You should direct your concerns towards the people who misuse it. Nobal encourages people to use it for reference and sparking new Ideas (as it should be used). It's a great tool for ideas references and just plain fun. I'm 100% behind him. It's not like he's saying, "use this cool tool and sell the art for profit". It's on each of us to make responsible decisions "With great power comes great responsibility". 😮
@@upswithwings expecting only artists to use ai is like expecting only writers to use spelling checker and article ai's, and only people with a degree to use coding ai's, or musicians music ai's, art AI is the one thats furthest along. Its not about misuse, there is no misuse, its about it costing people their jobs, and taking away possible future positions as well as taking away much of the worth of art, directing it at people using ai is dumb.
@@slightmovement8985 Its because I believe Ai art generators should be use for references and "just plain fun" that's why I say misuse. Its not like I have a say for what its made for, but I DO have a say for how I use it.
@slightmovement8985 Also, I never said said I was expecting anybody to do anything. Its up to you whether ya want to use it needless to say.... Im simply just stating that we have the power to do the right thing and I don't get why its dumb to direct your frustrations to the people who do wrong with the art AIs. They are the ones using the AI generators, and or AI and selling the created results and destroying the value of art. Is it wrong to promote responsible method of use to everyone? Um are we on the same side?😅
Your actually a really good teacher i was reading the animators survival kit and couldn't really figure out this concept but after watching this vid everything was a lot more clearer💯
@@Coffantasy I dont think so. As an artist myself i think using ai to create references for new ideas, especially ones that are hyperspecific that you cant find with just 2 clicks is a great way to incorporate AI into the creative workflow.
Watching this after attempting to do my (technically) second animation, which was a bouncing lollipop with a ribbon attached (I thought it’d be cute, idk 😂) and I’m actually shocked that I kind of was able to “intuit” making the ribbon ease in and out so that it looked “right” according to the feel of the motion I was going for- it followed a similar arc to your figure here. Obviously, it took a long time, I was just adding frames where it felt right, and it wasn’t such a smooth/straightforward process like how you planned the animation here, so this was really helpful in showing how to plan the timing, determine what needs to go on which frame, etc., along with explaining the types of motion. Thank you for such a great video! 🙏
I really love the way you introduced timing charts in this! I've always known about them, but I wasn't sure just how much they'd contribute to the animation process. Really great tutorial, thanks! :)
Ai is only harmful if you make it harmful, using it as a tool for reference only isn’t bad. ai already exist and isn’t going anywhere, so why not find the good in it.
@@weebleevideos9847For me the only thing I find harmful about A.I. generated images is when people use the art that it generates for profit and claim it to be “art”!🙄
@@thecreator308 😅 bro your argument is irrelevant, AI and racism are not the same thing, AI has its good and bad... Racism is just bad lol What kind of thinking ability you have there?
thank you so much, as a traditional artist getting into digital animation it does look a bit overwhelming. But, here you explained it so well. I appreciate the guides you make, and I will make sure to use these in my future animations!
man literally starts his video with a trailer for a website that uses pintrest and artstation to train their ai. Pintrest especially is known for people posting large amounts of uncredited art work, so its impossible for that art to be referenced with any consent. For those curious: CF Spark uses LAION-5B data set for their AI, which heavily just scrapes easily accessible publicly available (note: not necessarily licensed or free use) images for their data set.
I am just a beginner but I am really excited /intimidated and this really helped me with the former. Thanks I will be using all of your videos. I am trying to use Adobe animate hope I can navigate with your videos using that if not I will focus on the concepts once I learn the software. again thanks
helped me a lot I already knew about the motions but it seemed that I didn't understand the correctly and that's why my animations were not smothe at all and I didn't really know why after watching your video I found the problem thanks a lot will watch your other videos as well I am sure I can learn something from it !
not sure if anyone pointed this out yet but at 1:49 (and subsequently the video) you have exchanged the motion for ease in and ease out. When the images grow closer over time that motion is considered ease **in** and when the images space out over time that is easing **out** . Great video though!
the concepts are clear and the application was on point, but the terms are just wrong :/ considering the reach you have with your platform I would urge you to please cross check terms before uploading the video
Hello, Thanks for your feedback. The reason the terms are switched is because I first learned animation on the digital platform. Traditional animators refer to starting slow as an "ease out" and ending slow as an "ease in". Despite how you refer to them though, the important thing is to identify whether an object is moving constantly or accelerating: speeding up or slowing down. My upcoming video will go deeper into that. Happy animating!
