New revelations on Israel’s killing of its own citizens on 7 October | Ali Abunimah & Asa Winstanley
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 лют 2025
- Nora Barrows-Friedman, Asa Winstanley, Ali Abunimah and Jon Elmer of The Electronic Intifada were joined by Walaa Sabah, a journalist from Gaza now based in the UK; Huda Ammori, an activist with Palestine Action, on the day 159 livestream. You can watch the entire broadcast here: • Breaking news and anal...
YOUR GIFT SUPPORTS THE ELECTRONIC INTIFADA'S INDEPENDENT JOURNALISM ON PALESTINE:
• Donate by credit card or PayPal via Network for Good: bit.ly/GivetoEI
• Donate by credit card, ApplePay or US bank account via Kindful: bit.ly/EIKindful
Gifts are welcome from anywhere and are tax-deductible for US taxpayers as allowed by law.
𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐄𝐥𝐞𝐜𝐭𝐫𝐨𝐧𝐢𝐜 𝐈𝐧𝐭𝐢𝐟𝐚𝐝𝐚
Visit our website for more reporting: electronicintif...
Facebook: / electronicintifada
Twitter: / intifada
Instagram: / electronicintifada
Soundcloud: / intifada
Spotify: open.spotify.c...
Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple...
#TheElectronicIntifada #TheElectronicIntifadaPodcast
Journalists that seek the truth, we thank you. In this day and age it rare to find!
Stay safe please ❤
Thank you Electronic Intifada. Independent journalists with journalistic integrity are the heroes of our time.
100%.
These people are completely wrong and are spreading disinformation. They are anti-heros and you are stupid for believing it.
I didn't know that humas had such people on the payroll, you have to be well paid to be this immoral
@@sheenayoung6141I'd say someone that trolls every comment, as you have, on behalf of the illegitimate colonial project is much more likely to be an immoral, paid liar.
you can always tell a zionist by the sheer aversion to the truth and facts.
Evidence obviously doesn't really do it for you folks
Any news on the forty beheaded babies or the food supplies for Gaza that was actually a photo from 2022 in Moldova ?
It is impossible to overstate the importance of this reporting. Thank you for your continuing revelations of what actually occurred on 7 October.
No-one cares about this conflict, the world is way too busy dealing with the real problems they are facing
And how exactly would they know, unless they were actually took part in the atrocities
@@sheenayoung6141 They have been reporting what Israeli survivors have said and what Israeli media has reported. Try and pay attention if you can.
@@tonyprice2256 Wrong, they are reporting what humas and the media are spewing, not the truth, they have an agenda to push, and that is exactly what they are doing.
Desde un principio la policía dijo que Israel había estado en el lugar...y no quieren investigar porque su objetivo es terminar con los Palestinos.
Oct 7 needs to be fully investigated by a independent body
And who exactly would that be, the UN 😂,
That's why they are trying to kill all the witnesses.
Israel has alreaady destroyed the forensic evidence, so the full truth will never be known.
@@sheenayoung6141the is ils not allowing the UN investigators in doesn’t look very nice.
@@sheenayoung6141 let's send you to go investigate
"Sorry" and "regret" are words we may have heard from the "settlers" but that still didn't prevent them from taking the land!
Something that you will never hear from Islam
@@sheenayoung6141of course no one will ever hear that- no reason for it.
@@NorahsYarnArt Which is why you live your life in ignorance
@@sheenayoung6141Why do you have a problem with Islam?
@@sheenayoung6141
Are you trying to make sense or are you just typing words, just because you can..? What point are you trying to make? Or are you a bot, that we're trying to communicate with?
Thank you so much. Love from South Africa
Thank you south africa, love from the heavens and the world.
@@Imrankhan-pw4owyou welcome
Love you south africa from indonesia ❤
It's a pity that you don't love your own country first
@@sheenayoung6141 you know nothing. Sit down
First-class reporting and analysis.
Where, damn I missed that, too busy watching this BS propaganda channel
@@sheenayoung6141I doubt you even bothered watching
of course ,,, .... the truth is also that hamas bombed its own people ... to incite blame on israel !!!
