БЕСПОДОБНЫЕ ПЕСНИ У МАНФРЕД МАН. . МОЯ ЛЮБИМАЯ ГРУППА. ДА ГЛЯДЯ ПРАВДЕ В ГЛАЗА ВСЕ РОК ГРУППЫ ДА И НЕ ТОЛЬКО .КОТОРЫЕ ВОЗНИКЛИ В СЕРЕДИНЕ ПРОШЛОГО ВЕКА ЭТО ПРОСТО ТАЛАНТЛИВЫЕ ЛЮДИ. КОТОРЫЕ ПО ВЕЛЕНИЮ СВОЕЙ ДУШИ НАПИСАЛИ И СПЕЛИ ЧЕЛОВЕЧЕСТВУ СВОИ БЕСПОДОБНЫЕ ПЕСНИ. В КОТОРЫХ ПОДНЯТЫ МНОГО ТЕМ И ПРОБЛЕМ МНОГО ОПИСАНО ЖИЗНЕНЫХ СИТУАЦИЙ . И ПРАВДА ЖИЗНИ. ФИЛОСОФИЯ ЖИЗНИ. ЧЕМ И ЗАКРАЛАСЬ К ЭТИМ ГРУППАМ ЛЮБОВЬ И ПОЧИТАНИЕ ИХ ТВОРЧЕСТВА. И ЭТО ОЧЕНЬ ХОРОШО. ВЕДЬ МУЗЫКА ЭТО ЧАСТЬ ЧЕЛОВЕЧЕСКОЙ ЖИЗНИ. БЕЗ НЕЕ НИКУДЫ. КАК БЕЗ ВОДЫ. МУЗЫКА ДЛЯ КАЖДОГО . КАКУЮ БЫ ОН НЕ ЛЮБИЛ. У КАЖДОГО СВОЙ ВКУС. ЭТО КАК КИСЛОРОД. КАК СВЕЖЕЕ ДЫХАНИЕ. ЭТО КАК ОТДУШИНА ДЛЯ ЧЕЛОВЕКА ЭТО ЕГО ВНУТРЕНИЙ МИР. В КОТОРОМ ОН МОЖЕТ ВОПЛОТИТЬ. И ПРЕДСТАВИТЬ СВОИ МОЖЕТ БЫТЬ НЕСБЫВШИЕСЯ МЕЧТЫ И ЖЕЛАНИЯ. В КОТОРЫХ ЧЕЛОВЕК МОЖЕТ ПОБЫТЬ ПОКА СЛУШАЕТ ЛЮБИМУЮ ЕМУ МУЗЫКУ . ДА И НЫНЕШНИЕ ГРУППЫ КАЖДАЯ ПО СВОЕМУ ХОРОШАЯ. И У КАЖДОЙ ЕСТЬ СВОИ ПОКЛОННИКИ. СЛУШАЙТЕ ДРУЗЬЯ И НАСЛАЖДАЙТЕСЬ. ЭТИМ ПРЕКРАСНЕЙШИМ ИЗОБРЕТЕНИЕМ ЧЕЛОВЕЧЕСТВА. ВСЕМ ДОБРА ЖЕЛАЮ И МИРА. УДАЧИ. .
Many many years ago, I had a cassette tape recorded from a friend with this song, with 'Soldier of Fortune,' 'The House of the Rising Sun,' 'April,' and a few others. It was my base of music education. Today, I have tears when I listen to it.
I've loved this song since I heard it for the first time (was 16 or so). Now, I'm 61 and this song still gives me chills whenever I listen to it. One of my all-time favourites.
listening to this again... brought me back to a memory from middle school... in 1981 I am now 57 years old... thank you for opening up very beautiful memories... now I remember it again....❤❤❤
Comparto el criterio solo que ahora yo tengo 65 y cuando la escuché por primera vez se me chorrearon las ligas por la música la letra en fin la pentstonics sagrsds
grade 4 ako sa kantang ito madalas naririnig ko sa mga binata na umiinom na noon ng tuba at naggigitara.the best tlaga mga kanta noon d gaya ngaun basura na ang mga kanta.
