Need to spread this information to whole world and especially in the ears of thoese hindus who still thinks Sikhs are gaddar and government is always right
The real side of the story needs to be told more. The general sikh/punjabi/indian public do not understand the depths of pre84 & post84. The indian propaganda from the 80s and 90s has controlled the narrative too long. This is an excellent series to educate the ppl and have their questions answered and misunderstandings cleared. Thank you to all who are involved. 🙏
'To comprehend the nature of this attack, an example would be if the Roman Catholics were a minority and the italian army stormed the Vatican on the day of Easter on the orders of the Prime Minister' Reece Chaplin
theres not much eye witnesses interview of the other gurdwaras that were attacked and surrounded..that should be looked into before those eye witnesses pass away
Yes I agree. There is hardly any narratives about the other Gurdwara Sahib’s which were attacked. I would like to know about local testimonies what type of attack it was. Was it military or police. How it effected the local Sangat.
From my understanding the military enter on the evening of June 5th between the hours of 10:30-11:00. They entry is on the Clock Tower side. The entry is undertaken VIA the stairs where the troops are massively cut down. The actual attack still leans towards a shroud of mystery because when you hear the testimonies of the Sikhs who fought inside it is based on a point of view from what they could see from their fortified positions. It’s only local eyewitness or the few reporters left in Amritsar or the actual top brass of the military from their vantage point could tell you the whole operation in omnipresence narrative. General Sundarji who was in command of the operation says that he had to bring in tanks to stop the massacre of his troops.I would have liked to have heard an in-depth discussion of the killing of AS Atwal has there still seems to be a significant conspiracy about his death. Also an in-depth talk about the gunning down of Surinder Singh Sodhi & the background to why this had happened. The involvement of the woman in this role. The reporter Ritish Lakhi has done a lot of work on th his particular chapter. He has gone in-depth on the sub-plots of individual narratives that make-up the whole story.
Benti, please make a podcast on Bhai Sukhdev Singh Babbar and the Babbar Khalsa Jatha. This would be very informative and help sangat learn more/be aware as their contribution for Khalsa Panth and history is immense. 🙏🏽
Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh khalsa ji👏 You are doing a great uprala But please make sure it should be in punjabi Their english is little difficult for us to understand , i also understand tht you have most of ur audience from outside india also Rest it is Great uprala for the sangat👏👏❤️❤️
Question: Paji have there been any attempts whatsoever to try and take responsbility or repent by any of the individuals or larger groups who committed these Zulum? Thank you so much for this amazing in depth series, i would like to request if you could do follow up videos on the Sakhia you said were too many to delve into due to time.
I heard that Sant Jarnail Singh Ji left the Darbar Sahib complex a few days before the attack for a wedding and was allowed to both leave and return by the police is this true?
"On March 6, 1983, thirty Congress legislators from Punjab, convened an urgent meeting and submitted to the Prime Minister, a Memorandum, entitled, ‘Mis-Rule of Sardar Darbara Singh Government in Punjab : As viewed by Congress Legislators’. Apart from pointing out the various acts of omission and commission of Darbara Singh, the Memorandum furnished complete details of the people, places, time and manner in which the entire sacrilegious operation was conducted. Among the names of the persons involved in the sacrilegious acts was the Chairman of a public Corporation, who is said to have helped in procuring the heads of cows to be placed in the precincts of the Hindu temples. They alleged that the entire trouble was engineered to suit the designs of Darbara Singh. It read as under : “The Chief Minister himself got managed the first act of sacrilege of Hindu Temple at Amritsar...... He arranged to send heads of two calves from Mohali (where the beheaded bodies of these calves were found) in a trunk by bus and got the same thrown stealthily in or near the Hindu Temple at Amritsar"
It happened however it was fully condemned by Sant Ji and an MLA called Surinder Kapoor accused the govt of launching a conspiracy and commting these acts themselves. Beadbis of gurudware were happening then too with rumalla and angs of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj being rubbed into cow manure and other disgrsceful acts like tobacco being thrown into the Sri Harmandir Sahib sarovar yet mainstream media were silent on this.
@bostv @BasicsofsikhiTV I have a question for episode 5 veero, what would you say we can do moving forward as a panth to strenthen Sikhi and achieve autonomy as a people? It seems like we always have to wait for a leader to emerge ex. Sant Jarnail Singh ji, Deep Sidhu or Bhai Amritpal Singh, to be able to unite the kaum. This works wonders in short amount of time with the right leader but the Indian Government seems to have learned from their mistakes in the past and acts super fast nowadays to rid our kaum of these leaders. What can we do, it pains me the Sikhi is being supressed, the world needs a beautiful example of Halemi Raj to follow in this moment, Khalistan could be the answer. Thank you for this amazing seva! Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki Fateh
On shamsher final message. I agree with him up until the point of being critical of the idea of changing the system from within and being critical of Sikhs working in police/ army. Shahbeg Singh wouldn’t have been able to fortify the complex as well as it was without his military experience and Beant/ Satwant wouldn’t have been able to assassinate Indra without being in the system.