@@NobleFrugal thanks for taking your time to respond! It's interesting that you find your digital learning experience this way. If you don't mind, what sources did you learn from? I have a degree in animation (albeit traditional but I learned a lot from online sources also), and have worked in the industry for a while; from this standpoint it's important to know the right terminology for effective communication. All props to you for making easy to digest content and making these animation breakdowns! But the right terminology (for folks looking to work in the industry) is still a must. Have a great day! :)
Hello. Thank you as well. I agree with that. I'd have to say that it mainly comes from my experience with Blender 3D and the video editing programs I've used over the years. When editing your animation's curve, (in Blender, or Davinci Resolve, etc) the ease in ease out names are flipped (ease in slows the start, and ease out slows the end). For this reason, I may not continue using these terms at all since, depending on your perspective, they are interchangeable. However, you make a good point regarding industry work. I hadn't thought of that. Okay thanks, you have a good day too.
your channel was recommended to me by the algorithm after I did a few search on quick videos to onboard junior animators and I'm absolutely delighted that I also get to review everything by binge-watching your content!!
I know AI art makes it really scary for illustrators, but AI art cannot create something original the same way a human can. Where humans use references and create something entirely new, AI photoshops a bunch of images together to make something that resembles a new drawing. This difference is important, it means that, if a client needs something specific, the computer won't be able to replicate what the client is looking for completely. It is about intent, the intent of shape language, color palette, stylization, texturing, and shading, all of which are unique to each artist. I hope this has helped reassure anyone who is afraid of losing their jobs or doesn't even want to try as an artist. AI is a tool, just like how a pencil is a tool, or photoshop is a tool.
Kinda true , on the other hand, NO, Ai art don't just photoshops a bunch of image together. That's a common misunderstanding on how the AI works. Basicly the AI is just trained to denoise pics. When you give him a prompt, he basicly tries to understand how he usually have to denoise a noise picture that have the same kind of content than the ones you ask for. For that, yeah , he use a library (that sometimes uses licensed work wich sucks) but this library is actually just used to makes the AI understand what kind of goal is set when it will be time to denoise. I know that can be some see as some nitpicking, but I think it's important to tell because YEAH, Ai can create new stuff. On the other hand, this is just a tool , and if you really need a perfect result that you will have full control on , for now , you can't go without an artist, and you were right about that one^^
Sorry to tell you, but humans can't create anything original either. Even so far back as the greek philosophers, they knew that there's no such thing as an "original" idea. It's all remixing existing stuff in new ways.
So I've been animating for about a year now (I've got a channel where I post stuff) and I have to say, this is INCREDIBLY USEFUL! Thanks for another awesome video, they really help :)
hey @nobelfrugal i understood the concept of timing and spacing however....i was wondering ow do you know where to put your key frames when animating on twos do you have to calculate first in order to get perfect places to put your inbetweens? hope you see this and reply thank you
Key frames are like storyboards. Anyway, you dont need to "find where to put them", just add however many the inbetween frames are necessary to get to the next key frame.
Nice to see that you still improve and work inside openToonz. What is the name of the pad that you use with your xp pen? I do kinda miss something like that for my 22 inch screen. Never mind i did found my answer in previous video.
It would have been nice if drawing 5 the SR arm favored more of drawing B when coming down. That way it avoids twinning of the arms and the arc would flow better without popping into the final pose.
hi noble frugal, do you have some tips as to how to estimate the half desitance of the before frame when you ease in or ease out? thanks for the video!