I used to hear this song on buses plying the Quiapo-Guadalupe route in the mid-70's. I did'nt know the title coz it was not among the top hits at that time. I got the title from a colleague who heard me singing the few lines of the song which I knew. Tnx to youtube and the uploader, I can now hear this song to my heart's content...GOD BLESS !!!
Dont know the magic of this song. Why I dont get tired of singing and listening to it repeatedly.. what a wonderful song. So nice bck music/lyrics and VOCAL RENDETION 🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶💯❤
Musicaly I had a long run. Born in the early 60's to a couple of musical dino's. They had records of Herp Albert, Grieg and old Sweedish dansmusic. Thank you for that heritage. When I started to buy records my self it was often not the most expencive and modern records I ended up with. But I looked in the recordshops boxes of low priced failed records. And sometimes I found gold. The Roaring silence lp was very cheap and is probably one of my most valuble treasures to this day. An incredible musical eargasm that had a big impact on my future musical preferences. Questions is my pathway to contemperary music. The melancoly and instrumental geniuos of this song hits my central music core.
Heute Abend in Offenburg live erlebt !!! Super toll und eine irre Zeitreise in meine Jugend !!! mit meiner Tochter - heute so jung wie ich damals !!!! Irre............tolle Zeit, super Musik !!!!!
I am 55 years old man from Indonesia this guys changed all my live by thid song, such a wonderful pictures I keep deep in my hurt.Thank for your music. KRIDO HARTLAND ,BATANG - INDONESIA.
This is a beautiful Piece of Music and the basic melody is quite old (1860's), it is Franz Schubert's Impromptu No. 3 in G flat. Still I adore what Manfred Mann made from it!
Hallo untuk semua penggemar Manferd Mann, saya tidak tahu persis magna lagu ini tapi abgi saya ada kengangan sangat indah sekali,mari kita berbagi kebahagian Regards for all, Sulyadi Indonesia
j écoute beaucoups d autres groupes et de différents styles le LP du groupe BLUR , magic whip , les stones, KISS, the CAN, FAUST, DYLAN, Mothley Crüe, .........
I heard this song on my father's old radio one Sunday afternoon, when I was very little... I thought "answered questions with questions" was funny. I heard this song again in the taxi this morning and finally, I understood it. Memories, emotions came flooding... raw emotions I didn't know existed until this morning. Beautiful lyrics, lovely melody...
one of my favorite song in my high school life 1985-89. too much memories from candon national high school, philippines. greetings from las vegas! jun manzano❤️
hello sir mY kapatid ako jan sa santiago lapit sa candon... joe@vida escalona sa butol santiago. luv ko rin ang song nato. sirdodong balaga frm bantacan new bataan davao de oro. rgrda all
Our Lord JESUS CHRIST is the Light of the world. Whoever follows Him will never walk in darkness, but will have the light of life. Follow JESUS CHRIST and you will be saved !
Remembers wheen I was 17,18 years old. What a wonderful feeling listening this so many years after. Stil feeling moved by rhis master piece. I WAS 17,18 YEARS ODS Somewhere in Belgium
An admirer of their hit singles of the seventies, to my eternal shame I was slow to embrace their albums beyond Solar Fire - but I have formed the opinion that The Roaring Silence, from whence this comes, is a faultless, glittering jewel of a recording.
БЕСПОДОБНЫЕ ПЕСНИ У МАНФРЕД МАН. . МОЯ ЛЮБИМАЯ ГРУППА. ДА ГЛЯДЯ ПРАВДЕ В ГЛАЗА
ВСЕ РОК ГРУППЫ ДА И НЕ ТОЛЬКО .КОТОРЫЕ ВОЗНИКЛИ В СЕРЕДИНЕ ПРОШЛОГО ВЕКА ЭТО ПРОСТО ТАЛАНТЛИВЫЕ ЛЮДИ. КОТОРЫЕ ПО ВЕЛЕНИЮ СВОЕЙ ДУШИ НАПИСАЛИ И СПЕЛИ ЧЕЛОВЕЧЕСТВУ СВОИ БЕСПОДОБНЫЕ ПЕСНИ.
