Doctor Who | 11x1 "The Woman Who Fell to Earth" | New Series NEW DOCTOR! | Andres El Rey Reaction
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 лют 2025
- In a South Yorkshire city, Ryan Sinclair, Yasmin Khan and Graham O'Brien are about to have their lives changed forever, as a mysterious woman, unable to remember her own name, falls from the night sky.
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @andreselrey
-----Join the Bloopers-----
👉🏽 bit.ly/2McGBy4 👍🏽
----Contact Me-----
Discord 📝 bit.ly/2L5kvwJ
------- Check My Other Reactions!!----
🔴 bit.ly/3pGXizc
#doctorwho #doctorwhoseries11
ENDING OUTRO HAD A ISSUE WHEN UPLOADING...SORRY IT WAS JUST A RANT ANYWAYS! MORE TO COME LOL
!!!!!!!! LIKE LIKE LIKE LIKE...SHARE SHARE SHARE...SUBSCRIBE SUBSCRIBE SUBSCRIBE! !!!!!
- - Thank You For The Support - - - | Signed Your Friendly Neighborhood Reactor! Bloop! |
JOIN MY PATREON !!! www.patreon.com/andreselrey
JOIN MY UA-cam CHANNEL!! 💚💙💜 bit.ly/2McGBy4 ❤🧡💛
CHECK OUT MY OTHER REACTIONS!! bit.ly/3zufsvL
New Era, New Doctor, New Companions, New Monsters. It’s a ride!
Personally Season 11 is flat for me. But Season 12 and 13 is where Doctor Who picks up again for me!
Glad you liked this, if you like this then you’ll probably really like the rest of this era as it sets the tone for the rest of the series well. Great reaction
Segun Akinola’s music through Jodie’s three series doesn’t get enough praise. I had watched a documentary, “Expedition Volcano,” the year before this episode aired, and he had done the music for that. So I was really looking forward to series 11. I think that people expected series 11 to be like series 1-10 (a space opera; galloping pace, swelling orchestral, music that told you how to feel; companions that end up being Bad Wolf, Doctor/Donna, the universe pouring through their head, the Impossible Girl). If you like the quieter moments in this episode, Grace’s funeral, the chat with the four of them afterwards … if you like Jodie’s acting on the train with Yaz, or when she reformatted Ryan’s phone (“Not any more!), you’ll enjoy this era.
Thanks 💙
Love series 11.
This one is my favourite Doctor Who opener.
😲😲😲😲
@@MichaelM28 oh crazy .... You are back
@@MichaelM28 and yet you are because somehow you only appear during Jodie episodes. Bit of an obsession?
When Graham was standing over Grace's dying body, I was disappointed that he didn't say to her ''And for you, the Chase is over!''
He must've said that against the Daleks at some point
Literally in the middle of a night shoot for a role as an extra and open UA-cam in a break and the first thing I see is Andres? Always welcome ❤
You saying it was a breath of fresh air I totally understand. I felt like that when Matt Snith came on board. I'm very interested in how you enjoy this season.
I enjoyed this episode. The behind the scenes video showing Jodie making that jump way up in the air was intense! I think Jodie is great fun.
@@MichaelM28 LMAOOO NO WAY, you aren't a bot? I see you all the time being a freak show in the comments on the DW channel.. but thats so funny that you aren't a bot.
I don't enjoy the era either but you acc are a clown
@@MichaelM28 likes and dislikes don’t determine if you’re a fan. A fan is determined based off how much you love the show and your knowledge.
Will add that whilst I do think this era has its flaws, it's also got a lot of great stuff. I think you'll love a lot of things but ofc we'll have to see...
@@MichaelM28 L
@@MichaelM28 yeah, you're totally not obsessed...
A breath of fresh air is exactly the right description! Glad you enjoyed it 😊The amount of negativity this era gets is ridiculously out of proportion to it's faults. In terms of storylines/weaker episodes, it's on par with the rest of modern who. There was a huge backlash back in the day when Moffat and Smith took over, but it was nowhere near as vicious and long lasting as the backlash to 13s run has been. Plenty of the fanbase enjoy this era, but saying so can get you trolled like mad in the online community, so it's led to a really one sided narrative. Looking forward to seeing your reactions to the rest of the show!
