt mit Timo Boll gearbeitet hat. Wir wussten davon garnichts und sind aber trotzdem vom Konzept und der Umsetzung des KUKA Roboters schwer begeistert.
English:
After 2 years of development, we are very happy ad proud to present our DIY ping pong robot UHTTR-1, which is currently only able to play in passive mode.
Its a coincidence that the german company Kuka released a similar concept at the same time in relation with the german professional tabletennis player Timo Boll. We are also very excited about their ping pong robot and the concept that stands behind it.
For more information to the development of our UHTTR-1, please visit my blog: ulfhoffmannroboter.wordpress.com - Наука та технологія
We're finally reaching the point where most people can't tell the difference between CGI and real life.
Just like a couple of years ago when we reached the point where people think artificial flavours taste more real than flavours from actual fruits and vegetables.
Make 2 of these play an endless game of pingpong.
At first I thought this was real but towards the end I noticed that the movements seemed a bit unnatural, it moved too fast, and stopped too suddenly. Very well done though, and a great concept I think something like this would be awesome if it were real.
I don't doubt that its possible. You'd probably just need a massive budget and much more sophisticated equipment than that.
pretty sure that unnaturalness comes from the unusual clarity of the video
garthhh It might be something interesting to try to see if its possible, it would definitely be a challenge but it's pretty incredible what people have been able to figure out when it comes to robotics.
Dominatro92 There are little subtle things that indicate that it isn't quite real, I mean it's really well done but something just tells me in my brain that it isn't natural.
What's with this latest trend in ping-pong playing CGI robots?
Just spent three minutes of my life watching someone play ping pong with a robot, time well spent
Kuka Roboter sind ja toll, und ich werde mir das Match mit Timo Boll auf jeden Fall ansehen, aber so etwas in Eigenregie zu entwickeln hat nochmal eine ganz andere Qualität! Hut ab!
This should totally be on TV. I would watch it all day. Robot vs human in table tennis.
Have you tried setting up two and leaving them to it?
Brilliant
Respekt vor dieser Leistung...
Verbessern und dem DTTB vorstellen bzw den bekannten Tischtennis Firmen!
Absolut eindrucksvoll!
Wow! This is incredible! About two minutes in he really starts hitting it fast and hard.
Macht echt viel spaß als allein mit die wand spielen. Mit diese roboter noch besser zum Training und spielen. Toll idee. Hut ab! Echt unglaublich. Warum nicht.
Brilliant!!
Great work and congratulations from Egypt.
I hope some day I would be able to do great work like that.
You made me even more persistent to continue learning robotics.
Excellent!!! very impressive!
Thank god it's made in Germany, not in China.
That's why it's fake
Marten Oei lol
Marten Oei
Wait shouldn't it be the other way around?
MWcrazyhorse No, then it would just be a copy.
+babybirdhome fake Made in germany
In my opinion it´s amazing, so nice, wonderfull. One of the most impressive thing about table tennis I´ve ever seen!
This is revolutionary. Keep it up!
Hey! Colle arbeit! Großes lob an euch! Alleine die Idee! Richtig cool!
Nice 3D animation
Really cool, i din't expect it would work that great!
Awesome. It takes a lot of imagination and talent to create such a magnificient device. Congratulations!
Bitte was echt zuhause und das schon vor 8 Jahren. Beeindruckend
This is some good homebrew CGI. Even the music makes it seem real.
Wow fantastic invention... good player.
Buenísima!
It's awesome! Great job guys
Einfach geil. So sieht also unsere Zukunft aus ^^
Hut ab!
Spider webs near the video cameras.... brings new meaning to the term "Webcam"
Pretty amazing! Kudos
amazing! great work. Keep at it.
Cool! Nettes Projekt und sicher ausbaufähig!
Ja, mit noch besserer Grafik ! Und mehr effekten.
Als techniker kann ich nur Respekt sagen..
👍👍👍👌🍻
Sehr geil! Finde ich gut!
