I agree. That girlfriend had something going on, and I don't know if it was a substance or just fatigue from abuse. The defendant would seem to be in the top 10 villains of Judge Judy.
Absolutely and the plaintiff appeared just as scared and nervous and spoke as little as possible. The defendant is a monster! I hope Jasmin got away from him immediately after this was filmed.
Oh :( I thought the same too and.... when he approached her to kiss her or whisper something, she preferred to lean away from him. He’s seriously too creepy
@@benjaminlehman3221 he pretended to kiss her but he was speaking also. That's why she immediately started saying she didn't recall when she was on the stand.
I don't believe he threatened her. She didn't have to come to support him and yet she did. She is just as bad as him for staying with him when she knew what he did
@@Naturegurl124 You're not completely wrong, but on the other hand, you don't what kind of pictures she herself has sent to him previous to before this, or videos they had made together... I'm sure that once she found out that he was capable of perpetrating revenge porn, she was more than likely terrified of leaving him due to the consequences... He's obviously highly manipulative. My point is, you just don't know exactly what he has on her to keep her with him. She definitely didn't seem cool with the fact that he released revenge porn against her ex-girlfriend because THEY were having a fight. It seems like from the phone call, he had made the threat, but it wasn't something she took seriously, because in reality, what kind of sick f**k actually does that? Also, she didn't come there as his witness, she was just with him (IDK if that means that means she got a free plane ticket too? Each person probably gets 2, but IDK?)... Tampering with a witness, and telling a witness to lie, is essentially the same thing as threatening a witness. Especially if you have to leave and go back home with them.
@@MIS315 No one is being a drama queen. Because at the end of the day, legally, whether he politely asked her to lie for his dumbass, or he threatened her, BOTH are suborning perjury! No "threat" has to be made... If this was a real a courtroom, not Judge Judy, his dumbass would be in jail right now for tampering with a witness, but in REAL courtroom proceedings, they would NEVER allow a defendant and potential witness to come that close to one another.
I think that's why JJ was so careful in questioning her. She had enough to prove he was lying just from her confirming he was on the phone, and the witness didn't know that was all she needed. So although she did ask what he threatened to do, when the witness wouldn't say she left it alone.
I honestly think JJ was careful with her questioning because she knew he had threatened the witness. So she only got her to say it was him on the phone, which sealed the case without her having to say he posted the nudes. I think we can all tell he's the type to harm her if she had said more.
Not careful as much as it was a calculated approach. JJ gave the witness a loaded question and the witness answered - not knowing that she was also confirming the underlying speculation of whether or not Avery was the man in that recording.
Plus the witness choosing to say she doesn't remember to every other question JJ had, so she wasn't testifying against her boyfriend but couldn't be caught lying...that also told JJ what she needed to know about this case
It amazes me that some people can look you straight in the eyes, without blinking, and still lie to you. It's almost like a snake, which has no eyelids...
@@Naturegurl124 Yep she sure is with him and he probably told her he would kick her ass if she didn’t come to court and support him. I’d be willing to bet that she is in an abusive relationship and she is isn’t there willingly.
@cflournoy1529 Well she knew who he was and still decided to get back with him after they broke up. There has to be a point when you take responsibility for your own behavior as an adult, because in my opinion that still doesn't excuse her choosing to be with a man who posted pics of your girlfriend.
Judge Judy is smart. I can tell that she knew the woman was possibly an abuse victim. Judge made sure to say several times after the girlfriend was questioned, “see, I didn’t even have to break you up; I didn’t even have to break up the romance” to help him not take things out on her. Clever!!
She was also smart not to ever say "Was that him on the tape?" She just pretended that was an acknowledged fact (since she can't hear the proceedings from the back room). Also she said "There's tons more audio recording than this" so the woman would think if she denied it, she'd feel stupid but that was really the entirety of the recording.
I'm so glad the plaintiff had the forethought to start recording-- there would be no case had she not done this. I hope the defendant doesn't retaliate against his gf. She genuinely looked frightened to say the wrong thing.
No doubt in my mind he did. But I do hope that JJ called their local police force to explain the situation and to ask that they make rounds around his place or perform wellness check on her, etc., anything to provide her with *some* protection.
Agreed. Hopefully in situations like this one, he started to put himself between the witness and the person who they are sided with, so this doesn't happen again.
Typical abusive behaviour to make it the victims fault the abuse occured- like him telling the girlfriend 'you knew what the consequences would be (posting the pics) but you still didn't give me my f-ing keys back'. Hope she can get away from him
@mamathemeat You don't know he could of been drunk or something. I've done that many times to my alcoholic ex. I didn't want him end up killing someone because he insisted on driving drunk.
