Thanks Efraim, as a person coming from that evil background, I have much worse things to say much more strongly against these disgusting people but you’ve demonstrated incredible patience and grace. Thank you 🙂
You ought to share this. Westerners need to hear this. Also, we Christians should also be very apologetic, especially the Catholics. I am so very sorry the way the Jewish people got treated by the Church. If it had not been so, then perhaps the Levant would have stood firm against the Arab invaders back in 634. Without the few Syriac records we have found hidden in recent years, all we would have is the Muslim records from these events and Sebeos, which clearly lacks the perspective of those that were the victims. If we had records from the Jewish of what has happened to them, it helps us to turn the public record and the opinion. These young people have been brainwashed to believe in the Palestinian cause because they do not understand that they are NOT indigenous. The PLO before Hamas actually told them and their grandparents told them their people have been there since it was Canaan. 😂 The regular Palestinian people might have been less determined if they knew the truth that it had only been 200 years and they were in fact the settlers and occupiers from the invading forces. But that's not the story they received. My point is that we need Historians to go and document the Jewish Israeli family stories as far back as possible for the museums.
My day is no longer complete without watching at least one or two of your videos ... not since the days of JLI a decade+ ago has my mind and soul been so wonderfully fed on a daily basis .. Bless You as these shiurim bless all of us
Just Wow with that Zohar prophecy concerning Nebudchunezzar and Saddam Hussein!! I always thought the Zohar was mystic fluff, but I only had a Hebrew copy that was given to me as good luck, so I had no idea. That is amazing. I need to learn Hebrew and get an English copy for sure!
Another amazing lecture, Rabbi Efraim, I can listen for hours. Now binging through from present to past and learning so much about the future. Thank you for sharing your knowledge and thank God for directing me to this channel.
42:20 - There is, in fact, an attempt by some modern Muslim intellectuals, such as Mr. Mustafa Akyol and others, who are working hard to "reopen Muslim minds" (an eponymous book of Akyol's). I don't know if Islam will evolve in response to time (for it appears to be stuck in space and things), but Akyol makes a strong case.
As a Protestant Christian, I must say how much I admire the Jewish people and your plight through history. And this video has just taught me so many things I never knew about! Thank you Rabbi!
I cannot believe this episode. It’s so full of bias and opinion- what happened to you actually “educating people” - this war on Gaza has really changed you and the way you address a lot of your new content. It’s bordering on hateful undertones. If you revisit your lectures from 6 months ago- they have a completely different tone especially the ones when you discuss Muslims. When you mention the “war of independence” - did you actually even factually check the historical record? There were millions of arabs to a small Jewish nation who won above all else… come on 😂 there were many reasons arabs lost and Israel won. The way you lay the framework that oh Israel was such an underdog with old weapons and nothing else…is so untrue. They actually had proper weapons, and a very organized and well trained paramilitary whom many served in WW2. And Ben Gurion was vicious in his attack and creed on the Palestinians. There weren’t Miracles (as you want to believe) they were more so underhanded tactics used to at never got exposed …posing as “miracles”. And it has been happening since.
Hi Rabbi, I’ve been listening to your lectures. I’m fascinated with your knowledge & how you present the facts. Keep up the wonderful work. May G-d bless you & your family always!
I think you do great work. I’m struggling to understand as a mystic how some of these “vs.” teachings are helping to bring us together. Yes there are painful histories but when I read the comments here I see a lot of divisiveness and hate toward our human brothers and sisters wrongs and rights all in view, I aim toward something more I guess. I listen to you with an open heart but also as a black Jew, sometimes I struggle with divisiveness separatism racism in a community where persecution of the other is condemned. My comment notifications are turned off so internet fighters, please rest easy. I will not see
The overinflated example of an occasional semi-decent Muslim ruler who ignored Dhimmi laws, was used as an unfavorable comparison to get Europe to live up to its self-proclaimed Enlightenment values when it came to Jewish Emancipation. The closest the Ottomans ever came was part of the failed Tanzimat Reforms, leaving it to the European Empires to temporarily bring it to the rest of the region.
Please would it be possible for you to provide references for the points mentioned. It's very important to try and get to the truth of things and this cant be done unless information is verifiable. Thank you.
I did include references for all verses and many of the other points in the slides (as well as maps, graphics, and newspaper headings). Was there something specific you wanted a reference for?
Im an American liberal and yet fully supportive of Israel and the Jewish people. I love your videos, Im learning so much. Though perhaps its better not to put labels on the political beliefs of others. You must know that its the conservative right wing in America who fly the Confederate battle flag on their cars and mailboxes and proclaim loudly that "Jews control the weather and can call up hurricanes at will." In my state the political dialogue is such that, I feel like I live in Munich in 1936.
@Efraim Palvanov. I’m Muslim. But I like to watch videos on Judaism because it helps me understand all the three religions, so I am here. I’m from Central Asia just like yourself. I agree there was discrimination against Jews in Muslim lands, but nothing on the scale what was happening in the West at that time or until quite recently (all that business with the gas chambers). Depending on what Muslim land and during the reign of what sultan/khan, Jewish culture flourished. You said Maimonides found peace in Egypt under Saladin, which was a Muslim land with a Muslim sultan. But there are many more examples like this. I feel sorry for you guys and others who had to experience pogroms in Uzbekistan in the early 90’s. It seems that other minorities were targeted too, but there were signs that they were orchestrated from Moscow as Russians withdrew. But regardless, it’s not a justification. But I cannot recall any other pogroms or instances like that throughout the history of Central Asia, if you have examples, I’d like to listen really. What happened, doesn’t seem natural, is what I’m saying. I love Jews , I actually don’t care what religion you are, as long as you are a good person. Things that are happening now are sad but I think it has to do with politics, Netanyahu and how he has handled this real estate question. So, now this erupted and we are where we are, unfortunately. I hope I didn’t hurt anyone’s feelings or anything just like, just didn’t wanna walk quietly past video. Thanks! Peace to everyone!
Let's remember your Messiah and national hero Simon bar Kokhba who gruesomely tortured and murdered Jewish members of the Jesus sect of Judaism (proto-christians, before Jesus was deified) for refusing to take part in assassinations of local civil administrators. Wonder how bar Koseba would have dealt with Gandi or MLK ? He certainly was no Torah scholar that teaches you to treat others as you would have them treat you. "Eye for an eye" makes the whole world blind. Or was that the 270 Commandments of Hammurabi ? I like what Yoko Ono said about the importance of non violence in social action to not alienate the ruling administrators. Funny how history repeats. Ben Gurion ordering the assassination of Count Bernadette (not a military target) If y'all had accepted a bi-national representative Democracy (albeit being in the minority, where Jews would have to form coalitions, not unlike today) instead of an inherently dishonest partition pretend (not unlike Solomon with the baby) there would likely be a healthy thriving multicultural middle east (so-called "Cultural Zionism") today instead of the festering instability and refuge crisis across western Asia and western Europe. Really, 25 million internally displaced persons and another 12 million unwelcomed as unwilling migrants just so 6 million jews can immorality inhabit the slum we all know and love as "azreäl"? You just want to share your communal suffering by imposing it on others?
Beautifully put! I wouldn't have been so understanding, & I'm Jewish. My Jewish inlaws are from Syria, & they left Syria with their families, money & pride intact. Nobody forced them to leave.
@@dumbsaraiki9167 Yes, because Jesus Christ our Lord defeated death and took up our sins. Without selfless acts and a merciful God, Christianity infact wouldn't exist.
Verry knowledgeable to know there is a spiritual leader for every generation. His promise is true. I will never forsake you. I shall always be with you. My prophets have delivered my words to you.
Im agnostic but ill give you this... The ottoman empire largely had religious tolerance and i think people are referencing this era without other considerations. I couldn't agree more about the disproportionate attention given to the philistines, so many atrocities many with much higher death counts continually ignored while Israel is under a microscope. Finally, theres multiple muslim and Christian states but the scrutiny on the one small jewish state seems unfair.
Exactly. It is a disproportionate amount of attention by any reasonable standard but the anti-semites refuse to see it. You're not one, therefore you see the double standard
Religious tolerance being forcing people to pay Jizya and kidnapping the children of non-believers and forcing them to be conscripted into the army and raised as Muslims (Janissaries).
As an Iranian, I would say that unfortunately there has been persecution of the Jews in Iran from time to time. But, if you want to be fair, you should give credit to Iranians who have treated the Jews much better than the European Christians have done. It is important because the Jews who lived as guests in Persia committed a disgusting massacre of 75,000 Persians, and unfortunately celebrate that massacre every year. It's like the Germans celebrate the massacre of the Jews.
The "massacre" you are referring to was Jews defending themselves against those who sought their complete extermination. In any case, those ancient Persians were pagans and idolaters, and have nearly nothing to do with today's Iranians. (Similar to the way ancient Egyptians have nothing to do with today's Arab "Egyptians").
Just like they call the nakba a massacre yet they started it. Now they call the war in gaza a genocide yet they started it... They like attacking and when other people defend themselves against them, they play victim
Maimonides letter; *_"God has etangled us with this people, the nation of Ishmael, who treat us so prejudicially and who legislate our harm and hatred..... No nation has ever arisen more harmful than they, nor has anyone done more to humiliate us, degrade us, and consolidate hatred against us."_* *_"We bear the inhumane burden of their humiliation, lies and absurdities, being as the prophet said, 'like a deaf man who does not hear or a dumb man who does not open his mouth'... Our sages disciplined us to bear Ishmael's lies and absurdities, listening in silence, and we have trained ourselves, old and young, to endure their humiliation, as Isaiah said, 'I have given my back to the smiters, and my cheek to the beard pullers.'"_*
Not even half way through the video and am already fed up with the twistness and unscholarly taking of this so called lecture, although the cherry picking and very biased taking of the first section was bad enough, you falling into the very famous myth of the 1948 war was what lead me to pause in and write this comment. You claim to say that in that war Israel was outnumbered 100 to 1 and that it was a handful thousands jews against hundred of millions of arabs.. This is comical to say the least. The combined forces of the 5 arab states participating in that war didn't exceed 23000 soliders, 10000 from Egypt 4000 from Jordan and each of Lebanon Iraq and Saudi provided 3000 soldier as for the Israelis they bustelered their entire force of 29677 Soldier and this is all according to the diaries of Ben Gurion which you can check yourselves. Israel was not drastically outnumbered in their "independece" war in fact they outnumbered their attacking enermy plus they had the defensive advantage, the arabs were anything but comitted to that war since they each had their political troubles that were more pressing to them at home thus their very superficial involvement in the war translated by the relatively few soldiers each provided, Egypt alone had the most advanced and sophisticated military establishment in the region at the time they simply weren't ready to go all in for the palestinians in that war. This video is full of sentimental nationalistic nonsense judging from the audience and views no one takes these so called courses seriously either I don't know how youtube algorithme has suggested this to me.
I go to 22 minutes and started to read the comments. You are spot on with the cherry picking . And history tells us the only wars between Muslims and Jews came after isreal was formed. Yes there has been tensions and mistreatment on both sides but Muslims have been fighting Muslims since the 6th century. There is more conflicts between Muslims than Jews. So his point to say that the establishing of isreal causing wars is a myth really is a facts. Some of The rules he talked about came from umar ibn kattab as amongst the Jews was terrorists. Even a Jewish woman poisoned prophet Muhammad. So the context of the laws was not to humiliate the Jews but but to limit them politicaly and make them apppar as Jews not fake Muslims. After umars rule there was a innovation of these laws and they became extreme towards Jewish people. these laws are not Islamic in a way from our teachings but something from the minds of men. Did Jews and Muslims live peacefull in modern times 1600 1700 1800 1900s history tells us they did so to point out a time in history and single out that specific time is cherry 🍒 picking. Jewish people are human beings and if I have offended anyone Jewish I apologise. But I stand with my Muslim people in the middle east as there is a difference between having backwards laws placed upon u to children being bombed. The west has put laws on people for years. Only so long ago blacks could not marry whites. If I was born in that time I would have been a crime committed. Is that from the bible no its from the minds of men.
This is the Muslims behavior to not listen and start barkingģgg aggressively. He means jews against Arabs. So Arabs are much more than Jews. you think that you found something important to criticize this person as your prophet did. 😂
There was another component to polygamy in that part of the world, since bride kidnapping and forced conversion is common even today particularly against Christians, Hindus, Sikhs and others in places like Egypt, Pakistan, etc. Also against orphans as well with the Orphans' Decree that had the effect of encouraging an orphaned boy or girl to be very quickly married off, since married people had the legal status of adults and could not be taken for forcible conversion (although that did not do much against the bride kidnapping).
My pleasure! You should be able to find it online if you search "Letter to Yemen". There are also a number of books with collections of the Rambam's letters.
Polygamy was still practiced in Sefardic Judaisim until the 20th century. The reason for its ending approximately 1,000 years ago in Ashkenazi Judaism had nothing to do with it being wrong. It had to do with Christian persecution. Polygamy is returning to Judaism this century.
@@davidschalit907are you looking forward to it coming back? It’s true the Torah allowed it. But I hardly think it ever endorsed it. Every example of polygamy given in the Torah was dysfunctional.
