Are Coral Reefs Disappearing?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 вер 2024
- Does global warming threaten coral reefs? To the contrary, data show that corals are thriving in modestly warmer waters, and even are expanding their range.
Support this content 👉Donate - The Heartland Institute
heartland.org/...
Watch Linnea every Friday LIVE at 1 p.m. ET on The Climate Realism Show. / theheartlandinstitute
Download a FREE copy of Climate at a Glance for Teachers and Students and get the app so you are never without resources to combat climate alarmism: climateataglan...
…Or help us out by purchasing a hard copy on Amazon: shorturl.at/deiKS
Follow us on Instagram 👉@HeartlandInstitute
We’re on Facebook 👉 The Heartland Institute
Follow Linnea on Twitter 👉 / linnealueken
Sources used for this video can be found here: climateataglan...
Previously watched several people involved in protecting the great barrier reef saying it is actually thriving.
The great barrier reef is at its greatest extent ever.
Coral scares in Australia began in the 1980s, and they happen about once every 4-5 years when 'researchers' are running low on grant funds.
True
In the 80s they were just starting to collect data and thought that things like crown of thorn starfish were introduced species from merchant ship ballast tanks. Now they know CoTSF are natural and their numbers fluctuate , they better understand the flow of sediment and the effects of freshwater from cyclones. The scientists who are old and use data know the reef is fine, the ones that are sponsored by the I P C C and often have never dived there are the ones spreading the bad rumors. Climatology seems to be the only branch of science where you make more money by not using substantiated data.
HORSESHIT. The fucking coal government of Australia even said you're full of shit as well as this Ms. Luken petroleum engineer.
outlookreport.gbrmpa.gov.au/about/1-about-report
You will be very interested in the "Evidence Used' section, but of course you won't read it, can you even read?
Finally! Some decent science rather than emotive scaremongering. Well done!
You know the content is gonna be good when you get the UA-cam label warning on "Climate change."
And when someone is telling the truth about convid and vaxis you get an ad about covid vaxins.
Heartily agree, I use it as a recommendation.
@@gcujimmy Except that "warning" is on BOTH the real climate science and this FAKE climate science. So why not watch the real climate science? Because truly it ain't about the science but it is about YOUR brainwashing.
In Australia the Great Barrier Reef is in pristine condition. You can visit it anytime you want and it's beautiful. Of course you can keep telling us that it's dying but it's clear it's not.
A breath of sanity in an insane world! Thank you
From Australia. Our Professor Ridd lost his job for saying our Barrier Reef is not dying.
He did not tow the party line. Leftists always silenced dissent, because their lies cannot tolerate factual analysis, and Leftist power depends on maintaining their lies.
Yes, I remember how he was treated back then !!
@@TheVilborg ANYONE who doesnt agree with the agenda is 'removed', they need to claim consensus of opinion...
He also pointed out that pesticides are so diluted by the time the water reaches the reef that it also cannot affect it.
The original damage was caused by storms and an infestation of spiny sea urchins which eat coral!
Thank you for speaking the truth. Professor Peter Ridd had recently posted a video 2 days ago explaining the difference types or species of coral that become affected more than other coral, such as the Acropora that is affected by tropical cyclones and bleaching. But in10 years or less, the Acropora coral reestablishes itself in numbers.
What a great young person Linnea is...! Andrew from England
The same species of corals that live in the great barrier reef are also found off the coast of Vietnam and there the water is two degrees warmer than in Australia 🤔 and they have no problems there.
Apart from drag net fishing from the bad neighbors
I went to the Great Barrier Reef to count acanthaster planki in the early 90’s. It hasn’t changed since then.
she sure makes temperatures rise
And other things!!!!
@@jonhunter8737 Mine too.
Linea is a peach!
Love these shorts, great information. Will definitely order book.
much of the damage to the Great Barrier Reef occurred during cyclone seasons.
Which is typically accompanied with an influx offresh water.
Put fresh water in a saltwater aquarium and see what happens
Spoken like a Qld senator 😂
There's more coral reef now than ever the coral reef like warm water and we've got one water and we got more coral reef so get over it
Keep up the good work yourselves and the Climate Discussion Nexus are a regular source of sanity.
Ask the CCP who is doing the most coral destruction?
what
@@Kiyoone South China Sea for a start. CCPs third fleet are a plague of poisonous destructive locusts.
oooh i like the new look Linnea
4k is the way to go, Great message
Thanks again for, as always, presenting the truth in a calm, clear, rational manner! Sad thing is that fear propaganda, anything with high emotional content, is what the average MSM viewer wants to see...It brings up the advertising revenues. Watch the old movie "Network 1976".
