Ducati Desmosedici vs Ferrari 430 Scuderia

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 837

  • @xxn0thing
    @xxn0thing 11 років тому +22

    The problem with this video is the sound track. Who wants to hear music when you have a Ducati and Ferrari wailing around a track? Seriously!

  • @dennisrichards2540
    @dennisrichards2540 10 років тому +9

    I do enjoy these "whats faster car vs bike" videos. truth is the answer is as diverse as the tracks are. If you have a power circuit like the top gear test track then a motorbike will clean up. If you have a circular test track the car's going to clean up. Owning a car or a bike of this caliber
    realistically
    When reality comes'a'knockin we are not all millionaires, If you are great, buy both and ride your bike once a month in the summer when the weather is perfect. but we all have commitments and obligations so we have to put thought into our purchases.
    price vs performance (yes car guys roll your eyes)
    For the price of the entry level "sports car" MX-5 your looking at about £18,000 for something that really is a sports car in name only (I personally believe an MX-5 would be great fun to drive) but is not going to set your pants on fire with 0-60 in 12 seconds. maybe you could spec up and pay £25,000 and get one that does 0-60 in 10 seconds im not sure (im speculating at this point)
    got to any of the big 4 and you can ride away from a dealership for about £8000 on a 600 that is seriously in super car territory. it will do the speed limit in about 3.6 seconds and 100 not much later. What most people who don't ride motorbikes generally don't understand is that even modern "street bikes" are insanely fast by car standards and offer more comfort and (for me) more enjoyment for road riding
    For me a motorcycle makes sense. They offer good value for money, insane performance, easy to store and great fun. A motorcycle is great vehicle for anyone who owns an ordinary car.

  • @TwoColorShoe
    @TwoColorShoe 15 років тому +1

    Absolutely loved it. It's probably one of the best things you guys have put out thus far.

  • @ReggyRay289
    @ReggyRay289 15 років тому +1

    This video is awesome, it doesn't have the B.S. of Top Gear, who would have the Ferrari doing power slides around the track. This was an actual track test and I loved it.

  • @lionserpent
    @lionserpent 15 років тому

    That was great fun to watch. Thanks guys!

  • @desmo2591
    @desmo2591 15 років тому

    gotta love Italians passion for cars and bikes.

  • @BeamRider100
    @BeamRider100 10 років тому

    With less rotational inertia and unsprung weight, the ceramic discs give more benefits than the obvious better braking and better high temp performance to cut lap time.
    It's good to see the bike do a 1:47, even though the slicks seemed unfair.
    If someone said "Here, ride my Desmo with slicks around this here racetrack against my F430".
    It's not like you'd say "I insist you take the slicks off first, it's not fair".

  • @davidtheking341
    @davidtheking341 14 років тому

    cars are always faster then motorcycles, but motorcycles are pure awesomness and fun

  • @ztunelover
    @ztunelover 14 років тому

    just outta curiosity, was the scud slick shod as well? I still think the bike would be faster, but it wouldn't be that big a gap.

  • @MadIgor1
    @MadIgor1 13 років тому

    @Fonno88 what in "Capirossis machine REPLICA" didnt you understand? BTW the Scuderia is a race car, so what is your point?

  • @rcoles82
    @rcoles82 14 років тому

    @biglarfspeed6 its a track day version of the normal ferrari 430, so it is race ready

  • @sampsalol
    @sampsalol 15 років тому

    Amazing video, thanks for this!

  • @gixxerk4600
    @gixxerk4600 15 років тому

    why do people always compare the wrong cars, this ferrari and ducati are both top of their class, they are the best vehicles to test the car and bike, yea get a pro car racer and car will go quicker, but get a pro bike rider. and you cant compare a gumpert or a track car, because its designed for racing! these bikes can also be used every day for popping to the shops! this is a great video and a proper car vs bike test. maybe a different track with more corners would make the car win

  • @motard811
    @motard811 13 років тому

    Great business, many thanks for this footage

  • @TheDesmonaut
    @TheDesmonaut 15 років тому

    @ispeed2010 are you suggesting that the Ferrari FXX or even a Zonda or LP670 would do a 13 sec QUICKER lap than the trackday 430 suda? i mean that is a lot of time to make up. A LOT of time...

  • @pansho550F
    @pansho550F 14 років тому

    @54thAggressors I go with you in that, everyone can drive a Ferrari with its 5 settings traction control, but in the bike you got the body, knees and hands to do the difference.

