Who are Europe's Immigrants?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 бер 2024
- Into Europe: Who is actually coming to Europe?
Support Into Europe on Patreon: / intoeurope
© All Rights Reserved.
Contact information:
Email: Into.Europe@outlook.com
Twitter: / europeinto
Patreon: / intoeurope
It took me 5 months of effort and paperwork to onboard a high skilled Indian Software Engineer to my company here in Germany while at the same time thousands of illegal migrants were welcomed into the country. You can’t explain that to anyone….
how were they welcomed if they are illegal? they don't benefit of any welfare
I mean alot of indian illegally migrate through boats recently one was caught
@@bruhsusaltamash8141that is only done by pakistanis.
@@bruhsusaltamash8141 Not that much , I mean there are Indians who do that illegally. But As A Half Indian , I can say they do it by the rule most of the time and when they get to the country , they will work there pay there whole taxes and whatever need to be done . Bcz My Indian Dad taught me always think good for the people and country you're residing bcz it like a mother to you . [half german half indian]
Those are usually people from Pakistan and Bangladesh, who pretend to be Indians when they get caught. It's easy for them to fake it since the language and appearance is very similar and they throw away their passports. Indians almost always immigrate legally, and for the defined purpose of working and studying. They absolutely do not claim asylum first thing after reaching Europe, nor do they qualify for Asylum since our country isn't in war.@@bruhsusaltamash8141
Finland did a study on Sexual offences by nationality per 10,000. Afghanistan was 138/10K and Native Finnish was 3.33/10k. That's a 4000% increase between the 2 groups.
the million dolar question is: is this corelation or causation
The statistic is alarming but it's important to ask some more questions: How was this study carried out? What was determined to be a SO? How does this compare to other migrant groups? How does it compare to globally? How long were these immigrants in the country? Does it increase/decrease/stay the same with years in the country? How does it compare to people of this group in other countries? Theres many important questions to ask before jumping the gun and demonising a group.
@@XiloFono-ie9sh It's from wikipedia, check yourself 'Sexual violence in Finland'.
@@mohhie Presumably a complex multitude of reasons and not solely based on nationality but similar stats have been seen in other European countries.
Sounds about right, just look at Sweden and their Immigration problems from the Middle East. As a Pole that's one of the reason why we are scared to take them to our country.
The opposite of legal migration is not.... irregular but illegal.
Wrong. Opposite of irregular migration is, regular.
@@cemdursun Wrong. He mentioned legal migration which means that there is also illegal migration too.
it is the same ting@@Seventh7Art
It's the same thing lil bro
Am really sorry I wasn't born white
We don't fix low fertility by migration, it doesn't address the issue. It exploilt low income countries.
Exactly this!!!
Yes
its impossible to reverse the low fertility south korea spent more than 300 billion dollars on different programs to encourage people having kids it didnt work not their birth rates are the lowest in the world, now they are begging African countries to send their doctors and nurses to take care of their old people
i dont know man i'd rather work min wage in the EU amongst normal people in a civilized society than here. Its not explotation if its objectively better for recipient
@@TheFalseShepphardit is exploiting the other country, and those that stay in the other countries. The west is mining the talented from these countries and attracted them and making it harder for these other countries to build and grow their own countries. Sure the person that left may be better off but their departure makes others worse off.
In Barcelona 90% of people who spend the night at the police station are not Spanish
Source please?
i mean most Spanish people aren't even Spanish lol
Ya probably people on vacation partying 🤣
Is this because they are Catalans ? 🤣🤣
Tourists!!
I mean absolute numbers are cool and all but relative to population size would've probably been pretty good to know
5% for france
@@oussamaalaoui9121 and sweden 21% or so its insane and now gangs are terrorising the country and have killed more than 70 people or so last year alone not to mention the hundreds of damage to infrastructure homes etc
@@awellculturedmanofanime1246without immigrants economy will collapse and fall to recession since birthrates are low
@@SardorOrifkhanov Those immigrants are not contributing to their society, I want to live in Denmark, Netherlands, Switzerland, ya know, but those immigrants are causing trouble, not only for them, but for every immigrant that wishes to have a better life and more opportunities, they are damaging to the economy, instead of benefiting, and their economy won't collapse lmao
@@SardorOrifkhanov No it would not, the economy would be weaker but still much stronger that all 3th world countries, the point is, do you value come economy and growth or safety and unity?
Asylum is for people that flee persecution not if you flee poverty.
They just SAY they’re being persecuted
Ugh oh, controversial topic. I'm sure everyone in the comments will be nice and polite.
Same.
You must be new on UA-cam.
@@buddy1155I doubt he's new, he's just raising awareness of how crap people can be about certain topics.
The channel is a centrist liberal and he fails to address hate/extremism that is in this subject
@@wile123456 Wow, your hate must be so deep that you can't even recognise an objective video.
He didn't fail to address anything, the topic is WHERE did they come from, what you wanted to hear wasn't the topic and has nothing to do with the topic.
A nation is not just an economy.
Yes it is. Don't spread disinformation
💯 agree. A nation is a group of people that have something in common, be it culture, tradition, religion not economy.
Good thing he doesn't analyse economics in this video but simply demographics lol
Anything other than economy is an ideological delusion.
People coming from countries without long national tradition based on religio-ethnic values dont just dont understand that.
Ive given up on trying to explain why the concept of a nation is so important to so many of us eurpeans.
So, to summarize, Eastern Europeans go to work in Central Europe, and Africans/Arabs go to Western Europe for social benefits. But for some reason, this statement is considered almost fascist.
