If Pink Floyd had existed 100 years ago, this is the sound they would have produced. Only the instruments would be different. It would still have become a classic.
Impossible to be indifferent to Pink Floyd. Fantastic band. Virtuose in maximum degree. It seems like a force of nature. Great performance by the orchestra. My respect of the Brasil. Congratulations
The Pink Floyd's music is perfect played by orchestra. Great execution but better the original. A bit of lack of emotion especially by the vocalists. Emotion and pathos are the basis of Pink Floyd's music.
The vocalist on the right is not suitable for this song. Doesn't matter if they speak English or any language. She sings that like a pop song, overdoing it. Pink Floyd's vocals just need to be simple.
@@parsa_4 You sort of have a point, but, come on ... this song has been interpreted a thousand ways and back again. Just look at it as a cover interpretation; or better still, just keep to watching the original if you don't want to get so bent out of shape. I think the orchestra did a fine job, and even added a few rousing crescendos within to augment their interpretation. You are right in a technical sense, but why try to ruin a fairly good propogation of a classic because of one small element?
Great technique and no emotion. They play and sing like robots. But it is a great video to show how Lloyd Weber plagiarized Echoes to "create" The Phantom of the Opera.
В самом начале композиции фортепиано и арфа сыграли вразнобой знаменитую ноту "Си". И женский вокал здесь неуместен. Лучше бы вокал заменили инструментами.
I have to say the vocals disappointed, not engaging with the audience and they should have had a male voice with them and this would have been awesome!
And the whole time these two vocalists sang they thought they were doing a good job. Little did they know the geese from the next town over would have their heads for not replicating the original vocals as they all knew them to be and were verbally slayed for being "robotic". This frightened the two vocalists, but eventually they learned that it's always much easier to grade someone else's papers. Still, they took the constructive comments to heart and now only sing Welome To The Machine.
I gave them the thumbs up just because they did Echoes
A superb album always overshadowed by DSM, I love Echoes...
If Pink Floyd had existed 100 years ago, this is the sound they would have produced.
Only the instruments would be different.
It would still have become a classic.
Bravissimi, splendida versione!
Impossible to be indifferent to Pink Floyd. Fantastic band. Virtuose in maximum degree. It seems like a force of nature. Great performance by the orchestra. My respect of the Brasil. Congratulations
Echoes deserves full symphony-only version!!!
I want this played in my funeral. A jaw dropping cover for the greatest piece of musical art in history
Well expressed feeling
Beautiful work, thank you and greetings from Istanbul.♥️
It is great pleasure for my mind. Congratulations for all artists and technicians involved with this artistic project. Great God bless all. ❤🙏
I wish they would do the full song omg
Cool cover of my favorite Pink Floyd song, I really enjoyed it!
ALASBUENAS Jeff te doy la razón, pero la mejor.,.... APASALOBIEN TÛ Y TÔS
Outstanding.
Awesome effort by vocalists and orchestra.
1 word. AWESOME
I love everything about this, including the vocalists. Thanks for uploading it!
Incredibile!
Ecos!!que bonita versión de la gran calidad musical de Pynk Floyd
A disfrutar!!
Damn, that's some great 1919 camera
Naughtius Maximus lmao
do you know the mistake in the title?
Pink Floyd é Rock Clássico! Maravilha!
wow , fantastic , i have never hear echos done that way before, but i liked it!
¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡
EXCELENTE
Great!
hahaha listen carefully my big tit
Got some Atom Heart Mother's vibe when this turns orchestral
Excellente merci pinkfloyd incroyable
Beautifully done
Beautifuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuul
BELLISSIMA!!
It sounds a celebration of echoes track
very nice !!! pink floyd played by an orchestra , wow ..
The Pink Floyd's music is perfect played by orchestra. Great execution but better the original. A bit of lack of emotion especially by the vocalists. Emotion and pathos are the basis of Pink Floyd's music.
Extremely well executed, thanks!
