Tony Banks of Genesis (Part 1) - Episode 58 - The ProgCast with Gregg Bendian

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 13 кві 2022
  • / theprogcast (Part 2 available for Patrons!)
    TONY BANKS, keyboardist/composer/Genesis mastermind joins me for an in-depth
    discussion of Genesis' beginnings, his classical influences and favorite composers, lyric writing, the end of Genesis, and much, much more. This is Part One of our conversation. Part Two is available exclusively to my ProgCast Patrons, so please consider joining The ProgCast community, or sending a donation if you enjoy our content. Thanks, as always, for your support!
    / theprogcast
    Study Drums/Composition/Music with Gregg: www.bendianmusic.com
    GREGG BENDIAN is a percussionist/composer/producer/educator/podcaster from Teaneck, New Jersey. During his wide-ranging career he has toured internationally and recorded with Todd Rundgren, Jan Hammer, The Mahavishnu Project, Keneally-Bendian-Lunn, The Musical Box, John Zorn, Derek Bailey, Nels Cline, Cecil Taylor, Pat Metheny, Ornette Coleman and Zoot Horn Rollo. On the academic front, Gregg develops and teaches courses in studio production aesthetics, music history, and composing/arranging at William Paterson University of New Jersey. For the Yale Oral History of American Music, he has contributed over 100 expansive interviews with major figures including Wayne Shorter, Sonny Rollins, Quincy Jones, Carla Bley and Steve Reich. Bendian is archivist/producer for the Bottom LIne Archive of historic concerts. Recorded over 30 years at the Greenwich Village venue, the series features discs by Jack Bruce with Billy Cobham, The Brecker Bros, Lou Reed/Kris Kristofferson, Pete Seeger/Roger McGuinn, and Doc Watson. An accomplished percussionist and a composer of over 200 works, he has created a body of innovative music for jazz, rock, percussion (solo and ensemble) and mixed chamber groups, which include his Interzone and Trio Pianissimo bands. Gregg's music is published by Iamuziks (ASCAP). Begun in August of 2020, The ProgCast explores the creative process and musical history of a diverse assortment of cutting edge artists.
    You can also find us on:
    SPOTIFY:
    open.spotify.com/show/0x9bzb0...
    APPLE PODCASTS:
    podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
    www.bendianmusic.com
    open.spotify.com/artist/0HBmV...
    www.bottomlinearchive.com
    guides.library.yale.edu/oham/...
    www.mahavishnuproject.com
    www.wpunj.edu/coac/department...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 192

  • @KlausSgroi
    @KlausSgroi Рік тому +14

    Thank you for this. I regard Tony Banks as one of the greatest geniuses in popular music, and it's a pity he doesn't get the credit he deserves.

  • @stephenkeegan3554
    @stephenkeegan3554 11 місяців тому +4

    Only wish Tony would do something in 2023 with Steve. It would be amazing.

  • @dancinditedforyears6736
    @dancinditedforyears6736 2 роки тому +42

    I remember being a young teenage girl lying on my floor with headphones on just listening to Genesis music. I remember the gal who worked at our local record store would compliment my choice of music. I don't think many 12 or 13 year old girls were buying early Genesis music. I connected from early on. Love the interview

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +6

      Thank you so much. It's certainly a magical music to discover at such a magical age, isn't it? It colored my world.

    • @Yakkymania
      @Yakkymania Рік тому +1

      i’m a fairly young teenage girl who listens to Genesis, even though you’re past that stage of your life you’re not the only one

    • @dancinditedforyears6736
      @dancinditedforyears6736 7 місяців тому

      ​@@TheProgCastI'm an avid reader and was brought up in a house where our stereo cost as much, if not more than our cars. I still have my dad's records with a huge range of genre, classical, show tunes, Irish, big band, classic artists of the 40-60's also instrumental music of many kinds. I think they all formed my love of all quality music , that's the wrong word but I listened deeply and tried to hear every note and word.

    • @Lasse3
      @Lasse3 3 місяці тому

      My dad would always put on "Seconds out" he loved live music.
      And as a teenager I completely fell in love with "Afterglow" and then that evolved into my love for Genesis❤

  • @diegomorales8616
    @diegomorales8616 2 роки тому +32

    I think I've heard, seen, and read every Tony Banks interview, and this is easily the best.

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +4

      So kind of you to say. We really try to go deeper here on The ProgCast. So glad you noticed...

  • @stephenherrick9971
    @stephenherrick9971 2 роки тому +27

    Brutally honest,humble and informative...quite the GENESIS gentleman...one serious nice guy as well.Thx TB and Gregg!