You didn’t listen to anything! Go back and watch the first Episode. If you don’t understand Punjabi go learn it first and rewatch this. These guys mention over and over again how the State planned this for over 1 year and how the Indian government purposely attacked many other Gurdwaras (70+) beside the Darbar Sahib.
Question: There was a video that Sant Bhindranwale killed a Granthi in Akal Thakat because he didn't agree with him. His name was Giani Partap Singh. Can you address this?
Many of the killings of Sikhs was blamed on the Sikhs themselves. All those killed by the Sikhs were openly claimed by Jhujaroo Jathebandis like the case of DSP Bachan
This isnt true & has been proven not 1 single FIR or legal notice was on sant ji at the time, akali dal & congress & bjp were playing two sides of a political games
Can you make a video of exposing Puneet Sahani because he has said many things that he would regret and he shows evidence about it to prove his point and he mostly gets his evidence from anti Sikh writers and has taken context out of everything and missed all other information and other good books.
Whatever happened in 1984 was wrong and should have happened. But why Sikhs never mention(forget about accepting) what Sikh youth did to Hindus in Punjab post 1984? Sache ho taan puri gall karo, adhi ni.
Can you guys address the accusations proposed in this video, "Bhindranwale Was NOT A Hero | The REAL Story | Harbhajan | Operation Blue Star" by The Sham Sharma Show.
1:19:52 𝐓𝐇𝐄 𝐋𝐈𝐁𝐄𝐑𝐀𝐓𝐈𝐕𝐄 𝐏𝐀𝐑𝐀𝐃𝐈𝐆𝐌 Sikhism is not a religion if the word means only "one of the systems of faith and worship" or just "a personal awareness or conviction of the existence of a supreme being," it is a way of life, a cultural system that enlightens about living as liberated beings. The notion of personal freedom did exist in the form of moksha in Hinduism and as nirvana in Buddhism, but it bypassed the mediating structures that enforce and confirm freedom and change it into liberation. A person can be personally or individually free and still remain unliberated. ~📔SIKHISM AND POSTMODERN THOUGHT
![Sant Baba Nand Singh Ji Podcast | Gurmukh Series [PART 2]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/tHkAWQEUAFg/mqdefault.jpg)
PART3!! This podcast series is life changing, thankyou to the 4 speakers!
Bhai Shamsher Singh Jee - arguably on of the biggest thinkers of the Panth today.
May Guroo Sahibs light, vision and wisdom keep shining through you.
Thank you for this, finally 84 discussed in detail
Need to spread this information to whole world and especially in the ears of thoese hindus who still thinks Sikhs are gaddar and government is always right
learned more about my history in these parts than ever
Read and listen to gur ithyaas
@@kulbiesinghnihang meant political ithyaas
Need to learn about all Sikh ithihaas.
@@kulbiesinghnihang Need to learn about all Sikh ithihaas.
this is the content i’ve been looking for especially since reconnecting with my religion and this is awesome. thank you
Was waiting for this since past week. Really grateful for valuable information.
This deserves a million views !
Dhan sikhi❤❤❤
The real side of the story needs to be told more. The general sikh/punjabi/indian public do not understand the depths of pre84 & post84. The indian propaganda from the 80s and 90s has controlled the narrative too long. This is an excellent series to educate the ppl and have their questions answered and misunderstandings cleared. Thank you to all who are involved. 🙏
These men in this video are the ones who are pro pagandists
Waheguru ji🙏🏻
'To comprehend the nature of this attack, an example would be if the Roman Catholics were a minority and the italian army stormed the Vatican on the day of Easter on the orders of the Prime Minister' Reece Chaplin
Peace and love from Punjab, Pakistan 💚🇵🇰
Awesome work!
I can't describe how amazing this podcast series is, thank you 🙏🏽
Weheguru Sahab ji
1984 tribute website can not be accessed in India, it's blocked by the state. That's the freedom of speech, t's ridiculous.
Till date I have No Courage to watch these videos…
Heart trenching….
theres not much eye witnesses interview of the other gurdwaras that were attacked and surrounded..that should be looked into before those eye witnesses pass away
Yes I agree. There is hardly any narratives about the other Gurdwara Sahib’s which were attacked. I would like to know about local testimonies what type of attack it was. Was it military or police. How it effected the local Sangat.
