Most of the Hadiths were written by Persian authors. If It is not in accordance with Quran, it is just a narrative not even can be a hadith because Prophet Muhammed doesn’t say anything against Quran. Many fake slandering Hadiths have been written by persians after more than 200 years passed Prophet Muhammad’s (pbuh) death. Many of them contradicts Quran and slander about the Prophet. A person named Abu Dawud (Persian) has many contradictory hadiths. Hadiths must be filtered through Quran. Persians are not Arabs. In addition, Founder of Shia religion is Yemeni/persian jew.
@@Erol-Oztrk Why should the ethnicity of the scholars make a difference to their trustworthiness? Remember that Iran only became Shia relatively recently 400 years ago.
The reporters or collectors of hadiths lying or spreading falsehood has no correlation with them being Arab, Persian, subcontinent, etc. A large majority of the muhhaditheen were Persian and they were not corrupt
I am always trying to explain these nuances to people. Our deen is well, well-thought out and preserved ma sha Allah. Thank you for taking the time to make a well-made video on this topic. The graphics, timings, presentation and clear audio are appreciated and important. Now I can just share this video. Barak Allahu fik.
Barak Allahu feek. I study with one of the closest students of Al Sheikh Al Albani in Egypt. And I wanted to mention a few thing to the dear brothers and sisters. 1. Don't disregard memorization, even if not a scholar. How often do you meet a brother/sister who needs Naseeha or a small reminder? Every day probably. Nobody is obliged to take your word without any evidence. But if you know the strongest scholarly ruling AND the evidence, you will see that hearts get touched and moved by the word of Allah and his messenger ﷺ. 2. Start with the memorization of the Quran and don't let other things disturb you from it. Even Ahadith or Fiqh courses. If you know how to pray and fast and do your obligations and have somebody to ask if you don't know you are good to go. Every ill within yourself is fixed by the Quran. You could memorize the Quran in 2-3 years while working and studying, but if you mix in 3-4 courses on fiqh and seerah and other matters, this number fastly extends to 5, 10, 15, 20 years or worse: NEVER. As a Non-Arab you fall under the ruling of a child: You can memorize the Quran first, and then draw the rulings of it and deepen your understanding. After memorization of the Quran it is not uncommon to finish the Quran once a week. That means when you read tafseer of any ayah, you will come by that Aya once a week, revise it and ponder upon it. But if you learn tafseer and never read the Aya, you will forget it and not act upon it probably. Please, I urge you: Give your best to memorize the Quran. I ask Allah to make the Quran the light of our chests, and the fix for our wrongs and our daily companion. May Allah accept from you and me. Barak Allahu feekum
This is amazing سبحان الله. I want to memorize the Quran, but I sometimes struggle with setting up/maintaining good pacing. إن شاء الله I'll be moving to university in a few months and I want to know what you'd think a good pace or method of memorization would fit best. I am determined to memorize the Quran in the next few years, إن شاء الله may Allah reward you immensely for your comment and actions.
@@MrRadon54If you have any possibility to do the following do it, sit after Fajr and revise a juz everyday and then start learning the new page or line or two lines. Whatever you are able to memorize. The habit of revision is what will keep you on track. Because most people who stop memorizing, stop because they already memorized something and then they forgot and that demotivates them. But it is normal to forget, prioritize Revision insha Allah. And memorize something new everyday. Even if it is 2 ayat, one line, or half a page. That way you will finish, sooner or later إن شاء الله May Allah grant you success in Dunya and Akhira
@@Batu-sn8lbThe late Shaykh Qardāwī said in an interview that: After his Book 'Fiqh uz-Zakāt' was abridged without his permission by the Salafi publisher Zuhair ash-Shāwīsh (as usual), he went to Beirut to meet him. He said, that at the house of the publisher, he found the Sunni Ash'arī Muhaddith Shaykh 'Abdul Fattah Abū Ghuddah and the Salafi Shaykh Näsir al-Din al-Albānī debating on the Creed of Ashā'irah. He said, Shaykh 'Abdul Fattah was calm and civilized in his manners while Nāsir al-Din al-Albānī was haughty and arrogant. Zuhair ash-Shāwīsh was also supporting his Shaykh Nāsir al-Din al-Albānī against Shaykh 'Abdul Fattāh. Qardāwī said that he intervened to soften the debate but it turned out to be a hot debate between him and Shaykh 'Abdul Fattah on one side and Nāsir al-Din al-Albānī and his student on the other side! (*It should be noted that, Nāsir al-Din al-Albānī and his student Zuhair ash-Shāwīsh also later on parted and quarrelled with each other, as mentioned by Nāsir al-Din al-Albānī himself in the introduction of the later edition of his Book: 'Sifatu Salātun Nabiy') When Shaykh Ramadan al-Būtī defeated Albānī in a debate in Damascus, during that period the former wife of Nāsir al-Albānī approached Shaykh Būtī to tell him the faults of her former husband. Shaykh Būtī turned her away saying our dispute is objective and academic, not personal. Look at the character and manners of our noble Shuyūkh and the character of Albānī who is the spiritual mentor of countries like Saudi Arabia and Qatar today. If Imām al-Bukhārī was alive today, he would've instantly deemed him unfit to narrate and unreliable! When the mentor of these countries is like this, how would you expect his disciples to be any different? A plausible explanation for the current materialistic condition of these countries is the ideology (Wahhabism) which has been adopted by these countries that has reduced the religion to nihilistic rules without deeper significance and spirituality and hence we are observing the most rapidly secularisation and liberalisation of the Holy Lands. What do you think of the above, I just read it somewhere, do you think its false?
Amazing. Mashallah. You explained it very well. As someone who has studied for 8 years under scholars who do infect have their chain (Sanad) as mentioned in the video, you have explained this topic very well, and have emphasised the right points. Keep going!
I just discovered your channel today by chance. I watched the video in which you try the routine of The Prophet PBUH. And trust me it inspired me. I really like the work you are doing. I Appreciate it👍. May Allah SWT grant us all hidayah and show is the right path.
Most of the Hadiths were written by Persian authors. If It is not in accordance with Quran, it is just a narrative not even can be a hadith because Prophet Muhammed doesn’t say anything against Quran. Many fake slandering Hadiths have been written by persians after more than 200 years passed Prophet Muhammad’s (pbuh) death. Many of them contradicts Quran and slander about the Prophet. A person named Abu Dawud (Persian) has many contradictory hadiths. Hadiths must be filtered through Quran. Persians are not Arabs. In addition, Founder of Shia religion is Yemeni/persian jew.
The point of the video is not to discourage people from gaining knowledge. You need to learn the science of hadith. However this also shows why Hadith are not jokes. People can't just deny the extent of knowledge the hadith of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ provide.
As a Syrian Muslim that fled to sweden from the war, this video is very helpful and even inspirational, because sweden is very secular and you dont get the chance ro get more knowledge about our beautiful deen without consequences.
@@user-pz7mg9sx5r That's the problem. They say that they are secular, but at the same time have the cross on their flag and call themselves Cristian. But when someone with other beliefs ESPECIALLY Islam is in Sweden, it's suddenly not accepted and we get called terrorists :)
الله يعينك، طلعت على مصر و درست بالأزهر و بالاول كنت قول يا نيالهم يلي طلعلهم ينزحو لاوروبا، هلق بفهم ليش صرفها الله عننا، اثبت اخي الله يقويك و يثبت انجالك.
@@BasseC05 well... Why do you think that is? These claims didn't grow out of nowhere. The other issue here is that it appears that you are confusing secular government/society with the cultural heritage of a place. Christianity has had a huge cultural impact on Sweden for centuries at this point. It's like Turkey being a secular state BUT they have the crescent and star on their flag.
I ever had habbit to read Shahih Bukhari Muslim by my self everyday, lol. At the beginning I felt great, my iman boost up, but eventually i'm confused and even doubts start to grow. After that I realize that was a mistake, Islamic ruling not easy to judge its haram and just put the hadits like many Ummah did nowadays. Even more, I have more repect for the scholars of Islam, even they have different opinion from what I belief.
On a semi-related subject, Some Saliheen recommend reading the Saheeh Al-Bukhari during tough dark times. It's still the spoken words of the Messenger of God, sayiduna Muhammad (peace be upon him). So, maybe there's more to it, as you said yourself. Just saying😊
Much important and needed video nowadays young people do the same thing that they start directly drawing their own conclusions from Al Quran and books and spread wrong information thus creating confusion and controversies and there are higher chances that they get misled and deviate May Allah Almighty guide us to learn with a right approach
No i disagree even if you are not a student of knowledge or a scholor you should be abel to read books of hadith because the words of the prophet are clear and the grading of the hadith is already done so no problem
@@zak29488 And that's how many "misguided scholors" controlled the masses for a long time, look at countries like pakistan,india and bangladesh where most people are ignorent of the basics of islam and rely completely upon their "scholor" or "maulana" to such a state that most cannot even perfrom a simple prayer of jumah or salatul janazah and do you know why ? because they are very ignorent of the deen and think if you want to learn the deen then you must dedicate atleast 2-3 years in a "madrasah" (which is basically to make you a hardcore hanafi dismissing all the sahih hadith) And this has led to alot of shirk and innovations because "muslims" there are like sheeps led where-ever their "maulana" takes them and they are (like this video) strongly adviced against reading books of hadith lest they get funny ideas (get the actual truth of islam which will stop the money and "donations" reaching into the pocket of the "maulana")
I don't know why everyone is saying that this guy is saying don't read hadith he didn't say that, he only said that don't give fatwas on reading hadith.
