Julia Loffe is brilliant. I could listen to her for hours. Since Russia has declared war on Urkraine I have sought out her voice whereever I can find it.
Same here! Her insight into Russian history and what it has done to its people and their leadership is magnificent. Every interview is another well of further understanding.
I really resent the way Bret Stephens seems to automatically interpret any criticism of Israel as being fundamentally antisemitic - we have to be able to rationally discuss the ongoing occupation and the atrocities committed in this area of the world without people sabotaging the discussion using this knock-out argument!
@@nooneofconsequence1057 you are crazy. So just because the Arabs didn’t suffer like the Jews in concentration camps, they should let you colonize their lands??? Wtf logic is this ?
@@nooneofconsequence1057 Saying that imploring Israeli's to stop stealing other people's land, is the same as imploring Americans to stop staging coups in Latin America. Both statements are merited, and neither says absolutely anything about religious affiliation. All the other stuff you shotgunned in there is just white noise. The op is dead right, this equivocation was cheap and disingenuous. It's not a bit different from accusing someone of not being a patriot if they don't support Donald Trump, or any other politician, for that matter.
@@Brainbaskit guess I am confused. If a country has borders, and people lob stuff at you from outside, you can lob back, right? If they trespass to do harm, you can end them, right? Perhaps I misunderstood property rights, and self defense?
Why were the two Israeli soldiers in Ramallah to begin with? Why does Brett try to redirect a discussion ostensibly about Europe to a discussion about anti-Semitism?
Bret Stephens manages to blame Angela Merkel for Ukraine, Brexit, and Trump, all in one sentence. Here's someone who wants to be perceived as an intellectual but - in my opinion - doesn't know what he's talking about. Interesting to watch this three years later and to see them disproved regarding Europe's solidarity regarding Ukraine.
Nice to see all these imperialist war hawks in complete agreement. And yes, in reading B. Stephens columns in the NYT times all these years he is wrong or obviously a featherweight intellectually.
This whole "discussion" isn't about Europe at all, is it. It's completely permeated by one unvoiced question, namely: "will there be pogroms soon?" So much impotent fear and loathing.
@nothing Sure he knows, hes a Russian. And me too. Look - its about culture. Jews are naturally support liberal agenda - Russians coined a special term "ethnic liberalism". Anyway, James Kirpichnick so disgusting - will gladly punch his face no matter he Jew or not.
It's always a little strange to hear people who strongly identify with a particular group (in this case, Judaism) when they turn their noses up when other people who want to identify with a specific group and also want to protect that heritage..... You can't have it both ways people....... Unless you think your heritage is the only heritage of value???
They do. I won’t say all Jews but the zionists They literally think they’re better than everyone else that’s why they call themselves “the chosen ones.”
Oh yeah; Europe has never been more stable. No rise of nationalism; no fraying of relations; and best of all peace and harmony with Russia-not even a war in ukraine
This came on my auto-play, and I didn't know it was from five years ago at first. I'd like to see these people do a reaction video of this, now that five years have passed. Some points are a little off, but most is spot-on , especially Putin. How does this have only 425 likes as of 13-Feb-2023?
@@nooneofconsequence1057 For me jews always seem to form this closed-off society inside oursociety, wich is a very toxic thing for me. In Antwerp we have a jewish juwelery neighbourhood, the people there don't speak dutch, even living here for long times. They only go to jewish schools, stores, they only do business with jews. If you go inside their stores, you clearly feel not welcome. If you really care so much about anti semitsm its time to integrate an communicate outside this closed off society.
If I could be persuaded that these people were as brilliant as they seem to think they are instead of merely educated more than many, I would think of them as smart instead of smug. They speak as if they are quite pleased with themselves to have been invited to sit on the dais and all the better than those in the audience and certainly the betters of those of us in the fly over states. It's as if they either think they understand those whom they disparage such that they are justified in a summary dismissal or the hoi polloi aren't worth the effort to genuinely understand let alone get to know.
OMG… how did this woman get to ask such a incredible panel such … never a question but statements.. how this three just talked and shared there wisdom… thank you for getting through her… to the woman … keep your questions direct and to the point and quit trying to make yourself smart… that’s what your doing and it’s coming from a place of insecurity. Work on your knowledge and history. Has to the group… one of the most honest conversations with three intelligent thoughtful beings… Julia is a rock star with her wisdom… ❤️
Yes, maybe there needs to be a crusade to spread Christianity. If only we allowed Christianity to take root and have churches in every city and town. If only there were Christian TV stations and radio programs and music. If only young children were given over to the hands-on care of priests. What could go wrong?
