I guess the main difference is that Bandori tries to play stronger and more powerful voices, and in project sekai they just sing with their feelings, everything feels more calmy, like in a SEKAI
Also, the background music in Bandori is almost always recreated, usually with rock instrumentals (except in Pastel*Palettes, Hello, Happy World!, occasionally Poppin’ Party, and sometimes Morfonica’s covers). Although in a few cases, the instrumental of the Bandori cover sounds very similar to the original
Bandori mostly powerful in their instrumentals. They make and use their own unique style of composing the songs of each bands. As for Project Sekai. Most of them sang together, it creates this calming voice that i can't even explain
Yeah, since its bands in bandori i guess it makes sense but i think bandoris also have a lot of feelings put into it... (ik that maybe you didnt mean it didnt but qnyways)
Literally no, the only “powerful voices” in bandori are aiai, raychell and ayane. Btw Tomori’s va has more emotions in her voice than any pjsk character
my take on the main "difference" is that bandori is the type of music that would SLAP to be heard live, like at an actual show where they're playing their instruments. i think sekai's on the other hand is more "studio" music, with refinement rather than rawness. both are good! (on top of that i think it's why bandori girls have more energetic + louder voices, it's actually super hard to sing soft when you're tired! it's much easier to sing loudly)
Bandori is definitely more unique in the sense that they aren't just vocal covers, but they remake the whole arrangement to a rock group to fit them, and I'd say most of them work better, I like the Deepsea Girl cover more, as well as God-ish and Alien Alien etc. But sometimes the Pjsk cover is just better like in Telecaster B boy or Dreamin Chu Chu, mainly because the vocal fits more
As a very avid pjsk player I have to say, both covers of every song are SO GOOD like my jaw has dropped with a lot of the bandori covers bc they are so good. How about everyone is happy and hold hands and agrees what every cover is amazing in its own way and we all YIPPIEE
As someone who listens to Bandori and pjsk music on the daily, here are my two cents: The direction in song arrangement between the two games are apparent when you think about what both games market. Covers in Bandori is arguably why the series was able to take off. It cemented the whole ‘VAs playing in a live band’ the project had going. It’s also a way to showcase a bands particular sound which is something I really like about Bandori. And a bit off-base, but this is why I like to pay more attention to a song’s instrumental and not just the vocals. While occasionally pjsk will also change a songs arrangements, covers tend to remain faithful to the original in both instrumental and vocal direction to cater towards vocaloid fans and vocaloid’s rich history. Vocaloid is built off of the community and the creativity of its producers, and pjsk (at least the way I see it along with project DIVA & MIRAI) is a celebration of Vocaloid and its cultural impact. These different directions have their ups and downs. Bandori covers can enhance the sound of the original song with a band’s unique sound, if not at least a refreshing new sound to the formula. Covers can be hit or miss because perhaps the vocalist or their voice direction doesn’t quite fit or mesh well with the song. Same goes for instrumentation. It’s experimental and there’s bound to be some duds where the delivery didn’t quite land the way people want to. The band formula too may not be to everyone’s liking, with most covers being predominantly sung by the band’s lead vocalist. Pjsk covers having more vocalists allows for impressive vocal harmonies when done right as it can give songs more power. The fact that pjsk has male singers is something they have over bandori, having a better variety of vocalists in their songs. Sometimes, however, I feel the vocalists are held back by the limits of the original song, such that they don’t come out as powerful due to how the original song was tuned compared to what they’re musically capable of. Regardless, when it comes to whether you’d listen to one cover over another is personal preference, nothing to think too hard about. And for any reason too. I don’t like Afterglow’s cover of ‘Hated by life itself’ because of how much of a departure it is to the orignal song, but I *love* their ‘Night Sky Patrol’ for the same reason. I think I’ve rambled on enough so it’s about time I got to my comparisons of the Bandori & pjsk covers. I do wanna preface, I’m more biased to Bandori as that’s I game a started with back in 2019 (I also listen to a lot of Guilty Gear so I’m a bit of a J-rockhead). I’m hoping I can give a fair explanation for all these entries. - 1. Children Record: Despite what I’ve just prefaced, I want to give this song to *Vivid Bad Squad* . The song itself is already amazing (J-rockhead) and all of vbs are incredible vocalists. Afterglow’s cover is quite interesting, I really like Ran’s falsettos, but I much prefer the high energy from vbs’ cover, especially when It comes to the chorus. 2. Ego Rock: Both covers are quite fun but this one goes to *Wonderlands x Showtime* . I love the line distribution between the wxs cast, and I’m more of a fan of pjsk’s instrumental to hhw’s. 3. Hibana - Reloaded -: I’ve got a bias for this, but it’s not towards Roselia. This song is what made me really appreciate Ichika (CV. Nogachi Ruriko) as a vocalist and the duet with Miku is phenomenal. This cover is what got me to listen to Leo/need more and they’re now my favourite unit. Credit where credit is due, Roselia’s cover is just as amazing. I love the addition of the strings in typical Roselia fashion, and Yukina’s (CV. Aiba Aina) performance is just as incredible. But I love this cover for Ichika so this song goes to *Leo/need* . 4. Villain: This one’s tough. On one hand, Afterglow’s rock rendition of this song slaps, and Ran’s vocals work unexpectedly well too. She really made it her own song. But on the other hand, MizuMafu’s vocals fit this song to a T, from both the songs instrumental and theming. Screw it, I’m gonna give it to *both* of them. 5: Melancholic: This is one is a very close tie but I think I’m gonna give it to *Poppin’Party* . There’s nothing wrong with MMJ’s cover, actually both covers sound quite similar, but I love how poppy and lively Kasumi’s (CV. Aimi) vocals are. Don’t know, maybe it’s first-heard basis. Feel free to argue with me on this one. 6. God-ish: I have not listened to this song beforehand, or at least not that much. Bro, that small snippet of *RAS’* cover blew me away. Bassline? Slaps. Synths? Electrifying. LAYER (CV. Raychell)? BEAUTIFUL! Now there’s a point to be made that the heavy rock and electronic sound goes against the integrity of PinocchioP’s arrangement. Fair. But BROOOOOOOOOOOOOO THIS COVER FUCKS. 7. Telecaster B-boy: So I just read the lyrics of this song for the first time, bro this song is pro-trans? Didn’t know surii was chill like that. Anyways, this song goes to *Wonderlands x Showtime* . Afterglow’s rock cover is definitely interesting but not my favourite performance from them. Plus, the song felt like it was made for five people with how wxs sung it. Those guys are naturals. 8. Kyoufuu All Back: This song is goofy and I don’t think one particularly out performs the other. *Both* win. 9. Dreamin Chuchu: Now I don’t know how to clearly explain this but hear me out. The thing with Pasupare (ft.Kanon)’s cover is that it gives me too much diabetes that it could kill me. *MMJ’s* cover is like just right with the diabetes. 10. Otome Dissection: Another song I haven’t listened to much, though I think I should. This one is also tough for the same reason as Villain. Yukina’s vocal game is on point but at the same time, MizuMafu. Both instrumentals are snazzy too. I think I’m gonna give it to *Roselia* because not only can Yukina hit those high notes like a boss, those fuck ass jazz strings during the chorus is reminding me of Persona 5. Brownie points, bass slapping also on point👌. 11. Non-breath oblige: Like with God-ish, I wasn’t really a fan of this song. Then *MyGo* happened. The slow rock beat, the distorted chords but most importantly the clean guitar counter-melody to Tomori’s vocals 😩. Takamatsu Tomori (CV: Youmiya Hina) when I get you. The sense of desperation I feel from her voice and those high notes were immaculate. 12. Kyu-kurarin: Despite what others say, I want to give this song to *Hello, Happy World!* . Yes, the song sounds too happy for what it’s about, but ‘I’ find it funnily ironic how energetic it is. Like I think this cover has unfortunately physically altered how I listen to this song. Thing is, I can’t find any faults with MMJ’s cover other than, idk, MEIKO singing too long but that’s just being unfair. 13. Bocca della Verità: Can someone tell what this song is about? Like, as someone who often falls to low self-esteem, hearing a song go ‘I hate you’ be putting me off because like man what did I even do 😭. As for the covers, I’m just gonna say *RAS* . Same situation with God-dish where LAYER’s vocals and the electronic metal arrangement blows this song out of the park. I know this sounds like I’m copping out but I do not have strong feelings for this song. 14. Yoidore Shirazu: This song is so right up *Vivid Bad Squad’s* alley it’s unfair. I want to give credit to Roselia’s cover as it’s quite a departure from their usual style. Like, I don’t usually hear such clean strumming from the guitar in Roselia songs. And hey, they nailed that cover. But you look me straight in the face that you’d rate vbs’s harmonies below that. Slayed, they have. That is all. 15. Bad Apple!!: This one’s interesting as both Roselia and Nightcord have unique takes on this monumental song. I can’t describe well other than do you like rock or edm with a sick ass piano… now that I’ve laid it out as that, I’m gonna give this to *Nightcord* . That piano is really good. 16. Tokyo Teddy Bear: Believe it or not, I’ve never listened to this before too and I think that’s a sin. Once again, this one’s tough because I’ve got no preference for this song. If I were to compare, what I like in Roselia’s cover over Leo/need is the instrumentation. I think the strings adds a lot to this piece, but not so much that I’d prefer Roselia’s over Leo/need. In the same vain, the line distribution in Leo/need’s cover creates a lot of interest to the song’s benefit over Yukina’s solo performance, but Yukina didn’t do a bad job either. Imma leave this up in the air and so *both* win because I’d be debating over myself for hours otherwise. 17. QUEEN: I’m with others on this that Colopale should’ve changed the key for EmuNene’s cover. I’m an Emu vocalist defender, my girl sounds beautiful, but imagine if colopale lowered the key like in Morfonica’s cover. It would’ve been perfect 👌. So in case you haven’t guessed, I’m giving this song to *Morfonica* . Not only does the lower key complement Mashiro’s (CV: Shindou Amane) voice, the violin counter-melody just ties everything together. Solid. So overall, Bandori: 7 PJSK: 7 Both: 3 Did not expect to end on a tie! Kind of poetic. Again, to you who read through this whole thing, feel free to argue against any of my points because I was admittedly slack with some of these songs. Both games have good songs and you can listen to whatever you want to so don’t let anyone who says otherwise deter you. Have a good rest of your day!
@@Nahida-saving tldr; Music comes down to preference for all manner of reasons. It's important to respect other's opinions so we as a community can engage in friendly discussion in orderly conduct. My scoring ended up in a tie. I gave seven songs to Bandori, seven to pjsk, and three songs I made a tie.
I ABSOLUTELY LOVE BANDORI AND PROSEKA. LIKE, IT IS STUPID HOW MUCH I LOVE THE BOTH OF THEM. ( I’m a bandori OG(/hj), been playing since the ojamajo doremi collab )
TWINNINGGG i love both of them sm, both have so much depth to their music and i fear people only focus or hate on one aspect but ignore the other good ones 😢 i've played since ojamajo doremi too omg such old times 💔
IT MAKES ME SO SAD TO SEE PPL HATE ON BOTH GAMES I LOVE THEM SO MUCH 😭😭 they both have well written characters and amazing music. i also main bandori but i still love both games a lot
my jaw dropped at most of these bandori covers like what?? the arrangements and vocals are just soo good💥 0:30, 1:30 (😵), 2:30 (DAMN ive been replaying this for like 5 mins help im stuck), 3:30, 4:30, 5:00 (DAMN), 6:00
the main thing I noticed is that Bandori’s vocals are all either very strong or super cute. While pjsk is more diverse, only one character can really match Bandori’s strength there is no better or worse, just general tastes: if you like strong vocals, go to Bandori, if you prefer diverse vocals, go to pjsk, you can go to both if you have enough storage I personally prefer pjsk since I like the diversity, but I can understand why some would prefer bandori :)
@@Half-Asleep-i1z I agree with this altho I would like to add ena/mafuyu/ichika, they are more on the wider range while mizuki is also one but more on the powerful side
Personally, you can feel the "rawness" in Bandori's covers because they only require one or two vocals singing the song whereas in PJSK the arrangement makes it sound so compressed at times making it sound a bit off in a way. Either way, I love both games!
The thing I love about the bandori covers is that the music arrangements are put to where they try to match the song to that person singing it and bring a new spin to the original song. Not to mention that it’s just the va singing (and I know that sekai is based on the vocaloids so of course they’re gonna be in the song but you would think the tuning would be better in some of them). There’s a lot of covers that I love in sekai, but the tuning sometimes doesn’t fit with the va
ok so i strongly believe we will get emunene separate alts for queen. queen was obviously added to mirror king, which has riks alts already. why not give them alts to mirror king even more?