Это великолепно!!!!!!!!!!
excelente , eu até gravei o áudio para ouvir enquanto estiver nas estradas ou elaborando muitas de minhas petições .
I would love to see this live
The trumpets made it for me!
que pesado..... deveras pesado
muito bom
it's good, but the original is greatest, i miss Mason's amazing drums, the organs, the bass and the amzing tone of gilmour's guitar.
You have it in the back of your head, don`t you, so enjoy something new -what are complaining about?
Beautiful, I had goosebumps
Amazing job
Ack man, this is brilliant
maravilhoso
wonderfull!!!!
Well done!
For those of you commenting on the vocalists, you do realize that English probably isn't their first language, if they speak it at all.
The vocalist on the right is not suitable for this song. Doesn't matter if they speak English or any language. She sings that like a pop song, overdoing it. Pink Floyd's vocals just need to be simple.
@@parsa_4 You sort of have a point, but, come on ... this song has been interpreted a thousand ways and back again. Just look at it as a cover interpretation; or better still, just keep to watching the original if you don't want to get so bent out of shape. I think the orchestra did a fine job, and even added a few rousing crescendos within to augment their interpretation. You are right in a technical sense, but why try to ruin a fairly good propogation of a classic because of one small element?
I think they left out the organ because that would have been way too cheap a Phantom of the Opera reference.
My favorite PF song !
most appealing
Achei q as cantoras inventaram um pouco e não ficou bom.
O instrumental ficou nota 10.
Одлична изведба. Уникатно...
Brave
a mesma coisa que estar no ceu...
Sung like American pop singers
Rock the Phantom of the Opera. ONLY KIDDING!!! WEBER RIPPED OFF FLOYD!!!!
beatifull arrangement, sorry for the funky part.:)
Great technique and no emotion. They play and sing like robots. But it is a great video to show how Lloyd Weber plagiarized Echoes to "create" The Phantom of the Opera.
imagine if they did the whole 20 minutes
Perfect❤❤❤❤
без вокала было бы лучше
Best part is NOT there!! All good but is NOT THERE!!
good nights teacher can give me your email, greetings from Venezuela, I want to send an email
Epic, as the Original.
Albert Broccoli presents….
How phantom of the opera was written😂
В самом начале композиции фортепиано и арфа сыграли вразнобой знаменитую ноту "Си". И женский вокал здесь неуместен. Лучше бы вокал заменили инструментами.
Diminishing returns....
Nice, but heavily abridged, so I'd ding them points for that (if it were a point system.)
Steven STFU and enjoy the show!
Versione piatta.suoni troppo mischiati ,le cantanti non all'altezza,,,ridatemi i Pink Floyd (la versione di Pompei insuperabile)..
inimitabile
densy land
Its SLOVAKIAN not Slovenian.....Thats different
You are right it is different, but this is Slovenska filharmonija, on RTVSLO so SLOVENIAN!
It was Ok until the singers appear... 😒
Yes indeed, I imagine they can give a quality suck but jeez, conductor, pay the hoes with your own money.
Meglio della versione di Pnik Floyd, soltanto troppo breve.
Brilliantly played but pathetic vocals compared to the original voice of gilmour and rick wright. Honestly Opinion.
Yeah. Way too forceful of a tone and far too much vibrato
no one on this planet can do what Rick and Dave did in echoes
the singers are terrible.
I have to say the vocals disappointed, not engaging with the audience and they should have had a male voice with them and this would have been awesome!
And the whole time these two vocalists sang they thought they were doing a good job. Little did they know the geese from the next town over would have their heads for not replicating the original vocals as they all knew them to be and were verbally slayed for being "robotic". This frightened the two vocalists, but eventually they learned that it's always much easier to grade someone else's papers. Still, they took the constructive comments to heart and now only sing Welome To The Machine.
Absolutely dresdful vocals. 🤮
Singers ruined it.
Awful singers, but musicians performed great
They did echoes really nice