Vey! You have to shut it down your reacto-fascist-conservative thoughts! Your country is just a economy! Open the legs and let the Africans enter!
people on family reunification permits dont get goverment benefits and most migrant work permits dont permit collecting social benefits its usually asylum seekers that might get a social benefit and that is not someothing a person can live on which is good to encourage work, lol bulgarians were sucking Germany dry with all their welfare fraud they committed it was so bad germany had to change its benefits rules for eu citizens
Because in "central" europe, there is no social benefits. If you dont work, you aint going to have even enough for food. 😂
For eg. Germany pays 700-900€ to refugee. Poland gives 170€ 😂 170€ is enough for 4 weeks of cheapest food products and nothing more.
@@kerstas10 and that's right way. Migrants have to prove that they are useful for host countries, otherwise there is no point in letting them stay in Europe
Wrong, it said that they go through family unification, didn't say if they work or live on social benefits
So India in thumbnail was clickbait!
Yes😅 maybe
Indians mainly go to the uk or maybe Germany Other European countries aren't that much popular among Indians.
@@sexyboy-er1gc bruh Indians are freaking everywhere 🗿💀
@@sexyboy-er1gc Thats true.
There's a meme: An Indian nationalist and a turkic nationalist were arguing each other.. from their respective apartments in London and Berlin.
The Joke being the most nationalistic Indians are in London and the most nationalistic turks are in Germany
@@WilliamLi-nd4lz😂😂😂😂😂😂 haa haa that's funny
From France I'm waiting for the part 2 ! In France it's quite sad because nobody truly talk about immigration with all the aspects and facts that you described in your video and it's used by many political parties (right and left and center) to divide the society especially with social media or with the 24/7 news channels.
The same applies to Germany, this topic is far too polarizing, so I really welcome videos like this one
True
@@gianlucapistoia8993 And The Netherlands, And Portugal and every country in existence.
Hey France, I'm from Belgium and I cab clearly see a link of AFRICAN immigrants and crime rates. I never see any other immigrant from other continents committing crime
@@cedricdellafaille1361 watch closer
Turks in Bulgaria & Romania are not immigrants. They are minorities. They have been living there since the Ottomans
Turks were kicked out of Europe after the Balkan wars. They don't belong here. They never will.
They are colonizers
You think on Pomaks/Bosniaks, Turks was always have been in in Balkan only with military personal, not with Turkish population, Turks in Balkan today are only Croat, Serbian, Macedonian and Bulgarina convert in islam....they call himself today Bosniaks, Sandzak muslims, Gorani, Pomaks or just muslims, not more Slavs, in rare case they call himself Turks...
@@Joshua-dt5vi not true. They were part of the Ottoman Vilayet System.
@@x-man4966 It has nothing to do with what you said. The Ottoman Empire settled many Turkish tribes in the Balkans with its iskan policy. e.g. my grandfather also came from Bulgaria and was Turkmen. Read some history
if possible please make more videos about this topic. its realy improtend to educate people on it.
On the internet you can only educate the people who didn't needed to be educated in the first place.
The people who did needed this education missed the lessons and are trying to politicise the discussion.
True
educate yourself about typing skill first.
important
yeah illegal migration of europeans to americas, africa, australia didnt exist before lol
in Croatia we had around 400.000 people leave to the rest of EU, and then we got around 300.000 immigrant workes from Nepal, Philippines and other Asian nations.
So, would be interesting to see these numbers compared to country population.
In Croatia we have around 4 milion people
nema ih toliko
There's less than 200,000 and half are Serbs and Bosniaks
@@IvoJosipovic-sg5nq Ima ih još više! Ilegalnih i onih u tranzitu. U govnima smo do grla, a biti će još i gore, u slijedećim godinama, koje slijede.
@@HarisP000 This is not a truth! And, Serbs and Bosnia people are same blood and race, like us, in Croatia. These people, from mostly Asia, are people different race, culture, religion and mentality too. In a process is a replacement of native people with foreign these people. And, next step would be race mixing, like in France, UK, Belgium, the Netherlands, Sweden, ect. Simple as that!
Hey man what software you are using for your animations?
Oh a topic about migration in Europe? good, EVERYBODY DOWN!!!
what is with this trend among the people who make statistics charts to use barely different shades.
just use primary colors.
why use mint, azure and sky blue.
why the absolute .... just use red and green and blue. trendy ahles.
lmao as if europeans werent the first illegal migrants to almost evry continent and literally wiping out native populations in america with their diseases
@@tedcrilly46 Thanks you! This has been driving me cracy for a while now!
Hey,
I am Ukrainian. Work in IT.
I want to relocate after the war. Only by a work permit (I hope I'll be able to find a company in the EU that would want me to join). Not going to use any refugee or asylum statuses!
Where do you think the local community would be most welcoming? Or less hostile at least...
I've heard a lot of stories about people being irritated and tired from all the refugees from my country (after 2 years), and I can see why. So I don't want to add to the problem :(
BTW,
Thanks to all the good people in the EU who helped us out in this hard time. We are in debt.
Try New Zealand, Australia and the USA.
Italy was quite welcoming to ukrainians as far as I saw
@@ElectrostatiCrow Thanks for the advice, Considered these, but my parents will stay in Ukraine, and I'd prefer to be closer to them.
I'd say as long as you go to a bigger city you'll always be able to find a job and community. It's more about what you want for yourself I think
@@wuhamster7882 I see. It's good to be closer to family.
Goodluck.
This is a very interesting topic. Please make more videos about Norway and Nordic countries. Thank you!
This is just such an amazing channel. I wish everything I watched was this concise clear and relevant.
Under the Dublin III agreement, every migrant has to register in the first EU country they arrive at. This however, is rarely the case. A small minority of migrants from the MENAPT region want to stay in Greece or Italy, where they arrive. Most of them want to travel further to middle or north European countries like Germany, France or Sweden.