Thank you for pointing this. Matt Smith became my favorite and I know Jodi is some people's favorite too. The hate her season is wildly disproportionate to the quality of episodes to come. And, in my opinion, some of the most shocking revolations.
Glad you liked it. Its a strong beginning and I really like the actress playing the doctor. For me personally I find series 11 bland from a script perspective, the actors do their best. But also its a new production/writing team so they are finding their way slowly with some bumps on the way.
Really glad you liked this. As a fan of the show since Four I also really enjoyed it. I think for some there was just too much change, and I think (in my opinion at least) Twelve was always going to be a tough act to follow, but I reckon Jodie gave it a darned good go and I quite enjoyed her era. Looking forward to watching you make your own mind up. ;) :)
So happy you enjoyed this. As always your give your fair and balanced thoughts.
Something I have to say about this era is that there are some episodes that I genuinely do not like, but some of them are in my top favorites list, despite the huge number of episodes I consider 'favorites'. Jodie is phenomenal and I don't even mind bad episodes because I so enjoy watching her have fun in the job.
I'm glad you liked it. This era is a disappointing ride at times for me. Jodie does her best. Credit to her. But the revolving / dice rolling focus on companions and 'some' of the tepid delivery is an adjustment after we've had such dynamic and high calibre performances from the last 10 series. Even if we've not always loved every aspect of each of the companions' characters the whole time.
I've rewatched this section a number of times now. The best word is plateau. For every positive element, there's a big negative that manages to even it out to just average. There will be those that write the whole thing off as dire, which isn't objectivity true. But I can't ignore the fundamental deficiencies that seem to stem from the new show runner. A person who later admitted they had it longer than they wanted it. Because passing the baton on was very difficult. They had some absolutely fantastic ideas that were unfortunately often poorly realised, ineffectually applied, and narratively problematic. Having said that, we won't write off those gem elements that can be dug out amongst the expositional writing and box ticking exercise that plagues the approach to some of the script structures. Too often, I was just left wanting.
"person who later admitted they had it longer than they wanted it." He never said that, in fact he said from the start he planned to do 3 series though due to the pandemic at one point it looked like he wasn't going to be able to make the third season but thanks to hard work and determination he made it happen.
I did not like Capaldi's doctor and detested doctor wannabe Clara, so glad I don't ever need to watch his era again..and I have not.
@Friendly Otaku In an interview, that admittedly was only reporting what they had said. The impression was given that they had the job longer than expected or wanted. This very well was due to the pandemic, I'll concede this. But also finding their replacement was probably difficult. Someone appropriately tasked in improving the perception of the show's future success as well as the reported decline in viewing figures.
@@daryl9434 finding the replacement was difficult, this has been confirmed. "reported decline in viewing figures" Chibnall himself has debunked this and has said with tv habits changing viewing figures just don't matter in the way they used to and they never came up in his conversations with the BBC, in fact what mattered more was audience share - how much of the audience during Doctor Who's timeslot is watching the show and this aspect has continued to be strong so the BBC were very happy with the performance.
@Friendly Otaku That's fair. That's why I used the word perception. Do you feel the level of opposition to the declining quality was at the same level in the respective years? This might very well be the case, I honestly don't know. Some of it is 🧌's, like all big franchises have been subjected to. None of the episodes deserve a 1, 2, or even a 3. I'd be hard pushed to justify a 4. These scores are simply ludicrous. A common stance I've heard in defence of this era. Is the position that it's not as bad as people say. Which is true to a great degree. I critique it because I stuck with it, then went back and rewatched it again and again, analysing what worked and what didn't, separating out my own taste from the very basics we become accustomed to, as I've done with series 1-10. I came to the conclusion that the balance of appreciable factors is noticeably deficient in some really important areas at times. Let's not fail to notice that pre showrunning. Their episodes weren't amongst some of the highest appreciated episodes. I just say it as I see it.
Hello. I see in the comment a profil called "Micheal" who harass some comments in the video.
Great reaction ;) Love this episode !