As someone who adores both games, I honestly think it depends on which song is being covered and the direction. Bandori’s arrangements and intense vocal delivery lends itself so so so nicely to songs like God-ish and Queen. That being said, sometimes the direction falls flat like in Ego Rock, where it lowkey sounds like Kokoro was holding back her energy, and in Shoujorei which was too upbeat for the song and the vocals were kinda “shouty” and in your face. The same could be said about puroseka though. I adore the suave vocals in Yoidore Shirazu and the direction used for their Non-Breath Oblige cover where it sounds delicate and nostalgic, yet in covers like Queen Emu’s voice doesn’t really lend well to the song. Same thing in Melancholic and Tokyo Teddy Bear, where the mixing and tuning are kinda off plus the fact that Tokyo Teddy Bear lacks the intensity needed. TL;DR Idk it just depends on what the song needs and both of the games have different strong suits in terms of vocals, arrangements, and mixing and these strengths pop out depending on the song but I love both of these games they’re both super dear to me
5:32 i had a hard time choosing which i liked more Hello happy world feels full and bright. I really like it... But more more jump feels more melancholic and in character with the original songs
I don't like hello happy cover. It feels so happy and bright for a song like kyu kurarin. I mean it supposed to a song about depression, why Kokoro sing it like it's a very positive and happy song. The arangement are to much for me, it feels like the original arangement but with more disonances. So my ear can't really enjoy the combination of Kokoro sing so bright and the disonances of the arangement. I perfer MMJ cover. No hate to both game.
i love both covers so much!! bandori's arrangement for kyu-kurarin's is so good and mmj's vocals are so soothing. if u told me to pick one i'd choose to die. 😭😭😭 i feel like they both sound very dream-like in their own ways (especially if you listen to both full vers...begging for you guys to listen to both full vers...) i also love the original ver a lot so that's probably why i love both of these covers 😅
@@RisunersIDi like the hhw one the most because Kokoro's VA sound happy and its like it says in the song, shes trying to be happy while shes sad. (Thats what I get from the song btw idk how to explaij in words....) I think the instrumentals are also very melancholic and kinda scary in the bandori one too so i relaly like this one
THANK YOUUUUU❤❤❤on the whole I prefer Bandori as the band set up and usually one main vocalist is more my thing ~ but both are amazing! It’s strange because I love Bandori covers more but I’m a huge vocaloid fan … 5:02 MASTERPIECE!!!!! Tomori is amazing and her voice actor is amazing and the song suits her SO WELL !!!!!
30: ViVid Bad Squad 31: Wonderland X Showtime 32: Leo/Need 33. Afterglow and 25-ji 34. Poppin' Party 35. Raise a Suilen (No doubt) 36. Wonderland x Showtime 37. hello happy world and wonderland x showtime. 38. Pastelles Palette. 39. Roselia 40. MyGO!!!! And 25-ji 41. More More jump (i prefer the sad tone) 42. Raise a Suilen 43. Vivid Bad Squad 44. Roselia and 25-ji 45. Roselia 48. Morfonica
it’s time to give my (unwarranted) opinions again!! 30. children record - proseka. i love the contrast between anhane+akitoya’s voices, as well as the higher key. (however, i also acknowledge that aglow is covering the reboot, so the covers are bound to sound super different) 31. ego rock - proseka. i prefer the higher key, og instrumentals, and overall vocals in wxs’ cover. plus, len is tuned suuuper good (which isn’t surprising, he’s usually the ONLY vocaloid they’re consistently good at tuning) 32. hibana - proseka. roselia’s instrumentals are always super hard-hitting, but in this instance, i prefer deco*27’s lighter ones. plus, miku is tuned well here (rare sega w!) 33. villain - proseka. i usually love aglow’s renditions of so gs, but something about teniwoha’s use of “odd” instrumentals is so good that his sounds sound off WITHOUT them. plus, i like how mizumafu are singing softer than ran, simply because of the message of the song. (also, trans-coded character singing trans song lol) 34. melancholic - bandori. i like how energetic and upbeat kasumi sounds here, which kinda makes mmj’s cover sound bland compared to it. plus, the high notes (which i think is the keyboard? if so, common arisa w) compliments kasumi’s voice super well 35. god-ish - bandori. oh my lord i love layer so much it’s actually insane. usually, i prefer tamer god-ish covers because it makes the last chorus slap especially hard when all of the drums and instruments kick in. but ras always does so well with rock-type songs and i love it. plus, niigo’s cover is RUINED by miku’s presence. the cover would literally be so good if it weren’t for miku; she clashes so hard with the girls’ vocals, and the mixing is so bad. this was even proved because of mizumafu’s alt vocals that came out-they sound amazing! it’s literally miku that brings the whole cover down 36. telecaster b-boy - proseka. ran sounds a tad too upbeat when singing this song, considering the more somber lyrics. i prefer the lower key in wxs’ cover, as well as the more lowkey instrumentals. (also, common w len tuning as per usual) 37. kyofuu all-black - proseka. it’s super close, but it all comes down to my preference of singing. kokoro tends to sing super “bouncy” (for lack of a better term) which helps her a lot (ex: alien alien, darling dance)-but in some cases, like here, it’s totally offputting from the song itself. 38. dreamin chuchu - proseka. idk why, but the tempo in pasupare’s cover sounds weird to me 😭 like, the cover’s rlly good, but something about the chorus sounds off-putting to me 39. otome dissection - bandori. this was also super hard to settle on, but in the end, i love how powerful yukina sounds here. the only nitpick with niigo’s cover that i have is how jarring the switch to miku’s voice sounds sometimes, but even that isn’t a big deal to me. 40. non-breath oblige - proseka. i love tomori sm, she’s my favorite vocalist-but i prefer the softer angle that niigo goes for. it makes the song sound very personal, as if they’re singing the lyrics to me specifically, and i just love it. 41. kyu-kurarin - proseka. the drums in hhw’s cover is entirely too loud for this song imo, and it overshadows what’s supposed to be the high-pitched keyboard, which is what brings the whole song together imo. 42. bocca della vérita - bandori. ras’ instrumentals+layer’s amazing vocals strike again!! this is another hard one to choose between, but it came down to how well layer’s voice goes with the instrumentals. 43. yoidore shirazu - proseka. as much as i love yukina’s voice as a whole, there’s something that tends to make or break roselia’s covers for me: yukina sings very sharply. it usually helps her case for the more fast-paced or technically difficult songs where she needs to switch between high and low notes (fire bird, charles) but in this case, it doesn’t. i love the slur/slide of vbs’ voices (kohane specifically does it rlly well) because it fits the song and instrumentals sooo well. 44. bad apple - proseka. to be completely honest, this is a mix of my bias towards both marasy and kanade’s vocals specifically. marasy’s use of the piano is something that i absolutely adore (esp because i used to play piano), and i’ve been a fan of tomori (kanade’s va) since she played setsuna in love live. aka, most covers with kanade is bound to be preferred by me simply because of my kanade-bias 45. tokyo teddy bear - bandori. l/n has a rlly bad track record when it comes to vocaloid tuning+mixing, as well as line distribution. i’m not rlly talking about distribution between the four members, but rather how they tend to give the vocaloid WAY too many lines. rin’s mixing in l/n’s cover sounds off, and she has way too many lines imo. 46. queen - bandori. mashiro’s voice just sounds so good with this song, as well as rui’s violin in the background agshhfhshsc it’s literally so prettyyyyy. also, coming back to what i said with yukina for the yoidore shirazu cover-i feel this way with emu’s voice a lot. in wxs’ cover, i rlly enjoy how nene sounds-but emu sounds so off-putting because she doesn’t slide between notes like nene+mashiro do. i personally feel like this type of song requires the slide between notes, which emu doesn’t rlly do, so she just sounds out of place. plus, sega doesn’t know how to tune meiko at all, and idek why she’s in this cover in the first place. anyways, all this to say, both games are rlly good and all of the voice actors are incredibly talented, so don’t go hating on either game because that’s stupid!!!
for context: i play prsk pretty regularly, i have played bandori a bit but i don't know most songs children record: giving this one to vbs, i just think their voices fit better imo (also the second verse goes UNBELIEVABLY hard) ego rock: kokoro's voice goes SO WELL with this song??? also i've never liked the wxs cover, so hhw takes this one hibana -reloaded-: yukina's voice sounds great, but my overwhelming ichika bias means l/n takes this one! bonus points for actually good miku tuning villain: ran was hungry. (i've always thought the n25 cover was overrated anyways) melancholic: definitely not kasumi's best performance, mmj gets the win god-ish: i'm of the opinion that this song is not really meant for strong voices, but the god-ish rock cover goes WAY harder than i thought it would. also n25 doesn't really do good covers telecaster b-boy: honestly they're pretty evenly matched imo, but this one goes to wxs (len carried) kyoufuu all back: i hate this song, but kokoro's voice makes me hate it less dreamin chuchu: gonna give this one to aya and kanon !! don't like the luka tuning in the mmj cover otome kaibou: YUKINA CALM DOWN!! LEAVE SOME TALENT FOR THE REST OF US!!!!! non-breath oblige: i don't have a clue who MyGO!!!!! is, but i think i'm now a die-hard fan. i can't stop listening to it. this cover was... breathtaking (ba dum tshhh) kyu-kurarin: mmj wins because minori. shizuku is also here bocca della verita: THE BOCCA DELLA VERITA ROCK COVER GOES ABSOLUTELY INSANE?!??!?!? it reminds me a lot of futakuchi mana's cover which i absolutely adore and again, can't stop listening to this . i don't think ras is capable of missing yoidore shirazu: gonna give this one to vbs, i just enjoy the calmer vibe here bad apple!!: yukina no!! you'll kill them !!!!! tokyo teddy bear: secret third option: rondo from d4dj wins! (i don't like the l/n cover so yukina wins yet again) queen: i've heard like one morfonica song ever but SHE ATE THIS UP ?? also emunene sound way too strained... they should've lowered the key at least a little tldr: 6 for prsk, 11 for bandori. otome kaibou, non-breath oblige, bocca della verita, and queen bandori covers are going on my playlist IMMEDIATELY
Children's Record: VBS (they went so hard on the vocals WTF) Ego Rock: HHW Kokoro (this was so hard cause I love both covers so much and it's a 1v5 but I love the lower pitch so much I'm so sorry 😭) Hibana -Reloaded-: Roselia Yukina (the INSTRUMENTAL? THE ''na na na''? HJFJNVHFBHDB YUKINA ILYSM I also love Ichika's delivery on her cover too) Villain: Nightcord Mizuki and Mafuyu: (mizumafu and mizuena duos are so cracked also I love how Mafuyu subverted my expectations with the note on 1:54 it scratched my brain in a good way) Melancholic: Poppin'Party Kasumi: (lovee how expressive Aimi's voice is and the arrangement) God-ish: RAS LAYER and CHU2: (love the upbeat arrangement and LAYER's highnotes stratch my brain in a good way) Telecaster B-Boy: WxS (it's a 1v5 and I love the more chill vibe of WxS's cover) Kyoufuu All Back: WxS (love the harmonies and Nene and Emu so cute) Dreamin ChuChu: PastelPalettes (love their delivery and the arrangement) Otome Kaibou: Roselia Yukina (the arrangement actually had me gagged first listen and I LOVEE Yukina's delivery) Non-breath Oblige: Nightcord (I love the unique take from MyGO!!! and haven't heard much of their songs but I love her voice but I like the graceful approach from Nightcord and I love the instrumental it's so airy and gives everything an ethereal feel) Kyu-kurain: HHW Kokoro (I love the arrangement it's so colorful and full) Bocca Della Verita: Nightcord Mizuki and Mafuyu (plss this was actually so hard cause the arrangement for RAS's cover was so good WTF and I love how she plays around with her voice and her post-chorus part it scratches my brain but Mafuyu's delivery in this cover also scratches my brain it's so drastically different from her voice in other songs like Usseewa) Yoidore Shirazu: VBS (yukina ilysm but I also love this cover sm and TOYA AND KOHANE I SEE YOU GO OFFFF they popped off on this song sorry Yukina 😔😔) Bad Apple!!: Roselia Yukina (roselia bad apple cover will always be so iconic for me I just love the vibe and Yukina's voice is so graceful in this song but I love the Nightcord arrangement tho it was a nice surprise) Tokyo Teddy Bear: Roselia Yukina (I love the power she adds to the little high notes it has a punch to it) QUEEN: Morfonica Mashiro (plss I love the arrangement like THE VIOLIN?? omhcdbjvcbhdebvcehb also I love Mashiro's voice in this song she improved so much I love the little aggression in her delivery)
30. 50/50 31. Pjsk 32. Pjsk (it was so hard to decide but Miku and Ichika sounds so good together here) 33. Pjsk (this song just fits too well with Mizuki) 34. Bandori 35. Bandori (she's way too good at singing bro... I love n25 a lot and still I had no choice but to choose bandori for this one) 36. Bandori 37. Pjsk (Kokoro sounds too cutesy and nasally for me) 38. Bandori 39. Pjsk (somehow I like how n25 makes this song calmy) 40. Bandori (her voice❤) 41. 50/50 (what's wrong with sega they tuned Meiko so badly!!) 42. Pjsk (Mizumafu is the best) 43. Pjsk (Vbs sounds so good together here) 44. Pjsk (the piano sounds so good is sekai version! N25 & Miku always works) 45. Pjsk (I am sorry Yukina but you sound too nasally here. Ichika sounds so good) 46. Bandori (They should have lowered one key for the sekai version... Emu is clearly struggling to sing the high notes and she sounds like she is screaming...)
i'm a big fan of both bandori and proseka, so here's my opinion for each cover: children record - vbs, i like how their voices harmonize ego rock - wxs, just because it feels more fitting to have a group sing it instead hibana reloaded - love both but roselia absolutely clears, yukina's voice is so powerful villain - afterglow oml ran's voice is so fitting and the inst is godly melancholic - popipa, both are pretty similar but i like the bandori inst more god-ish - ras (no explanation needed) telecaster b-boy - very hard to choose but i think i slightly prefer afterglow kyoufuu all back - quite similar so both i guess dreamin chuchu - mmj, prefer the vocal variety instead of just cuteness overload otome kaibou - roselia. yukina's voice is too amazing non-breath oblige - mygo wow tomori's voice is breathtaking (pun intended) kyuukurarin - mmj, because i feel like their softer voices work a lot better for this song bocca della verità - ras the power in the vocals and the inst is crazy yoidore shirazu - roselia, not sure why but i just can't get myself to like the vbs cover bad apple - roselia tokyo teddy bear - can't pick so both queen - morfonica, the violin is a really nice touch and really makes the song so much nicer. mashiro's voice is a perfect fit too. tbh, i feel like emu's voice is a bit too high pitched here, so i don't like the pjsk cover that much so in summary, bandori: 11 proseka: 4 tie: 2 i think i just like band music a lot lmao. both bandori and proseka have their strong suits and excel in different ways
My opinion for QUEEN cover from wxs. It is not very good for me I mean it can be more good but I don't think they put 100% of their power to cover this song. Still perfer Morfonica cover, the violin instrument is so good. Sorry if I'm sound to biased with Morfonica.