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +2

      Stephen Herrick Thanks so much for watching!

  • @champ1061
    @champ1061 2 роки тому +17

    Love how Mr Banks draws the connection between "Watcher" and "Let's Go Away for A While."

  • @nyifnbr18
    @nyifnbr18 2 роки тому +20

    Thanks for not asking the same old same old questions, very enjoyable listen.

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +3

      My pleasure. Wanted to get a bit deeper with the Maestro.

  • @jeffbrett7849
    @jeffbrett7849 2 місяці тому +1

    this interview is very important....and it will be years from now! congrats!!
    Tony is a pharaoh

  • @moyako_woahhhh
    @moyako_woahhhh Рік тому +19

    I'm Japanese. I'm sorry for poor English.
    I love Genesis and I love his music!
    I'm not good at English so I could understand only a little😢 (I have to study more😅)
    but I was happy that I could listen to his voice and great talk! It's nice❤
    I want to understand more so I will listen to this nice video again.
    Thank you for great interview!!

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  Рік тому +3

      So happy to hear from prog fans in Japan! I love Japanese music, esp Boredoms, Takemitsu, and Kaiji Haino - just to start!

    • @FlyingPhilUK
      @FlyingPhilUK Рік тому +3

      Good to hear Genesis is still popular in Japan
      - have you ever seen Steve Hackett it Japan?
      - he's still a great way to hear the old Genesis!

    • @Aspartamebraintumor
      @Aspartamebraintumor 11 місяців тому

      Shingetsu - Oni is a great prog track from Japan

    • @robertsimpson9403
      @robertsimpson9403 4 місяці тому

      Japan vinyl is the best

  • @arag1030
    @arag1030 2 роки тому +12

    Best Rock/Prog Rock keyboardist of all time!

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому

      Cannot argue with that Ara! Shnorhakalut’yun!

  • @TheChadTI
    @TheChadTI 2 роки тому +11

    Greatest keyboard player ever.

  • @quaid667
    @quaid667 2 роки тому +18

    I'd love to tell Tony what a massive influence he has been on me as a songwriter. If i could be half as good as him, i'd be a very happy dude.

  • @TractorCountdown
    @TractorCountdown 2 роки тому +5

    I think you've hit a benchmark with this interview, Gregg. Musicians interviewing other musicians is often better anyway, but with your knowledge of the band's repertoire - playing it as well - that made it special, so thank you.

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +1

      You are very kind and I appreciate your support more than can know! Please consider our Patreon set up for more TB. www.patreon.com/theprogcast

  • @dereckvon
    @dereckvon 2 роки тому +13

    Tony and those magical chords. Great musician.

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +6

      The chords of TB are special indeed.

  • @1adneumann
    @1adneumann 2 роки тому +29

    Tony Banks got more nuance and flavor out of an ARP Pro Soloist than most keyboardist got out of a "bank" of synthesizers....

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +4

      Could not agree more!

    • @scifiwriter98
      @scifiwriter98 Рік тому +1

      Very true. One listen to Riding the Skree or the Cinema Show solo is proof of that. It's amazing what he produced with his mix of analog gear and early synth keyboards in the mid 70s.

    • @1adneumann
      @1adneumann Рік тому +1

      @@TheProgCast ..and my short kybd diatribe: "Less is more". Banks, Keith and Rick (the big three) all excelled using the old, sometime unreliable gear, hence the romance of it all...the moment they all started adding on digital gear, it started sounding, well...digital? Emerson shoulda stuck with the "BSS" gear, that GX_1 was really a game changer, but not in a good way... And Wakemans entourage of digi keyboards was just silly; the melloton, piano, organ, minimoog were just fine...Banks too; a talent like that should have shuck with setup he had....And, who would abandon a Hammond? They could all offord them....John Medeski is a perfct example... play the old gear!....(Don't get me started on Geoff Downes, the most talentless, unimaginative kybrdist out there; his new organ sounds make Spinal Tap sound like Larry Young)....i'll leave there, as I return to my Buchla system.. PS, I dig you Tube channel.....

    • @Aspartamebraintumor
      @Aspartamebraintumor 11 місяців тому +1

      @@1adneumann i'd throw kerry minnear in there and call it the big four

  • @MahavishnuProject
    @MahavishnuProject 2 роки тому +6

    "You have ten fingers, you know?" TB on the rich chord voicings he brought to rock music! Harmonic Master.

