I have a serious question for the shiekh. A brother at work told me whilst he was in Pakistan, the local imam showed him sahih bukhari in urdu and another in arabic. He pointed out that the arabic one did not include certain chapters in the urdu one and vice versa. Have you come across any off this? Barakallahu feek
Assalamu alaikum Brother, Imam Bukhari Rahimahullah wrote his Sahih in Arabic not Urdu is First point, Second point there are some people whom I know say that Imam Bukhari Rahimahullah wrote more than 6 lac Ahadeeth from which only 2.5k+ are Sahih but the Real Print has more than 7k which is Sahih and Authentic and Recommended by Many of the 'Ulama Rahimahumullah..... Seek the Truth yourself by getting the book yourself Brother... A Kind advice from a Kind Brother... May Allah Grant all of us True Knowledge and Guidance and Protect us from Falsified Knowledge. Aameen And is the Imam from Pakistan criticizing Sahih al Bukhari ? Or what was he trying to Say?
@@Abdullah-or2iz Wa 'alaikum assalam Akhi, maybe you wanted to say the correct thing but you did not word it correctly, but just to make clear, here some clarifications: 1. It is not correct to say that Imām Bukhārī thought that only 2,5k+ Ahadīth of the 600.000 that Imām Bukhārī knew were Sahīh. Imām Bukhārī has many other books, like al-Adab al-Mufrad of Tarīkh al-Kabīr, where he explicitly said regarding some narrations that they are Sahīh, but he did not include them in his Sahīh Bukhārī. This is because the aim and goal of Sahīh Bukhārī was never to included EVERY Sahīh Hadīth, but Imām Bukhārī had chapter headings in which he wanted to proofs points regarding Aqīdah or Fiqh or Mu'āmalāt etc. and he brought Hadīth in accordance to that. Nowehere did he say that this is a collection of ALL the Sahīh Ahadīth. 2. If you had look at an actual print of Sahīh Bukhārī you will realize that Imām Bukhārī brings one narration in many different chapters - again - according to the thing he wanted to proof there. For example: The first Hadith in Sahih Bukhari is about the intention, i.e. that every deed depends on the intention. Imām Bukhārī brought this Hadīth in multiple chapters, like in the Chapter of Oaths and Vows, Hadith 6689, and also in the Chapter of Tricks, Hadith 6958, to proof certain points. So if the complete Sahīh Bukhārī has around 7k Ahadīth, this is when you count without repetition. If you do not count the places where Imām Bukhārī repeated a Hadīth, you have way less narrations. 3. With regards to possible differences in the translated editions, this could be for the following reasons: - It was a summarized Sahīh Bukhārī. In the summarized editions of Sahīh Bukhārī the scholars removed the places where Imām Bukhārī repeated narrations (as I gave an example from before), to make the book more condences and more accessable. Because most regular Muslim will not want to read a 6 Volume Book. But if they have a summarized edition to start with studying Sahīh Bukhārī, this is beneficial. This is also beneficial for a beginner student of knowledge if he wants to get to know Bukhārī. - The publisher might have made a mistake- - Some minor changes in chapter could be because of the differences in manuscripts, but usually a good publisher puts that information in the footnotes, i.e. if there is a place where there are minor differences in the manuscripts. But this is normalyl not done in translations. And Allāh knows best 🌹
Jazakalaah khairan brothers for your replies. I just wanted to know if anyone heard these claims before. I know for sure theres nothing being hidden and its an anti wahabai anti saudi rhetoric.