Asylum seeker*
@@JossyFoopWhether you seek asylum, or have come just for a job, moving from one country to another makes you a migrant. They are migrants by description.
@@JossyFoop usually? no. but i wouldn't blame them lol, greece and italy are shitty countries
@@JossyFoop*Economic Migrant. Let's not tell lies
@@duck4834 European citizens crossing boarders aren’t subject to the Dublin agreement. Same applies to my rich Indian neighbours.
Soooo, I am a Turkish immigrant to Switzerland, I'm a neurosurgeon and have been a Swiss citizen for the last 3 years. (It took over 10 years in the country to get that), and I don't think I do anything bad to Switzerland, as Switzerland doesn't have many domestic neurosurgeons, they are mostly foreign people like me. I don't think immigration is bad if the people enter the country to work in a needed job, and who are you to judge other countries for taking in people to do jobs that they need to be done but their citizens just don't. Lots of love to all Swiss and Turkic people...
How do you feel about immigrants to turkey then? syrian refugees, arab skilled workers, and thelike?
@@Usamamohamud Immigrant, refugee and asylum seeker are completely different things
@@Roland_Deschain youre right but often they are lumped up into the same category especially from my experience here in Turkey. Im a Canadian thats been living here for half a decade and I’ve seen it personally
@@UsamamohamudI don't know what OP thinks but Turkey has no international obligation to accept refugees from south and east borders according to '61 UN agreement. Turkey is always pressured to change this. EU bribed long man to sign readmission agreement thus we have double the amount of refugees of whole europe combined. They are used mostly as low wage workers for tax evasion at best. They have become extremely taxing on the economy with free health care and medicine benefits.. not to mention they mostly have no intention to learn turkish and integrate. EU already took in qualified refugees like docs and engineers while the rest you know whom are here.
I wish you face racism in Switzerland as much racism your people give to foreigners in Turkey ! : )
In the end, the baseline is :
Do you consider your country to be just an administrative institution ?
If yes, then of course you wouldn't see any problem with migration, as it is just an administrative thing.
If no, if your country is also your nation, a group of people bound by common culture and core values, then you should at least be against mass migration.
This is an incredibly loaded statement to call a baseline. the "baseline" is much more nuanced and less obvious than what you've said.
Ipeople today see children as burden and have none
then when they are disappearing they blame migrants for “replacement”
Nah, mrsupremegascon is right!
No, they painted a false dichotomy in which the second option is emotionally charged with an appeal to tradition.
Furthermore, its almost as if they didn't watch the video that they commented on, which described how many countries are facing demographic collapse and that immigration may be necessary to prevent the economic collapse that will ensue.
What's clear is that when there is zero immigration and a below 2.1 fertility rate, economic decline is inevitable. Therefore countries must push for natalist policies to increase the fertility rate alongside attracting immigrants, all without angering racists and nationalists who oppose immigration for "culture" reasons and extreme feminist who think women are being treated like baby machines.
It's going to be extremely hard for countries to push past these two groups and to solve the underlying issues causing low fertility, but I pray that they succeed or else we are truly fucked. @@HedgehogZone
Can you explain why you should be “at least” against???
I feel that the whole immigration situation in Europe hasn't gotten a lot of attention because it is so fragmented. Thank you for informing me about these trends and hope you do so in the future! Very informative as a fellow EU citizen.
I agree that it's polarised, but it gets too much attention non stop in the media. Every single problem in society is blamed on immigration by far right politicians and activists. It's quite exhausting to talk about, since no one listens to the scientists or experts who actually understand it
@wile123456 and often the other side of the coin is to deny or downplay legitimate issues or potential negatives of immigration. When people are essentially telling you not to believe your own eyes, it's easier to take advantage of these issues.
what do you mean everyone constantly tralks about the positives and you arent even allowed to MENTION the negatives. it IS the actual problem to many symptoms that people complain about, the elephant in the room@@wile123456
@@chickenfishhybrid44The fact is, every expert agrees that the benefits of immigration outweigh the negatives. If we are to maintain our standard of living in the face of a falling birth rate, we need to let people in to replenish the workforce until automation can take over most jobs.
@@mildlydispleased3221 Ah the experts....who funds them....?
funny how those who come here to work cause statistically the least amount of trouble
Because they have a purpose. People which don't start doing stupid things. A large chunk of those are refugees which aren't allowed to work at the moment (reason being to protect European workers from the illegal practice of wage dumping). What many forget is that the EU has a easy law which would allow them to categorize some refugee groups under a special status which would allow them to work. The law was passed around 2015 in the context of larger than usual Syrian/Iraqi asylum seeking (thanks to the war on terror) but was never used up to 2022 for Ukrainians (not Syrians and Iraqi though)
What a coincidence!
Unless you look into it and find out most of these people are completely unemployable. They were barely employable in their former countries and that's despite a much lower standards of what work is. @@user6343
Honestly, I do not think that's surprising at all. I'm Turkish and most of the folks who leave the country nowadays are well educated reasonable people who happen to be upset at how things are run. That stereotype probably originates from past unskilled workers, people who happened to leave their countries in the 60s when nationalism was still a very strong concept mostly were those who couldn't fetch opportunity for obvious reasons. Germans got their fair share of our nitwits in the past 😀
Thats true. Here in England, the two ethnicitie with the lowest crime rates are chinese and Indian respectively. They also happen to be the highest earning ethnicity.
As opposed to... Africans
Great video
Always wanted to know this
Subbed
Thanks for sharing! Looking forward to part 2
We have a lot of interesting data about migration from a lot of EU countries. I mostly know about the data from Germany, the Netherlands and Denmark. The result is clear across all 3 countries of which I have read the statistics:
North African migrants are the most criminal migrants by far, followed by Sub-Saharan Africans and people from the Middle East. Sub-Saharan Africans, especially Somalis, are the least economically productive, most welfare-dependent migrants of all.