  • @me2ontube
    @me2ontube 14 років тому

    can you guys make it happen ... rossi vs schumacher - 599 gto and desmo

  • @TwoColorShoe
    @TwoColorShoe 15 років тому

    They probably ran separately so they could push the vehicles more to their limits without worrying about another vehicle on the track, and then later filmed each other going round together. In the video they even talk about their best lap times, so it certainly (and smartly) wasn't a "race" per say.
    It was still awesome to watch, though!

  • @Drinkyoghurt
    @Drinkyoghurt 13 років тому

    Why can't MCN invest in some good mics and drivers/presentators? really sub par as always

  • @Gywhard
    @Gywhard 14 років тому

    @91universo beh scusa, è una redazione inglese, quando recensiscono le BMW allora devono parlare tedesco?
    Non è che solo l'Italia è degna di Ferrari e Ducati, un sito inglese, che fa una recensione per un pubblico inglese che lingua dovrebbe parlare?

  • @groscave23
    @groscave23 12 років тому

    post a link of your sources, i wanna see that.

  • @turnoffski
    @turnoffski 15 років тому

    What about F1 car v F1 bike? or would that not be bias to the bike, being mcn

  • @themorganator
    @themorganator 15 років тому

    They were on the track at the same time - the full article is in this weeks MCN.

  • @Theonedjneo
    @Theonedjneo 13 років тому

    Were they racing or cruising?

  • @SmokinHaddock1
    @SmokinHaddock1 15 років тому

    Michael Neeves is a very decent club racer and front runner with the British Motorcyle Racing Club (Bemsee). There are far too many variables for these comparisons to work. Almeria is a very technical circuit. It flows if you get it right!

  • @jdpst20
    @jdpst20 10 років тому +13

    Totally pointless vid. The guy seems like he's going to get groceries in that Ferrari.

  • @Au_Hussar
    @Au_Hussar 14 років тому

    When did the race begin? All I saw was a guy with a passenger who I assume was Miss Daisy. However it is afterall a motorbike program, would be embrassing if the Scuderia won wouldn't it :)

  • @vetteburna
    @vetteburna 15 років тому

    How about shumi on a Ferrari FXX against Rossi on the desmosedici..

  • @SicSeb
    @SicSeb 12 років тому

    I understand what you mean, as a real world rider my 848 is more than enough for me. But if someone can afford it, why not. I've seen a Desmoscedici once in the wild and it was an amazing piece of machinery. Very intense sound and it's one of the most special bikes you can buy. If I could afford one I would buy one (there is one for sale @Goedhart Motoren), but in the real world it would be of no use whatsoever =P Just an amazing piece of exotica to own. Just like Ferrari, Lamborghini, Pagani.

  • @alekos103
    @alekos103 14 років тому

    Did the driver switched sport mode on???

  • @soobeng
    @soobeng 15 років тому

    common sense will tell that there is no way for a car to beat a bike in the race track. great video.

  • @gsxrpik
    @gsxrpik 14 років тому

    @Linxer22 depends on the track, long swooping turns the bike would kill.

  • @hazeljimmys
    @hazeljimmys 13 років тому

    @aluisious Are you from Alaska ? if you need help just just ask

  • @Rsvmillewouter
    @Rsvmillewouter 13 років тому

    why would anyone put music under this clip...

  • @2ndAveScents
    @2ndAveScents 10 років тому +2

    Shoulda let the Stig drive the Rarri. Amazing bike, but damn they didn't look like either one pushed very hard.

  • @gixxerk4600
    @gixxerk4600 15 років тому

    @ispeed2010 this was one of the best comparisons, a fast track car against a fast track bike. the 860 FXX is not a good comparison because its only a track car. the power to weight ratio will always be in the bikes favour, a 600cc bike will still produce about 800bhp per tonne. people who dont ride bikes and dont like bikes always say bikes are crap and slower, when the fact is, there usually not unless you put them against a fast car, or put them on a very tight twisty track!

  • @DB-gv6oi
    @DB-gv6oi 10 років тому

    Both beautiful... and I'd love to have 1 of each in the garage!!

  • @patryk996
    @patryk996 15 років тому

    The 200+hp is claimed to be stock. I don't know how much they really did to it (aside from the exhaust) to mod it from the "stock" version. CF panels come with those as well. BCM Ducati had two at their shop in NH, USA and I've gotten a chance to look them over pretty closely.
    Seems like they just might have had wheels and an exhaust as upgrades.
    Lastly, footage-wise, they didn't seem to really be pushing the vehicles that hard. Video seemed deceptive at best (aside from maybe the start).

  • @richXPT707
    @richXPT707 11 років тому +2

    A road going superbike will always beat a road going supercar. Because there are fewer emissions and safety requirements, bikes have always been closer to their racing cousins than cars.

