Military, political & geo-strategic reality of China's ‘new village in Arunachal’

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 979

  • @ThePrintIndia
    @ThePrintIndia  3 роки тому +64

    Good journalism needs support from smart people like you. Subscribe to ThePrint here: theprint.in/subscribe/

    • @pulkitchelawat2062
      @pulkitchelawat2062 3 роки тому +6

      Shekhar ji please tell us why is youtube taking your CTC and national interests down, saying it breaches youtube's policy

    • @pulkitchelawat2062
      @pulkitchelawat2062 3 роки тому +1

      Can't see episode 660 that was a national interest????🤔🤔🤔🤔
      Don't know what the reason is but it's very unfortunate that google/youtube finds only CTC to be taken down at a time when youtube is filled with dump and unnecessary stuff.

    • @prashantsingh-bd3eu
      @prashantsingh-bd3eu 3 роки тому +2

      Sir,why don't print have an sports section.

    • @pankajsingh-oy8vd
      @pankajsingh-oy8vd 3 роки тому +2

      Shekhar ji kya china say paisa aana band ho Gaya. Koi Nahin wadra uncle day le lo. Ya Maoist naxlite ke pass kafi paisa hai le lo. Kyo majak karte ho

    • @harmansinghheer
      @harmansinghheer 3 роки тому +2

      I would like to support but when could we expect an iOS APP from The Print.

  • @AbhishekGupta-ve8mr
    @AbhishekGupta-ve8mr 3 роки тому +213

    Interestingly, IIT Guwahati (the sixth IIT of India set up in Assam as a part of that Assam Accord (1985) ) has its hostels named after major rivers/lakes in NE India, esp. in Arunachal Pradesh. Few of those hostel named as Lohit, Kameng, Dibang, Barak, Siang, Subansari, Dhansari, Umium, Manas. Hostels in institutions are better named like this, a curious student would learn a thing or two with it.

    • @MaheshPatel-zu6jp
      @MaheshPatel-zu6jp 3 роки тому +9

      Same in the IIM - Ahmedabad.

    • @islandsunset
      @islandsunset 3 роки тому +47

      @@bazlur-Vancouver no wonder you won't set your foot in such reputed institutions.

    • @saptarshisengupta8235
      @saptarshisengupta8235 3 роки тому +11

      Iit kharagpur has hostels named after Freedom Fighters and other eminent personalities from indian history. Eg: Lala Lajpat Rai Hall, Madan Mohan Malviya Hall, Lal Bahadur Shastri Hall . Because the area used to be a prison camp for Indian nationalists during British rule.
      Have spent time in both institutes. Just the names of each hostel gives away so much information about Indian history and geography.

    • @MaheshPatel-zu6jp
      @MaheshPatel-zu6jp 3 роки тому +22

      @@bazlur-Vancouver
      Tu puncture bana .

    • @गांडूशिकारी
      @गांडूशिकारी 3 роки тому +14

      @@bazlur-Vancouver puncher putra aap yahan se prasthan karen!!

  • @abhibrotomukherjee8239
    @abhibrotomukherjee8239 3 роки тому +241

    SG: "I will talk about cricket for just one min." Goes on talking about cricket for 7mins. Unadulterated love for Cricket.

    • @venkataraodevraju367
      @venkataraodevraju367 3 роки тому

      Lol

    • @SlimjimMK11
      @SlimjimMK11 3 роки тому +4

      India BEAT us 2/1..
      I am sad and he has right to be happy and proud...

    • @sauron2000000
      @sauron2000000 3 роки тому

      Yes, Frank Woolly fanboi 🤑

    • @sauron2000000
      @sauron2000000 3 роки тому

      @@SlimjimMK11 Ok, fan of Mahatma Kote 😆

    • @sauron2000000
      @sauron2000000 3 роки тому

      @@sanjaysrivastava1100 I have not watched the video yet. I made no claims.

  • @iamsuperb3714
    @iamsuperb3714 3 роки тому +42

    from arunachal.
    You can say that India has lost two wars. first', the arm war, and then the infrastructure war
    Those border areas are extremely underdeveloped.

    • @AvanRoyOfficial
      @AvanRoyOfficial 3 роки тому +3

      Please don't give up bro

    • @iamsuperb3714
      @iamsuperb3714 3 роки тому

      @Green Scenery what a unique way of showing concern 👍😁

    • @iamsuperb3714
      @iamsuperb3714 3 роки тому +2

      @ ya, there are many huge projects going on at the moment here.
      And regarding integrity, government just needs to protect the area from china.
      People here are understanding, we are not like, the government is not giving us this, that, so we’ll go to china
      😂😂😂😂

    •  3 роки тому

      @@southasia7286 I hope you are not from Arunachal Pradesh...otherwise you are self - kicking YOURSELF beta..😎

    • @saketpatil1306
      @saketpatil1306 3 роки тому

      @@iamsuperb3714 lmao I thought you will say that government is useless, we should go to China 😂😂😂, don't worry bro bjp will definitely do good job.

  • @siddhantshukla7259
    @siddhantshukla7259 3 роки тому +39

    meanwhile rahul gandhi : why is modi letting Chinese build stuff on the land my great grandfather lost to them .

  • @SandeepReddy-c
    @SandeepReddy-c 3 роки тому +90

    Whenever I get confused on some issues SG always gives a clear answer to them that's why I stopped watching all nonsense news and prefer to watch news on print especially CTC, Thank you sir.

    • @ThePrintIndia
      @ThePrintIndia  3 роки тому +8

      Do keep watching #CutTheClutter, Sandeep.

    • @satya5003
      @satya5003 3 роки тому +3

      Watch for sometime, then you will "find out" and unsubscribe.

    • @sameshchandraray7212
      @sameshchandraray7212 3 роки тому +1

      1956 villeg what could new ?.

    • @manzoorbhat369
      @manzoorbhat369 3 роки тому

      I' have been exactly following u Sir. Big no to tv channels now

    • @oldmonkwins2083
      @oldmonkwins2083 3 роки тому

      I prefer watching Republic of Arnab Goswami the only channel with fact and truth. Fearless Arnab has give all these lutyens run for their money. Long live Republic TV

  • @sohammchoudhari99
    @sohammchoudhari99 3 роки тому +79

    Long awaited CTC on Chinese 'village' in Arunachal Pradesh. Thank you Shekhar Sir and the Print for decluttering this news.

