Method to madness? Marwan Bishara on the implications of Trump’s Gaza comments
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 лют 2025
- Al Jazeera’s senior political analyst, Marwan Bishara, examines the implications of US President Donald Trump’s proposal concerning Gaza and its reception by Israeli officials.
Bishara critiques the proposal, emphasising its controversial nature, as it aligns with what international human rights groups and UN figures have termed forced displacement and ethnic cleansing. He draws parallels between Trump and Israeli far-right figures such as Ben Gvir, suggesting a shared vision that could worsen tensions and exacerbate humanitarian issues in Gaza.
Bishara also reflects on the political dynamics at play, noting how Trump’s intervention could strengthen Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who is currently facing multiple legal and political challenges. He questions the sincerity of Trump’s proposal, given the US president’s history of making bold, often unrealistic statements. Bishara suggests that the proposal may be a tactical manoeuvre to deflect attention from other issues or to lay the groundwork for future negotiations.
Ultimately, Bishara expresses concern that Trump’s approach could undermine efforts to rebuild Gaza and address the humanitarian crisis, potentially leading to further obstruction of reconstruction efforts by both the US and Israel.
Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
#UnitedStates #Palestine #Gaza #WarOnGaza #TrumpGazaPlan #Israel #IsraelHamasWar #GazaWar #IsraelGazaWar #Egypt #Jordan #Israel #BenjaminNetanyahu #PalestinianRefugees #GazaEthnicCleansing #DonaldTrump #GazaDisplacement #GazaCeasefire #GazaGenocide
Please, someone should tell trump to rebuild LA first, I'm sure he is cursed, America will face many calamities because of him.
No money…
@@RiomaMario-f7x so why suggesting something even more expensive than rebuilding LA?
that's Newsom problem
@@125discipline2 No money for Americans - there's always plenty of money for Israel and the oligarchs.
you can never understand because you dont know whats happening
They are making a deal on Gaza without the people of Gaza. That’s not how the world works.
Who will rebuild Gaza?
If not Trump... then who?
They can step up at anytime.
@@JohnJacob33 NOONE asked trump to build anything he can easily step out
@@sumayabusur5527 Should they just live in tents? Someone has to rebuild. So if not him. Then who?
@@sumayabusur5527
The only thing "Palestinians" have built are tunnels for terror.
Aah I see. Then you tell some good deal involving Gaza with out uttering Israel
This is painfully sad and disturbing to treat the Palestinians as trow aways,Viva Peace Hope Freedom Justice and Humanity to Palestine❤❤❤ South Africa stands with Palestine,
Everybody, the whole world stands with the Pslestinian people!
All this could have been avoided. Cant replay the video
Your a Patel and if you end up in gaza they would throw you down the roof . Know your friends and who your enemies are
@@zoyailpatel3608 agree, it’s such a shame. Trump can’t see human beings in Palestinians
@@maghalie1612which whole world are u talking about
Because of the vast reserves of oil snd gas off the coast of Gaza which they want to take and own .
Of course. That’s been talked about since long before Oct 7. Media focuses on Oct 7 for convenience and to aid and abet Israel but says nothing about Oct 6 and for the entire 60 years before. It’s a better idea to repatriate everyone from Israel to their homes in EU and USA and leave Palestinians in piece on their land.
The US has more than enough resources in the US to actually care about a couple of billion in Gaza oil and gas. Stop kidding yourself that it’s about that. I actually don’t think he’s serious about this, but either way - will never get Gaza. This is just at the ready for 4 years 😂
USA export oil and gas
@@Salim-c3i1e i don't think america or israel is looking for oil or gas in gaza , they just in desperate need of land for the so called the great israel , america is just kind fulfilling israelis needs and wants
Free America from AIPAC.
Free the world from Al Jazeera
Pacman eat the ghost 👻
😢Save your politics from AIPAC
The war crimes continue!!!
Shame on these heartless freaks!!! God save Palestinians!❤💚🖤🤍
God didn't tell them to initiate October 7th.......God doesn't like violence so if you start your barbaric act then you have to find your own way out.
Save them from themselves
right back at ya, darkness. Fix you own problems and stop begging for u.s. aid. Move to where the food is.
@@aeolianharp1363your tiny hat is squeezing your head to tight.
It's allan willing. What do you mean abdool?@@KYN_AFRICA
Everything is made in China, but courage is made in Palestine.
But the warplanes and bombs are made in America , sadly.
Trrsm you mean
From a first-person perspective everyone always thinks they're the hero.
Also shahid belts and home made metro 😂
I don't think China is making or even thinking of something foolish like this! This can only the crazy mind of Trump! It's time to put him into a mental facility.
I've never seen Netanyahu look so happy before. He looked like he was about to break into song.