Pretty impressive CGI. But servo motors (like "these" on the robotic arm) make a very distinct sound, and this ones are not doing it. If you guys want to hear, go to... "Inside Adam Savage's Cave: Awesome Robot Spider!" 6:27 and hear the servos working
This man will never be forever alone again.
can't wait to see machine learning be applied so that robot can actively learn from mistakes and make itself smarter and smarter over time.
Super cool!
Wow that's awesome, I so need one of these.
If you watch it at 720p.
Don't look at the artifacts on the garage door from the cables on the hand, when it is moving from left to right from 0:03 - 0:09.
Don't look at the blur on the lower half of the garage door.
Don't look at the smudge and blur on the left shadow from the leg, middle of the net, and on the wall at the right end of the net from 0:44
Maybe a little too much reflection for the robot on the table?
But, keep up the great work. I mean 4320 frames is a huge number and the product is amazing.
Please let me know
What are the servos used here ? And From where you bought the servo brackets ?
very good. the robot's arm is so flexible and It seem can reflect immediately with the ball.
Oh~~ Wunderwahr!!!!
It is fake, look at 1:09!
You can see that the camera in the upper right of the garage door is in front of the table tennis racket because it was added to the footage later.
I thought that too, until I see your comment. Now I'm sure. I made a picture to demonstrate. bayimg.com/DaMBGAAFL
Well spotted! I uploaded a screenshot here: s0.uploads.im/JsE60.png
The screen on the computer at 37s looks fake too.
www.heise.de/hardware-hacks/meldung/Der-Tischtennisroboter-und-sein-Phantom-Tueftler-2154534.html
case closed.
@@davidproweb Do you understand camera exposure time can make that too? The Camera sensors integrate all the intensities received in the exposure time. It could be a compression artifact too. So this is not a solid proof. A blur image while taking a picture doesn't make the picture fake.
AMAZING I NEED ONE OF THESE!!!!!
Echt genial gemacht Jungs. ;D
thats pretty cool... someday this will exist with one of those combo tables.. combo ping pong, air hockey and foosball tables where it can entertain your family for hours.
Richtig gut!!
This is FANTASTIC! I can never find anyone to play ping pong with.
Challenge accepted, I have never lost a game, even in state championships! Bring it in ping pong lol no but really I like a good competition.
As I can see, you do not model effects yet!! Really cool, congrats!!
wunderbar!!
Great success. Is this project going to be open source?
Mike Stubbs that robot is great for your table tennis!
Michael und deine Master .das is unglaublich ,das gut uh.........
2 Davon wären Legendär
what if there's 2 of them?...
because its not legal to have 2 racquets/bats is my guess..
Although it ain't a real robot, good job on the 3D and compositing work.
Unfortunately it's a fake. Watch the second arm joint in the beginning tracking sequence- it disappears against the background.
Dose that robot arm look cg to any one other then me? cg or not it can be done so thats cool!
Increadible!
Yes, this is fake. I have reviewed the video for a few minutes and it has become very clear. Here is the evidence.
The computer screen is an overlay. The quality of the screen is poor. The OS as well as the software itself is very strange. Specifically the software. It is far to responsive and has options that make little sense. Someone creating a project like this does not go through the time to create such a user friendly interface also.
During the close up, the quality of the robot does not match up with the raw footage. The robot is pure CGI.
Also, at one point a few frames drop. To many its just some minor error. But believe me, I have worked with motion tracking animation and when a few frames dont track perfectly you may just drop the frames to prevent from re-rendering or tracking. This obviously is only happens with low budget type videos like we see here.
The Animation is well done, but to someone with animation experience like myself, its pretty clear that its not a physical object.