  • @bretedwards2899
    @bretedwards2899 2 роки тому +15

    Tony is one of the rare great lead keyboard players, as most of the time the guitarist does leads and there are many famous guitarists. Banks use of triads and arpeggios, along with occasionally using a two handed technique was very creative in the rock genre. If I had a question, it would be to inquire about his use of horror fantasy in songs like Musical box, Giant Hogweed (Gabriel lyrics?), Home by the sea, etc. Horror fantasy is popular in movies, but it is rare in rock music.

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +2

      Had to ask him about sci-fi - was always wondering. Thanks for watching!

    • @saffi01
      @saffi01 2 роки тому

      @@TheProgCast Wished you had asked him about Star Trek though :b Great interview!

  • @christopherstevens4771
    @christopherstevens4771 Рік тому +5

    Battle of Epping Forest was a fantastic song and one of this group's best. The vocals and music went well together.

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  Рік тому +1

      It was a joy to really learn it from the outside in. It is a singular achievement in the Genesis book.

    • @mikearchibald744
      @mikearchibald744 10 місяців тому

      I know the band badmouths it, but I would actually like to hear just an instrumental version, but the lyrics are just perfect, even Pete says he should have edited, but what would he take out?

  • @anatoliyzhalnin8393
    @anatoliyzhalnin8393 2 роки тому +10

    Tony has always been my favorite contemporary composer. His influence on the keyboard players immense. Don' get me wrong. Wakeman, Emerson, Moraz and others are superb too, but my heart has always been with Genesis.

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +3

      He is a towering presence in contemporary music to be sure.

    • @afaceforradiowithrichardma4831
      @afaceforradiowithrichardma4831 2 роки тому +3

      Don’t forget Eddie Jopson.

    • @garycitro1674
      @garycitro1674 Рік тому +1

      Kerry Minnear of Gentle Giant! Not as much of a showman but an incredible rock chamber music composer and instrumentalist!

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  Рік тому

      @@garycitro1674 Kerry, of course!

  • @pasi8800
    @pasi8800 2 роки тому +10

    This is absolutely wonderful! Thank you. Tony is a musical genius and living legend.

  • @Jellybeantiger
    @Jellybeantiger 2 роки тому +3

    Tony Banks my favourite musician,gday from Oz.

  • @Papabude
    @Papabude 2 роки тому +5

    You’re a VERY lucky man, Good Job

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому

      I would have to agree. Thanks for listening!

  • @critney_
    @critney_ 2 роки тому +8

    2nd Edit:
    The second part is available - yay!! :D
    Thanks Gregg!
    -----------------------
    Tony is simply awesome!
    Edit: Second part still only viewable as a patreon. Anyway, what is it with people talking to Tony using past tense 🤮
    I support Tony ! Don't forget to buy his classical albums!

  • @noohoozfurra
    @noohoozfurra 2 роки тому +6

    That Gregg, is the perfect example of how to interview one of our true Prog heroes and ensure he wasn't asked the same questions asked for decades! Interesting how Tony spends more time discussing the songs from Genesis 4/5 players rather than Genesis 3 players. I might be wrong, but it suggests his preference for that era. Whatever, great job, sir... 👏👏👏

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +4

      Thank you so much, Colin! I really appreciate you noticing that. I have seen most of the other interviews, so I knew I had to go somewhere else with the Maestro.

    • @noohoozfurra
      @noohoozfurra 2 роки тому +1

      @@TheProgCast My pleasure, Gregg. You really did a fantastic job...

  • @stephanevilleneuve9450
    @stephanevilleneuve9450 2 роки тому +6

    Great. The most interesting interview of TB that I have listening. Just enough of Genesis, lot of interestings facts of this great composer.

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +3

      Thank you for listening, Stephane. I have admired Tony for so long, it was the interview I dreamed about but also planned for.

  • @MahavishnuProject
    @MahavishnuProject 2 роки тому +11

    TB: "I don't know why people think singers do everything." Love it.

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +4

      That was both poignant and hilarious!

  • @gazza8127
    @gazza8127 2 роки тому +6

    Thank you so much Gregg, it's always such a joy and a privilege listening to Tony being interviewed, one of the great minds of Progressive Rock, this was excellent!

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +1

      Thanks so much for watching. More to come if you join our Patreon.

  • @panicsum
    @panicsum 2 роки тому +4

    The wonderful Mr Banks! Excellent conversation, thank you. I would seriously be speechless in his company.

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +3

      He is a bit intimidating but clearly a kind person of substance. Thanks for watching.