    • @tHaH4x0r
      @tHaH4x0r 10 років тому +2

      Not because of emissions. It is because building high hp/kg engines becomes exponentially more difficult with higher hp. Because of the already low kg of the bike it always has a higher kg/hp

  • @ngv4ever
    @ngv4ever 12 років тому

    is that 2012 desmosedici ?

  • @ExtremeDeathman
    @ExtremeDeathman 13 років тому

    @goonballer
    Wrong, the S1000RR beat the Aprilia on the track and on the road, tested in several magazines here in Europe.

  • @airsofter2247
    @airsofter2247 14 років тому

    @TopBike2009 The ducati is road legal standard and he was saying the only thing thats really changed is the tyres so what makes you think the bike isnt road legal, just because they have prepped it for a trackday ( removed plate, indicated ect ect). And the car is a 430 for starters so is like the bike on the faster side of things but the one in this video is a trackday prepped car with upgraded breaks ect

  • @Nohandle575
    @Nohandle575 15 років тому

    which is fastest in the rain with shopping and from cold?

  • @supercop46
    @supercop46 14 років тому

    @kablah8900 rossi on ducati?...

  • @droceretik
    @droceretik 14 років тому

    @d3vi0uz This video wasn't about a broad comparison between bikes and cars, especially F1.
    F1 cars will beat any vehicle around a track, especially any hypercars such as the Pagani Zonda. This was simply a track comparison between two road going Italian icons, Ferrari and Ducati. In this case the bike was quicker in acceleration and quicker in lap times as well as faster in top speed on the straight. The Ferrari probably was braking deeper into corners and was quicker entry to exit.

  • @paulqui3702
    @paulqui3702 10 років тому

    Both are excellent machines - the bike does have more race inspired goodies under that fairing than the car I think?

  • @ninjadave1978
    @ninjadave1978 15 років тому

    My point exactly, they were not on a slow twisty track for the car to take advantage hence a faster straight line car would help, plus second best track car or not they are still not as quick as you'd think and i'm talking from experience! People think if it has a ferrari badge it's unbeatable, bollocks there are far better track cars than a ferrari, i've seen them beat so many times and have ran with one no probs in a 530bhp subaru, they are not the be all and end all of cars!

  • @hazeljimmys
    @hazeljimmys 13 років тому

    @gordyvfr1200 I think you might have been out the same day as myself i think there was about 5 desmosdicrappies and another 6 other ducatis, all of them were riding like fannys and that was a dry day ; i also seen a big guy on a tiger pass some of them and they couldnt look at him in the corners he was hard on it , i think he comes from around Armadale area and they call him the captain . Does anyone know him ?

  • @lordfyrbane3587
    @lordfyrbane3587 11 років тому

    Have you ever ridden a superbike my friend. NO car can compare to the sheer speed, thrill and involvment of a superbike. In a car you are isolated and caged in with little or no inolvment with the world outside. Do yourself a favour and book yourself on a trackday riding a bike- you'll never forget it.

  • @gixxerk4600
    @gixxerk4600 15 років тому

    @pinespeakz its actually about £40000 and it can be used daily. and also dont forget, this is a £170,000 car

  • @Tommy1198S
    @Tommy1198S 14 років тому

    Screw the adverts

  • @jetstream01
    @jetstream01 15 років тому

    What a great bike. That car is still awesome for a car though. Both sound very good!

  • @TimZZR2
    @TimZZR2 15 років тому +1

    we want to hear that high revving v4 desmocedici engine :D

  • @franciscocastro742
    @franciscocastro742 10 років тому +1

    It was a given the ducatti would beat the ferrari motorcycles have always been in form to beat cars anyday in a race with turns. In a drag race maybe a car but in turns the motorcycles have the biggest advantage!!!

  • @RufioMini
    @RufioMini 14 років тому

    You can't say which is better. Cars have an immense contact patch advantage and bikes have a power-to-weight advantage. In a traffic light grand prix, bike all the way. On a twisty track, I'd go for the car. For fun, bike. For srs bsns, car.

  • @555gumby
    @555gumby 14 років тому

    Was it the fastest Sunday driver around the track?

  • @123456789lol
    @123456789lol 14 років тому

    @MrJakeluna That's unfair as well, F1 cars are incredible feats of machinery, nothing can beat an F1 car. The reason of the test was to try out road-legal vehicles against each other. Of course, there are some tracks where a car would thrash a bike, but in this instance the bike had the advantage on the course they were doing, because of the immense power to weight ratio.