@@sheenayoung6141😂😂😂 here u are again Israeli 🧌 😂😂😂
Thank you guys....however horrendous the truth might be it will always prevail over lies.....always!!!!! 🙏❤️🇯🇴
Yes it does, and that's why humas are hidden in tunnels
@@sheenayoung6141thanks for showing that the iof is NOT fighting an army.
God Bless Palestine and people of Gazza true testament to the strength of a people against all odds is Amazing only the Wisdom of God could be with you.
@@sheenayoung6141so sad that tunnels had to be built out of fear
If you steal something and write your name on it, it doesn't make it yours. .
Basically the history of Islam
@@sheenayoung6141basically you’re ignorant.
@@NorahsYarnArtand an obvious bigot
@@NorahsYarnArt well I'll be in good company on this channel
@@sheenayoung6141You mean ZIONISM. The proof is literally EVERYWHERE.
" If I don't steal it someone else will "
Thank you ei team. Your work is so usefull for us. ❤❤ Ali is so to the point
Thank you for all the updates.
I hear.. off the coast of gaza are massive oil and gas reserves, and netyenyahu handed out contracts for these reserves to western and arab companies just before the invasion started. Apparently those involved are shell BP some American oil companies, UAE, and rishi sunak father in laws company. If this is the case we should add these companies to the list of boycotts world wide....
This needs to be more widely recognized. It provides the motive.
That's why they are going to build a port. It's certainly not for humanitarian aid. This plan was floated first by Netanyahu a couple years ago.
Thats exactly whats going on....
What are wars fought for these days? Natural resources and supply lines..
Well it all fallen flat as finance refuses to invest to instable and insurance is gone to.
Brilliant journalism
Thank you Ali and everyone else at EI. We owe you a lot for all the work you’ve done. ♥️
What kind of work do they do, my bathroom needs repainting
@@sheenayoung6141that wasn’t very helpful- but then what was I expecting from you?
Reporting, analysis, educating the public - these types of things. You should watch their show! It's really great. Remember to wash the walls first and use good ventilation so you don't lose any more cognitive function!@@sheenayoung6141
Cow worshippers
@@sheenayoung6141
ALL AROUND THE WORLD KNOW THE GENOCIDE in GAZA .
A very good and brave work to reveal the truth.
A very special and unique work you are doing.
Some of us suspected this from initial reports.
Are you really this stupid, or it just an act
This explains why Netanyahu does not want these captives freed, because they would ultimately dismantle his whole Hasbara.
ese es su objetivo invadir y terminar con los Palestinos.
Love your work. Xxx Australia
Shame on you
Love you back ❤
Yes gigi and Bella Hadid (famous super models in America) their Palestinian father and grandparents were in the nakaba. Their grandparents helped home a Jewish family fleeing Europe. When their grandmother went away to stay with family whilst giving birth to gigi and Bella's father. When they returned to their home with their baby the people who they were helping refused to let them back into their home. They even refused to get a blanket for their new born baby. I read that story year's ago and it's always stuck with me. Just how cruel these European Zionists are.
You can understand why no one in Europe wanted them.
@@chocolatecosmos1424
You can understand why 109 Countries didn't want them.
No-one wants them, the Palestinians are too much trouble, very violent, unstable, you just cannot trust them
Read up about a British WW2 pilot/ world renowned author called Ronald Dahl.
He had a sinister encounter with a Jewish refugee who was permitted to stay on a Palestinian farm in the early 1940s.
That individual dropped a hint to the zionist plans for Palestine.
I heard that Story told by Mohammed Hadid in an interview.
So well done🎉I've forwarded it everywhere. Thank you EI, you're doing great work in revealing the truth❤
Last Spring a video was produced at a church in Gaza City that was built over 800 years ago. The members of that congregation were celebrating Psalm Sunday. There is another video on UA-cam featuring the pastor of Gaza Baptist Church, who was sharing the Gospel of Christ with the people of Gaza. Why have these people been ignored by most Christians in the U.S. ?
