The Blatant Censorship of All Quiet On The Western Front
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 лип 2023
- War breaks out in Germany in 1914. Paul Bäumer and his classmates quickly enlist in the army to serve their fatherland. No sooner are they drafted than the first images from the battlefield show them the reality of war. But in Germany itself the story would take a very different turn.
Get this months audiobook here: www.chirpbooks.com/history
Support me on Patreon: / stakuyi
Merch: stakuyi.creator-spring.com/
Subscribe to my channels and let me know what more you would like to see.
We organize games through
discord: / discord
Twitch / stakuyi
Podcast: historyofeverythingpodcast.com/ - Розваги
Ive always found calling the nazis "windmill boys" funnier than I probably should
The windmill boys and their friends the fag band and the sunny lads.
I mean, it is pretty funny.
Yes
Never thought of that one!
All Quiet on the Western Front is about WWI not WWII Nazis.
The fact our society penalises open conversations about Nazis and Hitler is very worrying. How can we understand evil if we can't call it what it is?
Sorry mister your starting to make too much sense, feel bad for being rational and trying to see anything more than a label for bad people, shame
@@Killthefish I read somewhere that humanity should fear their history but not hide from it, because it will always find you.
Why is everyone talking about Nazis in this comment thread. This film about WWI. The Germans were not Nazis at this point in history.
@@CT99234 you mean 2 guys talking about their ideas of why people throwing nazi as a insult when in reality it's much darker than just a word, you didnt gave to reply my guy but your right, they wernt nazi's, yet, how does that change our conversation? We know what nazis are we dont need to wait for the second movie to find out
we can call it what is it. Nobody is penalized for having conversations about NAZIS or Hitler. What the fuck do you think we are doing right this second??? Are you high?
Also, as a side note, the judge who sentenced Remarque's sister to death was killed when the courthouse room fell on him after an American bomber hit it
karma is sweet
Roland friesler
"It is God's verdict", to quote one morgue worker who saw Friesler's remains wheeled in. According to Luise Jodl (wife of Alfred Jodl, himself quite the evil piece of work), nobody else in the room, herself included, said anything afterwards. It was basically a mic drop.
The best part, however, is that not only was the lieutenant colonel whose Flying Fortress led the raid -one Robert Rosenthal - Jewish, but he had no idea he'd killed Friesler until after the war. A rabid anti-Semite who (presumably) believed the Jews controlled everything was accidentally annihilated by a Jew who didn't even know he was there. A fitting end.
@@keyabrade1861Ah. Gotta love this. 😊
@@keyabrade1861god that’s good
I work in a small bookstore in Germany and we are still selling this book on a regular basis. We always have it here. It's still being read by many.
And thats a good thing, i feel not enough realise the real horrors of war
It's a masterpiece.
Something else that I found was pretty cool about the 1930 movie was how it was filmed. They brought in actual World War 1 veterans who served on the front lines. The veterans showed the cast how to properly march in formation, wear their uniforms and go over the top of the trench. Several of the background characters were war veterans as well. Hope someone else finds this information interesting as well.
i did
That's freaking awesome. Thanks for sharing!
Wendigoon or already knew about it lol?
Unfortunately, they didn’t include any WWI vets in the 2022 version
@@FunkBastid as they all have died already
I hate censorship of history. It's the best recipe for repeating the past
See, I can understand censoring Nazis/Neonazis. But if you start auto censoring words you get something else entirely.
@@birbdad1842 bad ideas grow in darkness, as they become exciting because they are taboo. The stuffy shirted authorities don't want you to know about them which makes them tantalizing, forbidden knowledge. Bad ideas must be challenged and discussed openly in the light.
@@birbdad1842 that is how you get cod vanguard
@@birbdad1842mmm, considering that the victor writtes the history, you have to be stupid to believe the narrative around ww2. everything that is happening in the world now, all the degeneracy and chaos is caused by the outcome of the 2nd world war. murica and the bankers won but humanity lost.
@@birbdad1842 I side with Lithuanians on this one, how ever you treat nazis, that's how you treat commies. Ban swastica? Ban Hammer and Sickle too.
In case you need convincing, as a Finn I start with two counts of treason.
Both my grandfathers fought in WW1. My father's father suffered PTSD (then called shell shock) and ultimately died in a psychiatric hospital.
My mother's father never spoke of his experience and suffered hearing loss and chest infections which I suspect were from the noise of shells and possibly gas attacks. His brother, my great uncle was also profoundly deaf
I'm french and both sides of my family fought in the front lines. One of my great grandfather was a captain and barely survived a gas attack while rushing to put his mask on (left permanent scar on lungs i think) he vividly wrote the terror of the germans emerging from the smoke and the chaos that ensued.
He was captured and placed in a german POW camp and actually had wrote down the German treatment of them was respectfully and honorable (unlike the nazis that would come after). He even drew a pretty detailed map of the camp, for what reason,to escape or not, we really don't know but its a nice drawing.
