Bang Dream VS Project Sekai Cover Song Battle
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 вер 2024
- Fandmade Bang Dream MV Credits:
1 2 Fanclub by BrinbMMD: • [MMD x BanG Dream!] 1...
Happy Synthesizer by AtAt0307: • 【MMDバンドリ】『ハッピーシンセサイザ（V...
King by AtAt0307: • 【MMDバンドリ】『KING(Vo.相羽あい...
Renai Saiban by AtAt0307: • 【MMDバンドリ】『恋愛裁判(Vo.伊藤美来...
Roki by AtAt0307: • 【MMDバンドリ】『ロキ Full Ver....
Six Trillion Years and an Overnight Story by bluejob01: • shiranai
Vampire by Emma V: • Vampire - Poppin’ Party
Venom by Mars Catubig: • 【MMDバンドリ】ベノム (Venom)【美...
I actually cry everytime the pjsekai vers gets the more negative remarks for the instrumentals because they're literally the original😭😭😭
Bro bandori came out in 2016 bro tell if you don't know bandori with out telling me you don't know bandori
@@Luna_nebula nah tell me you dont know vocaloid without telling me you dont know vocaloid, not trying to start a fight here but most of project sekai's vocaloid covers instrumentals are the same as the actual song
that's quite literally possible???that someone likes a remade version of an instrumental better???cause it situationally is???
@@Luna_nebula tell me you dont know vocaloid without telling me you dont know vocaloid
@@Luna_nebula but vocaloid-
i really like the bandori covers actually as someone who doesn't play it, but i have to agree that it drove me crazy to comment on prsk's arrangements sticking too close to the originals because they literally ARE the originals. that's their schtick since they're part of official vocaloid stuff. it's completely fair to say you like the remix stuff better but it's not like prsk is rerecording everything to make zero changes
Idk if it’s just my extreme bias for pjsk, but the bandori instrumentals all sound so messy and unorganized, even the vocals even when better still sound messy and I’m not sure why
im a pjsk player and have never played bandori before, but i still prefer the bandori covers most of the time
the vocals are just so strong and good i love it 😭😭😭
I love Bandori covers but fans who like the Bandori covers sometimes are just harsh when somebody likes prjsk covers better😭
I think that by the end it comes to your music taste. if you like more to stick to the original, you will probably prefer prjsk, and if not, then bandori. But you can also like both or neither! :)
Meanwhile the prsk vampire cover that is sang lower
I'm pretty sure that the instrumentals for project sekai are the originals !!
Yeah they are so basically proseka isnt even changing the composition or instrumentals thats the original song 💀
Some of the instrumentals have been remastered but most are the same more or less
A good example would be night sky patrol of tomorrow. It sounds significant different to the original (and possibly the remake orangestar posted as well)
Akito and Toya’s cover for Dramaturgy isn’t the cover you hear in game for project SEKAI. Ichika and Miku are the actual characters who sung it in the official cover in game. There’s this “archives” thing (I think it’s only for Vivid bad squad?) that has 5 in-game songs that aren’t originally covered by the members. You can find it in the official Japanese UA-cam channel of project SEKAI.
Vbs archives are still coming out its just additional content
thats what she mentioned at the start
I agree with your opinion for sure but to the bandori fans reading this, why do most of you start attacking when someone chooses project sekai cover instead? I got attacked in multiple occasions when i said i prefer project sekai cover. Dont get me wrong, i play both games and I'm a fan of both games but i just dont understand
As a Bandori fan I apologize for you getting attacked for having a different opinion.
But as for the main reason, people think that liking music is an objective standpoint instead of a subjective one and think that thier opinion is right. Some Bandori fans can't accept when another rythem game does a "better" version of the cover and the same can be said for some Project Sekai Fans.
For example I was attacked by some Project Sekai fans in a comparison video just because I said that I prefer Bandori's Daybreak Frontline, Dramathurgy or Lost One's Weeping over Project Sekai's.
In any case both fandoms have thier bad apples and I'm sorry you have to encounter Bandori's bad apples.
@@Blue-Code im glad you gave me a proper reasoning and i also apologize to you that you encountered some bad fans. Thank you. I completely agree btw bandoris dramaturgy is more preferable than pjsk s version
I think i like King's original intrumental better ! I think i fits more with the image i have of this song ! I feel like Roselia's intrumental is just a little TOO MUCH for this one !