Assalamu alaikum Please refer to this video ua-cam.com/video/f_ryAoJI66k/v-deo.html In short, most likely the Urdu version had removed repeated hadiths to keep the book small It definitely saves some time and money And Allah knows best Also please, the Muslims and our scholars and knowledgeable ones have not been ignorant, instead of assuming you came across something new, always ask Allah for help and then search for the answer from authentic scholars/students of knowledge and authentic sources
@@Abdullah-or2iz Assalamu alaikum (this is specifically for you brother: I have listened to lectures and they say he memorised 6 lac (600,000) hadith Allah knows best the exact number, but from so many hadiths he tried to get the Sahih hadiths in Sahih Bukhari and he wrote Sahih Bukhari for over 16 years! May Allah have mercy on our scholars and guide us If you want to learn more, search Al Madrasatu Al Umariyyah Imam bukhari on youtube, amazing channel ) Please refer to this video ua-cam.com/video/f_ryAoJI66k/v-deo.html In short, most likely the Urdu version had removed repeated hadiths to keep the book small It definitely saves some time and money And Allah knows best Also please, the Muslims and our scholars and knowledgeable ones have not been ignorant, instead of assuming you came across something new, always ask Allah for help and then search for the answer from authentic scholars/students of knowledge and authentic sources
@@SaddamHussain-we9ec you can't get this accuracy of manuscripts in translations so I thought he's making fun of people who always say "is it available in English"😂
@@Salafite I still can’t find anything when searching on Google I really want to buy these books but the sheikh hasn’t linked anything and has made it very difficult for us to actually buy the books he’s recommended
BEHOLD, THE RIGOROUS SCIENCE OF HADITHS Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said: Dajjal is blind of left eye *[ Sahih muslim 2934a ]* Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said: Dajjal is blind of one eye *[ sahih muslim 2933c ]* Allah’s messenger said: Al-Masih Ad- Dajjal is blind in the right eye *[ Sahih Bukhari 7407 ]*
Ibn Umar reported that Allah's Messenger (ﷺ). made a mention of Dajjal in the presence of the people and said: Allah is not one-eyed and behold that Dajjal is blind of the right eye and his eye would be like a floating grape Sahih Muslim, 169 e
@@GeneralPotato1 Only Quran is 100% perfect. No human collection can be 100% perfect. Same with Bukhari. it is not perfect. So what percentage is imperfect. 10% ? And which hadith is that 10%.
@@indianrational6887 Akhi there is only 1 Hadith out of the 7563 that some scholars say is Hasan(bit lower then Sahih but still acceptable) but the majority say it isn't let me give you an example out of every Hadith book it is the most authentic book
@@GeneralPotato1 Thats what scholars claim. These kind of politically correct claims carry no authenticity. But the fact is Sahih bukhari is a collection of hadith from people whom the prophet himself didn’t authorize to narrate. No wonder it is full of contradictory statements.
@@indianrational6887 the way the Quran was preserved was through speech and writing yes? That is the same way the sahih bukhari is preserved thats why not every hadith is sahih a lot are daif(fake) but bukhari is authentic the way the hadiths of bukhari are preserved through speech sheikh bukhari was born 200 years after prophet muhammed become a prophet so its only 2-3 generations away from the prophet sheikh bukhari spent his whole life just collecting hadiths and making sure about their authenticity but allah swt knows best
![Imam Muslim [RA]](/img/n.gif)
Mashallah ♥️
I want to work like you for my religion
أحبك في الله يا شيخ ، الله يوفقك وينصرك ويحميك قلوبنا معك رعاك الله
As-salaamu Alaikum
Where can these editions be purchased?
Idk why he dint mention the link
Sir, as salamu alaikum,
Please put all the unboxing videos in a single playlist
جزاك الله خيرا
جزاك الله خيرا بارك الله فيك
Were can I buy these from
I really want to buy these but cannot find these can you please give me a link brother
Sifatusafwa Akhi
@@abdulwadood.8Sifatu Safwa
MashAllah
Can you please leave links for us to buy these books as many of us if not all of us are struggling to find the books online.
Sheikh, can you explain to me, someone told me that in sahih Muslim prophet mohamad practice slave trading.
AoA brother.
Where is the manuscript of bukhari written by bukhari himself?
JazakAllah khair
What your thought on darusslam print
I think I have a bit of a hearing issue. Can you write down the book reference? Publisher, etc...
Did you find out? As I really want to buy these books and I didn’t understand what he said
صحيح البخاري وصحيح مسلم (دار التأصيل، الطبعة ٢/٣)
Are darussalams books accurate?