I think it was my great grandfathers brother, but he unfortunately suffered severe shell shock (PTSD) and life was extremely difficult for him to do day to day tasks. His marriage that was planned before his service was called off when he returned as he was such a state of disarray..pretty sad really
My great grandfather fought in ww1 and my grandpa says he came back just fine. He was over all neutral to it all other than the feeling of it was his responsibility to have done so. One story he liked of his dads time there was how one night they were shooting artillery towards their position, and one landed so close to the trench it blew the tent cover away from where they were sleeping in the trenches, and a bunch of people panicked and started running, and my great grandpa just went back to sleep thinking it was probably safest to stay where he was, plus he was absolutely exhausted
I had 2 great grandfathers, that due to their thankfull young age endet up being double veterans.
One was rather short, not yet dwarfism, but what happens, when you're a rural outta there farmhelper + mining teenboy. His top height was 1,58m. This didn't give him ANY bonus points beeing in a charging infantry line, but the slightly more "prestigious" position of sapper / tunnel digger. Also being short helps in that case, that the enemy is spotting everyone, before they see you.
He was a heeeaaavy drinker, due to his post war job leaving him enough "free time to think" when not beeing at home with the wife (who was bigger then him) and his son (who was DEFENATLY bigger then him). But thankfully not shellshocked. But mostly always tired and somewhat scrawny, no matter how much he ate. And he had an appetite, that would put a nowadays american to shame.
He died peacefully, but for sure, never talked about the war, which turned bad for his son.
The other double vet coped the loss of two world wars, his potential second child who gotten to the sixth day and then called it a life (RIP lil Grunkle Leopold), the missed opportunity to join up a little settlement in chicago city, still looking for a properly staffed honorable drugstore keeper and his dear wife just 2 months after the war that dragged him back out of the homestead for a second time, he became a bit of a Dr jekyll and Mr Hyde. If the day was good, he was a hard working drugstore keeper with two employes, security for the shop (two trained sweet german shepherds, they where slightly smaller back then). The dogs kept good care of his wife and daughter, while he was out, while also keeping the snooping noses of party brownnosers off his ground and bookshelves.
Just WW1 alone created a hidden monster, who can scare a teacher to almost death just from speaking, after his daughter came back home with a ripped ear, due to her teacher discipling her too hard. Who said after the invasion of poland was emergency broadcast on the radio, that if he knew the godamn godlost Nazi Fat Cats where dragging his families asses into an even bigger obscenety of humanity, he'd taken the next ship to New york and then earn tickets for lil Ruthie and grandé Thessa.
He was later a rather silent recluse after running his bigass shop. retiring a made man with a merrily wed daugher, but no wife and no doggos. Still good company, but seriously despizing his "In Law comrades" coping mechanisms. But thats civillian class struggle below the ruling ceiling.
@@WolfHagenSdW It is an interesting phenomenon how most people who went through horrors of war won't talk about it. I could cite my grandfather, who fought with Partisans against both German occupiers and Croatian puppet-fascist state, which eventually landed him in German prison, thankfully not extermination camp. He was fond of retelling of stories and anecdotes from his past, even about how resistance worked and some funny cock-ups, his relationship with my grandma, who was also a part of resistance... really, any subject (especially geography and his pornography collection), but even as he recognised my interest in history, whenever I (or anyone else) would try to get him to talk about his war and prison experiences, or how it worked, he'd clam up. I'd understand not wanting to rehash the humiliating and painful things that happened to him, but he wouldn't talk even about the events. Again, after the civil war that broke apart Yugoslavia, although none of my friends nor family participated in it in the slightest, my then boyfriend knew several guys who had been in the war, and again, when asking about their experiences of the battlefront, they simply wouldn't talk about it, no matter how drunk, high... not a word about it would come out. The most I got from them was "I never thought I would be fighting for _that_ kind of outcome/country" (meaning, what former Yugoslavian republics, that became countries, turned into).
It's kind of stunning to me that we can't talk about the thing that we're never supposed to forget.
Its not that simple. You have to be very careful since there are many idiots out there who will want to glorify it
Because it will raise questions that money doesnt want answered
I feel like not enough youtubers call out YT's hypocrisy and censorship
I agree!
But even if more speak out, who's gonna stop YT from forcing their rules on us?
@@alphadawg81yeah I miss old UA-cam before ads n all this bs
Wanna bet corporate channels never face these problems???
DoublespeakTube
Some people here agree with YT on censorship, :(
I think Wendigoon had the same censorship problem trying to record his video on it, but that resulted in him passive aggressively eating hummus over scenes of war.
that was on the og movie
this reminds me of blm and Muslims🎉
@@luringen947 " Peaceful " protest footage.
Ill watch that instead of this crybaby lol i dont even make videos and i know you cant say sensitive stuff like that in videos. Dude acts all surprised and stuff
@@Khornecussion yeah cause right wingers are always so peaceful when they show up to counter protest XD
Respect to keeping your chin up and just dealing with the situation the best way you can! Much respect.
Language is fascinating in the modern world. I appreciate you trying your best to explain this story of doublespeak as honestly as you can within these limits. Well done, its a complicated story to tell.