You'll notice that most people who argue through name-calling aren't actually saying much at all. Please leave your vitriol in your own echo chambers and actually bring up points that you disagree with. Preferably also with why.
We disagree with Jewish control of our banks, media and politicians, and their sick plan to turn Europe into a third world hellhole. Why? Because we believe Europeans have a right to exist.
I'm curious if you've ever been in a third-world region. The idea of Europe becoming third-world (developing country with lower HDI) is, to my understanding, fairly implausible unless huge natural disasters or global war were to break out. Current HDI in Europe (lowest HDI) is around .700 vs. True third-world nations, where HDI is anywhere from .350-.500. It's a pretty huge distance. Third World Countries have little to no infrastructure, hugely lacking social resources (roads, schools, hospitals), and extremely week connections to the global marketplace. Do you see these things in Europe? Also, where is evidence of Jewish control of your banks, media and politicians? Who are these shadowy puppet masters? I hear about this from people, but there never seems to be any identity to the conspiracy. Yes, Europeans have a right to exist. Who is trying to dissent with that point? All liberal speakers say is that all people have a right to exist.
@@christianhuang519 I could literally post these all day. It's endless. ua-cam.com/video/-OmtHeyCMQU/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/oTIT7j4MsM0/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/Y1zChJHqIkk/v-deo.html The group you're referring to is 2% of the population yet more than 30% of its billionaires. Since every ethnic group has biases, misconceptions, and prejudices specific to it, if this particular group had them regarding people who aren't in their ethnic group, that would suddenly become politically relevant if they have this much disproportionate wealth and power, now wouldn't it? forward.com/schmooze/131574/jews-dominate-forbes-rich-list/ www.unz.com/runz/the-myth-of-american-meritocracy/ Literally, on this very website, comments which include combinations of words used to explain well known stats related to this issue are automatically deleted because the ADL has an office in Silicon Valley devoted to pressuring social media companies into censoring speech they disapprove of. Gee, what happens if these people have misconcpetions and prejudices about people who aren't in their group? And if they didn't have these misconceptions, that would make them unique and unlike every other ethnic group on the planet, so which is it? Are they just like everybody else or are they magical and special? www.adl.org/news/press-releases/adl-statement-on-youtube-policy-changes-to-reduce-extremist-content I could sit here and post stuff like this all day. The only reason I have to is because you pay no attention whatsoever. It's actually embarrassing for somebody to still be confused about this issue in 2020, or even in 2018 when you posted this comment, to be honest.
@@juliusebola9389 propaganda at its worst. Let’s talk about how the majority of SCOTUS is Catholic - oh no! The Pope is in control! That 30% of billionaires are Jewish (if even true), is similarly meaningless. Your ‘point’ sounds like as much jealousy as mere hatred. In fact, your ‘conclusions’ are the result of preconceived hatred’s. Look up how many medical doctors and PhDs are Jewish versus their population %. What conclusion might you come to then? Good luck wallowing in the usual sorry anger and vituperativeness.
1:01:26 A nice summary of the neoconservative view of why we should have (at least some elements of) a neoconservative foreign policy. If the US or EU leave a power vacuum, bad guys will swoop in and it will lead to greater problems for the US down the road. Time will tell how the EU/US's abandoning Ukraine (by failing in their commitments to the Budapest Memorandum) will lead to greater problems down the road.
27:55 Even Kant though that Hobbesian institutions were necessary for perpetual peace, since most people in fact do not follow the moral law. Implementation of perpetual peace cannot ignore empirical facts even if its normative foundations are purified of anything empirical.
liberal politics/financial partnerships joining control is a fascist investor's favorite dream come true. using socially narrated debt investments with foreign partnership/shared control is the favored way to accomplish. While Europe was going Soft Power (accepting investments from the wrong funding streams as "partnerships," not investments), those investment partnerships were taking over. It's become a disastrous mess for the whole world. The frightening issue is: these young people only studied half histories and then because of attributed the wrong controlling powers to both their heroes and villains. ie - Hitler to Stalin to all of the others were liberals upfront - promising fields of milk and honey. They became draconian despots when the "bill" came due. (each financed by the wrong money to ever allow anything good to actually be produced) If their own version of politics (cause and effect) ever won, all they'd need do is look into their mirrors to understand how evil recruits helpers to unravel the world. (and I don't mean that unkind.)