As Bandori and Project sekai player, both games have their own weakness and greatness, for me I like bang dream because the instrumental they need to play, it what inspired me to like playing music, for Project sekai their voice is just so good, in the end both games is the best rhythm gacha game imo Edit: I also loves Tomori from MyGo!!!!! voice so much XD
inserting my thoughts as well since I got into bandori back in global release on EN (I was a little late to proseka, only started late last year). Instrumentation in bandori is better than proseka, though that's by design since the intent is that bandori (specifically RAS, Roselia, Poppin Party, Morfonica) all have live concerts with instruments being played, whereas the focus on proseka seems to be vocals and harmonization. proseka also benefits from having male vocalists as well for more nuanced vocals. I am 100% biased for Roselia, but I will mention that Raychell (Vo. for RAS) is an absolute force of nature. The band that RAS is used to be the background instrumentation band for when pasupare/afterglow sing at concerts (since those groups, unlike Roselia/Poppin Party, don't play their own instruments) - they're the real deal, musicians first, seiyuu second. If you watch any of the clips of concerts for RAS, you'll understand - the amount of energy they bring to a performance is on a different level (and I'm a Roselia bias through and through) bandori definitely leans into more powerful vocals, though that is also a side effect of this showcase. Roselia, RAS, and Afterglow all lean heavy into strong punchy vocals - another comment here basically said bandori vocals were either all punchy and powerful, or cute. Appreciate both, no need to distinguish which one is "better" because in the end, music is pretty subjective.
The first ever rhytmn game i began playing was bandori but i dropped it because the way that all of their voices sounded in every song. It's so weird idk how to explain- i mean, it's not bad, it just sounds really uneasy and artificial, idk how to explain... pjsekai songs are more normal and pleasant to hear, and the same goes to d4dj. In my opinion, d4dj manner of singing simply slaps both bandori and pjsekai. Edit: I feel like me, myself, and i, just don't like how Bandori characters most of the time doesn't change their key (not in a reaaaally noticeable way when they do), which usually doesn't match with the original songs from the covers and even feels weird in the original songs from the game itself. Pjsekai usually makes key changes and are constantly making use of good harmonizing. An example is the Villain cover. You see that it feels like Ran its being forced to sing and just sings it with some key changes that aren't really noticeable and remarkable, and it feels like she's just bored while singing it. Mafuyu and Mizuki's cover have much more remarkable key changes and they deliver a LOT of feelings into the cover, specially Mafuyu. With Mafuyu's verses you can literally feel that she's most likely in a crazy/depressing episode. BUT, there's also rare cases where Bandori cast does it perfectly. For example, god-ish by raise a sulien. They're perfectly delivering their feelings by singing the song, perfectly changing the keys in a remarkable manner. In conclusion, here are MY thoughts and opinion about the three games: Bandori: Feels a bit "forced" (doesn't deliver the songs' feelings correctly or their voice sounds too forced)/Artificial/Uneasy (idk how to explain what i feel when i hear their voices, specially pastel palette, hello happy world and roselia). Pjsekai: Calm/Perfectly feels like the singers are delivering their feelings into the songs/Professionally pleasant to hear. D4DJ: They not only deliver their feelings into the song but they also have a good control of their voices. In other words, technique.
I started playing bandori and prsk around the same time (bandori late 2022 prsk early 2021) and I have to say I prefer bandori versions! They’re covers are genuinely always so good. I think for me bandori puts more emotion. Both are incredible tho!!
We really are going back to "Both are fine, people have preferences", "Bandori this, PJSK that", and "I love this so much" comment section moment again.
i cant help but feel like only mafuyu is able to fully match bandori’s energy anyway, what i like about mygo’s cover of non breath oblige, it sounds like theyre still fighting & struggling for their will to breath. nightcord’s is more peaceful & serene, like they’ve already given up.
I guess in Bandori they must make more powerful voices since all the groups are "Bands", so they must try to make powerful voices that accompany the instruments, because being a band, they must give equal importance to the instruments as to the voices, unlike proseka where only Leo / Need is a band, from then on all the other groups only specialize in singing, so they only give priority to the characterization of each character An example would be "God-Ish", I really prefer the Sekai version a thousand times, when listening to it and being able to say "yes, this is a cover of God-ish", unlike the bandori version where although it still sounds good, it actually feels like a different song
i feel like bandori focuses more on vocals,sometimes their background over powers their voicewhile pjsk is alright its like balanced, overall both are good
30. Both(though if we're counting alts I like antoya's alt more) 31. Pjsk(I love Len's voice here, and everyone sounds so lively) 32. Pjsk(both r SO GOOD, it's just that, Ichika & Miku's tuning sound so good it's addicting) 33. Pjsk(Mizumafu sound so good here, while I like the og more and generally like Ran's voice, it's still a banger) 34. Bandori(Kasumi sounds like she's having so much fun I love it) 35. Bandori(personally the pjsk cover flopped, I like the bandori cover more than the og, n that's saying alot cuz i LOVE the og) 36. Both(Ran's voice and the instrumental r so good, and I love Emu's voice here sm too) 37. Both(Ok I swear this will be the last both, BOTH OF THEM JUST SOUND SO FUN & SILLY OK) 38. Pjsk(It feels more whimsical yet sweet & fun at the same time, whilst bandori feels more lively & fun) 39. Bandori(Yukina singing those high notes flawlessly, my queen) 40. Bandori(niigo sounds good, but I love the og more, and even more I love tomorins voice, the instrumental & her sound so emotional like any minute she's about to cry, I love it.😭) 41. Pjsk(I like the calmer feel, though I do like the og best, I'll always love iyowa) 42. Bandori(I still like the sekai cover, but Rei's voice and the instrumentals are top tier) 43. Pjsk(vbs sound so good, & I like the og instrumental more) 44. Pjsk(It feels more like bad apple than bandori's+the instrumental is so good that piano bro?? Who let Kanade cook? Let her cook more) 45. Pjsk(while I do agree it could've been better, I still think it's a great cover, and the alts are good too, also ttb should've went to Aglow man) 46. Bandori no questions asked(I don't like the pjsk one and need a Nene alt right now+Morfonica is my fav group and that violin did not miss, ily Morfonica ily QUEEN ily Amane) (btw I love both of the games & this is just my opinion)
As a day-one player of both games (I quit Bandori around the time Morfonica arrived), here’s my take: I prefer Bandori mainly for the instrumental aspect (tbh…I still rockin with Risa bass part in King since that day…), but sometimes, I don’t think it suits every song. It really depends on how the cover is directed. My main issue with their covers is the **vocal range**. It’s not a problem with original songs, but for most covers-especially Afterglow’s-the pitch is just too high, which sometimes makes Ran’s voice lose its power (similar to what Project Sekai did with Leo/need…oh ichika…my girl). A clear example is "Non-breath oblige." You could think this was intentional to fit the concept of this song (yeah non-breath) but I still think it’s pitched so high that I can’t even clearly hear the lyrics throughout the entire chorus. This happens when you try to hit notes outside of your range and at that point, stopped sing in your chest voice. In many of Sekai’s covers, they tuned down the songs significantly so the VA could sing comfortably, but Bushiro seems to think, “Nah, they can do it.” and just don’t give a fck. On the other hand, I prefer PJSK mainly because their covers can create a different tone and feel. Take "Shoujo Rei” as an example, you can really sense the calming atmosphere in this song, which is hard to get in Bandori cause the heavier instrumental (yeah not that heavy, but still...). However, PJSK still struggles with tuning and mixing. Some songs have excellent tuning (mostly when the original producer is involved), but it’s rare to find that quality in their covers. Sometimes, this makes the songs boring because they don’t differ much from the originals, leading many players to think, “I prefer the original.” (Btw: I do appreciate how they create 3DMVs that respect the original songs, and I think that’s the main reason they don’t adapt the covers too much.)
Forget to pick LOL 1. Afterglow (I swear I’m done talking about the mixing in PJSK…) 2. WxS 3. Roselia 4. Niigo 5. 50/50 Both are fun and fit the original concept 6. I CANT. I’M SORRY 7. WxS 8. WxS (Instrument are the reason why I like this song in the first place, so… sorry Kokoro) 9. Paspare 10. Niigo (It’s Otome Kaibou…) 11. Definitely Niigo 12. HHW I enjoyed the adapt in this song, it’s add more fun 13. Roselia 14. VBS (Roselia is so good, but it somehow lacks the "vibe" where you just want to jump and sing along. That’s just the VBS vibe) 15. DO I REALLY HAVE TO PICK?????? EXCUSE ME I’M TAKING BOTH BYE (Don’t tell me Roselia full ver are not out yet…?) 16. Leo/need (idk why, but the Roselia version feels softer when the original already had heavy instrument…why don’t they just go harder aaaahhhhh) 17. Morfornica (the same reason why I choose Niigo non-breath oblige and goddam Amaneeeeeeeee)
dude... i genuinely cannot get over your comment about bandoris non breath oblige and rans vocals i am not an expert in singing, but i do have music experience and i can tell you that singing in an extremely high pitch is one of the hardest things to do. moreover, what bandori is trying to do is sing in the original key, which they do in every single song, no matter how hard it could be for the vocalist. doing something like that takes skill, especially for vocalists who have recently started or have geneally deep voices. it's okay to have opinions, but saying this about vocalists is absolutely insane to me. 😭😭
@@aliapartyworld Wow? I don’t understand how can you take my comment as an offense to VA? I think I made my points clear, like you said “singing in high pitches is hardest thing to do” YES I AGREE, THAT’S THE SAME THING I SAID IN MY COMMENT and that’s why I said it could be good if Bushi just tone down the pitch to match their range “sometime”. I never said the VA fails or unappreciated their effort (or maybe its sound like that for you?) all I said in my comment is just the fact about how normal people singing in their uncomfortable range would sound like which happen with everyone in this world, and I think it would be better for them to be able to sing in their “comfortable” range like most of their original song. As the longtime rhythm game player, I always wish the best for all of the VAs and If you still think my opinion is insane so let it be then.