There is a book about it and the website is Bibekgarh. It has the testimonies and eye witness accounts into one book.
❤️🙏🏽❤️
Gur Fateh Khalsa ji 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
From my understanding the military enter on the evening of June 5th between the hours of 10:30-11:00. They entry is on the Clock Tower side. The entry is undertaken VIA the stairs where the troops are massively cut down. The actual attack still leans towards a shroud of mystery because when you hear the testimonies of the Sikhs who fought inside it is based on a point of view from what they could see from their fortified positions. It’s only local eyewitness or the few reporters left in Amritsar or the actual top brass of the military from their vantage point could tell you the whole operation in omnipresence narrative. General Sundarji who was in command of the operation says that he had to bring in tanks to stop the massacre of his troops.I would have liked to have heard an in-depth discussion of the killing of AS Atwal has there still
seems to be a significant conspiracy about his death. Also an in-depth talk about the gunning down of Surinder Singh Sodhi & the background to why this had happened. The involvement of the woman in this role. The reporter Ritish Lakhi has done a lot of work on th his particular chapter. He has gone in-depth on the sub-plots of individual narratives that make-up the whole story.
Today before watching congratulations with Amritpal Singh victory!
Benti, please make a podcast on Bhai Sukhdev Singh Babbar and the Babbar Khalsa Jatha. This would be very informative and help sangat learn more/be aware as their contribution for Khalsa Panth and history is immense. 🙏🏽
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh khalsa ji👏
You are doing a great uprala
But please make sure it should be in punjabi
Their english is little difficult for us to understand , i also understand tht you have most of ur audience from outside india also
Rest it is Great uprala for the sangat👏👏❤️❤️
yes, but us non-punjabi speaking Sikhs also need to learn.
It's a shame, where we did not listen to panth pathsha and went with akaalis. They saw the future and knew akaalis will let them down
This is incorrect unfortunately. Maybe watch the series and then give your feedback
ੴ
Question: Paji have there been any attempts whatsoever to try and take responsbility or repent by any of the individuals or larger groups who committed these Zulum?
Thank you so much for this amazing in depth series, i would like to request if you could do follow up videos on the Sakhia you said were too many to delve into due to time.
Where are the links Bhai Sahib Ji mentioned for the Organisations?
I heard that Sant Jarnail Singh Ji left the Darbar Sahib complex a few days before the attack for a wedding and was allowed to both leave and return by the police is this true?
Not true. He died in the complex
SB OFFICIAL AI 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Question: A book by Mark Tully said "In order to incite Hindus, head and other parts of the anatomy of cows were thrown into temples". Is this true?
"On March 6, 1983, thirty Congress legislators from Punjab, convened an urgent meeting and submitted to the
Prime Minister, a Memorandum, entitled, ‘Mis-Rule of Sardar Darbara Singh Government in Punjab : As viewed by Congress Legislators’. Apart from
pointing out the various acts of omission and commission of Darbara Singh, the Memorandum furnished complete details of the people, places, time and manner in which the entire sacrilegious operation was conducted. Among the names of the persons involved in the sacrilegious acts was the Chairman of a public Corporation, who is said to have helped in procuring the heads of cows to be placed in the precincts of the Hindu temples. They alleged that
the entire trouble was engineered to suit the designs of Darbara Singh. It read as under : “The Chief Minister himself got managed the first act of sacrilege of Hindu Temple at Amritsar...... He arranged to send heads of two calves from Mohali (where the beheaded bodies of these calves were found) in a trunk by bus and got the same thrown stealthily in or near the Hindu Temple at Amritsar"
It happened however it was fully condemned by Sant Ji and an MLA called Surinder Kapoor accused the govt of launching a conspiracy and commting these acts themselves. Beadbis of gurudware were happening then too with rumalla and angs of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj being rubbed into cow manure and other disgrsceful acts like tobacco being thrown into the Sri Harmandir Sahib sarovar yet mainstream media were silent on this.
Sant ji gave money to the hindus to investigate the beadbi because it didnt help the sikhs in anyway so it didnt make sense for any sikh to do that
What is Name Of These Singhs ...
@bostv @BasicsofsikhiTV
I have a question for episode 5 veero, what would you say we can do moving forward as a panth to strenthen Sikhi and achieve autonomy as a people? It seems like we always have to wait for a leader to emerge ex. Sant Jarnail Singh ji, Deep Sidhu or Bhai Amritpal Singh, to be able to unite the kaum. This works wonders in short amount of time with the right leader but the Indian Government seems to have learned from their mistakes in the past and acts super fast nowadays to rid our kaum of these leaders. What can we do, it pains me the Sikhi is being supressed, the world needs a beautiful example of Halemi Raj to follow in this moment, Khalistan could be the answer.