Because most Christians in the USA are Evangelicals who are aiming to bring on the Second Coming (& therefore the Apocalypse) ahead of God's schedule. Christians (& others) who oppose this revision are not given voice by the controlled Media.
Bc Christians do not really care about other Christians that do not have the same culture and ethnic background.
Because christians are generally cowards. They'd rather support israel and ignore the sin and responsibility while they sit calmly on their phone judging this very statement.
They have town politics and internal squabbles about money to think about.
Exactly what I want to know.! I have come to the conclusion that it's just so much 'virtue signaling'.
"I stand for Israel. I stand for Israel."
It's a feel good self-congratulatory maxim, totally bereft of validity humanity, morality, or Biblical authenticity.
One State Solution, Palestine, with equal rights for All.
Which version ?
Pre 1948 borders, called Palestine, with the right of return to Palestine and Europe.
Every human has a right to live in peace regardless of Race and Creed.I Agree100%
@@Imrankhan-pw4owyes my brother!
Assalamu Alaykum Warahmatullahi Wabarakatuhu
@@hdm6897 walaikumsalaam wa rahmatulla e wabarakatuho my dearest brother.
Salute to you guys..going against the mountain of lies that has been heaped upon the world ..
Thanks Nora, Jon, Ali, Asa and of course Tamara. The truth needs to be told now more than ever.
Thank you EI FOR YOUR JOURNALISM.
Not new. One of the first hostages that were released said that and then we never heard from her again.
Tortured by israel
Thank you so much for your reports
Oct. 7 needs to be professionally investigated by an organization not under the political control of the government Israel or the United States.
You are the best team of journalists in the whole of the world ! Congratulations for your nice reporting based on facts. 💚🌺✍️🙏-bmd
Could you please not refer to killing their fellow citizens "friendly fire " ? This was deliberately done to incriminate Hamas liberators and provide cover for the Israeli occupying forces extermination. Let's call this massacre what it was intended to be. By the way thanks for your informative work ei..follow you very keenly.
"Friendly massacre"??...
It’s a very weird term, just meaning that those civilians were killed by their own side, but normally this is purely accidental?
Whereas we see this is actually Israeli policy to kill their own people rather than allow them to become hostages.
Well said
A version of Israils 'Hannibal directive' was reactivated on October 7th. Under this directive the lives of their own citizens take second place, allowing them to be killed, rather than being taken as hostages.
She did specifically say “so called friendly fire” to draw attention to the fact that it’s disingenuous. But yeah, it needs to be pointed out more strenuously.
Thanks for all of your hard work!
Thank you for your work!! The world needs to know this
The world is way too busy dealing with real problems
@@sheenayoung6141 I dont think so. Otherwise you would not be here and commenting everywhere.
@@juliannalevai I'm making comments to counter the propaganda
@@juliannalevai😅 , you noticed it too..
That guy telling about friendly fire to so long and said next to nothing. This was one case out of thousands of killings going on, not knowing which end is up. You proved nothing but that you had an outlier, statistically negligible. There was raping going on. So not everyone got raped. Maybe they had to get moving. You have no idea. So you’re going to say no one was raped. You picked out one example. That’s not how you test a theory. 18:37 18:37
Thank you so so much!🙏🏻🙏🏻
All that stolen Palestinian water certainly made a nice garden on the stolen land, judging from the kibbutz where the lady lived.
The reason why israel refuses to investigate.
Wrong, it's because they are way too busy destroying humas, once they have achieved that, they will investigate
@@sheenayoung6141 They investigated, They just refused to allow the International, independent investigators, who normally are called in to such incidents, to enter the region for a long time. Meanwhile, the destroyed forensic evidence essential to that work. As testimonies began emerging, they published the report of their own investigation, but only in Hebrew, which included details like their helicopters firing over a thousand missiles, including being ordered to fire at "anything that moved" on the route to Gaza, blowing up vehicles known to contain hostages, and that Israeli tank shells had killed 12 year old Liel Hatsroni and her family, whom Israeli propoganda said had been killed by Hamas for being Jewish.