my opinions (and thoughts when i can) 30. children record: vivid bad squad 31. ego rock: wondershow - i dont know bandori but it sounds like theres too little energy in the bandori cover 32. hibana reloaded: leo/need 33. villain: mizumafu 34. melancholic: poppin party - the mmj cover feels like something i would forget easily 35. godish: raise a suilen - no competition. the raise a suilen cover made feel like the original godish was too empty??? 36. telecaster b boy: wondershow 37. kyoufuu all back: both - deciding between one is too difficult of a decision 38. dreamin chuchu: pastel palettes (and kanon) 39. otome kaibou: roselia - the rearrangement is so heavy but like in the way a weighted blanket is heavy 40. non breath oblige: nightcord 41. kyukurarin: hello happy world 42. bocca della verita: raise a suilen - mizuki and mafuyu sound like theyre struggling to reach the notes 43. yoidore shirazu: vivid bad squad 44. bad apple: nightcord - i like the piano 45. tokyo teddy bear: roselia 46. queen: morfonica - colopale should have lowered the key so that emu wouldnt have sounded the way she did
I LIKE BOTH bc i love both games and all the vas are so talented I kinda prefer bandori a bit tho bc i REALLY like the band-ish feel of it (ofc since its bands) i love when songs are like that
I love both pjsk and bandori so so much, been playing bandori since it released. It took me a while to get into pjsk but now I love it too, mainly Niigo and WxS. For bandori I'm a Roselia fan forever. Fortunately both franchise's songs fit my taste so I personally don't have a favorite except for Roselia, but this is just my personal opinion. 30. Tie - Originally liked Ran's voice more, but the Vbs version grew on me, they are both just as good and equally powerful as well. 31. WxS - Kokoro sounds good, but WxS sounds much better to me. I love Emu's cheerfulness, Len also sounds great in this one and the 3D mv is a dopamine bomb. Everything sounds so perfect, one of the top WxS covers imo. 32. Roselia - Forgive me if I seem too biased for Roselia, but after hearing Yukina's voice nothing can compare. It's too powerful. Ichika's voice is also powerful in this one but I think Miku drags it down a bit, so there's an imbalance, while the Roselia cover sounds consistent and powerful throughout. 33. Tie- It's a close one, I think I like Ran's a tiny bit more but Niigo sounds just as good. Mizuki and Mafuyu are a great combo as well so I can't really choose. 34. Tie - I think both have a different vibe completely with Kasumi being very cheerful and Mmj a bit laid back and I both. 35. RAS - It's not even close imo. I was not expecting Layer to slay that hard. After hearing the RAS cover Niigo sounds so bland ngl. I think I like the original song better than Niigo's cover honestly, it just lacks the same impact that the other two have. 36. Afterglow - I really like the WxS cover, it's really good. But Ran takes this one for me by just a little. I like the instruments and it almost sounds like a different song which I kinda like. Again it feels like they have different vibes so it depends on what I feel like listening to on any day. 37. Tie- I know there's a lot of ties but they both fit my taste so well. I love how cute Kokoro sounds in this one and I love how diverse the song is in WxS. Both are great, both are cute. 38. Mmj - While I love how Kanon sounds in this one, her voice is gorgeous, I like the overall vibe of Mmj's cover. I could listen to it on repeat cause it sounds calm and Luka also sounds good here. If Aya sang in a slightly lower tone I think it would sound better. 39. Roselia - Uhhm yes I am very biased. Niigo sounds great, except for Miku at some parts maybe, but again Roselia is too powerful. 40. Niigo - Honestly my favourite is the original song and that's what I listen to, but between these two I think Niigo's vocals sound better to me. It's a really hard song to cover though so Mygo did a great job especially cause Tomori had to sing the whole song herself and it's also very good. 41. Mmj - I don't think this song fits Kokoro's style at all. She sounds very cheerful which suites her but the song kinda loses it's meaning in this cover. I think the Mmj members did a good job expressing the feelings of this song and the melody overall sounds better. Kokoro doesn't sound bad, it just doesn't really fit her vibe. 42. RAS - Originally I liked Niigo, but after RAS dropped this one, it again sounds land to me. I love Mafuyu's voice in this one, it sounds so powerful, but RAS just sounds better, with the instruments and all as well. 43. Roselia - I like the Vbs one, but not too much. I think it would have been better with just An and Kohane instead of everyone. It kinda doesn't mix too well. 44. Roselia - This one's a classic for me. I loved this one since the day it released and again I think Niigo used too many vocals at that part. Maybe just Mizuena would have fit better. 45. Tie/None -Honestly don't like the song in general so I don't have much of an opinion on this one. 46. Morfonica- I just think Mashiro fits the vibe of this song better. WxS sounds good but a bit too loud. Mashiro plus the violin fit this one really well. Again this is my opinion. I play both games and I will always love them both. They are all good in their own way.
WHAT COVER I PREFER AS A PJSK PLAYER AND SOMETIMES BANDORI PLAYER BCUZ YES!!! Children Record - Prsk ver Ego Rock - Prsk ver Hibana -Reloaded- - Bandori ver Villain - Prsk ver Melancholic - Bandori ver God-ish - Bandori ver (LOVE THIS SONG AAAA) Telecaster B-boy - Prsk ver Kyoufuu All Back - Bandori ver Dreamin Chuchu - Bandori ver Otome Kaibou - Bandori ver Non-breath oblige - Bandori ver Kyu-kurarin - Bandori ver Bocca della Verita - Bandori ver Yoidore Shirazu - Prsk ver Bad Apple!! - Prsk ver Tokyo Teddy Bear - Bandori ver QUEEN - Bandori ver
(ive put down most of my thoughts in a comment on the previous video, i recommend checking it out if you want to read more of my analysis on the covers ^^) id like to note that this video only features official song releases that are in the game. this distinction is important for bandori which has had some utattemita releases on youtube, and proseka which has alternate covers for some songs. bandori's utattemita in particular are only for the bands mygo!!!!! and mugendai mew-type (the latter of which isnt in the game), and they dont change the instrumentals for those. among them are some vocaloid covers (shoujorei, sweet magic, CH4NGE, lower, and yes i mean the nuyuri lower) which may be worth checking out!
@@anonitie unfortunately i cant explain it too well myself 🥲🥲 but what i understand is that mygo/mugendai's utattemita are an unofficial cover of sorts? like you can find the utattemita on their official yt pages but not under their discographies
30.) bandori more cohesive(?) arrangement. instrumental is clearer. but vbs bassline was GIVING i wish it was more audible 31.) pjsk concept fits better. i love harohapis fanfare theme but wxs brighter sound takes the win here especially the synth part and the bassline again 32.) bandori richer instrumental love the inclusion of orchestral strings(?). i didnt rlly like the vocal layering in pjsk and the electronic remix like build up to the mostly rock sounding chorus 34.) bandori i preferred the rock adaptation it just felt right. mzmf toned down the electronic punk(?) element from the original which made the cover pretty underwhelming compared to the other two versions 35.) bandori i liked kasumis vocal techniques and distinct tone more. mmj vocals felt too soft and polished for the instrumental that it sounds borderline monotonous 36.) bandori 25ji was true to the original which made it seem lacking compared to ras which adapted and added to the song while keeping electronic influence 37.) bandori retains the energy and flavor of the original. wxs kinda lost that energy lowering the pitch that much without much vocal distinction making it layered not to mention the instrumental being louder kinda blended them together 38.) pjsk kokoros vocal suits more expressive tones. wxs vocals actually suit eachother in this singing style having only what sounds like three members singing clearly at once compared to the last one where they sung altogether 39.) bandori i prefer pasupares approach which was more accurate to the original and their own concept. while original was very punchy with sharp percussions in mmjs ver you could barely hear or feel the drums. quick rant: i expected a more exciting tone with mmj because i associate their image with newly edgy idols and how could you not when their name is literally MORE MORE JUMP in all caps but it is funny seeing how out of both groups the one named Pastel Palettes went with the more stronger approach 40.) bandori the band rock instrumental sounded better with yukina. mfmzs vocal approach seemed lacking in comparison to yukinas powerful approach. 41.) bandori tomoris vocals and instrumental worked better together. i dont think lowering the pitch wouldnt be as much of a problem if they just did solo lines for the majority of the chorus 42.) tie this is what i was talking about more expressive tones with kokoro she just owns it. while it is still on the softer side i feel like it matches the energy and cuteness of mmjs image 43.) tie could do with a bit more clarity on the instrumentals but reis vocals pulls your attention away from it. mzmf pulled off powerful vocals really well the layered lines work as theres only 2 of them and it switches up often 44.) pjsk the layering is so good here cuz of vbss vocal variation and clarity and i prefer their instrumental. yukinas voice sounds pretty awkward in these kinda songs. 45.) tie points for roselia for adapting it so well i was afraid they wouldnt do the song justice because of their concept but they pulled through. 25ji gets it too they nailed the vibes the vocals and instrumental 46.) tie both are just really similar in terms of concept instrumental and overall sound. as for the vocals i believe they both suit the song pretty well 45.) bandori theyre both top tier covers but it strays too far from wxs concept. morfonica actually adapts the song to their unique elegant sound. conclusion: i have a preference for bandori music but i tried my best to rate without bias. problems i had with bandori were groups or vocals not particularly suiting certain songs. as for pjsk it was mostly direction choices and sounding lacking compared to the other. one thing that i particularly wasnt satisfied with was the use of layered vocals on top of relatively unclear instrumentals they just blend together unflatteringly compared to bandoris vocal mixing which stands out from the instrumental. for what i did like it was bandoris skill in adapting songs to suit their own concept and style. i like pjsk when they do monophonic harmonization(?) correctly and the basslines are sick asf i havent really heard that from bandori.
I guess the main difference is that Bandori tries to play stronger and more powerful voices, and in project sekai they just sing with their feelings, everything feels more calmy, like in a SEKAI
Also, the background music in Bandori is almost always recreated, usually with rock instrumentals (except in Pastel*Palettes, Hello, Happy World!, occasionally Poppin’ Party, and sometimes Morfonica’s covers). Although in a few cases, the instrumental of the Bandori cover sounds very similar to the original
Bandori mostly powerful in their instrumentals. They make and use their own unique style of composing the songs of each bands. As for Project Sekai. Most of them sang together, it creates this calming voice that i can't even explain
Yeah, since its bands in bandori i guess it makes sense but i think bandoris also have a lot of feelings put into it... (ik that maybe you didnt mean it didnt but qnyways)
Literally no, the only “powerful voices” in bandori are aiai, raychell and ayane. Btw Tomori’s va has more emotions in her voice than any pjsk character
@@vamprirocompletely agree
my take on the main "difference" is that bandori is the type of music that would SLAP to be heard live, like at an actual show where they're playing their instruments. i think sekai's on the other hand is more "studio" music, with refinement rather than rawness. both are good!
(on top of that i think it's why bandori girls have more energetic + louder voices, it's actually super hard to sing soft when you're tired! it's much easier to sing loudly)
Ily
No way its almost like....bandori has actual bands in it?
Who would've known they would play instruments....
Bro's successfully being objective here
THIS IS WHAT IM SAYINGGGG, PPL R FIGHTING OVER NOTHINGGG
ASTER!!!!
It’s hard cause Sekai has such great vocalists but the arrangements they make for Bandori are SO GOOD
real 😔
yeah but the art is eh
Fr fr
That's how I feel cuz bandori instrumentals are amazing
WHAT IF WHAT IF HEAR ME OUT
MIX PJSK VOCALS WITH BANDORI INSTRUMENTAL🏃
Came here to say Mafuzuki’s Villain is ADDICTING, like actually
real for this because when i try to think of the ag one i hear mizumafu
I LOVE VILLAIN SO MUCH SAME ACTUALLY HELP. MizuMafu after dropping the most fire cover
MafuMizu never miss, like NEVER
Agreeing with y’all like the duo that they ARE.
RIGHT??? THEY COOKED WITH THAT ONE! Plus they're my favorite duo because their vocals mix so well together
Bandori is definitely more unique in the sense that they aren't just vocal covers, but they remake the whole arrangement to a rock group to fit them, and I'd say most of them work better, I like the Deepsea Girl cover more, as well as God-ish and Alien Alien etc. But sometimes the Pjsk cover is just better like in Telecaster B boy or Dreamin Chu Chu, mainly because the vocal fits more
As a very avid pjsk player I have to say, both covers of every song are SO GOOD like my jaw has dropped with a lot of the bandori covers bc they are so good. How about everyone is happy and hold hands and agrees what every cover is amazing in its own way and we all YIPPIEE
are you 12
@@avinoired who hurt you??? They are right, leave them alone 💀
@@avinoired no 😭
@@Vlas.is.missingim sorry but this comment is so fucking wack helpepepeprkk
Me if I dont have beef with pjsk fandom be like
the difference between their godish is insane😭
FR
dude ive never played bandori before i love pjsk but the instrumentals had my jaw DROP. ROSELIA OTOME KAIBOU? HELLO? THEYRE ALL AMAZING HOLY
also these cards are gorgeous LMAO
play bandori play bandori play bandori play bandori play bandori
@@avinoired LMAO I WISH but my storage demands i do not 😔💔
0:46 WxS ego rock cover is just so charming, and the 3dmv is great
As someone who listens to Bandori and pjsk music on the daily, here are my two cents:
The direction in song arrangement between the two games are apparent when you think about what both games market. Covers in Bandori is arguably why the series was able to take off. It cemented the whole ‘VAs playing in a live band’ the project had going. It’s also a way to showcase a bands particular sound which is something I really like about Bandori. And a bit off-base, but this is why I like to pay more attention to a song’s instrumental and not just the vocals.
While occasionally pjsk will also change a songs arrangements, covers tend to remain faithful to the original in both instrumental and vocal direction to cater towards vocaloid fans and vocaloid’s rich history. Vocaloid is built off of the community and the creativity of its producers, and pjsk (at least the way I see it along with project DIVA & MIRAI) is a celebration of Vocaloid and its cultural impact.
These different directions have their ups and downs. Bandori covers can enhance the sound of the original song with a band’s unique sound, if not at least a refreshing new sound to the formula. Covers can be hit or miss because perhaps the vocalist or their voice direction doesn’t quite fit or mesh well with the song. Same goes for instrumentation. It’s experimental and there’s bound to be some duds where the delivery didn’t quite land the way people want to. The band formula too may not be to everyone’s liking, with most covers being predominantly sung by the band’s lead vocalist.
Pjsk covers having more vocalists allows for impressive vocal harmonies when done right as it can give songs more power. The fact that pjsk has male singers is something they have over bandori, having a better variety of vocalists in their songs. Sometimes, however, I feel the vocalists are held back by the limits of the original song, such that they don’t come out as powerful due to how the original song was tuned compared to what they’re musically capable of.
Regardless, when it comes to whether you’d listen to one cover over another is personal preference, nothing to think too hard about. And for any reason too. I don’t like Afterglow’s cover of ‘Hated by life itself’ because of how much of a departure it is to the orignal song, but I *love* their ‘Night Sky Patrol’ for the same reason.
I think I’ve rambled on enough so it’s about time I got to my comparisons of the Bandori & pjsk covers. I do wanna preface, I’m more biased to Bandori as that’s I game a started with back in 2019 (I also listen to a lot of Guilty Gear so I’m a bit of a J-rockhead). I’m hoping I can give a fair explanation for all these entries.