To me, the most gut-wrenching war movies will always be the ones that show each side as humans
If the movie doesn't make them human it's propaganda.
@@newtpondskipper Based opinion.
@newtpondskipper ay yo thank you for sharing this quote. idk why, but that quote brought joy to my heart lol
Not a movie but I'm suggesting an animated series you may like
The Long Long Holiday
French countryside children going through German occupation in WW2
@@dreysantillan i have heard about it just have to find it
It's awful how YT punishes creators for producing high quality history content. Never give up man❤
I am beginning to have serious doubts about whether what youtube is doing is legal or not (depending on context). I am no lawyer, but it appears to me they are censoring widely available information. Just my opinion.
It really shows how much like the Nazis YT has become Policing speech. How about screw off YT I'm going to say whatever the hell I want.
And yet every other history UA-camr I subscribe to say Nazi and Hitler in many videos without getting taken down. So….most likely bullshit then?
@ryandavies4197haha. You mean white nationalists, right?
Makes me wish a new uncle Ted would appear and send youtube HQ a "love" letter. For legal reasons, this is a joke.
Thank you for the continued effort and quality as always! It is so important as a story and message!
Thanks for persevering through!
It is insane to me that we would block history like this. We are just encouraging this to be forgotten about and then history will repeat itself.
Makes you think about why someone in charge would want you to forget. Maybe youtube isn't the good guy they say they are
@@-gibby538They definitely aren’t. They censor topics they don’t like but allow problems such as sex bots and corn to remain on the app.
@@-gibby538 likely not youtube censoring, this type of subject has been covered many many many times on youtube, it's likely just advertisers, they hold the power here on youtube.
Yup
@@Fleatohave you seen the people running UA-cam? Definitely are the ones censoring.
It's always sad when history is censored but you did a good job thank you for the video.
to quote the old song "isn't it ironic" that a piece about censorship and looking at historical truth without a filter gets censored because it mentions the involved parties...
well, that's what happens if you use algorithms and "AI" to moderate content....
And while as a historian I (naturally ) disagree on some of the conclusions by Mr Bell and am quite amused by the mangling of the German language, this is a very valid piece and a very valid non-propagandistic PoV. So yeah thanks for taking a stand and doing this again and again
Yatzee boys is actually quite good... you might want to consider GröFaz for Herr Adolf H (old historic abbreviation by Germans for "größter Führer aller Zeiten" which was his Yatzee-internal honorific ). Then again that might be another case of weird mangling^^
Its always sad to prohibit people from expressing themselves, especialy in the name of liberty. Fire with fire and as wise man said “I disagree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it”
True, especially History. what was said about it? oh, yeah, "those who forget the past are doomed to repeat it"... sad really.
History that is forgotten is bound to be repeated. Censorship of history is a sure way to forget how and why a historical event happened.
I don't think you need to describe every last gruelty from the movie in intricate detail to get your message across. I actually quite appreciate the fact that he doesn't show it or only describes it with very little detail. Because I found a lot of it quite disturbing and I'd rather not be confronted with it again.
My dad always finds the use of "confused Charlie Chaplin fans" a dry way to refer to the "Nono Party"
I'm sure this video was incredibly frustrating to get up on youtube but after watching it, 100% worth the effort. Great video and even more importantly, an insanely important topic for people to discuss given how easily the history "All Quiet on the Western Front" is based on could be repeated
Jesus Christ. I cant believe this. I was lucky to watch All Quiet both the 60-70 variant as well as the Netflix. It is a great movie and i beg people to watch both forms and reasearch WW1 if you love history and want to know why the world is the way it is. It was a horrible event in history that turned the world both against itself and against the youth of a generation.
I will also say this here. I wish those we lost so long ago rest in peace and I wish we never see another War like this again. If we do not study or learn from history we will lose more young men to fanatism and to the gears of war and political barons who do not care for us but the money they line their pockets with.
The 1930 one is way better
1930 one is nightmare fuel..... Or a PTSD simulator
MALE youth of a generation
@@doltBmBnot true at all. All suffer during war.
If you want both a brutal anti-war book and an extreme story in censorship, consider Vassily Grossman's "Life and Fate." The KGB confiscated the author's spent typewriter type.
When Johnny Got His Gun is another good anti war piece of media.
Grossman in general is just a great writer. I think everyone would benefit from reading really any of his works.
snipers on the eastern front by sepp allerberger
ive never read something so cruel and bloddy so detached from all humanity
and at the same time being so human through the real depiction of actual warfare
Hey its nice to see there's no spazz talking about "come and see" when it comes to this subject. There's a difference between a good antiwar film and propaganda trash.
@@SpookyScaryGangRapingSkeleton i mean come and see was realistic as it depicted the dirlewanger brigade
which was so devilish that even ss officers displayed disgust when in contact with them
Love your tiktoks and was pleased to find this channel. Keep up the amazing work I have some backlog to watch through!
a name i've often heard when referring to the "1930's war enthusiasts" is the "land men"
firstly, because "not seas".
second, because the charlie chaplin impersonator was austrian, which of course is landlocked.