Now about the positives, which we sadly don't get many migrants from: East Asians (Chinese, Japanese, Korean) are less criminal than the average citizen of the country they migrate to, they are more economically productive and often even a net contributer to public finances. Other highly productive and law-abiding migrants are EU-migrants that move from one EU country to another and immigrants from North America, Australia and New Zealand. Upper class, most often White, South Africans also do incredibly well in EU countries.
People from South America are not so clear, some are good, some are bad. The more close to Europeans they are culturally and ethnically, the better they integrate in Europe. Which should be very obvious.
Also, don't trust what someone says on the internet, just look it up yourself. Many countries publish this data very openly and with a bit of research you will be able to find it. Make sure to look at the official government data, not at some 3rd party media which are often biased towards the left or towards the right.
Good comment, thank you.
Integration…for someone who lives in/near EU its ofc easier to integrate. But it‘s also very interesting what the integration campaigns of different countries look like. I am from a small city of north Germany. Basically what they did to a lot of immigrants is, that they put them all into one area of the city, instead of giving them opportunities of accomendation to integrate. By asking especially far right politicians about how their integration campaign looks-you get no useful answer. Thought this is also an interesting factor!
In the 1960/70s*
@@meryemgundogmus2625 Surely bad integration policies and lack of German language courses have contributed to the bad integration of many migrants in Germany. But one has to ask: If that is the issue, why do the East Asians not have it? Why are East Asians doing incredibly well, even tho they live in the same system as African migrants and both groups do not have proper access to integration courses or language learning courses.
My assumption is: You can make it in Europe if you try hard, and many people do that, even Africans or people from the Middle East. But while most East Asians work incredibly hard to integrate and therefore succeed in Europe, most people from Africa and the Middle East don't seem to do that.
@@meryemgundogmus2625Why don't we give them an appartment near the Alster in Hamburg right ? That would definitely help them to integrate better. I also want one, cna I get one, for integration.
Wait so family reunification works that one man - father or son goes to France or Germany and then after some time he brings whole family in? And then all those people basically live on social benefits? What did we became here... we should really start taking care of "our own" people...
Family reunification should be sending the immigrant back home to their families.
Darn interesting!! Thanks so much for all of that 🙏
Great video, I thoroughly enjoyed it.
Migration in Belgium is a disaster; tons of Moroccans taking their family to Belgium, so on the one hand Belgians have to pay for their social benefits, whilst ruining neigborhoods, the education system and costing the country tons of money. It's truly sad.
you should've had more kids.
@@XiloFono-ie9shpeople don’t need to be like me, just not being unpleasant when coming in contact with, driving 100km/u in city streets with a stolen Mercedes and spitting liters of saliva everywhere you go would be of some start really…
@@XiloFono-ie9shwhich is true, I just find more Moroccans a lot more unpleasant to live with, compared to other nationalities, apart from Roma. It’s not about being a good or bad person, just some basic decency would be nice…
@@Parakeet-pk6dlBetter have more babies! It will reduce immigrants.
Bro the immigrants pay taxes aswell what r u yapping abt
The data can sometimes be misleading. When you look at Germany for example the refugees from Ukraine are of course listed as refugees and included into the 48% of the statistics. But at the same time they are allowed to work (have simultaneously a work permit) and all the other refugees get a work permit after between three to nine months. So technically Poland just puts them into an other categorie than Germany does but their reason for migration is the same.
Nope you are wrong. I as ukranian need to get the German working Visa. I dont have schngen yes, but I still need to have all that working permit cancer. If only your word were right and I can get german wroking visa the way you have explained.
@@jolyroger9224
Not Correct !!!
what you talking about is Correct ! in normal situations before 2022, but after that ALL Ukrainian they came to Germany they given immediately permit including "working permission" , and they immediately have right to register in Work agency and have unemployment benefits, and support to find a work !
:
and I know I'm talking about
In Poland we also have a programm which lets people with Polish ansectry come to the country on other terms and since we have quite complecated history with the shape of our east borders, many Bielarusians and Ukrainians fall into the category od people who can apply for it. I wonder how this affects the statistics...
I do research in the field. Great job, Hugo. This was quite good 👌🏽
Europe governments must listen to their ethnically European citizens on this topic fast. We are heading for real trouble if not. We have enough people and large populations in small countries.
If i am a girl with a European native language and European outlook on life, can i move to Europe? >~
@@Alyssa-pk5od no
@@angelawhitehead6187 You are so mean, girl :)
@@Alyssa-pk5od Yes you can. If you respect our laws, culture and are not going to break the laws, you can come and integrate with no problems.
@@mariusk5360 no need. We have enough foreign people. Some Europe countries are 20 percent foreign. What's your country? Europeeans might like to settle there!!
What baffles me is why numerous migrants who enter Europe illegally, particularly young men, seem resistant to embracing integration, diversity, and LGBTQ culture. This resistance appears to be a significant factor contributing to various challenges.
Not accepting LGTV already proves they have a Higher iq
@@kkkk25yearsago79 EU value that we are all sharing (with different degree ofc) so we don't care about your opinion ! 🤡🤡
In Romania started to come a lot of immigrants from Asia (Nepal, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, Vietnam) but no problems so far because not even one of them is a illegal immigrant, Poland does the same thing, and is one of the safest countries in the world.
"embracing" is probably best replaced with "acceptance". Not even everyday people in EU countries will embrace LGBTQ culture or diversity, they accept it. Nor do I think anyone should feel like they need to embrace those, it's perfectly fine to have your own cultures and not want to deal with the cultures of others.
i am here in europe for my studies atm. you can not believe how backwards some of my friends are. i have no idea how someone studying in uni can be homophobic but it is a real issue no one talks about.