9:122 When the believers mobilize, not all of them shall do so. A few from each group shall mobilize by devoting their time to studying the religion. Thus, they can pass the knowledge on to their people when they return, that they may remain religiously informed. This ayah is clearly not speaking about schollars and being a sheep that follows them blindly. Think with your big head Allah gave you for a reason. Quran alone is enough.
So your saying many people will have different opinions and mindsets on the teachings from the Quran and each of us should believe what we think is right?
@@astronoman008 Well yes because everyone has his unique experience and unique life. I will take one lesson from the Quran that fits me, you will take another one. Quran doesn't have any contradictions and whatever you understand from it is reasonable as long as you don't let outside determine your understanding. As long as you aren't spoonfed ideas from the "schollars" that have no basis in the Quran.
@@mohammedalsaeedd4:10 do you mean taking knowledge from the Salafi scholars or sufis with their fabricated chains and innovated polytheist tareeqahs? You should've made a separate video explaining Usul Al-Fiqh. Because it sounds as if you're inviting to sufi baatiniyyah (secret knowledge only known through innovated sufi tareeqahs and their grave worshipping, magician maulanas), or to be a Muqallid. Trimming the beard is not allowed in any Madhab.
@@mohammedalsaeedd You should explain Usul Al-Fiqh and those mantiq terms and make it into separate videos with illustrations as you seem knowledgeanle in it, and people are in need of knowing it. But as for this video, it comes out as anti-Ahlul Hadith and being a Muqallid (blind follower) to a specific Madhab and that the Salafi scholars and their rulings on the beard, eyebrows and pictures are incorrect. And that they have no clue about Usul Al-Fiqh. The video has a similar tune as the sufis. Abu Hanifah, Maalik, Ash-Shaafi'I and Ahmad رحمهم الله all said that if a Saheeh Hadith comes to me, then that is my Madh-hab.
@@Ibn_Abdulaziz I agree with you brother. This guy seems like a blind follower of shafi fiqh. He is bought and sold to the false concept. Message of this youtube video is extremely against independent study.
@@manav____ but independent study will only lead u astray, I mean sure u can gather some rulings from basic hadiths that need no explanation like the famous hadith about music, but just depending on urself and just sitting there reading sahih al-bukhari without the guidance of AT LEAST A STUDENT of knowledge, let alone a SCHOLAR, yeah people will definitely not gain proper knowledge if they study by themselves
Most of the Hadiths were written by Persian authors. If It is not in accordance with Quran, it is just a narrative not even can be a hadith because Prophet Muhammed doesn’t say anything against Quran. Many fake slandering Hadiths have been written by persians after more than 200 years passed Prophet Muhammad’s (pbuh) death. Many of them contradicts Quran and slander about the Prophet. A person named Abu Dawud (Persian) has many contradictory hadiths. Hadiths must be filtered through Quran. Persians are not Arabs. In addition, Founder of Shia religion is Yemeni/persian jew.
@@Erol-Oztrkbrother there is chains of Hadith which have a rigorous requirement such as number of Hadith narrated, is he a liar, how good is there memory, do they contradict eachother who did they hear it from, this is just simplification but there’s chains up to the Sahabah and then the Prophet PBUH. Also how can you understand the Quran without Hadith, explain Surah Tawbah not using Bismillah without understanding of the seerah or Surah Masad and the punishment of Abu Lahab, who’s he if you don’t know Hadith? This is just touching the surface…
Because he's a fool who thinks that you won't get any knowledge (or very little at best) from reading thousands of hadiths that have been authenticated by Imam al-Bukhari from the prophet SalAllahu alayhi wasallam.
Nonsense. Isn't that insulting people's intelligence? Do you have a scholar around all the time to answer your questions? Many hadith are pretty self explanatory.
@petboy5839 *Turns out many people misinterpreted what I was trying to say in this reply, I clarified it below* You just ignored the entire video. We SHOULD read hadith, but not make decisions like "this is haram and that is halal" based on literally ourselves who aren't even Huaffaz of Qur'an let alone be as knowledgeable as the scholars.
@@flint8173 I know what I memorized are authentic hadiths....why can't I quote hadiths saying what's haram or halal? If the hadith says music is prohibited, why can't I tell someone that music is prohibited? As long as the hadith is authentic then quoting shouldn't be an issue. Just make sure to give them the reference.
@petboy5839 ya bro, you're right but matters requiring research and if there are some conflicting hadiths then scholars are supposed to derive rulings when you know a ruling that is clear in the hadith you can quote it no problem
This is my first video from you brother, just subscribed, it was very knowledgeable yet short you made me think about a lot and that The Whole islam isn’t something easy to study, may Allah bless you 🤍
Exactly why Usul Fiqh is *very very* important. It bothers me everytime I mention a complex ruling, they ask for reference from the Quran/Sunnah without having any knowledge on how to interpret or extract rulings from it, nor understanding anything from the maqasid of the syariah. People think that the scholars just copy/paste rulings from textbooks without any sort of intellect or analogy. What a sad time we live in 😔
Brother, Excellent Explanation you showed the laymen their actual place on hadiths and through their so called "ruling" they not only become themselves astray but make others go astray too. May allah subhana huwa tallah give us proper understanding of deen. Ameen
@@mohammedalsaeedd Ameen Brother!!! Keep making these types of videos! I would love that you become a scholar of islam too. Ameen. My prayers are with you!!!
The point of the video: Hadith on its own is just a narration of something the prophet said or did. Understanding it and translating it into rulings or jurisprudence is a more complex process where elements of language, usul el fiqh and hadith verification come into play. Most regular people should avoid reading the hadith on their own. Without the guidance of a scholar, they’ll be lost and fall into traps of confusion and contradiction.
I have one question: Why do the scholars/muhaditheen always ignore the more important question (which should be the very first question): *Does The Hadith Contradict The Quran?* if Yes, Throw it, If No, then proceed with its authenticity/context questions.
To make a ruling from even one Hadith you must know the whole Noble Quran and hundreds of thousands of Hadith with their isnad and also context of all verses and Hadith because everything is related to one another. Thank you for this great explanation.
If there was an app regarding this. Having a hadith and underneath all these details..it would have been very helpful. Muslim developers/entrepreneurs should work in this field. So much of scholarly knowledge, with the help of technology, can be made accessible to all Muslims❤
Asalamu alaikum Jazakallah ul khaira kaseera An Ahle Sunnah watching you from KASHMIR Masha allah Love Arabic As saraf an nahaw etc etc May Allah Almighty guide us all salloo alal habeeb wa sallalahu ta aalaa alaa MUHAMMAD salllalahu alaihi wasallam Asalamu alaikum
SubhanAllah brother thanks for humbling us i pray i can learn everything you’ve mentioned and be one from the groups that study islam please pray for me🤲
Don't listen to this fool akhi. Read Sahih al Bukhari you will benefit from the words of the Prophet salAllahu alayhi wasallam and may Allah silence those who say otherwise or guide them. Just don't pass fatawah and write down any questions you have and take them to a scholar. May Allah bless you and allow you to benefit.
@@user-ze9tj9yj4t I am sorry but you must learn from a scholar, because you may not understand the same meaning in the same sense, we must know the background of why it was said and what was the scenario it was told on. People might be led astray if we use our own understanding of the Hadith, than what it actually means.
@@anoblivion1751 Brother, my teacher who has a Masters from the school of Hadith in Madinah and studied there for over 10 years and he specifically refuted this claim that laymen shouldn’t read Sahih alBukhari. His name is Mufti Muhammad ibn Muneer on the channels Hadith Disciple/Mufti Q&A. He said just simply write down questions you may have and put them to your trusted teacher. Furthermore, as I said before, people should generally not give fatwah or even open their mouths at all about the religion until they have the required knowledge. You know this concept is actually found in Sahih alBukhari itself, in the chapter “Knowledge is before speech and action” the Imam explains how we should not speak or act before we have the appropriate knowledge first. This collection of hadith is filled with heart softeners and reminders about pillars of Imaan which anyone can benefit from.