I read this book by chance in middle school. I was sick and tired of all those stupid teenage resistance books and I wanted something a little more realistic. I asked my dad, an army NCO, for suggestions. This book was the only one he could think of.
Also if you want one thats slightly more modern Catch 22
It’s still a teenage resistance book, but ain’t stupid haha
Infantry attacks, helmet for my pillow, generation kill, with the old breed, and one bullet away are all great memoirs of various wars. Starship troopers is a fiction story but loaded with great imagery and messaging regarding war. I read all of them when I was in the military.
Lions of Kandahar, The Only Thing Worth Dying For and Sled Driver are also amazing books about war/high-level special ops stories
The Things They Carried is a really good novel on The Vietnam war
I've never been affected by a piece of media in such a way, not until I watched this movie; specifically the scene where the main character was fighting the French soldier in the crater. Hearing that French man gurgle and struggle for his life despite knowing it was already over and our protagonist realizing how horrible it was to listen to him slowly pass and trying to help him. It hit me hard.
Never forget.
This movie sucks, watch the older one it is alot better.
While I liked this movie in its own way and felt it was a decent representation of how brutal war is, I actually prefer the 1979 and 1930 versions as they stay more true to the book. 1979 was my first version and probably my favorite out of all of them though. I feel you get a better background of the characters and you feel like you know them better.
@@MetalsirenIXI which version? 1930? Or 1979?
@@RadRicardo446 That is precisely what I like about this version. You do not get to know the characters and form bonds with them. They are just cogs in the destructive war machine and go down with no good reason and without anyone remembering them.
@@quuaaarrrk8056 There were a few scenes that were left out of the new version that disappointed me unfortunately. One being when Paul returns home and goes back to his old instructor. I feel it was such a powerful scene and didn't know why they would leave it out. In addition, which version of the foxhole/frenchman scene did you like the most? I like all versions of it and I feel all are emotional in their own way.
Great video, thanks for making this
Good (edit: "Excellent") summarization and analysis. Well done, mate.
another large creator named wendigoon made a all quiet on the western front video and opened it up expressing how frustrated he was because he kept having to remake the video because it kept getting censored by yt among other things.
sad to see such an important piece of media with such a strong message being censored so heavily.
Reminds you of certain country in Europe in 30s and 40s...
its better over moderated then undermoderated.
@ImperativeGames it's more like that country from 1919 to 1928 or so.
@@datcheesecakeboi6745why?
@@mitchelldkirby wym why? I'd rather have people say no no Germans instead of nutters praising the nazis
Started reading All Quiet in March of 2003 in Kuwait before we crossed from Matilda. Ended up finishing it in Nasiriyah just south of the bridge. I didn't expect to find it as relatable as it would end up being. The isolation, confusion, abject absurdity and terror of conventional warfare he describes is eerily timeless.
If you haven't read it or seen it, do so. The modern remake is good, but misses a lot of the heart rending detail the book provides.
Thanks for covering this one. People can't forget what they're asking for when they beg for war.
Love your videos man, UA-cam thankfully showed me your channel.
Keep on persevering!!! Your videos are so informative and entertaining.
Censorship... the perpetual evil that rides on the backs of the fearful and the angry.
We never seem to learn from past mistakes.
As long as it's pointed at a group they disagree with... people will support any injustice.
I disagree with pedophiles, I very much disagree with the things they want to look at online. Should we just let them get on with it because “censorship evil”?
@@CharlieNoodles Never go full retard bro.
@@CharlieNoodlesthat's just a little bit different, both legally and morally.
@@CharlieNoodlespedophilic content is immoral because it victimizes (real) children. Who is the victim when you mention the word Nazi?
My point, is that absolute statements like that are foolish. Yes it’s frustrating when a legitimate historian has to modify his words because the algorithms that enforce censorship are heavy handed. Guess what? That’s UA-cam. A private company that has the right to moderate its platform as it sees fit. You know who else is on this platform? Literal Nazis. And if either of you three have a better idea of how to stop hate speech propagating on this website I’m sure UA-cam would love to hear from you.
In the 1930 version of this movie, the actor Lew Ayers, staring as the German soldier Paul Bäumer, was so impacted by his experience that he became a pacifist for the rest of his life.
Warmongers love pacifists. Easy victims.
The rest of his life? Is he dead?
@@bcolt1911obviously someone who acted in a 1930 movie is dead. He'd be over a 110 otherwise. He died almost 30 years ago.
So he larped as a German and it changed him that much? 😂
Of course God forbid we let the actual truth out, that lots of Germans welcomed the war enjoyed their time in the trenches and in later life found themselves longing for the days of August 1914
@@Person0fColorout of all the language's in the world you chose to speak out of your arse. The person who wrote the book was german and there is nothing you can argue against it without looking like a bafoon. Ever wondered why there was a socialist revolution in the 1920's? Its because the german people were sick of the war and were suffering from it. The German army weren't cartoon villian's who were pure evil war mongering demon's, they were people,and nothing less. By the time it was 1918 the German Empire was onthe verge of collapse both economically, and internally due to increasingly radical parties that actually tried to overthrow the new weimar republic due to the mass starvation and death that was occuring because of the british blockade of merchant shipping to the German Empire, and the overall hatred for the Kaiser and the new Weimar Republic.