“You knew the consequences…” That was her “punishment” for not doing what she was told. He sounds like he’s scolding a misbehaving child who didn’t immediately jump to his orders. Instead of his equal partner. Instead of a grown woman making her own decisions about staying in, or ending their relationship. Perhaps keeping him out of her home so she could feel safe? That’s absolutely classic abusive behavior. He whispered in her ear, and she obeyed his order. He probably monitors her phone, and that’s why he got access to the photos in the first place.
@@macmachine At least he didn't go home with cash. These shows pay the judgement award from a fund, then split what's left between the litigants. Usually the fund is the $5,000.00. So if the plaintiff won the entire fund, that jerk goes home with nothing.
Holy crap. The way his girlfriend's face froze and she leaned into Byrd when that piece of human garbage defendant whispered in her ear was a giant red flag, alarm blaring warning. I hope that woman is okay and she leaves him.
Her testimony was solid. She was clearly confused about why she was being asked about the argument but confirmed that it was him which was all that was needed to demonstrate that he MORE LIKELY THAN NOT had posted the pictures. the big dummy
The interesting thing is that JJ didn't ask if it was the defendant on the audio tape; it prevented the witness from lying and denying, which would have bolstered the defendant's case. JJ just barrelled on like it was all parties agree this is the defendant talking, and asked her questions. By doing this, nothing the defendant was able to whisper to the witness had any bearing on the matter. The most the witness could claim was that she didn't remember.
@@dashopepper the woman's been a lawyer longer than anyone of them has been alive, she can definitely get the truth without asking a direct question, it's attorney 101.
Judy is smart. She saw the intimidation even though she called it romance. And so she asked her questions that wouldn’t get her in trouble when she left there but would answer her question about his character. That’s genius.
she needs to get a restraining order against him ... he is a danger to her. YOu can see the fear of him in her eyes. IF someone lies in court...they're case should be automatically dismissed
Since the person lying was the defendant and not the plaintiff, why would the case be dismissed? That wouldn't make sense when he wasn't the one suing. The plaintiff was.
This case was wild. The witness is beyond scared, scared because she knows if she says the wrong thing the defendant is probably gonna cause her harm. Beyond shocked JJ didn't just award the plaintiff 5,000 right when the defendant started whispering in the witness's ear. Byrd next time push him away man lolololol
His defense was to lie his butt off, the same thing he told his girlfriend to do in her ear as soon as she passed him. Byrd should have never let the defendant get close enough to whisper anything in her ear and stopped him another way from doing so.
2:35 What was he trying to do? He's already liable just by doing that. In JJ's arbitration, it's not "beyond a reasonable doubt" but "preponderance of evidence". That did more harm than good to his case. Edit: People who distribute revenge porn are sickos. People should not put themselves in such compromising positions in my opinion.
I wish they would have transcribed what he whispered to her. They both were mic'd up so I know production heard it exactly. Maybe they did in JJ's earpiece and that's why JJ didn't probe any deeper to protect the girlfriend... just wow
How could they transcribe what he said if they couldn't hear it? Not to mention it was a private utterance obviously not meant to be heard by everyone else, so why would the producers do that even if they could hear what he said? Why open themselves up to potential legal ramifications?
@@scribe712 your approach to this is so negative and disappointing. technology is advanced enough for the mics to pick up what people think they whisper. also, producers make choices. cast have mics on and clearly know they are being recorded. thus they would be legally protected. sigh. they just decided it wasnt necessary likely to preserve safety. likely why JJ kept saying she did her questioning in a way that didnt mess up his relationship. just because there is curiosity about what he whispered, it doesn't mean we are ignorant to the possibility. the real question is why are you ?
@@phDST1913I don't think it's quite that deep. I simply think that whatever was said must've been so quiet that the mics simply didn't pick up anything. Or rather he tried to say something there, but couldn't. But all we can do is speculate cause we'll never know.
Ahh he was trying to tell her something in her ear. Love me some judge Judy. She was like i didn’t even have to break up your relationship 😂 His but was lying from jump.
The witness thought about lying with the first question ,once she acknowledged that she remembered it was smooth sailing. Judge judys tactics are solid!
He was definitely gonna whisper something in her ear but realized at the last minute he wasn’t gonna be able to with Byrd standing right there. Can also tell from the look and actions of the witness that she has been through quite a bit of abuse, more than likely from him. What a POS
I honestly don't think that Judge Judy realized that he was whispering in her ear and assumed that he was giving her a kiss. What an ignoramus to have the nerve to actually do that. People would literally rather make a fool of themselves than just tell the truth. Embarrassing 🤦🏾♂️
JJ knew that he was directing her testimony about phone call in threatening manner. She was very careful in how she responded there, in her questioning of witness, and in how she spoke to him after questioning. She didnt want this fact finding to contribute to abuse on car ride leaving court (where he blames her for his loss). It appears to be abusive relationship and that's why JJ was careful. It obviously wasn't a lovely dovey kiss dude
Wow as soon as i saw him corner her i knew he was whispering threatening things in her ears her demeanor on her face was scared poor lady. I feel bad for her.