    • @prashanthramg9005
      @prashanthramg9005 3 роки тому +5

      @@naimilgandhi2648 you seem elated eh !!

    • @jmehta5357
      @jmehta5357 3 роки тому +4

      @@2010sourabh I do not want to use the word for you that Tim Paine used for Ashwin. It has been under Chinese occupation since 1959. So- Yes it is Nehru's fault.......

    • @jmehta5357
      @jmehta5357 3 роки тому +2

      @@prashanthramg9005 when fake news is called out should one not!!!

    • @amantiwari4987
      @amantiwari4987 3 роки тому

      @@2010sourabh occupied land pr aarti to utaregi nhi china
      twitter.com/AmanTiw24264390/status/1351386428089880576?s=20

    • @itsover9008
      @itsover9008 3 роки тому

      @@prashanthramg9005 Yes. Trust is built and can be destroyed easily. For a channel that keeps advertising trust, its about as trustworthy as Arnab's channel. Usually when you need to over-advertise something, the actual product doesn't have what is claimed.

  • @Vader19k8
    @Vader19k8 3 роки тому +37

    Thats why I hate our politicians who sucked to chinese now complaining without knowing history and geography.
    Thank u SG for clearing all the doubts.

    • @Arunava_Sar
      @Arunava_Sar 3 роки тому

      Nothing about politicians..
      Not a village of Chinese..
      It's integral part of India..
      Be educated to talk right about it

    • @doitteluguian982
      @doitteluguian982 3 роки тому +3

      @@Arunava_Sar POK also part of India.......same way that part is occupied by China after 1959 war.......gift from Congress and the same Congress party member papu confusing the people

  • @guri699
    @guri699 3 роки тому +112

    When are you decluttering Arnab's leaked messages?

    • @skillsforchildren9661
      @skillsforchildren9661 3 роки тому +19

      Yeh kabhi nahin karega. Chamcha hai

    • @ravinandanab
      @ravinandanab 3 роки тому +6

      Probably they also afraid ?

    • @RK-mz2sw
      @RK-mz2sw 3 роки тому +10

      There is nothing to discuss about on those chats.news jokers should not be given time in ctc

    • @mujahidrahim816
      @mujahidrahim816 3 роки тому +16

      Seems he ll not, as it raises questions on modi

    • @aadityamurali18
      @aadityamurali18 3 роки тому +3

      @@Milan-g2i Bangalore wasn't burnt. The riots were only in one area. I live in Bangalore and had no idea about it.
      I'm not trying to start an argument.

  • @jungami20
    @jungami20 3 роки тому +93

    Honestly thank God we have thePrint to explain this. I've been simply in a state of shock since I found out yesterday and desperately needed someone to explain to me what was going on.

    • @WandererSandip
      @WandererSandip 3 роки тому +9

      Yes credits to NDTV fake news.

    • @Aryan-iu9ck
      @Aryan-iu9ck 3 роки тому +9

      @@kunalvarshney9927 NDTV should have mentioned this, but always high on propaganda like other news channel.

    • @Aryan-iu9ck
      @Aryan-iu9ck 3 роки тому +2

      @@kunalvarshney9927 How come now it's disclosed by media by the print?
      That too after some 1 day.

    • @dub161
      @dub161 3 роки тому +1

      @@kunalvarshney9927 govt is not media agency bro but they should have launched formal protest.
      But still they are stuck in gandhi, vasudaiva kutumbakam despite some1 occupying ur land.

    • @WandererSandip
      @WandererSandip 3 роки тому

      @@kunalvarshney9927 yes just get your facts clear, certain parts of land were already given to the Chinese as gift long back. Yes they are our land but occupied land. Now suddenly claiming that villages are built in last year does not warrants to blindly criticise the government. Before Modi why didn't Congress do anything. Did u crticise that time?

  • @kasiviswanathankrishnan2412
    @kasiviswanathankrishnan2412 3 роки тому +6

    shekarji for people who don't know what to believe, this is perhaps one of your best cut the clutter.

  • @gauravkhairnar2439
    @gauravkhairnar2439 3 роки тому +68

    Definitely knew you gonna talk about India's victory 😍❤️🇮🇳

  • @sankalp6872
    @sankalp6872 3 роки тому +19

    The episode exposes Rahul Gandhi's tantrums. Territory lost in 1959 but blame it on Modi.

    • @amantiwari4987
      @amantiwari4987 3 роки тому +2

      @Noor Alhassan china occupied lol
      They occupied it in 1959.
      twitter.com/AmanTiw24264390/status/1351386428089880576?s=20

    • @sankalp6872
      @sankalp6872 3 роки тому +2

      @Noor Alhassan Lol. Aksai Chin is a part of India's official map. It is the official position of all Govt's including the Congress regimes. Clearly, you are a propagandist, Nothing wrong with that. People have their political preferences. The territory in question never had an Indian Army presence while China was developing infra from the 1990s. It was not gift wrapped by Modi or MMS. It was already with China since before 1962. Nehru was the PM back then. Here is the link from thePrint theprint.in/defence/china-builds-village-on-arunachal-pradesh-territory-it-occupied-in-1959/587909/

  • @detectivemalang3386
    @detectivemalang3386 3 роки тому +6

    India keeps winning at cricket, China keeps winning at geopolitics.

    • @GenSecWPNM
      @GenSecWPNM 3 роки тому

      Cricket, a sport played by a handful of nations.

  • @sachaadmi6203
    @sachaadmi6203 3 роки тому +14

    Request if we can use MARTYRED instead of KILLED while referring to Indian soldiers or brave civilians who lay down their lives fighting the enemy

    • @anmolpatelfifa
      @anmolpatelfifa 3 роки тому

      Martryed has a religious tinge ...
      Official term is KIA- killed in Action .