Mainly because I learned animation on the digital platform. Traditional animators refer to starting slow as an "ease out" and ending slow as an "ease in". Despite how you refer to them, the important thing is to identify whether an object is moving constantly or accelerating. My upcoming video will go deeper into that. Happy animating!
What is your source of income other than youtube? Because even I am thinking to not work for a studio and animate from home . Also does this earn well? Or is a studio better?
Quick question, what is the name of the thing you are holding in your left hand while drawing (controller thing)? I'm looking for something like that but never knew what it was called.
Can't quite wrap my head around an artist on youtube promoting AI art generation in his intro.
You should direct your concerns towards the people who misuse it. Nobal encourages people to use it for reference and sparking new Ideas (as it should be used). It's a great tool for ideas references and just plain fun. I'm 100% behind him. It's not like he's saying, "use this cool tool and sell the art for profit". It's on each of us to make responsible decisions "With great power comes great responsibility". 😮
@@upswithwings expecting only artists to use ai is like expecting only writers to use spelling checker and article ai's, and only people with a degree to use coding ai's, or musicians music ai's, art AI is the one thats furthest along. Its not about misuse, there is no misuse, its about it costing people their jobs, and taking away possible future positions as well as taking away much of the worth of art, directing it at people using ai is dumb.
@@upswithwings and what do you mean by misuse it, you are naïeve to believe its made to use as reference only
@@slightmovement8985 Its because I believe Ai art generators should be use for references and "just plain fun" that's why I say misuse. Its not like I have a say for what its made for, but I DO have a say for how I use it.
@slightmovement8985 Also, I never said said I was expecting anybody to do anything. Its up to you whether ya want to use it needless to say.... Im simply just stating that we have the power to do the right thing and I don't get why its dumb to direct your frustrations to the people who do wrong with the art AIs. They are the ones using the AI generators, and or AI and selling the created results and destroying the value of art. Is it wrong to promote responsible method of use to everyone? Um are we on the same side?😅
Your actually a really good teacher i was reading the animators survival kit and couldn't really figure out this concept but after watching this vid everything was a lot more clearer💯
I didn’t understand what he was doing. I’m still new to this
The first few minutes of this video is the most hilarious thing ever
yeah. its weird how an artist is promoting ai though.
@@Coffantasy I dont think so. As an artist myself i think using ai to create references for new ideas, especially ones that are hyperspecific that you cant find with just 2 clicks is a great way to incorporate AI into the creative workflow.
Watching this after attempting to do my (technically) second animation, which was a bouncing lollipop with a ribbon attached (I thought it’d be cute, idk 😂) and I’m actually shocked that I kind of was able to “intuit” making the ribbon ease in and out so that it looked “right” according to the feel of the motion I was going for- it followed a similar arc to your figure here. Obviously, it took a long time, I was just adding frames where it felt right, and it wasn’t such a smooth/straightforward process like how you planned the animation here, so this was really helpful in showing how to plan the timing, determine what needs to go on which frame, etc., along with explaining the types of motion. Thank you for such a great video! 🙏
Trying to learn animation, wish me luck ! :)
Good luck man wish you the best in your journey!
How's your animation going , I'm starting today so any suggestions will be appreciated
I really love the way you introduced timing charts in this! I've always known about them, but I wasn't sure just how much they'd contribute to the animation process. Really great tutorial, thanks! :)
Yeah I've been seeing these in animator's projects for the longest time but never really understood how they were used
VERY bold of you to assume i can draw a character
I tried this after that video and it get improved😳
I am so happy now
Thank you for this video 🤗
With everything out about A.I. generated images right now you wouldn’t think big artists with reach would be promoting something so harmful.
Ai is only harmful if you make it harmful, using it as a tool for reference only isn’t bad. ai already exist and isn’t going anywhere, so why not find the good in it.
@@weebleevideos9847For me the only thing I find harmful about A.I. generated images is when people use the art that it generates for profit and claim it to be “art”!🙄
@@weebleevideos9847 alright racism exists too are u against it or tryna find the good in it?