He was having a psychotic episode.
the smirk is beyond disgusting
He just got sucked off by Trump. Of course he's happy. Look at that smerk. Trump looks excited too.
@@LizzieLeishit was the face of satan with the fireplace behind him
He was about to break out in song there HE WON
Mainstream media is going to cry about this Qardun coin so hard soon
Walmart, Amazon and Trump support? Qardun token is going to 500x... I just hope there is not too many insiders
Impeach Trump
So he can get a 3rd term...... Hnmmmm
@@ryanwalters6184 He will be “gone” before he sees a 3rd term 😂😂😂🙄
No
You need better education not ideology and terrorism
Trump and Bezos discussed Qardun Token at the inaguration party
My god my god look what they r planing to do to the palestinians brothers and sisters please do not let this evil happen 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
I wish a reporter had asked Netanyahu if he brought his laundry with him this time.
The journalists were spineless could not muster the courage or moral duty to ask about his arrest warrant for war crimes genocide
When is the PressConference with Iranian's Komeindian?
Imagine one day your neighbour come in to your house, destroy it, force you out, take over and rebuild. Then telling everyone they are helping to solve a problem and should be applauded.
now imagine never getting over it and deciding to suffer for he next 100 years because of it, instead of rebuilding and moving on
Lobby control over US
Our politicians are bought and payed for by aipac.
Trump the joke of the next 4 years🤣🤣
DONKEE DONUTS…
Jokes on us.
The joke AND the DANGER.
No more Palestine
@@genarosalazar2818 guess again tiny hat. Palestine will always be river to the sea. Long after yours are gone.
These two would be the main obstructive persons in future for rebuilding the Gaza for the Palestinians,😭😭😭😭😭
I'm only here laugh at all Arab Americans who said Trump would be better than Kamala 😅
Do you want to say the Arabs vote trump into power???
It's trusting between lion and crocodile. 🤣
We call her Kamel tow.😃🙄😆🙈
O voted for Trump2024 bcz of illegal palastinian immigrants.
I think there the same just different ways of saying things remember what waltz said we believe in the expansion of Israel
Never heard about this Qardun Token coin until Trump endorsement but seems like it has some utility at least
Palestine was occupied by David, Persians, Greek, Roman, and Ottoman.
All occupations came and gone, but Palestinian people remained in Palestine.
Yes, Palestinians remained refugees for 4 generations.
So did the Jews
I liked this one...
Only Israel is exist in the bible.
There was no Palestinian people and land from from the beginning.
There will no Palestinian alien
Zero history knowledge..😅
Ben Tramp! This is brilliant! What a slap on the face of all pro-Palestinian Hippocrates.
Al Jazeera is hysterical. I can understand. :)
Trump is as subtle as a barn door. Rid Gaza of residents by constructing high end apartments that Palestinians cannot afford to rent.
This is so painful 😣
Aah I see. That is something to relieve pain. Your heart can't perceive it. How long this fighting sud continue. Political parties like Hamas and Fatah... they don't care about people they care about only power. In order to get into power they instigate people using word Israel
Hitting my head on a wall
Oooouch!
Justice ⚖️ for Palestine.
@@SharminAkter-eg3ke they got their "justice" on October 7th. Now it's time for our Justice. Permeant justice ⚖️
@@asherrf hope you get the same justice. Permanent justice.
I love the reporters' sigh at the end. You can tell he's frustrated because he actually cares..❤
There is no need to be afraid of anyone except Allah (let the trump speak,no Palestinian have to go to any other country)
I sooo pray and hope so bro,🙏
that's why America government wouldn't stop it the Gaza ceasefire because they wanted to finished it whole Palestinian people
Oh stop being a wet blanket. He’s never going to get the Gaza Strip.
If you think Trump is a fool that's exactly what he wants you to think.
He's a puppet of the american backroom socialites. He has no clear thoughts of his own.
@@bipolarbear7325 not a fool. Just another puppet replacing the old puppet. Puppet master sitting next to him.
Shouldnt Hamas and Iran pay for rhe reconstruction since rhey statred the war?
Of course
Brilliant! 😂
@@asherrf Nope. The one who ran a decades long brutal occupation and cried poor little victim me when the consequences knocked on the door should pay. No rocket science. Occupation is bad for your health said the doctor. I believe that 🤣
@Jan-e3z8s someone can't count, clearly. "Knocking" was a massive loss for them and their health. 💅🏾
They shouldn't have done October 7 😢
Then surrender back people territories then…
@RiomaMario-f7x Forget that.
They shouldn't have occupied Palestine since 1948 give them back their land and leave Palestine 🇵🇸
@@mouaadwdh4767 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@mouaadwdh4767 LOL. Forget it and move on.
Sooo much respect to u brother marwan ❤❤❤❤🙏🙏👍👍👍👍🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌
It's going to take a long time to rebuild and they will both be gone in four years.