-
1. Children Record: Despite what I’ve just prefaced, I want to give this song to *Vivid Bad Squad* . The song itself is already amazing (J-rockhead) and all of vbs are incredible vocalists. Afterglow’s cover is quite interesting, I really like Ran’s falsettos, but I much prefer the high energy from vbs’ cover, especially when It comes to the chorus.
2. Ego Rock: Both covers are quite fun but this one goes to *Wonderlands x Showtime* . I love the line distribution between the wxs cast, and I’m more of a fan of pjsk’s instrumental to hhw’s.
3. Hibana - Reloaded -: I’ve got a bias for this, but it’s not towards Roselia. This song is what made me really appreciate Ichika (CV. Nogachi Ruriko) as a vocalist and the duet with Miku is phenomenal. This cover is what got me to listen to Leo/need more and they’re now my favourite unit. Credit where credit is due, Roselia’s cover is just as amazing. I love the addition of the strings in typical Roselia fashion, and Yukina’s (CV. Aiba Aina) performance is just as incredible. But I love this cover for Ichika so this song goes to *Leo/need* .
4. Villain: This one’s tough. On one hand, Afterglow’s rock rendition of this song slaps, and Ran’s vocals work unexpectedly well too. She really made it her own song. But on the other hand, MizuMafu’s vocals fit this song to a T, from both the songs instrumental and theming. Screw it, I’m gonna give it to *both* of them.
5: Melancholic: This is one is a very close tie but I think I’m gonna give it to *Poppin’Party* . There’s nothing wrong with MMJ’s cover, actually both covers sound quite similar, but I love how poppy and lively Kasumi’s (CV. Aimi) vocals are. Don’t know, maybe it’s first-heard basis. Feel free to argue with me on this one.
6. God-ish: I have not listened to this song beforehand, or at least not that much. Bro, that small snippet of *RAS’* cover blew me away. Bassline? Slaps. Synths? Electrifying. LAYER (CV. Raychell)? BEAUTIFUL! Now there’s a point to be made that the heavy rock and electronic sound goes against the integrity of PinocchioP’s arrangement. Fair. But BROOOOOOOOOOOOOO THIS COVER FUCKS.
7. Telecaster B-boy: So I just read the lyrics of this song for the first time, bro this song is pro-trans? Didn’t know surii was chill like that. Anyways, this song goes to *Wonderlands x Showtime* . Afterglow’s rock cover is definitely interesting but not my favourite performance from them. Plus, the song felt like it was made for five people with how wxs sung it. Those guys are naturals.
8. Kyoufuu All Back: This song is goofy and I don’t think one particularly out performs the other. *Both* win.
9. Dreamin Chuchu: Now I don’t know how to clearly explain this but hear me out. The thing with Pasupare (ft.Kanon)’s cover is that it gives me too much diabetes that it could kill me. *MMJ’s* cover is like just right with the diabetes.
10. Otome Dissection: Another song I haven’t listened to much, though I think I should. This one is also tough for the same reason as Villain. Yukina’s vocal game is on point but at the same time, MizuMafu. Both instrumentals are snazzy too. I think I’m gonna give it to *Roselia* because not only can Yukina hit those high notes like a boss, those fuck ass jazz strings during the chorus is reminding me of Persona 5. Brownie points, bass slapping also on point👌.
11. Non-breath oblige: Like with God-ish, I wasn’t really a fan of this song. Then *MyGo* happened. The slow rock beat, the distorted chords but most importantly the clean guitar counter-melody to Tomori’s vocals 😩. Takamatsu Tomori (CV: Youmiya Hina) when I get you. The sense of desperation I feel from her voice and those high notes were immaculate.
12. Kyu-kurarin: Despite what others say, I want to give this song to *Hello, Happy World!* . Yes, the song sounds too happy for what it’s about, but ‘I’ find it funnily ironic how energetic it is. Like I think this cover has unfortunately physically altered how I listen to this song. Thing is, I can’t find any faults with MMJ’s cover other than, idk, MEIKO singing too long but that’s just being unfair.
13. Bocca della Verità: Can someone tell what this song is about? Like, as someone who often falls to low self-esteem, hearing a song go ‘I hate you’ be putting me off because like man what did I even do 😭. As for the covers, I’m just gonna say *RAS* . Same situation with God-dish where LAYER’s vocals and the electronic metal arrangement blows this song out of the park. I know this sounds like I’m copping out but I do not have strong feelings for this song.
14. Yoidore Shirazu: This song is so right up *Vivid Bad Squad’s* alley it’s unfair. I want to give credit to Roselia’s cover as it’s quite a departure from their usual style. Like, I don’t usually hear such clean strumming from the guitar in Roselia songs. And hey, they nailed that cover. But you look me straight in the face that you’d rate vbs’s harmonies below that. Slayed, they have. That is all.
15. Bad Apple!!: This one’s interesting as both Roselia and Nightcord have unique takes on this monumental song. I can’t describe well other than do you like rock or edm with a sick ass piano… now that I’ve laid it out as that, I’m gonna give this to *Nightcord* . That piano is really good.
16. Tokyo Teddy Bear: Believe it or not, I’ve never listened to this before too and I think that’s a sin. Once again, this one’s tough because I’ve got no preference for this song. If I were to compare, what I like in Roselia’s cover over Leo/need is the instrumentation. I think the strings adds a lot to this piece, but not so much that I’d prefer Roselia’s over Leo/need. In the same vain, the line distribution in Leo/need’s cover creates a lot of interest to the song’s benefit over Yukina’s solo performance, but Yukina didn’t do a bad job either. Imma leave this up in the air and so *both* win because I’d be debating over myself for hours otherwise.
17. QUEEN: I’m with others on this that Colopale should’ve changed the key for EmuNene’s cover. I’m an Emu vocalist defender, my girl sounds beautiful, but imagine if colopale lowered the key like in Morfonica’s cover. It would’ve been perfect 👌. So in case you haven’t guessed, I’m giving this song to *Morfonica* . Not only does the lower key complement Mashiro’s (CV: Shindou Amane) voice, the violin counter-melody just ties everything together. Solid.
So overall,
Bandori: 7
PJSK: 7
Both: 3
Did not expect to end on a tie! Kind of poetic. Again, to you who read through this whole thing, feel free to argue against any of my points because I was admittedly slack with some of these songs. Both games have good songs and you can listen to whatever you want to so don’t let anyone who says otherwise deter you.
Have a good rest of your day!
Too long too read
@@Nahida-saving tldr; Music comes down to preference for all manner of reasons. It's important to respect other's opinions so we as a community can engage in friendly discussion in orderly conduct.
My scoring ended up in a tie. I gave seven songs to Bandori, seven to pjsk, and three songs I made a tie.
Loved reading your thoughts!!
Have some bubbles because you wrote that long 🫧🫧🫧🫧🫧🫧🫧🫧🫧🫧🫧🫧🫧
It was a really good analysis, both games may drive the songs covers different but when they hit the right spot it sounds amazing
mygo’s non-breathe oblige successfully made me teared up ngl tomori’s vocal is so insane
real literally almost cried listening 2 it for the first time it's sooo good
MY JAW DROPPED AT BANDORI’S GOD ISH
ITS ACTUALLY AMAZING
edit: okay yall calm down, no need to insult each others content over a song 😭
Yeah, they cooked soo hard
Rei ate that and left NO crumbs
FR??
IKR
BANDORI GODISH IS AMAZING 1!1!1! DARE I SAY BEST RAS VOCALOID COVER
5:00のノンブレス・オブリージュ
バンドリの方一人で歌っている！？
しかも高音がとても綺麗で消えてしまいそうな儚さもあって、、めちゃ好きこのカバー……
I ABSOLUTELY LOVE BANDORI AND PROSEKA.
LIKE, IT IS STUPID HOW MUCH I LOVE THE BOTH OF THEM.
( I’m a bandori OG(/hj), been playing since the ojamajo doremi collab )
TWINNINGGG i love both of them sm, both have so much depth to their music and i fear people only focus or hate on one aspect but ignore the other good ones 😢 i've played since ojamajo doremi too omg such old times 💔
IT MAKES ME SO SAD TO SEE PPL HATE ON BOTH GAMES I LOVE THEM SO MUCH 😭😭 they both have well written characters and amazing music. i also main bandori but i still love both games a lot
@@vyr4nia 😔 Ojamajo Doremi best collab ( kokoro is best card.. )
Still made me so mad that ojomajo kokoron didn't come home bro
@@shxrlia hahahahahah
Both have different vibes
Project sekai is aiming to be similar with the original ver
But god damn, the arrangement for Bandori is amazing.
my jaw dropped at most of these bandori covers like what?? the arrangements and vocals are just soo good💥
0:30, 1:30 (😵), 2:30 (DAMN ive been replaying this for like 5 mins help im stuck), 3:30, 4:30, 5:00 (DAMN), 6:00
the main thing I noticed is that Bandori’s vocals are all either very strong or super cute. While pjsk is more diverse, only one character can really match Bandori’s strength
there is no better or worse, just general tastes: if you like strong vocals, go to Bandori, if you prefer diverse vocals, go to pjsk, you can go to both if you have enough storage
I personally prefer pjsk since I like the diversity, but I can understand why some would prefer bandori :)
Which character do you have on your mind, exactly?
@@orbitalslushie404 Mizuki
@@Half-Asleep-i1z I agree with this altho I would like to add ena/mafuyu/ichika, they are more on the wider range while mizuki is also one but more on the powerful side
@@tracesofthesunjingab they are strong, but bandori characters are just on another level, even as a Ichika fan, I can’t say she’s strong enough
THE LEGEND IS BACK AFTER A YEAR OMG
Personally, you can feel the "rawness" in Bandori's covers because they only require one or two vocals singing the song whereas in PJSK the arrangement makes it sound so compressed at times making it sound a bit off in a way. Either way, I love both games!
0:46 BOKU NO KOKORO WA EGO ROKKU
I LOVE WXS EGO ROCK SM
@@NewlyEdgyldols SAME
EGO ROCK SLAPS BOTH COVER AND ORIGINAL🗣️🗣️🗣️
why does no one like the new pjsk queen cover I love it😭😭😭
RIGHT 😭😭
idk how to explain it but Nene and Meiko is the only one that blending together while emu sounds too excited😭
@@AirendayooYeah her happy tone(??) doesn’t fit the vibe
i feel like they could have maybe made emu go a little lower? shes done it before so idk
Imo, emu's voice kinda ruined it, which has been a problem for some other wxs covers 😭
One thing I love about Bandori is the power of the voices😭 I love it so much
The thing I love about the bandori covers is that the music arrangements are put to where they try to match the song to that person singing it and bring a new spin to the original song. Not to mention that it’s just the va singing (and I know that sekai is based on the vocaloids so of course they’re gonna be in the song but you would think the tuning would be better in some of them). There’s a lot of covers that I love in sekai, but the tuning sometimes doesn’t fit with the va
I am demanding SEGA if they don't give me Nene alt for queen🙃
preach
real
For real 🫤
ok so i strongly believe we will get emunene separate alts for queen. queen was obviously added to mirror king, which has riks alts already. why not give them alts to mirror king even more?
@@diirectorr_Queen has a vocaloid in it tho, King doesn’t
Both Hibanas are good but I prefer Sekai's version because of the good Miku tuning.
I WISH THE SEKAI VERSION WAS A ICHIKA ONLY COVER
@@flyme2thestaractually there's a full alt vocal of Ichika's Hibana! You can find it on the fandom wiki
@@knui333 TY
6:00 BOTH COVERS SOUND AMAZING I LOVE BANDORI AND PJSK SM
As someone who adores both games, I honestly think it depends on which song is being covered and the direction.
Bandori’s arrangements and intense vocal delivery lends itself so so so nicely to songs like God-ish and Queen. That being said, sometimes the direction falls flat like in Ego Rock, where it lowkey sounds like Kokoro was holding back her energy, and in Shoujorei which was too upbeat for the song and the vocals were kinda “shouty” and in your face. The same could be said about puroseka though. I adore the suave vocals in Yoidore Shirazu and the direction used for their Non-Breath Oblige cover where it sounds delicate and nostalgic, yet in covers like Queen Emu’s voice doesn’t really lend well to the song. Same thing in Melancholic and Tokyo Teddy Bear, where the mixing and tuning are kinda off plus the fact that Tokyo Teddy Bear lacks the intensity needed.
TL;DR
Idk it just depends on what the song needs and both of the games have different strong suits in terms of vocals, arrangements, and mixing and these strengths pop out depending on the song but I love both of these games they’re both super dear to me
i yapped too hard in this one, i fear
I agree!! Sometimes Bandori does it better, other times it’s Prosekai
W comment
5:32 i had a hard time choosing which i liked more
Hello happy world feels full and bright. I really like it...
But more more jump feels more melancholic and in character with the original songs
I don't like hello happy cover. It feels so happy and bright for a song like kyu kurarin. I mean it supposed to a song about depression, why Kokoro sing it like it's a very positive and happy song. The arangement are to much for me, it feels like the original arangement but with more disonances. So my ear can't really enjoy the combination of Kokoro sing so bright and the disonances of the arangement. I perfer MMJ cover. No hate to both game.