@@thecreator308 😅 bro your argument is irrelevant, AI and racism are not the same thing, AI has its good and bad... Racism is just bad lol
What kind of thinking ability you have there?
@@LunaNK22 AI generated image is just stealing, aint no way you tryna find the good in that.
thank you so much, as a traditional artist getting into digital animation it does look a bit overwhelming. But, here you explained it so well. I appreciate the guides you make, and I will make sure to use these in my future animations!
man literally starts his video with a trailer for a website that uses pintrest and artstation to train their ai. Pintrest especially is known for people posting large amounts of uncredited art work, so its impossible for that art to be referenced with any consent. For those curious: CF Spark uses LAION-5B data set for their AI, which heavily just scrapes easily accessible publicly available (note: not necessarily licensed or free use) images for their data set.
I never understood the how to use the time line thing until now. I understand now thanks to your video, so thank you!
Excellent class sir. It's quite a step up from moving boxes to making characters move in a lifelike manner. Thanks
Agreed. Real easy to follow along. I need to practice these way more than I do.
Your explanation of timing charts, as well as your guided tutorial has helped me so much! Thank you!
tHIS WAS ACTUALLY HELPFUL, I'VE BEEN WANTING TO KNOW WHAT WAS THIS THING'S NAME AND WHAT WAS IT USED FOR AND NOW I FINALLY KNOW IT, TYSM
That has to be the most solid Promotion ive ever heard
Finally a video where the youtuber teaches instead just do it and expect us to understand
It's so clearly explanation at the beginning. Smooth Movement, make the animation looking good. Thx 4 the tutor.
I am just a beginner but I am really excited /intimidated and this really helped me with the former. Thanks I will be using all of your videos. I am trying to use Adobe animate hope I can navigate with your videos using that if not I will focus on the concepts once I learn the software. again thanks
This comment is a little old, but i hope you are doing well in your animating journey 😊
Thank you, Professor Frugal! Learning more every video
Such a great tutorial.... I learnt so much just from this basic tutorial to put into my own animattion.... love it :)
You explain these concepts really well
Thank you bro, for this clear and concise tutorial
LoL I just understood how to make timing charts. That's super helpful. Thanks!
I agree because I was so confused on that before , much appreciated , so many people skip explaining that
JESUS CHRIST, your animation set up is insane!!!
AWESOME JUMP ANIMATION! THANK YOU!
helped me a lot I already knew about the motions but it seemed that I didn't understand the correctly and that's why my animations were not smothe at all and I didn't really know why after watching your video I found the problem thanks a lot will watch your other videos as well I am sure I can learn something from it !
Thank you chief for such a great video this has sped up my process by alot ❤
You are the best teacher I have for animating so far, thank you for teaching so clear and great, please continue on making videos like this 🌹🌹
I followed along, and it worked! Thanks again Sebastian
not sure if anyone pointed this out yet but at 1:49 (and subsequently the video) you have exchanged the motion for ease in and ease out. When the images grow closer over time that motion is considered ease **in** and when the images space out over time that is easing **out** . Great video though!
the concepts are clear and the application was on point, but the terms are just wrong :/ considering the reach you have with your platform I would urge you to please cross check terms before uploading the video
Hello, Thanks for your feedback. The reason the terms are switched is because I first learned animation on the digital platform. Traditional animators refer to starting slow as an "ease out" and ending slow as an "ease in". Despite how you refer to them though, the important thing is to identify whether an object is moving constantly or accelerating: speeding up or slowing down. My upcoming video will go deeper into that. Happy animating!