Glad you loved this. I Love her think Jodie is an amazing actress and I think she brought the fun of 10 and 11 back. I know overall some of the stories over her run were not the best, that is not a reflection of her amazing acting. But like you said once on the bus I am not getting off till the end. Doctor who blood through my veins!
Its very different from the high concept, high energy of the previous few seasons of the 12th doctor. This era is more down to earth and plot heavy, with the doctor at the centre of every single scene and companions saying "whats that doctor?". Companion-wise its the opposite of the Clara type of companion.
Dr who ! Great reaction andre
Lovely to watch your reactions to the 13th Doctor's first story. I give it an 8,5 out of 10. The 13th Doctor reminds me a bit of the Seventh Doctor (my first Doctor), being a bit joyful and careless, but still very careful and thoughtful. IMO, this whole era is like an old classic Doctor Who season, but with a modern take and using modern effects. I'm so happy that you liked this. Greetings from Sweden and thank's for a fantastic UA-cam channel. 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
I think Jodie is a fantastic Doctor let down by some questionable writing at times ( I thought the same about Peter Capaldi).
My issues with this era is Chibnall wanting to make a mark in DW history and swinging the retcon hammer around but I'm getting way ahead of myself.
Enjoy the show and I for one am happy to have you back on the DW train earlier than expected ❤
Waiting for the full reaction 🏃🏻❤️
the historical from this era are great ❤
@@MichaelM28 ha the only Jodi bot here is you, leaving comments on every Jodi video ever, I don't see you in others doctor who relate videos 😂
@@ginabb76 yeah, he must really LOVE her *starts playing Wedding music for Jodie and Michael* lol
When you reach this point in Who, it's time to start watching Broadchurch.
And here it is, the start of an era that gets more flack than it really deserves! I'm so happy to see you enjoyed this first episode, looking forward to you reacting to more episodes!
I've seen people say that one day a great number of people will look back at this era and realise that it actually wasn't that bad. Maybe a few weak/middling episodes here and there, but every era has that.
@@thepandorica1660 Exactly! As well as the people who have grown up with this era with Jodie as their Doctor, they will particularly look back fondly! That's the beauty of Doctor Who
Love the mouse, where did u get it?
Best buy !! Razar I think that's the brand name
Is it just me or does the thing in the forest look like a giant easter Hershey kiss?
I like that you brought back Doctor Who early but even I wouldn't have urged you/pressured you to bring it earlier than the beginning of May...
Jodie was great, as were the companions. My problem with this era of the show is that the show runner seems to not be willing or able to follow through on things. For the next three seasons it's a fair bet that if you like a story or character and want to see more, you probably won't. The guy had some good ideas for things but he didn't seem like he knew what to do with them, unlike the previous two show runners - this stepped over the line of 'always leave them wanting more' for me. Prominent example was Ryan's dyspraxia, which got a fair amount of good press when this episode first aired but it's dropped almost immediately from the show, until it very rarely isn't. I didn't hate this period of the show's history at all, but I did notice that I wasn't quite as eager to see each new episode as in years past. There's some good stuff though - especially in Jodie's second season. 🙂
Some people said they would never watch Doctor Who again as soon as a woman was cast in the role. Ignore the man-babies and judge the episodes for yourself.
Oh, here we go with the morons 🙄...
@@MichaelM28 That 60% drop is utter nonsense. Do your research.
I really like this ep, and honestly, I like this era. Jodie really is quite good as the Doctor. I’ll admit sometimes the writing let her down, but overall I enjoyed the seasons with 13. I started watching in 2005 when the series came back. Have caught up with a lot of classic Who. I’ll keep watching and enjoying as long as it’s here for me to enjoy.
This era certainly has its faults, but the virulence of much of the criticism is out of all proportion to them. If people don't enjoy something, that's fine, and indeed it would be expecting a lot to think everyone should enjoy all eras of a show that's undergone many changes over many decades. However, I suspect that with time, it won't be obvious to many people what a lot of the fuss was about.
Anyway, I'm glad you enjoyed this episode, which I think is an under-rated one that mostly does a good job of doing what it needs to do. The weakest element by far is the villain, but then that's often also true for other "introductory" episodes (and isn't the main point of them). For the most part I felt this was a much-needed freshening up.