Nahh it was actually better
I mean pjsekai has better originals than covers so
into the night is a heavy pjsekai sweep any day, not only is kanade and miku's version really well done, but so are the other 5 versions of the song that pjsekai put out.
HELP THE CLIP YOU USED FOR ROSELIA ON SIX TRILLION YEARS AND AN OVERNIGHT STORY
it's actually so funny how, as a passive fan of both, i found myself disagreeing with your opinion at basically every turn LMAOOOO
still a very nice video! i appreciate getting to hear not only your preference but exactly how you feel about each rendition
Tbh project sekai cover doesn’t really change much beside the vocal mostly music is the literal same as the original (also it’s not nightcord 2500 it’s nightcord at 25:00 as a time)
Yeah I noticed that with most of the project sekai covers, usually when they won it was because the vocalists gave a really good performance
This isn't about the rating, and i'm sure you have already noticed this, but it's nightcord at 25:00 (the time) not 2500 ( also you are 100% correct with yori ni kakeru)
I’m pretty sure you can pronounce military time by saying x:xx hundred hours
@@Sam_8558 oh, thanks for letting me know
Actually, Dramaturgy has two groups covering it. Vivid bad squad for JP and Leo/need for En so basically your opinion might change or not. Since some songs have different units covering them, I hope you try to listen to Dramaturgy covered by Leo/need since it's not really fair. Some En players get confused and want to see Leo/need's performance. I knew about this since I play on En and when I realized that Vivid bad squad was the one who covered it here. I wanted you to rate the Leo/need ver aswell
roselia's instrumental of charles is just so superior to any other redemption, even in comparison to the original. actually, i used to dislike this song until i heard roselia's cover of it bc it's just so incredibly done, the vocals are amazing as always, but really what sells their cover as the best of all versions of charles is indeed the instrumentals kjsdnkdg
This feels a bit biased (probably just me though, and this is from someone who used to be a big Bandori fan)
i absolutely dislike whoever plays dramaturgy with the VBS cause they're not true covers. It's specifically called on the wiki, VBS Archive
I really like how bandori changes songs as if they are their covers. Proseka -most of the time- sounds like the music has nothing special. Yes I definitely love proseka vocals but they're just singing with the original song nothing special. Meanwhile, bandori really changes it and their version is always so exciting to listen. I overall definitely prefer bandori songs more. Because of yk strong vocals. (I play both of the games over 1.5+ year so I can finally write this)
I agree, Bang Dream’s rock arrangements are definitely the strongest aspect of their covers
bandori vas more scream than sing(
@@the_tapkawdym?
@@ILoveFriess their voices sound strained as if they are singing with all their might in a bad way
i find it hard to perceive voices that sound so strained. not all bandori's seiyuus have this problem but most of them do
@@the_tapka i see it with afterglow too but there are different types of singing voice and it doesn't make it bad it really comes downt to personal tastes
13:58 TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED??? LMFAO IT'S LIKE 25:00 A HOUR
Bandori is too powerful 😭
I can't see any music franchise winning them anymore
Roselia especially since I think they won all of their battles lol
“If it’s a 1 on 1, always bet on Roselia”
Dramaturgy is covered by leo/need,im pretty sure the vbs one is archived (ichikas cover will never be topped idc) imo king wxs is better,the instrumental for roselia was better but rui and tsukasas vocals are better imo. also i feel as if for project sekai it lowers the chance of winning because bandori doesn't have the vocaloids along with the whole band,the vocaloids often ruin the cover in my eyes,also with vivid bad squad i really hate kohanes voice so that always deducts points (no hate to va)
Songs that won't ever topped from pjsk:
Venom
Villain
King
Roki
Dramaturgy
Buriki no dance
Imo Roselia's Six Trillion Years is too much. Its like a 14 yo pretending to be a rockstar in their room. I know the song is meant to be intense but Ichika and Miku have the og instrumental, which is much less cluttered and chaotic than Roselia's. The Roselia instrumental almost irritates me because it distracts from the vocals, which are amazing.
okay but fun fact goddbye sengen is one of the most hated cover in prsk
huh why?? (mb for necroposting lmao
as bandori player i like dramaturgy and asu yozora from leo need more than VBS
I hate strong vocals.....