    • @sachaadmi6203
      @sachaadmi6203 3 роки тому

      @@anmolpatelfifa shahid or veergati ko prapt hue dharateerthi hue etc are well known in the subcontinent.english equivalent closest would be martyred.
      Religion of a soldier is the motherland so that's the religious context really

    • @anmolpatelfifa
      @anmolpatelfifa 3 роки тому

      @@sachaadmi6203 shaheed has a islamic tinge just like the word "Jahil " which is commonly used in the subcontinent without knowing the meaning of it (which is- anything pre islamic or before the relevation of islam)
      Centuries of islamic rule followed by british rule has made the indic masses disconnected with its own roots and which is evident by use of such terms in a loose way...

    • @shailendrashinde9410
      @shailendrashinde9410 3 роки тому

      Martyred is used when you die for religious movement. Indian army itself does not have martyred in its official nomenclature

  • @Sashi_Singh02
    @Sashi_Singh02 3 роки тому +44

    It's time for India and Indian people to man up
    Enough of athiti Devo bull crap we should stand shoulder to shoulder for tibetan people..they are the people who can lay their life for India

    • @drury2d8
      @drury2d8 3 роки тому +1

      Modi is xing pings good buddy.

    • @UzairKhan-qd3xu
      @UzairKhan-qd3xu 3 роки тому +5

      @@THEONE-si4xv bro are you blind cant you see these chutiyas are blinded they have nothing to eat but they think this false nationalism will somehow be a redemption!
      or a better explanation could be that they are 2 rupee per post it cell trolls !
      in which case let them do their job ignore them!

    • @rmenon66
      @rmenon66 3 роки тому

      @@UzairKhan-qd3xu I guess you work for 50 paisa per post

    • @rmenon66
      @rmenon66 3 роки тому

      @Daniel Daniel real cowards like you hide behind fake names

    • @jakedee4117
      @jakedee4117 3 роки тому

      It is irresponsible talk like that which has the potential to cause huge trouble for India and enormous human suffering.
      Do you really want to go to war with the largest nation in the world in the harshest terrain in the world in the age of satellites and atomic weapons ? And for what ? There is nothing in Tibet that India needs and it has many, many problems it needs to solve before it starts making new ones. Jammu & Kashmir is just the most obvious.

  • @onkarsingh2261
    @onkarsingh2261 3 роки тому +18

    Best CTC of this year untill now...

  • @SMA265
    @SMA265 3 роки тому +4

    Pujara's innings made it easy for India. Gill and Pant played superb innings but I gotta give it to the man who played more than 30+ overs to make sure a collapse like 36 doesn't happen. Accept congratulations from Pakistan. It always feels nice to see Asian team kicking some ass in Australia.

  • @shivamjha1403
    @shivamjha1403 3 роки тому +8

    Two of the most important events of the day. Sg sir! Superb! Hats off

  • @ramjidharmaraj
    @ramjidharmaraj 3 роки тому +52

    Another Geo strategic failure of Nehru to be passed down to all of his Successors. I have always envied Mao for his strategic thinking for his country, he did not care about his reputation, he did whatever good for his country. Whereas Nehru many things that are wrong for the nation just to keep a Good image of him. Nehru had 3 years from 1947 to 1950 to settle border issues and secure the water catchment area, he failed miserably but Mao just Bulldozed his way to occupy Tibet to secure their water catchment Area and even sit on water catchment of areas the South Asian rivers.

    • @tgsaravind
      @tgsaravind 3 роки тому +8

      You're attributing too much power to Nehru. What's worse is Modi hasn't done shit to improve things since 7 years. I dont think anybody at all has solution to these issues.

    • @TheVikramJoshi
      @TheVikramJoshi 3 роки тому +4

      May a times Veer Sawarkar used a term for Indians who have this kind of moral superiority complex, as "sad-guna vikruti" !!!

    • @eagleeye6986
      @eagleeye6986 3 роки тому +4

      Nehru was visionary for India 's Industrial restructuring credit must be given where it is due but was major failure in Geo- Strategy and Geo Politics, eg,Kashmir UN blunder and 1962 Indo-China War. I really wished Nehru should have left Foreign policy to Sadar Patel.

    • @ramjidharmaraj
      @ramjidharmaraj 3 роки тому +4

      @@TheVikramJoshi Boot lickers are no heros.

    • @shivam-aggarwal
      @shivam-aggarwal 3 роки тому +7

      Political Situation was different in India and China. If India also had Communism or Dictatorship like China, Nehru would have very well bull dozed his way through. Nehru had to deal with Brits, Muslims, Dalits, Nobility and many more things. He had his plate full, imo we should be thankful to him and move on given where we are at the moment. There are many British ex-colonies which had it more rough than India.

  • @Youdoyouyeah
    @Youdoyouyeah 3 роки тому

    Literally the best news on the internet. Shekhar Gupta is a hero!

  • @vaibhav_nitesh
    @vaibhav_nitesh 3 роки тому +2

    Having seen so many stories on 1962 war I can firmly conclude China invaded India to scare her in her early days of growing strong(if at all). And as we can see even up till today India has had a very cowed approach towards China.

  • @sameednakai8766
    @sameednakai8766 3 роки тому +21

    Declutter the recent Arnab Goswami, recent fiasco.

  • @indianmemer1482
    @indianmemer1482 3 роки тому +12

    Its just a chinese controlled area they have themselves admitted in their report that it was disputed in 1959 and annexed in 1962 and as well that village is behind the chinese military post

    • @pratyushkishore9030
      @pratyushkishore9030 3 роки тому +5

      The fake news and propaganda agencies NDTV put such articles so that to make people believe that china took areas of the india which was under current government

    • @prakashsawan558
      @prakashsawan558 3 роки тому +4

      No area that captured by China in Arunachal.
      In last war, India won the war in Arunachal boundary.
      India lost in Aksai Chin only, but win in Arunachal/ South Tibet.
      India should build infrastructre in north east as China did near our boundary.

    • @rohan8973
      @rohan8973 3 роки тому +2

      @@prakashsawan558 But Modi and cental govt. in general does not care about the NE-, trust me i am an Assamese .

    • @prakashsawan558
      @prakashsawan558 3 роки тому +4

      @@rohan8973 we have known that.
      He is a full retorics man, who came into power.

    • @indianmemer1482
      @indianmemer1482 3 роки тому +3

      @@rohan8973 I can understand brother but it is not like that he haven't done anything

  • @jaggi1938
    @jaggi1938 3 роки тому +3

    Strongly recommend sir that you use a light pointer when you show the maps and refer to some specific locations. We always do that in our business world. Thanks. Jaggi

  • @salilgokhale5310
    @salilgokhale5310 3 роки тому +13

    Fantastic analysis and you REALLY cut the clutter! Great job!