В КОТОРЫХ ПОДНЯТЫ МНОГО ТЕМ И ПРОБЛЕМ МНОГО ОПИСАНО ЖИЗНЕНЫХ СИТУАЦИЙ . И ПРАВДА ЖИЗНИ. ФИЛОСОФИЯ ЖИЗНИ.
ЧЕМ И ЗАКРАЛАСЬ К ЭТИМ ГРУППАМ ЛЮБОВЬ И ПОЧИТАНИЕ ИХ ТВОРЧЕСТВА.
И ЭТО ОЧЕНЬ ХОРОШО. ВЕДЬ
МУЗЫКА ЭТО ЧАСТЬ ЧЕЛОВЕЧЕСКОЙ ЖИЗНИ.
БЕЗ НЕЕ НИКУДЫ. КАК БЕЗ
ВОДЫ. МУЗЫКА ДЛЯ КАЖДОГО . КАКУЮ БЫ ОН НЕ ЛЮБИЛ. У КАЖДОГО СВОЙ ВКУС. ЭТО КАК КИСЛОРОД.
КАК СВЕЖЕЕ ДЫХАНИЕ.
ЭТО КАК ОТДУШИНА ДЛЯ ЧЕЛОВЕКА ЭТО ЕГО ВНУТРЕНИЙ МИР. В КОТОРОМ ОН МОЖЕТ ВОПЛОТИТЬ. И ПРЕДСТАВИТЬ СВОИ МОЖЕТ БЫТЬ НЕСБЫВШИЕСЯ МЕЧТЫ И ЖЕЛАНИЯ. В КОТОРЫХ ЧЕЛОВЕК МОЖЕТ ПОБЫТЬ
ПОКА СЛУШАЕТ ЛЮБИМУЮ
ЕМУ МУЗЫКУ . ДА И НЫНЕШНИЕ ГРУППЫ КАЖДАЯ ПО СВОЕМУ ХОРОШАЯ. И У КАЖДОЙ ЕСТЬ СВОИ ПОКЛОННИКИ. СЛУШАЙТЕ ДРУЗЬЯ И НАСЛАЖДАЙТЕСЬ.
ЭТИМ ПРЕКРАСНЕЙШИМ
ИЗОБРЕТЕНИЕМ ЧЕЛОВЕЧЕСТВА. ВСЕМ ДОБРА
ЖЕЛАЮ И МИРА. УДАЧИ. .
Many many years ago, I had a cassette tape recorded from a friend with this song, with 'Soldier of Fortune,' 'The House of the Rising Sun,' 'April,' and a few others. It was my base of music education. Today, I have tears when I listen to it.
I've loved this song since I heard it for the first time (was 16 or so). Now, I'm 61 and this song still gives me chills whenever I listen to it. One of my all-time favourites.
so did I
I'm 57, and I love it 😊👍
Yes me too
Agree, me too
me too. 나도 그래요.~^^
It reaches my soul everytime I listened to it.
July 4 2020. Anyone listening?
Agree. I get what the artist was saying in the song, literally or figuratively speaking. 😔😅🌌
it's Nov 13, 2021
Hell yeah love this song
Kenal lagu ini tahun 1980, sampai sekarang masih melekat dihati ini.
2022. 3. 6.sun
I remember when this song came out in the 70's one of my top favorite songs of all times. It says It all! Well crafted song!
1976! I still have the original album in mint condition, I keep it very safe, in a safe! 😂
listening to this again... brought me back to a memory from middle school... in 1981 I am now 57 years old... thank you for opening up very beautiful memories... now I remember it again....❤❤❤
Comparto el criterio solo que ahora yo tengo 65 y cuando la escuché por primera vez se me chorrearon las ligas por la música la letra en fin la pentstonics sagrsds
I cry everytime i hear this song,it mean so much to me...i dont know why but this song touches me deeply whenever i hear this....