Thank you for this amazing seva!
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki Fateh
On shamsher final message. I agree with him up until the point of being critical of the idea of changing the system from within and being critical of Sikhs working in police/ army. Shahbeg Singh wouldn’t have been able to fortify the complex as well as it was without his military experience and Beant/ Satwant wouldn’t have been able to assassinate Indra without being in the system.
They didnt change the system from within, they turned against it
🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️🌹🌹
Please call it a ghallugara and not a saka
very true bhai sahib
ਗੁਰਮੁਖੋ ਖਾਲਸੇ ਦੇ ਅਸਲੀ ਨਿਸ਼ਾਨ ਸਾਹਿਬ ਦਾ ਰੰਗ ਸੁਰਮਈ ਹੈ ਕੇਸਰੀ ਨਹੀਂ। ਘੱਟ ਤੋਂ ਘੱਟ ਅਸਲੀ ਨਿਸ਼ਾਨ ਸਾਹਿਬ ਤਾਂ ਆਪਣਾ ਲਵੋ। ਬਾਕੀ ਰਹੀ ਖਾਲਸਾ ਰਾਜ ਦੀ ਗੱਲ ਉਹਦੇ ਲਈ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਆਕੇ ਮੋਰਚਾ ਖੋਲਣਾ ਪੈਣਾ ਹੈ। ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂ ਜੀ ਕਾ ਖਾਲਸਾ, ਸ਼੍ਰੀ ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂ ਜੀ ਕੀ ਫਤਹਿ।
Darbar sahib was not under attack. These guys put at risk Darbar sahib. Let’s be clear.
You didn’t listen to anything! Go back and watch the first Episode. If you don’t understand Punjabi go learn it first and rewatch this. These guys mention over and over again how the State planned this for over 1 year and how the Indian government purposely attacked many other Gurdwaras (70+) beside the Darbar Sahib.
We want khalistand l am sikh but only 14 year old pls veer jii mai apni Jaaan nu Kirpan Kar du ka par never accept my country india
Question: There was a video that Sant Bhindranwale killed a Granthi in Akal Thakat because he didn't agree with him. His name was Giani Partap Singh. Can you address this?
Many of the killings of Sikhs was blamed on the Sikhs themselves. All those killed by the Sikhs were openly claimed by Jhujaroo Jathebandis like the case of DSP Bachan
This isnt true & has been proven not 1 single FIR or legal notice was on sant ji at the time, akali dal & congress & bjp were playing two sides of a political games
Fake news son of a cop you are.m
Bhindranwale was made by Congress to challenge Akali dal. He was no sant but an extremist
What action should Muslim do to go to haven according to guru granth sahb ?
Can you make a video of exposing Puneet Sahani because he has said many things that he would regret and he shows evidence about it to prove his point and he mostly gets his evidence from anti Sikh writers and has taken context out of everything and missed all other information and other good books.
Excellent episode
Whatever happened in 1984 was wrong and should have happened. But why Sikhs never mention(forget about accepting) what Sikh youth did to Hindus in Punjab post 1984? Sache ho taan puri gall karo, adhi ni.
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹very v v good khalsa ji edaande program bahut jaroori han
its not a saka but aGhalughara
GALLUGHARA**
Can you guys address the accusations proposed in this video, "Bhindranwale Was NOT A Hero | The REAL Story | Harbhajan | Operation Blue Star" by The Sham Sharma Show.
He is an idiot. Read the book Sant bhindranwale di roobroo june 84 di patrakaari
That whole video is a pro Indian shill telling Sikhs that someone who fought for you isn’t a hero.
Sham sharma is a far right nationalist who gets on ex raw agents who literally its their job to be anti sant ji 😂
Brother pls don't instigate religious sentiments.. be in peace
Half history.
1:19:52
𝐓𝐇𝐄 𝐋𝐈𝐁𝐄𝐑𝐀𝐓𝐈𝐕𝐄 𝐏𝐀𝐑𝐀𝐃𝐈𝐆𝐌
Sikhism is not a religion if the word means only "one of the systems of faith and worship" or just "a personal awareness or conviction of the existence of a supreme being," it is a way of life, a cultural system that enlightens about living as liberated beings. The notion of personal freedom did exist in the form of moksha in Hinduism and as nirvana in Buddhism, but it bypassed the mediating structures that enforce and confirm freedom and change it into liberation. A person can be personally or individually free and still remain unliberated.
~📔SIKHISM AND POSTMODERN THOUGHT
Cheti mildeh a Singh O