@@NobleFrugal thanks for taking your time to respond! It's interesting that you find your digital learning experience this way. If you don't mind, what sources did you learn from? I have a degree in animation (albeit traditional but I learned a lot from online sources also), and have worked in the industry for a while; from this standpoint it's important to know the right terminology for effective communication. All props to you for making easy to digest content and making these animation breakdowns! But the right terminology (for folks looking to work in the industry) is still a must. Have a great day! :)
Hello. Thank you as well. I agree with that. I'd have to say that it mainly comes from my experience with Blender 3D and the video editing programs I've used over the years. When editing your animation's curve, (in Blender, or Davinci Resolve, etc) the ease in ease out names are flipped (ease in slows the start, and ease out slows the end). For this reason, I may not continue using these terms at all since, depending on your perspective, they are interchangeable. However, you make a good point regarding industry work. I hadn't thought of that. Okay thanks, you have a good day too.
I scrolled down to the comments to point out the same thing.
your channel was recommended to me by the algorithm after I did a few search on quick videos to onboard junior animators and I'm absolutely delighted that I also get to review everything by binge-watching your content!!
I know AI art makes it really scary for illustrators, but AI art cannot create something original the same way a human can. Where humans use references and create something entirely new, AI photoshops a bunch of images together to make something that resembles a new drawing. This difference is important, it means that, if a client needs something specific, the computer won't be able to replicate what the client is looking for completely. It is about intent, the intent of shape language, color palette, stylization, texturing, and shading, all of which are unique to each artist. I hope this has helped reassure anyone who is afraid of losing their jobs or doesn't even want to try as an artist. AI is a tool, just like how a pencil is a tool, or photoshop is a tool.
also not to mention that ai cant make copyrightable work
yes keep bitching, but AI will allow anyone to be able to materialize what they have in their mind without failing and being a laughing stock!
Kinda true , on the other hand, NO, Ai art don't just photoshops a bunch of image together.
That's a common misunderstanding on how the AI works. Basicly the AI is just trained to denoise pics. When you give him a prompt, he basicly tries to understand how he usually have to denoise a noise picture that have the same kind of content than the ones you ask for. For that, yeah , he use a library (that sometimes uses licensed work wich sucks) but this library is actually just used to makes the AI understand what kind of goal is set when it will be time to denoise.
I know that can be some see as some nitpicking, but I think it's important to tell because YEAH, Ai can create new stuff.
On the other hand, this is just a tool , and if you really need a perfect result that you will have full control on , for now , you can't go without an artist, and you were right about that one^^
@@StupidBirdChannel ai art cant be copyrighted because of a monkey
Sorry to tell you, but humans can't create anything original either. Even so far back as the greek philosophers, they knew that there's no such thing as an "original" idea. It's all remixing existing stuff in new ways.
Everything seems to be clear for me now! Thank you Sir
Awesome video. Really like everything was perfectly explained and at a good pace.
좋아요 감사합니다: ) I am from South Korea. And Thank U for the tutorial video!!
This helped so much! Thank you!
This is the best timing chart video I have seen and I've seen a lot... Thank you and you earned a subscriber
I LOVE that song!! PLEASE PUT IT ON SPOTIFY
2:19 for those just starting , press the control tool with brush to draw straight line
That beat was fire 🔥 0:32
This video is so helpful, thank you!
Nice video my friend, thank you for the tips!
I find myself using this demo a lot as warm up practice.
don't appreciate the AI ad, everything else is gold, thanks a lot
thank. you for sharing, looking forward to see more character animation knowledge!
I didn't understand mapping out inbetweens and labeling frames till this video, this is a gamechanger. Thank you sm ❤❤
I love animation, but I am dissapointed with your AI art shill at the start.
Where to start bro
Why is the extreme drawing on the 17th frame? Why not 24 of whatever the last frame for 1 second is?
I didn't understand?
Why are you advertising A.I art?
I jusyt started animating today, I'm so excited to do ts
Big thanks man, my mentor didn't talked about that, but now i understand how it works.
Great stuff, always happy to see new uploads on this channel! Support indie animators!
So I've been animating for about a year now (I've got a channel where I post stuff) and I have to say, this is INCREDIBLY USEFUL! Thanks for another awesome video, they really help :)
Wow this video is very helpful 🤩
Glad you think so. Happy animating!