@@MehWhatever99 There were plenty of polygamous marriages throughout history. Many worked out fine. Most if not all the examples of Kings ruling in Tanach created dysfunctionality or the like. So no Mashiach?! Garden of Eden was vegan. So no meat? All irrelevant anyway. Sefardim in Israel want their traditions back. They feel that secular Zionists and Haredi Ashkenazim forced them to adopt traditions that aren't their own and to drop their own as well. So through Sefardi culture in Israel polygamy is on the agenda for returning. Which makes this Sefardi Rabbis talk on polygamy, laughable. Both due to his ahistorical comments about the subject and due to many in his own culture in Israel seeking its return.
@@davidschalit907 there are things Hashem permitted on account of human weakness. But, I believe, His plan was always that we would outgrow those weaknesses. There was already speculation in the Talmud 2000 years ago that at the time of the Mashiach the world would be vegetarian, as eating meat is not the Torah ideal. So why not also the abolishment of polygamy? In a time where women may have needed the protection of a man, polygamy may have been preferable to being alone. But in a perfected world, why would that be there be such a need?
Four points rabbi to consider: 1-The thrust of your whole argument rests on the testimony of one man, Maimonodes, who himself was under Muslim rule and in the highest trusted position in that rule with the ability to kill the King himself if he wished. This doesn’t sound like “persecution”. The incident he was talking about, namely, the force conversion imposed by a Muslim ruler in Yemen, is an anomaly. The proof is the simple fact of the continued existence of the Jewish community in almost all Muslim lands, Yemen included. Plus, usually, whenever you see a Muslim government persecuting Jews, you will find it also persecuting Muslims from the same or different persuasion than they are. For example, the Almohads also persecuted Ibn Rushd (Averos) and other Sunni scholars and Sufis, and of course the general population as usual. 2-You claim that Jews were always on the peaceful side, the Muslims on the violent side. Now this is a gross reduction of facts. In the time of Prophet Muhammed, some leading Jews in Medina were collaborating with the Meccan aggressors, after they made pacts with the Muslims, to try to destroy them. The Quran mentioned this. Now you might say “I don’t believe the Quran”, but on that point their can be no argument, because if that wasn’t true and everyone knew it, Muhammed would be, so to speak, shooting himself in the foot. He would be saying to Muslims, Jews, Meccans and the whole Arab world “I attaked these Jews because they betrayed us and conspired with our enemy in Mecca” when everyone would know that that was a lie. Not even a mediocre false prophet would make such a mistake. This and other historical arguments should suffice to show that in this case the Prophet wanted peace and these Jews wanted war. Similar examples can be multiplied from the past and the present. 3-The most striking thing to me was to hear from an orthodox rabbi the recommendation to us Muslims that we should “reform”. And what do you mean by reform? You say what amounts to: adding to or subtracting from the Law of God. You give the examples of polygamy and women education. Now, the principal and the examples are, to put mildly, not good. As for the principal, you are basically blaming Muslims for not altering what they believe is The Law of God. You from all people should know that devout servants of God do not do that. Your Torah prohibits that. Even Maimonodes in his letter to Yemen mentions the importance of keeping the law, no, he goes even farther than that and recommends killing whoever rejects the Oral Torah not only the Written one, as I remember. You boast that you “reformed”, that is for you to deal with on Judgment Day. But don’t blame Muslims for not playing with the Law of God regardless of the temporary trends of the age. As for the examples: well, the Quran is direct and clear that marrying one is not only the norm, the recommended norm, but also states unequivocally that there will always be a level of injustice with polygamy in general, even if it’s tolerable because of certain circumstances, but injustice nonetheless, even if it’s emotional injustice. It’s a dangerous act committed by pious people in very narrow and rare circumstances. Current Muslim practice in east and west testify that the norm is monogamy. Even Muslim kings and despots are mostly monogamous. So that’s out. As for women education, well since the time of The Prophet, starting with his own Wives, women were in fact obligated to learn the Quran and other religious matters like men, and there was no prohibition on learning if they wished. The wives of the Prophet were comanded in the Quran to teach the verses of God and wisdom to the people. Many of the top male scholars throughout the ages had female scholars as their “masters” in legal and spiritual matters. And so on. The principal of adding to or subtracting from the Law of God is blasphemy. Therefore I would suggest we shouldn’t do it, and for sure we shouldn’t recommend it if we want to keep our connection to The Almighty. 4-Now it seems that what you want from “reform” is basically for Muslims to accept the domination of the zionist state. Two points here: One, you should know that this is not how Muslims function. When we dominate, we strive to teach people justice; when we are dominated, we strive to teach people faith and resilience. Submitting to oppression is not an option. It will be temporary since Islam is to the world like the sun: it might set for a while but it will always rise as long as there is a world inhabited by people. Second, more importantly for you, is that you should be the first to condemn the whole principal of zionism. In the same letter of Maimonodes your quoting you have good guidance on that issue. He mentions the prayer of the sages against those who try to calculate the coming of the Messiah. Think about that. Just calculating, while waiting and observing Torah in the diaspora inflicted by God, is breaking a prohibition and getting your self under what amounts to a curse from the sages. OK, what did the zionists do? They went even beyond calculating the time of redemption from exile, no, they actually Worked to create the redemption by themselves. If the mental activity of getting out of exile is a curse, then the physical activity is a double or triple curse. The zionists put themselves in God’s place. No surprise there since generally they were secularists and atheists. Look at the current zionist state and how many Jews there are actively against religion. In some cases they went even beyond Sodom and Gemorah. You should know all that better than me. Dark principle roots usually produce poisonous fruits. The curse of the sages is above the head of those who calculate, and the curse of God is on those who actually transgress.
The talmud is the explanation of the torah (Hebrew Bible). Majority of jews do not believe the bible is a literal document. The torah scholars explain the torah(bible) has 4 levels of explanations.
This guy fails to compare the severity and extent of crimes against Jews committed by Christians relative to those committed by Muslims. Yes, Muslims did a lot of bad things to Jews, but it was sporadic and small scale, and the way they treated dhimmi was nothing compared to the way Christians treated Jews and Muslims living in Christendom. He also pretends like the 1948 war was unprovoked aggression against Zionists by Arabs (who also included Christians, not just Muslims). Well, Zionists never got permission from the local Arabs of Palestine to immigrate there en masse, that permission was given by the Ottoman government and expanded by the British government. And Zionists never got permission from their new neighbors to establish a Jewish supremacist ethnostate on land where Arabs were the majority (yes, even inside the initial borders of Israel). Zionists had been escalating terrorist attacks against Arabs for decades, and when they declared Israel to be an independent country in May 1948, they already had Plan Dalet ready to go for ethnic cleansing of Arabs. I call that illegal annexation of territory and an act of war. And this guy also completely leaves out the contextual information for why Arabs keep refusing two state solutions and attacking Israel. Go read about all the proposed agreements and find out why they said no. It’s because Israel presented totally unacceptable terms that hurt Palestinian refugees and violated the future sovereignty of the State of Palestine. And Israel has been committing constant crimes against Palestinians in Israel and Palestine for the past century. If you want to understand why the Arabs fight the Zionists, you have to learn about the problem from third party sources. Also, this guy totally stereotypes Muslims as terrorists and warmongers, ignoring all reasons why any of them are doing what they are doing, and the fact that Israelis are doing exactly the same things. Go read about all the things Israel has done to its neighbors and how it has helped America to do terrorism and worse crimes in the Middle East and Latin America. This isn’t happening at random. Likud, the ruling party of Israel, was founded by Menachem Begin, who was himself a leader of the terrorist militia Irgun. Read what Albert Einstein said about him in a letter to the New York Times in 1948, you’re in for a surprise. The Israeli far right takes inspiration from what the Hebrew Bible says about the Jews doing things to the Canaanites and Amalekites, and they combine that with European and American style ethnic supremacist nationalism and imperialism, to create a really toxic worldview. I don’t think those people represent all Jews, and if you ever want peace between Israel and its neighbors, the Israeli right wing coalition must be removed from power.
Rabbi Palvanov, whats your opinion on Rav Avraham ben Ha'Rambam claiming Sufism retained some lost aspects of the nevi'im or Jewish mysticism Jews in his region lost?
It's possible, especially considering that a lot of the early Muslim scholars and scribes were actually Jews! I spoke about it in the 'Judaism vs. Islam' video here: ua-cam.com/video/yBh_F5JzW1s/v-deo.html
Then he should read the older letters of rabbis from the golden era of the Jews. In any case, Jews lived better under Islamic rule than under Christians. not always but most of the time. The proof is that there would be no Jew today without Islam. but haters just hate.
Excellent insights informative and educational ! More on these subjects ! Thank you ! The present war is nothing short of Yeshuot ! Just being led to the discoveries of tunnels and weapons and having them destroyed is in itself is a huge gift from G-D ! 🙌
I kmow your business and I wish you had time to write books about all these various topics you address in your lectures. Ive seen the ones you've written.
How can it be occupation when Jews have been living continuously in the Levant for over 3000 years? If you want to talk about apartheid, tell me what's being forced to pay 30% of your earnings just because of your religon, how about being barred from your most holy sights, how about having your testimony in court be worth less then the majority religious caste, everything that Palestinian activists accuse Israel for, was done by the arabs 2x as bad
@@john4chan127it’s simple. >Someone lives in a house. >Somebody comes and takes the force with force under threat of murder. You rationalisation is a symptom of mental illness. To put it mildly, you are delusional. Your reference is to people who >are not here >are not you You imagine these non-existent people and project them onto yourself as if they are you This is how you twist people who break into someone’s property and rob/pillage/murder the people who are currently there. Please, seek help 🙏
Re the discussion about 18 minutes in, this is one reason I find the Palestinians claims to be so ludicrous. They attacked. They lost. Finders Keepers losers weepers. That's the way it works everywhere all the time.
I wish I was a Jew, I could speak the language GOD spoke to PROPHET MOSES But sadly, I wasn't and I can't, but I love your people with all my heart man 2. No one in all human history have been born like Moses, he is the one and only one who GOD himself spoke to him face to face
The truth is that Muhammad plagiarized not just Judaism but Christianity mixed it with Arab moon god and their culture then made himself second only to God. Then started to conquer and spread out. He was the OG Jim Jones, Charles Manson and Heavens Gate cult. In fact I would say he's the most successful cult leader ever.
The first part of lecture is fine. But gradually you are shifting to ziomism. The question is why did you come to claim your mother land after 3000 years? You have no answer for that. The other things you are talking is nothing but rubbish.
There were enough more 'recent' muz pogroms in the 80's and 90's in Uzbekistan, Dagestan, Yemen, Algeria, Ethiopia... And most of them had nothing to do with the zionim 'excuse'
I totally disagree with your take that Christianity which is based on Jesus's sacrifice on the CROSS is idolatrous. You are actually denying Jesus as the messiah. May God bring you to the light.
Yes, I am denying Jesus as the messiah. Please see 'Judaism vs. Christianity' here: ua-cam.com/video/Jgf7hBGqzJM/v-deo.html and also 'Who is Mashiach?' here: ua-cam.com/video/3rvL-sW5J04/v-deo.html
You're free to disagree. But I disagree with your statement. Jesus was a mascot created to blind people to the spiritual truths. Worshipping a man like he is God is idolatry. That is the problem with this world as it is today, worshipping humans like they are gods....
23:10 i wouldn't completely agree with this remark considering the Talmud was made around the same time as the first official manuscript of the New Testament in the Latin Vulgate. Judaism came first, i agree, but present Judaism has its differences as an offshoot to that branch as well, in that prayer itself is different. Albeit for one example that the Kippah, Tallith, and Tefillin were never worn during prayer in the Tanakh. So speaking from a Historical Context the two religions of Judaism and Christianity became official around the same time during 500 CE. Only for Islam to be official 100 years later when the Quran was made inspired by non-canonical scriptures from non-chalcedonian Christian's and Jews that did not follow Oral Torah who moved to Arabia.
So its up to on what you personally believe. Abrahamic Religions are a lot more nuanced then people ought them to be. Jews believe Oral Torah is the Word of God, Christians believe its Jesus, Muslims believe its the Quran. At the end of the day its all interpretation, thats below God himself. I do respect Judaism for being more ambiguous compared to the two however. God Bless.
When people talk about jewish-muslim history being positive they mostly refer to the relations with the Ottomans, which unless I missed it, is completely skipped. This shouldve been titled Jewish-Arab history
Hey bro, your talk was truly captivating. The historical narrative you shared about the pre-Israel era and the oppression faced by Jewish people under Muslim rule resonated with me. It's plausible that the tribal warlike culture of Arab society persisted post-Islamization. I also observe that while other religions have evolved, Islam has remained relatively stagnant. Reform seems necessary. However, I respectfully disagree with your confusion about why some, including many non-Muslims, harbor animosity towards Jews. Perhaps the idealized portrayal of Jews being universally fair isn't always accurate. It's essential to examine how Jews in power treated followers of the Christ during that era. Though it might seem controversial, the deeply ingrained stereotype of Jews as financially shrewd and unapologetically biased towards their own kind is sure to fuel escalating hostility over time by non Jews. Many of the facts you presented about Israel's attempts to negotiate fair deals with Palestinians are debatable. Nevertheless, I value your explanation, and I acknowledge the atrocities against Jews throughout history. As an agnostic (ex-Muslim) who doesn't adhere to organized religion, I refrain from commenting on specific faiths. I believe that all living beings strive to survive, and death serves as the great equalizer. If I were to adopt a belief system, I might consider making "game theory" my religion and follow its principles.