  • @joaod.andradecosme5869
    @joaod.andradecosme5869 5 місяців тому

    Greg B, thank you very much for this interview. I'm a big fan of this genius. Nice you cite "Me and Sarah Jane". One of the best compositiond of Tony Banks.

  • @TheProgCorner
    @TheProgCorner 2 роки тому +4

    What a band!!!! Great job.

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому

      Thanks for listening Prog Corner!

  • @Sammeep02
    @Sammeep02 2 роки тому +3

    1000000% genius.
    The Gabriel/Collins era debates just pain me. I know all too well it isn't Genesis without Mr.BANKS!!!! There is still a level of inventiveness and sophistication in 80s' Genesis, mostly on part of him.

  • @robotbarbarian
    @robotbarbarian 2 роки тому +5

    Thanks for posting this, Gregg! I really enjoyed it. I particularly like your well-thought-out questions and the general points you like to make to either trigger a good response or to inform us of your personal feelings and love for Genesis. I think most of us that discovered Genesis, especially in the early days, began a true love affair with their music that has stretched to this day.

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +4

      Thanks for your kind words. Yes, once they got in at an early age it was a lifetime of love.

    • @filmneye
      @filmneye 2 роки тому

      True music-lovers become entranced & fall under early Genesis' spell because we know great music when we hear it. (That's me being unbiased)

  • @flying13machine
    @flying13machine 2 роки тому +4

    Wow!
    You’re the drummer with the Musical Box!
    I had no idea!
    I’ve loved Genesis for so long and have been listening to your interviews lately.
    Especially love the long conversation with Andy Partridge!
    Thanks for keeping it all alive!!!

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +2

      Thanks TMB was fun while it lasted. The Andy interview was great fun as was the Hackett.

  • @garycitro1674
    @garycitro1674 Рік тому +1

    So happy to hear Tony give props to Steve Hackett on his arranging contribution to firth of fifth and a number of other times. I had the feeling that those guys hated each other, what you may even be true but he was so gracious in this interview.
    Great job, sir, and I was lucky enough to say TMB a number of times and you were just masterful.

  • @Ursulauu
    @Ursulauu 2 роки тому +3

    Great to see our Keyboard Hero - the one & only Tony B in the seat, fresh from their latest tour! - Love these interviews Gregg!

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +2

      Thank you, Ursula. So happy you could join us.

  • @StratsRUs
    @StratsRUs 2 роки тому +4

    Wonderful

  • @RickCT2000
    @RickCT2000 2 роки тому +4

    Brilliant interview. You nudged Tony to go places I have not heard him speak about before. Tony revealed a little more of his full life, beyond music and intertwined with music. Nice job and very deft!

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +3

      So glad you noticed and enjoyed. More to come!

  • @ralphmarrone3130
    @ralphmarrone3130 2 роки тому +1

    Fantastic interview. I thoroughly enjoyed it. Thanks!!!

  • @timothyclaffey9138
    @timothyclaffey9138 Рік тому +2

    The Musical Box (the band) is THE Genesis re-creator. Saw them in Chicago. Absolutely flawless!!!

  • @philseida5428
    @philseida5428 2 роки тому +2

    Thank you so much Gregg. So cool you were with The Musical Box. I saw them once 8 years ago or so doing Selling England and they were great. The Beatles and Genesis( mostly 1970-1977, the TTWT and Duke are Good as well. After that not as much ) are my two favorite Groups All Time. Your interview was excellent, especially The Questions and Discovering different things about Tony I never knew and it was the most comfortable I’ve ever seen Tony in an interview and I’ve seen quite a few. Tony is easily my Favorite Keyboardist with his Beautiful Melodic Chord Changes, Atmosphere, Style, Organ playing, Mellotron, electronic keyboard playing, piano, synths, Incredible Lyrical Songwriting, Composing and underrated Musicianship just in general. He could belt them out as well with The Knife, Fountain of Salmacis, Return Of The Giant Hogweed, Watcher of The Skies, The Lamb title track, Riding The Scree, The Lady Lies, One For The Vine, All in a Mouse’s Night, etc. A Genius Without A Doubt! Thank You 🙏 Again so much for this.

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому

      Thank you Phil. I was determined to get into some areas that perhaps had not been covered in the other TB interviews. So glad the hardcore fans are enjoying this one! Don't miss the Hackett interview Episode 38 and please hit us up on Patreon if you'd like to support what we're doing!

  • @ganazby
    @ganazby 2 роки тому +5

    Splendid interview. Thanks.