What is actual difference between dar ut taseel and other prints, explain with examples
I have a serious question for the shiekh. A brother at work told me whilst he was in Pakistan, the local imam showed him sahih bukhari in urdu and another in arabic. He pointed out that the arabic one did not include certain chapters in the urdu one and vice versa. Have you come across any off this? Barakallahu feek
Assalamu alaikum Brother, Imam Bukhari Rahimahullah wrote his Sahih in Arabic not Urdu is First point, Second point there are some people whom I know say that Imam Bukhari Rahimahullah wrote more than 6 lac Ahadeeth from which only 2.5k+ are Sahih but the Real Print has more than 7k which is Sahih and Authentic and Recommended by Many of the 'Ulama Rahimahumullah..... Seek the Truth yourself by getting the book yourself Brother... A Kind advice from a Kind Brother... May Allah Grant all of us True Knowledge and Guidance and Protect us from Falsified Knowledge. Aameen
And is the Imam from Pakistan criticizing Sahih al Bukhari ? Or what was he trying to Say?
@@Abdullah-or2iz Wa 'alaikum assalam Akhi, maybe you wanted to say the correct thing but you did not word it correctly, but just to make clear, here some clarifications:
1. It is not correct to say that Imām Bukhārī thought that only 2,5k+ Ahadīth of the 600.000 that Imām Bukhārī knew were Sahīh. Imām Bukhārī has many other books, like al-Adab al-Mufrad of Tarīkh al-Kabīr, where he explicitly said regarding some narrations that they are Sahīh, but he did not include them in his Sahīh Bukhārī. This is because the aim and goal of Sahīh Bukhārī was never to included EVERY Sahīh Hadīth, but Imām Bukhārī had chapter headings in which he wanted to proofs points regarding Aqīdah or Fiqh or Mu'āmalāt etc. and he brought Hadīth in accordance to that. Nowehere did he say that this is a collection of ALL the Sahīh Ahadīth.
2. If you had look at an actual print of Sahīh Bukhārī you will realize that Imām Bukhārī brings one narration in many different chapters - again - according to the thing he wanted to proof there. For example:
The first Hadith in Sahih Bukhari is about the intention, i.e. that every deed depends on the intention. Imām Bukhārī brought this Hadīth in multiple chapters, like in the Chapter of Oaths and Vows, Hadith 6689, and also in the Chapter of Tricks, Hadith 6958, to proof certain points.
So if the complete Sahīh Bukhārī has around 7k Ahadīth, this is when you count without repetition. If you do not count the places where Imām Bukhārī repeated a Hadīth, you have way less narrations.
3. With regards to possible differences in the translated editions, this could be for the following reasons:
- It was a summarized Sahīh Bukhārī. In the summarized editions of Sahīh Bukhārī the scholars removed the places where Imām Bukhārī repeated narrations (as I gave an example from before), to make the book more condences and more accessable. Because most regular Muslim will not want to read a 6 Volume Book. But if they have a summarized edition to start with studying Sahīh Bukhārī, this is beneficial. This is also beneficial for a beginner student of knowledge if he wants to get to know Bukhārī.
- The publisher might have made a mistake-
- Some minor changes in chapter could be because of the differences in manuscripts, but usually a good publisher puts that information in the footnotes, i.e. if there is a place where there are minor differences in the manuscripts. But this is normalyl not done in translations.
And Allāh knows best 🌹
Jazakalaah khairan brothers for your replies. I just wanted to know if anyone heard these claims before. I know for sure theres nothing being hidden and its an anti wahabai anti saudi rhetoric.
Assalamu alaikum
Please refer to this video
ua-cam.com/video/f_ryAoJI66k/v-deo.html
In short, most likely the Urdu version had removed repeated hadiths to keep the book small
It definitely saves some time and money
And Allah knows best
Also please, the Muslims and our scholars and knowledgeable ones have not been ignorant, instead of assuming you came across something new, always ask Allah for help and then search for the answer from authentic scholars/students of knowledge and authentic sources
@@Abdullah-or2iz
Assalamu alaikum
(this is specifically for you brother:
I have listened to lectures and they say he memorised 6 lac (600,000) hadith
Allah knows best the exact number, but from so many hadiths he tried to get the Sahih hadiths in Sahih Bukhari
and he wrote Sahih Bukhari for over 16 years!
May Allah have mercy on our scholars and guide us
If you want to learn more, search
Al Madrasatu Al Umariyyah Imam bukhari
on youtube, amazing channel )
Please refer to this video
ua-cam.com/video/f_ryAoJI66k/v-deo.html
In short, most likely the Urdu version had removed repeated hadiths to keep the book small
It definitely saves some time and money
And Allah knows best
Also please, the Muslims and our scholars and knowledgeable ones have not been ignorant, instead of assuming you came across something new, always ask Allah for help and then search for the answer from authentic scholars/students of knowledge and authentic sources
The Hadith Of Ammar RA? Same or the extra words removed? He will be killed by a Bagi Group?