Please please make another video on this topic or a longer one. I want to know more about it, and it has been a topic i've only seen talked about without nuance here in Portugal and just with polarization all around, especially during the election time.
Interesting video. Good job!
Thanks for breaking down the stats of migration. Would love to see a deeper dive on inter EU migration and maybe Brexit's effect on it.
Great videos btw, they keep increasing in quality :)
The main driver is a higher living standard. Simple as that.
Time to get 🍿
Please delve deeper in the subject of migration
Thank you for your good work!
🤘
We are very far to become a level one civilization! One language one earth ! One people! We are just a little advanced above animals!
Computerised work and AI does not require more people. So no immigrants needed in Europe
The Family category for migration isn’t very helpful. All of those people are coming as the result of someone in another category, whether past or present. A worker and their family. A refugee and their family. A student and their family. Etc.
You dismiss the illegal category as just a fraction of the legal migrants.
But even with official statistics it was 60%+ and as you said those numbers are very likely undercounting.
In other words, illegal
migration is probably about on par with legal.
Well if a person from China is migrating as a highly skilled worker, he's obviouslty going to have to brign his spouse and kids. They pay taxes.
When merit based migrants come in. They make several times more than the national average wages, which means the wealth per capita of the country as well as the talent increases.
Saying as a half Japanese half white individual myself.
Informative video.
It took me a while to understand that the drawings of migrating flash drives were actually of people
The fact thaat you seem like a one man army performing data analysis, script, shooting and editing, this is top notch. Subscribed!
I got a Residency Permit for Spain in 2022 as a (retired law enforcement) citizen born in the USA. Lived there almost 5 months. It was for dating purposes (met a woman in Barcelona who told me what "P.I.G.S." meant 🤣). It was the worst experience putting in all the paperwork in triplicate, getting 'official' translations, scrutiny of my lifelong financial docs/funds, etc. When I got to Spain I found out I even couldn't open a bank account without EXTEME hassle and unreasonable fees even with a US credit score of 800 (for reference) so I used transfer services like Charles Schwab/TransferWise. The food was great, the views amazing, and the Catalonia people were awesome but Spain as a whole with the rules were unbearable. To me, it 'looked'like a democracy but didn't act like one, with a 'royal' family and all. The USA is frought with perils of ALL kinds, but ultimately I really can do exactly what I want here without a real heavy hand, but sometimes you have to leave your country in order to really see it. Now all these other places people love to run to, I'll just visit for a month and do it that way.
You don't have to go through all of that in the US because you are a citizen. Do you think that the migration system is easy for legal immigrants in the US? Do you know that any legal foreign migrant cannot leave the US if they are, after some years of work permits, applying to a permanent residency (green card)? I have heard horrible stories of people not being able to visit their sick relatives for years because the process can take 5 years. Comparing your citizens experience in your own country with your experience as an immigrant in a foreign one is nonsense.
@@proy1990 said: " I have heard horrible stories.."
The migration system in the US is far easier, because of our borders folks can walk over from Canada or Mexico. Once here, it's easy to exist in the underbelly, work and make far more than even in European countries because our laws permit it. Even when caught, there isn't a deportation if you then claim asylum or religious persecution from Islam.
You 'heard stories' but anecdotes that aren't even yours aren't the norm. Everyone "knows a guy" or "heard a story".
My inlaws are from the Philippines. We sponsored them here and they stayed for 4.5 years. They could have went back any time to visit but chose to stay here and work. They just couldn't stay out of the country for a set amount of time; not that they 'couldn't leave' 🤣 They only went back because they stupidly wanted to get their PI government pension (which was peanuts) instead of staying the last 6 months to make them permanent residents.
The USA is WIDE open. You have no clue.
@@ADadSupreme my knowledge from around 3 friends is as anecdotal as your single experience in Spain. A friend of mine, from Italy actually, missed so many important family things because if she left the US, her green card process of already 2 years would have stopped. Of course, she was not obliged to stay, but the bureaucratic process is so slow and flawed for these legal processes that put people in awful situations. Another friend went there with his wife (she got sponsored by employer) with a family visa. Even though he was already there, he couldn't work for many months because the work visa is a separate and long process.
FYI: in Spain it is the same, if you get there from Africa you can get to work staying illegal, but here I'm talking about legal immigration and the issues you (or any national of any country) have no idea because you are a citizen.. "I really can do exactly what I want without a really heave hand" yes, because you are a national... If you were Spanish you would be able to open as many accounts as you want..
@@user-ow7do9ju2q Defintely will keep traveling. The world is wonderful.. I've been to Iquitos Peru and that place was a trip... literally and figuratively (ayahuasca). Many places in the Navy but Spain was the first country I "lived" in longer than 4 months.
I think Poland is next for me, then Germany.
I'm confused, Spain isn't a good democracy because of the Royal Family? And of course it was easy in the US for you, you are a citizen over there. Honestly, I'm speechless....
very interesting, thanks :)
Great video!
So Europe had no significant immigration from the U.S. & Canada block?
More like emigration to US and Canada.
Would be interested to also see emigtation and immigration statistics to US/Canada
Shocking, right?
its sort of the other way around, eastern europeans love the US's fat stacks that they give away
alot of american don't even travel out side of the us, so not that crazy
Immigration becomes a problem when it is too big. There are simply too many immigrants per native population. For this reason you see the rise of anti-immigrant parties. No one denies that some immigration is good - and it is. It is when it is too large that the immigrant groups have a significant number that this becomes a problem.
Solving the birth rate is a separate issue, and should not be conflated with immigration, nor should immigration be thought of as a solution to low birth rates.
Just out of interest what would be a better alternative to increase birth rates? I would say making things like kindergarten and schools better/more affordable could help many families but especially single parents.