Appreciate the feedback, thank you. If you're interested, I spoke more about Jewish-Christian relations here: ua-cam.com/video/Jgf7hBGqzJM/v-deo.html and Jewish-Muslim relations here: ua-cam.com/video/yBh_F5JzW1s/v-deo.html
@EfraimPalvanov Thanks for the link and thank you for making your videos. Everything is going to work out just as God intends it to. We were all blessed with the blessing of free will. As for me, I am gaining back the spiritual strength that God blessed me with. May God bless you, your family, and all of the people of Israel, always.
First o e I do t k ow who it is, second one is a psychopath who didn't have ancestors living unde islam. He used his parents being holocaust survivors to spew his hatred of Jews and Israel. He is a mamzer
Islam has no reform and yet the Quran has literally been amended severally through abrogation. Strange religion. I'm with you hoping for success amongst the reformers.
In the battle of Khandag ( trench) - Bani Q. were prophet allies, but they betrayed him and planed a war with Meccan’s ( pagans ). Meccan started attacking muslim homes in Medina, women and children to open a route for BaniQ. Because of the bad weather they retreated. Prophet told BaniQ. to retreat, but they didn’t listen and insisted for the war. The battle started, and many were killed and the rest were captured and they were exiled. They eventually went to Khybar.
A video, from 2024, shows people dressed in Jewish garb discussing the killing of non-jewish "slaves" and what penalties the master should suffer if the "slave" dies before 24 hours passes : youtube video title "Daf Yomi Bava Kama Daf 90 by R’ Eli Stefansky" forward to 6:20. Then they discuss other laws regarding handling their "slaves".
On the other hand, we have Maimonides' son, Avraham who incporprated the islamic prayer postures in Judaism, the entirety of Kalam philosophy. Always good to remember that both zionism and antisemitism are EUROPEAN phenomena. In that sense, zionism has European antisemitism internalized and incorporated in modern day, Herzlian zionism. And also, Rambam wrote other letters. Let it be a source of knowledge to you. Go forth and learn
1900-1948 1. 1901-1902: 3rd Cairo massacre, Ottoman Egypt 2. 1901-1907: 4th Alexandria massacres, Ottoman Egypt 3. 1903: 1st Port Said massacres, Ottoman Egypt 4. 1903-1940: Pogroms of Taza and Settat, Morocco 5. 1904: massacre of Jews in Yemen 6. 1907: Casablanca, pogrom, Morocco 7. 1908: 2nd Port Said massacre, Ottoman Egypt 8. 1909: comment from the British vice-consul of Mosul: “The attitude of Muslims towards Christians and Jews is that of a master towards his slaves.” 9. 1910: blood libel of Shiraz 10. 1911: Shiraz pogrom 11. 1912: 4th Fez, Pogrom, Morocco 12. 1914: expulsion of Jews from Palestine old enough to bear arms by the Ottomans 13. 1917: Jewish Inquisition of Baghdadi, Ottoman Empire 14. 1918-1948: adoption of a law prohibiting the raising of a Jewish orphan, Yemen 15. 1920: Irbid massacres: British mandate in Palestine 16. 1920-1930: Arab riots, British Mandate Palestine 17. 1921: 1st Jaffa riots, British Mandate Palestine 18. 1922: Massacres of Djerba, Tunisia 19. 1922: law of forced conversion of orphans in Yemen, concerning Jews including as adults 20. 1927: 60 Jews killed by Arabs in the Mellah of Casablanca Morocco 21. 1928: Massacres of Ikhwan, in Egypt and under British mandate in Palestine. 22. 1928: Jewish orphans sold into slavery and forced to convert to Islam by the Muslim Brotherhood, Yemen 23. 1929: anti-Jewish riots, British mandate: in August 1929, the Jews demanded the construction of the Western Wall; pogroms in Jerusalem, Hebron, Safed. To stop the violence, the British reject this request 24. 1929: 3rd Hebron Pogrom under British Mandate Palestine. 25. 1929 3e pogrom de Safed, mandate britannique Palestine. 26. 1933: 2nd Jaffa riots, British mandate in Palestine. 27. 1934: Anti-Jewish pogrom in Constantine Algeria. 200 Jewish stores were raided, the total material damage was estimated at more than 150 million francs. It also sent a quarter of Constantine’s Jewish population into poverty. 28. 1934: Pogroms in Thrace, Türkiye 29. 1934: 1st massacres in Farhud, Iraq 30. 1936: 3rd Jaffa riots, British Mandate Palestine 31. 1936: 2e massacre of Farhud, Irak 32. 1938: boycott of Jews in Egypt 33. 1939: discovery of 3 bombs in synagogues in Cairo 34. 1941 : 3e massacre de Farhud, Iraq 35. 1941: persecution of Jews in Libya 36. 1941: massacre of Jews in Baghdad, with the support of the authorities: approx. 170 dead 37. 1942: collaboration of the mufti with the Nazis. Plays a role in the final solution 38. 1942: Struma disaster, Türkiye 39. 1942: Nile Delta pogroms, Egypt 40. 1938-1945: Arab collaboration with the Nazis 41. 1942: discriminatory tax law of Varlik Vergisi in Turkey against Jews and Christians 42. 1942: looting of Jewish property in Benghazi and deportation to the desert 43. 1944: attack on the Jewish quarter of Damascus 44. 1945: anti-Jewish and anti-Christian riots in Egypt; churches and synagogues destroyed 45. 1945: 4th Cairo massacre, Egypt 46. 1945: Pogrom of Tripoli, Libya 47. 1947: segregation measures against Jews in Egypt 48. 1947: pogrom in Libya; approx. 130 dead 49. 1947 : Pogroms d’Aden au Yemen 50. 1947: 3rd pogrom d’Alep, Syrie 51. 1948: “emptying” of the Jewish quarter of Damascus, Syria 1800-1899 1. 1800: new decree adopted in Yemen, prohibiting Jews from wearing new or good clothes. Jews were forbidden to ride mules or donkeys, and were sometimes rounded up for long, naked marches through the Roob al Khali desert. 2. 1805: 1st pogrom in Ottoman Algeria against the Jews of Algiers after a famine. Frenchconsul Dubois-Thainville saves 200 Jews by sheltering them in his consulate. 3. 1805: exile of Jews from Algiers to Tunis and Livorno 4. 1805, the leader of the Jewish Nation of Algiers, Naphthalie Busnach, is killed while riots ravage the neighborhoods. 5. 1806: expulsion by fatwa of the Jews of Sali in Morocco 6. 1806: ban on Moroccan Jews wearing Western clothing 7. 1806: the janissaries of the dey of Algiers massacre and pillage in the Jewish quarter 8. 1807: expulsion of Jews from Tetouan 9. 1808: 1st massacres in the Mellah ghetto, North Africa 10. 1815, the chief rabbi of Algiers, Isaac Aboulker, is beheaded during a riot. 11. 1815: the Jews of Algiers are forced to fight against an invasion of locusts 12. 1815: 2nd pogrom of Algiers, Ottoman Algeria 13. 1816: in Algeria, ban on carrying weapons for Jews and Christians 14. 1820: Massacres of Sahalu Lobiant, Ottoman Syria 15. 1828 : pogrom de Baghdad, Iraq ottoman 16. 1830: 3rd pogrom of Algeria, Ottoman Algeria 17. 1830: start of the persecution of Jews in Persia, caused by the Russian advance in the Caucasus 18. 1830: ethnic cleansing of Jews in Tabriz, Iran 19. 1834: 2nd pogrom of Hebron, Ottoman Palestine 20. 1834 : Pogrom de Safed, Palestine ottomane 21. 1838: Druze attack in Safed, Ottoman Palestine 22. 1839: Massacre of the Mashadi Jews, Iran 23. 1839: forced conversion of surviving Jews from Mashadi 24. 1839: campaign of forced conversions of Iranian Jews 25. 1840: persecution of the Jews of Damascus; ritual murder case 26. 1840: forced conversion of the Jews of Mashadi 27. 1841: massive murders of Jews in Morocco; the sultan is obliged to consider the Jews as his personal property, which helps to protect them 28. 1840: Damascus, ritual murders (French Muslims and Christians kidnapped, tortured and killed Jewish children for entertainment), Ottoman Syria 29. 1844: 1st Cairo massacre, Ottoman Egypt 30. 1847: Dayr al-Qamar Pogrom, Liban ottoman 31. 1847: ethnic cleansing of Jews in Jerusalem, Ottoman Palestine 32. 1848: 1st pogrom of Damascus, Syria 33. 1848: total disappearance of the Jews of Mashhad 34. 1850: 1st pogrom of Aleppo, Ottoman Syria 35. 1854: anti-Jewish pogrom in Demnate, Morocco 36. 1857: beheading in Tunis of the Jewish coachman Batou Sfez, accused of blasphemy, while he was drunk 37. 1860: 2nd pogrom of Damascus, Ottoman Syria 38. 1862: 1st pogrom of Beirut, Ottoman Lebanon 39. 1866 : pogrom at Kuzguncuk, Turquie Ottomane 40. 1867: Barfurush massacre, Ottoman Türkiye 41. 1868: Eyub Pogrom, Ottoman Türkiye 42. 1869: Massacre of Tunis, Ottoman Tunisia 43. 1869: Massacre of Sfax, Ottoman Tunisia 44. 1864-1880: Marrakech massacre, Morocco 45. 1870: 2nd Alexandria massacres, Ottoman Egypt 46. 1870: 1st pogrom in Istanbul, Ottoman Türkiye 47. 1871: 1st Damanhur massacres, Ottoman Egypt 48. 1872: Massacres in Edirne, Ottoman Türkiye 49. 1872: 1st pogrom of Izmir, Ottoman Türkiye 50. 1873: 2nd massacre of Damanhur, Ottoman Egypt 51. 1874: 2nd pogrom of Izmir, Ottoman Türkiye 52. 1874: 2nd pogrom of Istanbul, Ottoman Türkiye 53. 1874: 2nd pogrom of Beirut, Ottoman Lebanon 54. 1875: 2 pogroms in Aleppo, Ottoman Syria 55. 1875: Massacre on the island of Djerba, Ottoman Tunisia 56. 1877 : 3e massacre de Damanhur, Egypte ottomane 57. 1877: Pogrom of Mansura, Ottoman Egypt 58. 1882: Massacre of Homs, Ottoman Syria 59. 1882: 3rd massacre of Alexandria, Ottoman Egypt 60. 1889: after the funeral of a rabbi, deemed too discreet, the Jewish cemetery of Baghdad was confiscated 61. 1889: looting of the Jewish quarter of Baghdad 62. 1890: 2nd Cairo massacre, Ottoman Egypt 63. 1890, 3e pogrom de Damas, Syrie ottomane 64. 1891: 4th massacre of Damanahur, Ottoman Egypt 65. 1897: murders in Tripoli, Ottoman Libya 66. 1890: Massacres of Tunis, Ottoman Tunisia 1700-1799 1. 1700: massacre of Jews in Yemen 2. 1747 : Massacres de Mashhad, Iran 3. 1758: executions of a Jew and an Armenian in Constantinople for violation of the legislation on the clothing of infidels 4. 1770: expulsion of Jews from Jeddah in Arabia 5. 1785 : Tripoli Porom, Libya ottomane 6. 1790-92: Pogrom of Tetouan. Morocco (Jews of Tetouan undressed and lined up) 7. 1790: destruction of most of the Jewish communities in Morocco 1600-1699 1. 1604: start of a period of famine, violence and forced conversions of the Jewish population of Fez: 2000 conversions in 2 years 2. 1608: persecution for two years of the Jews of Taroudat by the Berbers 3. 1622: forced conversion of the Jews of Persia 4. 1630-1700: Yemenite Jews were considered “impure” and therefore forbidden to touch a Muslim or a Muslim’s food. They were obliged to humble themselves before a Muslim, walk on the left side and greet him first. They could not build houses taller than those of a Muslim or ride a camel or horse, and when riding a mule or donkey, they had to sit on the side. When entering the Muslim quarter, a Jew had to take off his shoes and walk barefoot. If attacked with stones or fists by Muslim youths, a Jew was not allowed to defend himself. 5. 1650: Jews from Tunisia are deported to special neighborhoods called “hara” 6. 1650: forced conversion of the Jews of Persia, under Shah Abbas II 7. 1656: Jews expelled from Isfahan in Iran 8. 1660: 2 pogroms in Safed and Tiberias, Ottoman Palestine 9. 1670: Expulsion of Mawza, Yemen 10. 1676: expulsion of Jews from Sanaa in Yemen 11. 1678: forced conversion of Jews in Yemen 12. 1679-1680: Sanaa massacres, Yemen
@@MehWhatever99 "Maimonides' son, Avraham incporprated the islamic prayer postures in Judaism". I think this was the question/statement that needed addressing. Do you agree with it?
2000 jews killed in the course of the siege and sacking of Cordoba by berber muslims in 1011 AD. 6000 jews killed and their women made slaves in 1033 in Fez (Morocco). 4000 jews killed in 1066 by a muslim mob in Grenada. Anti-jewish progrom happened in Morocco in 1148 CE. Abd al-Mumin ... the leader of the Almohads after the death of Muhammad Ibn Tumart the Mahdi ... captured Tlemcen [in the Maghreb] and killed all those who were in it, including the Jews, except those who embraced Islam. ... [In Sijilmasa] One hundred and fifty persons were killed for clinging to their [Jewish] faith. ... One hundred thousand persons were killed in Fez on that occasion, and 120,000 in Marrakesh. The Jews in all [Maghreb] localities [conquered] ... groaned under the heavy yoke of the Almohads; many had been killed, many others converted; none were able to appear in public as Jews.[21]
So when talk about polygamy being allowed in the past but not anymore, he's admitting that they changed parts of their religion. If its from God, no human has the right to change it.