It says in the footnote that those wordings are not to be found in some of the manuscripts.
Yazeedi-ness showing if it's true
@@deenreloaded imam Hakim has brought with the same words the exact hadith so it wasn't a blunder in the manuscripts.
@@moosaali9371 Doesn’t matter if Al Hakim brought it, if it isn’t found in the manuscript it isn’t a part of the Sahih.
@@العقيلي-ف7و😂😂😂 son of muawiya don_&key 😂😂
Best shuruhat of bukhari are fath Al Bari and umdah ul qari
Dar altaaseel is in egypt not saudi arabia
Also صحيح البخاري by موسسة الرسالة ناشرون is a really good print with the Tahqiq of Shuayb Al Arnut
Assalamualaikum
#AuthenticIlmMission
is it also available in english or other languages?
you're joking right?
@@mewzi so what if he asked?
@@SaddamHussain-we9ec you can't get this accuracy of manuscripts in translations so I thought he's making fun of people who always say "is it available in English"😂
طبعة بيت السنة افضل طبعة للبخاري حاليا
لا تأخذ الطبعات لهذه الدرجه لان كل الطبعات لها فوائدها، والله اعلم
@@kindashop362 اخي انظر الي طبعة بيت السنة
العمل الجبار واثني عليها المشايخ وقد جمعت محاسن جميع الطبعات
والله اعلي واعلم
@@om6343 جميلة جدآ احببتها بس المشكلة الوحيدة ما في منها مجلد واحد 😅
@@kindashop362 نعم لا تصلح لمن يسافر
Make vedio ibn tayamiya
i cant find the books. Whats the publisher ? Darul tahsil?
Dar Altaaseel دار التأصيل
@@Salafite I still can’t find anything when searching on Google I really want to buy these books but the sheikh hasn’t linked anything and has made it very difficult for us to actually buy the books he’s recommended
@@abdulwadood.8 search for دار التأصيل صحيح البخاري and you will find a shop selling it. It is completely in arabic.
BEHOLD, THE RIGOROUS SCIENCE OF HADITHS
Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said:
Dajjal is blind of left eye
*[ Sahih muslim 2934a ]*
Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said:
Dajjal is blind of one eye
*[ sahih muslim 2933c ]*
Allah’s messenger said:
Al-Masih Ad- Dajjal is blind in the right eye
*[ Sahih Bukhari 7407 ]*
Ibn Umar reported that Allah's Messenger (ﷺ). made a mention of Dajjal in the presence of the people and said:
Allah is not one-eyed and behold that Dajjal is blind of the right eye and his eye would be like a floating grape
Sahih Muslim, 169 e
There are both Hadith in sahih Muslim about left eye and right eye but maybe you didn’t come across it .
.
What percentage of sahih bukhari is fabricated or fake.
Sahih means authentic Sahih Bukhari is fully authentic
@@GeneralPotato1 Only Quran is 100% perfect. No human collection can be 100% perfect. Same with Bukhari. it is not perfect. So what percentage is imperfect. 10% ? And which hadith is that 10%.
@@indianrational6887 Akhi there is only 1 Hadith out of the 7563 that some scholars say is Hasan(bit lower then Sahih but still acceptable) but the majority say it isn't let me give you an example out of every Hadith book it is the most authentic book
@@GeneralPotato1 Thats what scholars claim. These kind of politically correct claims carry no authenticity. But the fact is Sahih bukhari is a collection of hadith from people whom the prophet himself didn’t authorize to narrate. No wonder it is full of contradictory statements.
@@indianrational6887 the way the Quran was preserved was through speech and writing yes? That is the same way the sahih bukhari is preserved thats why not every hadith is sahih a lot are daif(fake) but bukhari is authentic the way the hadiths of bukhari are preserved through speech sheikh bukhari was born 200 years after prophet muhammed become a prophet so its only 2-3 generations away from the prophet sheikh bukhari spent his whole life just collecting hadiths and making sure about their authenticity but allah swt knows best
Jesus Christ is Lord, all glory to Jesus Christ!!
لا اله إلا الله
*There is no god except Allah*