Subahallah and while watching this i thought of people who only go by the Quran and rejects hadiths. Like people have contributed their lives just to know maybe 1 ruling and these people are not just ordinary people but closest the prophet the first 3 generations. Unfortunately people don't acknowledge the fact. May Allah keep us firm in his religion ❤
I know this isn't the point of the video but does the last part mean that its allowed for a woman to pluck her eyebrows according to the hanafi fiqh if she's doing it for her husband? I'm confused because I always thought this practice was clearly haram.
Thank you!!! You need so many more views for this. These hadith collection are NOT for laymen!!! "The hadith are misguidance except for the scholars" - Imam Malik RA
Thanks for sharing and clarifying further how the Hadith content is not the word of God 😊 Therefore humans are not obligated to follow it strictly. As for those imams and school of thoughts... That has made the religion of Islam even more complicated.
Sahih Bukhari is very authentic, we need to pray nd appreciate the author, your video could create doubt in d heart of innocent young muslims nd end up depriving them of the immense benefits in buhkari.
He like any other youtuber used de clickbait for more views.....how can anyone ask people not2 READ !! asking not2 read in itself is fitan.....donno wat really he is up2 though by asking people not2 read ....
He's saying that u shouldn't study Bukhari by urself thinking this is good, not saying u should ignore it, but if u decide to learn Sahih al-bukhari by urself without a scholar then yeah ur in real danger because some of these hadiths r really hard to understand by urself
@@SuperSonic-9999then say so. Dont study without a teacher - this is the Deen ya Ikhwa, not a time for a tiktok title. We all answer for our actions wallahualam
Then read first the more authentic book than Sahih Bukhari, i.e. the Quran. Then when you read Al-Bukhari you will know where things don't align, i.e. contradict the Quran or dubious or not related to Deen etc... However, to understand and follow Deen, you only need two things: Quran and Sunnah. The Sunnah does not rely on Sahih-Al-Bukhari, it is passed on through generations as known rituals.
SubhaanAllah your content is amazing and we need more of this🙏❤️. Is there a website or source where you compare the different scholars' (specifically the 4 schools of thought's) perspectives/فتاوى/rulings etc.
Thank you so much for your wonderful comment! I’m not aware of the existence of such a website. Sometimes, however, a scholar may be aware of what the other schools have said regarding a matter. It is not common however because each scholar is a master of their school.
There are still numerous ahadith that are literally clear, for example to learn duas. According to your logic, you shouldn't read the Quran because it's easy to misinterpret it. Solution: you look at Hadith explanations where they are really difficult to understand.
If you want to learn D'ua’ from Hadiths, then there is a very famous book that compiles such Hadiths in an easy way for laymen to read, that is, حصن المسلم, or the Fortress of the Muslim. The point of the video is that you shouldn't derive rulings from a Hadith without scholarly supervision, even if the Hadith is, to you, clear. Al-Qayrawani reported that Sufyan ibn ‘Uyaynah رحمه الله said: “The Hadith cause misguidance, except for the fuqahaa'.” (1/118 الجامع في السنن والآداب والمغازي والتاريخ) Ibn Abi Zayd al-Qayrawani who reported this saying said: "He (Sufyan) intends that people might take something in its apparent meaning when, in fact, it is interpreted in the light of another hadith or some evidence which remains hidden to them; or it may consist in discarded evidence due to some other (abrogating) evidence. None can meet the responsibility of knowing this except those who deepened their learning and obtained jurisprudence (fiqh)."
@@mohammedyasser1310 That's not what he said in the video though. He said 'reading sahih al-bukhari cover to cover, you won't benefit, or if you do it'll be very little'. This can constitute kufr. Sahih al-Bukhari doesn't just contain hadiths in fiqh, it contains hadiths about the virtue of seeking knowledge, imaan, aqidah, heart-softeners and more. Even if it is in fiqh, you don't have to derive rulings from it. Rather it can be a gateway for you to research what the scholars say about this issue and continue following the rulings you knew before.
@@user-ze9tj9yj4t How can what he said constitute Kufr? That is a very grave accusation you are making. Again, there are books written about all the sciences of Shari'ah, read those, since they contain both the evidence and delve deep into how they came to a specific conclusion. Just reading the Hadiths may bring more harm than good, for the reasons stated above and in the video.
Because Sahih alBukhari is filled with the speech of the Prophet salAllahu alayhi wasallam in all matters, so to say you won't benefit from it is saying that the prophet salAllahu alayhi wasallam's speech is not beneficial. There is a difference between accidentally making a statement which could be considered as kufr, and being a kafir, which the maker of the video is not (he's clearly a Muslim). The point I'm making is he needs to fear Allah before he talks about the religion and the most authentic book of hadith - which is revelation from Allah.@@mohammedyasser1310
I would advise reading bukhari as a source of spirituality instead of as a source of deriving rulings, there are many chapters you can benefit from in this regard like the chapters of manners or the chapter of the softness of the heart or virtue of prophets and virtues of the companions
I recently acquired a summarized version of Sahih al-Bukhari on November 24th and am eager to commence memorization starting next week. Truly, finding this video is a divine guidance from Allah, subhanu wa ta'ala. Jazakallahu Khairan brother.
Whether you want to memorise it or not, don't ever forbid yourself from benefitting from the words of the prophet salAllahu alayhi wasallam regardless of what any ignorant person on youtube says. If you have any questions write them down, and don't come up with fiqh rulings yourself, simple as that.
salaam my brother, I mean this in all respect, and more so interesting discussion. I do like what you are saying, that just anyone should not be stating what a ruling should be, as this like much disinformation in the world is many times due to lack of research and understanding. But one feeling I was getting from the video is that I was almost being told I could not become an scholar of Hadith, or gain thorough and proper understanding of the proofing process. I just don't want viewers to be detracted from learning and educating themselves, but rather just be more conscious of their understanding especially when attempting to inform others on particular rulings. All in all great work my brother, Alhumdulillah
Wa Alaikum Al Salam Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuh. Great point. I also felt like it was a little bit discouraging to be honest. Despite this, I think that the way he presented it will have more benefit than harm as, in our current time, people that don't even know the basic principles of Islam are giving their own rulings. This has become very common and his approach to making this video will show them very clearly that they are not even close to that level yet. In Sha Allah it will be for the better.
Tbh personally I didn't take it that way. Rather the delving into specific details can make us appreciate the efforts of the ulema even further. That doesn't we cannot also study hadith as well under scholars, if there's a will there's a way...
@@tahsintahsinuzzaman781 inshallah yes brother , lol that is basicially what i said. Also, The fact that YOU personally did not take it that way Does not mean the average person will see the same as yourself.
Asalamu Alaikom Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuh. Alluhama Barik brother. I just ran across this video and watched a couple of other videos and I want to encourage you to keep going. Your videos are very simple yet very information packed and they cover massive topics. May Allah reward you and help you in becoming a source of light for this Ummah. Also, I know you probably already know this, but make sure to keep purifying and renewing your intention so you don't miss out on the massive reward that is waiting for you In Sha Allah. Jazak Allah Khairan Akhi.
May Allah bless you for your wonderful comment. I truly thank you so much. The matter of the intention is of utmost importance and sensitivty to me. None of the views or likes or anything are worth it if my deed is not done for Allah SWT. In fact, there are ahadith from the Prophet PBUH warning us from the danger of perfoming deeds for the others to praise us. I will keep your words in mind along with my own reminders. Thank you again!🤍
Brother the video is not pushing people away from the way of the messenger of Allah, rather it is pushing people away from creating innovations in our faith and following the messenger of Allah in the wrong way. @@mahmoudelbakkouch2709
That's a very educative video. Also the pacing was great. Keep doing video like this. Online is for younger people and they would love video like these.
This are not good reasons to tell people to stop reading al bukhari it is still the best source of ahadith and it will bring value to everyone reading it
With all due respect, I disagree. It could do bring far more damage than benefit to the non-scholar who reads it. Especially once they encounter hadiths that contradict each other. That could create doubts and often does. Don't forget you still have an enemy trying to push you away from your religion. Shaytaan will take every chance to destroy you.
@@rajinhossain5742 Idk, but if ur lucky u might find a scholar and learn, maybe there could be 1 in ur masjid or someplace nearby, but even for me I don't have access to any scholars, or at least I didn't search my area yet
Salam Alaikum Brother, I was just thinking about how you have remembered this much long script and these much points😄 By the way, may Allah Help you and give you more beneficial knowledge and increase your knowledge. Ameen ya Rabb
Alaikum Assalam brother. Thank you for your wonderful comment. I must admit I have it by my side in case I forget or if I want to check the wording🤪. Thanks again for your comment. Ameen🤍
i just re-dive deep into islamic knowledge couple months ago. I used to school on islamic boarding school as High School learning nahwu and shorof, fiqh, tafseer, hadith, mustholah-hadith. For a decade (in Hijry calendar) i used to think I know enough, went astray, preach and judge other people online, went sick for a year, struggling to get of dunya, but alhamdulillah still going back to Allah. Alhamdulillah i started opening online lesson from scholar while opening the book (Tafseer jalalayn) and attending offline majlis-'ilm to scholar with books that I had and i didn't. Allah had guided me back to righteous peoplepath of knwoledge and even started memorizing Quran. I'm not an Arab and I did 2 pages memorization a day. We can do it Insya Allah. Keep us youngin's, adult, elder into your doa every day to back and Istiqamah in this path. 🙏🙏🙏 Allahummaghfir warham ummata sayyidina Muhammad Allahummaj'alna ummata sayyidina Muhammad shallallahu alaihi wasallam. 🙏 Insya Allah we will make Our Beloved Prophet pbuh. proud of us yawmal qiyamah. Keep learning, sweating, and tired until it doesn't even matter. Insya Allah we can sit with Anbiya, Awliya', Scholars, Shaleheen yawmal qiyamah. Amiin.
