I agree it wasn’t the best performance because everything else overshadowed her violin, but such criticism proved everyone wrong. She’s amazing, and I love her! She won in the end!
To know that she cried for hours in the bathroom after this, completely shattered, breaks my heart. One thing is for certain. They didn’t deserve her!!! She’s amazing! I consume violin music daily and she is the most inspirational person to me. I’ve told everyone about her since she began. I’ve always loved Lindsey. I’m incredibly proud of her and so glad she didn’t get accepted by them. She’s so much better off without them. This wasn’t her path and it is so much better that it wasn’t. She’s amazing
Those criticisms really hurt lol, really glad that she’s doing better now !! By the way, since you consume violin music daily, maybe I can introduce you to a band with a violinist? They make good songs and are really amazing! They have violin solos instead of guitar solos :)) The band name is LUCY. Here’s one of their songs! ua-cam.com/video/7ljGIA-if7A/v-deo.html edit: you can turn on the captions for English subs! :)
The criticism were completely accurate. The song sounded scratchy and terrible to the ear. The harsh criticism is probably what made her get better-and that’s what actually enabled her success. Pretending that something is good when it obviously isn’t doesn’t actually help people. British guy’s commentary sounded harsh, but was great feedback and spot on.
I feel like it was a sounds issue. The violin was too quiet and everything else was too loud, with that you can barely hear what it is supposed to sound like
It's her intonation, it's not the best and it's not helping that she's moving around like she is. It's rectangle tough to do what she does but it backs up what Pierce is saying.
The violin sound also sounded very bad audio quality which may have been a mic issue. There were some sour notes but not to the level of hate that she got from that judge
They chose a song, and dressed her like that to make her look bad because they didn't want a violinist in their show. That's so simple as that. She was so talented, she did everything she could, but the plan didn't include her.
@@Coolpotayto the producers, they do stuff like this all the time, there's tons of people who auditioned who were told by staff to say or do a certain thing or just straight up play a song the person auditioning isn't strong in against their wishes
Never heard of her before so she's definitely not "the most famous violinist out there"? Ever heard of Itzhak Perlman or Jennifer Koh? How about Hilary Hahn?
"You're not good enough to get away with flying through the air and trying to play the violin at the same time." Meanwhile, she is literally touring right now playing violin while doing aerial hoop/trapeze at the same time. She is LITERALLY flying through the air playing violin nowadays. Take that, AGT.
Well obviously she’s better now than 14 years ago. The judges had to evaluate the acts based on what they saw on the stage, not based on future potential..
@@tiiaramo Judge the act they set up to fail. Not a conspiracy theory, her costume and song choice was done by agt. They pitched the karaoke wrong. Not their first time doing this. After the PINK impersonator, I know better than to trust these shows
She is awesome she prob barely had time to practice this stuff. To do what she is doing requires hours of practice and she did it. Her show is amazing her albums are amazing. I love how none of them have talent but can speak on it. Sharon riding ozzy coattails. Sharon may have picked him up but ozzy put that together and made it a giant monster. I still find it absolutely hilarious when he did a song with post everyone saying post making ozzy famous 😂. Sorry guys ozzy turned more fans onto post not the other way around lmfao
Well it did actually. It’s a common phrase to say that violons sounds like rats when you don’t play it well. Plus she was out of tune and it was really squeaky. As a violinist, inspired by her itself, I would say she had a big gap to fill that time before auditioning. It wasn’t even average actually, it was really somewhere around 3 if rated from 10.
Came here after the music video for Eye Of The Untold Her where we can hear the words of Pierce in the background, like a reminder of how wrong he's been, how wrong they've all been because no, she doesn't need a group, and yes, she's good enough.
😢 I know me too and made me feel even more amazed about how brave and inspiring she is like an angel that God choose to help out anyone who may face or faced similar circumstances ❤
I went to a concert of her last night and the words of the jury were used as the opening: they played in the whole room while Lindsey walked on the stage and started playing. That was truly remarkable.
Piers is eating his words hard nowadays. Honestly not the best performance, but I'm assuming she didn't get to pick the songs. The producers definitely sabtoged her and that was the greatest thing they could have done for her career. She's an amazing star!
Yeah... I love her and used to think how the hell could they eliminate her but while I disagree with the criticism about stuff like needing a group and that she's not good enough I can see why she lost that one. She was still honing her craft. Not to mention she got the last laugh!
Idk how but I only found her recently and she's amazing ... even more respect for her now because she knew she had something so unique and she kept at it ! She's worked hard and she's a star now instead of letting the criticism crash her
Tbh just because she is now famous does mean this performance was worthy of her winning this show. Just because now I know how to do a bunch of things does not mean I was able to do them in the past. You learn from past mistakes and become better and that was what she did.
she is without a doubt my favorite violinist. I love the fact that she proved all their judgment wrong. I had a critic when I was 11years old that said I would never be able to play the violin. I wish I never believed him but now at 54 I am teaching myself to play the violin and I am so glad I am.