7:00 Dhimmi description is tremendously deceptive. Including the Baghdad Decree is venomous. Did the Rambam have to wear all that? How come? Did the Rambam ever say something about Islam that was taken wrong by Both Muslims and Jews?
@toobsock Yes, there is a lot of Jewish symbolism in The Matrix, as I explored in depth in 'The Matrix & Judaism' video here: ua-cam.com/video/iezjFyO_dHA/v-deo.htmlsi=5SfdMt78AyD-31wB
You may be correct about some of the things you spoke about but you will need to provide proof. Oct 7 was not the beginning of the issue. There is a very long history behind all this. You say Arafat never wanted to agree to anything and at times walked out of meetings? Could it be because what was being offered was unfair, could it be because he knew israel would never comply with whatever was agreed and didn't Yitzak Rabin want to make peace and was killed? Just like Arafat was poisoned. You also say muslims force others to convert ? As a revert muslim (previously catholic) I was never forced to convert to Islam. It is incorrect. If it was ever done in the past it was not in accordance with Islamic law. No one can force another to become a Muslim. Also we do not worship the stone in Mecca. We do not worship objects or idols. Another point, IF you claim that in 1948 jews returned to the promised land then you justify that taking it by displacing all who lived there and even killing to have it was the correct thing to do? And even worst doing it after the terrible and barbaric holocaust? Sorry but I have a problem believing the almighty would allow such an injustice. Doesn't your holy book say you must wait for the arrival of the messiah to establish in any land? Whatever happened to that order? We can debate for hours about who's right or wrong depending on which side you are on. Only the almighty knows and one day we will all be informed
Listen to yourself, just because you were not forced to convert doesn't mean others were not. No the book doesn't say they have to wait for the messiah to become a nation. Also if you don't worship the stone then why do you go around it and kiss the thing that looks like woman's organ?. Without lies islam dies
The truth is Zionism is not brotherhood among mankind. The way forward is mutual respect and that cannot happen until Zionism is removed. L'chaim Alhamdulillah.
Hertzl didn’t want to add religion to his movement, but then he didn’t have support needed for the movement. They ended up misusing or getting profit from the religion.
who said the following...? "the world will never enjoy another moment of peace and tranquility ever again until and unless islam is ended..." answer... me... truth.out...
I appreciate your history lesson however, I would like to make a couple of minor corrections; The Romans were not Christians, they were pagans who were wearing the name of Christ/Messiah in order to unite their warring Kingdom. The Roman Catholics are not Christians. They believe in Christ/Messiah, just as the Muslims do, but they do not follow Christ/Messiah. A Christian follows the teachings of Christ. Muslims follow the teachings of Muhammad. Catholics follow the teachings of the papacy, not Christ/Messiah. So when the Romans sent the crusaders to take over the holy land and attack the Muslims and the Jews, they were doing it in the name of Christ/Messiah but they weren't doing it at the direction of Christ/Messiah because Christ/Messiah told his apostles to do just the opposite! Jesus told his apostles to go and teach and baptize in the name of the FATHER, Son and holy spirit, but if anyone rejected that teaching, they were to knock the dust from their shoes and move on! The Messiah never instructed his apostles to force, tax, torture, or burn at the stake, anyone who rejected the message! Jesus was a Jew, he operated on Jewish principles. Jesus warned that there would be many who would come in his name, pretending to be Christian/Messianic, when they were not! The Roman Catholic Church is the foremost of these masquerading entities who pretend to be sheep but are really wolves in sheep's clothing! No I'm not talking about the average Catholic here. The average Catholic is just as fooled as everyone else by the tricks of the Roman Catholic papacy. I'm talking about the Roman Catholic papacy and clergy who knowingly and intentionally masquerades as Christ (the vicar of Christ), even claiming to be God himself on Earth, while at the same time changing God's laws! Even as recently as this year, Pope Francis has changed yet another one of the Ten Commandments! The Roman Catholic Church is the counterfeit Christian Church. It is the counterfeit Jewish temple! Just examine closely the garb and the temple layout of the Vatican! They have completely appropriated the Hebrew Temple and levitical priesthood! This is the effort of the enemy Satan to obscure the name of the true god, and the name of his Messiah,and to prevent the message of the good news of the Kingdom from getting through! And yet, in spite of every effort of the Roman Catholic church, the good news has gotten through! Now that the message of the Kingdom has spread all the way around the globe, the fullness of time has come for the choose to retake their position as Kings and priests and help to correct the misunderstandings that the Roman Catholic papacy has fostered throughout history and their false representation of the Christ/Messiah.
I’m not a religious man I was raised in the Anglican Church. I’ve been blessed to meet many people from many different backgrounds I don’t question another person beliefs if we are all children of god can we not just accept that we all have a equal right to practice our beliefs.
Also Ishmael died righteous, as opposed to Essav who didn't. We can't just ignore this tradition. The deification of a man is considered idolatry. It doesn't abide by Noahide laws. Rome too brought good things with her in her time. It doesn't change the fundamentals. As jews, we shouldn't play anybody else's game but God's.
There is a lot of important info here but context is also important. The 20th century was the worst in history for Jewish/Muslim relations and the best in history for Jewish/Christian relations and nevertheless millions of Jews were killed by Christians in the 20th century and thousands by Muslims. There is simply no comparison. Christians have historically been exponentially worse to Jews than Muslims even though it is true that there have been many difficult periods under Islam.
There is plenty of information on what being a Dhimmie meant. Pretending it was something nice is ridiculous! The Pact of Umar tells some of what being a Dhimmie was.
@shainazion4073 Heres the Pact of Umar RA "In the name of God, the Merciful, the Compassionate. This is the assurance of safety which the servant of God, ʿUmar, the Commander of the Faithful, has given to the people of Jerusalem. He has given them an assurance of safety for themselves, for their property, their churches, their crosses, the sick and healthy of the city and for all the rituals which belong to their religion. Their churches will not be inhabited by Muslims and will not be destroyed. Neither they, nor the land on which they stand, nor their cross, nor their property will be damaged. They will not be forcibly converted. And [as per the Christians’ request] Jews will not live in the same areas as them. The people of Jerusalem must pay the taxes like the people of other cities and must expel the Byzantines and the robbers. Those of the people of Jerusalem who want to leave with the Byzantines, take their property and abandon their churches and crosses will be safe until they reach their place of refuge. The villagers [who had taken refuge in the city at the time of the conquest] may remain in the city if they wish but must pay taxes like the citizens. Those who wish may go with the Byzantines and those who wish may return to their families. Nothing is to be taken from them before their harvest is reaped. If they pay their taxes according to their obligations, then the conditions laid out in this letter are under the covenant of God, are the responsibility of His Prophet, of the caliphs and of the faithful" Witnessed by: Khālid b. Walīd; ʿAmr b. al-ʿĀs; ʿAbd al-Rahmān b. al-ʿAwf; Muʿāwiya b. Abī Sufyān. The ruling christians told Umar RA ( the disciple and companion of Prophet Muhammad (saw) and also his father in law) that they had expelled and banish jews in the land. As Umar RA was bringing them back, they worried that jews would still be annoyed at them so told Umar RA to keep jews in another area from them, so they are not neighbours. So Umar RA agreed and included it in his Pact. Read the above, how is it unjust in anyway???
@shainazion4073 Heres the Pact of Umar RA, how is it unjust in anyway In the name of God, the Merciful, the Compassionate. This is the assurance of safety which the servant of God, ʿUmar, the Commander of the Faithful, has given to the people of Jerusalem. He has given them an assurance of safety for themselves, for their property, their churches, their crosses, the sick and healthy of the city and for all the rituals which belong to their religion. Their churches will not be inhabited by Muslims and will not be destroyed. Neither they, nor the land on which they stand, nor their cross, nor their property will be damaged. They will not be forcibly converted. And [as per the Christians’ request] Jews will not live in the same areas as them. The people of Jerusalem must pay the taxes like the people of other cities and must expel the Byzantines and the robbers. Those of the people of Jerusalem who want to leave with the Byzantines, take their property and abandon their churches and crosses will be safe until they reach their place of refuge. The villagers [who had taken refuge in the city at the time of the conquest] may remain in the city if they wish but must pay taxes like the citizens. Those who wish may go with the Byzantines and those who wish may return to their families. Nothing is to be taken from them before their harvest is reaped. If they pay their taxes according to their obligations, then the conditions laid out in this letter are under the covenant of God, are the responsibility of His Prophet, of the caliphs and of the faithful. Witnessed by: Khālid b. Walīd; ʿAmr b. al-ʿĀs; ʿAbd al-Rahmān b. al-ʿAwf; Muʿāwiya b. Abī Sufyān.
@shainazion4073 For some reason the Pact of umar comment was deleted. The Pact of Umar was a wonderful Pact. You search up Umar RA story coming to Jerusalem, its an amazing story.
41:00 It was only banned for Ashkenazim though. Sephardim had polygamy well into the last century, albeit uncommon (as uncommon as in most muslim countries)
I have always known that every peiceful time in a "good" country for jews is just a marage that will disappear in time. It is hard to feel it today with so many freedoms in galus but we need to remember that we are still in galus even when we are in zion.
All these religion content creators pretend to speak for god cause it makes them feel special. This guy is a "rabbi" or iman or priest or whatever instant loss of credibility.
Since Oct 7th, I’ve put on Tefillin for the first time in 30 years, lit the Chanukah candles and looking forward to practicing Judaism so much more.
Your profile picture is disgraceful considering the sincerity of this comment
@@pebystroll million ways to be jewish, it is one of them.
@@pebystrolllet the secular Jew do his thing and let him express this message he wants to share (or her)
Baruch HaShem
Welcome home
Thank you Efraim. I know it's hard to fit all of this material in a little over an hour.
My pleasure!
Another classic, Efi. Thank you.
My pleasure!
Terrific video Rav. May HaShem continue to bless you.
Amen, and may He bless you as well!
@@EfraimPalvanovAmen
Thanks Efraim, as a person coming from that evil background, I have much worse things to say much more strongly against these disgusting people but you’ve demonstrated incredible patience and grace. Thank you 🙂
This comment was typed by stubby Jewish fingers in Tel Aviv
@@Mousedibno he was a muslim
@therealfahadameen Thank you so much! Really appreciate the feedback :)
@@billr.2210 For sure buddy
You ought to share this. Westerners need to hear this. Also, we Christians should also be very apologetic, especially the Catholics. I am so very sorry the way the Jewish people got treated by the Church. If it had not been so, then perhaps the Levant would have stood firm against the Arab invaders back in 634. Without the few Syriac records we have found hidden in recent years, all we would have is the Muslim records from these events and Sebeos, which clearly lacks the perspective of those that were the victims. If we had records from the Jewish of what has happened to them, it helps us to turn the public record and the opinion. These young people have been brainwashed to believe in the Palestinian cause because they do not understand that they are NOT indigenous. The PLO before Hamas actually told them and their grandparents told them their people have been there since it was Canaan. 😂 The regular Palestinian people might have been less determined if they knew the truth that it had only been 200 years and they were in fact the settlers and occupiers from the invading forces. But that's not the story they received. My point is that we need Historians to go and document the Jewish Israeli family stories as far back as possible for the museums.
My day is no longer complete without watching at least one or two of your videos ... not since the days of JLI a decade+ ago has my mind and soul been so wonderfully fed on a daily basis .. Bless You as these shiurim bless all of us
So glad to hear, thank you! May you be blessed as well!
Just Wow with that Zohar prophecy concerning Nebudchunezzar and Saddam Hussein!! I always thought the Zohar was mystic fluff, but I only had a Hebrew copy that was given to me as good luck, so I had no idea. That is amazing. I need to learn Hebrew and get an English copy for sure!
It's written in Aramaic
Another amazing lecture, Rabbi Efraim, I can listen for hours. Now binging through from present to past and learning so much about the future. Thank you for sharing your knowledge and thank God for directing me to this channel.
Thank you so much!
Every lecture is phenomenal, thank you Rabbi Efraim! Baruch HaShem!
Thank you Rafael!
I thank yourself and Rambam for this inspirational talk.
My pleasure!
Wham Bham Thanks Jewess Ma'am.
42:20 - There is, in fact, an attempt by some modern Muslim intellectuals, such as Mr. Mustafa Akyol and others, who are working hard to "reopen Muslim minds" (an eponymous book of Akyol's). I don't know if Islam will evolve in response to time (for it appears to be stuck in space and things), but Akyol makes a strong case.
I am glad I found this video filled with wise knowledge and light, and history.
Well explained brother salom
Thank you!
As a Protestant Christian, I must say how much I admire the Jewish people and your plight through history. And this video has just taught me so many things I never knew about! Thank you Rabbi!
My pleasure!
Me too
@sxrk
Rabbi wants Caliphate back
ua-cam.com/users/shortsRDXgNAZuY68?si=wSuaS9R2lfYGvnGR&sfnsn=mo
Excellent, thank you so much. Shabbat Shalom oo mevorach and Gd bless you all from benjy in Tsfat🍎🍏🍊🙂🙏🙏💛
Thank you Benjy, Shabbat Shalom!
