I didn’t realise that the guy I was trolling used to be the Chief Economic Advisor to the Government of India and is an alumnus of IIM Calcutta. He did his PhD from University of Chicago under under Raghuram Rajan! 😂😂😂😂
Raghuram Rajan is A IMF Stooge intentionally giving indian govt bad advice to run india in such degrowth mode to reduce indian workers leverage to have better living standards, safety and so forth so its ripe for exploitation
To compare per capita income in terms of gold prices for 1947 and 2025, we can find: 1. Per Capita Income in each year. 1947: ₹247/year 2025: ₹184,205/year 2. Gold Price per gram in each year. 1947: ₹1.50/gram 2025: ₹7,882/gram --- Per Capita Income in Terms of Gold (in grams) 1. 1947: 247/1.50 = 164.67grams of gold. 2. 2025: 184,205/7,882 = 23.37grams of gold. Summary: In 1947, an average Indian could afford approximately 164.67 grams of gold with their annual income. In 2025, an average Indian can afford approximately 23.37 grams of gold with their annual income.
मतलब उसे समय में कोई मजदूर को जितनी मजदूरी मान लेते है 5-10 रुपया , और आज दिन मजदूरी है 300-500 रुपया , लेकिन जितना गोल्ड वह व्यक्ति उस समय की मजदूरी में ले सकता था , उतना आज एक दिन की मजदूरी में नहीं ले सकता है । देखने में लगता है कि उस समय जो मजदूरी 5- 10 थी, आज बढ़कर 300 से 500 रुपए हो गई है लेकिन असल में वह मजदूरी आज की मजदूरी ज्यादा थी , आज भी लोगों का शोषण हो रहा है , जब तक लोग देश की देश की मुद्रा रुपया को नहीं समझते तब तक उनका शोषण होता रहेगा इसके समझने के लिए पुस्तक रुपया मूल्य की मापक यह शोषण का साधन लेखक घनश्याम वर्मा जी को पढ़ना होगा ।
Bro u always point out mistakes but it would be much better if u teach people how to think about these economic issues by providing resources, i.e PLEASE provide resources for learning economics bro. PLEASE provide a plan to learn economics etc so that atleast basic stuff like this can be understood!!!! THANKS for your work
So according to BJP IT cell employee Rishi Bagree, today's India is as much rich as it was at the eve of independence? Kon sa maal phookte hai ye IT cell wale?
Even after all the destruction Congress did to India, still in 1976 China open western and investment capitalist trade but still congress took about 11 years + to bring this open economy to us in 1991 ☠️ - I removed 4 years as government of other collation parties were in central power for them.
Congress built the country up from scratch after British rule. Your roads, railways, iims, iits, aiims, airports, basic heavy industry... all congress. Don't follow blindly the narrative of destruction. Yes they were corrupt that is different story. Are present Govts any less corrupt.
Abe ghanchakkar wo economic advisor tha use pata hai pehle exchange rate sarkar decide kartit thi. Uska pura arguement to sunta. 1 line to puro kari nahi tune. Tu bhi ye tweet karne wale ke jaisa hi hai. Dono ko bas views chahiy
To summarise a) $2700 in 1947 (post world war 2) is a lot different than $2700 in 2024. b) The decrease in per capita (in $) until 1991 doesn't really imply drop in standard of living. Since, the rigid protectionist policies that were in place back then, would have potentially led to the drop in exchange rate regardless of the people's standard of living at those points in time. c) Even if the standard of living has improved since 1947 without any breaks, there's still a lot of room for improvement.
Good ! I learnt a lot from your videos! Anyway, I want to know your opinion about UBI ( would it be beneficial in case of India) and hypothetically suppose if NYAY the congress promised scheme was indeed have been passed? Would it be good for indians (as whole) or bad?
Only way to stop this problem is replacment with a new economic model. You can't fight this system cause we are meant fail in this system but we can replace it or else we will be replaced.
Well there are very smart ways to critique the pre 1991 period and we did miss many opportunities certainly twitter poltical trolls of parties would be the last one to learn it
Nice video And I have a suggestion. There was a debate between Akash banarjee and Palki Sharma Akash said that our GDP per capita is very low, then palki countered it saying our GDP per capita doubled in a decade. I think, we should check growth rate of every country GDP per capita in a decade then decide. It looks like a lot of hardwork
Palki ki khde 2 le le lega ye keshav bhai 😂😂 She was good journalist bt it seems that she is now working for current ruling party... I can give u facts
@@keshavbedi there is difference GDP growth rate which was backed by very high inflation rate of 10 percent and GDP growth backed by 4-5 percent GDP growth rate.i hope u know the difference between both.