  • @Limpy955i
    @Limpy955i 14 років тому

    @91universo
    and when you are talking about a Mercedes and a VW?
    Sprichst du dann auch Deutsch?

  • @guysteel
    @guysteel 15 років тому

    No matter what you're racing, it almost always comes down to the power to weight ratio. This bike has 200HP and the car has 500HP the bike has a far better power to weight ratio. I'd be happy with either one.

  • @zepmon
    @zepmon 15 років тому

    the bit where the car wasnt going quick was because thay were trying to get shots for the videothe laps they did quick arent on the video for some reason

  • @brugiindahouse
    @brugiindahouse 13 років тому

    why did they put the music?!?!?!!?!

  • @SR71BBFLYER
    @SR71BBFLYER 14 років тому

    @biglarfspeed6 I'm a biker at heart...but I see your point. Then again, there are plenty of videos with specially modified 800hp cars going up against basically stock bikes in rolling starts so I guess it balances out in the end.Fact is...NO ONE is going to have the fastest vehicle...there will always be someone building something faster.So just enjoy the one u luv. I do.My CBR11 was no longer the fastest once the 'Busa dropped but I'am not about to trade for anything.

  • @chuckdawg82
    @chuckdawg82 13 років тому

    @dude157 That's a tough call. Bikes are aerodynamic bricks as you go faster. At some point a car will have better aerodynamic profile to win out on a straight sprint.

  • @04cscholes
    @04cscholes 14 років тому

    Ducati Desmosedici vs F1 car Much more interesting as they both are the ultimate versions of each vehicle

  • @benjyboba
    @benjyboba 13 років тому

    @goonballer actually this desmo got more power than bmw. Its got over 200 hp at the rear wheel on this desmosecidi. If you notice with mcn, they rarely ever put a ducati in a test with full exhaust systems, but I think this one has been slightly tuned. Power is nothing unless someone can use it. I think Ducati need to sort out their gp bike for poor Rossi.

  • @MagtatagongTao
    @MagtatagongTao 13 років тому

    @ozekiozeki1 if both of them are crushed who do you think would cry more?

  • @biglarfspeed6
    @biglarfspeed6 14 років тому

    @gongzee It's basically like racing a scuderia against a 599xx.

  • @a2birdcage
    @a2birdcage 14 років тому

    Cars can never create the man-machine interface as well as a bike can.

  • @nimbly1693
    @nimbly1693 14 років тому

    @ajpein Agreed. The Stig vs. Valentino Rossi. There is a match up.

  • @mrbobsshow
    @mrbobsshow 15 років тому

    Hell Id kill to have either one!!

  • @Brimmy11
    @Brimmy11 13 років тому

    203bhp at the rear wheel?

  • @FrenchJohn
    @FrenchJohn 14 років тому

    The dude owns both of them lool the ferrari in the motorcycle world and the ferrari itself! Nice one mate! lool

  • @eebsy
    @eebsy 15 років тому

    Is that not the camera man, buddy?

  • @me2ontube
    @me2ontube 15 років тому

    i don't care who's driving or who's riding ... the stig, rossi, schumacher, you name it ... THE DESMO RULES

  • @ClandestineAssassin
    @ClandestineAssassin 13 років тому

    The Desmosedici costs about $60,000...kinda pricey but hell of a great bike. You can buy a kawasaki zx10r or bmw s1000rr, turbocharge or supercharge it for a fraction of the price, and you'd smoke a desmosedici. A 2011 zx10r (us version is restricted) puts about ~163hp at the rear wheel, BMW S1000rr puts about 170-173 hp at the rear wheel. When it comes to city driving, a scooter can beat a ferrari because you can lane split cars! Its all relative my friends!

  • @drpeppington
    @drpeppington 13 років тому

    @2wheelfamily I'm pretty sure it's roughly $100000 Australian. Check Bikepoint for prices, I've seen a few on there

  • @biglarfspeed6
    @biglarfspeed6 14 років тому

    @gongzee There's still a huge difference between between a race prepped bike lacking headlights/turn signals sporting race tires, and a street legal track day car meant for the road with road tires and full trim. The racing tires with pre-warming give the bike an enormous advantage, and make this a biased race.

  • @Aduro90
    @Aduro90 12 років тому

    Its certainly not worth 2.5 million by a long shot. But you clearly weren't listening, this Desmo was not one of the standard production models selling for that price, and is worth a fair chunk more.

  • @mugget
    @mugget 15 років тому

    are you sure about the wheels?
    listen again - what he says is "16.5 inch Marchesini wheels means we can run proper racing tyres which a standard Des can't."

