The Gilmour bits and solos sound like they're from the Pulse version of the song. This is awesome. Whoever put this cut together deserves a Meddle (bum dum tss)
Pulse's solos are better structured, on the CD versions.This contains errors so it might be from the video.Surely when you hear strings it is from Gdansk.
It's only a matter of TIME before the differences between US AND THEM just become disputes of ANY COLOUR YOU LIKE, but we shouldn't be LEARNING TO FLY just yet, just let me go through ONE OF MY TURNS. (UMMAGUMMA) let's just go SEE EMILY PLAY with DOGS, SHEEP, and othet ANIMALS. (That's some heavy Floyd)
Amazingly ensambled: Best piece ever..! (disclamer: there is a special place in hell waiting for the twisted mind who placed an advert in the middle of that solo)
I made this same edit on cassette way back in the day, but I was forced to use the PF version from Delicate Sound CD as it was around the time of the Berlin concert so, early 90's. Definitely sounds better with the Pulse version. The DSOT version seemed very subdued compared the edginess of the Berlin show. Also I used to always transpose my CD's of Radio KAOS and Momentary Lapse in the opposite cases, trying to mentally will the to parties to live in harmony!! Oh well...
Very nice, was it recorded in 1979/1980? I always imaged that Gilmour further developed 'the second solo' during the later tours, but the basic musical structure is all here already.
Dear Toasted Pig, from 9:36 , where he makes it sound like angry seagulls soaring overhead.... where was that from? Album or Performance? Thanks! Whenever I want to hear C.Numb, yours here is the one!
Please read the description. "All I know is that this clip is a mix between Roger Waters (the wall in Berlin 1990), and Pink Floyd. And the end solo is about 7 minutes long."
The solo is never long enough for me!
I feel that shit.
Fr!
Best solo ever
same feeling xd
Honest to god, specifically this version, this solo, is my favorite piece of music ever composed.
The Gilmour bits and solos sound like they're from the Pulse version of the song. This is awesome. Whoever put this cut together deserves a Meddle (bum dum tss)
Pulse's solos are better structured, on the CD versions.This contains errors so it might be from the video.Surely when you hear strings it is from Gdansk.
It's only a matter of TIME before the differences between US AND THEM just become disputes of ANY COLOUR YOU LIKE, but we shouldn't be LEARNING TO FLY just yet, just let me go through ONE OF MY TURNS. (UMMAGUMMA) let's just go SEE EMILY PLAY with DOGS, SHEEP, and othet ANIMALS. (That's some heavy Floyd)
its wrong
It must be from the live in Berlin 21 July 1990 I recognize the ambulance at the start of the video.
Ha funny!
Amazingly ensambled: Best piece ever..! (disclamer: there is a special place in hell waiting for the twisted mind who placed an advert in the middle of that solo)
it's wonderful to be comfortably numb...
I've never heard anything else that beats this song.
My favorite version , thanks and toast pig, .
this is candy to my ears
On my way to work right now, and I am Comfortably Numb .
THE BEST BAND and THE BEST GUITARIST!!!!GILMOUR LEGENDS PLEASE!
O melhor solo de guitarra de todos os tempos, se alguém conseguir provar ao contrário, me mostre.
This is as good as it gets. Trust me.
This is my favourite take so far.
ua-cam.com/video/eZ7oODRoJxA/v-deo.html
BEST song EVER!! BEST BAND EVER!! Thanks so much!! Hey from Aussie land. :D
The second solo is mixed so well. We just need someone to remaster it
This is from 2 different shows, but nevertheless, great job with the mix!
WOW. Just WOW................
esto fue muy ...intenso!!.....buen trabajo.!
Thank You.
Wow! Solo!
always had fear and hatred for the ambulance...
mindblown!!!!
AWESOME ❤️
That version on the P.U.L.S.E release is somewhat shorter than the one broadcast on PPV (the same show). 9:29 on P.U.L.S.E; 10:42 or thereabouts PPV.
Yes, the CD version sounds more structured. They have edited out parts of the solo that do not actually work so much on repeated plays.
I made this same edit on cassette way back in the day, but I was forced to use the PF version from Delicate Sound CD as it was around the time of the Berlin concert so, early 90's. Definitely sounds better with the Pulse version. The DSOT version seemed very subdued compared the edginess of the Berlin show. Also I used to always transpose my CD's of Radio KAOS and Momentary Lapse in the opposite cases, trying to mentally will the to parties to live in harmony!! Oh well...
Very nice, was it recorded in 1979/1980? I always imaged that Gilmour further developed 'the second solo' during the later tours, but the basic musical structure is all here already.
All I know is that this clip is a mix between Roger Waters (the wall in Berlin 1990), and Pink Floyd. And the end solo is about 7 minutes long.
+Servaas Verbrugge + some taken in PULSE LIVE
its pulse's c-n version. it doesnt mean its bad (imho solo is best ever i heard), but i thought i might find something i havent heard
Guys,
Do you know what happened to thr original extended studio version with absolutely different lyrics?
Can't find it on YT anymore
I'm not sure but I have it on a DVD
You want me to record it and upload it?
I've just heard this song and it wasn't quite enough. Is there a loooonger version?
I don´t know
I know right haha that solo should be longer
This is awesome roger waters is the best.
if you put the playback speed at 1.1when gilmour starts to sing ,and before the final solo, it sounds better.
☝️👀💯🐓
" La mejor fotografía "
Toasted pig, You have my vote for God!!!! Thank you so much!!!
true version
The fact that there was an add in the middle of the solo really pisses me off
Dear Toasted Pig, from 9:36 , where he makes it sound like angry seagulls soaring overhead.... where was that from? Album or Performance? Thanks! Whenever I want to hear C.Numb, yours here is the one!
Sorry but I have no answer. I hav no information about this track
Pulse performance
That solo is unworthy of us mortals
It's kick ass!
Wtf why put two ads in the middle of the solo, killed the vibe
I did not so that. Its UA-cam
This is a few clips from different concerts. Don't advertise extended version . More like a compilation.
Please read the description. "All I know is that this clip is a mix between Roger Waters (the wall in Berlin 1990), and Pink Floyd. And the end solo is about 7 minutes long."
i find this solo better than pulse's
Why a commercial in the middle?
You do not put an ad whenever the solo is playing !! :/
Thats not me. Its UA-cam
This song has always defined my life. My BFF feels the same way.
magic starts at 5:13
Dude, its Pink Floyd, the magic starts at 0:00
@@Sliderxs true dat man
Waters later success is Gilmore!
Should have made the two parts at same speed
no adds, please..............................................................................................................
propaganda bem no meio do salo monstro
His performance on April 9 2016 is up there as one of his best imo
ua-cam.com/video/eZ7oODRoJxA/v-deo.html