YUKINAAAAAAAA 😍😍😍
ROSELIA SOLOOO
I spend more time at sekai, and yet it's somehow more familiar. but in some, bandori still sounds more plausible.
I wanna list my opinion as to which i think is better 2 so yaya ( ALSO IT’S WHICH I THINK SOUNDS BETTER, THIS VIDEO DOES A WAY BETTER JOB AT RATING IT THAN ME)
1. Pjsk
2. Bandori (losing just barely to pjsk in my mind set, the bandori is so jammy wammy)
3. Pjsk (I adore the vocals here for some reason)
4. Pjsk (The cover with ena and mizuki is so dear to me for some reason and idk why)
5. Pjsk (I’ll for sure have to listen to the full song to make sure my opinions pjsk but yeah)
6. Pjsk (I adore emus voice) ((I feel like im being mean to bandori 😭))
7. Pjsk (AHHHH) (yummy)
8. Pjsk (idk how to explain it but pjsk (gives off a warm feel to me that makes me feel happy)
9. Pjsk (OKAY BANDORI IS SO ENERGETIC AND I LOVE IT- but the pjsk cover makes me so happy, and same as the person in the video, it was the first cover i hears.)
10. PJSK!! (:3)
11. Pjsk (the love trial cover by pjsk will always be my favorite, love trial is so dear to me-)
12. Pjsk (idk how to explain it, but the pjsk one seems like it has more? defo not more but i dont have better words.)
13. Pjsk (ROKI ROKI ROKI!) ((I feel so mean rrr- i’ve picked so many pjsk covers over the bandori ones, im sorry bandori fans.)
14. Pjsk (im gonna feel real bad if my next opinion is pjsk again.)
15. Pjsk (🥹)
16. Pjsk (I SWEAR MY NEXT OPINION WILL PROB BE BANDORI OVER PJSK)
17. Pjsk (Help.)
18. Pjsk (I’m)
(HOW DID MY BRAIN ONLY LIKE 1 OF THOSE?)
How are yall mad about covers😭🤔🤔🤔
When it comes to Charles I love both but somehow I prefer Vflower's lmfao
roselia on top
11:19 MrBeast
So I’m a vocaloid fan aswell as a person who comes from a family of professional musicians, witch is why I don’t like bandori covers, they sound like they are constantly hurting themselves (the main reasons I also hate Leo/needs cover of lost one’s weeping as well as the vocals not even matching up) by stretching their vocals, and all the vocals also sound so similar that it’s hard to appreciate each individual voice. And the vocaloid fan in me has more irrational feelings because I massively prefer original instrumentals, and while it is perfectly reasonable to like the different instrumentals I just have wayyyyy to much nostalgia for the original songs, and that’s why I’m a stupid autistic person who hyper fixates on the tiniest details😂
as a project sekai fan, i see your points!! but i guess im too used to the pjsk covers, and i usually dont listen to very loud music (like the covers in bandori) so that’s probably why i’ll have to agree to disagree with some of your opinions. also, by “loud music” i mean how the voices in bandori are high pitched.
Idk what some of these comments r on, u can be critical of project sekai’s instrumental even its the original. For some songs bandori’s rock instrumental is so much better, like Charles and King. Just because pjsk has original instrumentals doesn’t mean you can’t critique it. Most of the criticism is that there isn’t much going on. And how bandori takes a much more punky rock approach that makes some of the instrumentals boast the song in so many ways.
Don't forget cover unichord
UniChØrd cover will always be superior
There is no way you just said yoru ni kakeru is about suicide
It is
As a bandori and proseka fan both covers are the best
imo bandori covers r pretty much universally better than pjsk tbh. vocals are better, plus full band covers of vocaloid songs are such a treat
this is,,, pretty biased
i can't talk, i'd give all the wins to proseka
i hope you know an opinion is literally also a bias towards the one you prefer..it’s the definition of an opinion you can’t have one with out bias
did u read my reply to myself
@@boknyangzisn't that also biased?
@@SaijoClaudine read my reply to myself pleek
12:08 WHAT IS THIS MV LMFAO
It's amazing
Bandori be in the negatives☠☠☠☠☠
fr
ik they cant even make original songs cause their too lazy☠
i play both proseka and bandori but proseka is definetly better
So you guys don't like Bandori?
@@H4Z3LLL ..... I'm not a bandori fan but I know they made originals. Please do some research.