Search, "Israeli general killed Israelis on 7 October then lied about it"
100%, “until after the war.”
@@sheenayoung6141really? any kid who watches tv crime shows knows the term “contaminated crime scene” besides the investigations would’ve taken place in zones outside the war zone, investigators could’ve been allowed in and left alone to do their job- but obviously someone didn’t want them there. Besides give facts or spare us your speculations- they will she says, huh
@@NorahsYarnArtrocket scientist there were 29 different locations.
You have a government in Tel Aviv that has no care for human life. It’s own citizens or those from any other country or ethnic group. They are as close to the methods of operations of any previous lunatic dictatorship hell bent on a far right ideology of complete, unapproved power. Diplomacy seems not to work, threats are ignored, countless UN resolutions similarly. It’s the most horrific episode of my lifetime, because it’s being done with the full knowledge of the world. Not hidden away like the Killing Fields of Cambodia, or Equatorial Guinea. We can all see. Yet are powerless to stop… or that’s what they’d have us believe. Boycotts and continued publicity are hurting the economy and it has now gone so far I doubt it could be recovered.
I think that you meant to say Islam and communism
Israel only ignores the UN resolutions because the US lets them
True. Looking at the inhumane brutality of the Israeli government has shocked the world. So many protesters ignored but still continue to and many boycott Israeli products it’s all people can do. Voting out politicians that are complicit is another way.?
@@sheenayoung6141 you are either blind or illiterate or maybe a mix of both to deny the manifest genocide that is taking place.
@@sheenayoung6141
If Israel don't care the own citizens , how we can to wait for the security or respect to other people !??
Your words are useless .
NOW , ALL AROUND THE WORLD KNOW about the GENOCIDE in GAZA .
,
Thank you for educating us about these important investagations and news that we cannot learn from MSM.
Thank you for all you do.
Crazy how we knew this from day 1, but didn't go around yelling it without solid proof
unlike SOME claims
Thank you for you're hard work 💜
Free Palestine
Stop.the Land Grabbing!!!!!!!
ZIONIST ZOMBIE!@@talksmoke1190
Free Israel.
@@Zerja
The Zionists are Free to go back to wherever they came from.
@@Zerja
Israel is free to go back to wherever they came from.
Thank you for exposing too much lies.
Liarsus uk nato sahooni djjallis
As always, excellent journalism and commentary. Thank you.
Thank you ❤❤
Thank you for your excellent conversation
Hannibal Protocol by the IDF.
No other army in the world behaves in this depraved way.
Have you not heard of Islam
@@sheenayoung6141 and the US, UK and other European Armies
@@fm-oldmanphil those countries actually fought the Nazis, instead of joining them like Islam did
@@sheenayoung6141 are you saying those armies have never committed war crimes?
Thank you for your excellent reporting EI.
Thanks for all your efforts spreading the truth !
Thank you for such a great program
thank you so much for sharing this update!
Heartbreaking truth. Thank you.
Very interesting. Thank you for your work.
John Hankey's video posted yesterday on UA-cam: OCTOBER 7 WAS AN INSIDE JOB
Thank you for your careful exploration and sharing of the truth
great analyst and exposure guys.
Great work Electronic Intifada
Thank you
Thanks ei. I hope you can publish full video of the interview with subtitle.
GREAT REAL INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALISM..RESPECT FROM SOUTH AFRICA 🇿🇦 🇿🇦 🇿🇦
Appreciate you guys
Expert journalism as always. I learned a lot.
