Amy Lee's vocals are like nothing else in the music industry. So haunting, uniquely beautiful, and writes music totally perfect for her sound. I wish she was more commercially successful. She's totally underrated.
She's so adorable!! :) You know, to be honest, I think Amy has a beautiful voice. I like the small imperfections you can hear. It makes her amazing. Also, her personality shines through everything she does... How can you not respect someone like that?
@EvanescenceFreak01 definetly - no live noises like the crowd or whatever - also - the last note is played in slow motion so it fits the sound perfectly. You can't mime slow motion :P
@kmyhzyl I'm almost completely certain it's the studio version, not a live version. But the sing live, they never do playback, so I think the person who made the video has just dubbed the studio version over this live version ...
People, she obviously wasn't lip synching, they recorded her live and then played the studio version over it for the video. It's easy to see since you cannot hear the crowd at all in the quieter parts of the song, and the fact that the song fades out at the end would be impossible to do live. You can't just fade out drums or whatever. Plus, looking at her neck and chest you can tell that her voice is in full use. It was probably a shit performance and magicTV overrode it.
amy lee is so gorgeous i like her because she is were she is now only because shes got REAL TALENT and she isbeautiful without being anorexic or go around without a shirt i think all super stars should be like this specially teenagers cuz they are like role models for little kids LOVE U AMY
Realmagic obviously didn't record the audio at this show. I was there and it was live. I recorded the show myself actually so I have a recording of the 'real' live performance.
Amy has the best sense of humor. xD "You snuck a peek!" And I loved how she imitated it ... but it didn't quite work for her ... xD. Cool card trick. =)
I never heard a live song that sounded like the recorded original. So that "bring me to life" was the original. Hmm but if you got some live videos of artist that are very close to the original please let me know.
Well they've only released two albums so far, um, she did a few side projects & collaborations, and they're currently working on the third record....I know what you mean, I was kinda the same...then again i was 8 when they released this xD
Pixieman5000 is right everyone. They would never do playback. Fade out is not possible live. Crowd is silent, which means somethings blocking the audio, as in the track version on the video. Calm down. Evanescence will never use playback.
I personally like Fallen better than The Open Door, but that record is better in the sense that there's so much freedom on it... You appreciate that music, because Amy isn't being controlled.. T.O.D. went platinum waaaaaay faster than Fallen did too... And their newest self titled record is platinum too... I don't see we are the fallen doing that shit... (I see them rippin shit off though o.O)
Actually, I think the show has just placed the original track over the live performance, since you can't even hear the crowd or anything in the entire performance.
im ev fan, but tbh.. sorry. for me its playback. listen to it and you'll see, its playback. there are 2 options: 1. they did playback on concert 2. realmagic just putted song from album for video (but why they didnt use real music and voice, from concert?) yeah, Amy would never lipsync, but guys! some tv's, shows etc say that you MUST play with playback or they wont let you play. but sometimes they change mind. look at festivalbar and top of the pops - i guess amy sings live there, but usuall
@YasminSystem Shut the front door! What the hey is wrong with you? Every one of their songs were as great as the next great band in line (who ever that is) Amy didn't jank up the vocals, she made them awesomer than they already were. I think you need to give their songs another go before you judge some other great band...
The actual performance was live. Tv shows and the like are FAMOUS for dubbing a studio version over a live version. This would have had NOTHING to do with Evanescence. Amy Lee can hold her own live no problem. Remember American Bandstand? Well the performers were NEVER allowed to sing live it was always synced. So relax it's not like they were doing it live like at a Brittany Spears concert .
@YasminSystem I COMPLETELY disagree... Evanescence is one million times better then We Are The Fallen. Their lyrics are better, the music is better, and Evanescence songs don't all sound the same like We Are The Fallen's songs do.. plus Amy's voice is way better... just sayin.. :) But after all this is just my opinion.... but I honestly think it's a fact.. :)
its sort of obvious its playback. but i dont blame her - this song is living hell to sing. its soo hard and she isnt anywhere near as good in any other concert.. hmm... GO AMY!
without Ben and the rest of the guys, Evanescence is just mediocre. Their seconds CD was... a 5 on a scale to 10.... If it even had been a 2 or a 1, so I could so it really sucked. You should go and buy yourself "We are the fallen"! If you open your ears and stop licking Amy Lees´ toe nails, you´ll appreciate what you hear ;-)
Amy and John are actually singing. Someone just used the album version over the live version..