@@RisunersID I agree, although the happiness doesn’t fit the context, I love the arrangement in its own way
@@Kanaderuyo_MinomafuNo1 Yeah, I don't think any other band would fit this song as well
i love both covers so much!! bandori's arrangement for kyu-kurarin's is so good and mmj's vocals are so soothing. if u told me to pick one i'd choose to die. 😭😭😭 i feel like they both sound very dream-like in their own ways (especially if you listen to both full vers...begging for you guys to listen to both full vers...)
i also love the original ver a lot so that's probably why i love both of these covers 😅
@@RisunersIDi like the hhw one the most because Kokoro's VA sound happy and its like it says in the song, shes trying to be happy while shes sad. (Thats what I get from the song btw idk how to explaij in words....) I think the instrumentals are also very melancholic and kinda scary in the bandori one too so i relaly like this one
morfonica queen my beloved
THANK YOUUUUU❤❤❤on the whole I prefer Bandori as the band set up and usually one main vocalist is more my thing ~ but both are amazing!
It’s strange because I love Bandori covers more but I’m a huge vocaloid fan …
5:02 MASTERPIECE!!!!! Tomori is amazing and her voice actor is amazing and the song suits her SO WELL !!!!!
30: ViVid Bad Squad
31: Wonderland X Showtime
32: Leo/Need
33. Afterglow and 25-ji
34. Poppin' Party
35. Raise a Suilen (No doubt)
36. Wonderland x Showtime
37. hello happy world and wonderland x showtime.
38. Pastelles Palette.
39. Roselia
40. MyGO!!!! And 25-ji
41. More More jump (i prefer the sad tone)
42. Raise a Suilen
43. Vivid Bad Squad
44. Roselia and 25-ji
45. Roselia
48. Morfonica
it’s time to give my (unwarranted) opinions again!!
30. children record - proseka. i love the contrast between anhane+akitoya’s voices, as well as the higher key. (however, i also acknowledge that aglow is covering the reboot, so the covers are bound to sound super different)
31. ego rock - proseka. i prefer the higher key, og instrumentals, and overall vocals in wxs’ cover. plus, len is tuned suuuper good (which isn’t surprising, he’s usually the ONLY vocaloid they’re consistently good at tuning)
32. hibana - proseka. roselia’s instrumentals are always super hard-hitting, but in this instance, i prefer deco*27’s lighter ones. plus, miku is tuned well here (rare sega w!)
33. villain - proseka. i usually love aglow’s renditions of so gs, but something about teniwoha’s use of “odd” instrumentals is so good that his sounds sound off WITHOUT them. plus, i like how mizumafu are singing softer than ran, simply because of the message of the song. (also, trans-coded character singing trans song lol)
34. melancholic - bandori. i like how energetic and upbeat kasumi sounds here, which kinda makes mmj’s cover sound bland compared to it. plus, the high notes (which i think is the keyboard? if so, common arisa w) compliments kasumi’s voice super well
35. god-ish - bandori. oh my lord i love layer so much it’s actually insane. usually, i prefer tamer god-ish covers because it makes the last chorus slap especially hard when all of the drums and instruments kick in. but ras always does so well with rock-type songs and i love it. plus, niigo’s cover is RUINED by miku’s presence. the cover would literally be so good if it weren’t for miku; she clashes so hard with the girls’ vocals, and the mixing is so bad. this was even proved because of mizumafu’s alt vocals that came out-they sound amazing! it’s literally miku that brings the whole cover down
36. telecaster b-boy - proseka. ran sounds a tad too upbeat when singing this song, considering the more somber lyrics. i prefer the lower key in wxs’ cover, as well as the more lowkey instrumentals. (also, common w len tuning as per usual)
37. kyofuu all-black - proseka. it’s super close, but it all comes down to my preference of singing. kokoro tends to sing super “bouncy” (for lack of a better term) which helps her a lot (ex: alien alien, darling dance)-but in some cases, like here, it’s totally offputting from the song itself.
38. dreamin chuchu - proseka. idk why, but the tempo in pasupare’s cover sounds weird to me 😭 like, the cover’s rlly good, but something about the chorus sounds off-putting to me
39. otome dissection - bandori. this was also super hard to settle on, but in the end, i love how powerful yukina sounds here. the only nitpick with niigo’s cover that i have is how jarring the switch to miku’s voice sounds sometimes, but even that isn’t a big deal to me.
40. non-breath oblige - proseka. i love tomori sm, she’s my favorite vocalist-but i prefer the softer angle that niigo goes for. it makes the song sound very personal, as if they’re singing the lyrics to me specifically, and i just love it.
41. kyu-kurarin - proseka. the drums in hhw’s cover is entirely too loud for this song imo, and it overshadows what’s supposed to be the high-pitched keyboard, which is what brings the whole song together imo.
42. bocca della vérita - bandori. ras’ instrumentals+layer’s amazing vocals strike again!! this is another hard one to choose between, but it came down to how well layer’s voice goes with the instrumentals.
43. yoidore shirazu - proseka. as much as i love yukina’s voice as a whole, there’s something that tends to make or break roselia’s covers for me: yukina sings very sharply. it usually helps her case for the more fast-paced or technically difficult songs where she needs to switch between high and low notes (fire bird, charles) but in this case, it doesn’t. i love the slur/slide of vbs’ voices (kohane specifically does it rlly well) because it fits the song and instrumentals sooo well.
44. bad apple - proseka. to be completely honest, this is a mix of my bias towards both marasy and kanade’s vocals specifically. marasy’s use of the piano is something that i absolutely adore (esp because i used to play piano), and i’ve been a fan of tomori (kanade’s va) since she played setsuna in love live. aka, most covers with kanade is bound to be preferred by me simply because of my kanade-bias
45. tokyo teddy bear - bandori. l/n has a rlly bad track record when it comes to vocaloid tuning+mixing, as well as line distribution. i’m not rlly talking about distribution between the four members, but rather how they tend to give the vocaloid WAY too many lines. rin’s mixing in l/n’s cover sounds off, and she has way too many lines imo.
46. queen - bandori. mashiro’s voice just sounds so good with this song, as well as rui’s violin in the background agshhfhshsc it’s literally so prettyyyyy. also, coming back to what i said with yukina for the yoidore shirazu cover-i feel this way with emu’s voice a lot. in wxs’ cover, i rlly enjoy how nene sounds-but emu sounds so off-putting because she doesn’t slide between notes like nene+mashiro do. i personally feel like this type of song requires the slide between notes, which emu doesn’t rlly do, so she just sounds out of place. plus, sega doesn’t know how to tune meiko at all, and idek why she’s in this cover in the first place.
anyways, all this to say, both games are rlly good and all of the voice actors are incredibly talented, so don’t go hating on either game because that’s stupid!!!
I love bandori covers more, they have vocalists with different tones, styles and their arrangements is pretty good. It feels more lively
I'm in love wth Mashiro Queen 🌷🫶😭
Mashiro queen ate and left no crumbs ❤️❤️
i appreciate you coming back after a year to give an update lol
3:04 literally any song ran covers goes hard
for context: i play prsk pretty regularly, i have played bandori a bit but i don't know most songs
children record: giving this one to vbs, i just think their voices fit better imo (also the second verse goes UNBELIEVABLY hard)
ego rock: kokoro's voice goes SO WELL with this song??? also i've never liked the wxs cover, so hhw takes this one
hibana -reloaded-: yukina's voice sounds great, but my overwhelming ichika bias means l/n takes this one! bonus points for actually good miku tuning
villain: ran was hungry. (i've always thought the n25 cover was overrated anyways)
melancholic: definitely not kasumi's best performance, mmj gets the win
god-ish: i'm of the opinion that this song is not really meant for strong voices, but the god-ish rock cover goes WAY harder than i thought it would. also n25 doesn't really do good covers
telecaster b-boy: honestly they're pretty evenly matched imo, but this one goes to wxs (len carried)
kyoufuu all back: i hate this song, but kokoro's voice makes me hate it less
dreamin chuchu: gonna give this one to aya and kanon !! don't like the luka tuning in the mmj cover
otome kaibou: YUKINA CALM DOWN!! LEAVE SOME TALENT FOR THE REST OF US!!!!!
non-breath oblige: i don't have a clue who MyGO!!!!! is, but i think i'm now a die-hard fan. i can't stop listening to it. this cover was... breathtaking (ba dum tshhh)
kyu-kurarin: mmj wins because minori. shizuku is also here
bocca della verita: THE BOCCA DELLA VERITA ROCK COVER GOES ABSOLUTELY INSANE?!??!?!? it reminds me a lot of futakuchi mana's cover which i absolutely adore and again, can't stop listening to this . i don't think ras is capable of missing
yoidore shirazu: gonna give this one to vbs, i just enjoy the calmer vibe here
bad apple!!: yukina no!! you'll kill them !!!!!
tokyo teddy bear: secret third option: rondo from d4dj wins! (i don't like the l/n cover so yukina wins yet again)
queen: i've heard like one morfonica song ever but SHE ATE THIS UP ?? also emunene sound way too strained... they should've lowered the key at least a little
tldr: 6 for prsk, 11 for bandori. otome kaibou, non-breath oblige, bocca della verita, and queen bandori covers are going on my playlist IMMEDIATELY
Ok but the bandori QUEEN cover ate
2:36 raychell godish ily>>>
REAL IT OUDID NIGHTCHORDS SADLY 😕 ILY IT BUT IT NEEDS MORE WORK
Raise a Suilen NEVER fails me
hi mimi
@@Magesmmd JAYLAA HAII
raychelle CLOCKED
Children's Record: VBS (they went so hard on the vocals WTF)
Ego Rock: HHW Kokoro (this was so hard cause I love both covers so much and it's a 1v5 but I love the lower pitch so much I'm so sorry 😭)
Hibana -Reloaded-: Roselia Yukina (the INSTRUMENTAL? THE ''na na na''? HJFJNVHFBHDB YUKINA ILYSM I also love Ichika's delivery on her cover too)
Villain: Nightcord Mizuki and Mafuyu: (mizumafu and mizuena duos are so cracked also I love how Mafuyu subverted my expectations with the note on 1:54 it scratched my brain in a good way)
Melancholic: Poppin'Party Kasumi: (lovee how expressive Aimi's voice is and the arrangement)
God-ish: RAS LAYER and CHU2: (love the upbeat arrangement and LAYER's highnotes stratch my brain in a good way)
Telecaster B-Boy: WxS (it's a 1v5 and I love the more chill vibe of WxS's cover)
Kyoufuu All Back: WxS (love the harmonies and Nene and Emu so cute)
Dreamin ChuChu: PastelPalettes (love their delivery and the arrangement)
Otome Kaibou: Roselia Yukina (the arrangement actually had me gagged first listen and I LOVEE Yukina's delivery)
Non-breath Oblige: Nightcord (I love the unique take from MyGO!!! and haven't heard much of their songs but I love her voice but I like the graceful approach from Nightcord and I love the instrumental it's so airy and gives everything an ethereal feel)
Kyu-kurain: HHW Kokoro (I love the arrangement it's so colorful and full)
Bocca Della Verita: Nightcord Mizuki and Mafuyu (plss this was actually so hard cause the arrangement for RAS's cover was so good WTF and I love how she plays around with her voice and her post-chorus part it scratches my brain but Mafuyu's delivery in this cover also scratches my brain it's so drastically different from her voice in other songs like Usseewa)
Yoidore Shirazu: VBS (yukina ilysm but I also love this cover sm and TOYA AND KOHANE I SEE YOU GO OFFFF they popped off on this song sorry Yukina 😔😔)
Bad Apple!!: Roselia Yukina (roselia bad apple cover will always be so iconic for me I just love the vibe and Yukina's voice is so graceful in this song but I love the Nightcord arrangement tho it was a nice surprise)
Tokyo Teddy Bear: Roselia Yukina (I love the power she adds to the little high notes it has a punch to it)
QUEEN: Morfonica Mashiro (plss I love the arrangement like THE VIOLIN?? omhcdbjvcbhdebvcehb also I love Mashiro's voice in this song she improved so much I love the little aggression in her delivery)
w take ngl and i love how respectful you are while ranking each cover ❤
just a hunch do yoy like roselia
@@noodleislost omg how did you know?!?? 😲
@@Akira-ck3dy just a hunch
This is such a good rating
2:37 the high note felt a lot more better compared to pjsk is all I’d have to say but it sounds so much better
30. 50/50
31. Pjsk
32. Pjsk (it was so hard to decide but Miku and Ichika sounds so good together here)
33. Pjsk (this song just fits too well with Mizuki)
34. Bandori
35. Bandori (she's way too good at singing bro... I love n25 a lot and still I had no choice but to choose bandori for this one)
36. Bandori
37. Pjsk (Kokoro sounds too cutesy and nasally for me)
38. Bandori
39. Pjsk (somehow I like how n25 makes this song calmy)
40. Bandori (her voice❤)
41. 50/50 (what's wrong with sega they tuned Meiko so badly!!)
42. Pjsk (Mizumafu is the best)
43. Pjsk (Vbs sounds so good together here)
44. Pjsk (the piano sounds so good is sekai version! N25 & Miku always works)
45. Pjsk (I am sorry Yukina but you sound too nasally here. Ichika sounds so good)
46. Bandori (They should have lowered one key for the sekai version... Emu is clearly struggling to sing the high notes and she sounds like she is screaming...)