Poor presents... Tirmp have spoken 😂😂😂😂🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
7th-Oct - Completely backfired 😮😮😮 Who's idea it was ???(Iran, Hamas, Turkey, Quatar, Hezbollah???)
Yes
It hasn't actually. A whole generation have educated themselves to the ongoing genocide. People who otherwise would have sympathy for Israel have now realised what is really going on. Apart from a few fundamentalist Hindus in India even overseas Jewish communities are disassociating themselves from Israel. The Jewish leaders in Australia who have been quietly cheering on Israel till now have today distanced themselves from Trumps comments.
I am in $5k in Qardun token 🚀
Kinda makes sense
6:08 exactly right. Brilliant move on Trumps part
Thanks Marwan ❤
Marwan god bless trying to make sense of this madness.
October 7th was a blender
Love and respect to the people of palestine...God be with you...time to lend a hand ! (in peace)
You mean ...There is NO Allah BUT al LAH ? and many more are likely to be sent to enjoy the sexyParadise of al LAH?
It's a great idea why should they live in ruble for decades
Palestinians will never ever leave their land.
Or really? Look how a half of the population of Syria left..
Everybody know Syrian can return to their homeland if wish but not the case in Palestine
Just wait and see ha ha ha
MOAB?
They will never go forward too
Like monsters playing musical chairs.
Trump not president he just a comedy stand-up
The ICJ clarification of July 19, 2024 states: 1. Israel must leave all illegally occupied territories (Gaza, West Bank, East Jerusalem... SYRIAN GOLAN HEIGHTS). 2. Israel and all supporters of the illegal occupation are obliged to pay reparations (US, Germany, UK...)-
ICC is irrelevant, about to be sanctioned by US Congress
FORHENIOUS CRIMES
lgbqia+ says so?
Absolutely shocking
Lol
Bring the Chinese in to reconstruct Gaza. The gulf Arabs are awash with money they can afford to look after their brothers.
Marwan is not happy
🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭
✌️🇮🇱✌️🇮🇱✌️🇮🇱✌️🇮🇱✌️
I love it when Marwan is not happy.😂 You know you're on the right track.
Nonsense....Hamas sympathizers..the earlier you accept the better...
Marwan living in 5 star luxury in Qatar
He forgot to mention Kushner Trump son in law who is close to MBS this is all a plan
Insults and distortion of History is all you Zionists have
Trump is a genius. Thinking out of the norm is the hallmark of a genius. Daring to use it is the symbol of a great leader. That is why he was elected again. Go Trump, Peace through strength.
Israelis like lunatic demented Trump because he is easily manipulated
Albert Einstein wrote in 1946, "I am in favor of Palestine being developed as a Jewish Homeland but not as a separate State. It seems to me a matter of simple common sense that we cannot ask to be given political rule over Palestine where two thirds of the population are not Jewish. What we can and should ask for is a secured bi-national status in Palestine with free immigration."
In response to the necessity for a Jewish state, in 1936 Einstein wrote, "I believe that the unique durability of the Jewish community is to a large degree based on our geographical dispersion, and the fact that we consequently do not possess instruments of power that will allow us to commit great stupidities out of national fanaticism."
@acesfullmike5371
Who cares what Einstein said 79 years ago.
How is your protest vote against Biden working out?
Maybe if biden had not aided on the death of 50k Palestinians his vp would be in office.
Biden was no better.
@@jimbocho660 by all logic, your comment makes absolutely no sense.
@@jimbocho660
At least Biden doesn't support the far-right in Israel and is willing to sanction settlers. Observe Trump; he nullifies everything and even suggests expelling Palestinians in Gaza while "owning Gaza."
Great because I didn’t have to vote for gen oc ide
So I dont think things are as they seem.
The 47th is pretty much forcing the specific lobby to talk out in front of everyone and showcasing to them that their ideas won't work.
At least thats how I see it
Very clever... That kinda probing has been happening ALOT..
@adamdrozdowski7786 Also, i see it as a pressure toward the Saudis.
The way I see it, nothing can happen without them(probably Turkey as well) being on the table.
Plus, the 47th knows that the balance of power will lean toward the Chinese should he even move.
Now the question is, even if this happens, assuming all sides agrew and I mean all sides who is footing the bill?
We are talking 100s of billions of $$$
Good interview right on point🇨🇦
"Fox news".... the fact that Marwan couldn't resist the urge to call out fox news makes it looks like he's really pained.
As Al jazeera is to the Palestinians so is fox news to the Israelis no offence.
And sky news to high flyers????
The world is honestly GETTING sick of these CLOWNS meTHINKS
Who will rebuild Gaza?
If not Trump... then who?
They can step up at anytime.