  • @arrowsskateshop9324
    @arrowsskateshop9324 2 роки тому +4

    Great interview! Thank you for doing this!

  • @cosmicdrifter287
    @cosmicdrifter287 2 роки тому +5

    Great,great job on this.Good friday indeed!

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +2

      Thanks so much. We really appreciate hearing from you!

    • @cosmicdrifter287
      @cosmicdrifter287 2 роки тому

      @@TheProgCast Hi Gregg, You bet i keep an eye on your postings.

  • @NS9213
    @NS9213 2 роки тому +5

    Great interview. And how overlooked Brian Wilson is. Pet Sounds and SMiLE are Masterpieces in chord construction.

  • @geoffreylogsdon162
    @geoffreylogsdon162 Рік тому +3

    Nice job Gregg! And you are quite the musician yourself, it was nice to work with you at Progday a few centuries ago 🙂

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  Рік тому

      Thanks Geoffrey. I remember that windy day very well. Focus rocked.

  • @apian29
    @apian29 2 місяці тому

    Just found your channel. Loving this stuff!! So cool

  • @aminahmed2220
    @aminahmed2220 2 роки тому +1

    The interview is fantastic with Tony banks have a great weekend

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому

      Thanks so much Amin. I really appreciate it.

  • @zappatull
    @zappatull Рік тому +1

    How did I just discover this podcast today?!!? Amazing!

  • @peterdanish9237
    @peterdanish9237 2 роки тому +2

    Fab job Gregg! Congrats!!!

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +1

      Thanks Peter! So glad you enjoyed it.

  • @lhair02
    @lhair02 Рік тому +2

    wow! Tony banks rarely gives an interview these days! obviously you've been in touch with Banks since your days with musical box were recognised so thats really really wicked

  • @steveglossop
    @steveglossop 2 роки тому

    Such a fascinating interview that touches on other areas of Tony's interests. Many thanks Gregg.

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому

      Thanks for saying Steve. I appreciate it.

  • @poodius7
    @poodius7 2 роки тому +3

    Great interview from a Prog God!

  • @psychicdriver4229
    @psychicdriver4229 2 роки тому +1

    Very enjoyable, thank you... loved the musical box too ...saw you guys a couple of times...

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому

      Awesome to hear that! Thanks so much.

  • @stefanocivitarese4029
    @stefanocivitarese4029 8 місяців тому

    Wonderful conversation. The Battle of Epping Forest, though, is possibly my favourite Genesis song! I’ve recently been to Epping Forest, and I could not take the tune out of my mind for days

  • @gynandroidhead
    @gynandroidhead Рік тому

    This just made my day

  • @afaceforradiowithrichardma4831
    @afaceforradiowithrichardma4831 2 роки тому +4

    I’ve seen you guys. You’re amazing. Saw you at the Keswick in PA.

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +2

      Thanks so much Rich. It was quite a thrill to perform all of that early Genesis music in a total and complete presentation for the fans around the world who love it so much.

  • @ignatzmuskrat3000
    @ignatzmuskrat3000 Рік тому

    Engaging interview. Loved it. My Tony story goes back to the Duke tour when the night before the Fox theater gig, I saw Tony and his wife coming out of the Phipps Plaza theater(a posh mall) where Empire Strikes Back was playing. They were coming out as my group was going in. Also, I was tripping on blotter and thought it best to allow him his privacy. But, what a surprise to see him pass right by me! Besides, the place was packed and too loud for a compliment. I still regret it. 😆

  • @alessandronespoli6600
    @alessandronespoli6600 2 роки тому +3

    T h a n k y o u Gregg! ❤️

  • @markusantonio4866
    @markusantonio4866 Рік тому

    Arpeggios on Duke Travels-Dukes End are incredible.

  • @guitarplayer30001
    @guitarplayer30001 Рік тому

    cheers

  • @JohnnyTronny19841
    @JohnnyTronny19841 Рік тому

    Awesome interview. At the end I was yelling at the screen for Tony to listen to the Vertigo soundtrack. I might start a petition about it, stay tuned lol

  • @Aspartamebraintumor
    @Aspartamebraintumor 11 місяців тому

    Tony mentions 2001 being his favorite sci-fi movie... and it reminds me of one of my favorite moments in life was seeing that movie high as a kite in the omniverse theater in Philly

  • @charlesnolan7602
    @charlesnolan7602 Рік тому

    I grew up in south Jersey!
    I saw your drumming on the Trick of the Tail Musical Box show'- I want to say 2016. My first Genesis show was the Trick

  • @proggydan8257
    @proggydan8257 2 роки тому +1

    That was excellent! I hope you may include an interview with Bill Bruford one day! Thank you.