I cannot believe this episode. It’s so full of bias and opinion- what happened to you actually “educating people” - this war on Gaza has really changed you and the way you address a lot of your new content. It’s bordering on hateful undertones. If you revisit your lectures from 6 months ago- they have a completely different tone especially the ones when you discuss Muslims.
When you mention the “war of independence” - did you actually even factually check the historical record? There were millions of arabs to a small Jewish nation who won above all else… come on 😂 there were many reasons arabs lost and Israel won. The way you lay the framework that oh Israel was such an underdog with old weapons and nothing else…is so untrue. They actually had proper weapons, and a very organized and well trained paramilitary whom many served in WW2.
And Ben Gurion was vicious in his attack and creed on the Palestinians. There weren’t Miracles (as you want to believe) they were more so underhanded tactics used to at never got exposed …posing as “miracles”.
And it has been happening since.
Another muslim here trying to attack others
And probably you also think the arabs didn't attack the Jews on the independence war and they just want peace while the Jews want to genocide them?
Hi Rabbi, I’ve been listening to your lectures. I’m fascinated with your knowledge & how you present the facts. Keep up the wonderful work. May G-d bless you & your family always!
Glad to hear, thank you. May you and your family be blessed as well!
I so appreciate your scholarship.
Thank you so much!
You never cease to inspire me with your knowledge. We are so blessed to have you in our generation. Such a privilege for Jew and non jew alike.
Thank you so much!
I think you do great work. I’m struggling to understand as a mystic how some of these “vs.” teachings are helping to bring us together. Yes there are painful histories but when I read the comments here I see a lot of divisiveness and hate toward our human brothers and sisters wrongs and rights all in view, I aim toward something more I guess. I listen to you with an open heart but also as a black Jew, sometimes I struggle with divisiveness separatism racism in a community where persecution of the other is condemned.
My comment notifications are turned off so internet fighters, please rest easy. I will not see
The overinflated example of an occasional semi-decent Muslim ruler who ignored Dhimmi laws, was used as an unfavorable comparison to get Europe to live up to its self-proclaimed Enlightenment values when it came to Jewish Emancipation. The closest the Ottomans ever came was part of the failed Tanzimat Reforms, leaving it to the European Empires to temporarily bring it to the rest of the region.
Please would it be possible for you to provide references for the points mentioned. It's very important to try and get to the truth of things and this cant be done unless information is verifiable. Thank you.
I did include references for all verses and many of the other points in the slides (as well as maps, graphics, and newspaper headings). Was there something specific you wanted a reference for?
If you really want to know you'll do your own research, even if starting with only rudimentary skills.
I love this, thank you
My pleasure!
Im an American liberal and yet fully supportive of Israel and the Jewish people. I love your videos, Im learning so much. Though perhaps its better not to put labels on the political beliefs of others. You must know that its the conservative right wing in America who fly the Confederate battle flag on their cars and mailboxes and proclaim loudly that "Jews control the weather and can call up hurricanes at will." In my state the political dialogue is such that, I feel like I live in Munich in 1936.
@Efraim Palvanov. I’m Muslim. But I like to watch videos on Judaism because it helps me understand all the three religions, so I am here. I’m from Central Asia just like yourself. I agree there was discrimination against Jews in Muslim lands, but nothing on the scale what was happening in the West at that time or until quite recently (all that business with the gas chambers). Depending on what Muslim land and during the reign of what sultan/khan, Jewish culture flourished. You said Maimonides found peace in Egypt under Saladin, which was a Muslim land with a Muslim sultan.
But there are many more examples like this.
I feel sorry for you guys and others who had to experience pogroms in Uzbekistan in the early 90’s. It seems that other minorities were targeted too, but there were signs that they were orchestrated from Moscow as Russians withdrew. But regardless, it’s not a justification. But I cannot recall any other pogroms or instances like that throughout the history of Central Asia, if you have examples, I’d like to listen really. What happened, doesn’t seem natural, is what I’m saying.
I love Jews , I actually don’t care what religion you are, as long as you are a good person. Things that are happening now are sad but I think it has to do with politics, Netanyahu and how he has handled this real estate question. So, now this erupted and we are where we are, unfortunately. I hope I didn’t hurt anyone’s feelings or anything just like, just didn’t wanna walk quietly past video. Thanks! Peace to everyone!
Appreciate the feedback, thank you!
Before the Russians took over Central Asia Muslims were trying to forcibly converted Jews to Islam. Also used various pressure.
Let's remember your Messiah and national hero Simon bar Kokhba who gruesomely tortured and murdered Jewish members of the Jesus sect of Judaism (proto-christians, before Jesus was deified) for refusing to take part in assassinations of local civil administrators. Wonder how bar Koseba would have dealt with Gandi or MLK ? He certainly was no Torah scholar that teaches you to treat others as you would have them treat you. "Eye for an eye" makes the whole world blind. Or was that the 270 Commandments of Hammurabi ?
I like what Yoko Ono said about the importance of non violence in social action to not alienate the ruling administrators.
Funny how history repeats.
Ben Gurion ordering the assassination of Count Bernadette (not a military target)
If y'all had accepted a bi-national representative Democracy (albeit being in the minority, where Jews would have to form coalitions, not unlike today) instead of an inherently dishonest partition pretend (not unlike Solomon with the baby)
there would likely be a healthy thriving multicultural middle east (so-called "Cultural Zionism") today instead of the festering instability and refuge crisis across western Asia and western Europe. Really, 25 million internally displaced persons and another 12 million unwelcomed as unwilling migrants just so 6 million jews can immorality inhabit the slum we all know and love as "azreäl"?
You just want to share your communal suffering by imposing it on others?
Beautifully put! I wouldn't have been so understanding, & I'm Jewish. My Jewish inlaws are from Syria, & they left Syria with their families, money & pride intact. Nobody forced them to leave.
Without lies, Islam dies.
Sorry Khazar but Am Jishmael Hai😘
And without crucifixion, Christianity does not exist
Pagans man God😂
@@QuranInAllLanguageLook your ears 😂😂😂😂
@@dumbsaraiki9167 Yes, because Jesus Christ our Lord defeated death and took up our sins. Without selfless acts and a merciful God, Christianity infact wouldn't exist.
Was waiting for it ,it came at 8:35 there shows
Truth!
Thank you for putting this so beautifully 💙🇮🇱
My pleasure!
Anyone asking for references in this excellent video, please read the book “The Dhimi” by Bat Ye’or
@mimArmand
Rabbi wants Caliphate back
ua-cam.com/users/shortsRDXgNAZuY68?si=wSuaS9R2lfYGvnGR&sfnsn=mo
Thank you Efi, I would like to hear your shiur about Tikkun HaBrit. Thanks 🙏
Verry knowledgeable to know there is a spiritual leader for every generation. His promise is true. I will never forsake you. I shall always be with you. My prophets have delivered my words to you.
Understanding sequence of events is a blessing unto Kings. For they have searched the matter out. Not in vain, and not without reward.
Thank you for the hope!
Im agnostic but ill give you this... The ottoman empire largely had religious tolerance and i think people are referencing this era without other considerations. I couldn't agree more about the disproportionate attention given to the philistines, so many atrocities many with much higher death counts continually ignored while Israel is under a microscope. Finally, theres multiple muslim and Christian states but the scrutiny on the one small jewish state seems unfair.
Exactly. It is a disproportionate amount of attention by any reasonable standard but the anti-semites refuse to see it. You're not one, therefore you see the double standard
are you turkish?
@@Michael-rc7pe nah I'm a Florida man...
Their genocide of the Armrnians, Assyrians, Jesidi... preceeded the holocaust.
Religious tolerance being forcing people to pay Jizya and kidnapping the children of non-believers and forcing them to be conscripted into the army and raised as Muslims (Janissaries).
As an Iranian, I would say that unfortunately there has been persecution of the Jews in Iran from time to time. But, if you want to be fair, you should give credit to Iranians who have treated the Jews much better than the European Christians have done. It is important because the Jews who lived as guests in Persia committed a disgusting massacre of 75,000 Persians, and unfortunately celebrate that massacre every year. It's like the Germans celebrate the massacre of the Jews.
The "massacre" you are referring to was Jews defending themselves against those who sought their complete extermination. In any case, those ancient Persians were pagans and idolaters, and have nearly nothing to do with today's Iranians. (Similar to the way ancient Egyptians have nothing to do with today's Arab "Egyptians").
A wild Amalekite appears.
Just like they call the nakba a massacre yet they started it. Now they call the war in gaza a genocide yet they started it... They like attacking and when other people defend themselves against them, they play victim
Maimonides letter;
*_"God has etangled us with this people, the nation of Ishmael, who treat us so prejudicially and who legislate our harm and hatred..... No nation has ever arisen more harmful than they, nor has anyone done more to humiliate us, degrade us, and consolidate hatred against us."_*
*_"We bear the inhumane burden of their humiliation, lies and absurdities, being as the prophet said, 'like a deaf man who does not hear or a dumb man who does not open his mouth'... Our sages disciplined us to bear Ishmael's lies and absurdities, listening in silence, and we have trained ourselves, old and young, to endure their humiliation, as Isaiah said, 'I have given my back to the smiters, and my cheek to the beard pullers.'"_*
@shai
Rabbi wants Caliphate back
ua-cam.com/users/shortsRDXgNAZuY68?si=wSuaS9R2lfYGvnGR&sfnsn=mo
Not even half way through the video and am already fed up with the twistness and unscholarly taking of this so called lecture, although the cherry picking and very biased taking of the first section was bad enough, you falling into the very famous myth of the 1948 war was what lead me to pause in and write this comment. You claim to say that in that war Israel was outnumbered 100 to 1 and that it was a handful thousands jews against hundred of millions of arabs.. This is comical to say the least. The combined forces of the 5 arab states participating in that war didn't exceed 23000 soliders, 10000 from Egypt 4000 from Jordan and each of Lebanon Iraq and Saudi provided 3000 soldier as for the Israelis they bustelered their entire force of 29677 Soldier and this is all according to the diaries of Ben Gurion which you can check yourselves. Israel was not drastically outnumbered in their "independece" war in fact they outnumbered their attacking enermy plus they had the defensive advantage, the arabs were anything but comitted to that war since they each had their political troubles that were more pressing to them at home thus their very superficial involvement in the war translated by the relatively few soldiers each provided, Egypt alone had the most advanced and sophisticated military establishment in the region at the time they simply weren't ready to go all in for the palestinians in that war.
This video is full of sentimental nationalistic nonsense judging from the audience and views no one takes these so called courses seriously either I don't know how youtube algorithme has suggested this to me.
I go to 22 minutes and started to read the comments. You are spot on with the cherry picking . And history tells us the only wars between Muslims and Jews came after isreal was formed. Yes there has been tensions and mistreatment on both sides but Muslims have been fighting Muslims since the 6th century. There is more conflicts between Muslims than Jews. So his point to say that the establishing of isreal causing wars is a myth really is a facts. Some of The rules he talked about came from umar ibn kattab as amongst the Jews was terrorists. Even a Jewish woman poisoned prophet Muhammad. So the context of the laws was not to humiliate the Jews but but to limit them politicaly and make them apppar as Jews not fake Muslims. After umars rule there was a innovation of these laws and they became extreme towards Jewish people. these laws are not Islamic in a way from our teachings but something from the minds of men. Did Jews and Muslims live peacefull in modern times 1600 1700 1800 1900s history tells us they did so to point out a time in history and single out that specific time is cherry 🍒 picking. Jewish people are human beings and if I have offended anyone Jewish I apologise. But I stand with my Muslim people in the middle east as there is a difference between having backwards laws placed upon u to children being bombed. The west has put laws on people for years. Only so long ago blacks could not marry whites. If I was born in that time I would have been a crime committed. Is that from the bible no its from the minds of men.
This is the Muslims behavior to not listen and start barkingģgg aggressively.
He means jews against Arabs. So Arabs are much more than Jews. you think that you found something important to criticize this person as your prophet did. 😂
seethe, ishmaelite. We will never bow to you EVER
There was another component to polygamy in that part of the world, since bride kidnapping and forced conversion is common even today particularly against Christians, Hindus, Sikhs and others in places like Egypt, Pakistan, etc. Also against orphans as well with the Orphans' Decree that had the effect of encouraging an orphaned boy or girl to be very quickly married off, since married people had the legal status of adults and could not be taken for forcible conversion (although that did not do much against the bride kidnapping).
Please cite sources.
Very interesting. Great video 🇮🇱🙏❤🇧🇬
Thank you!
Listening to this as a Muslim about 15 mins in. Facinating thank you for your efforts. Gd is 1 ❤
Thank you Efraim for this Shiur! Where is the letter you mentioned from the Rambam? Where can I find it?
My pleasure! You should be able to find it online if you search "Letter to Yemen". There are also a number of books with collections of the Rambam's letters.
Thank you!
What is the historic reference how Jews were treated under Islamic rule? This for example 08:00?
@iillii
He lied
Rabbi wants Caliphate back
ua-cam.com/users/shortsRDXgNAZuY68?si=wSuaS9R2lfYGvnGR&sfnsn=mo
Please make more videos on this thank you
@Elokin
Rabbi wants Caliphate back
ua-cam.com/users/shortsRDXgNAZuY68?si=wSuaS9R2lfYGvnGR&sfnsn=mo
Polygamy was still practiced in Sefardic Judaisim until the 20th century. The reason for its ending approximately 1,000 years ago in Ashkenazi Judaism had nothing to do with it being wrong. It had to do with Christian persecution.