@@user6343 Unfortunately there is no alternative to increasing birth rates - either you increase birth rates or you don't - that's a reality we have to accept. Replacing the native population with foreigners doesn't solve the low birth rate issue - it still persists. You are correct that Kindergarten and schools could be more affordable, but generally families are under a lot of pressure both in time and money. One parent used to be enough to support the whole family (whether it's the mother or the father who work) the kids are looked after by a stay at home parent. It's not possible now - costs are too high. I think making energy cheaper will have a knock on effect, as will housing - at the moment houses are simply too expensive. If you take immigrants out of the equation, houses will still be too high - this is because not enough are built, but more so that Hedge Funds, Investors and Corporations are purchasing residential real estate. Since these parties have access to more funds they easily outbid families for homes or force them to raise their initial offers. That's for families, but it is worth noting that the marriage rate has also declined to all time lows - due to Divorce laws and this is an unintended consequence of the #MeToo movement.
General attitudes have changed, Women tend to wait longer to get married but Men generally don't want older women and after 30 it gets increasingly difficult to give birth - women are under more pressure on that front.
There's a lot more - but too much to fit in a UA-cam comment. Great question though.
Helpful thank you!
Good job! Well presented 🎉
I am an agnostic gay freelance art director with a great passion and a good publicity on social media, I applied to Germany for a vacation with my boyfriend just to get rejected, yet those who do it illegally say it’s so easy! I really wonder why would Germany stop me from going for tourism yet they accept those who want to come and stay and maybe spread their own culture instead of integrating! It’s too sad and it’s so unfair!
We've had enough of your kind
I am sorry. Try Italy? I know Meloni is a racist and a fascist, but I hope we can get rid of her soon.
@@HarisP000what kind? Are you against Italian immigrants too? Because we are everywhere in the world.
Europe for Europeans
Colonizers are mad quess what we don't care we gonna sent more 😂😂
Africa was for African
In your IMAGINATION 😉
@@kareem43592 And you will all be sent back.
Love this video would like to see more!
thnk u for ur efforts
hey guys remember when we held those referendums where all the real German, French, English and Italian people voted and agreed to have our countries permanently and radically transformed by endless waves of alien migration?
Well. One could argue our forefathers voted for colonisation, which is basically us going to these alien countries and tell them they should speak, behave and think like Europeans.
@@alioshax7797doesn't matter. Two wrongs DO NOT make a right.
The Mongols also invaded eastern Europe. The Europeans are not the only ones who colonised
@@alioshax7797 Yes. People no longer alive to day made decisions and I doubt any of those decisions were democratic. Generational sin doesnt exist buddy. Its amazing 21th century western individual doesnt understand this.
@@alioshax7797Wtf are you talking about? Modern democracy started in the 19th century, centuries before the first colonies were established. Besides, even if you want to be racist and project sins on people that didn’t even exist during colonialism, you should be mad at the people in USA, South America etc. They are the colonisers, not us who decided to stay in Europe
@@crocs4304 The XIXth century was "centuries before the first colonies were established" ? You sure about you ? Most colonial conquests took place in the XIXth century. India, Algeria, subsaharan Africa, Malaysia, Korea (for Japan), Egypt, and so on.
Spanish and Portugese colonial empires started in the XVth and XVIth centuries. France, Britain and the Netherlands followed closely.
When Africa was divided up between European powers in 1885 at the Congress of Berlin, France, Great Britain, Belgium, Portugal and Spain were all either republics or constitutional monarchies with strong parlamentary power. And these colonies came to an end, for most of them, in the 1960s or even 1970s for Portugal and Spain.
Colonial empires were started by european monarchs, but they were expanded and achieved by european democracies.
I'm saying this as a Frenchman with no foreign origins I know of, by the way.
French people when migration is mentioned: 😡
And for a good reason.
same in UK
@@KillingTheEgo No.
@@mildlydispleased3221 What No?
@@KillingTheEgo French people when colonialism (or neo-colonialism) is mentioned: 🤥
Why did you add the name "indian" to the thumbnail when you are not talking anything about india? Clickbait? There is only one mention of india in the entire video.
because indians are a large group of migrants to the eu, as said here 7:08
big topic to discuss, would love to see more of it
I knew the situation was complex, but damn... I vote for more videos about this!
This is so politically correct video without diving deep into real problems of migration.
So in Germany, only 8% come to work, 85% are basicly people who come as "refugee" (mainly people who just want wellfare) and their family. This is so depressing.
Bro they do work no matter how they entered
The rule of money will always flow to the newer investments and innovations. So its no wonder that money will move to poland etc.
@@z27mohammeddealing drugs is not a job.
@@larrydogson5448 Yes, and I said they get a job, didn't say they deal drugs. Even though a large portion of illegals do bc of inequality
@@z27mohammedIn Germany half of the people collecting wellfare are non germans. Not counting the "Germans", that have a migrant background (we are giving away citezenships like candy)
Nice graphs. ❤
Can you please do a video about migration - crime commited based on their origins? I am actually very interested! Great video!
These numbers seem very off from what our gov has been telling us (the Netherlands).
I guess different governmental representatives (not the bureacratic machines like Eurostat in the background) are heavily influenced by their ideology and thus frame numbers to be preferable for them.
Based on the thumbnail, I was hoping you’d tell us what percentage of the EU immigrants come from which countries.
Turkey and Ukraine make significant minorities but idk of Indians, most south Asians (Bangladeshi, Pakistani and srilankans) are coined under the term 'Indian'.
@@Nagvanshieus May be srilankan but not pakistani and bangladeshi
@@Nagvanshieuswe Indians don't enter eu like Bangladeshi,srilankans and Pakistani (except Punjabis) , we only go for works
@@Nagvanshieus WTF! Why would Bangladeshi, Pakistani and Sri lankans are coined under "Indian". We are a seperate group they are seperate.