I disagree with Brett's premise when he poses that saying Israelis are great people but they need to curb THEIR greed is a veiled antisemitic statement & parallel to saying-- Jews are a great people but need to curb THEIR greed for money. So, we cannot say the Russians are great people but they have to curb their greed for other people's land. We can say it & we must say it. It is NOT anti anything but is just a FACT. The occupied land by the Israelis that belongs to Palestine-- which was agreed upon by BOTH parties as belonging to Palestine-- is only acknowledged as a part of Israel by one country and that is the United States. WHY? The United States needs and uses Israel, selling billions of dollars of weapons to Israel who in a quid pro quo is never criticised for its actions even when they qualify as crimes against humanity. Since the Ukrainian Invasion, I've often thought of the situation in Palestine and Israel. IN essence Israel says Palestine is NOT a land; it's ours. And Palestine says Israel is NOT a land; it is ours til Britain gifted it to the Jews following WWll. Which is TRUE? Can another country give a land and its people away? The moral answer is NO. Palestine is a land that existed in pre-Christian times and was called Palestine by the Greeks; Ergo the land and the PEOPLE have existed as Palestine for 2 milleniums. Many people conquered it-- the Greeks the Romans the Ottomans excetera --but it was always called Palestine by The World At Large. In contrast, Israel as a land acknowledged by the world by that name is a country that was given by Britain to the Jews in 1949 following World War II and it was carved from the 2000 yr old land & PEOPLE called 🇵🇸. So there was NO land called Israel by the world at large til recently but there was a land called Palestine beginning 2000 years ago and continuing until 1948. In a similar sense, there was a land called Ukraine over 2,000 years ago and there was NO land called Russia because Moscow did NOT even exist and when it finally did, it was a small village to the north. I could go on but I'll let this comparison -- which tho not identical is similar in that a more powerful nation gaslights the existence of another weaker nation-- incubate in ones mind. I needed to correct Mister Brett Stephen , whose ancesters changed THEIR last name at some point from a Jewish name to a neutered name--but did not change his paranoia which led to this false equivalency--a logical fallacy which invalidates his premise and puts into doubt all that follows. Julia also a Jew is more clear headed and does NOT fall into the same quagmire of a premise based on a logical fallacy.
Geopolitics includes Financial, Religion, Medical, Food, Energy etc - You must remain objective - All of these people bring in Their Political Truths and Personal Truths which "Muddy the Waters" Their is no right or wrong in Geo politics, there just is - Much of what happens in the World has to do with Cycles, either bottoming or Topping - Many of them are long term, some are shorter term - Some are even Universal - Too have an Objective View, you must understand where we are in some of the more important cycles
James Kirchick ,when you pick on Hungary, why don't you look at it in historical perspective like being abused during the Roman Empire, 150 years of occupation by the Ottoman Empire, the Habsburg Empire sending always Hungarian peasants on the front line and the fact that the Germans put the highest pressure on Hungarians to surrender Jews. Fear of authorities penetrated ordinary Hungarians for a thousand years of continuous occupation by a foreign great power...don't blame the ordinary citizen who is collaborating with occupying power because the moment the Germans left, they had to cooperate with Soviet power, let alone the fact that almost all able bodied Hungarian soldiers were sent to Siberian Gulags for at least 5 years after the war. It is disingenuous your unilateral characterization of Hungarians who after all for their politicians' mistakes have lost 6 million of their population to Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Croatia, and Ukraine after the First World war. Hitler after all gave them back Transylvania while forcing on Hungary the most compliance for their agenda of persecuting Jews. You should not take out of context any of these occurence...after all Hungary is the smallest country in Central Europe and has the World second largest synagogue and Yeshiva, the largest in Europe and has the most jews in Eastern and Central Europe despite the smallest population...so anti semitism in Hungary is mostly a defense mechanism against punishment for no matter who's sides is Hungary on. Orban is another issue, but he is a maverick on a tightrope between Russia and Nato...being the only country who has no oil and gas reserves at all...context matters ! Size matters ! Geographical position matters, GDP matters and all the other issues that put Hungary for a thousand years since they became a Christian Nation exactly under pressure from Rome. Hungary during their barbarian period under Attila managed to conquer Europe...after becoming Christian they shrunk next to nothing.