    • @ThePrintIndia
      @ThePrintIndia  3 роки тому

      Hi Salil. Do keep tuning in and watching #CutTheClutter.

  • @nishithgupta7624
    @nishithgupta7624 3 роки тому +15

    It pains me to see India's territory in occupation of some other country.
    PS: Not a political comment.

    • @shashwat8463
      @shashwat8463 3 роки тому +2

      @@rjrocks249 lol. It's Animal Kingdom. Territory matters. This passive attitude is the reason Indians have the least share of world's resources/real estate per capita. Keep your bad ideas to yourself.

    • @shashwat8463
      @shashwat8463 3 роки тому

      @@rjrocks249 Nope, it's a general misconception. We don't breed any more than any other people.
      Whole of North and South America, Australia, New Zealand among other places is populated by "Europeans". We not only lost territory, but non Muslims from nearby territories were also forced to move inside.

  • @kartikanand7709
    @kartikanand7709 3 роки тому +1

    Can you please tell me where I can find the link to the your article from the time Dr Manmohan Singh visited Arunachal. Thank you.

    • @Dronecomplexx
      @Dronecomplexx 3 роки тому

      ua-cam.com/video/iL_JdcVCvYo/v-deo.html

  • @Sahil_Bhatia_
    @Sahil_Bhatia_ 3 роки тому +39

    Expecting your episode on national interest on Arnab Goswami's leaked chats

    • @balkaransidhu5334
      @balkaransidhu5334 3 роки тому +4

      He will but with chocolate coated criticism.

    • @abhi565b
      @abhi565b 3 роки тому +6

      Come out of arnabphobia. Already entire Pakistan fears his and major Gaurav Arya reporting and analysis on Pakistani establishment and here Antonio maino and his pappu are suffering from same arnabphobia

    • @nopenope684
      @nopenope684 3 роки тому +7

      @@abhi565b yah bro massive quid pro quo = arnabphobia. Lmao

    • @vbond585
      @vbond585 3 роки тому +2

      @@abhi565b Arnab is for BJP what Barkha was for Congress...

    • @abhi565b
      @abhi565b 3 роки тому +4

      @@vbond585 and BJP is far better than Congress in national security so I support Arnab Goswami. Remember BJP is not Congress. Congress is a private limited party controlled by a single fake Gandhi family. Even Krishna supported arjuna in Mahabharat and karn supported Duryodhan but you can't simply put Karn in krishna category. We must always stand for righteousness and back righteous forces

  • @snrism
    @snrism 3 роки тому

    Love this type of journalism! Giving historical context, focusing on the actual issue, giving perspectives from both sides.. great job Shekar Gupta!

  • @utkarsh_Shrivastava
    @utkarsh_Shrivastava 3 роки тому +13

    We can have a detailed separate CTC on why we were able to win the series

  • @Raul87549
    @Raul87549 3 роки тому +1

    Start watching from 21:00 onwards, he came to the point from there on.

  • @binuraj1733
    @binuraj1733 3 роки тому +10

    "Manmohan Singh initiated a lot of projects and had to shelve it because of environmental activists but its good India has started the development lately" I guess its the Modi govt, Please find some courage to name and give the credit Guptaji. I know it might have hurt you to the core complaining bout your previous masters, we know some facts about you too!

  • @lasyavardhana
    @lasyavardhana 3 роки тому

    Great analysis of the village in Arunachal, people usually consider today's situation, without trying to read anything about the past. Thank you Shekar Gupta, for referring to various book, and educating us about the history of the place.

  • @riichobamin7612
    @riichobamin7612 3 роки тому +4

    I have posted this comment in another video and I will post it here too. I want to see how people respond to my comment (which is inflammatory I admit but I am quite frustrated):
    The mainland Indian govt. (yes I am calling it mainland Indian govt. because I ,as a native of Arunachal, don't see New Delhi caring about North East) only knows how to send soldiers under AFSPA in North East and gun down locals. But when it comes to standing up for the North East, it rarely does that.
    Case in point: in 2013, the GoI (Government of India) had dropped the names of Sikkim and Arunachal Pradesh from a World Bank loan JUST to avoid objections by China. And till 2007 the Central Governement had a policy of not developing roads in Arunachal because they were afraid that Chinese can use those roads once they capture Arunachal.
    As I have said earlier, the Government of India knows only how to legislate laws like AFSPA to kill and suppress it's citizen while it does very less when the time comes to stand up for them.

    • @siddharth8180
      @siddharth8180 3 роки тому +4

      😭😭😭
      A bitter truth. But, I hope you people will feel more united to India in coming few years.

    • @riichobamin7612
      @riichobamin7612 3 роки тому +1

      @@siddharth8180 thanks man ! Appreciate the concern. I don't hate mainland Indians, I just don't like the GoI.

    • @girishsamant4601
      @girishsamant4601 3 роки тому +1

      @@riichobamin7612hey buddy I just want to ask as you are local guy just tell how much have PLA pushed inside. Recently I heard they shot down 1 MiG-21 by SAM. just explain me.
      And government still is making road in Arunachal I saw it in wall street journal and also they even connected railways to Arunachal .
      AFSPA? Well I thought it is been now removed from NE states except Nagaland and manipur

    • @riichobamin7612
      @riichobamin7612 3 роки тому +2

      @@girishsamant4601 dude, Arunachal isn't like UP or Bihar. In those states, people speak a common language and often travel throughtout the states and can live anywhere easily as there isn't much cultural differences between districts. That is not the case with Arunachal (and other tribal states like Nagaland). Here the culture, food, traditional dress and langauge (with only Hindi and English as the Lingua Franca) changes from tribe to tribe and therefore you will find great variations within a district. So people mostly keep to themselves and their tribe. So I only know as much as is being told in the news.
      And you just proved my point man. After more than half a century is the GoI trying to improve the infrastructure of the state. And I was speaking for the whole North East. Aren't Manipur and Nagaland part of North India and therefore of India ? If a country has to use military force to keep a state from breaking away and becoming an independent country, isn't it same as colonizing said state ? I can understand that there will be radical people who will need to be dealth with force to maintain peace, but TO KEEP A STATE under military force ? This shows the incompetence of the GoI (irrespective of the political party or coalition who forms the govt. ).

