Oh so helpful! Nice video! Carmina as of this writing is waiving the custom fees temporarily and their website is so much fun as I put together some makeups but I have no idea what last I should get lol. need to visit their flagship in manhattan for sure
I have a pair of Carmina shoes in the Rain last but am considering buying a shoe in the Simpson last. They recommend upsizing 1/2 size for the Simpson. How would you compare the Simpson to the Rain?
Where is this storm? Is it on the stud soles or the ridgeway or commando. I haven’t seen it on fb groups but I admit I don’t follow Reddit and SF as much as I used to. Thx
@@wishoeguy I google about them, and find some posts on style forum. They say, the dainite was to stiff and impossible to break in and they don’t belongs to dress shoes and so on. In my opinion, every guy needs an black Oxford; but when you more into other styles, then the rubber soles are a good choice for these Oxford’s, because of versatility. If there is a occasion what calls for these shoes (wedding or funeral) and the weather is wet or it’s snowing, there are lots of benefits.
True. I’m if the opinion that the profile of the shoe is what matters for formality, not when you cross your legs and show your sole (unless a tux). Since Dainite is a low profile like a city sole I don’t think it matters much. However I also like the feel of leather soles better. They also give the style more options with beveled and fiddleback waists, enhanced finishing etc. both have their place. I’m about 60% leather but just like the feel more.
Hej great video.I am wondring konw what do you think about rain last and detriot last.I have a oxford size Uk5 in rain last, its suit me good.which size should I choose with a derby in detriot last.
Just made my first purchase of Carmina shoes. I got the double monk strap 80250 forest last in brown vegano. Are they true to size or do they run small or large? Cheers! 🥂
Feelings are mixed. I would say insteps on oxfords run large but sizing is a little on the short side. Each last is a little different but if you have a low instep you should reach out and ask about specific lasts with your feet. They can help.
I’m sorry. I’m sure they have one but I don’t know. I would reach out to the store nearest you. There are two in NYC if you’re in the USA. You can also reach out by IG messenger or email but my experience is the turn around may be a bit long.
I think the Oscar is between D and E width on the US standard so it’s more accommodating than forest if your foot is a little wide. The toe is also different. The forest has a high toe but the Oscar has a bulbous toe but then has a slimmer vamp. If you have a very high volume foot but not wide you’d find the Forest a little better. Both fit me well in the same size.
Great Video. Is there a noticeable difference between the fit for the Rain last versus the Forrest last? I was a bit curious about that. Most of my Carmina shoes are on the Rain last, which fits perfectly. I have one pair of loafer on the UETAM last, which is a little tight at the instep but fits everywhere else. Any information that you could offer would be greatly appreciated.
@@wishoeguy thanks for replying to this question. exactly what I was wondering as well. Just ordered a rtw forest last to confirm sizing before placing a custom order :)
I don’t know them all but Detroit, Oscar, Forest, Rain, Simpson. Most sizing guides will compare to one of these. You do need to note that some lasts, especially on MTO have different widths. Rain has a D (Narrow) EE (like a US D) and EEE (like a US E). When in doubt email the store for support. The sales person I worked with in NYC answers the email and is very very knowledgeable. I’ve also emailed the general box for sizing advice and they were extraordinary. They really offer great service. I don’t want to take that for granted.
Due to lifelong Orthopedic problems and the need to put orthotics in my shoes, I went to Carmina's store locally at 45th St. in New York, hoping I could get fit with a quality pair of dress shoes that I could fit my orthotics into and wear comfortably. Instead, I was met by a pushy salesman who was just hellbent on selling whatever they had in stock. When I got home and double checked the Detroits he had sold me, I saw that my orthotics were in fact cutting into the sides of the shoes, and would in no time be damaging the linings. Although I could probably get a perfect pair of custom Carminas for myself, I can't trust this company anymore. I'm just taking these shoes back.
When you lose weight even your hat size changes. I have noticed losing 50 pounds, everything shrinks...almost everything.
Oh so helpful! Nice video! Carmina as of this writing is waiving the custom fees temporarily and their website is so much fun as I put together some makeups but I have no idea what last I should get lol. need to visit their flagship in manhattan for sure
I have a pair of Carmina shoes in the Rain last but am considering buying a shoe in the Simpson last. They recommend upsizing 1/2 size for the Simpson. How would you compare the Simpson to the Rain?
I followed this advice. If your feet are shallow and narrow, the Simpson fits true to size. Mine are shallow at the front but on the wide side.
@@wishoeguy Thanks. I'm impressed with the first pair of shoes from I got from Carmina.
Excellent video. Great camera angle that really show cases the toe shapes of the different shoes.
Love this video
Did you notice some extended time for breaking in the dainite style sole in comparison to a leather sole?
No. The shoes are flexible right away. The break in is mostly your feet settling in the cork. About 24 hours of wear.
@@wishoeguy thanks for your answer. I’m asking because there is a lot of shit-storm on dainite soles.