@@nooneofconsequence1057 Israel has over 200 nuclear weapons. Long as that is true, there won't be another Holocaust. Or even a major pogrom. It might mean the end of the world (read up on "the Sampson Option"), but it won't be another Holocaust. I am a militant opponent of anti-Semitism. But Bret Stephens is full of sh*t. He's blandly specious attention-getter. Julie Ioffe is whipsmart but she's come to some weak conclusions here. IDK the others.
The late, great Prof Stephen Frand Cohen was the authority on Russo matters at the time of your recording. His view on the Baltics was that Russia already subsidizes their energy and questioned why they'd want to pay their pensions for what he considered largely undefendable territories. His understanding of matters Russo remains unchallenged even though Julia is highly competent.
Victoria Nuland working with Strobe Talbot to bribe former Soviet Nations to become NATO assets, seems to run into some opposition as the need for affordable energy supplies indicates the energy network that Russia built over the last 50 years was providing an adequate supply of energy? The use of NATO bombs to force Eastern Europe to conform to Western Colonial Powers demands appeared to be as forceful as Tito facing Russian intervention in the 1950's? The contemporary debt that the US has built up by attempting to buy the affection of Balkan States, appears as superficial as any area that the US has intimidated with troops. Now even Latin America seems to desire Russian Grain as the US seems to have become overly exploitative?
Oh Crap! With the war I am pursuing once again any place where Julia shares her views.... But now finding this discussion, again with the war, I am reaching once again for James Carroll. "CONSTANTINE'S SWORD". James Carroll pivots his discussion on the wooden cross in front of Auschwitz in Poland. This particular wooden cross has a history. His sometimes candid discussion is wide ranging, so well informed and mostly balanced. It is a reference for me. I return to it often. OOPS, I also just discovered Catherine Belton's book... Another e-bay order. Thank you Julia~you have no idea the value of your view to the western world. (I can't afford PUCK but am checking it out.) 💙 💛
The four people on the panel should not be disheartened by the 39 dislikes to the only 28 likes on this video. Of the 39 negatives, 37 are because of their poor ensembles, I mean they are really inferior dressers.
Julia Loffe is brilliant. I could listen to her for hours. Since Russia has declared war on Urkraine I have sought out her voice whereever I can find it.
Totally
Exactly, Ioffe and Kasparov are excellent listening
Agree. I think Julia has proven herself to be an experienced reporter in this particular area. She offers perspective.
Totally 🙏🏼💪🏼🙏🏼
Same here! Her insight into Russian history and what it has done to its people and their leadership is magnificent. Every interview is another well of further understanding.
I really resent the way Bret Stephens seems to automatically interpret any criticism of Israel as being fundamentally antisemitic - we have to be able to rationally discuss the ongoing occupation and the atrocities committed in this area of the world without people sabotaging the discussion using this knock-out argument!
@@nooneofconsequence1057 you are crazy. So just because the Arabs didn’t suffer like the Jews in concentration camps, they should let you colonize their lands??? Wtf logic is this ?
👏👏👏 you are absolutely right!
@@nooneofconsequence1057 Saying that imploring Israeli's to stop stealing other people's land, is the same as imploring Americans to stop staging coups in Latin America. Both statements are merited, and neither says absolutely anything about religious affiliation. All the other stuff you shotgunned in there is just white noise. The op is dead right, this equivocation was cheap and disingenuous. It's not a bit different from accusing someone of not being a patriot if they don't support Donald Trump, or any other politician, for that matter.
@@Brainbaskit guess I am confused. If a country has borders, and people lob stuff at you from outside, you can lob back, right? If they trespass to do harm, you can end them, right? Perhaps I misunderstood property rights, and self defense?
@@Driver-ur9mf uh, i can't understand what your point even is through all that word salad. Maybe try reformatting your response?
...so, i get it now, its not about europe, but about jews..................
Why were the two Israeli soldiers in Ramallah to begin with? Why does Brett try to redirect a discussion ostensibly about Europe to a discussion about anti-Semitism?
Cuz he’s pro Zionist
Bret Stephens manages to blame Angela Merkel for Ukraine, Brexit, and Trump, all in one sentence. Here's someone who wants to be perceived as an intellectual but - in my opinion - doesn't know what he's talking about.