Polygamy is returning to Judaism this century.
Do you consider polygamy a moral practice?
@@TheLincolnrailsplitt
It's irrelevant what I think.
The Torah allowed for it.
@@davidschalit907are you looking forward to it coming back?
It’s true the Torah allowed it. But I hardly think it ever endorsed it. Every example of polygamy given in the Torah was dysfunctional.
@@MehWhatever99
There were plenty of polygamous marriages throughout history. Many worked out fine. Most if not all the examples of Kings ruling in Tanach created dysfunctionality or the like. So no Mashiach?!
Garden of Eden was vegan. So no meat?
All irrelevant anyway. Sefardim in Israel want their traditions back. They feel that secular Zionists and Haredi Ashkenazim forced them to adopt traditions that aren't their own and to drop their own as well. So through Sefardi culture in Israel polygamy is on the agenda for returning. Which makes this Sefardi Rabbis talk on polygamy, laughable. Both due to his ahistorical comments about the subject and due to many in his own culture in Israel seeking its return.
@@davidschalit907 there are things Hashem permitted on account of human weakness. But, I believe, His plan was always that we would outgrow those weaknesses.
There was already speculation in the Talmud 2000 years ago that at the time of the Mashiach the world would be vegetarian, as eating meat is not the Torah ideal. So why not also the abolishment of polygamy? In a time where women may have needed the protection of a man, polygamy may have been preferable to being alone. But in a perfected world, why would that be there be such a need?
Four points rabbi to consider:
1-The thrust of your whole argument rests on the testimony of one man, Maimonodes, who himself was under Muslim rule and in the highest trusted position in that rule with the ability to kill the King himself if he wished. This doesn’t sound like “persecution”. The incident he was talking about, namely, the force conversion imposed by a Muslim ruler in Yemen, is an anomaly. The proof is the simple fact of the continued existence of the Jewish community in almost all Muslim lands, Yemen included. Plus, usually, whenever you see a Muslim government persecuting Jews, you will find it also persecuting Muslims from the same or different persuasion than they are. For example, the Almohads also persecuted Ibn Rushd (Averos) and other Sunni scholars and Sufis, and of course the general population as usual.
2-You claim that Jews were always on the peaceful side, the Muslims on the violent side. Now this is a gross reduction of facts. In the time of Prophet Muhammed, some leading Jews in Medina were collaborating with the Meccan aggressors, after they made pacts with the Muslims, to try to destroy them. The Quran mentioned this. Now you might say “I don’t believe the Quran”, but on that point their can be no argument, because if that wasn’t true and everyone knew it, Muhammed would be, so to speak, shooting himself in the foot. He would be saying to Muslims, Jews, Meccans and the whole Arab world “I attaked these Jews because they betrayed us and conspired with our enemy in Mecca” when everyone would know that that was a lie. Not even a mediocre false prophet would make such a mistake. This and other historical arguments should suffice to show that in this case the Prophet wanted peace and these Jews wanted war. Similar examples can be multiplied from the past and the present.
3-The most striking thing to me was to hear from an orthodox rabbi the recommendation to us Muslims that we should “reform”. And what do you mean by reform? You say what amounts to: adding to or subtracting from the Law of God. You give the examples of polygamy and women education. Now, the principal and the examples are, to put mildly, not good. As for the principal, you are basically blaming Muslims for not altering what they believe is The Law of God. You from all people should know that devout servants of God do not do that. Your Torah prohibits that. Even Maimonodes in his letter to Yemen mentions the importance of keeping the law, no, he goes even farther than that and recommends killing whoever rejects the Oral Torah not only the Written one, as I remember. You boast that you “reformed”, that is for you to deal with on Judgment Day. But don’t blame Muslims for not playing with the Law of God regardless of the temporary trends of the age. As for the examples: well, the Quran is direct and clear that marrying one is not only the norm, the recommended norm, but also states unequivocally that there will always be a level of injustice with polygamy in general, even if it’s tolerable because of certain circumstances, but injustice nonetheless, even if it’s emotional injustice. It’s a dangerous act committed by pious people in very narrow and rare circumstances. Current Muslim practice in east and west testify that the norm is monogamy. Even Muslim kings and despots are mostly monogamous. So that’s out. As for women education, well since the time of The Prophet, starting with his own Wives, women were in fact obligated to learn the Quran and other religious matters like men, and there was no prohibition on learning if they wished. The wives of the Prophet were comanded in the Quran to teach the verses of God and wisdom to the people. Many of the top male scholars throughout the ages had female scholars as their “masters” in legal and spiritual matters. And so on. The principal of adding to or subtracting from the Law of God is blasphemy. Therefore I would suggest we shouldn’t do it, and for sure we shouldn’t recommend it if we want to keep our connection to The Almighty.
4-Now it seems that what you want from “reform” is basically for Muslims to accept the domination of the zionist state. Two points here: One, you should know that this is not how Muslims function. When we dominate, we strive to teach people justice; when we are dominated, we strive to teach people faith and resilience. Submitting to oppression is not an option. It will be temporary since Islam is to the world like the sun: it might set for a while but it will always rise as long as there is a world inhabited by people. Second, more importantly for you, is that you should be the first to condemn the whole principal of zionism. In the same letter of Maimonodes your quoting you have good guidance on that issue. He mentions the prayer of the sages against those who try to calculate the coming of the Messiah. Think about that. Just calculating, while waiting and observing Torah in the diaspora inflicted by God, is breaking a prohibition and getting your self under what amounts to a curse from the sages. OK, what did the zionists do? They went even beyond calculating the time of redemption from exile, no, they actually Worked to create the redemption by themselves. If the mental activity of getting out of exile is a curse, then the physical activity is a double or triple curse. The zionists put themselves in God’s place. No surprise there since generally they were secularists and atheists. Look at the current zionist state and how many Jews there are actively against religion. In some cases they went even beyond Sodom and Gemorah. You should know all that better than me. Dark principle roots usually produce poisonous fruits. The curse of the sages is above the head of those who calculate, and the curse of God is on those who actually transgress.
Ahmein, beautifully stated, thank you for taking the time to type this out
Please tell me what is the different between Torah and Talmud?
The talmud is the explanation of the torah (Hebrew Bible). Majority of jews do not believe the bible is a literal document. The torah scholars explain the torah(bible) has 4 levels of explanations.
This guy fails to compare the severity and extent of crimes against Jews committed by Christians relative to those committed by Muslims. Yes, Muslims did a lot of bad things to Jews, but it was sporadic and small scale, and the way they treated dhimmi was nothing compared to the way Christians treated Jews and Muslims living in Christendom. He also pretends like the 1948 war was unprovoked aggression against Zionists by Arabs (who also included Christians, not just Muslims). Well, Zionists never got permission from the local Arabs of Palestine to immigrate there en masse, that permission was given by the Ottoman government and expanded by the British government. And Zionists never got permission from their new neighbors to establish a Jewish supremacist ethnostate on land where Arabs were the majority (yes, even inside the initial borders of Israel). Zionists had been escalating terrorist attacks against Arabs for decades, and when they declared Israel to be an independent country in May 1948, they already had Plan Dalet ready to go for ethnic cleansing of Arabs. I call that illegal annexation of territory and an act of war. And this guy also completely leaves out the contextual information for why Arabs keep refusing two state solutions and attacking Israel. Go read about all the proposed agreements and find out why they said no. It’s because Israel presented totally unacceptable terms that hurt Palestinian refugees and violated the future sovereignty of the State of Palestine. And Israel has been committing constant crimes against Palestinians in Israel and Palestine for the past century. If you want to understand why the Arabs fight the Zionists, you have to learn about the problem from third party sources. Also, this guy totally stereotypes Muslims as terrorists and warmongers, ignoring all reasons why any of them are doing what they are doing, and the fact that Israelis are doing exactly the same things. Go read about all the things Israel has done to its neighbors and how it has helped America to do terrorism and worse crimes in the Middle East and Latin America. This isn’t happening at random. Likud, the ruling party of Israel, was founded by Menachem Begin, who was himself a leader of the terrorist militia Irgun. Read what Albert Einstein said about him in a letter to the New York Times in 1948, you’re in for a surprise. The Israeli far right takes inspiration from what the Hebrew Bible says about the Jews doing things to the Canaanites and Amalekites, and they combine that with European and American style ethnic supremacist nationalism and imperialism, to create a really toxic worldview. I don’t think those people represent all Jews, and if you ever want peace between Israel and its neighbors, the Israeli right wing coalition must be removed from power.
An interesting reference on the subject is Bostom's book The Legacy of Islamic Anti-Semitism.
It is an excellent intellectual resource.
What about "Sabetay T'zvi" ???
Rabbi Palvanov, whats your opinion on Rav Avraham ben Ha'Rambam claiming Sufism retained some lost aspects of the nevi'im or Jewish mysticism Jews in his region lost?
It's possible, especially considering that a lot of the early Muslim scholars and scribes were actually Jews! I spoke about it in the 'Judaism vs. Islam' video here: ua-cam.com/video/yBh_F5JzW1s/v-deo.html
“We have reformation although we don’t agree with reformation”that’s a wild statement and then say Muslim ima are stuck in the Middle Ages lol
Then he should read the older letters of rabbis from the golden era of the Jews. In any case, Jews lived better under Islamic rule than under Christians. not always but most of the time. The proof is that there would be no Jew today without Islam. but haters just hate.
Without lies, islam dies
Well,this episode is about the relations between Muslims and Jews,not Christians and Jews.
No lies detected
Excellent insights informative and educational ! More on these subjects ! Thank you ! The present war is nothing short of Yeshuot ! Just being led to the discoveries of tunnels and weapons and having them destroyed is in itself is a huge gift from G-D ! 🙌
🇮🇱Am Yisrael Chai 🇮🇱
I kmow your business and I wish you had time to write books about all these various topics you address in your lectures. Ive seen the ones you've written.
You can't justify occupation by telling false negatives. How about the Spain under Islamic rule that gave freedom to Jews.
As I mentioned in the video, Maimonides had to flee Islamic Spain because of intense persecution and oppression...
How can it be occupation when Jews have been living continuously in the Levant for over 3000 years? If you want to talk about apartheid, tell me what's being forced to pay 30% of your earnings just because of your religon, how about being barred from your most holy sights, how about having your testimony in court be worth less then the majority religious caste, everything that Palestinian activists accuse Israel for, was done by the arabs 2x as bad
@@john4chan127it’s simple.
>Someone lives in a house.
>Somebody comes and takes the force with force under threat of murder.
You rationalisation is a symptom of mental illness. To put it mildly, you are delusional.
Your reference is to people who
>are not here
>are not you
You imagine these non-existent people and project them onto yourself as if they are you
This is how you twist people who break into someone’s property and rob/pillage/murder the people who are currently there.
Please, seek help 🙏
Idk where did you get your information from but read history again
Re the discussion about 18 minutes in, this is one reason I find the Palestinians claims to be so ludicrous. They attacked. They lost. Finders Keepers losers weepers. That's the way it works everywhere all the time.
I wish I was a Jew, I could speak the language GOD spoke to PROPHET MOSES
But sadly, I wasn't and I can't, but I love your people with all my heart man
2. No one in all human history have been born like Moses, he is the one and only one who GOD himself spoke to him face to face
Props for mentioning West Papua.
The truth is that Muhammad plagiarized not just Judaism but Christianity mixed it with Arab moon god and their culture then made himself second only to God. Then started to conquer and spread out. He was the OG Jim Jones, Charles Manson and Heavens Gate cult. In fact I would say he's the most successful cult leader ever.
The first part of lecture is fine. But gradually you are shifting to ziomism. The question is why did you come to claim your mother land after 3000 years? You have no answer for that.
The other things you are talking is nothing but rubbish.
Please see my other video on the true history of Zionism here: ua-cam.com/video/OqyZUm05o7w/v-deo.html
Agree 💯
You are talking about pre Islamic world. Don't confuse us. As compared to western world.
There were enough more 'recent' muz pogroms in the 80's and 90's in Uzbekistan, Dagestan, Yemen, Algeria, Ethiopia... And most of them had nothing to do with the zionim 'excuse'
@@markkussusa Ethiopia? The Jewish Falasha live in the Christian regions and were persecuted by the Christians of the majority Christian country.
Literally talking about from Mohammed and on.
This is an excellent assessment of the treatment of Jews under Muslim rule.
I totally disagree with your take that Christianity which is based on Jesus's sacrifice on the CROSS is idolatrous. You are actually denying Jesus as the messiah. May God bring you to the light.
Yes, I am denying Jesus as the messiah. Please see 'Judaism vs. Christianity' here: ua-cam.com/video/Jgf7hBGqzJM/v-deo.html and also 'Who is Mashiach?' here: ua-cam.com/video/3rvL-sW5J04/v-deo.html
You're free to disagree. But I disagree with your statement. Jesus was a mascot created to blind people to the spiritual truths. Worshipping a man like he is God is idolatry. That is the problem with this world as it is today, worshipping humans like they are gods....