The plaintiff looks so beaten by this experience. A very hard lesson for her. The defendant on the other hand 😮😵🚩🚩🚩. Such a confident abuser that he actually tried to gaslight JJ, the plaintiff and the witness, right there, in front of 10 million people. Jasmine does not look very happy either- I sense the defendant is coercively controlling her. GET OUT GIRL! 🏃♀️🏃♀️🏃♀️ Edit: I posted comment before reading others. It's heartening so see how many other people picked up the exact same abuse tells. Thank goodness more people are recognizing signs of abuse 🙏
But she willingly got back with him after she knew he posted the pictures, chose to come to court to support him and she lied to cover for him. The plantiff should have nothing to do with her after thid
I don't know when this episode aired, but I am so happy to see Jasmin's Facebook doesn't show her as involved with either of these two now. Seems she is living her absolute best life. This man is BAD.
Judge Judy is a smart damn woman lol, She knew exactly what to ask without asking it directly. He thought Judy was gonna ask if thats him on the call, but she snuck around it by asking what were they arguing about. Keys to what? That was such a smart way to get the answer.
Wow, that man is dangerous. I wouldn’t doubt it if he was threatening her when he was whispering in her ear. The way she was sitting up there she looked absolutely terrified. Then trying to gaslight the plaintiff be saying “she’s confused.” So messed up.
If that was my daughter and I saw that on NATIONAL TELEVISION. This guy would be in the back of my trunk and I would help the entire neighborhood look look for him.
The defendant is a liar from beginning to end. Judge should have found him in contempt of court for whispering to the witness and fined him (out of HIS pocket) $1000.
She was not confused. If anything, she looked scared of the consequences for telling the truth. She couldn't look at him out of fear. It wouldn't surprise me if she got a beating for saying the truth that it was him.
This guy gives my chills in all the worst ways. I have no doubt he beats his girlfriend. This is the type of guy you hear about on the news who shot his girlfriend because she broke up with him. I hope someone took care of him before he did anymore damage to anyone.
There's no doubt he was whispering something in her ear and she looked extremely uncomfortable and scared. He gives off abusive and manipulative vibes. This was a weird case.
Well, she's probably never been in front of so many people before with an opportunity to say, "Please help me" and just couldn't work up the nerve. Or she is on drugs and can barely get through the day.
If she was confused, it was because JJ didnt ask when the creepy Defendant told her to deny. JJ proved he was a liar because he at first denied a conversation, then partially admitted one. By having the witness authenticate the conversation took place and where, she indirectly autheticates the content. He wasnt thinking of that but JJ was.
There was another revenge porn case JJ did years back (except the POS defendant basically photoshopped his ex’s head from a picture and pasted it on a cartoon/photo body on a flyer promising sex or calling her a W.) Anyway she also called him an “amoral, low life, piece of crap.” You can tell she was absolutely incensed with the defendant, especially because he only did it to get back at her after the plaintiff called him he cops on him after he beat her…while pregnant.
2:31 does JJ have the power to place someone under arrest. The defendant really messed up there. 3:21 the witness was thinking really hard about lying to JJ
Unfortunately, no, at this this point in time JJ is nothing more than a TV personality (a Former judge, yes, but not for a very long time). If she had any compassion at all, she would have had a production assistant hold her back to speak with her and tell her her legal options, the actual criminal ones. Because what he did to her was definitely illegal... Unfortunately, it usually winds up MUCH worse for the woman who intended for the picture(s) to be seen by a singular person, than the man who then completely ruins said woman's life forever. The man usually gets a slap on the wrist, while the woman will forever have difficulty finding employment, mending relationships with friends and family. People just look at women differently, like they should know better. Which, as someone who was a teenager in the 90's, I've agreed with in the past, but having watched several documentaries about it, I've come to realize, that while I still agree that you should never take those types of pictures for anyone for any reason (I mean they could get hacked for all you know!), that I was victim blaming. And that was very wrong of me, I couldn't see both sides before. I now realize why it's literally called REVENGE porn.
I'm glad he lied in the manner he did...this video is on the internet for all of eternity so as he continues to move through life this video is proof of how he can bold face lie, and especially to a ruling body. #fool
That was so creepy. Anyone else getting abuse vibes from the couple? 😬
Yes absolutely!!! She also looks zonked out.. never seen a human being resemble a zombie more :( Sad.
He’s really creepy. When he tried to whisper to her, right next to Byrd. Unreal.
wouldn't be surprised if he's ever been arrested for domestic violence. He looks like a straight up socio/pyschopath.
I agree. That girlfriend had something going on, and I don't know if it was a substance or just fatigue from abuse. The defendant would seem to be in the top 10 villains of Judge Judy.