She didn't prove them wrong in any way. They said she was talented but all the jumping around made the musical aspect of the performance suffer, and they were absolutely right. She is an extremely talented violinist but this is a competition and this performance was not good enough.
@@amp788It's frustrating what kind of measures people count to create an idol "world-class" "best of coumtry best of talant". Lower pitch? Few notes missed? Art isn't about perfection, this show goes easy on judges cuz all the have to notice are imperfections other than that they can say "yes you are talanted but.."
There’s something wrong with the violin or maybe the base! But this is the proof that you should never judge yourself too harsh. One thing might go wrong, or even 2, 3, 10… but you should keep going if that makes you happy! Look at her now! ❤
Honestly, I really appreciate Howie and Sharon for being respectful and constructive. They don’t just tell her she just straight up isn’t good enough. They take the time to explain why it didn’t really work out tonight and Howie even congratulated her on making it here. Piers seems to take pleasure in telling people they suck or aren’t good enough if they don’t meet his self centered viewpoints. His word choices seem to imply that he doesn’t think she’ll ever get better or be able to do this kind of style. At least Sharon and Howie don’t try to disparage her. Piers Morgan. Professional douchebag. But on the bright side, Lindsey is a huge star now with a massive following and she stayed true to who she was; a dancing violinist.
howie and sharon werent sugar coating anything, they told her the truth without being douchebags.... meanwhile piers just told her she sucked because her style wasnt something that he'd normally listen too and i get that there a people around the world who do shit like this and we have to overcome it but just because thats how the world works doesnt mean its a good way and doesnt mean we cant change it@@abhaybhandary7010
@@abhaybhandary7010 He put her down saying he doesn’t think she could pull any of it off (implying never). That’s not constructive criticism, that’s encouraging her to give up on it. Constructive criticism would have been what the other two judges said.
Any instrument will match any song so long as they’re in key. It was the sound design and even if she missed notes, it doesn’t matter. Y’all know musicians miss notes in live concerts all the time
A world-class violinist!? No violinist does this without missing a note. Not world-class violinists. This is borderline impossible. The people who often pull this are faking. I don't know much about Lindsey but she's a great violinist.
@Hahshdhbcbcyoutube why do people have to be "world class talanted" to be talanted we wouldn't have any people trying to learn violin if it takes ages starting with being introduced to a violin and music early age to be able to place you under the bracket of best of the best and it's ussualy not due to the progress and talent or skill it's just the "My kid mastered violin at age 5" kind of shit that's makes judges like him think they really are eligible to compete amongst those of the same background
I'm here after her amazing new video telling the story of how she overcame not being good enough by growing into being more awesome than anyone could have believed.
He was right btw, i couldnt hear a shit of her violen, i didnt find any harmony with the choices of musics, and her violen realy sounded bad. He told her that she was not good enough; well 10 years later she wasnt, now she is ! Congrats Lyndsey, but , i agree with Piers on his judgment that day
Yeah I think it was down to a lot of factors 1) song choice 2) sound 3) violin couldn't be heard 4) she did sound like she missed some notes and I would put that down to her not having fully perfected her craft yet That said imo while the judges had some decent points about the performance I'm shocked they couldn't see the potential
@@madeleine5561they basically said they see potential, almost everyone. They gave some advices what they would do to improve. Pierce gave stupid comment, but he was not wrong, this was bad performance. As we can see happens to the best :)
It definitely wasn't the best performance. And it's clear that the arrangement wasn't made to show the violin, which is a problem. When you can't hear yourself because everything else is on top of you, that tends to happen. But she evolved so much in the last couple of years. Good for her!
I don’t agree with everyone saying “she’s better off” and “they were so wrong!” They were completely right, and it looks to me that, even if she cried afterwards, she took the constructive criticism and listened to every word, and because of that, she is now absolutely amazing!
Lindsey is truly amazing and so much talented. She is not only an amazing violinist , but also a beautiful singer and a great aerial dancer. man you should go to her concert and feel the vibe and energy.🔥❤
She didn't need to be a world class violinist. She didn't need a group. Don't take criticism of one moment for your career. Take it for that one moment, they didn't like her playing and she knew why.
Honestly, they're right. This was just not cutting it. Then she went on to work hard and improved her playing and also created her style, with the dance and acrobatics etc. She became a star..a viral sensation, a success story. But at this point, this just wasn't it. What she does now? Totally incredible. She needed this honest opinion and this defeat to go on to win bigger battles later.
Back then she did need work. She was definitely on to something and has major talent. She worked her butt off to improve and she has. Now she’s exactly where she needs to be. She’s perfected her craft. Her concerts are incredible!