🤥
fr 😔 i rlly wanted another deep voiced emu cover
i'm a big fan of both bandori and proseka, so here's my opinion for each cover:
children record - vbs, i like how their voices harmonize
ego rock - wxs, just because it feels more fitting to have a group sing it instead
hibana reloaded - love both but roselia absolutely clears, yukina's voice is so powerful
villain - afterglow oml ran's voice is so fitting and the inst is godly
melancholic - popipa, both are pretty similar but i like the bandori inst more
god-ish - ras (no explanation needed)
telecaster b-boy - very hard to choose but i think i slightly prefer afterglow
kyoufuu all back - quite similar so both i guess
dreamin chuchu - mmj, prefer the vocal variety instead of just cuteness overload
otome kaibou - roselia. yukina's voice is too amazing
non-breath oblige - mygo wow tomori's voice is breathtaking (pun intended)
kyuukurarin - mmj, because i feel like their softer voices work a lot better for this song
bocca della verità - ras the power in the vocals and the inst is crazy
yoidore shirazu - roselia, not sure why but i just can't get myself to like the vbs cover
bad apple - roselia
tokyo teddy bear - can't pick so both
queen - morfonica, the violin is a really nice touch and really makes the song so much nicer. mashiro's voice is a perfect fit too. tbh, i feel like emu's voice is a bit too high pitched here, so i don't like the pjsk cover that much
so in summary,
bandori: 11
proseka: 4
tie: 2
i think i just like band music a lot lmao. both bandori and proseka have their strong suits and excel in different ways
IVE BEEN WAIT FROM SO LONG THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR POSTING
I LOVE HOW TOMORI SING NON BREATH SOLO❤❤❤❤
Fr it gave me chills when listening to it for the first time
YEAH!!!
My opinion for QUEEN cover from wxs. It is not very good for me I mean it can be more good but I don't think they put 100% of their power to cover this song. Still perfer Morfonica cover, the violin instrument is so good. Sorry if I'm sound to biased with Morfonica.
i love the instrumentals for the bandori songs so much🥲🥲
to be honest, pjsk covers are more my style but im sorry, RAS and SOME roselia covers clocked pjsk
Yes!! Roseila's vocals are way too good
THE BANDORI BAD APPLE COVER??? HOLY MOLY
I dont play bandori but wow dreamin chuchu definitely suited thst vocalist! I love miku and all but wow wow wow the this onr slapped
As Bandori and Project sekai player, both games have their own weakness and greatness, for me I like bang dream because the instrumental they need to play, it what inspired me to like playing music, for Project sekai their voice is just so good, in the end both games is the best rhythm gacha game imo
Edit: I also loves Tomori from MyGo!!!!! voice so much XD
ボカロオタクとしてはプロセカの方がやっぱ安心感というか安定感あるなあ……
穏やか系だったりちょっと不気味な感じだったりそういう雰囲気はやっぱバンドアレンジだと激しくなっちゃってなあ
わかる、原曲を知らないで聴いてる分にはどっちも聴けるけど原曲知ってて聞くとバンドリは独自のアレンジで原曲の良さがかき消されてしまってる気がする。
ボカロ厨としてはプロセカのほうが好きかな
inserting my thoughts as well since I got into bandori back in global release on EN (I was a little late to proseka, only started late last year). Instrumentation in bandori is better than proseka, though that's by design since the intent is that bandori (specifically RAS, Roselia, Poppin Party, Morfonica) all have live concerts with instruments being played, whereas the focus on proseka seems to be vocals and harmonization. proseka also benefits from having male vocalists as well for more nuanced vocals.
I am 100% biased for Roselia, but I will mention that Raychell (Vo. for RAS) is an absolute force of nature. The band that RAS is used to be the background instrumentation band for when pasupare/afterglow sing at concerts (since those groups, unlike Roselia/Poppin Party, don't play their own instruments) - they're the real deal, musicians first, seiyuu second. If you watch any of the clips of concerts for RAS, you'll understand - the amount of energy they bring to a performance is on a different level (and I'm a Roselia bias through and through)
bandori definitely leans into more powerful vocals, though that is also a side effect of this showcase. Roselia, RAS, and Afterglow all lean heavy into strong punchy vocals - another comment here basically said bandori vocals were either all punchy and powerful, or cute.
Appreciate both, no need to distinguish which one is "better" because in the end, music is pretty subjective.
The first ever rhytmn game i began playing was bandori but i dropped it because the way that all of their voices sounded in every song. It's so weird idk how to explain- i mean, it's not bad, it just sounds really uneasy and artificial, idk how to explain... pjsekai songs are more normal and pleasant to hear, and the same goes to d4dj. In my opinion, d4dj manner of singing simply slaps both bandori and pjsekai.
Edit: I feel like me, myself, and i, just don't like how Bandori characters most of the time doesn't change their key (not in a reaaaally noticeable way when they do), which usually doesn't match with the original songs from the covers and even feels weird in the original songs from the game itself. Pjsekai usually makes key changes and are constantly making use of good harmonizing. An example is the Villain cover. You see that it feels like Ran its being forced to sing and just sings it with some key changes that aren't really noticeable and remarkable, and it feels like she's just bored while singing it. Mafuyu and Mizuki's cover have much more remarkable key changes and they deliver a LOT of feelings into the cover, specially Mafuyu. With Mafuyu's verses you can literally feel that she's most likely in a crazy/depressing episode. BUT, there's also rare cases where Bandori cast does it perfectly. For example, god-ish by raise a sulien. They're perfectly delivering their feelings by singing the song, perfectly changing the keys in a remarkable manner.
In conclusion, here are MY thoughts and opinion about the three games:
Bandori: Feels a bit "forced" (doesn't deliver the songs' feelings correctly or their voice sounds too forced)/Artificial/Uneasy (idk how to explain what i feel when i hear their voices, specially pastel palette, hello happy world and roselia).
Pjsekai: Calm/Perfectly feels like the singers are delivering their feelings into the songs/Professionally pleasant to hear.
D4DJ: They not only deliver their feelings into the song but they also have a good control of their voices. In other words, technique.
I started playing bandori and prsk around the same time (bandori late 2022 prsk early 2021) and I have to say I prefer bandori versions! They’re covers are genuinely always so good. I think for me bandori puts more emotion. Both are incredible tho!!
bandori vocals and covers will forever be my favourites
I will always love Roselia’s cover of Bad Apple 🫶
The Nightcord version sounds very nice as well though
I DON'T PLAY BANDORI BUT HOLY??GODISH BANDORI??? IM IN LOVE..
We really are going back to "Both are fine, people have preferences", "Bandori this, PJSK that", and "I love this so much" comment section moment again.
I just started playing bandori and i really like their covers. But prosekai also has amazing covers, so my picks were a mix of both.
i cant help but feel like only mafuyu is able to fully match bandori’s energy
anyway, what i like about mygo’s cover of non breath oblige, it sounds like theyre still fighting & struggling for their will to breath. nightcord’s is more peaceful & serene, like they’ve already given up.
I guess in Bandori they must make more powerful voices since all the groups are "Bands", so they must try to make powerful voices that accompany the instruments, because being a band, they must give equal importance to the instruments as to the voices, unlike proseka where only Leo / Need is a band, from then on all the other groups only specialize in singing, so they only give priority to the characterization of each character
An example would be "God-Ish", I really prefer the Sekai version a thousand times, when listening to it and being able to say "yes, this is a cover of God-ish", unlike the bandori version where although it still sounds good, it actually feels like a different song
i feel like bandori focuses more on vocals,sometimes their background over powers their voicewhile pjsk is alright its like balanced, overall both are good
I LOVE the new Pjsk QUEEN cover but a Nene alt and MEIKO alt would be godly
1:51 the instrument goes hard omg
Hai mimi
RIMI??? IS FHAT YOU???
@@aliapartyworld ALIA HAIII
im 3 weeks late but hi oomf
@@shirokanesSHIRO ITS GIO. why does oomf always appear everywhere i go😭
30. Both(though if we're counting alts I like antoya's alt more)
31. Pjsk(I love Len's voice here, and everyone sounds so lively)
32. Pjsk(both r SO GOOD, it's just that, Ichika & Miku's tuning sound so good it's addicting)
33. Pjsk(Mizumafu sound so good here, while I like the og more and generally like Ran's voice, it's still a banger)
34. Bandori(Kasumi sounds like she's having so much fun I love it)
35. Bandori(personally the pjsk cover flopped, I like the bandori cover more than the og, n that's saying alot cuz i LOVE the og)
36. Both(Ran's voice and the instrumental r so good, and I love Emu's voice here sm too)
37. Both(Ok I swear this will be the last both, BOTH OF THEM JUST SOUND SO FUN & SILLY OK)
38. Pjsk(It feels more whimsical yet sweet & fun at the same time, whilst bandori feels more lively & fun)
39. Bandori(Yukina singing those high notes flawlessly, my queen)
40. Bandori(niigo sounds good, but I love the og more, and even more I love tomorins voice, the instrumental & her sound so emotional like any minute she's about to cry, I love it.😭)
41. Pjsk(I like the calmer feel, though I do like the og best, I'll always love iyowa)
42. Bandori(I still like the sekai cover, but Rei's voice and the instrumentals are top tier)
43. Pjsk(vbs sound so good, & I like the og instrumental more)
44. Pjsk(It feels more like bad apple than bandori's+the instrumental is so good that piano bro?? Who let Kanade cook? Let her cook more)
45. Pjsk(while I do agree it could've been better, I still think it's a great cover, and the alts are good too, also ttb should've went to Aglow man)
46. Bandori no questions asked(I don't like the pjsk one and need a Nene alt right now+Morfonica is my fav group and that violin did not miss, ily Morfonica ily QUEEN ily Amane)
(btw I love both of the games & this is just my opinion)
As a day-one player of both games (I quit Bandori around the time Morfonica arrived), here’s my take:
I prefer Bandori mainly for the instrumental aspect (tbh…I still rockin with Risa bass part in King since that day…), but sometimes, I don’t think it suits every song. It really depends on how the cover is directed. My main issue with their covers is the **vocal range**. It’s not a problem with original songs, but for most covers-especially Afterglow’s-the pitch is just too high, which sometimes makes Ran’s voice lose its power (similar to what Project Sekai did with Leo/need…oh ichika…my girl).
A clear example is "Non-breath oblige." You could think this was intentional to fit the concept of this song (yeah non-breath) but I still think it’s pitched so high that I can’t even clearly hear the lyrics throughout the entire chorus. This happens when you try to hit notes outside of your range and at that point, stopped sing in your chest voice. In many of Sekai’s covers, they tuned down the songs significantly so the VA could sing comfortably, but Bushiro seems to think, “Nah, they can do it.” and just don’t give a fck.
On the other hand, I prefer PJSK mainly because their covers can create a different tone and feel. Take "Shoujo Rei” as an example, you can really sense the calming atmosphere in this song, which is hard to get in Bandori cause the heavier instrumental (yeah not that heavy, but still...). However, PJSK still struggles with tuning and mixing. Some songs have excellent tuning (mostly when the original producer is involved), but it’s rare to find that quality in their covers.
Sometimes, this makes the songs boring because they don’t differ much from the originals, leading many players to think, “I prefer the original.” (Btw: I do appreciate how they create 3DMVs that respect the original songs, and I think that’s the main reason they don’t adapt the covers too much.)
Forget to pick LOL
1. Afterglow (I swear I’m done talking about the mixing in PJSK…)
2. WxS
3. Roselia
4. Niigo
5. 50/50 Both are fun and fit the original concept
6. I CANT. I’M SORRY
7. WxS
8. WxS (Instrument are the reason why I like this song in the first place, so… sorry Kokoro)
9. Paspare
10. Niigo (It’s Otome Kaibou…)
11. Definitely Niigo
12. HHW I enjoyed the adapt in this song, it’s add more fun
13. Roselia
14. VBS (Roselia is so good, but it somehow lacks the "vibe" where you just want to jump and sing along. That’s just the VBS vibe)
15. DO I REALLY HAVE TO PICK?????? EXCUSE ME I’M TAKING BOTH BYE (Don’t tell me Roselia full ver are not out yet…?)
16. Leo/need (idk why, but the Roselia version feels softer when the original already had heavy instrument…why don’t they just go harder aaaahhhhh)
17. Morfornica (the same reason why I choose Niigo non-breath oblige and goddam Amaneeeeeeeee)
dude... i genuinely cannot get over your comment about bandoris non breath oblige and rans vocals
i am not an expert in singing, but i do have music experience and i can tell you that singing in an extremely high pitch is one of the hardest things to do.
moreover, what bandori is trying to do is sing in the original key, which they do in every single song, no matter how hard it could be for the vocalist. doing something like that takes skill, especially for vocalists who have recently started or have geneally deep voices.
it's okay to have opinions, but saying this about vocalists is absolutely insane to me. 😭😭
@@aliapartyworld Wow? I don’t understand how can you take my comment as an offense to VA? I think I made my points clear, like you said “singing in high pitches is hardest thing to do” YES I AGREE, THAT’S THE SAME THING I SAID IN MY COMMENT and that’s why I said it could be good if Bushi just tone down the pitch to match their range “sometime”. I never said the VA fails or unappreciated their effort (or maybe its sound like that for you?) all I said in my comment is just the fact about how normal people singing in their uncomfortable range would sound like which happen with everyone in this world, and I think it would be better for them to be able to sing in their “comfortable” range like most of their original song.