Amy Lee's vocals are like nothing else in the music industry. So haunting, uniquely beautiful, and writes music totally perfect for her sound. I wish she was more commercially successful. She's totally underrated.
man I love Amy's stagewear! She's so creative!
i went to one of her conserts O.M.F.G thatwas the best moment of my life!!!!!!!!!
Amy I love you, my lifeee!!!! s2
this isn't live.
but the are still the best
She's so adorable!! :) You know, to be honest, I think Amy has a beautiful voice. I like the small imperfections you can hear. It makes her amazing. Also, her personality shines through everything she does... How can you not respect someone like that?
It was a great interview, not the normal questions over and over again.
great song and great singer
this band is the best live!
@EvanescenceFreak01 definetly - no live noises like the crowd or whatever - also - the last note is played in slow motion so it fits the sound perfectly. You can't mime slow motion :P
Shit,She Really Is The Queen Of Metal
yea they are great live holy shit!! i love them so much :)
She a good singer go Evanescence you rock
@kmyhzyl I'm almost completely certain it's the studio version, not a live version. But the sing live, they never do playback, so I think the person who made the video has just dubbed the studio version over this live version ...
Thank you. This comment deserves more likes so more people can see it.
Hell yeah!
It doesn't sound live because the CD recording is on top of the video. They don't lipsynch
@Illuminati10101 In some places, it's actually required by law, for televised concerts to have playback audio.
ha shez so friggen adorable "That's where you snuck a peek!" lol XD
she sings good live!!
So true!
People, she obviously wasn't lip synching, they recorded her live and then played the studio version over it for the video. It's easy to see since you cannot hear the crowd at all in the quieter parts of the song, and the fact that the song fades out at the end would be impossible to do live. You can't just fade out drums or whatever. Plus, looking at her neck and chest you can tell that her voice is in full use. It was probably a shit performance and magicTV overrode it.
amy lee is so gorgeous
i like her because she is were she is now only because shes got REAL TALENT and she isbeautiful without being anorexic or go around without a shirt i think all super stars should be like this specially teenagers cuz they are like role models for little kids
LOVE U AMY
Realmagic obviously didn't record the audio at this show. I was there and it was live. I recorded the show myself actually so I have a recording of the 'real' live performance.
is it playback....! lol! bytheway awsome video
ما اجمل هذه الاغنية الجميلة يا سلام مافي كلام عليها
Amy has the best sense of humor. xD
"You snuck a peek!" And I loved how she imitated it ... but it didn't quite work for her ... xD.
Cool card trick. =)
I never heard a live song that sounded like the recorded original. So that "bring me to life" was the original. Hmm but if you got some live videos of artist that are very close to the original please let me know.
evanescence in caracas,venezuela ...!!!!
kanon -just a great performance
i think i agree with you
:O
amazing :P
Haha I love her!!! :)
Amy shuffling cards- that was funny
@Lisq yea u can tell its recorded but.... they mite hve done that jus for the vid nt for the performance
I totally agree and I think they realized that it was off cuz they zoom out a lot and dont really focus on amys face
Go on their official site and Amy left a message.
0:00, I think it's not Amy Lee ...
I do the drunkin' shuffle every Saturday night!!!!
it's playback i'm absolutly sure but i still love evanescence
if it's playback than why john can sing at 0:45. I think the music is going under the screen
Live????
@tonikdotwarzy55 Dlaczego tak uwazasz?? przeciez to tylko ktos podlozyl muzyke do koncertu
I like amy's outfit
Well they've only released two albums so far, um, she did a few side projects & collaborations, and they're currently working on the third record....I know what you mean, I was kinda the same...then again i was 8 when they released this xD
Pixieman5000 is right everyone. They would never do playback. Fade out is not possible live. Crowd is silent, which means somethings blocking the audio, as in the track version on the video. Calm down. Evanescence will never use playback.
i loved her hair. WHY DID SHE CUT IT!!!!