I watched the history of snipers and this instantly became one my fav channels, love your work man keep it up💪🏽🖤
I had never seen any other All Quiet movie or read the book before I watched the 2022 Netflix movie and... just holy fuck. I kinda knew what to expect considering that it's the first world war, but the story that was told and the way it was told was so brutal and tragic that I was sad for the next couple weeks after watching it. The crater scene hit me right in the gut and it took a lot for me to not break down seeing it. Genuinely want to pick the book up and read it because of that movie.
You should. It's an excellent book. That movie sort of misses it's point by connecting his story to all these historically significant events. It's just the average, insignificant, brutal story of a German soldier who fought and died and it didn't really matter. Totally different story.
The 2022 film doesn’t do the story justice, and the peace negotiation scenes were not part of the original story as told.
I find it immensely interesting that anyone would censor anything to do with this book today. Maybe was just where I live, but this book was actually part of the mandatory curriculum for eighth grade. Since then it has remained at the top of my list for my most favored novels. My sister who is five years younger than myself just wrapped up eighth grade and I was absolutely elated to help her and her friends with the discussions that surrounded this book in the curriculum.
Do you live in Germany?
@@akumasstorytime3910Not to answer for the gentleman above, but I am from Germany and had the book as required reading in 8th grade as well.
@@akumasstorytime3910 Nope. Middle America.
@@machinegunyelly6944 yeah I am aswell that's why I asked. I remember a lot of books being mandatory so I thought it was a Germany thing.
I read it in high school in the US (California no less)
Excellent video. UA-cam needs to get its head out of its posterior and realize that context is important and stop pointlessly censoring work. History - raw, fact based history- should never be censored. History isn't supposed to make you feel good, it's supposed to make you think. This book was compulsory reading when I was in high school and it was one of the few I actually did read. Keep up the great content - your videos aren't just entertaining, but important.
They won't, for the same reason they won't fix contentID and copyright strikes: Dealing with the consequences of a bad system is cheaper than fixing the system.
They honestly won't. It's too "expensive" to have the company hand more than 10 real people. The company would rather have AI do it. I'm serious, and not being pithy or a technophobe. It's also somehow you can still have porn on here. Just found out about a guy who has TWO videos of him showing how to shave your back end hole area.
But historians can't be candid about the subject matter of it's about war, and N4Z1s especially.
@@dragonsword7370 Yep. Anything that is considered "educational" can get around the rules, that's how the asshole shaving vids are up. There are also yoga vids where the entire vid is a woman bending over with her ass to the camera and is trying her darndest to show ass and pussy through her yoga pants. Clearly a thinly veiled softcore vid, not teaching yoga, but even when REPORTED they approve it.
A quote I saw on the tank museum in Germany - "If we want to live in peace, we need to talk about war"
@@LB-ou8wt reminds me of a quote, “if you want peace, prepare for war”.
Thank you for making these informative videos, I enjoy watching it
This video and title was brilliant. it took me half way past the video to really understand the double entendre.
I really appreciate your dedication in getting this video made. All's Quiet on the Western Front is an incredibly important story in its own right, but the events surrounding the story are also important to understanding that moment in history.
My senior year of highschool I chose to take a WWI history class. I decided to do so as my former civics teacher was leading the class and I really enjoyed his civics class. It was one of the best decisions I have made. We delved deep into All Quiet On The Western Front. Also we explored our local WWI history. I learned just how influential my local Red Arrow and Rainbow national guard units were during the conflict. When we forget our history, our history will come back to say hello. Additionally, I love your channel sir. From one random fact enthusiast to another, keep up the great work.
You must be from near me! I live a bit south of Red Arrow highway now, but I had to read Al Quiet in I think 9th grade when I grew up.
People: forget what they're capable of so they go with anything
History: Hello, Bonjour, I'm here for you knee caps, again.
So where are you from? My grandfather was a Red Arrow in WWI
Just found this video, sorry I missed it at first. Thank you for more history on UA-cam.
Excellent work
Thanks for the great video Stak. I'm pretty sure that I can speak for most of us, when I say that we all appreciate the effort and dedication to the videos you create.
Indeed. I appreciate your efforts.
what makes this great? it had a clickbait thumbnail, a frankely bad explanation on nazi germany, not to mention him being a broken record "woe is me youtube wont like me see nazi" like how many times did he mention it when 1 would suffice?
One thing you might not know about the preservation of the original uncut version of the 1930s movie is, that it originally was lost a big fire and the only reason we still can see it today is the personal collection of Joseph Göbbels him self. So the man who hated this movie probably the most, rescued it.