Yo siempre he creido en ella y en sus posibilidades, me enfadé mucho con los jueces porque podina haber sido mas coherentes sin la dureza utilizada.Ella hizo un trabajo bueno que a ella le gustaba porque ella ve mucho mas allá de la musica pero no gustaba a los jueces,yo me fije en su habilidad con el instrumento, como lo ama y como lo mece con sus bailes al hacerlo sonar.ella transmitia humildad, sencillez y felicidad.Muchas veces solo nos fijamos si la melodia es bonita etc, cuando lo importante es el mensaje espiritual que nos puedan hacer llegar al alma aunque tan solo sea en algunas parte de la musica"Aquel que entiende la música comprende su alma y lo comparte".(No es lo mismo entender que comprender).Saludos a todos
Rewatched this after watching her new single & i gotta say she really took this critisism like a champ. It was really harsh "feedback" specially from the 1st judge. The 2nd judge was pretty hypocritical since they said they wanted something new but went on to say that she needed a singer/ a group (basically a band(?) :/ im really happy that she decided to keep on with her career on her own ❤ rarely any of the winners in AGT get going/ recognition in their career after the show. She honestly didnt need them. Been a fan since Crystalize 💙
Glad she came a long way and become so successful through other gigs ever since. So glad Piers and Sharon are no longer the judges, not to mention I’m glad Howie took over David Hasselhoff’s place
And she played the Royal Albert Hall in London last night. Which of them 3 can say they have had a standing round of applause from thousands of people who have oaid to see them.
Honestly, I think her violin was drowned out by the sound system of the show..... You didn't hear much of her playing at all.... But looking it at now, that rejection was a blessing in disguise for us all 🎶🥰👍
Honestly, as a sound tech myself, a lot of the pitchiness comes from the mix. They accused her of missing notes, but I truly can’t hear what notes are missing. Plus the fact that the judges wouldnt know either. Maybe they meant that some notes were flat or sharp? Which could be the case, except if you literally just slow the video down you can hear that they’re all on key. Lindsey’s solo music has figured out an amazing balance of volumes and tones. I think these three judges shown here all those years ago didn’t know it, but we’re actually talking to the sound techs. I think the violin was too loud (easy to do, violins are notoriously difficult to mix, especially if you’ve got hundreds of other acts to quickly mix as well), and i think an electric violin could’ve done the set more justice, since the gains and EQs can be more easily adjusted without losing the integrity of the instrument. For example if I played my acoustic guitar pretty loudly while playing an upbeat 90s song in the background, it would stand out like a sore thumb. It doesn’t fit in because it’s not mixed well. I obviously don’t know everything that happened that day, but that’s just what I observed to be some of the problems. No one asked for that, I just wonder if anyone had similar thoughts?
Also would like to add that non-sound techs aren’t trained to hear the problem, they just hear that something’s off. In this case it was the violin that sounded off, but not for the reason they thought. Thus concludes my ted talk.
she's said she's glad she lost it made her rethink everything, and well we see where's she at today! but IDk, im a huge fan! and never heard her violin sound that bad! also don't watch the show cause i believe they already know who they want. mix those 2 together and you get show sabotage! but who got the last laugh!! love your music Lindsey! keep rocking!
Hmm... I don't know about missing notes. I listened to it again and I don't think there necessarily were missing notes. The problem, I think, was that the violin kind of gets drowned out especially towards the end when the female voice starts singing. It's like my mind got distracted by that voice when it came on, and I lost the violin which should have been the star of the performance from beginning to the very end.
2:10 is the only good part because the songs and the violin didn't work together most of the time. even today i prefer her solo works over the ones with singing
She took the criticism, and used it to improve. I feel like she was stitched up by the show because they wanted someone else to win. It's like the difference between sound for the opening act and sound for the headliners. Sound engineers can make you either feel it in your feet, or in your stomach. This was done on purpose. But whatever, they were so wrong, especially Sharon. Lindsay isn't filling venues in Vegas, she's filling Arenas in London, New York and France.
Rejected because she tried something Different & unique but now see what that Different & unique had brought her 😌 #LindseyStirling is now one of the best hip hop violinists ❤
Let me tell you something, as a violinist, I will guarantee you it HURTS when you play fast-tempo songs and one the top of this shes moving, and this dude has to say "eh SoUndS likE StrAnggLiNG RATs" like bless her 👌👌👌👌👌👌( ik its not her best but still. credits
Este video lo vi hace años y me indigno ver y saber como en estos programas los humillan, para hacer más atractivo el espectáculo, no son algo agradable estos realitys, más que para darnos cuenta que hay gente maravillosa en todo el mundo con grandes talentos. Hoy 6 de sep 2023 regresé a buscar el video para mostrarselo a mi nieta de 5 años, que cuando deseas algo solo tienes que luchar por ello en contra de gente como los jueces o personas como ellos, que querer es poder y que es una de muchas lecciones de vida, que te enseña a alcanzar tus sueños en contra de las adversidades y conseguirlos. Amamos a Lindsey y la bebé la escucha desde que nació, hoy esta lista en su aprendizaje, para saber y conocer, cuanto lucharon grandes artistas de la ciencia, la literatura y el arte en general, para alcanzar la gloria en contra de gente como esta a la que llamaría "A5esino5 de sueños" Bravo, bravo, bravo, hoy esas lágrimas son consideradas un precio, justo por la gloria de la que hoy disfrutas y la lección que le enseño hoy a mi nieta es que siempre debes levantarte con la cara en alto y jamás permitir que nadie destruya tus sueños, porque todos podemos ser lo que queramos.