Great reporting as always guys. Thank you and keep up the amazing journalism
Said no sane person ever
@@sheenayoung6141Z!onism = Naz!sm
The world finally sees you devils
@@sheenayoung6141Keep lurking in this channel as israhelll has been exposed as a modern day n@z! regime
@@sheenayoung6141Your lies has been exposed. Keep watching you Israeli devils
Finally 😅, I finally found a news media outlet that's actually telling the truth 👍😎💯🎇. Great reporting 💯
Looking for a true loyal patriotic American in US politics ~ Is like looking for a needle in a haystack ~ (See A-I-P-A-C for details)
Thomas Massie is one of I'm not mistaken
Iff they exist ther ar in game off hiding and sliping helper,Allah will help us i beliwe i pray to protect all in need ,forgiwe us,conect us all to bi like one brain and act like one body or on bether way he know best,hez name Al Azim i call and asking for solution to win freedom and human rights for all world wide ,special and first their wher ar people in need like in Gaza now,inshallah,Elhamdullillah,lowe4all alain with AL RAHMANI ,LOWE , PEACE,HELTY AND WELT, to bee under Al mighty protect till end off time,respect Sarajevo BiH
Don't worry Donald Trump will soon be President
He might be the only one. Dee cee is full of xionizt shills.
Thank you... Respect these people for thier bravery to reveal the truth..
Thank you for educating us.
You are all so brilliant
.i love that quote from the internet "every accusation by Israelis is a confession"
I am always waiting imapssiontely for your new stream!
I love your clear, factual presentations-so well put together!
Justice for the people of Palestine
The Israeli People’s Committee. Interim Conclusion Report, April 2021:
From Uncontrollable Impulse to Criminal Spin?
NOT SURE YOU WANT TO ENVY US
"I was impressed frankly with the obsession of your prime minister, he called me thirty times, thirty times. He would call me at 3:00 o'clock in the morning and he would ask me what about the variants, what data we have, and I said, "Prime minister it's three o'clock…". He said, "No, no! don't worry, tell me." Or he would call me to ask about children, "I need to vaccinate the schools," or to ask about pregnant women. So, he convinced me frankly that he will be on top of it." (Pfizer CEO Dr. Albert Bourla, interview on Israeli TV, March 2021)
ABSTRACT: The Israeli People’s Committee has uncovered a multitude of malfunctions and failures at the administrative, ethical and legal levels during the COVID-19 vaccination campaign at the beginning of 2021 in Israel. In this document, we aim at presenting and elaborating the main features of these malfunctions, which have led to severe damages in many Israelis in the short term, and sadly to possible future damages. It seems that the entire country got caught up in a medical-social chaos, where the leadership has enabled a situation of fear and uncertainty to run its course out of control, and even contributed to its further enhancement. But most of all, we cannot ignore severe suspicions shared by all the committee members, that the fundamental sin, which led to the chaos and its casualties, is the way in which two very powerful personages, prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Pfizer CEO Dr. Albert Bourla, agreed upon a massive vaccination campaign in Israel that is unprecedented in scale and nature. A vaccination campaign that lacks effective safeguards for public safety, that is devoid of any concern for people who may be harmed by the vaccine, and that has allegedly guaranteed to encompass populations, for which the safety of the vaccine has not been tested (pregnant women and their fetuses), and later also children, for whom the need to be vaccinated is totally unclear, while pushing aside any safety considerations. From this exact episode, where both parties came to an agreement regarding the vaccination campaign, which involved a wide variety of ethical and safety violations, an unrestrained drama was initiated that has revealed itself to be impulsive, neglectful and reckless. The agreed upon vaccination campaign concerns matters of life and death, yet is being conducted in an amateurish, irresponsible and aggressive manner, and it led to the political arena taking over the medical arena and bending it to its needs, while paralyzing all alarm systems, monitoring measures and open scientific discussion. Unfortunately, most of the medical system collaborated with this unsupervised process, starting with the higher ranks, and ending with field doctors - some actively, some by keeping quiet from fear of reprisal. !!!
Thank you so much for this perspective. It has been utterly glossed over by the mainstream media. I find that amazing in this day and age of information sharing.
I hope THE PEOPLE in Israel are Watching and Listening to This they need to Know THE WHOLE TRUTH. THESE ZIONESTS ARE ROTTEN THROUGH AND THROUGH. FREEDOM FOR PALESTINE 🇵🇸.
Thanks for your excellent work, as always
Can we talk about Yossi Landau. ZAKA ? The very root of the lie , that spread globally .