Alhamdulillah thank you brother.. i’m always wondering about this. This helps me to get an understanding as to why lay man can’t just simply read the Hadith and interpret it by themselves
Salamu Alaykum Akhi, I recentky discovered channel and may Allah continue to bless you and your family and keep you consistent in uploading beneficial content onto UA-cam. I HAVE to know one thing.... What is the name of the nasheed at the end of your videos? I've been trying to find it for some time but to no avail. Jazakhallah Khair for spreading the khair
This so underrated i immediately subscribed by the quality and clarification Masha Allah Allahumma Barik 🎉❤ I never bought sahih bhkhari (I read online)but i want to purchase it can u recommend there are so many
SubhaanAllah! ☆ The way you beautifully and simply explained it helps so much! JazakAllahu Khairan Brother! InshaAllah, you'll be blessed with more Hikmah always! ♡
Well as you can see there is bias between schools and undoubtedly the chain of transmission had biases too throughout. The work put forth in trying to make sure wrong hadith aren't put in is a lot. But if we can't question the bias of long standing tradition when it seems that something slipped through, then it's wrong to say..." We're above you and don't you ever question!" That's where I call BS
That is why Hadith is a historical record than book of guidance like Quran because first of Allah will not reveal 20 books besides Quran and will not make it so confusing and contraindicatory
Hadith is not contradictory, it literally teaches u so many rulings, some of these rulings aren't even in the Quran, not to mention all the prophecies that came true that were mentioned in hadiths
I always read the " Nurani " in our country it's the hardest but form my childhood I learn that For someone " Nurani " is easy , but for us it's hard . so please don't criticize without any reason
The simple question r which Hadith book qualify with this criteria? Was Quran n Deen incomplete before this Hadith literature was made? n have they not distorted or added things in Quran?
Of course Islam is not purely about rulings; however, they play a very big part in Islam as they teach us how to live according to the rules set by Allah. The goal of this video is not to disregard the other aspects of Islam, but instead, to help people understand that if you are not knowledgeable enough, you can not make your own rulings as this has become a massive issue in our times.
wrong, u do'nt need to be a schooler to understand that in sahih Bukhari all hadith are sahih, unless sheikh has written a side note, that tells otherwise, this man here is making a big deal out of nothing, resulting in telling you not to reed these books , coz you are not a schooler , all wrong.
I think the title is a bit misleading, isn’t the title “STOP reading Sahih Al-Bukhari before knowing this” a better title than the current one. And i liked the video a lot, it opened my eyes towards an important issue of inventing things from our head yet we don’t have the proper knowledge which can mislead us and others as well. there are scholars through whom we get guided when it comes to the rules and hadiths of our religion, Jazakallahu Khayra
@@Andalusic Quran alone doesn't function without hadith, because hadiths explain the Quran itself, many hadiths have prophecies that came true today, not to mention they're proven to be the words of our prophet Mohamed صلى الله عليه وسلم
I have a question for you about a hadith. Sahih al-Bukhari 5779 Narrated Sa`d: I heard Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) saying, "Whoever takes seven 'Ajwa dates in the morning will not be effected by magic or poison on that day." There is a challenge from Imam Tawhidi that if this verse is authentic, a Sunni believer should eat dates and drink a cup of kerosene. My question is: Based on all these criteria, what is the reason (besides not dying or ending up in the hospital) not to do this challenge?
Imam Tawhidi? You mean that zionist dog? He's neither Imam nor a muslim, The claim he made about being an Imam from Australian Imam council is false and he is a open war monger. Now let's get back to your claim, Problem with you people is that you are talking them literally, The hadith can be applied same as the term an apple a day keeps doctor away, But does that mean doctors literally stay away from you? No, That statment implies the nutritional value in the apple keeps you healthy so that you don't need to go to a doctor for health issues. Same applies for the hadith and as for the benefits search "Protective effects of Ajwa date extract against tissue damage induced by acute diclofenac toxicity" article in Pubmed.
@@dailydoseofexistence7159 Well, we should talk about Christianity because it is true and we shouldn't waste our time on false religions, but you have to answer my question first. If this hadith is authentic and your explanation is true, then what stops you from doing this challenge?
But how do we know that which which school is right there are telling all the possibilities isn't it more confusing, i think its probably mention in other hadiths which will clarify that if it is haram or not , (plucking of the eyebrows )
Incredible, my respect for the scholars just skyrocketed
Most of the Hadiths were written by Persian authors. If It is not in accordance with Quran, it is just a narrative not even can be a hadith because Prophet Muhammed doesn’t say anything against Quran. Many fake slandering Hadiths have been written by persians after more than 200 years passed Prophet Muhammad’s (pbuh) death. Many of them contradicts Quran and slander about the Prophet. A person named Abu Dawud (Persian) has many contradictory hadiths. Hadiths must be filtered through Quran. Persians are not Arabs. In addition, Founder of Shia religion is Yemeni/persian jew.
@@Erol-Oztrk
Why should the ethnicity of the scholars make a difference to their trustworthiness? Remember that Iran only became Shia relatively recently 400 years ago.
The reporters or collectors of hadiths lying or spreading falsehood has no correlation with them being Arab, Persian, subcontinent, etc. A large majority of the muhhaditheen were Persian and they were not corrupt
@Erol-Oztrk They were muslims werent they? Thats what matters.
@@mobeenkhan824400? The shiittification of Iran happened in less than 100 years ago when Laanatullah Kwhoremeini came in the scene.
I am always trying to explain these nuances to people. Our deen is well, well-thought out and preserved ma sha Allah. Thank you for taking the time to make a well-made video on this topic. The graphics, timings, presentation and clear audio are appreciated and important. Now I can just share this video. Barak Allahu fik.
Barak Allahu feek. I study with one of the closest students of Al Sheikh Al Albani in Egypt.
And I wanted to mention a few thing to the dear brothers and sisters.
1. Don't disregard memorization, even if not a scholar. How often do you meet a brother/sister who needs Naseeha or a small reminder? Every day probably. Nobody is obliged to take your word without any evidence. But if you know the strongest scholarly ruling AND the evidence, you will see that hearts get touched and moved by the word of Allah and his messenger ﷺ.
2. Start with the memorization of the Quran and don't let other things disturb you from it. Even Ahadith or Fiqh courses. If you know how to pray and fast and do your obligations and have somebody to ask if you don't know you are good to go. Every ill within yourself is fixed by the Quran. You could memorize the Quran in 2-3 years while working and studying, but if you mix in 3-4 courses on fiqh and seerah and other matters, this number fastly extends to 5, 10, 15, 20 years or worse: NEVER.
As a Non-Arab you fall under the ruling of a child: You can memorize the Quran first, and then draw the rulings of it and deepen your understanding. After memorization of the Quran it is not uncommon to finish the Quran once a week. That means when you read tafseer of any ayah, you will come by that Aya once a week, revise it and ponder upon it.
But if you learn tafseer and never read the Aya, you will forget it and not act upon it probably.
Please, I urge you: Give your best to memorize the Quran.
I ask Allah to make the Quran the light of our chests, and the fix for our wrongs and our daily companion. May Allah accept from you and me.
Barak Allahu feekum
May you be rewarded for all muslims who are motivated to memorise the Quran after reading your comment. SubhanAllah
This is amazing سبحان الله. I want to memorize the Quran, but I sometimes struggle with setting up/maintaining good pacing. إن شاء الله I'll be moving to university in a few months and I want to know what you'd think a good pace or method of memorization would fit best. I am determined to memorize the Quran in the next few years, إن شاء الله may Allah reward you immensely for your comment and actions.
@@MrRadon54
look at the ''tikrar method half page''
@@MrRadon54If you have any possibility to do the following do it, sit after Fajr and revise a juz everyday and then start learning the new page or line or two lines. Whatever you are able to memorize.
The habit of revision is what will keep you on track. Because most people who stop memorizing, stop because they already memorized something and then they forgot and that demotivates them.
But it is normal to forget, prioritize Revision insha Allah.
And memorize something new everyday. Even if it is 2 ayat, one line, or half a page.