@@WhitesaucePasta772 Same thing. Changing religion will not change your origin. Not talking abt srilanka
Would be interesting to see the employment data correlated to this. Like what sectors people are working, what % of family reunification person are working as well.
I would love to know more about the numbers and differences between countries. Please do more…
I’ve been watching for 5 minutes and was wondering why my country (the uk) wasn’t being included in the map. I’m too high bruh.
You kept immigration statistics from Greece, Cyprus and Malta out for a reason? A focus on Portugal, Spain and Italy would be more useful than on Ukraine and Russia.
exactly!!! Ukraine and Russia are not Europe to begin with!
because most migrants dont tend to stay there long term, he already mentioned in the video that places like greece, cyprus, malta are losing more immigrants than are coming in, he focused on places where immigrants are staying long term
@@AmericanDreamerhey bro help me for illegal immigration
@@taknoef9195bro you too help me for illegal immigration
@@AmericanDreamer Україна - це Європа!
Great video and fantastic data. I wish you explored that last part (what kind of visa each migrant nationality is most likely to have) a bit further, as in, other regions besides the ones you mentioned. Nevertheless, really well done. I wish the discussion here in Germany took this approach and added some much needed rationality.
Good vlog. Keep doing it.
Analysis of the effect on demographics would be nice. Can it reverse trends? Politics? - Sweden
Relative impact vis-a-vis population size and concentration within countries around certain urban areas would be interesting to understand.
Hey thanks for the video I was just teaching some lessons on demographics and this came in handy
this video didnt say anything
Why? Free money housing
exactly 🔥
why does europe provide free money and housing to their immigrants?
And white women 😊
@uruguaylusitano5797 not gonna end well for them
@@drpepper3838 the migrants or the white women?
As a French myself, this is how I see things : for the immigrants from north-Africa, it's an "old" immigration, their families and them have been coming to Europe for 60 or 50 years, so it's normal they are more present on the "family reunification" part of the stats. For Afghans, Syrians and Ukrainians, its a "new" immigration, that started in the last 10 years, as consequences of conflits. Between the two, you have the African immigrants, who are a bit of both, some of them having been coming to Europe for decades (mostly located on the west part of the continent), and others that are coming in more recent waves (mostly from the east of Africa).
Great topic with good insights! I would like to learn the type of jobs/work by nationality for immigrants in Europe if possible 🙏🏼🙏🏽🙏🏿
Spain 🇪🇸 has always been a tolerant and open country with people who come from other countries, since for many years we were immigrants in France 🇫🇷 , Germany 🇩🇪 or Switzerland 🇨🇭 and we contributed to the progress of these countries. Now we have a large Hispanic American community (Colombia 🇨🇴, Venezuela 🇻🇪, Cuba 🇨🇺, Ecuador 🇪🇨, Argentina 🇦🇷...) due to our historical and cultural ties; as well as from North Africa, especially Morocco 🇲🇦 due to its geographical proximity and even from Ukraine 🇺🇦. I believe that legal and controlled immigration and people who want to come to Spain to work and contribute to the progress of the country will always be welcome.
That's a similar case with a lot of western countries though. The issue is the economic issues that the global South South has and yes people there try to change situations there, but...as per usual the elites in the global South are super corrupt.
Well you know we were the same in ireland. I don't have a problem with people coming to Ireland but within reason and in a balanced and positive way. We should have tough and high standards and make sure that people who come here have jobs supplied and are checked properly(including refugees and political migrants). We should be welcoming but not foolish and not to the detriment of our country.
There are towns in Ireland where there are more foreigners than native people, many of them don't speak English and many of them aren't interested in integration with their new neighbours.
@@aaronruss6331 you should stop islamization of Ireland first
Proof? @@ciarand2823
lately, in France the most frequent newborn name was Mohammed (and related). I'm kinda shocked that gov financially support arabs who live in EU for free, with free housing, food etc. They don't bother to work, study language, assimilate.
In 2023, In France it's actually:
Jade, Louise and Emma for girls. Gabriel, Léo and Raphaël for boys.
I have searched in French, for 2022 and 2020 too. Did not find mohammed.
It's not "mauvaise foi". I actually tried to find something proving your point, in vain.
Arabs in France do work and study the language in their home country since their countries are mostly francophone, if not the learn it while living there (if by Arabs you mean North Africans)
@@z27mohammed syrians and afghans speak French.... you must be right, it's their second native language :D
@@hwfq34fajw9foiffawdiufhuaiwfhw North Africans and Arabs are different ethnicities
@@heartborne123 when did I mention Afghanistan or Syria
"Illegal migration occurs due to:
1. Greedy Western countries (Europe and America) restricting developing nations from processing their natural resources into higher-value products to generate substantial revenue and provide jobs for their growing populations. This is exemplified by the WTO case against Indonesia for attempting to create employment opportunities in the nickel industry to address its demographic boom (large youth population).
2. Western countries causing wars in other nations (NATO). Ukraine's desire to join NATO has angered Putin. The wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, all caused by America, have led to humanitarian crises in the Middle East. Europe and America do not consider Palestinians to be human beings.
Japan has scant natural resources but its population does have an average IQ 106 which is very useful for designing high end products. whereas the Congo has an abundance of natural resources but an average IQ of 79. There is no equivalence.
Viewing the world through a communist lens gives a very distorted view of reality.
Equality only exists in religious and political ideologies. The driving force behind evolution is inequality, endless variations therefore endless possibilities.