Poetic justice
This story is easily disprovable. The film was an American production, in English, with global distribution. The idea of a "preserved uncut version" is cute but it's best to stick to reality
@@holly3934 unlikely =/= disproven.
@@MrJohansen No where did I say it was unlikely, that's because it's objectively false. It doesn't even take Google to find out, just knowing the basic details of the film + common sense would tell you this is a myth. If you did Google it you'll find 0 information showing that the film was recovered from Göbbles, rather you'll find plenty detailing screenings throughout the west all the way from its release until well after the war. Arguing that lack of evidence means it could be true is also incredibly foolish due to the overwhelming evidence suggesting it was never lost. Please, if you're going to be a history enthusiast I recommend practicing healthy scepticism for any grand claim, even more so when there's little support from cross referenced first hand sources
@@MrJohansen it factually didnt happen.
Leaving a comment, sub and like to help with the algorithm. UA-cam has screwed over so many content creators that are doing nothing but trying to thrive and create a career for themselves. Best of luck to you and keep up the hard work man.
Excited to check it out
Growing up my dad taught US and World history. All Quiet on the Western Front was part of his curriculum when he taught WWI. It really is one of the books that movies do well but still never quite get it all. And it will forever make you second guess voting for a warmonger. Thank you for the video!
Voting for a "warmonger" who is the war monger?
Having read that book, I see war as an activity nobody directly involved wants to be involved and anyone not involved directly hails it as patriotism or whatever the case is at the time.
@@at0mic282 war can be a drug for some
@@viveka2994exactly. The book and the movie cover up the fact that many Germans openly welcomed both world wars. All nations were enthusiastic but the Germans were a late developing country and really really wanted to fight for their country and Kaiser.
Ernest Junger and Ernst Von Salomon were “old fighters” and influenced many Germans with their ideas.
They loved war
saw this movie as a freshman in high school (mid 1970's). part of history class. maybe my teacher was your dad; more likely that a lot of teachers saw the educational value of this movie. as they say, war is hell.
Stakuyi, thank you so much for being dedicated to discussing this subject!!!
Great video bro!
I’m currently re reading the book for the first time in about twenty years. This book and unbroken are great references of the trials of war.
UA-cam has been on some certified pansy behavior and your not alone man. Keep your head up man it will get better soon.
This film was a fine telling of a WW1 story. But it was *not* "All Quiet on the Western Front" in anything more than name. The training part was removed (the book's entire first act!), they subbed in a prologue about some kid... they made up an entire B plot about the diplomatic negotiations... changed details about characters and events...
Imagine if they rebooted "Full Metal Jacket" and took out boot camp and Gunny Hartman and just started the film from "Me so h*rny, me love you long time"... and inserted an original B-plot about Kissinger and Nixon sabotaging the Paris peace conference.
It's literally that flagrant.
This was an original story, elements of which alluded to parts of "All Quiet"(if you want to be charitable and not call it a blatant ripoff), but they really did not need to put that name on this for any reason other than marketing.
The 1979 TV movie is still the best adaptation, imo.
Finally someone who actually read the damn book.
I was so disappointed when Himmelstoss wasn’t in the film. Plus, the name of the novel is taken from the ending of the novel where Paul dies on such an insignificant day which was super impactful. In the Netflix film, it ends with a huge battle scene. Definitely the worst of the three renditions if you are comparing it to the book. Not to mention how they also changed Kat’s entire character and death alongside the dynamic of the entire group. A huge part of the novel was the relationship of the characters and how quickly it just went away. Here, there are no characters to speak of. You’re right, it’s a generic war movie, not All Quiet on the Western Front.
@@chalkwizard1292orrection: It IS “All Quiet on the Western Front”, it’s not the best version. It still has the same message, delivered with similar bluntness and brutality. It’s just that the 1930 film did it better.
If you’re honest, the BEST adaptation is the 1930 film!
I read the book after watching the netflix thing, because I liked it so much, and now im so disappointed how they didnt even try to be faithful to the original story
Thanks!
Appreciate your hard work
Thank you for making this despite your frustration. As a german myself i think it is important to keep proper documentation of all the good and bad stuff our ancestors did. Both my granddads were soldiers in WW2 although on opposite ends of the political spectrum. So i am part of the last generation to hear first hand reports. If we today choose to tell storys differently it's fine, but we have to keep old storys as they are. The way how a story is told is as important and a document of its time, as the story itself. Rewriting even fictual novels because some words 'are offensive' is as good as burning the book and we all thankfully know who was a big fan of that.
Germany did nothing wrong.
@@finnberglander7816 i beg to differ. Killing off good portions of the population because of religion, sexual orientation, heritage, disability or just disagreement in an Industrial scale is clearly wrong. Back to topic: banning and burning books because they don't fit the own narrative is also clearly wrong.
@@bengtkunze5569 Man...I remember when I believed all the things that government school taught me as well.
The information is out there buddy, I hope you look into it further.
@@finnberglander7816 i don't know what school has to do with stories i was told by my grandparents, their siblings and friends, but you do you...
sausages.........not really! i truly wish we had techno+mdma. could of had a dance off instead.....