  • @seanh1492
    @seanh1492 Рік тому +3

    I’d like to share another Keswick experience on the minuscule off-chance that Tony will see it here. This was at a Hackett gig not long after the infamous “Sum of the Parts” documentary whose editing at least implied TB control issues and a level of conflict behind the SH and PG departures from Genesis. Early in the gig some lout yelled “F__ Tony Banks”. Hackett completely stopped proceedings to say “no, no, no, I can’t have that. Many of the songs you’re going to hear tonight were written by Tony and we’re incredibly privileged to have them”. Then a comment to the effect that he’s proud to call Tony Banks a friend. In an environment where people still need good guys and bad guys in a story, I thought this a poignant moment of class from Hackett when he could easily have ignored it and gone on with the show - as its star, of course.

  • @AntonyRG1
    @AntonyRG1 2 роки тому +3

    And there's me thinking that the busyness of the lyrics on The Battle of Epping Forest was because there was a battle going on.

  • @arfshesaid4325
    @arfshesaid4325 2 роки тому

    great stuff Tony, i have always loved your complete honesty with regard to music , both your own and others . People in most cases strive to tell and receive the truth , however when they get just that, the truth, they simply cant handle it. Of all the contributions to that great sound and writing i feel that yours was the most important, however the overall efforts from every single person and the pushing and pulling amongst your band mates was in the end a perfect mix musically. I'm personally disappointed that you guys rode off into the sunset the way you did as it did zero justice , to , say the years 1972 to Duke whenever that was 1982 maybe. There are clearly thousands that dont agree with me , but , thanks for that SPECIAL ten or so years that blew me away .
    i hope i run into you or Mike one day
    thanks for the hype

  • @temeralane7867
    @temeralane7867 2 роки тому

    #ILoveYouTony 💛 #ThankYou 🎶🎹🎶

  • @crispyrobot77
    @crispyrobot77 2 роки тому +5

    Tony is such a brilliant writer. Perhaps one of the most profound lyrics I've ever heard by any Human is from "One for the Vine" (Lyrics by Tony Banks)
    Then, on a distant slope
    He observed one without hope
    Flee back up the mountainside
    He thought he recognised him by his walk
    And by the way he fell
    And by the way he
    *Stood up, and vanished into air*

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +4

      One For The Vine is an all-time TB fave here, too!

  • @walternyc
    @walternyc 2 роки тому

    3:15 I was expecting "Can you tell me where my country lies? He even seem to be singing it 😄

  • @storeymark
    @storeymark 2 роки тому +1

    Hey that's nothin'. I saw Genesis in London, Ontario in April 1976, the very first time Phil Collins was the front man with Bill Bruford on drums. That was some show!

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому

      Wow! That is an iconic moment in Genesis history. So lucky you could be there!!!

    • @storeymark
      @storeymark 2 роки тому

      @@TheProgCast It was incredible watching Bruford and Collins drum together.

  • @arag1030
    @arag1030 2 роки тому +1

    My three top pianists/keyboardists of all time:
    1. Tigran Hamasyan
    2. Lyle Mays
    3. Tony Banks

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +1

      That is a very cool top three!

  • @santibanks
    @santibanks 2 роки тому +1

    Very good conversation, especially as it weren't the standard questions which have been answered so many times by now. I've been happy and lucky to have seen Genesis in March this year including one of their last London gigs. The end of a fabulous band and era.
    And I know you from your work with Metheny. It's s a real revelation to me that you played with TMB for some time. I unfortunately missed out on the tours you did with them. How did you get the gig with TMB as I assume this was after Levac left?

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому

      Thanks so much for noticing, Santi. I was drumming with TMB after Martin left, yes. There were very few drummers that took prog seriously as a form of repertoire then - years ago, so I guess that's how I got the gig. That, and knowing all the Phil Collins and Bruford parts!