Domestic inflation on certain necessary goods is at an all time high post liberalisation. Also inflation alone is barely any proper manner to express or comment on the economy itself.
Ismein BJP kahan se aa gayi? You don't have to politicise an educational content. Shayad ye dikhana zaruri tha ki tum jahan ke Graduate ho wahan ke ☪️hatuKaar ho. The criteria to calculate Per capita income itself is full of too many loopholes, especially income inequality which is obvious and also the cost of living in the backdrop. Your high per capita income means nothing if the cost of living is too high in your country. Its high time that we scrap off the crappy method to calculate it. & Consider breaking down per capita income on categorical basis from low to high earning individuals and do factor in the cost of living to get the true value of Per Capita Income. It may sound challenging but with the help of advanced AI tools it shouldn't be that difficult. Unless the economists want to remain lazy forever.
Lmao The bjp chatukars call anyone a musalman Fyi this dude is reffred to as a bhagwa communist in left wing circles as he is a devout hindu and is distrusted due to that lmao
@@pseudojournalist Going by your logic the countries which claim to be a muslim, by calling themselves essentially a Muslim country are all BJP chatukars. “FYI” in my original comment, which is still unedited, nowhere was it mentioned that, “this dude”, is a “musalman”, if you care enough to check his YT bio, you'll see where he has graduated from. Which has less to do with religion and more to do with brainwashing.
Bde bhai camparison ko chodo. Congress ne desh ke bussnuess ka batha bitha diya tha . Itni fomality bussiness krne me ki koi bussiness krne se bhi drta tha .
inshort currency rates were fixed back then now post 1991 eco-liberalization it is floating also why do u make videos u prolly pront money from your economics backgrnd lol
I didn’t realise that the guy I was trolling used to be the Chief Economic Advisor to the Government of India and is an alumnus of IIM Calcutta. He did his PhD from University of Chicago under under Raghuram Rajan! 😂😂😂😂
रट्टू तोता 😂 है वो
Raghuram Rajan is A IMF Stooge intentionally giving indian govt bad advice to run india in such degrowth mode to reduce indian workers leverage to have better living standards, safety and so forth so its ripe for exploitation
To compare per capita income in terms of gold prices for 1947 and 2025, we can find:
1. Per Capita Income in each year.
1947: ₹247/year
2025: ₹184,205/year
2. Gold Price per gram in each year.
1947: ₹1.50/gram
2025: ₹7,882/gram
---
Per Capita Income in Terms of Gold (in grams)
1. 1947:
247/1.50 = 164.67grams of gold.
2. 2025:
184,205/7,882 = 23.37grams of gold.
Summary:
In 1947, an average Indian could afford approximately 164.67 grams of gold with their annual income.
In 2025, an average Indian can afford approximately 23.37 grams of gold with their annual income.
मतलब उसे समय में कोई मजदूर को जितनी मजदूरी मान लेते है 5-10 रुपया , और आज दिन मजदूरी है 300-500 रुपया , लेकिन जितना गोल्ड वह व्यक्ति उस समय की मजदूरी में ले सकता था , उतना आज एक दिन की मजदूरी में नहीं ले सकता है । देखने में लगता है कि उस समय जो मजदूरी 5- 10 थी, आज बढ़कर 300 से 500 रुपए हो गई है लेकिन असल में वह मजदूरी आज की मजदूरी ज्यादा थी , आज भी लोगों का शोषण हो रहा है , जब तक लोग देश की देश की मुद्रा रुपया को नहीं समझते तब तक उनका शोषण होता रहेगा इसके समझने के लिए पुस्तक रुपया मूल्य की मापक यह शोषण का साधन लेखक घनश्याम वर्मा जी को पढ़ना होगा ।
Palki ko khud nahi pata hoga 😂
Usko ghanta pata hota hai. Wo bs report padhne me expert hai.
