86: Bhagavad Gita Class by Swami Tadatmananda - Ch.12 Verses 12-13

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 вер 2022
  • New class uploaded each week. All prior classes available here: • Bhagavad Gita - classe...
    Bhagavad Gita in English verse chanted by Swami Tadatmananda: • Complete Bhagavad Gita...
    Swami Tadatmananda's translation, audio download, and podcast available on our website here: arshabodha.org/teachings/bhag...
    Swami Tadatmananda is a traditionally-trained teacher of Advaita Vedanta, meditation, and Sanskrit. For more information, please see: www.arshabodha.org/

КОМЕНТАРІ • 36

  • @ravish05
    @ravish05 Рік тому +2

    Thank you much swamiji for the excellent reply to the question I had posted last week. Really appreciate it. Hari om 🙏🙏

  • @saritabhatia9078
    @saritabhatia9078 Рік тому +1

    Naman Gurudev! Dhanyavad 🙏 Gurudev! It’s such an awesome journey with you on the mysterious Spiritual Path of enlightenment!
    Your teachings have removed so many obstacles on the path of Spiritual Growth! Gratitude 🙏 Gurudev for your blessings!
    🙏🕉🔔🪔🇮🇳🦢🪷🦢🪷🦢🪷🦢🪷🦢🇮🇳🪔🔔🕉🙏🌹📚🌺📚💐

  • @saritabhatia9078
    @saritabhatia9078 Рік тому +1

    Thank You 🙏 Gurubhai Ravi Sankararaman for asking such a good question and Thank You 🙏 to our Pujya Gurudev, for answering this important question in such a way that many of our doubts were removed about the practical implementation of principles of Karma Yoga!
    Gratitude 🙏 ! Gratitude 🙏!
    🙏🕉🪔🔔🇮🇳🦢🪷🦢🪷🦢🪷🦢🪷🦢🇮🇳🔔🪔🕉🙏

    • @tzadik36
      @tzadik36 Рік тому

      Pratibodha viditam matam

  • @rpd-ut9rt
    @rpd-ut9rt Рік тому +2

    🙏

  • @vasukinagabhushan
    @vasukinagabhushan Рік тому

    Karma Yoga is doing one's duty without expecting any results.

  • @gridcoregilry666
    @gridcoregilry666 Рік тому

    Thank you so much!!!

  • @monikavarma4
    @monikavarma4 Рік тому +7

    Thank you swamiji.. is there any way we can join your satsangs and Vedanta classes also online ? Or view recordings here on you tube?

  • @makingofmandala7264
    @makingofmandala7264 Рік тому

    Namaste! Thank you Guruji. 🙏

  • @markk221
    @markk221 Рік тому

    thank you so much for today's teachings.and have a nice day

  • @knowledgeispower604
    @knowledgeispower604 Рік тому

    The thing i love about advait most it never stops you from reading one book or other its confident in its teaching advaiti never miss translate they try to be as accurate as possible

  • @tzadik36
    @tzadik36 Рік тому

    Pronaams! 🙏 Namaskaars to all!🙏

  • @chironsthea607
    @chironsthea607 Рік тому

    Namaste, om shanti

  • @srinivasaboggaram
    @srinivasaboggaram Рік тому +2

    Namasthe SwamyJi, thanks for another wonderful session, I keep looking forward to your next sessions always. Could you please record the Tuesday Vedanta class as well for online students like me 🙏🏽. Also it would be nice to hear the sathsang though it’s not a session it help clarify many questions many others may have like me. 🙏🏽

  • @luismiguel69able
    @luismiguel69able Рік тому

    yes!!!! Tuesdays are back!

  • @cooluva7892
    @cooluva7892 Рік тому +3

    We eagerly wait for Sunday mornings to listen to your wonderful explanations of Gita teachings! Are the Tuesday evening Satsangs going to be live-streamed? It will be wonderful if we can also watch them!

  • @alukuhito
    @alukuhito Рік тому

    🙏🕉

  • @ritswik
    @ritswik Рік тому

    12:30 meditation is fixing your mind on a object of meditation.

  • @guilhermecoutinho7521
    @guilhermecoutinho7521 Рік тому

    I realy like that concept of the iluminat is realy powerfull! However I think the idea can lead to neglect or passivity to your self or others. Imagine I have a problem with sickness I belive that altough I'm part of god I still should try to heal a make good decisons for my body. Maybe because of dharma idk hope to see a clear explanation in the next verses. Namaste untill next sunday 😎

  • @srinivaskrovvidi1711
    @srinivaskrovvidi1711 Рік тому

    Thanks very much Samiji, please let us know when do you plan to be in India next time, I really would love to be physically present in any of your classes.

  • @ssapthar
    @ssapthar Рік тому +1

    Thank you Swamiji 🙏 Looking forward to your Tuesday lessons.
    I just recently listened to your Advaita Makaranda and I have a question relating to that text and today's teachings. How do you intellectually make a jump from, 'I am not a karta and not a bhokta but a witness (sakshi)' to 'I am not even a Sakshi'? Also, not sure if I should say - 'I am a witness' or 'I am the Witnesses'? Thank you.