That way you will finish, sooner or later إن شاء الله
May Allah grant you success in Dunya and Akhira
@@Batu-sn8lbThe late Shaykh Qardāwī said in an interview that:
After his Book 'Fiqh uz-Zakāt' was abridged without his permission by the Salafi publisher Zuhair ash-Shāwīsh (as usual), he went to Beirut to meet him.
He said, that at the house of the publisher, he found the Sunni Ash'arī Muhaddith Shaykh 'Abdul Fattah Abū Ghuddah and the Salafi Shaykh Näsir al-Din al-Albānī debating on the Creed of Ashā'irah.
He said, Shaykh 'Abdul Fattah was calm and civilized in his manners while Nāsir al-Din al-Albānī was haughty and arrogant. Zuhair ash-Shāwīsh was also supporting his Shaykh Nāsir al-Din al-Albānī against Shaykh 'Abdul Fattāh.
Qardāwī said that he intervened to soften the debate but it turned out to be a hot debate between him and Shaykh 'Abdul Fattah on one side and Nāsir al-Din al-Albānī and his student on the other side!
(*It should be noted that, Nāsir al-Din al-Albānī and his student Zuhair ash-Shāwīsh also later on parted and quarrelled with each other, as mentioned by Nāsir al-Din al-Albānī himself in the introduction of the later edition of his Book: 'Sifatu Salātun Nabiy')
When Shaykh Ramadan al-Būtī defeated Albānī in a debate in Damascus, during that period the former wife of Nāsir al-Albānī approached Shaykh Būtī to tell him the faults of her former husband. Shaykh Būtī turned her away saying our dispute is objective and academic, not personal.
Look at the character and manners of our noble Shuyūkh and the character of Albānī who is the spiritual mentor of countries like Saudi Arabia and Qatar today. If Imām al-Bukhārī was alive today, he would've instantly deemed him unfit to narrate and unreliable! When the mentor of these countries is like this, how would you expect his disciples to be any different? A plausible explanation for the current materialistic condition of these countries is the ideology (Wahhabism) which has been adopted by these countries that has reduced the religion to nihilistic rules without deeper significance and spirituality and hence we are observing the most rapidly secularisation and liberalisation of the Holy Lands.
What do you think of the above, I just read it somewhere, do you think its false?
Underrated video, deserves more views and recognition inshallah
Finally someone made a video about it. Thanks man,it was an easing explanation.
Of course brother🙏🏽
Amazing. Mashallah. You explained it very well. As someone who has studied for 8 years under scholars who do infect have their chain (Sanad) as mentioned in the video, you have explained this topic very well, and have emphasised the right points. Keep going!
8 years Mashallah! Thank you so much for your comment:) May Allah keep us both steadfast🤍🤲🏽
I just discovered your channel today by chance. I watched the video in which you try the routine of The Prophet PBUH. And trust me it inspired me. I really like the work you are doing. I Appreciate it👍. May Allah SWT grant us all hidayah and show is the right path.
Thank you so much brother! I’m very glad you’re enjoying it. May Allah bless you🤍
Most of the Hadiths were written by Persian authors. If It is not in accordance with Quran, it is just a narrative not even can be a hadith because Prophet Muhammed doesn’t say anything against Quran. Many fake slandering Hadiths have been written by persians after more than 200 years passed Prophet Muhammad’s (pbuh) death. Many of them contradicts Quran and slander about the Prophet. A person named Abu Dawud (Persian) has many contradictory hadiths. Hadiths must be filtered through Quran. Persians are not Arabs. In addition, Founder of Shia religion is Yemeni/persian jew.
The point of the video is not to discourage people from gaining knowledge. You need to learn the science of hadith.
However this also shows why Hadith are not jokes. People can't just deny the extent of knowledge the hadith of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ provide.
As a Syrian Muslim that fled to sweden from the war, this video is very helpful and even inspirational, because sweden is very secular and you dont get the chance ro get more knowledge about our beautiful deen without consequences.
If it is secular that means it is open to every religion?
@@user-pz7mg9sx5r That's the problem. They say that they are secular, but at the same time have the cross on their flag and call themselves Cristian. But when someone with other beliefs ESPECIALLY Islam is in Sweden, it's suddenly not accepted and we get called terrorists :)
@@BasseC05 , the irony is that if non Muslims do terrorist acts they will not be considered as terrorist its only the Muslim community 🥲
الله يعينك، طلعت على مصر و درست بالأزهر و بالاول كنت قول يا نيالهم يلي طلعلهم ينزحو لاوروبا، هلق بفهم ليش صرفها الله عننا، اثبت اخي الله يقويك و يثبت انجالك.
@@BasseC05 well... Why do you think that is? These claims didn't grow out of nowhere. The other issue here is that it appears that you are confusing secular government/society with the cultural heritage of a place. Christianity has had a huge cultural impact on Sweden for centuries at this point. It's like Turkey being a secular state BUT they have the crescent and star on their flag.
Wow I just realised this thanks. I remember opening up Sahih Al-Bukhari and being confused. This is the truth about how the scholars are needed.
I ever had habbit to read Shahih Bukhari Muslim by my self everyday, lol. At the beginning I felt great, my iman boost up, but eventually i'm confused and even doubts start to grow. After that I realize that was a mistake, Islamic ruling not easy to judge its haram and just put the hadits like many Ummah did nowadays. Even more, I have more repect for the scholars of Islam, even they have different opinion from what I belief.
On a semi-related subject, Some Saliheen recommend reading the Saheeh Al-Bukhari during tough dark times. It's still the spoken words of the Messenger of God, sayiduna Muhammad (peace be upon him). So, maybe there's more to it, as you said yourself. Just saying😊
Great channel, will follow with immense interest. May Allah grant us understanding of our religion!
Thank you so much Ghufran! I hope you enjoy it:)
Much important and needed video
nowadays young people do the same thing that they start directly drawing their own conclusions from Al Quran and books and spread wrong information thus creating confusion and controversies and there are higher chances that they get misled and deviate
May Allah Almighty guide us to learn with a right approach
No i disagree even if you are not a student of knowledge or a scholor you should be abel to read books of hadith because the words of the prophet are clear and the grading of the hadith is already done so no problem
Yes but it’s important to get the right knowledge from it which you can’t attain by yourself so study under a scholar.
@@zak29488 And that's how many "misguided scholors" controlled the masses for a long time, look at countries like pakistan,india and bangladesh where most people are ignorent of the basics of islam and rely completely upon their "scholor" or "maulana" to such a state that most cannot even perfrom a simple prayer of jumah or salatul janazah and do you know why ? because they are very ignorent of the deen and think if you want to learn the deen then you must dedicate atleast 2-3 years in a "madrasah" (which is basically to make you a hardcore hanafi dismissing all the sahih hadith) And this has led to alot of shirk and innovations because "muslims" there are like sheeps led where-ever their "maulana" takes them and they are (like this video) strongly adviced against reading books of hadith lest they get funny ideas (get the actual truth of islam which will stop the money and "donations" reaching into the pocket of the "maulana")
@@ayanmaqsood4880 there are no daaif hadith in Al Bukhari and Muslim and they are arranged in chapters which makes it much easier for the reader
I don't know why everyone is saying that this guy is saying don't read hadith he didn't say that, he only said that don't give fatwas on reading hadith.
@@tahamunawar287okay, dont read quran then, because you must study under scholar, because the quran is not clear
9:122 When the believers mobilize, not all of them shall do so. A few from each group shall mobilize by devoting their time to studying the religion. Thus, they can pass the knowledge on to their people when they return, that they may remain religiously informed.
This ayah is clearly not speaking about schollars and being a sheep that follows them blindly. Think with your big head Allah gave you for a reason. Quran alone is enough.
So your saying many people will have different opinions and mindsets on the teachings from the Quran and each of us should believe what we think is right?
@@astronoman008 are you saying that only the schollars can feed you what they think Quran says?
@@dusanspasojevic123 I was asking not being inquisitive
@@astronoman008 Well yes because everyone has his unique experience and unique life. I will take one lesson from the Quran that fits me, you will take another one. Quran doesn't have any contradictions and whatever you understand from it is reasonable as long as you don't let outside determine your understanding. As long as you aren't spoonfed ideas from the "schollars" that have no basis in the Quran.
Great work brother and this is a huge topic/content that you just simplified. May ALLAH Bless you 😇
May Allah bless you too! Thank you so much❤️
@@mohammedalsaeedd4:10 do you mean taking knowledge from the Salafi scholars or sufis with their fabricated chains and innovated polytheist tareeqahs?
You should've made a separate video explaining Usul Al-Fiqh. Because it sounds as if you're inviting to sufi baatiniyyah (secret knowledge only known through innovated sufi tareeqahs and their grave worshipping, magician maulanas), or to be a Muqallid. Trimming the beard is not allowed in any Madhab.