I hope you enjoy this era it will be very different to what your use to but that's what the show is about. Change. Ignore the arrogant man babies and old school misogynists and enjoy it.
@@MichaelM28 Real fans embrace change your not a real fan if you fear it.
@@joshuaverran9443 its a crazy bot...
Joshua verran i agree.
Sometimes you'll go: "what?!" just like you did in the previous series.
Sometimes you 'll go: "I love this" just like ...
Sometimes you'll go: "ahahhhhahahaahhahaaaa" just ...
you'll get the geste, just like the previous series, this show has his faults but it also gives you the feeling you're watching something special and
I'm sure you will keep watching and enjoying this show, ohw, I'm so sure of it!!! And I will watch you doing that.
I like this Era overall. I really like Jodie. I think she didn't get the best writers and that was a disservice to her. There are a lot of things I really dislike about this Era, but overall it's enjoyable.
@@MichaelM28 LMFAO you're joking, right?
@@transientanus 😂 don't pay attention it's jus a crazy guy who needs help. He living the same comments on every reaction to 13 Doctor or video from official channel 😂😂😂
@@lastchristmas8153 Hahaha! I appreciate you, that's really funny. I guess folks like him just have too much time on their hands XD
He does this in every video that features Jodie he must really hate her that much 😂
@@lastchristmas8153 exactly. I'm thinking he's secretly obsessed and embarrassed to admit he actually loves this era. It's the only place we see him after all...
i left it after a few episodes but maybe i start this season again after your episodes...
Personally I loved these newer series
I'm not ashamed to say that I don't mind this era. It's certainly not the best, but I enjoy it occasionally. With that being said the stuff I do Enjoy the most won't be here until Series 12 which, while not "OMG one of the best", is still a great season, and ya know what, Series 13 is also pretty good, not great, but good, so can't wait until you reach that. Jodie Whittaker is a Doctor I wish I liked More, when she nails it she nails it but a good actress can only carry a role so much when it's written so inconsistently within a single episode for some stories. And the companions arent really the most interesting. I'm sorry if I sound negative but I'm just being honest with how I feel about this era without spoiling it. But there are things to enjoy about it, and I'm tired of fans acting so "binary" about it.
@@MichaelM28 come now, don't be so negative. There are aspects to like, stories to enjoy. Can't go too in depth for spoiler reasons for the people who haven't watched, but still, this may be the weakest era of New who, possibly all of DW, but there's still some things in here to enjoy.
@@arkthegreenwolfx3627 he's only masking his enjoyment. Think about it. What else would explain the fact the only place we see him is during 13's era stuff and not anywhere else like the Classic era or with Moffat or RTD?
I love Jodie as the doctor !! She became my fave doctor and I think s12 and s13 are probably in my top 5 series. There’s a few things I don’t like about this era but I feel like that can be said about any era of doctor who 😂
@@MichaelM28 why
@@thesarcasticsimmer1383 He's scared of women.
Salad Man 4 evah!!!
People did complain a lot about Jodie, but I really enjoyed her iteration.
@@MichaelM28 ha! I called it! I knew you'd say that!
To me something was immediately off and missing, plus I didn’t like the cinematic new camera, it just didn’t feel very who.
For me this episode had its faults but was ok, sadly however it pretty much never picked up... episodes ranged from a high of "meh" to many lows of "dire" or "abismal" afterwards.... (having said that there is a 10 minute sequence in the next episode that was good and gave me chills and a little hope... of course it didn't lead anywhere..)
The season was disappointing to my taste, but I think this introduction episode was very good. It set the standard high. At this point I thought I was going to enjoy the season.
I won't go into spoilers, but I don't thin Chibnal (the showrunner for this season) was respectful of Doctor Who Canon. But I will reserve specific comments until after the reactions to the specific episodes are posted.
Doctor Who doesn't really have a canon.
War Doctor wasn't canon until it was.
I definitely don't like this era as much as previous ones, but I don't hate it either. Some good, some bad... it's fine.