Interesting to watch this three years later and to see them disproved regarding Europe's solidarity regarding Ukraine.
I could not agree more!
Of course they are united over Ukraine they have the USA military might to do their dirty work, take that out of the equation and see what happens
Nice to see all these imperialist war hawks in complete agreement.
And yes, in reading B. Stephens columns in the NYT times all these years he is wrong or obviously a featherweight intellectually.
Because she owed to be blame… her words then where her feelings… let Russia have them… Georgia means nothing to us
He is an intellectual but influenced by hard data. Notice how the others do agree with albeit reluctantly.
Return, return of antisemitism?
It never left
There's A reason for that.
This whole "discussion" isn't about Europe at all, is it. It's completely permeated by one unvoiced question, namely: "will there be pogroms soon?"
So much impotent fear and loathing.
@nothing Sure he knows, hes a Russian. And me too. Look - its about culture. Jews are naturally support liberal agenda - Russians coined a special term "ethnic liberalism". Anyway, James Kirpichnick so disgusting - will gladly punch his face no matter he Jew or not.
@@nooneofconsequence1057 Israel?! You accept us tax payer $...fund yourself!
Totally agreed!
It's always a little strange to hear people who strongly identify with a particular group (in this case, Judaism) when they turn their noses up when other people who want to identify with a specific group and also want to protect that heritage..... You can't have it both ways people....... Unless you think your heritage is the only heritage of value???
They do. I won’t say all Jews but the zionists They literally think they’re better than everyone else that’s why they call themselves “the chosen ones.”
It can't feel any worse to be right.
When certain people are "worried" about Europe it means Europe is doing something right.
Don't worry they'll fix that.
nope
Oh yeah; Europe has never been more stable. No rise of nationalism; no fraying of relations; and best of all peace and harmony with Russia-not even a war in ukraine
Funny that many comments are obviously antisemitic on this page.
Correct.
This came on my auto-play, and I didn't know it was from five years ago at first. I'd like to see these people do a reaction video of this, now that five years have passed. Some points are a little off, but most is spot-on , especially Putin. How does this have only 425 likes as of 13-Feb-2023?
These folks were thinking nothing but how do changes in Europe affect us the Jewish people? Julia Ioffe has a hard time public speaking.
@@nooneofconsequence1057 For me jews always seem to form this closed-off society inside oursociety, wich is a very toxic thing for me. In Antwerp we have a jewish juwelery neighbourhood, the people there don't speak dutch, even living here for long times. They only go to jewish schools, stores, they only do business with jews. If you go inside their stores, you clearly feel not welcome. If you really care so much about anti semitsm its time to integrate an communicate outside this closed off society.
@@benefiet stop fear mongering. If they share a common language, why does it hurt you?
I love Julia.. The way she can set the stage of things is brilliant. Sadly, the host of the conversation keeps interrupting.
If I could be persuaded that these people were as brilliant as they seem to think they are instead of merely educated more than many, I would think of them as smart instead of smug. They speak as if they are quite pleased with themselves to have been invited to sit on the dais and all the better than those in the audience and certainly the betters of those of us in the fly over states. It's as if they either think they understand those whom they disparage such that they are justified in a summary dismissal or the hoi polloi aren't worth the effort to genuinely understand let alone get to know.
Master races are often viewed as being smug, merely because they recognize and accept their inherent superiority.
@@texasray5237 funny how your comments only prove their observation about spreading antisemitism
They are elitists smug idiots!!!
@@nooneofconsequence1057 totally true… she is not aware of the entire premise of history repeats… these three should be in our state department ❤️
@@nooneofconsequence1057 b
OMG… how did this woman get to ask such a incredible panel such … never a question but statements.. how this three just talked and shared there wisdom… thank you for getting through her… to the woman … keep your questions direct and to the point and quit trying to make yourself smart… that’s what your doing and it’s coming from a place of insecurity. Work on your knowledge and history. Has to the group… one of the most honest conversations with three intelligent thoughtful beings… Julia is a rock star with her wisdom… ❤️
The ability to preach to the Choir seems an easy subject?
Omg the interviews questions are unstructured statements and very poorly constructed! This is whinge festival. At least Julia Ioffa is articulate.
Europe has lost its mooring in Christianity.