@@mohammedalsaeedd You should explain Usul Al-Fiqh and those mantiq terms and make it into separate videos with illustrations as you seem knowledgeanle in it, and people are in need of knowing it.
But as for this video, it comes out as anti-Ahlul Hadith and being a Muqallid (blind follower) to a specific Madhab and that the Salafi scholars and their rulings on the beard, eyebrows and pictures are incorrect. And that they have no clue about Usul Al-Fiqh. The video has a similar tune as the sufis.
Abu Hanifah, Maalik, Ash-Shaafi'I and Ahmad رحمهم الله all said that if a Saheeh Hadith comes to me, then that is my Madh-hab.
@@Ibn_Abdulaziz I agree with you brother. This guy seems like a blind follower of shafi fiqh. He is bought and sold to the false concept. Message of this youtube video is extremely against independent study.
@@manav____
but independent study will only lead u astray, I mean sure u can gather some rulings from basic hadiths that need no explanation like the famous hadith about music, but just depending on urself and just sitting there reading sahih al-bukhari without the guidance of AT LEAST A STUDENT of knowledge, let alone a SCHOLAR, yeah people will definitely not gain proper knowledge if they study by themselves
The visual diagrams are so helpful, very high quality video brother
They took a long time to edit so I'm glad you enjoyed them😂
This is why you should ask to scholars recording some issue.
Appreciated for your effort you gained a new subscriber ❤.
Most of the Hadiths were written by Persian authors. If It is not in accordance with Quran, it is just a narrative not even can be a hadith because Prophet Muhammed doesn’t say anything against Quran. Many fake slandering Hadiths have been written by persians after more than 200 years passed Prophet Muhammad’s (pbuh) death. Many of them contradicts Quran and slander about the Prophet. A person named Abu Dawud (Persian) has many contradictory hadiths. Hadiths must be filtered through Quran. Persians are not Arabs. In addition, Founder of Shia religion is Yemeni/persian jew.
@@Erol-Oztrkbrother there is chains of Hadith which have a rigorous requirement such as number of Hadith narrated, is he a liar, how good is there memory, do they contradict eachother who did they hear it from, this is just simplification but there’s chains up to the Sahabah and then the Prophet PBUH. Also how can you understand the Quran without Hadith, explain Surah Tawbah not using Bismillah without understanding of the seerah or Surah Masad and the punishment of Abu Lahab, who’s he if you don’t know Hadith? This is just touching the surface…
wanted to watch this vid, but I couldn't do it for more then 22 sec, bruh why would you put music in Islamic videos???
Because he's a fool who thinks that you won't get any knowledge (or very little at best) from reading thousands of hadiths that have been authenticated by Imam al-Bukhari from the prophet SalAllahu alayhi wasallam.
And btw laymen can read bukhari provided they dont derive rulings from them as they are not qualified and that is for scholars
Nonsense. Isn't that insulting people's intelligence? Do you have a scholar around all the time to answer your questions? Many hadith are pretty self explanatory.
@petboy5839
*Turns out many people misinterpreted what I was trying to say in this reply, I clarified it below*
You just ignored the entire video. We SHOULD read hadith, but not make decisions like "this is haram and that is halal" based on literally ourselves who aren't even Huaffaz of Qur'an let alone be as knowledgeable as the scholars.
@@flint8173 I know what I memorized are authentic hadiths....why can't I quote hadiths saying what's haram or halal? If the hadith says music is prohibited, why can't I tell someone that music is prohibited? As long as the hadith is authentic then quoting shouldn't be an issue. Just make sure to give them the reference.
@petboy5839 ya bro, you're right but matters requiring research and if there are some conflicting hadiths then scholars are supposed to derive rulings when you know a ruling that is clear in the hadith you can quote it no problem
@@petboy5839read medical books and do oppressions on people 😂
This is my first video from you brother, just subscribed, it was very knowledgeable yet short you made me think about a lot and that The Whole islam isn’t something easy to study, may Allah bless you 🤍
Exactly why Usul Fiqh is *very very* important. It bothers me everytime I mention a complex ruling, they ask for reference from the Quran/Sunnah without having any knowledge on how to interpret or extract rulings from it, nor understanding anything from the maqasid of the syariah. People think that the scholars just copy/paste rulings from textbooks without any sort of intellect or analogy. What a sad time we live in 😔
jazak ALLAH chair brother. I wish someone made such a video 100 years ago.
Brother, Excellent Explanation you showed the laymen their actual place on hadiths and through their so called "ruling" they not only become themselves astray but make others go astray too.
May allah subhana huwa tallah give us proper understanding of deen. Ameen
This is the danger of speaking without knowledge and May Allah سبحانه وتعالى protect us all from this calamity🤲🏽🤍
@@mohammedalsaeedd Ameen Brother!!! Keep making these types of videos! I would love that you become a scholar of islam too. Ameen.
My prayers are with you!!!
@@mohammedalsaeeddAmeen bro fr 🤲🏾
The point of the video:
Hadith on its own is just a narration of something the prophet said or did. Understanding it and translating it into rulings or jurisprudence is a more complex process where elements of language, usul el fiqh and hadith verification come into play.
Most regular people should avoid reading the hadith on their own. Without the guidance of a scholar, they’ll be lost and fall into traps of confusion and contradiction.
I have one question: Why do the scholars/muhaditheen always ignore the more important question (which should be the very first question): *Does The Hadith Contradict The Quran?* if Yes, Throw it, If No, then proceed with its authenticity/context questions.
Asalamwalaikum and may Allah bless you my brother. Love the delivery, knowledge, and the humor you put into it
I'm very glad you enjoyed it! May Allah bless you too:)
THE THIRD MUSLIM
To make a ruling from even one Hadith you must know the whole Noble Quran and hundreds of thousands of Hadith with their isnad and also context of all verses and Hadith because everything is related to one another. Thank you for this great explanation.
If there was an app regarding this. Having a hadith and underneath all these details..it would have been very helpful. Muslim developers/entrepreneurs should work in this field. So much of scholarly knowledge, with the help of technology, can be made accessible to all Muslims❤
;)
There's a website called Sunnah, it has the narrators' names and whether it's sahih or hasan
Asalamu alaikum
Jazakallah ul khaira kaseera
An Ahle Sunnah watching you from KASHMIR
Masha allah
Love Arabic As saraf an nahaw etc etc
May Allah Almighty guide us all
salloo alal habeeb wa sallalahu ta aalaa alaa MUHAMMAD salllalahu alaihi wasallam
Asalamu alaikum
Felt that the audio was bit fast paced, slow down would be better imo. Also, who is the reciter @ 3:46 ?
SubhanAllah brother thanks for humbling us i pray i can learn everything you’ve mentioned and be one from the groups that study islam please pray for me🤲
Don't listen to this fool akhi. Read Sahih al Bukhari you will benefit from the words of the Prophet salAllahu alayhi wasallam and may Allah silence those who say otherwise or guide them. Just don't pass fatawah and write down any questions you have and take them to a scholar. May Allah bless you and allow you to benefit.
@@user-ze9tj9yj4t I am sorry but you must learn from a scholar, because you may not understand the same meaning in the same sense, we must know the background of why it was said and what was the scenario it was told on. People might be led astray if we use our own understanding of the Hadith, than what it actually means.
@@anoblivion1751 Brother, my teacher who has a Masters from the school of Hadith in Madinah and studied there for over 10 years and he specifically refuted this claim that laymen shouldn’t read Sahih alBukhari. His name is Mufti Muhammad ibn Muneer on the channels Hadith Disciple/Mufti Q&A. He said just simply write down questions you may have and put them to your trusted teacher. Furthermore, as I said before, people should generally not give fatwah or even open their mouths at all about the religion until they have the required knowledge. You know this concept is actually found in Sahih alBukhari itself, in the chapter “Knowledge is before speech and action” the Imam explains how we should not speak or act before we have the appropriate knowledge first. This collection of hadith is filled with heart softeners and reminders about pillars of Imaan which anyone can benefit from.
Subahallah and while watching this i thought of people who only go by the Quran and rejects hadiths.
Like people have contributed their lives just to know maybe 1 ruling and these people are not just ordinary people but closest the prophet the first 3 generations. Unfortunately people don't acknowledge the fact.
May Allah keep us firm in his religion ❤
Mashallah! Incredible work brother!
Amazing video, keep up the good work👍
Scholars are super heroes ❤
CONFIREMED!
I know this isn't the point of the video but does the last part mean that its allowed for a woman to pluck her eyebrows according to the hanafi fiqh if she's doing it for her husband? I'm confused because I always thought this practice was clearly haram.
may Allah bless you brother , eye opening Wallahi
May Allah bless you too!
You earned a sub brother. Thanks a bunch for this info. Huge respeccc to our scholars
Thank you!!! You need so many more views for this. These hadith collection are NOT for laymen!!!