  • @temeralane7867
    @temeralane7867 2 роки тому +1

    🤗 #ILOVETONYBANKSSOMUCH 💛

  • @steveboland7241
    @steveboland7241 7 місяців тому

    I don't think, even now, that Tony Banks truly realises the huge impact that Genesis had, and continues to have, on the whole 'progressive rock' scene. Genius is so over used but honestly, look at the body of work - Tony Banks - genius

  • @Schimnesthai
    @Schimnesthai 2 роки тому +1

    This was great, really enjoy to hear Tony and your questions were excellent.
    I was watching and reading other interviews (as usual) and i was wondering what was Tony trying to say about guitars, in many he mentioned a few things and then moved on, this interview finally answered that to me, basically "any chord sounds good compared to keyboard" and that's very interesting.
    14:58 "I wanna hold your hand", very similar to "where are you my father" on salmacis
    37:50 WHATT?? lmao... "bread bin" what??? double glazing is funny, but sheets sound like something else. Also, Calling All Stations has some very bad lyrics "soldier ant" "take in your hands a little ray of light and turn it into a beam that pierces the darkness of the night" wich sounds like Ray being an anime protagonist or something.
    42:21 lmao... also, who is adele?
    50:39 This is the most unbelievable sentece i have ever heard.

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +1

      Thank you for listening. So glad to get to the questions Tony has not been asked a million times. Same with my Steve Hackett interview where I ask him about alternate tunings... ua-cam.com/video/SPfe5c7trBU/v-deo.html

    • @Schimnesthai
      @Schimnesthai 2 роки тому

      @@TheProgCast I'll watch it, already on my watch later playlist... tomorrow maybe, its 23:48 here... good night i guess!

  • @josephramone5805
    @josephramone5805 2 роки тому +1

    I like how Tony characterizes "The Battle Of Epping Forest" as having successful vocals and a successful instrumental section when isolated from each other, but not working well when mixed together. Which is EXACTLY what I've always thought about that piece.
    That's not the only Gabriel era Genesis song where the vocals and instruments don't mix very well. I can absolutely see where Tony thinks that the music was ruined by the vocals.
    IMO, Peter was much better solo than with Genesis, however sacrilegious that may sound to some Genesis fans.

  • @mohomoho1
    @mohomoho1 2 роки тому

    2001 and Bladerunner standouts for me. Also Stalker by Tarkovsky also a standout.

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому

      Great sci-fi stuff. Wish we could have had more time but check out the last hour on Patreon. www.patreon.com/theprogcast

  • @roddmcleodable
    @roddmcleodable 2 роки тому +3

    man, I would love to ask him about lyrics of Me and Sarah Jane, Evidence of Autumn, Heathaze, Behind the Lines, Mad Man Moon, Snowbound... so many. Guide Vocal!

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +1

      Wish could get to it all, but of course Mr Banks has limits to his free time...

    • @Yakkymania
      @Yakkymania Рік тому

      i think Mike wrote Behind the Lines, but yeah i agree

    • @roddmcleodable
      @roddmcleodable Рік тому

      @@Yakkymania OH! That's interesting. How did you find that out?

    • @GenesisFan01
      @GenesisFan01 3 місяці тому

      Mike wrote Snowbound as well as the lyrics to Behind the Lines.

  • @benoitroux9639
    @benoitroux9639 2 роки тому

    As a musician, a question fascinates me about the music of Genesis. I believe that the early time signatures were fairly straight (4/4, 3/4, even 9/8), but this changed suddenly with Selling England by the Pound. The solo in Cineman Show is in 7/8, and the piano intro of Firth of Fifth broke that so completely by changing many times. After The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway, this rhythmic complexity return with Trick of the Tail, with Dance on a Vulcano (7/8) etc. I wonder how that process of "liberating" the rythm happened.

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому

      Excellent area of inquiry. I think Phil brought a lot of that to the band's approach.

  • @mattk5020
    @mattk5020 2 роки тому +1

    Thoroughly enjoyed it and I do hope genesis do something in the future. Was this interview done after the recent tour?

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +2

      This was right before the final leg and London shows. We talk about the end of Genesis in part two which is available to patrons... www.patreon.com/theprogcast

    • @mattk5020
      @mattk5020 2 роки тому

      @@TheProgCast Thanks very much and I would like to ask you how to go about setting up a Zoom with Tony Banks and I'm from England and I'd like to contact him or write to him. I saw part 2 last night and really loved the interview and both were excellent. Would you be able to do a Zoom also with Phil Collins and Mike Rutherford and Peter Gabriel. Many thanks

    • @mattk5020
      @mattk5020 Рік тому

      ​@@TheProgCast Can you interview Mike Rutherford.

  • @Stevedrums741
    @Stevedrums741 Рік тому +1

    I'm a Bergen County boy.

  • @Schimnesthai
    @Schimnesthai 2 роки тому +4

    Ok, i have never used Patreon in my life, but i'm willing to pay and learn if you asked Tony about "Who Dunnit?" *and* "Calling All Stations".