As the longtime rhythm game player, I always wish the best for all of the VAs and If you still think my opinion is insane so let it be then.
Seeing this video made me do the 1000 yard stare after remembering the war between bandori and prjsk fans on the last comparison video lmao
Idk i love it when theres multiple singers 😭😭😭
1. Pjsk
2. Pjsk
3. Bandori (really hard i like both a lot)
4. Pjsk
5. Pjsk
6. Bandori
7. Pjsk (really close)
8. Pjsk
9. Pjsk
10. Bandori
11. Bandori
12. Pjsk
13. Bandori (very close)
14. Pjsk (very close)
15. Bandori
16. Pjsk
17. Bandori
5:19 it’s really is one of their best cover
I play Bandori and Proseka and I love basically all of these 👏
I love both. I love the singers in project Sekai more, but i also love the song list in Bandori more
my opinions (and thoughts when i can)
30. children record: vivid bad squad
31. ego rock: wondershow - i dont know bandori but it sounds like theres too little energy in the bandori cover
32. hibana reloaded: leo/need
33. villain: mizumafu
34. melancholic: poppin party - the mmj cover feels like something i would forget easily
35. godish: raise a suilen - no competition. the raise a suilen cover made feel like the original godish was too empty???
36. telecaster b boy: wondershow
37. kyoufuu all back: both - deciding between one is too difficult of a decision
38. dreamin chuchu: pastel palettes (and kanon)
39. otome kaibou: roselia - the rearrangement is so heavy but like in the way a weighted blanket is heavy
40. non breath oblige: nightcord
41. kyukurarin: hello happy world
42. bocca della verita: raise a suilen - mizuki and mafuyu sound like theyre struggling to reach the notes
43. yoidore shirazu: vivid bad squad
44. bad apple: nightcord - i like the piano
45. tokyo teddy bear: roselia
46. queen: morfonica - colopale should have lowered the key so that emu wouldnt have sounded the way she did
Children record : Vbs
Ego rock: Wxs
Hibana -Reloaded-: Roselia
Villain: mizumafu
Melancholic: Popipa
God-ish: Ras
Telecaster B-boy: Aglow
Kyoufuu all back: Harohapi
Dreamin' Chuchu: pasupare x kanon
Otome kaibou: Roselia
Non-breath oblige: Mygo!!!!!
Kyu-kurarin: Mmj
Bocca della verità: Ras
Yoidore shirazu: Roselia
Bad apple!!: Roselia
Tokyo teddy bear: Roselia
QUEEN: Monica
3:40 both are great i fear
Updates: (Some are on desc)
Tensei ringo
i love the bandori cover instrumentals!!! and i kinda prefer bandori covers to pjsk, sorry pjsk fans i'm not really a huge pjsk fan anymore
I LIKE BOTH bc i love both games and all the vas are so talented
I kinda prefer bandori a bit tho bc i REALLY like the band-ish feel of it (ofc since its bands) i love when songs are like that
I love both pjsk and bandori so so much, been playing bandori since it released. It took me a while to get into pjsk but now I love it too, mainly Niigo and WxS. For bandori I'm a Roselia fan forever. Fortunately both franchise's songs fit my taste so I personally don't have a favorite except for Roselia, but this is just my personal opinion.
30. Tie - Originally liked Ran's voice more, but the Vbs version grew on me, they are both just as good and equally powerful as well.
31. WxS - Kokoro sounds good, but WxS sounds much better to me. I love Emu's cheerfulness, Len also sounds great in this one and the 3D mv is a dopamine bomb. Everything sounds so perfect, one of the top WxS covers imo.
32. Roselia - Forgive me if I seem too biased for Roselia, but after hearing Yukina's voice nothing can compare. It's too powerful. Ichika's voice is also powerful in this one but I think Miku drags it down a bit, so there's an imbalance, while the Roselia cover sounds consistent and powerful throughout.
33. Tie- It's a close one, I think I like Ran's a tiny bit more but Niigo sounds just as good. Mizuki and Mafuyu are a great combo as well so I can't really choose.
34. Tie - I think both have a different vibe completely with Kasumi being very cheerful and Mmj a bit laid back and I both.
35. RAS - It's not even close imo. I was not expecting Layer to slay that hard. After hearing the RAS cover Niigo sounds so bland ngl. I think I like the original song better than Niigo's cover honestly, it just lacks the same impact that the other two have.
36. Afterglow - I really like the WxS cover, it's really good. But Ran takes this one for me by just a little. I like the instruments and it almost sounds like a different song which I kinda like. Again it feels like they have different vibes so it depends on what I feel like listening to on any day.
37. Tie- I know there's a lot of ties but they both fit my taste so well. I love how cute Kokoro sounds in this one and I love how diverse the song is in WxS. Both are great, both are cute.
38. Mmj - While I love how Kanon sounds in this one, her voice is gorgeous, I like the overall vibe of Mmj's cover. I could listen to it on repeat cause it sounds calm and Luka also sounds good here. If Aya sang in a slightly lower tone I think it would sound better.
39. Roselia - Uhhm yes I am very biased. Niigo sounds great, except for Miku at some parts maybe, but again Roselia is too powerful.
40. Niigo - Honestly my favourite is the original song and that's what I listen to, but between these two I think Niigo's vocals sound better to me. It's a really hard song to cover though so Mygo did a great job especially cause Tomori had to sing the whole song herself and it's also very good.
41. Mmj - I don't think this song fits Kokoro's style at all. She sounds very cheerful which suites her but the song kinda loses it's meaning in this cover. I think the Mmj members did a good job expressing the feelings of this song and the melody overall sounds better. Kokoro doesn't sound bad, it just doesn't really fit her vibe.
42. RAS - Originally I liked Niigo, but after RAS dropped this one, it again sounds land to me. I love Mafuyu's voice in this one, it sounds so powerful, but RAS just sounds better, with the instruments and all as well.
43. Roselia - I like the Vbs one, but not too much. I think it would have been better with just An and Kohane instead of everyone. It kinda doesn't mix too well.
44. Roselia - This one's a classic for me. I loved this one since the day it released and again I think Niigo used too many vocals at that part. Maybe just Mizuena would have fit better.
45. Tie/None -Honestly don't like the song in general so I don't have much of an opinion on this one.
46. Morfonica- I just think Mashiro fits the vibe of this song better. WxS sounds good but a bit too loud. Mashiro plus the violin fit this one really well.
Again this is my opinion. I play both games and I will always love them both. They are all good in their own way.
Pjsk should do solo covers like bandori!! Yeah you have to get an extra cover card to unlock it!! Bandori will always be better
For the first song bandori used the reboot ver of it so thats another reason why it might sound very different
non breath oblige my go is so good tho
i like the bang dream more because it feels like they make the song unique to them rather than just copying it note for note
bandori bocca della verita is so good what?
My honest opinion
Vocals:pjsk
Instrumental: bandori
I like how PJSK incorporates the vocaloids into the songs
WHAT COVER I PREFER AS A PJSK PLAYER AND SOMETIMES BANDORI PLAYER BCUZ YES!!!
Children Record - Prsk ver
Ego Rock - Prsk ver
Hibana -Reloaded- - Bandori ver
Villain - Prsk ver
Melancholic - Bandori ver
God-ish - Bandori ver (LOVE THIS SONG AAAA)
Telecaster B-boy - Prsk ver
Kyoufuu All Back - Bandori ver
Dreamin Chuchu - Bandori ver
Otome Kaibou - Bandori ver
Non-breath oblige - Bandori ver
Kyu-kurarin - Bandori ver
Bocca della Verita - Bandori ver
Yoidore Shirazu - Prsk ver
Bad Apple!! - Prsk ver
Tokyo Teddy Bear - Bandori ver
QUEEN - Bandori ver
大勢と一人っていうボーカルの多さでも結構印象変わるよね、バンドリ派。
guys imagine the bandori instumental with the pjsk vocals (would that go good)
There are varieties, in some prsk wins and in others bandori... Except pasupare, for me they win in everything
I prefer pjsk for most but Yukina akways slays and leaves no crumbs
Bandori sticks with its own instumental while project sekai goes with the orginal soundtrack while also using voices with alot more emotion.
(ive put down most of my thoughts in a comment on the previous video, i recommend checking it out if you want to read more of my analysis on the covers ^^)
id like to note that this video only features official song releases that are in the game. this distinction is important for bandori which has had some utattemita releases on youtube, and proseka which has alternate covers for some songs.
bandori's utattemita in particular are only for the bands mygo!!!!! and mugendai mew-type (the latter of which isnt in the game), and they dont change the instrumentals for those. among them are some vocaloid covers (shoujorei, sweet magic, CH4NGE, lower, and yes i mean the nuyuri lower) which may be worth checking out!
omg can you explain the diff between utattemita and a cover 😭
@@anonitie unfortunately i cant explain it too well myself 🥲🥲 but what i understand is that mygo/mugendai's utattemita are an unofficial cover of sorts? like you can find the utattemita on their official yt pages but not under their discographies
@@geomectias ohhhh okay thank you!
30.) bandori
more cohesive(?) arrangement. instrumental is clearer. but vbs bassline was GIVING i wish it was more audible
31.) pjsk
concept fits better. i love harohapis fanfare theme but wxs brighter sound takes the win here especially the synth part and the bassline again
32.) bandori
richer instrumental love the inclusion of orchestral strings(?). i didnt rlly like the vocal layering in pjsk and the electronic remix like build up to the mostly rock sounding chorus
34.) bandori
i preferred the rock adaptation it just felt right. mzmf toned down the electronic punk(?) element from the original which made the cover pretty underwhelming compared to the other two versions
35.) bandori
i liked kasumis vocal techniques and distinct tone more. mmj vocals felt too soft and polished for the instrumental that it sounds borderline monotonous
36.) bandori
25ji was true to the original which made it seem lacking compared to ras which adapted and added to the song while keeping electronic influence
37.) bandori
retains the energy and flavor of the original. wxs kinda lost that energy lowering the pitch that much without much vocal distinction making it layered not to mention the instrumental being louder kinda blended them together
38.) pjsk
kokoros vocal suits more expressive tones. wxs vocals actually suit eachother in this singing style having only what sounds like three members singing clearly at once compared to the last one where they sung altogether
39.) bandori
i prefer pasupares approach which was more accurate to the original and their own concept. while original was very punchy with sharp percussions in mmjs ver you could barely hear or feel the drums.
quick rant: i expected a more exciting tone with mmj because i associate their image with newly edgy idols and how could you not when their name is literally MORE MORE JUMP in all caps but it is funny seeing how out of both groups the one named Pastel Palettes went with the more stronger approach
40.) bandori
the band rock instrumental sounded better with yukina. mfmzs vocal approach seemed lacking in comparison to yukinas powerful approach.
41.) bandori
tomoris vocals and instrumental worked better together. i dont think lowering the pitch wouldnt be as much of a problem if they just did solo lines for the majority of the chorus
42.) tie
this is what i was talking about more expressive tones with kokoro she just owns it. while it is still on the softer side i feel like it matches the energy and cuteness of mmjs image
43.) tie
could do with a bit more clarity on the instrumentals but reis vocals pulls your attention away from it. mzmf pulled off powerful vocals really well the layered lines work as theres only 2 of them and it switches up often
44.) pjsk
the layering is so good here cuz of vbss vocal variation and clarity and i prefer their instrumental. yukinas voice sounds pretty awkward in these kinda songs.
45.) tie
points for roselia for adapting it so well i was afraid they wouldnt do the song justice because of their concept but they pulled through. 25ji gets it too they nailed the vibes the vocals and instrumental
46.) tie
both are just really similar in terms of concept instrumental and overall sound. as for the vocals i believe they both suit the song pretty well
45.) bandori
theyre both top tier covers but it strays too far from wxs concept. morfonica actually adapts the song to their unique elegant sound.
conclusion:
i have a preference for bandori music but i tried my best to rate without bias. problems i had with bandori were groups or vocals not particularly suiting certain songs. as for pjsk it was mostly direction choices and sounding lacking compared to the other. one thing that i particularly wasnt satisfied with was the use of layered vocals on top of relatively unclear instrumentals they just blend together unflatteringly compared to bandoris vocal mixing which stands out from the instrumental. for what i did like it was bandoris skill in adapting songs to suit their own concept and style. i like pjsk when they do monophonic harmonization(?) correctly and the basslines are sick asf i havent really heard that from bandori.
Thanks for uploading after a year🎉🎉
sorry but bandori’s queen and godish clocked pjsk 😭😭
RIGHT like both are good don't get me wrong but BANDORIS ARE JUST
BETTER (in my humble opinion)
emunene were actually so good in queen tho
@@mafiyuusREAL!! i LOVE project sekai’s covers but at this case we all know who the winner is when it comes to these songs😭
Yea
As someone who loves n25 godish.. and every n25 song in general they def did it better
ily
i will pick bandori's cover song any day
THE LEGEND HAS CAME BACK
Bandori has strong vocals, while Proseka goes for blending voices. I love both games and their own covers
what makes the covers from both games unique is that they follow a specific type of theme for their own game