I'm shocked I think Lindsay was fantastic and talent like I've never seen before. Who can dance like that and play the violin. I think the judges are way too critical and need to lighten up.
Yes, she did missed one note or two... no, she was talented enogh already!. I went to her show in Argentina and was one of the best night of my life. As many here has said... the music was too loud to apreciate her perfonce.... but with time she got her truly stile. That was her mistake. Love you lindsey !!
for the judges who insulted his abilities, YOU CAN CRY NOW and will regret it for the rest of your life. because his violin playing has rocked the world. Lindsey Stirling - Carol of the bells 🔥
Heureusement qu'elle ne s'est pas arrêté là.. Grâce à sa détermination elle est riche connus elle fait ce qu'elle aime et elle fait kiffer le monde avec son violon je trop fan
I agree it wasn’t the best performance because everything else overshadowed her violin, but such criticism proved everyone wrong. She’s amazing, and I love her! She won in the end!
That criticism is garbage even in the moment. Piers Morgan is a loser.
She was too ambitious. A LOT of move were impossible with violon playing well.
@@bretagnejean2410 Her performance was great. That garbage review came from a garbage person.
she is way better than this it's just the song she picked, she should of picked one of her own
@@gustavodominguez6247 Her performance was well worthy of advancement. You're overthinking it. Piers Morgan is a tw*t.
To know that she cried for hours in the bathroom after this, completely shattered, breaks my heart. One thing is for certain. They didn’t deserve her!!! She’s amazing! I consume violin music daily and she is the most inspirational person to me. I’ve told everyone about her since she began. I’ve always loved Lindsey. I’m incredibly proud of her and so glad she didn’t get accepted by them. She’s so much better off without them. This wasn’t her path and it is so much better that it wasn’t. She’s amazing
shes awful... on violin. i cant judge her "dancing"
Those criticisms really hurt lol, really glad that she’s doing better now !!
By the way, since you consume violin music daily, maybe I can introduce you to a band with a violinist? They make good songs and are really amazing! They have violin solos instead of guitar solos :))
The band name is LUCY. Here’s one of their songs! ua-cam.com/video/7ljGIA-if7A/v-deo.html
edit: you can turn on the captions for English subs! :)
Where did you hear the part about her crying? I never knew that
@@jocelyn9058 yeah google it, it made me feel so sad for her
The criticism were completely accurate. The song sounded scratchy and terrible to the ear. The harsh criticism is probably what made her get better-and that’s what actually enabled her success. Pretending that something is good when it obviously isn’t doesn’t actually help people. British guy’s commentary sounded harsh, but was great feedback and spot on.
And she took it like a champ. She didn't crumble, she saw her weak points and worked them out.
Great artist, and greater person.
She did crumble. She said she had a breakdown in the bathroom afterward. But that’s ok because her feelings were valid.
@@musichealseveryone lol think ment on stage. She was fine until she went to the bathroom but she didn't show it in front of others.
@@Kt-cn2rq that's what I meant, thank you😊
She did….she was literally on the bathroom floor for hours
@@Kt-cn2rq sure, but even if she had broken down on stage, that would have been fine. Why should she have to hide her emotions?
I feel like it was a sounds issue. The violin was too quiet and everything else was too loud, with that you can barely hear what it is supposed to sound like
It's off key and off rythm. It's not that it's quiet.
Yeah it just sounded too messy. She does better without all the actual singing cause her violin does that for her
It's her intonation, it's not the best and it's not helping that she's moving around like she is. It's rectangle tough to do what she does but it backs up what Pierce is saying.
The violin sound also sounded very bad audio quality which may have been a mic issue. There were some sour notes but not to the level of hate that she got from that judge
No the sound guys did her dirty
She said she was glad she didn't win because she is now the most awesomest music artist out there in my book!!!
I never seen any of the American got talent winner being successful afterward which is crazy. It was the best thing for her to not win
she didnt need agt to get where she is now! she done it on her own!
She didn’t need a singer, she just needed more encouraging people around her
They chose a song, and dressed her like that to make her look bad because they didn't want a violinist in their show. That's so simple as that. She was so talented, she did everything she could, but the plan didn't include her.
By "they", you mean the judges chose the song? 😕
@@Coolpotayto the producers, they do stuff like this all the time, there's tons of people who auditioned who were told by staff to say or do a certain thing or just straight up play a song the person auditioning isn't strong in against their wishes
Wow. Humiliating people just to make it entertaining. Smh. 😑
In recent years AGT has actually gone to great lengths to get non-singers to win. Oh how the tables have turned…
Man. She is EXTREMELY talented with the violin. But she ruined it with the rest.
Annnnnnnnd 12 years later she's the most famous violinist out there with her own EPIC Konserts and... WOW.... The force was strong in this one! :)
Never heard of her before so she's definitely not "the most famous violinist out there"? Ever heard of Itzhak Perlman or Jennifer Koh? How about Hilary Hahn?
Joshua Bell >>>>
@@Cellulolytic what?