☹️ yeah
The witness looked scared to tell the truth. I fear for her safety.
arghhhhhhh ditto
She sure did. Scratching and moving around.
Absolutely and the plaintiff appeared just as scared and nervous and spoke as little as possible. The defendant is a monster! I hope Jasmin got away from him immediately after this was filmed.
Oh :( I thought the same too and.... when he approached her to kiss her or whisper something, she preferred to lean away from him. He’s seriously too creepy
Girl was terrified.
I'm surprised she didn't rule for the plaintiff immediately when he started whispering in her ear to lie
It seems that he tried to kiss her but very suspicious
Judge Judy should have given him 30 days in the county jail for tampering with the witness
@@benjaminlehman3221 he pretended to kiss her but he was speaking also. That's why she immediately started saying she didn't recall when she was on the stand.
I know, that took a lot of nerve.
I agreed! That wasn’t a kiss.
Can’t believe Byrd let him get close to her as she entered. It wasn’t love, he absolutely threatened her. What a coward and a thug.
Agreed! Loser!
I don't believe he threatened her. She didn't have to come to support him and yet she did. She is just as bad as him for staying with him when she knew what he did
He didn't threaten her you drama queen. He just told her to lie
@@Naturegurl124 You're not completely wrong, but on the other hand, you don't what kind of pictures she herself has sent to him previous to before this, or videos they had made together... I'm sure that once she found out that he was capable of perpetrating revenge porn, she was more than likely terrified of leaving him due to the consequences... He's obviously highly manipulative.
My point is, you just don't know exactly what he has on her to keep her with him. She definitely didn't seem cool with the fact that he released revenge porn against her ex-girlfriend because THEY were having a fight. It seems like from the phone call, he had made the threat, but it wasn't something she took seriously, because in reality, what kind of sick f**k actually does that?
Also, she didn't come there as his witness, she was just with him (IDK if that means that means she got a free plane ticket too? Each person probably gets 2, but IDK?)...
Tampering with a witness, and telling a witness to lie, is essentially the same thing as threatening a witness. Especially if you have to leave and go back home with them.
@@MIS315 No one is being a drama queen. Because at the end of the day, legally, whether he politely asked her to lie for his dumbass, or he threatened her, BOTH are suborning perjury! No "threat" has to be made... If this was a real a courtroom, not Judge Judy, his dumbass would be in jail right now for tampering with a witness, but in REAL courtroom proceedings, they would NEVER allow a defendant and potential witness to come that close to one another.
Just from this post, I get the feeling that he is abusive and controlling.
Ya think 🤔😏
also on the news today, the sky is blue and water is wet
lol@@lilsaam
A terrible abuser. I felt scared on behalf of his girlfriend. She looked terrified when he was whispering in her ear.
I think that's why JJ was so careful in questioning her. She had enough to prove he was lying just from her confirming he was on the phone, and the witness didn't know that was all she needed. So although she did ask what he threatened to do, when the witness wouldn't say she left it alone.
He whispered to or threatened her to not say anything. This guy is a piece of work.
I guess you mean POS.
You can tell that she was scared
Sure is!
Guys shouldn't be jealous, that's a female trait
He needs to be arrested. These women better wake up
I honestly think JJ was careful with her questioning because she knew he had threatened the witness. So she only got her to say it was him on the phone, which sealed the case without her having to say he posted the nudes. I think we can all tell he's the type to harm her if she had said more.
Not careful as much as it was a calculated approach. JJ gave the witness a loaded question and the witness answered - not knowing that she was also confirming the underlying speculation of whether or not Avery was the man in that recording.
Plus the witness choosing to say she doesn't remember to every other question JJ had, so she wasn't testifying against her boyfriend but couldn't be caught lying...that also told JJ what she needed to know about this case
@@xcutionunknown9634 It wasn't loaded
That was a smooth move JJ did with them questions for real!!!
It amazes me that some people can look you straight in the eyes, without blinking, and still lie to you. It's almost like a snake, which has no eyelids...
Lol ... Filthy snake
I had a few girlfriends like that 😄
My ex boyfriend was like that.
He is what JJ said he was.
It’s insulting to snakes to compare them to this POS or any like him
The witness's face when he whispered in her ear. She looked so embarrassed and uncomfortable.
She looked petrified in fear when that monster "boyfriend" whispered in her ear.
@@Crazycatlady71That’s what I was going to say! She didn’t look embarrassed, she looked absolutely horrified.
@cflournoy1529 Yes she's so horrified that she is still with him and there to support him when she knew what he did.🙄
@@Naturegurl124 Yep she sure is with him and he probably told her he would kick her ass if she didn’t come to court and support him. I’d be willing to bet that she is in an abusive relationship and she is isn’t there willingly.
@cflournoy1529 Well she knew who he was and still decided to get back with him after they broke up. There has to be a point when you take responsibility for your own behavior as an adult, because in my opinion that still doesn't excuse her choosing to be with a man who posted pics of your girlfriend.