It's playback. But she can sing it like that live.
hahah , how did he do that..?
OMG I thought Amy was singing live but... I don't care I love Amy and Evanescence anyway =)
This sounds exactly like the recorded and edited version. This is NOT live!
I personally like Fallen better than The Open Door, but that record is better in the sense that there's so much freedom on it... You appreciate that music, because Amy isn't being controlled.. T.O.D. went platinum waaaaaay faster than Fallen did too... And their newest self titled record is platinum too... I don't see we are the fallen doing that shit... (I see them rippin shit off though o.O)
Actually, I think the show has just placed the original track over the live performance, since you can't even hear the crowd or anything in the entire performance.
Yea, i bet you guys are real close friends.
they sung it live somebody audio swapped it lol.
im ev fan, but tbh.. sorry. for me its playback. listen to it and you'll see, its playback.
there are 2 options:
1. they did playback on concert
2. realmagic just putted song from album for video (but why they didnt use real music and voice, from concert?)
yeah, Amy would never lipsync, but guys! some tv's, shows etc say that you MUST play with playback or they wont let you play.
but sometimes they change mind. look at festivalbar and top of the pops - i guess amy sings live there, but usuall
lol missionary shuffle ;)
Nice boots.. ;)
usually ppl lipsync on top of the pops or festivalbar. i guess, this show on rl magic is only one, where ev did playback.
xscuse me!!! Amy lee doesn't lip sync and she nvr haz!!!!
@YasminSystem Shut the front door! What the hey is wrong with you? Every one of their songs were as great as the next great band in line (who ever that is) Amy didn't jank up the vocals, she made them awesomer than they already were. I think you need to give their songs another go before you judge some other great band...
The actual performance was live. Tv shows and the like are FAMOUS for dubbing a studio version over a live version. This would have had NOTHING to do with Evanescence. Amy Lee can hold her own live no problem. Remember American Bandstand? Well the performers were NEVER allowed to sing live it was always synced.
So relax it's not like they were doing it live like at a Brittany Spears concert .
@deagla2 ummmm wat?????
why is she lipsinging?
it's playback...at the beginning of Evanescence they had to play playback...I think :D
But Amy's voice live is way better :)
thats not the original audio... playback... not funny, she sings well live so take the playback over it away... thanks
first time I see Evanescence when ... Amy is singing not live... its playback O.o
Yeaaahhhh Playback :OOO
its playback, but its pretty!
@YasminSystem I COMPLETELY disagree... Evanescence is one million times better then We Are The Fallen. Their lyrics are better, the music is better, and Evanescence songs don't all sound the same like We Are The Fallen's songs do.. plus Amy's voice is way better... just sayin.. :)
But after all this is just my opinion.... but I honestly think it's a fact.. :)
its sort of obvious its playback. but i dont blame her - this song is living hell to sing. its soo hard and she isnt anywhere near as good in any other concert.. hmm... GO AMY!
@YasminSystem Again with the crap, suck it up and face it!
EVANESCENCE IS AN AMAZING BAND!
NOT LIVE
Amy marrie me
she wont coz she have all rdy married me :D
thats playback!!! but.. nice
I'm shocked thats lip sync for bring me to life
without Ben and the rest of the guys, Evanescence is just mediocre. Their seconds CD was... a 5 on a scale to 10.... If it even had been a 2 or a 1, so I could so it really sucked.
You should go and buy yourself "We are the fallen"! If you open your ears and stop licking Amy Lees´ toe nails, you´ll appreciate what you hear ;-)
Stop doing magic tricks and ask her something! WTH!?
PLAY BACK??? LOL
wow this actually is a playback,she's barely singing.
this group is good but this performance wasnt the best :(
its definetely playblack:( too bad
Playback...easy in this way...
she looks.. not really pretty today