LMAO!!! Talking about something completely worthless! :)))))))))))
Yes, maybe there needs to be a crusade to spread Christianity. If only we allowed Christianity to take root and have churches in every city and town. If only there were Christian TV stations and radio programs and music. If only young children were given over to the hands-on care of priests. What could go wrong?
@@Bigwave2003 👏👏👏
You'll notice that most people who argue through name-calling aren't actually saying much at all. Please leave your vitriol in your own echo chambers and actually bring up points that you disagree with. Preferably also with why.
We disagree with Jewish control of our banks, media and politicians, and their sick plan to turn Europe into a third world hellhole. Why? Because we believe Europeans have a right to exist.
I'm curious if you've ever been in a third-world region. The idea of Europe becoming third-world (developing country with lower HDI) is, to my understanding, fairly implausible unless huge natural disasters or global war were to break out. Current HDI in Europe (lowest HDI) is around .700 vs. True third-world nations, where HDI is anywhere from .350-.500. It's a pretty huge distance. Third World Countries have little to no infrastructure, hugely lacking social resources (roads, schools, hospitals), and extremely week connections to the global marketplace. Do you see these things in Europe?
Also, where is evidence of Jewish control of your banks, media and politicians? Who are these shadowy puppet masters? I hear about this from people, but there never seems to be any identity to the conspiracy.
Yes, Europeans have a right to exist. Who is trying to dissent with that point? All liberal speakers say is that all people have a right to exist.
@@christianhuang519 I could literally post these all day. It's endless.
ua-cam.com/video/-OmtHeyCMQU/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/oTIT7j4MsM0/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/Y1zChJHqIkk/v-deo.html
The group you're referring to is 2% of the population yet more than 30% of its billionaires. Since every ethnic group has biases, misconceptions, and prejudices specific to it, if this particular group had them regarding people who aren't in their ethnic group, that would suddenly become politically relevant if they have this much disproportionate wealth and power, now wouldn't it?
forward.com/schmooze/131574/jews-dominate-forbes-rich-list/
www.unz.com/runz/the-myth-of-american-meritocracy/
Literally, on this very website, comments which include combinations of words used to explain well known stats related to this issue are automatically deleted because the ADL has an office in Silicon Valley devoted to pressuring social media companies into censoring speech they disapprove of. Gee, what happens if these people have misconcpetions and prejudices about people who aren't in their group? And if they didn't have these misconceptions, that would make them unique and unlike every other ethnic group on the planet, so which is it? Are they just like everybody else or are they magical and special?
www.adl.org/news/press-releases/adl-statement-on-youtube-policy-changes-to-reduce-extremist-content
I could sit here and post stuff like this all day. The only reason I have to is because you pay no attention whatsoever. It's actually embarrassing for somebody to still be confused about this issue in 2020, or even in 2018 when you posted this comment, to be honest.
@@juliusebola9389 propaganda at its worst.
Let’s talk about how the majority of SCOTUS is Catholic - oh no! The Pope is in control!
That 30% of billionaires are Jewish (if even true), is similarly meaningless. Your ‘point’ sounds like as much jealousy as mere hatred.
In fact, your ‘conclusions’ are the result of preconceived hatred’s.
Look up how many medical doctors and PhDs are Jewish versus their population %. What conclusion might you come to then?
Good luck wallowing in the usual sorry anger and vituperativeness.
@@forrestgossett we already know you view yourself as “the chosen ones “
1:01:26 A nice summary of the neoconservative view of why we should have (at least some elements of) a neoconservative foreign policy. If the US or EU leave a power vacuum, bad guys will swoop in and it will lead to greater problems for the US down the road. Time will tell how the EU/US's abandoning Ukraine (by failing in their commitments to the Budapest Memorandum) will lead to greater problems down the road.
Time has told.
Reading this in March 2022 proves out the truth of your comments.
Everyone should aim to follow just war theory. It would really help prevent a lot of dumb shit from happening
27:55 Even Kant though that Hobbesian institutions were necessary for perpetual peace, since most people in fact do not follow the moral law. Implementation of perpetual peace cannot ignore empirical facts even if its normative foundations are purified of anything empirical.
so it's world trough jews view basically. I like Julia, rest are so-so.
I mean this is the 92y 😅
Somebody should teach them the causality-principle and take away the blinkers.
