Who Sang It Best? Mirror Mirror (Angel Of Music) Opening - The Phantom Of The Opera

A selection of actors to portray The Phantom in the show’s history
1. John Owen-Jones
2. Earl Carpenter
3. Killian Donnelly
4. James Gant
5. Simon Bowman
6. Peter Lockyer
7. Jonathan Bourne
8. Josh Piterman
9. Brent Barrett
10. David Thaxton
11. Hugh Panaro
12. Gerard Butler
13. Peter Karrie
14. Peter Joback
15. Ben Crawford
16. Anthony Crivello
17. Ben Forster
18. Jonathan Roxmouth
19. Michael Crawford
20. Colm Wilkinson
21. Anthony Warlow
22. Ben Lewis
23. Ramin Karimloo

[@PhantomOperaWickedTheaterPhan]

While all the Phantoms here are phenomenal for different reasons, I particularly enjoy Ben Crawford’s Phantom the most. There’s something so special about his voice that I really like. He is amazing.

[@kyrasmeliansky5660]

Ben Crawford, Ramin Karimloo, And micheal Crawford just did it for me, they’re the best

[@mariekevanmuijden4675]

John Owen-Jones all the way for me. His anger is believable and you almost feel the way the Phantom must have felt. I prefer a Phantom who doesn't sing 'fool' exactly to the note, meaning it is more a spoken than a sung 'fool!!'.

[@christinewells-leddon9287]

My favorites would be Ramin Karimloo and Michael Crawford

[@florzinhala]

JOJ, Hugh Panaro, Josh Piterman, Peter Lockyer, Michael Crawford.

[@swanben11]

There are many great Phantoms, but Anthony Warlow and JoJ just do it for me.

[@Alexia3220]

John Owen Jones❤❤❤

[@Mr-tu4cj]

Michael Crawford is the only one who gets it. He sounds like an actual ghost! The others are great but they don’t have the same atmosphere to them.

[@ritakowalski1677]

Ramin Karimloo is a very close second!

[@andreahomer9434]

For me, *the* Phantom is Anthony Warlow. The level of menace and madness he generates along with the sheer power of his voice make him the ultimate Phantom for me. Pity I'll never get to see him in the role.
Out of the Phantoms I've seen live, John Owen Jones is spectacular.
So...
Who sang it best here?
1. Anthony Warlow
2. John Owen Jones
Thank you for your hard work. These clips are wonderful.
Have subscribed!

[@rickardroach9075]

This lucky Aussie saw him twice, c.1990 and c.2007. 😉

[@andreahomer9434]

@@rickardroach9075 Oh, I'm very jealous! How wonderful.

[@ingridmay66]

Butler, Ramin, Crawford

[@gast3r661]

I love Colm Wilkinson but I can only see him as Jean ValJean and no one else

[@alanshore17]

Forgot Howard McGillin. I love his mirror scene-he explodes!

[@EmilyGloeggler7984]

My dream Erik is one who has a good healthy operatic technique and voice and who tries to be faithful to Leroux’s description, and makes the character believable. Very few achieve that. Those who did closer to that, on this list of yours with the clips you presented are Michael Crawford, Josh Piterman, Anthony Warlow, John Owen Jones, James Gant, and Peter Lockyer. I will give a shout-out to Brent Barrett for his excellent delivery but his voice is not operatic or suitable for the character.

[@joshuaoconnor6191]

Killian Donnelly hands down 🤍

[@Janine0401]

Killian Donnelly. No need to think

[@natekrieger5741]

Tony Crivello

[@paganimumboota9873]

We love Jon Bourne!!!

[@ritakowalski1677]

Gerard Butler hands down

[@kellycannobbio746]

Agreed! I loved the raw, masculine and passionate tone in his voice! ♥️🔥😍🥰🎭

[@Mr-tu4cj]

He sounds way too harsh imo Phantom shouldn’t sound growls and masculine.

[@kellycannobbio746]

#ButlerDidItBetter
😁🔥✊🏻🥰🎭