    • @riichobamin7612
      @riichobamin7612 3 роки тому +1

      @@girishsamant4601 if my comment seemed hostile or disrecpectful, I am sorry and that wasn't my intention. I am just frustrated now and that may influence my poor choice of words in delivering my message.

  • @Aashiqdar-pm9gm
    @Aashiqdar-pm9gm 3 роки тому +1

    yaar ,cut the long story short, kitna khaaya china ney..... it gives me joy .....from kashmir

  • @paichethan
    @paichethan 3 роки тому +7

    Don't promote cricket. Every one is doing that to attract young cricket lovers.
    Promote so other game . Your snooker, pool examples to explain politics is fantastic

  • @mitaparikh1257
    @mitaparikh1257 3 роки тому +2

    So basically chinese did construction in region they have occupied since 1959. Why is there sensationalism regarding this? Modi govt has done fastest border infrastructure development to prevent any further loss of territory.

  • @priyala-vashu
    @priyala-vashu 3 роки тому +10

    ये भी बता दो कि वह एरिया 1959 से चीन के कब्जे में है। कोई आज का नहीं । नेहरू की देन है सब

    • @richy9rich
      @richy9rich 3 роки тому

      You have commented 10hours before. But this channel has given like for the person who has commented 9hours ago. Samaj me aaya kuch.

    • @priyala-vashu
      @priyala-vashu 3 роки тому +1

      @@richy9rich तुम शायद उनमें से हो जो दोस्त द्वारा स्टेटस नहीं दिखने पर नाराज हो जाते हैं लेकिन मेरे दिमाग में ऐसी बाते नहीं आती 👍 just chill

    • @SanatanAngel
      @SanatanAngel 3 роки тому

      It's himalayan blunder by nehru.just follow the below link
      ua-cam.com/video/eauvqVuFwl8/v-deo.html

  • @medicosstation5231
    @medicosstation5231 3 роки тому +1

    Ultimate research and analysis

  • @rr.in.the.cosmos
    @rr.in.the.cosmos 3 роки тому +12

    India just doesn't have enough guts to stand upto the dragon.
    IT IS the truth.

    • @Metalhead_667
      @Metalhead_667 3 роки тому

      Even the US goes on a back foot when it comes to China.

    • @rr.in.the.cosmos
      @rr.in.the.cosmos 3 роки тому

      @@Metalhead_667 most common folks boycott "the print" & "the wire".
      I wonder how most Indians(more than 90%) KNOWINGLY ignore plain facts just by blindly following a trait. Only a handful remain .

    • @Metalhead_667
      @Metalhead_667 3 роки тому

      @@rr.in.the.cosmos those media houses are running agendas that suit their leftist masters. So no wonder why people reject them. Would they ever do case study about UPA and their likes?

  • @rajeevjain6644
    @rajeevjain6644 3 роки тому +1

    The encroachment affects all Indians. It is inappropriate to divide them on their political affiliations. Now the point is what should the government do and why?

  • @krishnakumarbs4800
    @krishnakumarbs4800 3 роки тому +3

    In fact I thought that you would mention Rahul Dravid who trained these new youngster's who lynched the B-Gavaskar trophy. I was disappointed as there was no mention about him. India gave a fitting reply to those who teased our team members. Next time they will be careful before bowling on body to injure Indian cricketers...Great feeling.

  • @hm_t
    @hm_t 3 роки тому +1

    Love u sir for resolving arunanchal issue .... To helpful for internal security topic for UPSC point of view

  • @anvisworld5515
    @anvisworld5515 3 роки тому +5

    Can you please do a ctc on kashmiri pandits exodus from kashmir. It would be great to listen from you

  • @alishujaat1127
    @alishujaat1127 3 роки тому +2

    After debacle in ladakh and territory lost to China under Modi , its astonishing how attempts are being made to put recent territory lost on previous regimes

    • @galaxyofvid2738
      @galaxyofvid2738 3 роки тому

      Thats what called chankaya niti of Sanatan dharam which means lying deceiving making propaganda is part of the their dharam which krishan used to do in their fictional stories and shakuni too

  • @sharmadpak
    @sharmadpak 3 роки тому +9

    WHY did you PURPOSEFULLY forget what development activities Narendra Modi govt. did after the failure of Manmohan govt. in AP around this area??? Isn't it also part of the 'declutter'?

  • @jayantochoudhury5631
    @jayantochoudhury5631 3 роки тому

    Excellent analysis. Just one clarification. Isn't Mechuka in Siang? And Daporijo in Subansiri?

  • @anilnavani3619
    @anilnavani3619 3 роки тому +15

    So Rahul has been lying as usual! This guy is too far gone, he needs urgently to see a shrink.

  • @SoumyanathChatterjee
    @SoumyanathChatterjee 3 роки тому

    Nicely explained thank you. One clutter that confuse us is the fact Tibet is a separate country.
    We need to recognise it and work to evict CCP and PLA from Tibet. It's sad that USA passed the Tibet bill while we, Indians keep quiet.

  • @baron226
    @baron226 3 роки тому +6

    why this guy suddenly change the subject from military to sports? weird

  • @raghav3093
    @raghav3093 3 роки тому

    I love sg's passion for cricket, to go so far as almost saying a bad word, salute to this man, he is a beacon of light to these dark times

  • @SAM-df1cc
    @SAM-df1cc 3 роки тому +3

    Whenever the news of chinese aggression comes you talk about 1959 and 1962 instead of commenting more on the present situation.

    • @mavking4290
      @mavking4290 3 роки тому +3

      I guess you haven't heard the proverb ' Those who don't read history, becomes history'

    • @cauliflowerhead2735
      @cauliflowerhead2735 3 роки тому +1

      You are extremely naive

    • @Rahul-yq9ye
      @Rahul-yq9ye 3 роки тому

      It's just lik .. Pakistan constructing in pok ... And critisising modi government for construction... They have occupied the territory long ago... Now we are claiming it's ours ... Until we fight and get it back ... practically it's Pakistan land until india occupies it...