Judge Judy is smart. I can tell that she knew the woman was possibly an abuse victim. Judge made sure to say several times after the girlfriend was questioned, “see, I didn’t even have to break you up; I didn’t even have to break up the romance” to help him not take things out on her. Clever!!
She was also smart not to ever say "Was that him on the tape?" She just pretended that was an acknowledged fact (since she can't hear the proceedings from the back room). Also she said "There's tons more audio recording than this" so the woman would think if she denied it, she'd feel stupid but that was really the entirety of the recording.
Something tells me he will take it out on her anyway…..😢
he most likely did anyway. These narcissist will still pin blame on you no matter what. @@abowling5759
sooo clever!! love her!!
That guy is a major CLOWN!!! His behavior is disgusting! Just bold face lied to judge Judy. Like WOW
It's actually a "bald-faced lie".
And on national TV and all over the internet.
Well he’s locked up for murder now
Someone get the feeling this is an abusive relationship and that he has her completely under his control?
If it is she getting her ass beat when they get home
What control? She's swapping spit with the plaintiff.
@@biff5856 What’s that got to do with anything?? You can’t be seriously be on the defendants side
@@Paerata12 I'm not on anyone's side. They're all their own worst enemies
@@biff5856 Even so there’s no denying the dude’s a gaslighting monster. At least the plaintiff wasn’t trying to lie and manipulate the truth.
I'm so glad the plaintiff had the forethought to start recording-- there would be no case had she not done this. I hope the defendant doesn't retaliate against his gf. She genuinely looked frightened to say the wrong thing.
I'm sure he did :(
Thinking about the same thing.
i disagree. defendant did nothing wrong.
No doubt in my mind he did. But I do hope that JJ called their local police force to explain the situation and to ask that they make rounds around his place or perform wellness check on her, etc., anything to provide her with *some* protection.
SHE DESERVES PUNISHMENT FOR HER BEHAVIOR.@@carlairving
I almost screamed when he leaned over to whisper in her ear. As if nobody was going to SEE that 🤦🏻♀️
I’m surprised Byrd didn’t push him away from his girlfriend.
Agreed. Hopefully in situations like this one, he started to put himself between the witness and the person who they are sided with, so this doesn't happen again.
I don’t understand why he didn’t, that kind of stuff is what a bailiff is for. What’s the point of having him there otherwise?
I'd failed this one. He probably said to GF "lie baby, lie" before JJ said something and bird took her.
@@mauvemouse9259 I'm sure Byrd heard what he said to her and would have mentioned it if needed.
Tat: he slipped up there, he should have stood between them as she walked in, to keep them apart. I think he said "don't say nothin'
Wow the defendant really dug himself a hole, what a weird case
Typical abusive behaviour to make it the victims fault the abuse occured- like him telling the girlfriend 'you knew what the consequences would be (posting the pics) but you still didn't give me my f-ing keys back'.
Hope she can get away from him
And the biggest blow to his fragile ego was most likely the "more than friends" situation between his gf and the plaintiff.
Yeah but why not give someone their keys that’s also abusive
@mamathemeat You don't know he could of been drunk or something. I've done that many times to my alcoholic ex. I didn't want him end up killing someone because he insisted on driving drunk.
Lotta females do the same thing
“You knew the consequences…” That was her “punishment” for not doing what she was told. He sounds like he’s scolding a misbehaving child who didn’t immediately jump to his orders. Instead of his equal partner. Instead of a grown woman making her own decisions about staying in, or ending their relationship. Perhaps keeping him out of her home so she could feel safe? That’s absolutely classic abusive behavior. He whispered in her ear, and she obeyed his order. He probably monitors her phone, and that’s why he got access to the photos in the first place.
Major control and domestic violence vibes. And the fact that he’s using a third person’s nudes to blackmail her to get the keys is so conniving.
Exactly! He kept saying you knew the consequences as if she was a child!
Tbh she should call the police and have him jailed to teach his slimy ass
@@TheAray6and that right there told judy everything she needed to know
He really tried to pull a fast one on Judge Judy. "She's confused" Cost him $5000. Ya clown 🤡😂
He wasn't swift enough for JJ 👩🏻⚖️🙌🏾
You do know HE doesn't pay that. The production does. That's why folk agree to go on the show in tge 1rst place.
@@macmachine At least he didn't go home with cash. These shows pay the judgement award from a fund, then split what's left between the litigants.
Usually the fund is the $5,000.00. So if the plaintiff won the entire fund, that jerk goes home with nothing.
She was not confused at all. She looked terrified more than anything
It didn’t cost him didly…..the show pays
So sad ,the girlfriend doesn't look good....she looks depressed and frightened!
Frightened, maybe. But depressed? I definitely didn't see that.