"The hadith are misguidance except for the scholars" - Imam Malik RA
Thank you so much for your comment!🤍
Walikum Salam!
I found your channel today. Thank You for clarification of hadith.,
JazakALLAH.
Thankyouuuuuuuu❤❤❤
For Making a single video for all of it😭😭👌
Thanks for sharing and clarifying further how the Hadith content is not the word of God 😊
Therefore humans are not obligated to follow it strictly. As for those imams and school of thoughts... That has made the religion of Islam even more complicated.
11:1 Alif-Lãm-Ra. ˹This is˺ a Book whose verses are well perfected and then fully explained. ˹It is˺ from the One ˹Who is˺ All-Wise, All-Aware.
To clear it is called sahih "صحيح " al bukhari all hadith are sahih in it almost all scholars agree
Marshallah, may Allah increase you in knowledge in these matters
Sahih Bukhari is very authentic, we need to pray nd appreciate the author, your video could create doubt in d heart of innocent young muslims nd end up depriving them of the immense benefits in buhkari.
He like any other youtuber used de clickbait for more views.....how can anyone ask people not2 READ !! asking not2 read in itself is fitan.....donno wat really he is up2 though by asking people not2 read ....
He’s just saying what the approach should be
He's saying that u shouldn't study Bukhari by urself thinking this is good, not saying u should ignore it, but if u decide to learn Sahih al-bukhari by urself without a scholar then yeah ur in real danger because some of these hadiths r really hard to understand by urself
@@SuperSonic-9999then say so. Dont study without a teacher - this is the Deen ya Ikhwa, not a time for a tiktok title. We all answer for our actions wallahualam
Then read first the more authentic book than Sahih Bukhari, i.e. the Quran. Then when you read Al-Bukhari you will know where things don't align, i.e. contradict the Quran or dubious or not related to Deen etc... However, to understand and follow Deen, you only need two things: Quran and Sunnah. The Sunnah does not rely on Sahih-Al-Bukhari, it is passed on through generations as known rituals.
salam brother, just subbed you.
Your Content is very knowledgeable and informative.
May ALLAH Bless you
so much reliance on scholars and their opinion...
Well, but any hadith in Sahih Al-Bukhari is automatically sahih so you don't need to make any search regarding the validity of the haidths in it
SubhaanAllah your content is amazing and we need more of this🙏❤️. Is there a website or source where you compare the different scholars' (specifically the 4 schools of thought's) perspectives/فتاوى/rulings etc.
Thank you so much for your wonderful comment! I’m not aware of the existence of such a website. Sometimes, however, a scholar may be aware of what the other schools have said regarding a matter. It is not common however because each scholar is a master of their school.
@@mohammedalsaeedd Have you taken a look at seekersguidance?
@@mohammedalsaeedd oh okay. Jazaak Allahu khairan and إن شاء الله ربنا يزد علمنا
Ilm Hadith is no doubt very vast and deep, but does that mean a layman should not read Hadith. A totally wrong conclusion
There are still numerous ahadith that are literally clear, for example to learn duas. According to your logic, you shouldn't read the Quran because it's easy to misinterpret it. Solution: you look at Hadith explanations where they are really difficult to understand.
If you want to learn D'ua’ from Hadiths, then there is a very famous book that compiles such Hadiths in an easy way for laymen to read, that is, حصن المسلم, or the Fortress of the Muslim.
The point of the video is that you shouldn't derive rulings from a Hadith without scholarly supervision, even if the Hadith is, to you, clear.
Al-Qayrawani reported that Sufyan ibn ‘Uyaynah رحمه الله said: “The Hadith cause misguidance, except for the fuqahaa'.” (1/118 الجامع في السنن والآداب والمغازي والتاريخ) Ibn Abi Zayd al-Qayrawani who reported this saying said: "He (Sufyan) intends that people might take something in its apparent meaning when, in fact, it is interpreted in the light of another hadith or some evidence which remains hidden to them; or it may consist in discarded evidence due to some other (abrogating) evidence. None can meet the responsibility of knowing this except those who deepened their learning and obtained jurisprudence (fiqh)."
@@mohammedyasser1310 That's not what he said in the video though. He said 'reading sahih al-bukhari cover to cover, you won't benefit, or if you do it'll be very little'. This can constitute kufr. Sahih al-Bukhari doesn't just contain hadiths in fiqh, it contains hadiths about the virtue of seeking knowledge, imaan, aqidah, heart-softeners and more. Even if it is in fiqh, you don't have to derive rulings from it. Rather it can be a gateway for you to research what the scholars say about this issue and continue following the rulings you knew before.
@@user-ze9tj9yj4t How can what he said constitute Kufr? That is a very grave accusation you are making.
Again, there are books written about all the sciences of Shari'ah, read those, since they contain both the evidence and delve deep into how they came to a specific conclusion.
Just reading the Hadiths may bring more harm than good, for the reasons stated above and in the video.
Because Sahih alBukhari is filled with the speech of the Prophet salAllahu alayhi wasallam in all matters, so to say you won't benefit from it is saying that the prophet salAllahu alayhi wasallam's speech is not beneficial. There is a difference between accidentally making a statement which could be considered as kufr, and being a kafir, which the maker of the video is not (he's clearly a Muslim). The point I'm making is he needs to fear Allah before he talks about the religion and the most authentic book of hadith - which is revelation from Allah.@@mohammedyasser1310
Dont read quran then
I would advise reading bukhari as a source of spirituality instead of as a source of deriving rulings, there are many chapters you can benefit from in this regard like the chapters of manners or the chapter of the softness of the heart or virtue of prophets and virtues of the companions
So complicated I don't know who to trust anymore. If the prophet is still among us, there would be no need for this much complexity.
i cant even defend hadith, i find it weird when the manuscripts come 300 years after muhammad so no point in me beliving in it
👏 thanks for this brother and salam from Bosnia
Of course brother and Alaikum Assalam!
I recently acquired a summarized version of Sahih al-Bukhari on November 24th and am eager to commence memorization starting next week. Truly, finding this video is a divine guidance from Allah, subhanu wa ta'ala.
Jazakallahu Khairan brother.
This video aime to push you away from the messenger of Allah read the hadedth.
Whether you want to memorise it or not, don't ever forbid yourself from benefitting from the words of the prophet salAllahu alayhi wasallam regardless of what any ignorant person on youtube says. If you have any questions write them down, and don't come up with fiqh rulings yourself, simple as that.
salaam my brother, I mean this in all respect, and more so interesting discussion. I do like what you are saying, that just anyone should not be stating what a ruling should be, as this like much disinformation in the world is many times due to lack of research and understanding. But one feeling I was getting from the video is that I was almost being told I could not become an scholar of Hadith, or gain thorough and proper understanding of the proofing process. I just don't want viewers to be detracted from learning and educating themselves, but rather just be more conscious of their understanding especially when attempting to inform others on particular rulings. All in all great work my brother, Alhumdulillah
Wa Alaikum Al Salam Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuh. Great point. I also felt like it was a little bit discouraging to be honest. Despite this, I think that the way he presented it will have more benefit than harm as, in our current time, people that don't even know the basic principles of Islam are giving their own rulings. This has become very common and his approach to making this video will show them very clearly that they are not even close to that level yet. In Sha Allah it will be for the better.
Tbh personally I didn't take it that way. Rather the delving into specific details can make us appreciate the efforts of the ulema even further. That doesn't we cannot also study hadith as well under scholars, if there's a will there's a way...
@@tahsintahsinuzzaman781 inshallah yes brother , lol that is basicially what i said. Also, The fact that YOU personally did not take it that way Does not mean the average person will see the same as yourself.
Asalamu Alaikom Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuh. Alluhama Barik brother. I just ran across this video and watched a couple of other videos and I want to encourage you to keep going. Your videos are very simple yet very information packed and they cover massive topics. May Allah reward you and help you in becoming a source of light for this Ummah. Also, I know you probably already know this, but make sure to keep purifying and renewing your intention so you don't miss out on the massive reward that is waiting for you In Sha Allah. Jazak Allah Khairan Akhi.
May Allah bless you for your wonderful comment. I truly thank you so much. The matter of the intention is of utmost importance and sensitivty to me. None of the views or likes or anything are worth it if my deed is not done for Allah SWT. In fact, there are ahadith from the Prophet PBUH warning us from the danger of perfoming deeds for the others to praise us. I will keep your words in mind along with my own reminders. Thank you again!🤍
This video is pushing people qwajy from the messenger of Allah
Brother the video is not pushing people away from the way of the messenger of Allah, rather it is pushing people away from creating innovations in our faith and following the messenger of Allah in the wrong way. @@mahmoudelbakkouch2709
Thank you brother for your enlightment
Brother why are you putting music in the video its haram
That's a very educative video. Also the pacing was great. Keep doing video like this. Online is for younger people and they would love video like these.