Mee too...this is my life..
It has a deep meaning.
True Empath people feel the Deep meaning here , Trust me I know !! The Great Storm is Here !!
Ako din
Same here....I love this music so much...it really means a lot in my life...
what a spiritual song ...
i believe that everyone who listened to this song will feel relax and peace inside...
Yes
Slow rock memories
My father requested me to play this song right now and as of this moment, he's singing. ❤️
🤣
한국 jtbc뉴스보다가 급하게 검색~감미로운 음악 잘듣고갑니다
Thank you for listening to the nice music.
2023 and I’m still listening to this song. The Meaning itself is so deep❤️
😊
All rockers never grow old. You know, because they dies young but they were still alive.
좋네요.
몇일전부터 이 노래가 입에서 맴돌아서
지금 듣고 있네요.
심금을 울리는 음악
na alala ko ang aking kabataan..the best song ever..napapa iyak ako pag na dinig ko ang kantang ito..questions.
Ganda sa tenga sarap ulit ulitin
Ganda sa tenga sarap ulit ulitin
grade 4 ako sa kantang ito madalas naririnig ko sa mga binata na umiinom na noon ng tuba at naggigitara.the best tlaga mga kanta noon d gaya ngaun basura na ang mga kanta.
oo nga masyadong memorable din sakin this song
Naalla ko tambay pko sa ulilang kawayan san Joaquín pasig
역시 혼자 있을때 잘 맞는 노래. 좋은 음악 올려 주셔서 고맙습니다 Thank you
Великолепная песня, за это надо Нобелевскую премию давать! 👍
Нобелевскую премию Францу Шуберту :-)
I'm 23 years of age but i really love this kind of music. Specially classic ❤️
I like this song so much..
Me too
Watching and listening here at 2020 from Philippines! Hearing it when i was a kid year 1985.
MAG LIFE mungkin kita seumuran, sy 58thn..lagu wkt kita kecil...enak didengar dan jadi nostalgia lagu rock.. dari indonesia
Same here. I’m 49 kabayan
same here Ithink..?!
@@antireligion8679 I'm 44
1985 - Slow rock era sa Pinas
A question will always be a question and that is why this song remains the same in my heart and i'll cherish this song QUESTION since my childhood.
Don't know why the melody of this great piece really touches my soul deeply.. I do love this song💜💖 #childhoodmemory☺️
everytime i hear this song i remember my childhood days,,,it was very nice song...loved it.
I used to hear this song on buses plying the Quiapo-Guadalupe route in the mid-70's. I did'nt know the title coz it was not among the top hits at that time. I got the title from a colleague who heard me singing the few lines of the song which I knew. Tnx to youtube and the uploader, I can now hear this song to my heart's content...GOD BLESS !!!
not buses, but jeepneys too
Dont know the magic of this song. Why I dont get tired of singing and listening to it repeatedly.. what a wonderful song. So nice bck music/lyrics and VOCAL RENDETION 🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶💯❤
originaly from SCHUBERT mate around 1800 I think
I'll never get tired of this beautiful song and it's paradoxical lyrics.
.o
Ñ
Musicaly I had a long run. Born in the early 60's to a couple of musical dino's. They had records of Herp Albert, Grieg and old Sweedish dansmusic.
Thank you for that heritage.
When I started to buy records my self it was often not the most expencive and modern records I ended up with. But I looked in the recordshops boxes of low priced failed records.
And sometimes I found gold. The Roaring silence lp was very cheap and is probably one of my most valuble treasures to this day.
An incredible musical eargasm that had a big impact on my future musical preferences.
Questions is my pathway to contemperary music. The melancoly and instrumental geniuos of this song hits my central music core.
Schubert ♡♡♡ this melody is so hauntingly beautiful!
Heute Abend in Offenburg live erlebt !!! Super toll und eine irre Zeitreise in meine Jugend !!! mit meiner Tochter - heute so jung wie ich damals !!!! Irre............tolle Zeit, super Musik !!!!!