@@scribe712 she looks like she is afraid of her boyfriend and when you are in such a situation you are depressed.....
I would’ve ruled against him and held him in contempt for tampering with a witness as soon as he pulled that whispering move.
It's an arbitration court. Not an actual court of law. Also it's only a civil case. Not a criminal one. It's a TV show. Not Court TV.
Contempt of court lmao
He literally twisted every word he could to manipulate this situation.
Holy crap. The way his girlfriend's face froze and she leaned into Byrd when that piece of human garbage defendant whispered in her ear was a giant red flag, alarm blaring warning. I hope that woman is okay and she leaves him.
“Shes confused” took me out 😂😂😂 he’s unfortunately not one of a kind
He is insane!
That guy is such a manipulative scrub. He will lie till the day he dies. He did that to her ex girlfriend imagine what he will do or has done to her.
He definitely whispered for her to lie. THAT’S WITNESS TAMPERING which is a crime!
Her testimony was solid. She was clearly confused about why she was being asked about the argument but confirmed that it was him which was all that was needed to demonstrate that he MORE LIKELY THAN NOT had posted the pictures.
the big dummy
Not confused, scared of what would happen to her after.
The interesting thing is that JJ didn't ask if it was the defendant on the audio tape; it prevented the witness from lying and denying, which would have bolstered the defendant's case.
JJ just barrelled on like it was all parties agree this is the defendant talking, and asked her questions. By doing this, nothing the defendant was able to whisper to the witness had any bearing on the matter. The most the witness could claim was that she didn't remember.
I didn't see her confused. Just scared.
@@dashopepper the woman's been a lawyer longer than anyone of them has been alive, she can definitely get the truth without asking a direct question, it's attorney 101.
Nope that wasn’t confusion. That was I’m going to get it when I get home if I tell what happened look. There’s a difference.
Someone needs to send the witness help … bad vibes
yeah like yesterdayyyyyyyyyyyyyy
She’s confused ? That’s kinda scary 😭
Definitely. Gaslights the gf, and thinks he can do it to JJ, too. Pure narcissistic behavior right there!
Yes...I even cringed at that statement. Many women have heard that from their abusive partners.
Not really. She is just lying to cover her boyfriend
Judy is smart. She saw the intimidation even though she called it romance. And so she asked her questions that wouldn’t get her in trouble when she left there but would answer her question about his character. That’s genius.
she needs to get a restraining order against him ... he is a danger to her. YOu can see the fear of him in her eyes. IF someone lies in court...they're case should be automatically dismissed
Since the person lying was the defendant and not the plaintiff, why would the case be dismissed? That wouldn't make sense when he wasn't the one suing. The plaintiff was.
This case was wild. The witness is beyond scared, scared because she knows if she says the wrong thing the defendant is probably gonna cause her harm. Beyond shocked JJ didn't just award the plaintiff 5,000 right when the defendant started whispering in the witness's ear. Byrd next time push him away man lolololol
Anyone else think he threatened her when he leaned in close...im convinced this scum did just that.
She looked threatened. He probably told her to keep her mouth shut
His defense was to lie his butt off, the same thing he told his girlfriend to do in her ear as soon as she passed him.
Byrd should have never let the defendant get close enough to whisper anything in her ear and stopped him another way from doing so.
That or Judge Judy should’ve went after him for that and say that he’s tempering with evidence
I think he was saying "Tell them it wasn't me you were talking to in the recording" but before he could get a few words out, JJ put a stop to it.
@@johnsmi213
Exactly, and that's why she acted like she was confused answering questions Judge Judy was asking her to answer.
The witness looks petrified 😳
He was reminding her who she had to go home with. He's abusive.
@ 3:20 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 The look on the Face ... She was Dead Frozen ...
2:35 What was he trying to do? He's already liable just by doing that. In JJ's arbitration, it's not "beyond a reasonable doubt" but "preponderance of evidence". That did more harm than good to his case.
Edit: People who distribute revenge porn are sickos. People should not put themselves in such compromising positions in my opinion.
whisper in her ear to update her
he was trying to get her to back him up
I know that look in the witness’s face, I’m very sure he threatened her 😢
the defendant tried to whisper in her ear trying to manipulate her
I wish they would have transcribed what he whispered to her. They both were mic'd up so I know production heard it exactly. Maybe they did in JJ's earpiece and that's why JJ didn't probe any deeper to protect the girlfriend... just wow
How could they transcribe what he said if they couldn't hear it? Not to mention it was a private utterance obviously not meant to be heard by everyone else, so why would the producers do that even if they could hear what he said? Why open themselves up to potential legal ramifications?
@@scribe712 your approach to this is so negative and disappointing. technology is advanced enough for the mics to pick up what people think they whisper. also, producers make choices. cast have mics on and clearly know they are being recorded. thus they would be legally protected. sigh. they just decided it wasnt necessary likely to preserve safety. likely why JJ kept saying she did her questioning in a way that didnt mess up his relationship. just because there is curiosity about what he whispered, it doesn't mean we are ignorant to the possibility. the real question is why are you ?