非常棒的教程！非常细致的讲解！非常感谢！
Thank you very much
This method is so easy❤
The billowing on the pants on the down, real nice touch.
Very clear explanation 🙂
just got into animation this helped a lot!!!
hey @nobelfrugal i understood the concept of timing and spacing however....i was wondering ow do you know where to put your key frames when animating on twos do you have to calculate first in order to get perfect places to put your inbetweens? hope you see this and reply thank you
Key frames are like storyboards. Anyway, you dont need to "find where to put them", just add however many the inbetween frames are necessary to get to the next key frame.
I dont know if the intro music video is promoting AI generating for images, but if its like the new lensa stuff I can't say I support
Thank you for the valueable knowledges!
Thank you a lot for this video! I actually learnt a lot :)
Nice to see that you still improve and work inside openToonz. What is the name of the pad that you use with your xp pen?
I do kinda miss something like that for my 22 inch screen. Never mind i did found my answer in previous video.
great video, thank you!
yo you back love your videos :)
More to come my friend. It's good to be back. Thank you I hope you find them helpful.
Im not sure this has been asked before, but i really wanna know... in what program you make your thumbnails?
Time + Matter = Space
Animation Potential = Space + Time
Luckily u r correct...
espectacular video
again, thanks man learning a lot from ur channel, ill try to tag u so u can see what uve helped me create.
I just downloaded opentoon to use as my software of choice. I been using cs5 photoshop. I really want to take animation seriously.
No AI over here sorry buddy 1:13
This was very helpful Thank you so much for your trouble
Hey, just wanna say that ur vids help me lot! Thnx!!
We need more videos in this playlist….plz sir🙂
ngl animating body parts moving was pretty confusing, getting the angles and position. i hope this works
Sir, you are an inspiration!!🙏🙌
thanks a lot friend.its amazing!
It would have been nice if drawing 5 the SR arm favored more of drawing B when coming down. That way it avoids twinning of the arms and the arc would flow better without popping into the final pose.
my head had exploded 😮💨😮💨but thanks for ur work🤗
Just watched this while eating
Feel new motivation in me
What's the name of the animation software btw ?
Opentoonz
Huge thanks
hi noble frugal, do you have some tips as to how to estimate the half desitance of the before frame when you ease in or ease out? thanks for the video!
thanks.. The video was very helpful 😊
Whoa, how can you get ease in and ease out mixed up?
Mainly because I learned animation on the digital platform. Traditional animators refer to starting slow as an "ease out" and ending slow as an "ease in". Despite how you refer to them, the important thing is to identify whether an object is moving constantly or accelerating. My upcoming video will go deeper into that. Happy animating!
@@NobleFrugal You and a load of young animators have to be careful.
The concept should be separated from the words used incorrectly in one app.
The one app being Flash now called Animate.
why didn't i found channel like this from years ago???
If not for my quick rush to the comments, I almost quit watching the video cos I thought I had maybe clicked onto a rap music rehearsal by mistake
this is very helpful and very good explanation :D ok time to practice this!
Your back I actually missed being treated by you 👽🌻
now i know what 'ease in' and 'ease out' are
HAPPY 70K SUBS🎉
Thank you so much 😀
You're getting good man.
Hey noble I just want to say how do I make old school animation
Wow❤
I have to beginners guide to animation paperback book but I'm not sure how I should use it
Is this the beginning of the tutorial or should I watch it after another video?
What is your source of income other than youtube? Because even I am thinking to not work for a studio and animate from home . Also does this earn well? Or is a studio better?
Quick question, what is the name of the thing you are holding in your left hand while drawing (controller thing)? I'm looking for something like that but never knew what it was called.
Hello. That is the Tourbox Elite. It's an express key remote made for inputting shortcuts. They are quite handy. I hope this helps!
what's the thing on your Left hand? the object you use like a keyboard for Opeentoonz
Another comment he responded saying it’s the Tourbox Elite an express key remote made for inputting shortcuts.