@@e.b.4379 she's definitely up there man
she isn't the most famous violinist. she's the most famous in what SHE does with the violin
there are others out there more famous than she is
"You're not good enough to get away with flying through the air and trying to play the violin at the same time."
Meanwhile, she is literally touring right now playing violin while doing aerial hoop/trapeze at the same time. She is LITERALLY flying through the air playing violin nowadays. Take that, AGT.
Well obviously she’s better now than 14 years ago. The judges had to evaluate the acts based on what they saw on the stage, not based on future potential..
@@tiiaramo Judge the act they set up to fail. Not a conspiracy theory, her costume and song choice was done by agt. They pitched the karaoke wrong. Not their first time doing this. After the PINK impersonator, I know better than to trust these shows
@@tiiaramo obviously the judges said rubbish
She is awesome she prob barely had time to practice this stuff. To do what she is doing requires hours of practice and she did it. Her show is amazing her albums are amazing. I love how none of them have talent but can speak on it. Sharon riding ozzy coattails. Sharon may have picked him up but ozzy put that together and made it a giant monster. I still find it absolutely hilarious when he did a song with post everyone saying post making ozzy famous 😂. Sorry guys ozzy turned more fans onto post not the other way around lmfao
I've seen her twice in concert.... and it wasnt cheap. She is an absolute all star and one of a kind..... She's beautiful..... Love her!!!!
Saw her one time and it was fantastic, magic! :-)
The violin did not sound like a bunch if rats being strangled. It was good. The other sounds did overshadow the violin but it didn't sound bad at all
it wasn't bad but it wasn't that good either
it sounded squeaky and out of tune
but still impressive
@@okboomer6724 I think it sounded bad cause the other sounds were making it unhearable
It sounded terrible.
Well it did actually. It’s a common phrase to say that violons sounds like rats when you don’t play it well. Plus she was out of tune and it was really squeaky. As a violinist, inspired by her itself, I would say she had a big gap to fill that time before auditioning. It wasn’t even average actually, it was really somewhere around 3 if rated from 10.
I think it sounded good.
Came here after the music video for Eye Of The Untold Her where we can hear the words of Pierce in the background, like a reminder of how wrong he's been, how wrong they've all been because no, she doesn't need a group, and yes, she's good enough.
😢 I know me too and made me feel even more amazed about how brave and inspiring she is like an angel that God choose to help out anyone who may face or faced similar circumstances ❤
I went to a concert of her last night and the words of the jury were used as the opening: they played in the whole room while Lindsey walked on the stage and started playing. That was truly remarkable.
He's not wrong tho, this was not her best 🤷♂️
At the time she was good, but this performance went really bad. Not judges fault, rather Lindsay's and people who helped her prepare it.
Piers is eating his words hard nowadays.
Honestly not the best performance, but I'm assuming she didn't get to pick the songs. The producers definitely sabtoged her and that was the greatest thing they could have done for her career. She's an amazing star!
And now she's one of the most famous violinists in the whole world and one of my biggest inspirations ❤️
OMG... This was really bad, and I didn't expect it to be. Good thing she decided to be strong and get better. She'a amazong now.
Yeah... I love her and used to think how the hell could they eliminate her but while I disagree with the criticism about stuff like needing a group and that she's not good enough I can see why she lost that one. She was still honing her craft. Not to mention she got the last laugh!
Idk how but I only found her recently and she's amazing ... even more respect for her now because she knew she had something so unique and she kept at it ! She's worked hard and she's a star now instead of letting the criticism crash her
She had such a great attitude about all of it. That AND….SHE PROVED THEM WRONG!! Love it ❤
I literally saw Lindsay flying through the air playing violin at her concert this week, she's soaring now! 🕊️
Tbh just because she is now famous does mean this performance was worthy of her winning this show. Just because now I know how to do a bunch of things does not mean I was able to do them in the past. You learn from past mistakes and become better and that was what she did.
Incredible that Lindsey kept going after this and that she developed her style in a place like Utah. She is a unique gem!
She still said thank you 😭😭😭 glad she proved them wrong in the end
Yep! F**k AGT!!!
she is without a doubt my favorite violinist. I love the fact that she proved all their judgment wrong. I had a critic when I was 11years old that said I would never be able to play the violin. I wish I never believed him but now at 54 I am teaching myself to play the violin and I am so glad I am.
She didn't prove them wrong in any way. They said she was talented but all the jumping around made the musical aspect of the performance suffer, and they were absolutely right. She is an extremely talented violinist but this is a competition and this performance was not good enough.
@@amp788It's frustrating what kind of measures people count to create an idol "world-class" "best of coumtry best of talant". Lower pitch? Few notes missed? Art isn't about perfection, this show goes easy on judges cuz all the have to notice are imperfections other than that they can say "yes you are talanted but.."