@@saurabh1087 haa
@@VipinMGaur vo bjp ki spoke person ban gyi hai
Palki ko sirf UPI pata hai aur kuch nahi
ROASTED ❌
FRIED ✅
😂
Deep fried
Bro u always point out mistakes but it would be much better if u teach people how to think about these economic issues by providing resources, i.e PLEASE provide resources for learning economics bro. PLEASE provide a plan to learn economics etc so that atleast basic stuff like this can be understood!!!! THANKS for your work
😂read ncert of class11 and 12 ye kro phr aage bta dunga cheers
Yanis Varoufakis
Aajkal surname se pata chal jaata kaun kiska gun gaan gayega aur kis se nafrat karega.
रुपया किसी वस्तु के मूल्य का मापक है , रुपया एक स्टैंडर्ड है , जैसे किलोग्राम , लेकिन लोगो को अवैध रुपया के माध्यम से कंट्रोल किया जा रहा है ,
My Favourite Economics Teacher
So according to BJP IT cell employee Rishi Bagree, today's India is as much rich as it was at the eve of independence?
Kon sa maal phookte hai ye IT cell wale?
Atleast Kashmir, Manipur, West Bengal, Assam, Kerla aur Tamilnadu ka Sleeper Cell wala Maal nahi Phoonk rahe.
"My source is that I made it the fuck up"
1947 में 1 डॉलर में 1 रूपए होता था ।
आज एक डॉलर 84 रुपया पहुंचा चूका है ।
Even after all the destruction Congress did to India, still in 1976 China open western and investment capitalist trade but still congress took about 11 years + to bring this open economy to us in 1991 ☠️ - I removed 4 years as government of other collation parties were in central power for them.
Congress built the country up from scratch after British rule. Your roads, railways, iims, iits, aiims, airports, basic heavy industry... all congress. Don't follow blindly the narrative of destruction. Yes they were corrupt that is different story. Are present Govts any less corrupt.
Abe ghanchakkar wo economic advisor tha use pata hai pehle exchange rate sarkar decide kartit thi. Uska pura arguement to sunta. 1 line to puro kari nahi tune. Tu bhi ye tweet karne wale ke jaisa hi hai. Dono ko bas views chahiy
To summarise
a) $2700 in 1947 (post world war 2) is a lot different than $2700 in 2024.
b) The decrease in per capita (in $) until 1991 doesn't really imply drop in standard of living. Since, the rigid protectionist policies that were in place back then, would have potentially led to the drop in exchange rate regardless of the people's standard of living at those points in time.
c) Even if the standard of living has improved since 1947 without any breaks, there's still a lot of room for improvement.
Good ! I learnt a lot from your videos! Anyway, I want to know your opinion about UBI ( would it be beneficial in case of India) and hypothetically suppose if NYAY the congress promised scheme was indeed have been passed? Would it be good for indians (as whole) or bad?
Needs experimentation
Bro its per capita Income not GDP written here
Saw that thread last night and thought to tag you who knew you'd already plan to make a video
Now I am addicted to his videos
Sir you are a very rational person, could please guide me how can i learn economics in depth I am pursuing my bcom.🙏🙏
Only way to stop this problem is replacment with a new economic model.
You can't fight this system cause we are meant fail in this system but we can replace it or else we will be replaced.
As if British rule left India with anything.
Well there are very smart ways to critique the pre 1991 period and we did miss many opportunities certainly twitter poltical trolls of parties would be the last one to learn it
Nehru ki galti 🤡🤡
Beizzat hone ke liye bhi talen chaihe hota hai, 😂. Keep on going brotha.
Nice video
And I have a suggestion. There was a debate between Akash banarjee and Palki Sharma
Akash said that our GDP per capita is very low, then palki countered it saying our GDP per capita doubled in a decade.
I think, we should check growth rate of every country GDP per capita in a decade then decide.
It looks like a lot of hardwork
I did a video comparing GDP growth under Manmohan Singh and Modi. Do check it out.
@ask_shrey
Bhai india ki per capita 2004 se 14 double se bhi jyada bdhia thi ...😂
Palki ki khde 2 le le lega ye keshav bhai 😂😂
She was good journalist bt it seems that she is now working for current ruling party...
I can give u facts
@@keshavbedi there is difference GDP growth rate which was backed by very high inflation rate of 10 percent and GDP growth backed by 4-5 percent GDP growth rate.i hope u know the difference between both.