    • @galaxyofvid2738
      @galaxyofvid2738 3 роки тому

      You got it right there... thats the design of brahmans to save their pawn called modi 😂

  • @pogo1649
    @pogo1649 3 роки тому

    Dont you think an article on the Whasapp leaks should be conducted instead of last few days of articles?

  • @bodigavikas576
    @bodigavikas576 3 роки тому +24

    Even the GOD OF RAIN wanted to watch the game.So he/she TOOK THE DAY OFF and sat in front of the SCREEN.

  • @kkverma68
    @kkverma68 3 роки тому

    Excellent information Shekhar. Stay blessed.

  • @bsp3615
    @bsp3615 3 роки тому +7

    SG
    There is no clutter... simple fact is that when the nation was ruled by the family who have no national interest except for its own interest..... nations generations to come have to suffer...

    • @tgsaravind
      @tgsaravind 3 роки тому

      Let's agree with that argument, only for a moment. Then what has the current dispensation done to resolve these issues in the last 7 years? ZILCH.

    • @bsp3615
      @bsp3615 3 роки тому

      @@tgsaravind that is what I conveyed....a continuous destruction of six decades can never be undone in 7 years or 70 years or 700 years....some are irreparable.....that is glaring without even assuming for a moment for an argument sake

  • @siddharthaganguli5299
    @siddharthaganguli5299 3 роки тому

    Simply awesome!!
    Sir you brought our the unknown history in precise neatness.

  • @MassalaStar
    @MassalaStar 3 роки тому +12

    I was waiting for Kashmir Issue Tonight, that thing is always underrepresented I'm sure your next video will be about that

    • @yashvardhanthakur1968
      @yashvardhanthakur1968 3 роки тому

      Whats the issue?

    • @nethajibhakthan9321
      @nethajibhakthan9321 3 роки тому +10

      Yup I too need a CTC of "exodus of kashmiri pundits" by pro Pakistani Islamists in Kashmir 👍

    • @avant-garde378
      @avant-garde378 3 роки тому +2

      Yes.....the forced exodus and extermination of KP by Islamist.

    • @girishsamant4601
      @girishsamant4601 3 роки тому

      Kashmir issue started after a massive scam that took place in 1987 state elections where muf lost
      To congress. After millitancy started growing and pak didn't left a stone unturned to further fuel this. I wish atal bihari vajpayee could have remained PM he could do good things and kashmir would have been peaceful place.😭

    • @tgsaravind
      @tgsaravind 3 роки тому

      The more important question is what is the BJP govt doing to get them back to the valley. All else is useless.

  • @drsumitghoshal6205
    @drsumitghoshal6205 3 роки тому +1

    The subtitles are a let down once again. Sanjay Manjrekar becomes Manchakar, counter insurgency turns into counter incidency! Several more...

  • @deepanjaldas9543
    @deepanjaldas9543 3 роки тому +28

    SG expecting a CtC from you on Arnabs leaked whatsapp chats

    • @sasindranvm3366
      @sasindranvm3366 3 роки тому +1

      Yes.It is full of clutters. Not.only Arnab but his masters.Arnab is just HMV(His Masters Voice).He is TRPatriot.(Nationalism for his channels TRP and vote for BJP)

    • @pranayvaka1113
      @pranayvaka1113 3 роки тому +1

      I think SG ji is closely following it and most probably make a CTC when the court verdict comes

    • @galaxyofvid2738
      @galaxyofvid2738 3 роки тому +1

      He us B team if of modi to cover this he won't open his mouth

    • @bomeekyaash8109
      @bomeekyaash8109 3 роки тому

      @Heisenberg Says Exactly bro, people are overrating Arnab's chat leak without knowing the truth. Many people are also saying that Arnab played with nation's security. Even there's no proof found till now.

  • @ajaykumarshukla1095
    @ajaykumarshukla1095 3 роки тому

    Reliable exposition. 👌👌👌🙏🙏🙏🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹.

  • @arjunkprasad1508
    @arjunkprasad1508 3 роки тому +8

    the way you said dickhead... lol :D 24:20

  • @v.a.2796
    @v.a.2796 3 роки тому

    Sir..this is not fair. You should never underestimate the power of celebration. You should have celebrated this historic milestone...just doing chit chat about it...everything doesn't need to be cluttered to be talked about.

  • @daneilpatro2776
    @daneilpatro2776 3 роки тому +3

    Non-left news portals such as op-India have went vocal for local with zoho (Indian CRM platform) , will you go vocal for local too? Can we expect the print to go atmanirbar?

  • @imagine2234
    @imagine2234 3 роки тому

    Great one Shekhar saab!!

  • @THEVENGENCEGURU
    @THEVENGENCEGURU 3 роки тому +7

    Why is it called a village? They built a garrison - to house troops year round. SG seems to be blind to deduction on this one.

    • @THEVENGENCEGURU
      @THEVENGENCEGURU 3 роки тому

      @@MrReon1806 I'm Haryanvi bro.
      Akhikesh only knows how to pose for TV interviews. Its good they lost, Yogi is better.

    • @THEVENGENCEGURU
      @THEVENGENCEGURU 3 роки тому

      @@MrReon1806 I'm not surprised your first instinct was to try to make some caste connection. Petty people petty thoughts 🤣

    • @THEVENGENCEGURU
      @THEVENGENCEGURU 3 роки тому

      @@MrReon1806 lol you should not have replied.
      You want to distill my identity and my political disposition to my caste - which is scary and backwards. As youths we should distance ourselves from this caste talk. We should not even include it in trolling comments. You presumed where I stood politically - on the basis of my surname, that is what I wanted to point out. Never assume. Always ask. We know casteism is rampant in India and I would think a million times before blaming a certain group for that issue - perhaps its more complicated than what you can comprehend. This exchange also tells me how much you know about Haryanvi politics, Yadavs/Aheers do not hold power in the state. Finally, you cannot blame the ongoing casteism for how you interact with the world. You seem to simply be propagating it instead of diminishing it. Here, in this exchange, casteism is not the problem, you are the problem.