Where is this storm? Is it on the stud soles or the ridgeway or commando. I haven’t seen it on fb groups but I admit I don’t follow Reddit and SF as much as I used to. Thx
@@wishoeguy I google about them, and find some posts on style forum. They say, the dainite was to stiff and impossible to break in and they don’t belongs to dress shoes and so on.
In my opinion, every guy needs an black Oxford; but when you more into other styles, then the rubber soles are a good choice for these Oxford’s, because of versatility. If there is a occasion what calls for these shoes (wedding or funeral) and the weather is wet or it’s snowing, there are lots of benefits.
True. I’m if the opinion that the profile of the shoe is what matters for formality, not when you cross your legs and show your sole (unless a tux). Since Dainite is a low profile like a city sole I don’t think it matters much. However I also like the feel of leather soles better. They also give the style more options with beveled and fiddleback waists, enhanced finishing etc. both have their place. I’m about 60% leather but just like the feel more.
Hej great video.I am wondring konw what do you think about rain last and detriot last.I have a oxford size Uk5 in rain last, its suit me good.which size should I choose with a derby in detriot last.
You should reach out and ask Carmina. I’ve never worn the Detroit last as they told me it was designed for a wider foot. This was in person in NYC.
hello，one question I usually fitting the Redwing Boot in US 8D/UK 7. And it is okay to buy the same size Uk7 in Carmina forest last?
Probably. I’m not sure of Redwing lasts but forest last is pretty forgiving and a great boot last.
Just made my first purchase of Carmina shoes. I got the double monk strap 80250 forest last in brown vegano. Are they true to size or do they run small or large? Cheers! 🥂
Feelings are mixed. I would say insteps on oxfords run large but sizing is a little on the short side. Each last is a little different but if you have a low instep you should reach out and ask about specific lasts with your feet. They can help.
Just found your channel, enjoying your videos. Can you recommend a Carmina last that would accommodate orthotics?
I’m sorry. I’m sure they have one but I don’t know. I would reach out to the store nearest you. There are two in NYC if you’re in the USA. You can also reach out by IG messenger or email but my experience is the turn around may be a bit long.
Do you find the Forrest Norwegian's fit true to size?
Want some of these but as they are made to order I wouldn't like to order the wrong size.
Yes. I find the Forest tts.
@@wishoeguy thanks for the info. Beautiful shoes!
If you wear Gucci or Santoni, which size please do you go for? Seeing that yOu are size 10UK in Carmina
Sorry I’ve never tried Gucci or Santoni.
Santoni 8.5 uk, Carmina Rain 9 uk for me.
How would you describe the Oscar Last vs the Forest Last fit - same room - about the same ? Thank you ?
I think the Oscar is between D and E width on the US standard so it’s more accommodating than forest if your foot is a little wide. The toe is also different. The forest has a high toe but the Oscar has a bulbous toe but then has a slimmer vamp. If you have a very high volume foot but not wide you’d find the Forest a little better. Both fit me well in the same size.
@@wishoeguy thank you kind sir ! Greatly appreciate your feedback
How. Did. You. Make. Your. Feet. Narrow. !!! Please. Explain. !!! Thanks. !!!
I lost 47% of my body weight. Nothing fancy. Just diet and exercise.
Great Video. Is there a noticeable difference between the fit for the Rain last versus the Forrest last? I was a bit curious about that. Most of my Carmina shoes are on the Rain last, which fits perfectly. I have one pair of loafer on the UETAM last, which is a little tight at the instep but fits everywhere else. Any information that you could offer would be greatly appreciated.
I feel the fit between Rain and Forest is super similar. Slightly more toe room in Forest but not enough to change sizing.
@@wishoeguy thanks for replying to this question. exactly what I was wondering as well. Just ordered a rtw forest last to confirm sizing before placing a custom order :)
Hello, can you please name from widest to narrowest lasts in Carmina?
I don’t know them all but Detroit, Oscar, Forest, Rain, Simpson. Most sizing guides will compare to one of these. You do need to note that some lasts, especially on MTO have different widths. Rain has a D (Narrow) EE (like a US D) and EEE (like a US E). When in doubt email the store for support. The sales person I worked with in NYC answers the email and is very very knowledgeable. I’ve also emailed the general box for sizing advice and they were extraordinary. They really offer great service. I don’t want to take that for granted.
there is no whole cut in your colection thats a derby
I have a number of Wholecut derbies. We also call them plain toe vouchers.
What is the last of the cap toe on the most right hand side?
Both the split toe boot and the semi brogue are on the rain last.
Due to lifelong Orthopedic problems and the need to put orthotics in my shoes, I went to Carmina's store locally at 45th St. in New York, hoping I could get fit with a quality pair of dress shoes that I could fit my orthotics into and wear comfortably. Instead, I was met by a pushy salesman who was just hellbent on selling whatever they had in stock. When I got home and double checked the Detroits he had sold me, I saw that my orthotics were in fact cutting into the sides of the shoes, and would in no time be damaging the linings. Although I could probably get a perfect pair of custom Carminas for myself, I can't trust this company anymore. I'm just taking these shoes back.