They have talked about it very early specially after NYT reports. The Grayzone and Mondoweiss did that too.
I Love your truthfulness podcasts 😊Im sharing,subscribed and liking all your videos!
I didn't know that they had a truthfulness podcast, I thought that they only did propaganda
Thank you for your much needed work guys! Much love and respect 🤍
History is the progenitor of truth! And, truth stands on its own feet!
You are doing such important work. This investigation on what happened on October 7 must continue and, so far, the emerging information is telling a more nuanced story which would’ve led to a very different world perspective, especially here in the west.
Thanks for the truth
Grazie mille
Great journalism. Thank you
Thanks for this esposure
Thank you. ❤
Amazing how the Kibbutz and music festival next to concentration camp called Gaza is mirror imgage of the Oscar winning film 'The Zone of Interest'.
Are you really this stupid, or is it an act
It's so similar
..the concentration camp that American citizens have visited on vacation every year since Israel pulled out of the Gaza strip? 🤣
Thank you
Merci beaucoup!
A refreshing change to see the sensible date format. D/M/Y.
Thank you guys great news reporting. ❤
Where? I missed that, too busy watching this BS
@@sheenayoung6141any counter argument to what’s mentioned in the video?
You mistyped...watching instead of WRITING...@@sheenayoung6141
You guys are doing a good job. Hope you get to what is best for all. Thank you for your work.
Have any of the Occupiers effected by October 7th, whether victims or relatives, shown an ounce the self awareness in that they are the invaders? the occupiers? the bad people? that they should never have been there? That they should not be holding a concert next to a concentration camp? Have any of them?
In my view, illegal settlers are a colonial occupying force and not, by definition, civilians. Ergo, no Israeli civilians died on October 7th.
They ignore the very existence of Palestinians
@@shovanbijoy7136 actually one of the communities was a peace kibbutz filled with activists who regularly worked for Palestinian rights. Sadly, they were murdered. A lot of them were elderly. Terrible situation.
@@RevSteveHermann Those kibbutz were actually Palestinian villages... Talking about rights in stolen land...
Also living happily in front of a concentration camp?
@@shovanbijoy7136 Years before all of that land was inhabited by Jews. So do you think it is ok to murder unarmed innocent people? Seriously? how is this ok? Would you kill those people if you were there? Look at what has happened in Gaza as a result. It is terrible. So many people suffering,
SILENCE is not an Option, STAND UP, SPEAK UP so that when your Children, your Friends, your Conscience ask WHAT did YOU do when a Genocide was happening, they will know, your Heart and Soul will know YOU stood for JUSTICE, YOU were on the Right side of History...
Keep up the amazing work guys!!
Great work. Keep it up.
Amazing journalism
Damn I missed that, too busy watching this BS propaganda channel
@@sheenayoung6141missed it or didn’t even bother watching it?
@@sheenayoung6141how much are they paying you for your dumb comments in tube?
Thank you for sharing this video. Please help share as many as we possibly can. #freepalestine
Highly intriguing report. Yes,.. Yes,.. the Broader Context is very important to this Israeli Palestinian resistance captive's interview. I did some researching on kibbutz culture way back around the time of the attack. I was surprised to learn that these are not innocent villages. They often have one or more guardians who go through special defense training iirc... not-to-mention that many villagers themselves have served at one time or another. To make matters more "poignant", as you point out... this 60 yr old Israeli woman, gunned down by the Israeli apache attack helicopter, had herself been to an exhibition concerning that fact that these kibbutz villages/homes were once Palestinian and written a letter about her deep regret,.. ... how horrifyingly ironic that one day she would die by the hand she thought was that of her protector, the same hand(s) which at some point took a home away from a Palestinian and gave it to her family. The WHOLE situation, when viewed in the Larger context is sickening. Good job to all of you for stitching together a complex yet vital comprehensive history of this particular event. Let us hope the Al-J article/documentary lands, as planned.
Thank you for your contribution to understanding what to (or not) trust.
I am really looking forward for the whole truth to come
Awesome work guys ❤
Thank you Electronic Intifada 🙏