This are not good reasons to tell people to stop reading al bukhari it is still the best source of ahadith and it will bring value to everyone reading it
With all due respect, I disagree. It could do bring far more damage than benefit to the non-scholar who reads it. Especially once they encounter hadiths that contradict each other. That could create doubts and often does. Don't forget you still have an enemy trying to push you away from your religion. Shaytaan will take every chance to destroy you.
@@mohammedalsaeedd how should one read it then? under a scholar?
@@rajinhossain5742
yes, u learn Sahih al-bukhari under the guidance of a REAL SCHOLAR
@@SuperSonic-9999 where can I find one?
@@rajinhossain5742
Idk, but if ur lucky u might find a scholar and learn, maybe there could be 1 in ur masjid or someplace nearby, but even for me I don't have access to any scholars, or at least I didn't search my area yet
wow im acc shocked yk, ur video is subhanallah a huge eye opener. Wallah May Allah bless you akhi, inshallah one day i can become a scholar
You absolutely can. With a sincere intention and true desire, you 100000% can.
i want to know the meaning of those arabic words starting from question 6 😢😢
Is there a translation for the terminologies used in the video like in questions 6,7,8?
Salam Alaikum Brother, I was just thinking about how you have remembered this much long script and these much points😄 By the way, may Allah Help you and give you more beneficial knowledge and increase your knowledge. Ameen ya Rabb
Alaikum Assalam brother. Thank you for your wonderful comment. I must admit I have it by my side in case I forget or if I want to check the wording🤪. Thanks again for your comment. Ameen🤍
@@mohammedalsaeedd bro can you go more in depth.
أولا إن موسيقى هو حرام وهذا قول جميع العلماء. ثانيا إن سيدنا محمدا صلى الله عليه وسلم أمرنا بإعفاء اللحية. السلام على من اتبع الهدى
i just re-dive deep into islamic knowledge couple months ago. I used to school on islamic boarding school as High School learning nahwu and shorof, fiqh, tafseer, hadith, mustholah-hadith. For a decade (in Hijry calendar) i used to think I know enough, went astray, preach and judge other people online, went sick for a year, struggling to get of dunya, but alhamdulillah still going back to Allah. Alhamdulillah i started opening online lesson from scholar while opening the book (Tafseer jalalayn) and attending offline majlis-'ilm to scholar with books that I had and i didn't. Allah had guided me back to righteous peoplepath of knwoledge and even started memorizing Quran. I'm not an Arab and I did 2 pages memorization a day. We can do it Insya Allah.
Keep us youngin's, adult, elder into your doa every day to back and Istiqamah in this path. 🙏🙏🙏
Allahummaghfir warham ummata sayyidina Muhammad
Allahummaj'alna ummata sayyidina Muhammad shallallahu alaihi wasallam. 🙏
Insya Allah we will make Our Beloved Prophet pbuh. proud of us yawmal qiyamah. Keep learning, sweating, and tired until it doesn't even matter. Insya Allah we can sit with Anbiya, Awliya', Scholars, Shaleheen yawmal qiyamah. Amiin.
Alhamdulillah thank you brother.. i’m always wondering about this. This helps me to get an understanding as to why lay man can’t just simply read the Hadith and interpret it by themselves
Salamu Alaykum Akhi, I recentky discovered channel and may Allah continue to bless you and your family and keep you consistent in uploading beneficial content onto UA-cam. I HAVE to know one thing.... What is the name of the nasheed at the end of your videos? I've been trying to find it for some time but to no avail. Jazakhallah Khair for spreading the khair
This so underrated i immediately subscribed by the quality and clarification Masha Allah Allahumma Barik 🎉❤
I never bought sahih bhkhari
(I read online)but i want to purchase it can u recommend there are so many
SubhaanAllah! ☆ The way you beautifully and simply explained it helps so much! JazakAllahu Khairan Brother! InshaAllah, you'll be blessed with more Hikmah always! ♡
Thank you brother for another Brilliant video!
Mashaallah brother truely high quality work
Allahuma Barik nice video, may I ask how you gained so much knowledge?
Well as you can see there is bias between schools and undoubtedly the chain of transmission had biases too throughout. The work put forth in trying to make sure wrong hadith aren't put in is a lot. But if we can't question the bias of long standing tradition when it seems that something slipped through, then it's wrong to say..." We're above you and don't you ever question!" That's where I call BS
جامد يابني والله، جزاك الله خيرًا.
That is why Hadith is a historical record than book of guidance like Quran because first of Allah will not reveal 20 books besides Quran and will not make it so confusing and contraindicatory
Hadith is not contradictory, it literally teaches u so many rulings, some of these rulings aren't even in the Quran, not to mention all the prophecies that came true that were mentioned in hadiths
So the hadith about music is a weak hadith? Listening to music would be hard to give up.
❤❤❤This video has brought me so much joy, so to me AlSaeed has live up to his name, literally😁
beautifull video brother keep up. May allah bless you for this
Thank you so much. May Allah bless you too!🤍
I always read the " Nurani " in our country it's the hardest but form my childhood I learn that
For someone " Nurani " is easy , but for us it's hard . so please don't criticize without any reason
The simple question r which Hadith book qualify with this criteria? Was Quran n Deen incomplete before this Hadith literature was made? n have they not distorted or added things in Quran?
It's called sahih al bukhari meaning the authentic hadeeths collected by al bukhari
u still can read it just to gain knowledge and if there is anything u dont understand then just ask the imam in ur masjid or online
Great channel by the way, May Allah reward you
Fun fact: All the hadiths is sahih bukhari are sahih with respect to Sanad
1 Thing you forgot:
Islam is not about rulings
Of course Islam is not purely about rulings; however, they play a very big part in Islam as they teach us how to live according to the rules set by Allah. The goal of this video is not to disregard the other aspects of Islam, but instead, to help people understand that if you are not knowledgeable enough, you can not make your own rulings as this has become a massive issue in our times.
Can you please show which hanafi scholars have held that opinion in regards to the plucking of the eyebrow?
جازاك الله خير
Thanks bro for such beautiful explanation, May Allah reward you. Can u tell me the nasheed in the end
wrong, u do'nt need to be a schooler to understand that in sahih Bukhari all hadith are sahih, unless sheikh has written a side note, that tells otherwise, this man here is making a big deal out of nothing, resulting in telling you not to reed these books , coz you are not a schooler , all wrong.
I think the title is a bit misleading, isn’t the title “STOP reading Sahih Al-Bukhari before knowing this” a better title than the current one.
And i liked the video a lot, it opened my eyes towards an important issue of inventing things from our head yet we don’t have the proper knowledge which can mislead us and others as well. there are scholars through whom we get guided when it comes to the rules and hadiths of our religion, Jazakallahu Khayra
We only need Quran as book
I like your suggestion. Thank you. Changed have been made:) I'm glad your eyes have been opened. May Allah bless you🤍
@@Andalusichadith rejector?
@@mohammedalsaeedd jazakallahu khayra brother, may Allah bless you too
@@Andalusic
Quran alone doesn't function without hadith, because hadiths explain the Quran itself, many hadiths have prophecies that came true today, not to mention they're proven to be the words of our prophet Mohamed صلى الله عليه وسلم
incredible work!
I have a question for you about a hadith.
Sahih al-Bukhari 5779
Narrated Sa`d:
I heard Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) saying, "Whoever takes seven 'Ajwa dates in the morning will not be effected by magic or poison on that day."
There is a challenge from Imam Tawhidi that if this verse is authentic, a Sunni believer should eat dates and drink a cup of kerosene. My question is: Based on all these criteria, what is the reason (besides not dying or ending up in the hospital) not to do this challenge?
Imam Tawhidi? You mean that zionist dog? He's neither Imam nor a muslim, The claim he made about being an Imam from Australian Imam council is false and he is a open war monger.
Now let's get back to your claim, Problem with you people is that you are talking them literally, The hadith can be applied same as the term an apple a day keeps doctor away, But does that mean doctors literally stay away from you? No, That statment implies the nutritional value in the apple keeps you healthy so that you don't need to go to a doctor for health issues.
Same applies for the hadith and as for the benefits search "Protective effects of Ajwa date extract against tissue damage induced by acute diclofenac toxicity" article in Pubmed.
Should we talk about the Bible now?
@@dailydoseofexistence7159 Well, we should talk about Christianity because it is true and we shouldn't waste our time on false religions, but you have to answer my question first. If this hadith is authentic and your explanation is true, then what stops you from doing this challenge?
I now know that i know nothing. I have so much more to learn about Islam. Alhamduillah that i found your video, great work keep it up
Just because you may get an misunderstanding doesnt mean you don't read. Ask he scholars or people who have knowledge when you have a confusion
But how do we know that which which school is right there are telling all the possibilities isn't it more confusing, i think its probably mention in other hadiths which will clarify that if it is haram or not , (plucking of the eyebrows )
Why is this channel that underrated??
Reciter at 3:46 PLEASE?