Viewing a 2017 recording with the hindsight of 2022, did anyone question Europe's dependency on Russia's fossil fuels?
liberal politics/financial partnerships joining control is a fascist investor's favorite dream come true. using socially narrated debt investments with foreign partnership/shared control is the favored way to accomplish. While Europe was going Soft Power (accepting investments from the wrong funding streams as "partnerships," not investments), those investment partnerships were taking over. It's become a disastrous mess for the whole world.
The frightening issue is: these young people only studied half histories and then because of attributed the wrong controlling powers to both their heroes and villains. ie - Hitler to Stalin to all of the others were liberals upfront - promising fields of milk and honey. They became draconian despots when the "bill" came due. (each financed by the wrong money to ever allow anything good to actually be produced)
If their own version of politics (cause and effect) ever won, all they'd need do is look into their mirrors to understand how evil recruits helpers to unravel the world. (and I don't mean that unkind.)
57:57 did Julia Ioffe just compare Germany's finally winning a Wold War to the Chicago Cubs' finally winning a World Series?
I disagree with Brett's premise when he poses that saying Israelis are great people but they need to curb THEIR greed is a veiled antisemitic statement & parallel to saying-- Jews are a great people but need to curb THEIR greed for money.
So, we cannot say the Russians are great people but they have to curb their greed for other people's land. We can say it & we must say it. It is NOT anti anything but is just a FACT. The occupied land by the Israelis that belongs to Palestine-- which was agreed upon by BOTH parties as belonging to Palestine-- is only acknowledged as a part of Israel by one country and that is the United States. WHY? The United States needs and uses Israel, selling billions of dollars of weapons to Israel who in a quid pro quo is never criticised for its actions even when they qualify as crimes against humanity.
Since the Ukrainian Invasion, I've often thought of the situation in Palestine and Israel. IN essence Israel says Palestine is NOT a land; it's ours.
And Palestine says Israel is NOT a land; it is ours til Britain gifted it to the Jews following WWll. Which is TRUE? Can another country give a land and its people away? The moral answer is NO.
Palestine is a land that existed in pre-Christian times and was called Palestine by the Greeks; Ergo the land and the PEOPLE have existed as Palestine for 2 milleniums. Many people conquered it-- the Greeks the Romans the Ottomans excetera --but it was always called Palestine by The World At Large. In contrast, Israel as a land acknowledged by the world by that name is a country that was given by Britain to the Jews in 1949 following World War II and it was carved from the 2000 yr old land & PEOPLE called 🇵🇸. So there was NO land called Israel by the world at large til recently but there was a land called Palestine beginning 2000 years ago and continuing until 1948.
In a similar sense, there was a land called Ukraine over 2,000 years ago and there was NO land called Russia because Moscow did NOT even exist and when it finally did, it was a small village to the north.
I could go on but I'll let this comparison -- which tho not identical is similar in that a more powerful nation gaslights the existence of another weaker nation-- incubate in ones mind.
I needed to correct Mister Brett Stephen , whose ancesters changed THEIR last name at some point from a Jewish name to a neutered name--but did not change his paranoia which led to this false equivalency--a logical fallacy which invalidates his premise and puts into doubt all that follows. Julia also a Jew is more clear headed and does NOT fall into the same quagmire of a premise based on a logical fallacy.
@@nooneofconsequence1057 if you know that you were in Europe, why didn’t Germany give you German lands for reparations?
Geopolitics includes Financial, Religion, Medical, Food, Energy etc - You must remain objective - All of these people bring in Their Political Truths and Personal Truths which "Muddy the Waters" Their is no right or wrong in Geo politics, there just is - Much of what happens in the World has to do with Cycles, either bottoming or Topping - Many of them are long term, some are shorter term - Some are even Universal - Too have an Objective View, you must understand where we are in some of the more important cycles
julia was tight she saw everthing coming until today 2023 iam impressed
I feel dumber after suffering through this non informative anti intellectual presentation. None of them can complete any of their points convincingly.
America is provoking war in Ukraine and Europe as a good puppet is jumping along the American string. Well done, must be hard.
Q - Did the panel even ONCE mention the #KALERGI PLAN? No. Likely not. Outta sight .......