    • @THEVENGENCEGURU
      @THEVENGENCEGURU 3 роки тому

      @@MrReon1806 There is nothing known as "your people" or "my people" we are all Indians. You, deducing my politics from my surname, are just as bad as other people voting for the same caste as themselves. If you cant understand this, then god help you. You are going in a loop, disproving your own point. This is youtube gold. Good day fellow Indian.

  • @lensviewbykaushik
    @lensviewbykaushik 3 роки тому

    SG Sir! Master piece from the master journalist!!

  • @maitorunmai5082
    @maitorunmai5082 3 роки тому +8

    Thanks sir, for such a detail information. You seems to know more on the area than most of the local educated persons. Wonder if the government had any idea to what it's dealing with now.

  • @manujjoshi1682
    @manujjoshi1682 3 роки тому

    Sir, please buy a better mic. The audio quality is too poor.

  • @sudhanshupandey5196
    @sudhanshupandey5196 3 роки тому +6

    Thank you Shekhar sir bringing clarity in this issue.

  • @SatyaPrakash-oq4gy
    @SatyaPrakash-oq4gy 3 роки тому

    People misunderstood it, actually it is 56inch waist instead 56 inch chest. ...it is not a fault on his part. .

  • @diva7892
    @diva7892 3 роки тому +6

    Disputed territory since yesteryears : yes .... Chinese outpost earlier on : yes .... Full village construction was only done in 2020 (sattelite images available) on fhe watch of the modi govmt .... So let us not play down the role of this useless government & try to repose responsibility elsewhere

    • @TheSoLuna2
      @TheSoLuna2 3 роки тому +2

      Good that you are taking a moral umbrage against something that must be made right by the Modi government. However, in the same breath, have you tried to address the other wrongs? For example ceding 36000 sq kms in Askai chin to the Chinese by the Congress? Or unilaterally ceasing the war in Kashmir and going to the UN by congress? Or, being in cahoots with the PLA and receiving donations for RGF and, in lieu, toeing their line? Modi governments list of achievements and governing without being imbued in corruption is something that we have never seen happen before. Like other issues, this too will be dealt by them. Unlike the congress, this government does not shy away from a showdown - as we saw in Doklam and Ladakh. Litany of lies and deceit does not make the former government better, who, until their last tenure, had their hands in the cookie jar with Augusta Westland. Try to have an open mind and give credit where it’s due.

    • @FirePhoenix1701
      @FirePhoenix1701 3 роки тому

      Anyone with common sense would understand it doesn't matter if they built a hut or an Eiffel tower sized building over there. We still have to fight their troops on land and win it back if it was lost many many years ago! why the f was it lost? How do you expect this government to go to war for the land lost decades ago? Use your common sense for once gosh..

    • @TheSoLuna2
      @TheSoLuna2 3 роки тому

      @@FirePhoenix1701 umm even this one was lost to the Chinese decades ago, if you watched the entire episode. It didn’t suddenly happen when BJP came in to power.

    • @FirePhoenix1701
      @FirePhoenix1701 3 роки тому +1

      @@TheSoLuna2 Right. That's exactly my point too. I was replying to "Div A". These people expect BJP to overturn every damage done in the past in just 6-7 years lol. These people have to get off their play station and understand how things work in real life.

    • @arin1512
      @arin1512 3 роки тому

      Since you are unable to grasp what Mr.Gupta said, perhaps this might help.
      1. This land was lost in 1959 and consolidated by 1962. How are you going stop construction in an area which you have ceased control over in 1959.
      2. Do you want to get back this piece of land RIGHT NOW or consolidate and defend the other sectors which are of strategic importance at this stage.
      3. Are we in a position to go to war with China right now? Given the current asymmetry, it would be strategically foolish to initiate a war.
      4. Never forget 1959/62/67, 2017, 2020. Build yourself and bide your time for the opportune moment.
      5. The irony is that we Indians don’t like to look back at the past 500yrs of shame of being controlled by foreign invaders. We “let it go”.

  • @malcolmdsouza4463
    @malcolmdsouza4463 3 роки тому

    I wonder why Indian government has not raised objections to construction on a disputed Indian territory, this will be the same as we face in Ladakh when we did not complain road and base development.

  • @Lalsingh-hu8bg
    @Lalsingh-hu8bg 3 роки тому +3

    Sir, please cutt the cluter about Arnab's leak WhatsApp chats.. How can an Anchor knew such sensitive information in advance?
    He almost jeopardized our National Security!

    • @rafiqibrahimnathanie1739
      @rafiqibrahimnathanie1739 3 роки тому

      Explain and Expose.

    • @jaideepc786
      @jaideepc786 3 роки тому +1

      He already refers to Republic TV as 'those Commando Comic channels' 😁
      Thats sums up his view on ArGo, pretty much. I don't think he will waste an episode on it.
      I liked Arnab in his NDTV, early-TNow days, but frankly in his Republic TV awatar, tis become disgusting to watch more than 5mns. One wonders which audience he caters to, as I haven't seen a single thinking person talk +ve of ArGo's journalism in the last 2 yrs..
      Perhaps, his game is now to get full time into the hurly burly of electoral politics as a BJP cax..
      He would indeed be a powerful debator for the BJP in one of the *Sabhas, but as a journo, I think his credibility is irretrievably lost. ArGo is without doubt an intelligent guy, maybe playing to a specific career plan.

  • @nakshatraroy7442
    @nakshatraroy7442 3 роки тому +1

    I understand the cliche that they had better infrastructure on their side during 1962 invasion but how come 'lack of infrastructure like road etc' ON OUR SIDE' did not hamper Chinese incursion ONTO OUR SIDE but did hamper the movement/supply line of our troops? How come they could supply their troops well inside NEFA through the 'no infrastructure' territories of NEFA but we could not?

  • @amanshukla8758
    @amanshukla8758 3 роки тому +5

    Damn good analysis. SG never fails to impress in CTC

  • @kubssharma
    @kubssharma 3 роки тому

    Beautiful Journalism!

  • @gagandeepchawla9464
    @gagandeepchawla9464 3 роки тому +10

    Sir please do an episode on Arnab Goswami's alleged WhatsApp chat leak. Lot of clutter around it and hardy any new channel have covered the story.