    • @rsr9200
      @rsr9200 Рік тому +2

      Your question, “How do you intellectually make a jump from, 'I am not a karta and not a bhokta but a witness (sakshi)' to 'I am not even a Sakshi'?” piqued my interest and I will present my opinion which may or may not adequately address that question. It seems to me that the question is based on the premise that our doership as individuals (i.e., as doer of an intellectual jump) is involved in realizing our true nature as Satchitananda atma aka Brahman aka Ishvara aka the reality of the sakshi and sakshya. However, as I understand it, the teachings of the Bhagavad Gita covered in this video suggest to us that since there is only Ishvara, there is no doer or enjoyer other than Ishvara. Hence, our belief that we are individual doers/enjoyers is an erroneous belief. Further, the correction or removal of this error cannot be accomplished by us through our doing as individuals but rather it just takes place through the grace or doing of Ishvara. Therefore, for moksha aspirants like us, Sri Krishna teaches Ishvara arpana buddhi (mentioned by Swamiji in previous lessons) and prasada buddhi (mentioned in this lesson) as means for invoking and receiving Ishvara’s grace of freedom from doership and enjoyership, i.e., jivanmukhti/moksha.

    • @ssapthar
      @ssapthar Рік тому +1

      @@rsr9200 Thank you for your reply.

  • @gorabacha
    @gorabacha 8 місяців тому

    Would it reasonable to call ishwar Arpana buddhi, bhog buddhi?

  • @radhikaprasad8012
    @radhikaprasad8012 Рік тому

    Please enable us to access the vedanta classes online as well.

  • @paramasadguru1618
    @paramasadguru1618 Рік тому +1

    There is one totally effective, easy and direct spiritual practice that does not contain any adhikāri bhéda, which can be practiced by anyone at any time. This is, by perceiving and understanding the subtlest sense of "I Am- ahaṃ asmi" that pulsates in every human being in and throughout one's life. No one can experience one's absence even for a moment because "I Am that we ARE" is eternally present in all of us beyond space and time. By awakening our Power of Witnessing, if we learn to observe this most personal and intimate Sense of "I Am", it becomes easy to outdo the ignorance of 'I Am the body- the three bodies' and to steadily establish ourselves in the Subtlest Knowledge of "I Am", which helps us to connect ourselves effortlessly and effectively with the Underlying Supreme Principle of "I AM- Paramātma".

    • @rsr9200
      @rsr9200 Рік тому

      Perhaps, Popeye the Sailor Man, the legendary spinach-loving cartoon character, would heartily endorse the “I AM” based approach for self-realization you seem to advocate. His famous refrain “I yam what I yam and that's all what I yam” succinctly articulated his existential philosophy. Although Popeye never spoke of the “Underlying Supreme Principle”, I suspect he was on to it! 😜

    • @paramasadguru1618
      @paramasadguru1618 Рік тому

      @@rsr9200Advaitha Makaranda:
      1 aham asmi sadaa bhaami, I ever exist; always do I shine;
      2 kadaachit na aham apriyah; I am never disagreeable to Myself;
      3 brahma iva aham atah siddham, thus it is established, “Brahman alone am I” -
      4 sachidaananda lakshanam. of the nature of Existence-Consciousness-Bliss.

    • @rsr9200
      @rsr9200 Рік тому

      @@paramasadguru1618 First, it is instructive to note that the author of Advaita Makaranda starts that text with a moving prayer invoking the grace of Ishvara in the form of Sri Krishna. Therefore, I have no reason to believe that he would advise us to dispense with the teachings of Sri Krishna in the Bhagavad Gita which accommodate adhikari bheda in favor of the Popeye technique for self-realization advocated in the original posting on this thread.
      Second, the Advaita Makaranda is fully grounded in the wisdom revealed through the Upanishads and the Upanishadic teachings of the Bhagavad Gita and is intended for our nidhidhyasana on what it means for our svarupa as satchitananda to be identical to Ishvara’s svarupa as satyam jnanam anantam. In contrast, the Popeye technique being advocated seems to dispense with the Upanishads as the pramana for satchitananda atma/Ishvara/Brahman and seems to suggest that we would just stumble into realizing our true nature as Ishvara/Brahman by somehow “perceiving and understanding the subtlest sense of "I Am- ahaṃ asmi" that pulsates in every human being”.
      Third, the claim that the Popeye technique will enable us to “steadily establish ourselves in the Subtlest Knowledge of "I Am", which helps us to connect ourselves effortlessly and effectively with the Underlying Supreme Principle of "I AM- Paramātma" defies reason. Assuming the term Paramatma is being used interchangeably with Satchitananda atma, I cannot fathom how a “connection” can be made with satchitananda atma. In the English language, a connection implies joining of two objects. However, Satchitananda atma is not an object and hence connecting to Satchitananda atma seems illogical to me. Furthermore, since Satchitananda atma is all there is, what is there other than Satchitananda atma for any connection to be made at all?

  • @SonOfChrist777
    @SonOfChrist777 Рік тому

    What happened to Arjun in the last whom gita was given?

  • @rajukunjukrishnan472
    @rajukunjukrishnan472 Рік тому

    Pranam Guruji

  • @daisybelleamberbush
    @daisybelleamberbush 6 місяців тому

    🙏🙏

  • @markk221
    @markk221 Рік тому

    thank you so much for today's teachings.and have a nice day

  • @kanishkajoshi563
    @kanishkajoshi563 Рік тому

    🙏

    • @heinzehrsam118
      @heinzehrsam118 Рік тому

      Thank you Swamiji! I am always appreciative of being able to learn from your teachings.
      I would also love to participate in your Tuesday classes, should you load them in UA-cam or on your website.