This is a good introduction for 13. However, I don't enjoy this era, I think the writing is pretty bad, and I have issues with some of the storylines, which is too bad, because I do like Jody. It takes her a little while to embody the Doctor, but she gets there. With some better writers, she could have been a really good Doctor. But let's go through this era, because there's a big prize at the end XD
Yeah I quite like this episode is a good start :) This era is far from being as good as the previous to me, but it's still enjoyable ^^
The thing that really took me out of this episode is that she fell to Earth (yes we know that the Doctor has done it before in a spacesuit backwards), but no suit, no problem WTF, It made me strongly dislike this impossible woman doctor and Almost walk away from Doctor who... Almost!!!
Well, a Time Lord is still immune to physical harm within the first fifteen hours after a regeneration. 10 got his hand cut off, but then grew another one just fine. River got shot at repeatedly...no effect. It's possible this is the case with 13 here.
@@thepandorica1660 Yet when Matt Smith got shot while regenerating he died - The Impossible Astronaut.
@@colindeane9759 because it was a robot. With the tiny people inside, remember? 😊
@@hb4080 however we are told by River...
"Whatever that thing was killed him in the middle of his regeneration cycle"
Delaware the third "That is most certainly is the Doctor and he is most certainly dead"
Spoilers it's a robot that can Miraculously produce regeneration energy but the point remains we are led to believe if you kill a timelord while regenerating... they are most certainly dead!!
@@colindeane9759 that's true, but we learn later in the wedding with river that it was a ruse by the doctor from the start 🤷♂️ when he said "I just told you my name" but he actually whispered "look into my eye" and we see the doctor dancing
This era is definitely a mixed bag but I still think it’s enjoyable overall :)
@@MichaelM28 everyone can have their own opinions
@@SamDavs Ignore him he's been doing this for years he's after attention and to get a rise out of you.
I'm not a fan of the 13 era. I gave it a chance, but checked out halfway through the second season, for reasons I can't get into, because *spoilers*, but I'll be here for your reaction videos. That being said I thought this was an okay episode, the Doctor was still "cooking", so we don't see the full person necessarily. I didn't care for the villain, wearing teeth seemed silly to me. Grace's death was rough, and I was right there with Ryan & Graham.
Could the mods get rid of Michael as he is a well known troll.
I'd like to believe they have many times but he keeps on creating a new account and doing the same nonsense. Almost like he secretly loves this era, as it's the only place we see him
I will try to handle it
I personally dont like most of the episodes of the Jodie Era, not Jodies fault though, i like her as the doctor. But many episodes don`t got the doctor Who feeling for me.
I am not a fan of the whittaker/chibnall era, but im still sticking with you for the journey of course! Jodie gets some really weak material to work with and her acting choice for the doctor is just too frantic and hyper, i feel exhausted watching her hahaha
I’d probably like this era slightly more if Ryan didn’t exist. He’s just the worst actor I’ve seen in anything for a really really long time, if not THE worst actor in Doctor who of all time. His wooden voice just makes his entire run un rewatchable for me
I love the quality. Better graphics than the prior seasons. Shame the season isn’t the best
I love the 13th Doctor!
Good on ya daffy 😊
@@MichaelM28 Just because you dont like it doesn't mean other people are fake fans if they like it their allowed too stop dictating people.
I hate Jodie Whittaker's entire time as the Doctor, but I'm definitely still here for your reactions!!!
I was in the same boat for the Capaldi era as I never connected with his doctor. I never watch any reactions from anybody for his past 3 series so looking forward to Jodies.
@@booradley8895 I have an exact opposite opinion. I love 12 and simply just don't like 13 at all. But everyone is entitled to their opinions and I respect yours
Dw is terrible from this point 😢
😴
Grow up
Gatto Rubio In your opinion other people might like it everyone has their era.
Lol welcome to the era where nothing makes sense but don’t worry since Jodie will breathlessly explain the plot for you mid-episode 😂 I’ll still be here for the ride, I do think there’s still some very good moments here and there. Hope you catch up in time for the next series to start in November.
The next series starts in 2024 we only have the 3 anniversary specials and possibly a Christmas special that may or may not be on Christmas this year
General T Has Doctor Who ever made sense? Lol
And you have reached what is generally the worst era of the doctor. And hopefully the next one gets back to being good after this doctor dies.
And it isn't her fault, its just that the new show runner is terrible. (Show runner or writer, don't remember which.)