@@phDST1913I don't think it's quite that deep. I simply think that whatever was said must've been so quiet that the mics simply didn't pick up anything. Or rather he tried to say something there, but couldn't. But all we can do is speculate cause we'll never know.
Ahh he was trying to tell her something in her ear. Love me some judge Judy. She was like i didn’t even have to break up your relationship 😂 His but was lying from jump.
The witness thought about lying with the first question ,once she acknowledged that she remembered it was smooth sailing. Judge judys tactics are solid!
2:26 He wasn’t kissing her. He was whispering in her ear, the way he wanted her to testify on the stand.
Still that doesn’t accuse this three ring triangle.
Well done Judge Judy. Loved the way you extracted the truth.
Fantastic
He was definitely gonna whisper something in her ear but realized at the last minute he wasn’t gonna be able to with Byrd standing right there. Can also tell from the look and actions of the witness that she has been through quite a bit of abuse, more than likely from him. What a POS
The way he reacted to her and the way she didn’t even want to acknowledge him rang alarm bells
She was scared to death couldn't recall anything and he kept saying she's confused 😄
Who in the right mind would anybody ever trust that guy again; the way he whispered seemed threatening.
he definitely threatened her with that whisper. she couldn’t focus on any of the questions afterwards. i fear for her.
I honestly don't think that Judge Judy realized that he was whispering in her ear and assumed that he was giving her a kiss. What an ignoramus to have the nerve to actually do that. People would literally rather make a fool of themselves than just tell the truth. Embarrassing 🤦🏾♂️
JJ knew what he was doing. It was obvious. She simply chose not to call him out about it since it wasn't necessary.
JJ knew that he was directing her testimony about phone call in threatening manner. She was very careful in how she responded there, in her questioning of witness, and in how she spoke to him after questioning. She didnt want this fact finding to contribute to abuse on car ride leaving court (where he blames her for his loss). It appears to be abusive relationship and that's why JJ was careful. It obviously wasn't a lovely dovey kiss dude
You hear the whisper of words on the audio.
Him whispering in his girlfriend ears was so embarrassing 😂
Judge Judy is an impeccable cross examiner
Ah...the good ole "it wasn't me" ! Cant believe that's still used.
I hope plaintiff keep as far away from both of them as possible. He seems dangerous and abusive and girlfriend is too afraid to go against him.
Wow as soon as i saw him corner her i knew he was whispering threatening things in her ears her demeanor on her face was scared poor lady. I feel bad for her.
That guy is scary af. HIs girlfriend is going to pay a price for her honesty. Awful.
him whispering to her just gave himself up
The plaintiff looks so beaten by this experience. A very hard lesson for her. The defendant on the other hand 😮😵🚩🚩🚩. Such a confident abuser that he actually tried to gaslight JJ, the plaintiff and the witness, right there, in front of 10 million people. Jasmine does not look very happy either- I sense the defendant is coercively controlling her. GET OUT GIRL! 🏃♀️🏃♀️🏃♀️
Edit: I posted comment before reading others. It's heartening so see how many other people picked up the exact same abuse tells. Thank goodness more people are recognizing signs of abuse 🙏
But she willingly got back with him after she knew he posted the pictures, chose to come to court to support him and she lied to cover for him. The plantiff should have nothing to do with her after thid
This guy thought Shaggy Defense works at Judge Judy? You must be kidding me!
Jasmin will be beat up later that day
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂fr fr
@@roos5099 not sure if that was meant to be a joke 🤔
Nah. She just seems high af
The way he looked at his gf after her testimony. Like she was gonna pay for that later. She looked terrified to speak.
This was wild. He is terrifying and gives off very abusive vibes.
I don't know when this episode aired, but I am so happy to see Jasmin's Facebook doesn't show her as involved with either of these two now. Seems she is living her absolute best life. This man is BAD.
I hope that he has warrants and they arrest him for something even mistaken identity, just jail him....
The old 'just keep denying it no matter what overwhelming evidence shows up' defence. Didn't quite work.
Trumps ghetto love child.
Judge Judy is a smart damn woman lol, She knew exactly what to ask without asking it directly. He thought Judy was gonna ask if thats him on the call, but she snuck around it by asking what were they arguing about. Keys to what? That was such a smart way to get the answer.
Wow, that man is dangerous. I wouldn’t doubt it if he was threatening her when he was whispering in her ear. The way she was sitting up there she looked absolutely terrified. Then trying to gaslight the plaintiff be saying “she’s confused.” So messed up.
She’s just *so* good at what she does. Judge Judy is full of seichel
02:53 The witness thinks Byrd is trying to shake her hand.