The family category really skews the data I feel cuz reunification is imp but for reunification a member of that family must already be in the EU his/her status should be considered eg if they came on work visa and gained permanent residency then classify their family members as Family category for reunification but if the original member came as a refugee then the subsequent family members should also be classified as refugees. But that’s just my way of thinking. I’m Indian and I see education and work being main drivers of Indians moving to the EU but the paperwork and cost is ofc cumbersome but what confuses me is uneducated refugees can jump to EU soil and get incredible govt benefits whereas Indians or Chinese paying high visa costs furnishing background info struggle to get any long term stay options in most EU nations. Frankly high skilled labour or foreign students can contribute to EU economies and go there with that aim along with better std of living expectations unlike refugees but still EU law favours the latter over the former I struggle to make sense of this logic .
Europe needs to develop a program, which encourages ethnic Europeans to have more children.
😂😂😂😂
Here in Italy they do have a lot of tax breaks but still no children
Its mainly because women work and have no time for having childs or if they have then only one or two. The conservative status of the women staying at home and the men working should be restored otherwise even if having children is subsidised people just not have the time for children. I personally do all I can to prevent the demographic collapse ( I have 4 children ) The ultimate goal should be the fertility rate of 2,1 because thats the replacement rate and the european union no longer needs migrants for sustaining the economy.
@dreamingof777....Will never happen lol. You can not force people to have more childeren if they don't want to and the socio-economic climate is not conducisve. Just accept that ethnic Europeans will decrease in numbers, this has been the case for years actually. Just that populist bait media want to focus on it so they can win elections. The old age in Europe increasing and the childbirth rate is decreasing. European women are also not virtle as before due worsen health and genetics.
@@akeno6451 Would you like forced imprisonment of women for the sole purpose of procreation ? Sounds like you would like that.
You are being slowly conquered.
This is a really good intro but we need to hear factual data about what comes after that
I'm Argentine with Italian passport, like me, in Argentina trere are many people with european citizenship that you did not split in your analisys....
😂😂😂. You're Latin American. No Italian.
@@DeutschlandVerreckeNah it's actually a major concern of the Italian gov. that the large amount of Argentinians with Italian roots ask for their EU citizenship (as Italian law allows that) to be able to come to Europe, vote in Europe and profit from better living conditions in Europe. Milei had a reason in saying that he wants to build a nation resiliant and economically strong like Italy, which for us europeans seems strange but compared to South America's economy is strong
@@DeutschlandVerrecke you are right, I'm latin american. I just comment that if I move to europe, I will not appear as inmigrant but I consider that is a mistake. I will be an inmigrant as any other.
I agree with you that Italian government has to change this law, many people here without any connection whit Italy (just a distant italiann relative) get the citizenship.
In my case, my mother was Italian, but I'm Argentine not Italian. I think Italy goverment has to change this situation asap!
@@josecentis4098 well at least you would blend into italian society really fast as we share culture , similar languages , religiion , morality etc etc if you really wanted to work and blend in and not as a welfare dog
I wonder how civil war would affect the economy?
Just don't start a civil war and there won't be a civil war
That's a nice question.
Bruh wow how can you think of this intresting question?
As a Namibian I've always found it interesting how black Africans are portrayed as the face of the European replacement theory when we only barely surpass north africa in numbers and are behind the middle east and south Asia.
The reason is because you are mostly watching media from the Anglosphere. In America and Britain the black population is.much larger. While in Germany it is focused on Arabs.
@@ukj5850Well in the UK it isn't that large. France has way more black Africans than the UK. Largest immigrant group here are Indian/Pakistani.
@@ukj5850no true the black population in Britain is about 3.4% of the population while Indian and Eastern European are much higher , Indian are over 12%of the England population yet when people say immigrants they immediately think that black Africans are highest immigrant which it is not even close
Theory?
great replacement theory is from a French old racist, who is living in 1911. No one wants to replace Europeans, it's just due to wars and conflicts. Migration is a natural thing and all organisms do it to survive. Don't listen to extreme right concpiracies, they are delusional.
Is it true for Bulgaria that more people are coming than leaving because our population shrinks fast and one of the factors is EU migration
Not enough data
I want more focus on the countries where the people are moving to Europe from
I predict in the distant future that their Will be countries with a birth rate below replacement and high immigration rates to Europe leading the country to become somewhat empty in a relatively small amount of time
"How do we fix our aging population?"
"How about we make it easier for our young citizens to find employment, get married and start families by lowering their tax burden and offering them low interest home loans."
*gets thrown out the window*
"Let's import massive amounts of people from outside the continent to keep salaries low and demand for housing high. Doesn't matter where they come from, they'll integrate just fine, we just need to spend more of our citizen's tax money on welfare for them so they can be comfortable."
Boomers gonna boom 😅
And if u don't want to pay taxes ur the bad guy ahahhahahah
This should be common knowledge by now
But in Germany you are branded as extreme right if you say this
Putting your countries' citizens first is simply what a nation should be built upon. But you will probably never have intelligent debates over this topics in Germany, it is all just low IQ left vs. right fighting...
Capitalism is great, am i right ? 🤑
" Who are Europe's invaders?"
Fixed
Same could be said for Europe in much of the 18-19th centuries.
Muslims have never been able to integrate in 1400 years, they never will.
This is the kind of comment I was looking for, now I know I'm in UA-cam :3.
You need more Indian immigrants
@@antelopelol2865 shalom
3:50 They take up most of the conversation because there are far less troublemakers coming from regular migration. Also combined and including the ones not being counted (for whatever reason) we are at about 3/4 Mio thats over a third which is irregular.
Dice deeper pls or from different perspectives, but keep doing the good work
2030 UK Sharia Law
If you dont act now
Yess😢😢 facts
1757-1947 English Law in india
2nd largest economy to poorest economy
Now oppressors are feeling the same what oppressed people once felt
@@user-oy5bf1vz5care you talking about your mum?
InchaAllah ❤