Jedna z najpiękniejszych pereł z mojego worka ulubionych :)
The message of truth & life is truly covered in this song. Very deep ...
Eine zeitlose, wunderschöne Ballade. Gesanglich, Instrumental, einfach schön.
Very beautiful song... ‘‘terima kasih Sudah upload
I grew up with this beautiful song, it reminds me of all my friends who loved the song as well.
when i heard this song i can't believe that chris thompson sings different in this song and in his solo career
The depth of this song captured my soul
2020 still listening to this piece of Quality Classic Rock Music...
Slow Rock Memories....
NO QUESTION,ONE OF THE BEST ROCK BALLADS,!!! Of all time....
I am 55 years old man from Indonesia this guys changed all my live by thid song, such a wonderful pictures I keep deep in my hurt.Thank for your music.
KRIDO HARTLAND ,BATANG - INDONESIA.
This is a beautiful Piece of Music and the basic melody is quite old (1860's), it is Franz Schubert's Impromptu No. 3 in G flat. Still I adore what Manfred Mann made from it!
hartmutcc63 you had very good ears for music well done..
Well done mate! You have very broad horizon of great music. Thanks!
❤ thank you :-)
I cros my heatt
indeed
The guitare sounds makes me think at te band Kayak from the Netherlands.... similar kind of music...very beautiful...poems put on music...
Hallo untuk semua penggemar Manferd Mann, saya tidak tahu persis magna lagu ini tapi abgi saya ada kengangan sangat indah sekali,mari kita berbagi kebahagian
Regards for all,
Sulyadi Indonesia
Sulyadi Soekaemi : mengajak kita untuk introspeksi
luarbiasa ni lagu...
Dalem..dengerin lagu ini pas malam..cuaca langit terang,kita liat keatas...betapa kecilnya kita..dibandingkan dengan ciptaan Tuhan
Sangat puitis maknanya sulit ditangkap tapi indah
@@TheSeeta59 suara & lagu ny keren menyentuh hati banget ..!!!
Woowwww... 1st time in 40 years.. I've heard again.. I was 15 then🙈😍
Музыка моей молодости! Спасибо,КЛАСС.
Everlasting song with magical lyric for me. I do not know why this song is always keep it inside my mind, body & soul! very inspiring me👍🏼👍🏼
questions are always part of our lives...what a song...
Wow ..the pictures in the video are beautiful... a nice complement to the song
this song never old..remind me when i was a child.
The start of red horse,wat amazing
Nice song remaind me when i was a child..
Yes a great music of manfreds mann, i love this song until now and forever.. great songs ever!
I really love SLOW ROCK MUSIC!!! Thank you for uploading this kind of music.
정말 오랫동안 잊고 살았는데 우연히 여기서 듣네요.
너무나도 멋지고 완벽한 곡이라서 잠자기전까지도 반복해서 들었었는데 어쩌다 까맣게 잊었을까요????
감동입니다.
the singer voice is superbly beautiful and the lyrics pricks my heart.
Verry well said angie motenegro.
its 2019 of September,who still listens
Vu en concert 4 fois, et j écoute encore et toujours la même magie, le groupe accroche. le LP Chance, de 1980, est un bel Opus.
j écoute beaucoups d autres groupes et de différents styles
le LP du groupe BLUR , magic whip , les stones, KISS, the CAN, FAUST, DYLAN, Mothley Crüe, .........
Me
Even in december
Me
Great song. I remember my childhood when my father playing this music
I love this music..one of my favourite song,,,it was included i n the slow rock memory vol.1.
I remember good old days with my friends during my teener years. It's one of my precious moments.
Thank you for sharing this - gives me goosebumps every time I hear it!
:')
This is one of the songs my father used to play when i was little
Same here, same memory.
Timeless, not heard this for years!
When this song came out I bought the album and wore it out playing this GEM. Great music. Must have in there music collection.
Slow rock is forever never fades out...
+richard sumang Good musics doesn't have an expiration date !