I haven’t watched the latest film yet but that ending you describe is so far from the book’s ending, which is absolutely perfect & gives book its very title. It’s a great book everyone should read.
It's a good watch if you have the time, I would recommend you watch it at home at night for a better atmosphere.
Yeah, I watched the latest version and was pretty disappointed. The plot doesn't follow the book much. It does pull in a few of the big scenes but it changes both the plot of the book and the message of it.
The book and previous movies, to me, had the message of this is war. War sucks. It's brutal and indifferent.
The latest version seems to push the message that the Generals and the Politicians are doing everything they can to make the lives of the grunts as awful as they can while they themselves gorge on the finest luxuries of life and complain if their croissant is slightly too dry. And yes, the ending is just awful. It expects soldiers to make a full frontal assault across no man's land during the last 15 minutes before the ceasefire. There's a scene where a whistle blows and everyone engaged in hand to hand combat just puts down their weapons. The only upside I can say is that it does show the terror of combat.
@@jonathonrodriguezthomas6457 wh at I've heard about the movie I'D sum up as: "It's not 'Im Westen nichts neues'. It fails at being that. It is, however, a non-too-shabby story INSPIRED by the novel." if it wouldn't try to masquerade as All quiet on the Western Front, it'd be much more palatable.
@@undertakernumberone1 Yeah, exactly. It's a good film on its own merit but don't judge it as a book adaptation
@@morganmcallister2001 Glad it wasn't just me. I've not read the book or seen the other two versions. But I watched this one and I never engaged emotionally with it at all. It was very well made. I would like to have seen the bit with the tanks on the main screen. But there was nothing to the main character. Who spent it all reacting not acting. Which isn't how you write drama. Don't think the time jump helped either. It's a four star film for me, but it's not one I'll ever come back to.
Very well done!
made a point of subscribing when you mentioned your problems with the no-no word for the fourth or fifth time saying you were frustrated learning what youtube allows, and you're new to the platform. Great content so far and a consistent viewer gained
I wonder what moustache man thought of this movie, being a veteran of the Great War and all. Apparently his experiences in the war were one of the reasons there wasn't any chemical weapons used, so he must've realized something.
The reason he became a moustache model was his big bushy Teutonic stache kept his gasmask from sealing properly and he got a dose. Ever since, he trimmed it up and ruined it for anyone else.
Yeah even though the Germans used gas on Concentration camp victims.
He was transporting letters and messages to the trenches. He didn't actually fight or anything.
No chemical weapons? How about Zyklon b?
@@latayantheazran Can you point to any battles in which german forces bombarded allied or soviet troops with zyklon b?
Thank you for persevering with this episode. Not being able to call a spade a spade doesn't stop spade lovers from romanticising what a spade is, it just means everyone else forgets what a spade is.
That being said perhaps UA-cam wouldn't have a problem with "jack-booted thugs" which suitably conveys the badness of the group.
Use , Knobelbecher ' , the german slang for the boots.
I subbed based on your honesty and bluntness
Very good video. I couldn't have said it any better myself.
Censorship has gone completely off the rails. I've been on Discord servers where saying "dumb" or "stupid" is a bannable offense, in any context.
Nothing beats getting a warning when you say "I think I made a stupid mistake"
Discord moment
Discord is ran by kneck beards who don't go outside and 4channers who spam the n word, that site is not worth chatting on beyond a personal server for you and your friends. I'm in a couple servers just to see the insane amount of delusion these people live in, at a certain point it goes from entertaining to just straight up worrying.
your own fault for using discord
@@organicleaf You mean it's his own fault for using electronic communication, right?
I mean, it's totally the computer communication protocol's fault that some servers has absolutely upstuck mods..
@@johanmetreus1268 well no, its still his fault for even wanting to use public discord servers, like for real, who the fuck would want to waste his time on shit like that? Because if it were electronic communication, Shit like WhatsApp would ban those words too, but you can say everything you want there
i appreciate you, this channel, and everyone that works on these videos
Amazing video, thanks
this hit me like nail in the head! never knew history of this book
I remember watching this as a kid which was inappropriate for my age but the horror and impact it left on me has forever shaped my view of war. Amazing video.
Most Germans welcomed the war and were happy that it came and lots of Germans would later go on to be nostalgic for August 1914.
Some people like war and are good at war , but we can’t let that truth be true all war is horrible and everyone in it has a terrible experience 😂
This is a childish view of war
@Person0fColor do they still like war after seeing their friends get blown to pieces? Weird comment
@@Astro2024yes? People aren't wholly rational, we like to glorify things
@@Person0fColor That was true for all nations involved, our current view of war devoid of romance and glory was formed from WW1.
Didn't it come out like last year?
It's sad that this story and history in general gets censored by UA-cam. If we try to silence the past, we'll be doomed to repeat it
Have you ever considered if they actually wanted that to happen? I mean we the common folk only wanted to get on with our lives but what of the heartless bastards on top? What do they want? Do you really think that daddy government wants peace?