James Kirchick ,when you pick on Hungary, why don't you look at it in historical perspective like being abused during the Roman Empire, 150 years of occupation by the Ottoman Empire, the Habsburg Empire sending always Hungarian peasants on the front line and the fact that the Germans put the highest pressure on Hungarians to surrender Jews. Fear of authorities penetrated ordinary Hungarians for a thousand years of continuous occupation by a foreign great power...don't blame the ordinary citizen who is collaborating with occupying power because the moment the Germans left, they had to cooperate with Soviet power, let alone the fact that almost all able bodied Hungarian soldiers were sent to Siberian Gulags for at least 5 years after the war. It is disingenuous your unilateral characterization of Hungarians who after all for their politicians' mistakes have lost 6 million of their population to Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Croatia, and Ukraine after the First World war. Hitler after all gave them back Transylvania while forcing on Hungary the most compliance for their agenda of persecuting Jews. You should not take out of context any of these occurence...after all Hungary is the smallest country in Central Europe and has the World second largest synagogue and Yeshiva, the largest in Europe and has the most jews in Eastern and Central Europe despite the smallest population...so anti semitism in Hungary is mostly a defense mechanism against punishment for no matter who's sides is Hungary on. Orban is another issue, but he is a maverick on a tightrope between Russia and Nato...being the only country who has no oil and gas reserves at all...context matters ! Size matters ! Geographical position matters, GDP matters and all the other issues that put Hungary for a thousand years since they became a Christian Nation exactly under pressure from Rome. Hungary during their barbarian period under Attila managed to conquer Europe...after becoming Christian they shrunk next to nothing.
21:33 "Thank God I'm an American. This will never happen here."
I have said that several times in my life. Sometimes it DOES happen here.
this is a dreary neo-liberal cliche-slinging, ego-stroking session. how to get the maximum number of things wrong in the minimum amount of time.
@@nooneofconsequence1057 Israel has over 200 nuclear weapons. Long as that is true, there won't be another Holocaust. Or even a major pogrom. It might mean the end of the world (read up on "the Sampson Option"), but it won't be another Holocaust. I am a militant opponent of anti-Semitism. But Bret Stephens is full of sh*t. He's blandly specious attention-getter. Julie Ioffe is whipsmart but she's come to some weak conclusions here. IDK the others.
@@nooneofconsequence1057 anti semitism or anti Zionism?
"Weimarization" - interesting concept.
Why so quiet
Angela Merkel was an angel 😇!
Silly 😜
Wow..."Rewriting of the past in order to write a dark future" James Kirchick
The late, great Prof Stephen Frand Cohen was the authority on Russo matters at the time of your recording. His view on the Baltics was that Russia already subsidizes their energy and questioned why they'd want to pay their pensions for what he considered largely undefendable territories. His understanding of matters Russo remains unchallenged even though Julia is highly competent.
Victoria Nuland working with Strobe Talbot to bribe former Soviet Nations to become NATO assets, seems to run into some opposition as the need for affordable energy supplies indicates the energy network that Russia built over the last 50 years was providing an adequate supply of energy?
The use of NATO bombs to force Eastern Europe to conform to Western Colonial Powers demands appeared to be as forceful as Tito facing Russian intervention in the 1950's?
The contemporary debt that the US has built up by attempting to buy the affection of Balkan States, appears as superficial as any area that the US has intimidated with troops.
Now even Latin America seems to desire Russian Grain as the US seems to have become overly exploitative?
Oh Crap! With the war I am pursuing once again any place where Julia shares her views.... But now finding this discussion, again with the war, I am reaching once again for James Carroll. "CONSTANTINE'S SWORD". James Carroll pivots his discussion on the wooden cross in front of Auschwitz in Poland. This particular wooden cross has a history. His sometimes candid discussion is wide ranging, so well informed and mostly balanced. It is a reference for me. I return to it often. OOPS, I also just discovered Catherine Belton's book... Another e-bay order. Thank you Julia~you have no idea the value of your view to the western world. (I can't afford PUCK but am checking it out.) 💙 💛
The four people on the panel should not be disheartened by the 39 dislikes to the only 28 likes on this video. Of the 39 negatives, 37 are because of their poor ensembles, I mean they are really inferior dressers.
Is that it, really?
And here I thought it was because of their BS opinions.
...and Wolyn, july 11,1943?
Listening to American journalists talking about 'Europe' is always entertaining.
This was so funny!!
I live in California. Europe is some place east of Colton on the 10.
Thoroughly evil, cynical people.
More clue less bs
uhm
40 minutes I’ll never get back
Barf
Capitalism is best economic system lmao, 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
It is