There’s something wrong with the violin or maybe the base! But this is the proof that you should never judge yourself too harsh. One thing might go wrong, or even 2, 3, 10… but you should keep going if that makes you happy! Look at her now! ❤
Honestly, I really appreciate Howie and Sharon for being respectful and constructive. They don’t just tell her she just straight up isn’t good enough. They take the time to explain why it didn’t really work out tonight and Howie even congratulated her on making it here. Piers seems to take pleasure in telling people they suck or aren’t good enough if they don’t meet his self centered viewpoints. His word choices seem to imply that he doesn’t think she’ll ever get better or be able to do this kind of style. At least Sharon and Howie don’t try to disparage her. Piers Morgan. Professional douchebag.
But on the bright side, Lindsey is a huge star now with a massive following and she stayed true to who she was; a dancing violinist.
I liked Sharon up until the point she said get a group with a singer
Well but piers told the truth not everything should be sugar coated
howie and sharon werent sugar coating anything, they told her the truth without being douchebags.... meanwhile piers just told her she sucked because her style wasnt something that he'd normally listen too and i get that there a people around the world who do shit like this and we have to overcome it but just because thats how the world works doesnt mean its a good way and doesnt mean we cant change it@@abhaybhandary7010
@@abhaybhandary7010 He put her down saying he doesn’t think she could pull any of it off (implying never). That’s not constructive criticism, that’s encouraging her to give up on it. Constructive criticism would have been what the other two judges said.
Sorry, but her violin really didn't match that song. She definitely has a better selection of songs these days that compliment her violin playing.
The EQ on the violin was awful
Any instrument will match any song so long as they’re in key. It was the sound design and even if she missed notes, it doesn’t matter. Y’all know musicians miss notes in live concerts all the time
They most likely chose the songs for her :/ I'm so glad she did her own thing instead
A world-class violinist!? No violinist does this without missing a note. Not world-class violinists. This is borderline impossible. The people who often pull this are faking. I don't know much about Lindsey but she's a great violinist.
Ikr
Dancing and playing the violin is not the same as playing a violin at a concert.
She's talentive!
@Hahshdhbcbcyoutube why do people have to be "world class talanted" to be talanted we wouldn't have any people trying to learn violin if it takes ages starting with being introduced to a violin and music early age to be able to place you under the bracket of best of the best and it's ussualy not due to the progress and talent or skill it's just the "My kid mastered violin at age 5" kind of shit that's makes judges like him think they really are eligible to compete amongst those of the same background
Her violin wasn't the problem. The background music was.
I'm here after her amazing new video telling the story of how she overcame not being good enough by growing into being more awesome than anyone could have believed.
He was right btw, i couldnt hear a shit of her violen, i didnt find any harmony with the choices of musics, and her violen realy sounded bad. He told her that she was not good enough; well 10 years later she wasnt, now she is ! Congrats Lyndsey, but , i agree with Piers on his judgment that day
The producers chose the song if im not wrong
@@vinnvii wait do the acts not choose their own songs
@@mehnotreallymyname3888 no
she wasn't bad, she was forced to humiliate herself with this horrible selections of songs
@@mfst4rg1rl wait do in a show that i need to showcase my talents. I don't choose the elements needed to showcase my talents.
Honestly that was awful, but not because of her. It was the song choices, how loud everything else was.
Feels like they sabotaged her on purpose.
Yeah I think it was down to a lot of factors
1) song choice
2) sound
3) violin couldn't be heard
4) she did sound like she missed some notes and I would put that down to her not having fully perfected her craft yet
That said imo while the judges had some decent points about the performance I'm shocked they couldn't see the potential
@@madeleine5561they basically said they see potential, almost everyone. They gave some advices what they would do to improve. Pierce gave stupid comment, but he was not wrong, this was bad performance. As we can see happens to the best :)
It definitely wasn't the best performance. And it's clear that the arrangement wasn't made to show the violin, which is a problem. When you can't hear yourself because everything else is on top of you, that tends to happen. But she evolved so much in the last couple of years. Good for her!
How DARE THEM TO DO SUCH A SING ! LINDSEY STIRLING IS THE BEST VIOLONIST EVER TODAYYYY !!!! that commercial TV show !! Believe in ur dreams !
The background music is louder than the sound of the violin can’t totally appreciate the act
I don’t agree with everyone saying “she’s better off” and “they were so wrong!” They were completely right, and it looks to me that, even if she cried afterwards, she took the constructive criticism and listened to every word, and because of that, she is now absolutely amazing!
Exactly it was true but there were better ways to tell her that
@aliaflow6877 Yeah. There were better ways to tell her. "Strangled rats" is just crazy.
@@tolulaiyemo81 that is absolutely true.
she has come so far. im glad she didnt give up after.
A fine example of how sometimes in life things happen for a reason and although it hurts like hell, there is a better path ahead 🥰😍
Lindsey is truly amazing and so much talented. She is not only an amazing violinist , but also a beautiful singer and a great aerial dancer. man you should go to her concert and feel the vibe and energy.🔥❤
i just watched her preform last night and the progress she’s had is so amazing
God did she prove them wrong, she is amazing sounds great and thank god she stayed solo she’s a legend
Everything happens for a reason. The criticism partially contributed to her success today 🌟 a trueee inspiration!!!
I'm so glad he was honest with her. It made her so much better. That performance was crap.