Oh yeah, if you dont believe me, just look at his other videos. Specifically the first one. That is even more obvious, In that video the rig moves way to quickly for any actual rail set robot and the motion blur is set to high.
idk man , idk dont think its fake, they made one in japan that used a high speed camera that reacted within 20 milliseconds !! O.O it wood beat anyone at rock,papper,scissors ( look up Janken Robot ) .... and this looks fairly thought out on his blog.. thingy... here
ulfhoffmannroboter.wordpress.com/
But if it is fake, then he went to great lengths to convince people lol
I can understand the challenge to make it not just return the ball but return the ball in a way that gives robot an advantage. Well done though!
There are too many things that gave away that the robot is an animation.
To the untrained eye, it is very convincing. Well done.
Amazing!
Ein Wunder der Technik!!!!!
I do not know if you can read English but Facebook has this video and it does not a have a source or link to this video. Viva LA UA-cam .
Great job on the CG. Few shadows and things don't line up. Cable at the bottom doesn't behave like a real cable would.
sau gute arbeit!
Fascinating :D
So Nice.
Can you guys see that starting at 2:10 and going on to the clip. The arm appears to be CG and not a real robotic arm.
This takes forever alone to a whole new meaning...
Super!
for who think that kuka commercial was fake, this is another version.... #tofb
Como faço uma cara de espanto, mas espanto de verdade?
#PQP
What if you hit it a short ball/drop shot?
I was wondering that too...
awesome!!
CG Fake (-:
Leider ja, aber ich bin auch erst drauf reingefallen. Die hohen Beschleunigungen ohne wackeln sind unmöglich. Manche sachen sind auch nicht sauber maskiert.
Ich vermute sie haben einfach 2 Leute gegeneinander spielen lassen und haben danach den roboter animiert.
Stefan Welker die Schiene sieht echt aus aber der schlitten und der schläger haben ne merkwürdige farbe die richtig fake aussieht. außerdem sieht es bisschen verschwommen aus
This is a nicely done 3D rendering! ;) you're better at graphics than at engineering :)
can it handle my super spin returns?
Seems fake to me, the guy probably just played against a blue wall (chroma key) and the robot seems to be a 3D animation that was added later, plus you can notice its perspective doesn't change in relation to its position in the table. And I don't see the robot's cable moving anytime.
1:09 - The camera at the wall appears front of the racket
***** How do you explain the camera appearing in front of the racket, then?
***** Then explain the magical disappearing and reappearing pieces of the "robot" between the 0:03 and 0:06 marks. Watch the rounded part of the arm vanish into thin air and reappear again.
Furthermore: hackaday.com/2014/03/28/the-amazing-ping-pong-robot-was-fake/
Hilfe Alter was baust Du bitte heutzutage😆🙌🥳 größten Respekt auf jeden Fall dafür.
GREAT JOB!!!;)
Was für Servos setzt du ein? Robotis Dynamixel?
If a guy built this in his garage, then the kuka robot will simply demolish Timo Boll.
For those unaware, Timo Boll, one of the world's best table tennis players, is to play against a robot in a match on March 11. UA-cam "Kuka Timo Boll"
Richtig cool
Man, you're a genius! I thought it's impossible, because you've solved a problem with fast perception!
Pure Awesomeness!/!
Coll absolut cool
Wow! Echt genial! Wie weit ist das Projekt denn heute (2016)?
sorry das war ein fake von einem animationsbüro
But the machine doesn't appear to put the spins on the ball. Back to the drawing board.
Spettacolare, complimenti !!!
Purtroppo a quanto pare è un fake!
No de veru. Tutto computer. Leggiti i commenti, c'è uno che mette una gif troppo esplicita purtroppo
Comunque fatto bene davvero
Technology plis...
What is the music used in this video?
Absolut Klasse. Wann ist das Ding Serienreif? :-)
respekt!
Das System arbeitete nur passiv.
Hat sich in der Zwischenzeit etwas getan?
Eine neue Definition für "Tennisarm" : -)
I would pay upwards of dollars for this.
That is pretty awesome, must have one.
Make two and put them in an art installation!
Endlessly playing ping pong all day and night.
Top!!
I'm glad my CGI-radar is still working perfectly.