23:10 i wouldn't completely agree with this remark considering the Talmud was made around the same time as the first official manuscript of the New Testament in the Latin Vulgate. Judaism came first, i agree, but present Judaism has its differences as an offshoot to that branch as well, in that prayer itself is different. Albeit for one example that the Kippah, Tallith, and Tefillin were never worn during prayer in the Tanakh. So speaking from a Historical Context the two religions of Judaism and Christianity became official around the same time during 500 CE. Only for Islam to be official 100 years later when the Quran was made inspired by non-canonical scriptures from non-chalcedonian Christian's and Jews that did not follow Oral Torah who moved to Arabia.
So its up to on what you personally believe. Abrahamic Religions are a lot more nuanced then people ought them to be. Jews believe Oral Torah is the Word of God, Christians believe its Jesus, Muslims believe its the Quran. At the end of the day its all interpretation, thats below God himself. I do respect Judaism for being more ambiguous compared to the two however. God Bless.
When people talk about jewish-muslim history being positive they mostly refer to the relations with the Ottomans, which unless I missed it, is completely skipped. This shouldve been titled Jewish-Arab history
Barbary Pirates and slave trade across the Sahara, East Africa and so on.
Hey bro, your talk was truly captivating. The historical narrative you shared about the pre-Israel era and the oppression faced by Jewish people under Muslim rule resonated with me. It's plausible that the tribal warlike culture of Arab society persisted post-Islamization. I also observe that while other religions have evolved, Islam has remained relatively stagnant. Reform seems necessary. However, I respectfully disagree with your confusion about why some, including many non-Muslims, harbor animosity towards Jews. Perhaps the idealized portrayal of Jews being universally fair isn't always accurate. It's essential to examine how Jews in power treated followers of the Christ during that era. Though it might seem controversial, the deeply ingrained stereotype of Jews as financially shrewd and unapologetically biased towards their own kind is sure to fuel escalating hostility over time by non Jews. Many of the facts you presented about Israel's attempts to negotiate fair deals with Palestinians are debatable. Nevertheless, I value your explanation, and I acknowledge the atrocities against Jews throughout history. As an agnostic (ex-Muslim) who doesn't adhere to organized religion, I refrain from commenting on specific faiths. I believe that all living beings strive to survive, and death serves as the great equalizer. If I were to adopt a belief system, I might consider making "game theory" my religion and follow its principles.
Appreciate the feedback, thank you. If you're interested, I spoke more about Jewish-Christian relations here: ua-cam.com/video/Jgf7hBGqzJM/v-deo.html and Jewish-Muslim relations here: ua-cam.com/video/yBh_F5JzW1s/v-deo.html
Wasn't it ten wise Jewish elders who penned the Quaran?
Spoke about that possibility here: ua-cam.com/video/yBh_F5JzW1s/v-deo.html
@EfraimPalvanov Thanks for the link and thank you for making your videos.
Everything is going to work out just as God intends it to. We were all blessed with the blessing of free will.
As for me, I am gaining back the spiritual strength that God blessed me with.
May God bless you, your family, and all of the people of Israel, always.
Check out Dr. David Wasserstein's "So, what did the Muslims do for the Jews?" for a broader perspective.
Ilan Pappe and Norman Finkelstein would like a word…
First o e I do t k ow who it is, second one is a psychopath who didn't have ancestors living unde islam. He used his parents being holocaust survivors to spew his hatred of Jews and Israel. He is a mamzer
Islam has no reform and yet the Quran has literally been amended severally through abrogation. Strange religion. I'm with you hoping for success amongst the reformers.
In the battle of Khandag ( trench) -
Bani Q. were prophet allies, but they betrayed him and planed a war with Meccan’s ( pagans ).
Meccan started attacking muslim homes in Medina, women and children to open a route for BaniQ. Because of the bad weather they retreated.
Prophet told BaniQ. to retreat, but they didn’t listen and insisted for the war. The battle started, and many were killed and the rest were captured and they were exiled. They eventually went to Khybar.
A video, from 2024, shows people dressed in Jewish garb discussing the killing of non-jewish "slaves" and what penalties the master should suffer if the "slave" dies before 24 hours passes : youtube video title "Daf Yomi Bava Kama Daf 90 by R’ Eli Stefansky" forward to 6:20. Then they discuss other laws regarding handling their "slaves".
And?
They became slaves for kidnapping people
The miracle of jew is the dollar bill Uncle Sam...
On the other hand, we have Maimonides' son, Avraham who incporprated the islamic prayer postures in Judaism, the entirety of Kalam philosophy. Always good to remember that both zionism and antisemitism are EUROPEAN phenomena. In that sense, zionism has European antisemitism internalized and incorporated in modern day, Herzlian zionism. And also, Rambam wrote other letters. Let it be a source of knowledge to you. Go forth and learn
1900-1948
1. 1901-1902: 3rd Cairo massacre, Ottoman Egypt
2. 1901-1907: 4th Alexandria massacres, Ottoman Egypt
3. 1903: 1st Port Said massacres, Ottoman Egypt
4. 1903-1940: Pogroms of Taza and Settat, Morocco
5. 1904: massacre of Jews in Yemen
6. 1907: Casablanca, pogrom, Morocco
7. 1908: 2nd Port Said massacre, Ottoman Egypt
8. 1909: comment from the British vice-consul of Mosul: “The attitude of Muslims towards Christians and Jews is that of a master towards his slaves.”
9. 1910: blood libel of Shiraz
10. 1911: Shiraz pogrom
11. 1912: 4th Fez, Pogrom, Morocco
12. 1914: expulsion of Jews from Palestine old enough to bear arms by the Ottomans
13. 1917: Jewish Inquisition of Baghdadi, Ottoman Empire
14. 1918-1948: adoption of a law prohibiting the raising of a Jewish orphan, Yemen
15. 1920: Irbid massacres: British mandate in Palestine
16. 1920-1930: Arab riots, British Mandate Palestine
17. 1921: 1st Jaffa riots, British Mandate Palestine
18. 1922: Massacres of Djerba, Tunisia
19. 1922: law of forced conversion of orphans in Yemen, concerning Jews including as adults
20. 1927: 60 Jews killed by Arabs in the Mellah of Casablanca Morocco
21. 1928: Massacres of Ikhwan, in Egypt and under British mandate in Palestine.
22. 1928: Jewish orphans sold into slavery and forced to convert to Islam by the Muslim Brotherhood, Yemen
23. 1929: anti-Jewish riots, British mandate: in August 1929, the Jews demanded the construction of the Western Wall; pogroms in Jerusalem, Hebron, Safed. To stop the violence, the British reject this request
24. 1929: 3rd Hebron Pogrom under British Mandate Palestine.
25. 1929 3e pogrom de Safed, mandate britannique Palestine.
26. 1933: 2nd Jaffa riots, British mandate in Palestine.
27. 1934: Anti-Jewish pogrom in Constantine Algeria. 200 Jewish stores were raided, the total material damage was estimated at more than 150 million francs. It also sent a quarter of Constantine’s Jewish population into poverty.
28. 1934: Pogroms in Thrace, Türkiye
29. 1934: 1st massacres in Farhud, Iraq
30. 1936: 3rd Jaffa riots, British Mandate Palestine
31. 1936: 2e massacre of Farhud, Irak
32. 1938: boycott of Jews in Egypt
33. 1939: discovery of 3 bombs in synagogues in Cairo
34. 1941 : 3e massacre de Farhud, Iraq
35. 1941: persecution of Jews in Libya
36. 1941: massacre of Jews in Baghdad, with the support of the authorities: approx. 170 dead
37. 1942: collaboration of the mufti with the Nazis. Plays a role in the final solution
38. 1942: Struma disaster, Türkiye
39. 1942: Nile Delta pogroms, Egypt
40. 1938-1945: Arab collaboration with the Nazis
41. 1942: discriminatory tax law of Varlik Vergisi in Turkey against Jews and Christians
42. 1942: looting of Jewish property in Benghazi and deportation to the desert
43. 1944: attack on the Jewish quarter of Damascus
44. 1945: anti-Jewish and anti-Christian riots in Egypt; churches and synagogues destroyed
45. 1945: 4th Cairo massacre, Egypt
46. 1945: Pogrom of Tripoli, Libya
47. 1947: segregation measures against Jews in Egypt
48. 1947: pogrom in Libya; approx. 130 dead
49. 1947 : Pogroms d’Aden au Yemen
50. 1947: 3rd pogrom d’Alep, Syrie
51. 1948: “emptying” of the Jewish quarter of Damascus, Syria
1800-1899
1. 1800: new decree adopted in Yemen, prohibiting Jews from wearing new or good clothes. Jews were forbidden to ride mules or donkeys, and were sometimes rounded up for long, naked marches through the Roob al Khali desert.
2. 1805: 1st pogrom in Ottoman Algeria against the Jews of Algiers after a famine. Frenchconsul Dubois-Thainville saves 200 Jews by sheltering them in his consulate.
3. 1805: exile of Jews from Algiers to Tunis and Livorno
4. 1805, the leader of the Jewish Nation of Algiers, Naphthalie Busnach, is killed while riots ravage the neighborhoods.
5. 1806: expulsion by fatwa of the Jews of Sali in Morocco
6. 1806: ban on Moroccan Jews wearing Western clothing
7. 1806: the janissaries of the dey of Algiers massacre and pillage in the Jewish quarter
8. 1807: expulsion of Jews from Tetouan
9. 1808: 1st massacres in the Mellah ghetto, North Africa
10. 1815, the chief rabbi of Algiers, Isaac Aboulker, is beheaded during a riot.
11. 1815: the Jews of Algiers are forced to fight against an invasion of locusts
12. 1815: 2nd pogrom of Algiers, Ottoman Algeria
13. 1816: in Algeria, ban on carrying weapons for Jews and Christians
14. 1820: Massacres of Sahalu Lobiant, Ottoman Syria
15. 1828 : pogrom de Baghdad, Iraq ottoman
16. 1830: 3rd pogrom of Algeria, Ottoman Algeria
17. 1830: start of the persecution of Jews in Persia, caused by the Russian advance in the Caucasus
18. 1830: ethnic cleansing of Jews in Tabriz, Iran
19. 1834: 2nd pogrom of Hebron, Ottoman Palestine
20. 1834 : Pogrom de Safed, Palestine ottomane
21. 1838: Druze attack in Safed, Ottoman Palestine
22. 1839: Massacre of the Mashadi Jews, Iran
23. 1839: forced conversion of surviving Jews from Mashadi
24. 1839: campaign of forced conversions of Iranian Jews
25. 1840: persecution of the Jews of Damascus; ritual murder case
26. 1840: forced conversion of the Jews of Mashadi
27. 1841: massive murders of Jews in Morocco; the sultan is obliged to consider the Jews as his personal property, which helps to protect them
28. 1840: Damascus, ritual murders (French Muslims and Christians kidnapped, tortured and killed Jewish children for entertainment), Ottoman Syria
29. 1844: 1st Cairo massacre, Ottoman Egypt
30. 1847: Dayr al-Qamar Pogrom, Liban ottoman
31. 1847: ethnic cleansing of Jews in Jerusalem, Ottoman Palestine
32. 1848: 1st pogrom of Damascus, Syria
33. 1848: total disappearance of the Jews of Mashhad
34. 1850: 1st pogrom of Aleppo, Ottoman Syria
35. 1854: anti-Jewish pogrom in Demnate, Morocco
36. 1857: beheading in Tunis of the Jewish coachman Batou Sfez, accused of blasphemy, while he was drunk
37. 1860: 2nd pogrom of Damascus, Ottoman Syria
38. 1862: 1st pogrom of Beirut, Ottoman Lebanon
39. 1866 : pogrom at Kuzguncuk, Turquie Ottomane
40. 1867: Barfurush massacre, Ottoman Türkiye
41. 1868: Eyub Pogrom, Ottoman Türkiye
42. 1869: Massacre of Tunis, Ottoman Tunisia
43. 1869: Massacre of Sfax, Ottoman Tunisia
44. 1864-1880: Marrakech massacre, Morocco
45. 1870: 2nd Alexandria massacres, Ottoman Egypt
46. 1870: 1st pogrom in Istanbul, Ottoman Türkiye
47. 1871: 1st Damanhur massacres, Ottoman Egypt
48. 1872: Massacres in Edirne, Ottoman Türkiye
49. 1872: 1st pogrom of Izmir, Ottoman Türkiye
50. 1873: 2nd massacre of Damanhur, Ottoman Egypt
51. 1874: 2nd pogrom of Izmir, Ottoman Türkiye
52. 1874: 2nd pogrom of Istanbul, Ottoman Türkiye
53. 1874: 2nd pogrom of Beirut, Ottoman Lebanon
54. 1875: 2 pogroms in Aleppo, Ottoman Syria
55. 1875: Massacre on the island of Djerba, Ottoman Tunisia
56. 1877 : 3e massacre de Damanhur, Egypte ottomane
57. 1877: Pogrom of Mansura, Ottoman Egypt
58. 1882: Massacre of Homs, Ottoman Syria
59. 1882: 3rd massacre of Alexandria, Ottoman Egypt
60. 1889: after the funeral of a rabbi, deemed too discreet, the Jewish cemetery of Baghdad was confiscated
61. 1889: looting of the Jewish quarter of Baghdad
62. 1890: 2nd Cairo massacre, Ottoman Egypt
63. 1890, 3e pogrom de Damas, Syrie ottomane
64. 1891: 4th massacre of Damanahur, Ottoman Egypt
65. 1897: murders in Tripoli, Ottoman Libya
66. 1890: Massacres of Tunis, Ottoman Tunisia
1700-1799
1. 1700: massacre of Jews in Yemen
2. 1747 : Massacres de Mashhad, Iran
3. 1758: executions of a Jew and an Armenian in Constantinople for violation of the legislation on the clothing of infidels
4. 1770: expulsion of Jews from Jeddah in Arabia
5. 1785 : Tripoli Porom, Libya ottomane
6. 1790-92: Pogrom of Tetouan. Morocco (Jews of Tetouan undressed and lined up)
7. 1790: destruction of most of the Jewish communities in Morocco
1600-1699
1. 1604: start of a period of famine, violence and forced conversions of the Jewish population of Fez: 2000 conversions in 2 years
2. 1608: persecution for two years of the Jews of Taroudat by the Berbers
3. 1622: forced conversion of the Jews of Persia
4. 1630-1700: Yemenite Jews were considered “impure” and therefore forbidden to touch a Muslim or a Muslim’s food. They were obliged to humble themselves before a Muslim, walk on the left side and greet him first. They could not build houses taller than those of a Muslim or ride a camel or horse, and when riding a mule or donkey, they had to sit on the side. When entering the Muslim quarter, a Jew had to take off his shoes and walk barefoot. If attacked with stones or fists by Muslim youths, a Jew was not allowed to defend himself.