    • @yashvardhanthakur1968
      @yashvardhanthakur1968 3 роки тому +1

      Lefties shouldn't get too excited too early as they usually do

    • @crudetorefined4059
      @crudetorefined4059 3 роки тому

      News Channels will not cover this. Because.. "Hamam me sab nange hai". And if you think being neutral, there is nothing new in his chat.
      Everyone in the country knows that something big wi happen after pulvama. And Smriti Irani's ministry news was first Twitted by PMO and he is having a media house they have "sutra". After every election you will get such news " sutra bata rahe h ki sidhu ji ko deputy CM nahi banaya jayega.. isle paas ye Mantralay ho skta hai"
      Plus even without leaked chats everyone know that he have relationships with BJP leaders.
      Uski chat chod k hume is baat pe khada hona chahiye ki news channels k political parties se connection hote h. Congress BJP dono k news channels bate hue h. Aur sab mil k humko chutiya bana rhe h.

  • @sdua1995
    @sdua1995 3 роки тому

    21:30. Shekhar Gupta talks funny here. Says India may ignore the Chinese intrusion here for now as priority is other regions. It's like saying a finger is lost but priority is to save the vital organs. Agreed. Still a finger loss is a finger lost ?

  • @maheshgoenka5902
    @maheshgoenka5902 3 роки тому +21

    Says will talk about cricket for 1-2 minutes only. Goes on to chat for 7.

    • @mavking4290
      @mavking4290 3 роки тому +1

      I guess you never heard the 2 minutes speech concept

  • @medicosstation5231
    @medicosstation5231 3 роки тому +1

    Hatsoff

  • @abhimanyusingh6761
    @abhimanyusingh6761 3 роки тому +7

    The thing that we should focus on developing infrastructure near the border.
    2nd whatever Rahul says is a joke, he should relax and go to Bangkok.

  • @sudeeprpsonawane5529
    @sudeeprpsonawane5529 3 роки тому +1

    If Shekhar says Harsha Bhogle is "cricket expert", then Sanjay Manjrekar is Bollywood singer, Shane Warne a former football player and I'm NASA scientist who discovered intelligent aliens living on a planet in a galaxy 100 billion light years away!! 🤪😁🤓

    • @karannainwal1990
      @karannainwal1990 3 роки тому +1

      True that's how ecosystem in India works Harsha bhogle and Ramchahdra Guha are cricket experts without even playing tennis ball cricket .
      Thankfully New India is coming out of this slavery mindset where English was intelligence.

    • @sudeeprpsonawane5529
      @sudeeprpsonawane5529 3 роки тому +1

      @@karannainwal1990 Harsha played college level cricket in Hyderabad. He used this fact to promote himself in the mid 1980s. His knowledge about cricket is poor. Knowing statistical data is not cricket knowledge. Charu Sharma has far more knowledge and he is a humble person. I knew both while I worked as a cricket reporter in Mumbai 30 years ago after I did not make an impact as cricketer. My contemporary Ravi Shastri is India coach.

    • @karannainwal1990
      @karannainwal1990 3 роки тому +1

      @@sudeeprpsonawane5529 Sir Try starting a youtube channel of your own where you can discuss cricket at every level. Like a commentary on current situation and some interesting stories from past you seem to be very knowledgeable.

  • @pichumanisankar2617
    @pichumanisankar2617 3 роки тому +4

    “This creates a delicious problem for 🇮🇳 India” 👍🏾

  • @jkuang
    @jkuang 3 роки тому +1

    British Empire: I draw a line in South Tibet and claim this area.
    China: I do not agree.
    India: Whatever British Empire claimed, I claim.
    China: Let's fight! Again!
    India: No. Let's have a stare contest.
    Did I summarize the situation accurately? :)

  • @bodigavikas576
    @bodigavikas576 3 роки тому +4

    Great content for GS PAPER-2 UPSC(IR)

  • @shauryakapoor6402
    @shauryakapoor6402 3 роки тому

    Brilliant video, thanks for clarifying the issue sir!

  • @pichumanisankar2617
    @pichumanisankar2617 3 роки тому +7

    “This is a let go syndrome “ 👍🏾

    • @kapilrana5075
      @kapilrana5075 3 роки тому

      @ india is a poor country still..it doesnt make any sense..iran is poor, pak is poor look what they are doing even going against america..this was really a let go syndrome.

    • @kapilrana5075
      @kapilrana5075 3 роки тому

      @ why would i go to those lands

  • @raghurajsingh2425
    @raghurajsingh2425 3 роки тому

    You are only the brave journalist who can tell the truth
    .

  • @asokedas2977
    @asokedas2977 3 роки тому +5

    "Chhappan inch" right! Hilarious but shows your abhorrence for Modi.

  • @vaibhav8011981
    @vaibhav8011981 3 роки тому

    This is correct analysis.....

  • @devendrapratapsingh6972
    @devendrapratapsingh6972 3 роки тому +3

    Even china make a whole village in India but govt. didn't give permission to farmers protesters in capital.irony?

  • @rajanarayananbadrinathan5667
    @rajanarayananbadrinathan5667 3 роки тому

    Thanks SGji ..Crystal Clear 👌!! As always very informative

  • @DedsoRupiyaDega
    @DedsoRupiyaDega 3 роки тому +3

    The print is already enormously funded by tukde tukde gang. i request GOI to start a probe on The Print

  • @brijesh5907
    @brijesh5907 3 роки тому

    Watch from 21:49 to understand whether it is new or old occupation

  • @shourjasengupta622
    @shourjasengupta622 3 роки тому +2

    snehesh is the most bell end expert on military strategies, just bin him

  • @arjunpeshawaria3835
    @arjunpeshawaria3835 3 роки тому

    I am curious to see the line of actual control on the map with China. We know what it looks like in J&K and Ladakh. Haven't seen one for Arunachal or is it sensitive?

  • @amaypajay685
    @amaypajay685 3 роки тому +3

    Shekhar Ji thanks for considering our request. 👍😀❤️ #GabbaTest

  • @dharanasa
    @dharanasa 3 роки тому

    The Indian team had to score 150 plus runs in last 20 overs on the 4th day to win with 5 wickets in hand. It was more of an IPL T 20 match scenario with no restrictions on bowling. Such exposure earlier did provide a booster dose to Indian players and they won. This counteracts the sceptics that due to extensive play with IPL players were tired and hence they could not play.