Is a plan that will never see a day , Iran is laughing at the Arabs countries chickening 😂😂
Yes… chicken backsites
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
The flag of evil
Toilet paper 🇮🇱=🧻🚽💩
That's not a flag it's a toilet paper
@ and the Palestinians can use it all they want when they live in Yemen
@@mouaadwdh4767cry about it
I am ashamed as an American, not that the government cares what the people think.
No future for Gaza[
We went from crony capitalism to crony imperialism in 16 days.
Actions have consequences….
It's right and better for peace.
Indeed
He also said he wanted to sell Puerto Rico !!!!
I wish Mexico would buy it
Gulf Mexico to gulf trumpeter….
The sooner your simple mind learns to accept your reality the easier this process will be, for you. For Israel has spoken.
😂😂😂
You don't know HOW DUMB that sounds... THAT WILL make the world HATE you... "for Israel has spoken". OMG
@@adamdrozdowski7786 Obey and you will be ok. For Israel has spoken.
If someone listened to Israeli ambassador to UK Tzipi who wanted Palestinians to go to Sinai “temporarily” and Israeli spokesman who was pleading to Khamas to lay down their arm release hostages and surrender they would know what Israel had in their minds long time ago
“Gaza is an experiment” .... this isn’t a science lesson....it’s about Palestinian lives. Justice for Gaza.
Many Americans cheering on trump’s redevelopment plans! Perhaps not the Palestinians living in Michigan who voted for trump.
Bullshit. This American is absolutely against this taking of land and displacement of the Palestinians. This is a throwback to the taking of native land here.
There are not a lot of Palestinians in Michigan. The Arab population is mostly from Lebanon, Yemen, and Iraq, and you have some of course who are from Palestine by way of Jordan. But they should not be seen as representative of mainstream Palestinian-American opinion in the US. The Arab world is very divided on how to actually support Palestine. So Arab-Americans, many of whom have no relation to that land, should not be held to a higher standard than world leaders, who breathe fire about Israel to the public but do business with them in private.
They lost the war. Several times. It's obvious the palastinians cannot govern themselves.
😢
Well. There you have it
Guess where He will build his new Trump Tower ?
GAZA HEIGHTS
Gaza Israel 🇮🇱
The Palestinians want out of Gaza but the pro-Palestinians will never allow them to leave.
So they walked back into Gaza blind?
What is your source?
America not learn his previous war
Vietnam, Afghan….????
Not learnt from Afghanistan and Iraq where they said they would give the people the peaceful life with prosperity and equality
This is what it looks like to lose a war that you start.
marwan is getting older these last few days too fast
Dear world please forgive us who did not vote for this president We ( U S A ) have become cruel greedy, self serving awful people I'm so sorry to be a part of this
Yes, please forgive the tampon Tim voters
😂😂😂
Love it Marwan..Ben Trump! 😂😂😂
marwan is nervous.
Black's for Trump-2024!President Donald J Trump is doing the will of "God ".
Trump is doing the will of the devil
@forestman2382 you misspelled hamas
@johnsmith7140 no I meant Israel .Israel is thousands times worse than Hamas. Israel is a terrorist state
trump is not well.
no more baklava! 😀
Oklahoma then????
That last bit made a lot of sense,
Build luxury apartments that palestinians cant afford
Am here watching everything but let me tell the whole world that without my presidency nothing will happen good in this world.
עם ישראל חי
Don't forget what USA did to Japan helped them out and now look at Japan
Yes so great Japan has negative population growth, 200% debt to GDP, slow and cumbersome beaurocracy and a depressed and overworked population
Poor clueless analyst was praising trump two days back. poor chap bushaaraaaaaa 😄😄😄
Bucharestaaaaaa
Bangladesh. .Sheikh Mujibur Rahman's house is Dhanmondi 32. This house has been demolished by militants and IS members. The people of Bengal want justice in the international court. International demands to bring them under the law।।Since Sheikh Hasina is not the Prime Minister in Bangladesh, the militant ISIS has increased in the country and they have risen again. Abductions, murders, arson, vandalism in various places, Bangladesh has now become unsafe, so the world Appeal to save Bangladesh.
Marwon needs to take ESL classes.
I really wander for those who are still struggling with their wrong movement while rolling tears on the chest together with heartless towards Infront of them and they will never ever succeed in their actions towards presidency of the state.
Trump is crazy 🤪
No people should ever be displaced to make way for people of the "correct" ethnicity. The whole basis upon which Israel was created is profoundly wrong, and this is what we should be addressing, not doubling down on the mistakes of the past.
Unless people sell their Qardun Token before launch, this is going to sell out instantly after it reaches mainstream media
Real face of Democracy 😂😂😂😂
Greedy AIPAC politicians.
Better than being a CAIR or muslim brotherhood politician
Haha
Trump is expected to mention Qardun Token this week and the ICO is already almost sold out