In 2004 it was 700$
In 2014 it was 2035$
Growth almost 300%
In 2024 3758$
Gowth 75% 🤡🤡
Palki khud moodi bhakat hai
Vo masterstoke waali hai English mai
Power capita per gdp ... Nahi per capita income ...
Per capita Gdp as a share of GDP pf India was same in 1947 Vs 1991.
Bro can you give opinion on! Should india take more debt in order to fix important issues
Mai bhi modi supporter hu lekin ye data to kachra jaisa hai
Isse accha inflation ka % dikha ke compare kar dete (modi ke term me sabse kam thi)
Domestic inflation on certain necessary goods is at an all time high post liberalisation. Also inflation alone is barely any proper manner to express or comment on the economy itself.
Bro eating whole gobar bhkt gang in every video 😂😂😂
Ismein BJP kahan se aa gayi? You don't have to politicise an educational content.
Shayad ye dikhana zaruri tha ki tum jahan ke Graduate ho wahan ke ☪️hatuKaar ho.
The criteria to calculate
Per capita income itself is full of too many loopholes, especially income inequality which is obvious and also the cost of living in the backdrop.
Your high per capita income means nothing if the cost of living is too high in your country. Its high time that we scrap off the crappy method to calculate it. & Consider breaking down per capita income on categorical basis from low to high earning individuals and do factor in the cost of living to get the true value of Per Capita Income.
It may sound challenging but with the help of advanced AI tools it shouldn't be that difficult. Unless the economists want to remain lazy forever.
Lmao
The bjp chatukars call anyone a musalman
Fyi this dude is reffred to as a bhagwa communist in left wing circles as he is a devout hindu and is distrusted due to that lmao
@@pseudojournalist
Going by your logic the countries which claim to be a muslim, by calling themselves essentially a Muslim country are all BJP chatukars.
“FYI” in my original comment, which is still unedited, nowhere was it mentioned that, “this dude”, is a “musalman”, if you care enough to check his YT bio, you'll see where he has graduated from. Which has less to do with religion and more to do with brainwashing.
Me bhi vohi bolne wala tha, ye log 1947 se 2014 tak kashmir ko stabilize nhi kar sake aur bjp ne bas 10 salo me kar diya 😂
The person speaking to Palki was CEA to Government of India under BJP rule, and Rishi Bagree is a serial BJP IT Cell troll.
@@IndianAmericanTrumpSuppoter 🔔 kiya . Desh loot liya 3 guna paisa kha gaye desh ka jitna poore pichle 65 saal me poora desh chala
Subbed
Bro please views on paveet Singh podcast w dostcast
His views on Israel -palestine and casteism are pretty interesting.
Would love to know the reality
Vo bs Abhishek kar k sophisticated version h😂😂😂
Haven't seen
Abe pahle poori video toh dekh le bhai choti clips ke base par perception mat banao
Keshav bhai aap galat field me agye ho roasting channel start kare 10 million ek month me ho jayege apke 😂😂
Please watch honest saying podcast lakshay Chaudhary episode time satmp 1:22:36
Omg lakshay Chaudhary is defination of gawar
Most comprehensive answer contained here:
ua-cam.com/video/8ZyT0UEAlYo/v-deo.htmlsi=C8fGh4vkZUzw4Jtp
Population bhi matter karti hai
Commen voter should read economic rather wath hate devate
Bde bhai camparison ko chodo. Congress ne desh ke bussnuess ka batha bitha diya tha . Itni fomality bussiness krne me ki koi bussiness krne se bhi drta tha .
Ye har video me compliment de kar criticise karta hai
inshort currency rates were fixed back then now post 1991 eco-liberalization it is floating
also why do u make videos u prolly pront money from your economics backgrnd lol
Tere college ka naam dekh k pata chal Gaya…. Tu kis side se bolega 😂😂😂
Tere comment se pata chalta hai ki aaj bhi diaper pehenke ghoomta hai😂
👏
Delhi School of Economics?
@@keshavbedi Jamia
@@DM-gq5pt or Tera naam dekhke bhi pata lag raha hai ki tu 2 rupay per comment wala ruling government ke troLL gang se hai .,,,
Halki upadyay ko dimag nhi h😂
😂
Bewakoof just searched it on the Google he is speaking the truth