    • @critney_
      @critney_ 2 роки тому +3

      Maybe we're lucky and Gregg will upload it later here for non patreons. (Meanwhile, I gave the video a like, disabled my ad blocker and clicked the ad - to give him some revenue - even though the ad suggested I should lose some weight! xD)

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  Рік тому +1

      Patreon helps us keep the lights on and the level high, you guys!

    • @critney_
      @critney_ Рік тому +1

      @@TheProgCast but same do the ads, likes and subs and other videos are fully viewable!

  • @davidkyle2073
    @davidkyle2073 9 місяців тому

    Love Tony’s contributions to the musical universe. Mostly. Great questions many never before asked of him. Awfully funny to hear the always highly opinionated, and hyper-critical Mr. Banks label Ralph VW occasionally “trite” whilst hearing the refrains😅 of “That’s All”. Etc etc in my mind…

  • @seanh1492
    @seanh1492 Рік тому

    My experience watching The Battle of Epping Forest played by TMB in the Keswick is that it’s the single song that got the most rapturous, ecstatic applause from the crowd - I mean a whole audience of white men in their 50s and 60s completely losing their sh_t beyond anything I saw with the guaranteed eternal crowd pleasers like Supper’s Ready or Firth of Fifth - total mayhem unbecoming of such a crowd. The climax of that song is actually quite a moment. I’ve always thought the human brain more capable of processing many layers of elements than we assume it can - in this instance strawberries and cream with custard on top being just what was called for. I’d be fascinated to know if the TMB members noticed this or if it was lost in the playing or possibly a one-night only phenomenon. If I could beam back to 1973 and tell the band it wasn’t the compositional pig’s ear they’ve been thinking it was, or at least far more effective than they think, then I’d do so.

  • @davidkyle2073
    @davidkyle2073 9 місяців тому

    You brought out of Tony what outstanding attention to orchestral colours and concern for sounds he had. I can’t think of a single Genesis tune from a large repertoire that contains “dated” synth sounds. Quite remarkable, when his equally famous prog contemporaries all have cringe worthy examples of nearly unlistenable synth patch choices in their back catalogues.

  • @71organicmusic35
    @71organicmusic35 2 роки тому +2

    i wouldnt change one thing on any song that genesis ever wrote..........they are masterpeices

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +1

      Wouldn't know where to start. They are perfect.

  • @tonynorman6814
    @tonynorman6814 2 роки тому +6

    The wonderful Tony Banks. Great christian name too 😄

  • @bwakser
    @bwakser 2 роки тому +1

    Will we ever see Part 2?

    • @MahavishnuProject
      @MahavishnuProject 2 роки тому

      Join The ProgCast's Patreon - totally worth a few bucks to see it and to support Gregg's special brand of interviews.

  • @turnerthemanc
    @turnerthemanc 8 місяців тому

    I was always getting roasted off my Piano teacher when I was 13 because I hadnt practiced what he had set me. It because I spent the week working out Watcher of the skies intro and Time Table on the piano

  • @askoholli9306
    @askoholli9306 11 місяців тому

    A great interview. Bernard Herrmann was not British, though.

  • @groberts3967
    @groberts3967 2 роки тому

    I was listening to Lamb lies down, wind and wuthering seconds out when I was in high school in the 80s. Hearing what kids listen to now is, is .. mind boggling! This music is some type of outer space language that they don’t comprehend . If it’s not a simple repetitive, basic elementary synthetic manufactured dumb down rhythm pattern, they’re clueless

    • @TheProgCast
      @TheProgCast  2 роки тому +1

      Genesis stands the test of time, does it not?

  • @walternyc
    @walternyc 2 роки тому +1

    Interesting how the 50s were all about the single hits then The Beatles invented the album and now with Spotify brings the single hit again and the album seems something from the past.

    • @JCM-LedZeppelin-Stories
      @JCM-LedZeppelin-Stories 2 роки тому

      And the same emotional denial of the 50s in people...

    • @jandron94
      @jandron94 Рік тому +2

      It's more like for all culture : a bit of this, a YT video, a bit of that. We tend to picnic.
      I had the great pleasure in the late 80s of scouring "braderies" (boot sales) and picking-up Genesis 70s vinyle records to then "religiously" listen to them from start to end both sides on the family record player. A complete ceremonium with record inspection and dusting included.

  • @temeralane7867
    @temeralane7867 2 роки тому +1

  • @michaelfraser5723
    @michaelfraser5723 11 місяців тому

    women's hair dye works best