I saw her AGT performance and it was bad honestly.
Can’t imagine she grew from that low to this high. She is surely my favourite.
BRUH she lowkey ate the stage
She didn't need to be a world class violinist.
She didn't need a group.
Don't take criticism of one moment for your career. Take it for that one moment, they didn't like her playing and she knew why.
La música de fondo no dejó que se luciera su violín la opacó, ya era grande desde entonces pero no le ayudó la música
Honestly, they're right. This was just not cutting it. Then she went on to work hard and improved her playing and also created her style, with the dance and acrobatics etc. She became a star..a viral sensation, a success story. But at this point, this just wasn't it.
What she does now? Totally incredible.
She needed this honest opinion and this defeat to go on to win bigger battles later.
Agreed.
Look at her now. She definitely had the last word. I love lindsey❤
Back then she did need work. She was definitely on to something and has major talent. She worked her butt off to improve and she has. Now she’s exactly where she needs to be. She’s perfected her craft. Her concerts are incredible!
It really wasn’t that awful there were some weak points but we see her now and she made him regret it 😊
Mmm you can hear those strings barking back. She def needed practice but now she's a freakin beast
He really just knew he had to save her from Beyonce. He's secretly a hero
The joke is on the jury, she filled a concert hall last week in Frankfurt Germany and delivered an exciting performance
Yo siempre he creido en ella y en sus posibilidades, me enfadé mucho con los jueces porque podina haber sido mas coherentes sin la dureza utilizada.Ella hizo un trabajo bueno que a ella le gustaba porque ella ve mucho mas allá de la musica pero no gustaba a los jueces,yo me fije en su habilidad con el instrumento, como lo ama y como lo mece con sus bailes al hacerlo sonar.ella transmitia humildad, sencillez y felicidad.Muchas veces solo nos fijamos si la melodia es bonita etc, cuando lo importante es el mensaje espiritual que nos puedan hacer llegar al alma aunque tan solo sea en algunas parte de la musica"Aquel que entiende la música comprende su alma y lo comparte".(No es lo mismo entender que comprender).Saludos a todos
Esos Jueces estaban muy torpes, bailar, actuar y tocar el violín y a tal velocidad es complicadisimo, ella es única
13 years ago i loved her performance and I still do ❤️ she’s so talented
And now she tours the world!
From 2024 hre and Lindseys latest MV Eye of the Untold Her jst proves this wrong! The music overshadowed lindsey but still see how she's grown!
Now that I think of it I've never seen a violinist move at all while performing so she's really trying something different here!
She was the one who introduced me to violin and I loved it and picked it up because of her. I’m so glad she ended up the best and did not give up
She is so damn good this performance was great. I love her jason richardson collab too
It's the music in the background that gave a noisy combination
Rewatched this after watching her new single & i gotta say she really took this critisism like a champ. It was really harsh "feedback" specially from the 1st judge. The 2nd judge was pretty hypocritical since they said they wanted something new but went on to say that she needed a singer/ a group (basically a band(?) :/ im really happy that she decided to keep on with her career on her own ❤ rarely any of the winners in AGT get going/ recognition in their career after the show. She honestly didnt need them. Been a fan since Crystalize 💙
Glad she came a long way and become so successful through other gigs ever since. So glad Piers and Sharon are no longer the judges, not to mention I’m glad Howie took over David Hasselhoff’s place
She definitely has improved a lot. But they were really harsh on her
The last judge was probably the kindest…
and many years later she is coming to Istanbul to play at a full concert. Can’t wait for wednesday 😊
I saw her in concert 2 days ago and she started it with their negative comments. What a flex as it’s so obvious now they were wrong.
2:13 The coordination on her feet while playing the violin.. omg I could never
And she played the Royal Albert Hall in London last night.
Which of them 3 can say they have had a standing round of applause from thousands of people who have oaid to see them.
If they weren’t playing the background music and just the voice, it would have been INCREDIBLE. They really screwed her over.
Honestly, I think her violin was drowned out by the sound system of the show..... You didn't hear much of her playing at all.... But looking it at now, that rejection was a blessing in disguise for us all 🎶🥰👍
he makes a valid point.
Yeah they weren't wrong at all. Happy that things worked out though. 😊
Honestly, as a sound tech myself, a lot of the pitchiness comes from the mix. They accused her of missing notes, but I truly can’t hear what notes are missing. Plus the fact that the judges wouldnt know either. Maybe they meant that some notes were flat or sharp? Which could be the case, except if you literally just slow the video down you can hear that they’re all on key. Lindsey’s solo music has figured out an amazing balance of volumes and tones. I think these three judges shown here all those years ago didn’t know it, but we’re actually talking to the sound techs. I think the violin was too loud (easy to do, violins are notoriously difficult to mix, especially if you’ve got hundreds of other acts to quickly mix as well), and i think an electric violin could’ve done the set more justice, since the gains and EQs can be more easily adjusted without losing the integrity of the instrument. For example if I played my acoustic guitar pretty loudly while playing an upbeat 90s song in the background, it would stand out like a sore thumb. It doesn’t fit in because it’s not mixed well. I obviously don’t know everything that happened that day, but that’s just what I observed to be some of the problems. No one asked for that, I just wonder if anyone had similar thoughts?