The way she was looking i can tell she was scared of him
JJ laugh was the sealing of his fate
If that was my daughter and I saw that on NATIONAL TELEVISION. This guy would be in the back of my trunk and I would help the entire neighborhood look look for him.
damn jasmine is clearly being abused BAD. she looks terrified and the way he went to her ear really creeped me out
The defendant is a liar from beginning to end. Judge should have found him in contempt of court for whispering to the witness and fined him (out of HIS pocket) $1000.
He sure did whisper something to her because she looked SCARED. I could hear a whisper sound.
She was not confused. If anything, she looked scared of the consequences for telling the truth. She couldn't look at him out of fear. It wouldn't surprise me if she got a beating for saying the truth that it was him.
I doubt he'd do that after appearing on TV. At least not right away.
@@scribe712 I hope not. But you would be surprised. Some abusers actually do it in public.
Defendant was trying to whisper in her ear before she took the stand. He seems like an abuser!
This guy gives my chills in all the worst ways. I have no doubt he beats his girlfriend. This is the type of guy you hear about on the news who shot his girlfriend because she broke up with him. I hope someone took care of him before he did anymore damage to anyone.
This matter should be shared with the authorities for criminal charges.
There's no doubt he was whispering something in her ear and she looked extremely uncomfortable and scared. He gives off abusive and manipulative vibes. This was a weird case.
Judge Judy is one of the smartest women I've ever seen. She always surprises me.
the defendant is definitely something 😬
Jazmine was terrified. I hope she is okay. Just messy and nasty business
He's a sociopath.
She looks like she’s afraid of him. I can’t believe he whispered in her ear in front of Judge Judy. Wow!
The defendant and his girlfriend deserve each other, why the plaintiff is involved with the girlfriend truly escapes me 😢
His girlfriend looks scared I think she needs to get far away from him
The Man was obstructed justice of the case
Hey you can’t whisper like that!
THAT LOOKED CRAZY HOW HE WALKED UP ON HER OMG AND JJ STILL GOT THE ANSWERS OUT OF HER!
What a great court officer allowing the witness to be tampered with right there in the court room. 🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
This was a great case!! Very sad all in all though :(
Lol when he said "she doesnt wanna be brought up in the middle of it" boy she is the middle of it.
I have no issues with how JJ settled this case, but for the record, that witness did look confused.
She looked terrified definitely not confused
Well, she's probably never been in front of so many people before with an opportunity to say, "Please help me" and just couldn't work up the nerve. Or she is on drugs and can barely get through the day.
If she was confused, it was because JJ didnt ask when the creepy Defendant told her to deny.
JJ proved he was a liar because he at first denied a conversation, then partially admitted one. By having the witness authenticate the conversation took place and where, she indirectly autheticates the content.
He wasnt thinking of that but JJ was.
@@briandfallon74 You mean the creepy Defendant
@@skeldare let me edit!!!!! Thanks!
He should go to jail👏🏻 you can’t post photos like that of someone else that’s illegal!!!
There was another revenge porn case JJ did years back (except the POS defendant basically photoshopped his ex’s head from a picture and pasted it on a cartoon/photo body on a flyer promising sex or calling her a W.)
Anyway she also called him an “amoral, low life, piece of crap.”
You can tell she was absolutely incensed with the defendant, especially because he only did it to get back at her after the plaintiff called him he cops on him after he beat her…while pregnant.
I remember that one 👍🏾
I love when judge Judy just lets people step in it, and then she doesn't let it go. She just lets them linger and show the world who they truly are.😂
2:31 does JJ have the power to place someone under arrest. The defendant really messed up there.
3:21 the witness was thinking really hard about lying to JJ
Unfortunately, no, at this this point in time JJ is nothing more than a TV personality (a Former judge, yes, but not for a very long time).
If she had any compassion at all, she would have had a production assistant hold her back to speak with her and tell her her legal options, the actual criminal ones. Because what he did to her was definitely illegal... Unfortunately, it usually winds up MUCH worse for the woman who intended for the picture(s) to be seen by a singular person, than the man who then completely ruins said woman's life forever. The man usually gets a slap on the wrist, while the woman will forever have difficulty finding employment, mending relationships with friends and family. People just look at women differently, like they should know better. Which, as someone who was a teenager in the 90's, I've agreed with in the past, but having watched several documentaries about it, I've come to realize, that while I still agree that you should never take those types of pictures for anyone for any reason (I mean they could get hacked for all you know!), that I was victim blaming. And that was very wrong of me, I couldn't see both sides before.
I now realize why it's literally called REVENGE porn.
It's an arbitration show. Not an episode of Court TV.
Judy when she first hears the recording: that’s it?!
Judy later: there is 3 hours of recording
I'm glad he lied in the manner he did...this video is on the internet for all of eternity so as he continues to move through life this video is proof of how he can bold face lie, and especially to a ruling body. #fool