5. 1650: Jews from Tunisia are deported to special neighborhoods called “hara”
6. 1650: forced conversion of the Jews of Persia, under Shah Abbas II
7. 1656: Jews expelled from Isfahan in Iran
8. 1660: 2 pogroms in Safed and Tiberias, Ottoman Palestine
9. 1670: Expulsion of Mawza, Yemen
10. 1676: expulsion of Jews from Sanaa in Yemen
11. 1678: forced conversion of Jews in Yemen
12. 1679-1680: Sanaa massacres, Yemen
@@MehWhatever99 "Maimonides' son, Avraham incporprated the islamic prayer postures in Judaism".
I think this was the question/statement that needed addressing. Do you agree with it?
@@brianc4594 my point was that antisemitism was never a uniquely European phenomena.
2000 jews killed in the course of the siege and sacking of Cordoba by berber muslims in 1011 AD. 6000 jews killed and their women made slaves in 1033 in Fez (Morocco). 4000 jews killed in 1066 by a muslim mob in Grenada.
Anti-jewish progrom happened in Morocco in 1148 CE. Abd al-Mumin ... the leader of the Almohads after the death of Muhammad Ibn Tumart the Mahdi ... captured Tlemcen [in the Maghreb] and killed all those who were in it, including the Jews, except those who embraced Islam. ... [In Sijilmasa] One hundred and fifty persons were killed for clinging to their [Jewish] faith. ... One hundred thousand persons were killed in Fez on that occasion, and 120,000 in Marrakesh. The Jews in all [Maghreb] localities [conquered] ... groaned under the heavy yoke of the Almohads; many had been killed, many others converted; none were able to appear in public as Jews.[21]
The video very obviously states that antijudaism and 'antijewishism' which is meant by antisemitism is deeply rooted in the islamic world.
So when talk about polygamy being allowed in the past but not anymore, he's admitting that they changed parts of their religion. If its from God, no human has the right to change it.
7:00 Dhimmi description is tremendously deceptive.
Including the Baghdad Decree is venomous. Did the Rambam have to wear all that? How come? Did the Rambam ever say something about Islam that was taken wrong by Both Muslims and Jews?
Jew who is falower of Torah not Talmoth?
Start speaking the truth and you’ll start seeing the demons at work in real time 😉
Islam is the one with demons
In The Matrix, Zion is the last human city, and The Nebuchadnezzar is Morpheus's ship defending it. Thoughts?
Allows for conflicting interpretations :)
@toobsock Yes, there is a lot of Jewish symbolism in The Matrix, as I explored in depth in 'The Matrix & Judaism' video here: ua-cam.com/video/iezjFyO_dHA/v-deo.htmlsi=5SfdMt78AyD-31wB
You may be correct about some of the things you spoke about but you will need to provide proof. Oct 7 was not the beginning of the issue. There is a very long history behind all this. You say Arafat never wanted to agree to anything and at times walked out of meetings? Could it be because what was being offered was unfair, could it be because he knew israel would never comply with whatever was agreed and didn't Yitzak Rabin want to make peace and was killed? Just like Arafat was poisoned. You also say muslims force others to convert ? As a revert muslim (previously catholic) I was never forced to convert to Islam. It is incorrect. If it was ever done in the past it was not in accordance with Islamic law. No one can force another to become a Muslim. Also we do not worship the stone in Mecca. We do not worship objects or idols. Another point, IF you claim that in 1948 jews returned to the promised land then you justify that taking it by displacing all who lived there and even killing to have it was the correct thing to do? And even worst doing it after the terrible and barbaric holocaust? Sorry but I have a problem believing the almighty would allow such an injustice. Doesn't your holy book say you must wait for the arrival of the messiah to establish in any land? Whatever happened to that order? We can debate for hours about who's right or wrong depending on which side you are on. Only the almighty knows and one day we will all be informed
Listen to yourself, just because you were not forced to convert doesn't mean others were not. No the book doesn't say they have to wait for the messiah to become a nation. Also if you don't worship the stone then why do you go around it and kiss the thing that looks like woman's organ?. Without lies islam dies
The truth is Zionism is not brotherhood among mankind. The way forward is mutual respect and that cannot happen until Zionism is removed. L'chaim Alhamdulillah.
Hertzl didn’t want to add religion to his movement, but then he didn’t have support needed for the movement. They ended up misusing or getting profit from the religion.
who said the following...?
"the world will never enjoy another moment of peace and tranquility ever again until and unless islam is ended..."
answer... me... truth.out...
I appreciate your history lesson however, I would like to make a couple of minor corrections;
The Romans were not Christians, they were pagans who were wearing the name of Christ/Messiah in order to unite their warring Kingdom.
The Roman Catholics are not Christians. They believe in Christ/Messiah, just as the Muslims do, but they do not follow Christ/Messiah. A Christian follows the teachings of Christ. Muslims follow the teachings of Muhammad. Catholics follow the teachings of the papacy, not Christ/Messiah.
So when the Romans sent the crusaders to take over the holy land and attack the Muslims and the Jews, they were doing it in the name of Christ/Messiah but they weren't doing it at the direction of Christ/Messiah because Christ/Messiah told his apostles to do just the opposite!
Jesus told his apostles to go and teach and baptize in the name of the FATHER, Son and holy spirit, but if anyone rejected that teaching, they were to knock the dust from their shoes and move on! The Messiah never instructed his apostles to force, tax, torture, or burn at the stake, anyone who rejected the message! Jesus was a Jew, he operated on Jewish principles.
Jesus warned that there would be many who would come in his name, pretending to be Christian/Messianic, when they were not! The Roman Catholic Church is the foremost of these masquerading entities who pretend to be sheep but are really wolves in sheep's clothing!
No I'm not talking about the average Catholic here. The average Catholic is just as fooled as everyone else by the tricks of the Roman Catholic papacy. I'm talking about the Roman Catholic papacy and clergy who knowingly and intentionally masquerades as Christ (the vicar of Christ), even claiming to be God himself on Earth, while at the same time changing God's laws! Even as recently as this year, Pope Francis has changed yet another one of the Ten Commandments!
The Roman Catholic Church is the counterfeit Christian Church. It is the counterfeit Jewish temple! Just examine closely the garb and the temple layout of the Vatican! They have completely appropriated the Hebrew Temple and levitical priesthood!
This is the effort of the enemy Satan to obscure the name of the true god, and the name of his Messiah,and to prevent the message of the good news of the Kingdom from getting through! And yet, in spite of every effort of the Roman Catholic church, the good news has gotten through!
Now that the message of the Kingdom has spread all the way around the globe, the fullness of time has come for the choose to retake their position as Kings and priests and help to correct the misunderstandings that the Roman Catholic papacy has fostered throughout history and their false representation of the Christ/Messiah.
According to the Bible codes if I recall correctly hidden in the verse of wood and stone are the words Jesus/Yeshua and Mecca,
I’m not a religious man I was raised in the Anglican Church. I’ve been blessed to meet many people from many different backgrounds I don’t question another person beliefs if we are all children of god can we not just accept that we all have a equal right to practice our beliefs.
Including child marriage and polygamy?
Also Ishmael died righteous, as opposed to Essav who didn't. We can't just ignore this tradition. The deification of a man is considered idolatry. It doesn't abide by Noahide laws. Rome too brought good things with her in her time. It doesn't change the fundamentals. As jews, we shouldn't play anybody else's game but God's.
There is a lot of important info here but context is also important.
The 20th century was the worst in history for Jewish/Muslim relations and the best in history for Jewish/Christian relations and nevertheless millions of Jews were killed by Christians in the 20th century and thousands by Muslims. There is simply no comparison. Christians have historically been exponentially worse to Jews than Muslims even though it is true that there have been many difficult periods under Islam.
Why not it's one land both Israel and Palestinians live together .
If you noticed he never references his opinion of what dhimmi means to historians, its just heresay and no actual historical record of oppression
There is plenty of information on what being a Dhimmie meant. Pretending it was something nice is ridiculous! The Pact of Umar tells some of what being a Dhimmie was.
@shainazion4073
Heres the Pact of Umar RA
"In the name of God, the Merciful, the Compassionate. This is the assurance of safety which the servant of God, ʿUmar, the Commander of the Faithful, has given to the people of Jerusalem. He has given them an assurance of safety for themselves, for their property, their churches, their crosses, the sick and healthy of the city and for all the rituals which belong to their religion. Their churches will not be inhabited by Muslims and will not be destroyed. Neither they, nor the land on which they stand, nor their cross, nor their property will be damaged. They will not be forcibly converted. And [as per the Christians’ request] Jews will not live in the same areas as them.
The people of Jerusalem must pay the taxes like the people of other cities and must expel the Byzantines and the robbers. Those of the people of Jerusalem who want to leave with the Byzantines, take their property and abandon their churches and crosses will be safe until they reach their place of refuge. The villagers [who had taken refuge in the city at the time of the conquest] may remain in the city if they wish but must pay taxes like the citizens. Those who wish may go with the Byzantines and those who wish may return to their families. Nothing is to be taken from them before their harvest is reaped.
If they pay their taxes according to their obligations, then the conditions laid out in this letter are under the covenant of God, are the responsibility of His Prophet, of the caliphs and of the faithful"
Witnessed by: Khālid b. Walīd; ʿAmr b. al-ʿĀs; ʿAbd al-Rahmān b. al-ʿAwf; Muʿāwiya b. Abī Sufyān.
The ruling christians told Umar RA ( the disciple and companion of Prophet Muhammad (saw) and also his father in law) that they had expelled and banish jews in the land. As Umar RA was bringing them back, they worried that jews would still be annoyed at them so told Umar RA to keep jews in another area from them, so they are not neighbours. So Umar RA agreed and included it in his Pact.
Read the above, how is it unjust in anyway???
@shainazion4073
Heres the Pact of Umar RA, how is it unjust in anyway
In the name of God, the Merciful, the Compassionate. This is the assurance of safety which the servant of God, ʿUmar, the Commander of the Faithful, has given to the people of Jerusalem. He has given them an assurance of safety for themselves, for their property, their churches, their crosses, the sick and healthy of the city and for all the rituals which belong to their religion. Their churches will not be inhabited by Muslims and will not be destroyed. Neither they, nor the land on which they stand, nor their cross, nor their property will be damaged. They will not be forcibly converted. And [as per the Christians’ request] Jews will not live in the same areas as them.
The people of Jerusalem must pay the taxes like the people of other cities and must expel the Byzantines and the robbers. Those of the people of Jerusalem who want to leave with the Byzantines, take their property and abandon their churches and crosses will be safe until they reach their place of refuge. The villagers [who had taken refuge in the city at the time of the conquest] may remain in the city if they wish but must pay taxes like the citizens. Those who wish may go with the Byzantines and those who wish may return to their families. Nothing is to be taken from them before their harvest is reaped.
If they pay their taxes according to their obligations, then the conditions laid out in this letter are under the covenant of God, are the responsibility of His Prophet, of the caliphs and of the faithful.
Witnessed by: Khālid b. Walīd; ʿAmr b. al-ʿĀs; ʿAbd al-Rahmān b. al-ʿAwf; Muʿāwiya b. Abī Sufyān.
@shainazion4073
For some reason the Pact of umar comment was deleted.
The Pact of Umar was a wonderful Pact. You search up Umar RA story coming to Jerusalem, its an amazing story.
@@shainazion4073
The Movie the Message
ua-cam.com/video/J-F7Cz_ZMEo/v-deo.htmlsi=rs6tN8aLbASbP4LL
41:00 It was only banned for Ashkenazim though. Sephardim had polygamy well into the last century, albeit uncommon (as uncommon as in most muslim countries)
Saladin was the ruler how brought back the Hebrew language because it a from of Arabic. Saladin was pretty wise ruler.
Brother, you really need to educate yourself about this history
I have always known that every peiceful time in a "good" country for jews is just a marage that will disappear in time. It is hard to feel it today with so many freedoms in galus but we need to remember that we are still in galus even when we are in zion.
All these religion content creators pretend to speak for god cause it makes them feel special. This guy is a "rabbi" or iman or priest or whatever instant loss of credibility.
so then who is meshech...?