@@vondantalingting youtube is utterly incompetent. That's it. They want money and everything else is treated with complete uncaring incompetence.
@@TealJosh Private media businesses care about money, but pissed off governments make it hard to make money. On the other hand, governments need positive media coverage, and will gladly make it worth the media business's while in various ways. Thus, private media businesses usually pay attention to what their governments want and comply with it.
Read a book called "Manufacturing Consent: the Political Economy of the Mass Media".
@@macdeus2601 I'm aware of Noam Chomsky and Manufacturing Consent. UA-cam isn't private media. What's happening with YT is dissimilar to what happened after 911 when all (neo)liberal media fell lockstep to rile people up for Iraq war.
For UA-cam the algorithm is a black box that is trained on needs of advertisers. No one knows exactly what happens in the algorithm. People can just observe the input and output.
@@TealJoshit's also owned by jews
Great video, good luck
I watch all of your videos and you make me smarter ever day
The "World War 2 In Colour" series from 2008, made for Channel 5, had a fantastic mood-setting intro; horns and strings. For some reason, presumably because there are video of That German Leader´in the intro, copies on UA-cam of this intro was taken down by UA-cam for "Hateful Content". It is a documentary series about the Second World War. There is literally nothing Hateful in it.
Talk about how bad the Nazis were? Banned!
Take Nazi arguments and swap out political and/or ethnic groups to fit your own whack-ass views? Great content, good job!
Very much a spirit of the law vs letter of the law thing.
Ask yourself why they don’t want you to listen to his speeches
I'm a big fan of the term "no-no Germans" that's funny stuff.
Should have been "9-9 Germans"
Hey Stak thanks for making this video! This is the reason I finally watched the new movie and it was amazing.
Great video 👍
This video finally convinced me to subscribe. Your dedication to talk about difficult subjects even against these ridiculous censorship attempts is truly inspiring. Thank you for that
Thanks for all that you do. I appreciate your content and honestly everytime I watch one of your videos I feel a little bit better about myself. I a huge history buff and think it's truly an amazing idea to do what you are doing. Love you content. Keep it up.
-STAY RUGGED
Fascinating, thank you
Thanks for the vid 🤓
All things considered, I’m sure most if not all of us here appreciate the effort on your end to just get this video posted. Great video as always
Thank you for persevering and getting this out.
Great video
If it means watching it in uncensored form and to make sure you get paid for your hard work, I would go watch it and subscribe to your patreon. Also, I love the original and own a copy of it. First time watching it was in 10th grade American history II class.
Here's a few options for alternatives. National socialists, 30s German nationalists, and if you're willing to delve into some dark humor the German Bakers union.
I follow a podcast that refers to them as “Mid Century Germans” 😂😂
And to add to that last one “German gas company” can also work
@@sandalogaming6766link to podcast?
Ordering the book now
Don’t let the UA-cam Yazi Algorithm beatcha!
Just subbed and am binge watching the hell out of your channel while I deliver packages. Thanks for so much good work!
I’ve been waiting for this one to be released as this is one of my favorite movies as it is so impactful. You did an amazing job covering it! Thank you!
When you think about it, the most shocking thing about the whole censorship when talking about historical event is how much it backfires.
Using terms like "unalive" and "evil mustache man group" instead of calling these things what they are, it takes out the impact that all of this should have. Instead of being shocked by historical events it becomes a meme.
The worst part is, those terms are in and of themselves begrudging attempts to keep history alive despite corporate site censorship! It sucks how attempts to keep discussions alive still help whitewash them ;_;
its like newspeak
I find it fascinating that all the true crime podcasts can’t say all the things they are stopping you from saying without their videos being taken down
So, I've been subscribed for sometime. And I just now sorted your videos by most popular... How is your most popular video only 600k views?!? You are criminally unrecognized. You're content is truly amazing
Really good effort. Great way to discuss propaganda vs reality. Censorship it's the path to don't understand, speaking with facts and looking many sides of the story always brings a bigger picture
Thanks for all your hard work. I have learned more about history from your channel than any class I ever took
book break downs like this would be cool
Subscribed for the convictions against censorship.
I’ll stay for the high quality production.
You’re my favorite guy to listen to when it comes to history. And your stuff is always well done, thanks for the content man
The 2022 film was such a good movie. Shockingly brutal and honest. I’m far from disillusioned as to the horrors of war, and it was still eye opening. Definitely a must watch.
hate how much this felt like you were not just describing 1930 Germany... (I'm sure this is nothing new for anybody in this channel, but hearing somebody else saying it really makes some of this hit home)
The streisand effect demands a boost to this video!
I'd like to own a copy of this book. This looks like one of those stories you should read at least once.
You could also watch the original 1930 movie. It makes some changes from the book that I think help make it a better antiwar story.
You can find All Quiet on The Western Front in some odd places. I found and bought a copy at a Dollar General being trampled on amongst all the crappy romance novels. I just needed a gallon of milk. I also found a copy starship troopers a few years later.