Also would like to add that non-sound techs aren’t trained to hear the problem, they just hear that something’s off. In this case it was the violin that sounded off, but not for the reason they thought. Thus concludes my ted talk.
she's said she's glad she lost it made her rethink everything, and well we see where's she at today! but IDk, im a huge fan! and never heard her violin sound that bad! also don't watch the show cause i believe they already know who they want. mix those 2 together and you get show sabotage! but who got the last laugh!! love your music Lindsey! keep rocking!
She is cute. Can't believe they hate her.
She’s come a long way since this, to say the least. Thank godness she didn’t let this discourage her to pursue her dreams!
Hmm... I don't know about missing notes. I listened to it again and I don't think there necessarily were missing notes.
The problem, I think, was that the violin kind of gets drowned out especially towards the end when the female voice starts singing.
It's like my mind got distracted by that voice when it came on, and I lost the violin which should have been the star of the performance from beginning to the very end.
I think he was spot on with his assessment. I’m glad he didn’t lie and I’m glad she still went on to be successful.
This is Amazing. I am pretty sure 😮
2:10 is the only good part because the songs and the violin didn't work together most of the time.
even today i prefer her solo works over the ones with singing
She took the criticism, and used it to improve.
I feel like she was stitched up by the show because they wanted someone else to win. It's like the difference between sound for the opening act and sound for the headliners.
Sound engineers can make you either feel it in your feet, or in your stomach. This was done on purpose.
But whatever, they were so wrong, especially Sharon.
Lindsay isn't filling venues in Vegas, she's filling Arenas in London, New York and France.
The scene hair is so cute
Rejected because she tried something Different & unique but now see what that Different & unique had brought her 😌 #LindseyStirling is now one of the best hip hop violinists ❤
She really doesn't need a group 😊
“the most dangerous thing you can tell someone is good job”- Whiplash
The pop songs dont really leave enough room for the violin to shine
This makes me so convinced on the "pay to play" theory with competition shows
Let me tell you something, as a violinist, I will guarantee you it HURTS when you play fast-tempo songs and one the top of this shes moving, and this dude has to say "eh SoUndS likE StrAnggLiNG RATs" like bless her 👌👌👌👌👌👌( ik its not her best but still. credits
Everytime I watch this, I wanna cry. Why do I do this to myself??
Este video lo vi hace años y me indigno ver y saber como en estos programas los humillan, para hacer más atractivo el espectáculo, no son algo agradable estos realitys, más que para darnos cuenta que hay gente maravillosa en todo el mundo con grandes talentos.
Hoy 6 de sep 2023 regresé a buscar el video para mostrarselo a mi nieta de 5 años, que cuando deseas algo solo tienes que luchar por ello en contra de gente como los jueces o personas como ellos, que querer es poder y que es una de muchas lecciones de vida, que te enseña a alcanzar tus sueños en contra de las adversidades y conseguirlos.
Amamos a Lindsey y la bebé la escucha desde que nació, hoy esta lista en su aprendizaje, para saber y conocer, cuanto lucharon grandes artistas de la ciencia, la literatura y el arte en general, para alcanzar la gloria en contra de gente como esta a la que llamaría "A5esino5 de sueños"
Bravo, bravo, bravo, hoy esas lágrimas son consideradas un precio, justo por la gloria de la que hoy disfrutas y la lección que le enseño hoy a mi nieta es que siempre debes levantarte con la cara en alto y jamás permitir que nadie destruya tus sueños, porque todos podemos ser lo que queramos.
Watching here again for the EYE OF THE UNTOLD HER!
I'm shocked I think Lindsay was fantastic and talent like I've never seen before. Who can dance like that and play the violin. I think the judges are way too critical and need to lighten up.
Yes, she did missed one note or two... no, she was talented enogh already!. I went to her show in Argentina and was one of the best night of my life.
As many here has said... the music was too loud to apreciate her perfonce.... but with time she got her truly stile.
That was her mistake.
Love you lindsey !!
I bet he regrets that now seeing how successful she has become and he and the show don't get a cut of her success LOL
She improved since that BIG TIMES! Well done, Lindsey)
i fucking love it how lindsey proved them wrong xd
Is she the most famous violinist today?
They say all that but here i am years later excited to see HER tour she worked her ass off for. ❤❤❤
for the judges who insulted his abilities, YOU CAN CRY NOW and will regret it for the rest of your life.
because his violin playing has rocked the world. Lindsey Stirling - Carol of the bells 🔥
Heureusement qu'elle ne s'est pas arrêté là.. Grâce à sa détermination elle est riche connus elle fait ce qu'elle aime et elle fait kiffer le monde avec son violon je trop fan
Lindsey to Piers: every breath I take without your permission raises my self esteem
She is her own spark❤
Penampil sekeren ini saja masih di bilang kurang, tapi hebatnya dia TDK menyerah