  • @strofimios
    @strofimios 14 років тому

    Good test but ,i think, that it is doing bike a favour.The car you have to put against the bike is the supercharged ariel atom or ,even better,the new V8 ariel atom.

  • @rushlimbaughisawsome
    @rushlimbaughisawsome 14 років тому

    @loboxido I have to disagree. I'm not saying the bike isn't cool, but I would feel way cooler and happier in the Scuderia. I guess it's just personal preference.

  • @BKingAndy
    @BKingAndy 14 років тому

    the last minute of that video is the best LOL

  • @Chico8504
    @Chico8504 14 років тому

    @MrWillydoit I concur, this guy looked like he was on a Sunday drive. I think the bike will still win, but it should be closer.

  • @sriranganferrari
    @sriranganferrari 12 років тому

    No comparison...Both are great and manly in their own ways...

  • @deriwhiteswift
    @deriwhiteswift 13 років тому

    Geez that old man has all my dream machine

  • @DjJtown
    @DjJtown 13 років тому

    @llucaskelly I agree completely. He made no attempt at coming anywhere close to the limits of the car. At no point was he near redlining the engine or the edge of tire adhesion. This was a waste of time and a smack in the face of motorsports enthusiasts.

  • @tafka100
    @tafka100 14 років тому

    @54thAggressors
    that means nothing.racing is a team sport, building the machine is part of the sport.
    if everybody raced the same cars and the same bikes it wouldnt matter how much its up to the machine or driver, youd still have to be a better driver than others to win.

  • @assman12354
    @assman12354 13 років тому

    I was sorta surprised, I do both motorcycles and rally car, and I thought the grip from the car might keep it in front of the bike, its cool the bike won

  • @airsofter2247
    @airsofter2247 14 років тому

    @TopBike2009 Thats a fair point but what im trying to say is that in this vid, both the car and bike are very very high spec and in the highest group of their respected groups which would make it a fair race. I know what your trying to say, it would be fair if the bike was racing a formula 2 car or something along those lines (dont know a huge amount about car racing, so dont know what would be fair in your mind) but then that would be road legal so it would be a fair race if you understand me.

  • @ItsJakeTheBrake
    @ItsJakeTheBrake 13 років тому

    @ScbrN5454 Well I guess they make a couple of laps for pictures and videos and don't really show an entire lap of them pushing it to the limit.

  • @droceretik
    @droceretik 14 років тому

    @vsuripa It took you 6 minutes to realise this? What are you going to do with the six minutes if you get it back?

  • @LiMaMuFu
    @LiMaMuFu 14 років тому

    1) The bike is running on slick tyres... the ferrari wasnt.
    2) Like jxi100 said... theyve just added 80-100kg to ferraris weight.
    3) The Scuderia shoudnt have been choosed to made this race.
    But... in the end, it will always depend on what kind of circuit you're racing.

  • @yeltneBmadA
    @yeltneBmadA 15 років тому

    @pinespeakz I didnt actually want to put 2 people on the bike mate, i was just stating how unfair the test was. Like i said enzo vs ducati, that way its best ferrari road car vs best ducati road bike. Oh and a decent driver for the car too.

  • @dude157
    @dude157 13 років тому

    When it comes to car v bike, it usually comes down to the track. On straights and accelerating out of the exit of a bend, a bike will blitz a car, however in the braking zones and through most corners a car will be quicker. By the way the car was being driven here, i don't think it was a fair match. However i reckon both flat out here, the bike would still comfortably beat the ferrari. But at some other tracks the ferrari may have the edge. Important to point out the bike was on full slicks

  • @OdrikT800
    @OdrikT800 14 років тому

    @supercop46 next year it could be possible to see him on ducati

  • @wingding028
    @wingding028 15 років тому

    what needs?

  • @Biker999s
    @Biker999s 9 років тому

    All right then ...
    One way or another , Italia magistra vitae !!!

  • @maxbify
    @maxbify 14 років тому

    when you hear a ferrari v8 you will never forget that sound :D

  • @IIdemonII
    @IIdemonII 14 років тому

    WHERE IS THE STIG?

  • @benjyboba
    @benjyboba 15 років тому

    I got a better race for them, how about Micheal Neeves on the desmo vs Valentino Rossi in lap times on the desmo. Then the ferrari driver vs a proffesional car racer, then compaire the time differences on both car and bike with good riders. My money would be on the bike even if I were racing it with its insane power and handling. I rekon they should do a few more races but on different tracks to get a better comparison. Well done Mike for showing the truth.