? I love this song
Ķ
World most beautiful song! Love this song!
Спасибо огромное ШЕДЕВР!!!
Still listening in May 30 2019, some of my collegeu are Gone. Thanks God im still here.🌏🌏🌍🌎
I heard this song on my father's old radio one Sunday afternoon, when I was very little... I thought "answered questions with questions" was funny. I heard this song again in the taxi this morning and finally, I understood it. Memories, emotions came flooding... raw emotions I didn't know existed until this morning. Beautiful lyrics, lovely melody...
I remember when i was in high school days. This is one of my favorite slow rock songs. And now im in middle age, i still love playing this song.
This one my favorite song, I'm watching from Rome Italy
Love this song back then,till now! Slow rock,never dies
Make my eyes burst into tears, the song which my Dad used to play for me when i was 3 years old.
Hope you hear this song in heaven too Dad
The intro is from Franz Schubert's Impromptu No. 3 in Gb. That's why this song is immortal.
Omg!...reminiscin this classic song...I was in my high school days! ..Epic!!!
I've never got tied of listening to this song.
A song that turns to the inner core of each one! INTERIORITY!
Although I'm not a big MMEB fan, this is one of my all-time favourites. Is among my top 10 of songs ever!
Great song and wonderful pics. Thx for this. Happy X-Mas to all.
Fantastic song. I can hear this song every day!
My innocent life full of Questions.... now all question answered as age ran but not the memories... love it 4evaah!😘
Nov,15 2019,i really like this song,sobrang relate,sayang dna maibbalik ang nakaraan,
The unforgetable songs, a great singer. Thanks for upload!
Still listening here! Decembet 31, 2019. Welcome 2020
one of my favorite song in my high school life 1985-89. too much memories from candon national high school, philippines. greetings from las vegas! jun manzano❤️
hello sir mY kapatid ako jan sa santiago lapit sa candon... joe@vida escalona sa butol santiago. luv ko rin ang song nato. sirdodong balaga frm bantacan new bataan davao de oro. rgrda all
Yey another great song bu the Mann! Mellow but powerful!
Our Lord JESUS CHRIST is the Light of the world. Whoever follows Him will never walk in darkness, but will have the light of life. Follow JESUS CHRIST and you will be saved !
For as long as the search for this it is one of the most beautiful song I heard Thank you very much
Wonderful lyrics!
good music as this lasts decades..forever love slowrock!
beautiful...used to smoke weeds when i was younger while listening to this song
Remembers wheen I was 17,18 years old. What a wonderful feeling listening this so many years after. Stil feeling moved by rhis master piece. I WAS 17,18 YEARS ODS Somewhere in Belgium
One of my favorite songs , i still remember when I was in high school . When someone who love me .
Firstt heard this song when i was in Jeddah, am now 65 and still listening this song in my hometown Santiago City, Philippines.
I want to drink more, more and more! Ang sarap talaga ng panahon namin.. tamang 120...
Yeah, lakaz nun. Sinolo mo e, pwede naman 60 60 plus kabayo. Lakas tama.
ANUNG BRAND MU NUON? PLAIN BA HILIG NYU?
Sò profound...Manfred Mann n the Earth band so underrated...
Chris Thompson was lead vocals on this superb song.
Lovely song.
Excellent video creation.
what a beautiful song... i covered this song of my funeral....
ang gumawa ng kantang ito ay grabi ang pinagdaanan sa buhay,sobrang ganda nga mensahe
still listening in 2019 .. was my lullaby when i was child... :)
Ang slow rock song ang nag papalakas ng loob ko at nag tatanggal ng mga problema said Buhay ko.
Digging my chilhood's memories...
Love my father, mother n all family in bandung
40+ years and every time I hear it, is as fresh as ever.
great classic song! With this song I ain't got question.
An admirer of their hit singles of the seventies, to my eternal shame I was slow to embrace their albums beyond Solar Fire - but I have formed the opinion that The Roaring Silence, from whence this comes, is a faultless, glittering jewel of a recording.
Absolutely Mantastic ☺