Thank you. It is wonderful to see and hear facts instead of alarmist nonsense.
sort of reminds me of the prairie fires that happen where i'm from. Some "expert" says it will be 100 years before the top soil is rebuilt to grow grass. The year after the fire it is the greenest spot in the whole pasture because all the dead grass is gone. New growth happens the same year, or after the winter is over, depending on when the fire happened.
That "expert" is an idiot. Farmers regularly burn off fields to kill off pests and to.put more alkalinity into the soil. And yes, it does grow back greener and healthier almost over night
Oh hell, the reefs at the Bikini Atoll are thriving and we detonated 23 nuclear devices there...
My understanding is that during Covid reefs recovered because there were no tourists.
Thank you for spreading the truth
2:22 Yes. you too. 😍
Coral loves warmer water. With increased water temps, coral will expand millions of square miles in the ocean
Top quality , thanks so much for this will subscribe !
Amazing how there is a context climate change banner attached to this actual facts on the Great Barrier Reef. 🤣
Thank you. Keep us informed with the truth, facts, and examples of success.
Fresh water after a storm and flooding also harms coral reefs.
If its is so bad, why are tourists still allowed to ramble all over it???
I just found this series of videos and find them very interesting and informative. Thanks
Wonderful videos! Thank you for reasoned truth👍
Nature will look after herself, she has been doing it pretty well now for millions of years.
It's almost like, we may not know everything.
The reefs that I fish is absolute thriving, the wind here in North Queensland has stopped nearly all fishing for over 3 months now
Hanuma Bay in Oahu and Mermaid Reef in Abaco were spectacular the first time I visited them. On the most recent visits to these places, all coral was dead and covered with silt. Too many tourists with sunblock may be the reason.
I just was on zanzibar. Zanzibar used to be a giant coral reef (and under water). Coral reefs come and go
Good information, formation, thank you.
Coral reefs dye off when large amounts of fresh water is dumped into the ocean from storms,
Coral is mostly Calcium carbonate, carbonate comes from CO2 dissolved in water.
Hence more CO2 in our world means more 'food' for new coral reefs.
The last i saw was the reefs are increasing in area over the past decade.
Interesting how under the video there is no ability to share the link.....
Could you do a video on the hole in the ozone? Last week there was a news piece about all the things mankind is doing that is making it worse.no mentions about all the volcanoes under it.
Thanks for your vids and honestly
Doesn't matter if any reef dies, they're not permanent features on Earth. They will grow and die off all the time.
No, the coral reefs all over the world are growing, but we have to use coral safe sunscreens and body washes
Wow! Beautiful lady.
Look up the heartland institute.
Yes, coral reefs are dying. The data is clear.
It's all about the narrative. If they can't scare you, they can't control you.
I doubt the sunscreen part.
There aren't thousands or millions of people covered in sunscreen swimming on the reef.
No they come and go wake up
It’s a planet
Ok, pay attention now. This is important: i have checked with the Australian Institute of Marine Biology. One the one hand they have stated that the great barrier reef has recovered from earlier blows but on the other hand they say there is a danger from too many blows in short time succession and that the kind of coral recovery is rather one sided ie, it has an impact on the bio diversity of the reef. So, not the extend in quantity is important but the quality. They also do not claim the reef is dying which is what the media say. And then there are articles on the website about the dangers of climate change. Conclusion, how is the average person to know what is real? Do i take Reed's side and trust him so i then do not trust the institute? Hard to know. Like w almost everything, the positivos do not see the bad side or claim it is not important. The negativos always point to where things go wrong and project more bad stuff happening in the future. All this in context of a conversation w a biologist friend of mine who is clearly on the doom side who pulled out example after example of 'evidence'. I dont know where the truth lies anymore, HELP!
Sorry, it is Ridd not Reed. Must be the reefs..
Maybe try looking at ice and rock core sample data that shows the Earth has positively flourished in much higher concentrations of atmospheric CO2 and we are presently in a CO2 drought in relative terms of how old the Earth is? Also try and understand what the Milankovich cycle means for our planet along with El Nino and La Niña and the circulatory patterns of the Worlds oceans that transfer heat/energy from the Sun to our Oceans which are then circulated and give rise to our weather and thus the ‘climate’ 😊
Corals adapt by exchanging zooxanthel that no alarmist can bury. It is proven in more and more studies, the only concern for them is
that it won't be enough. However, this is only from the point of view of an alarmist, because zooxanthellas have a huge diversity and we know zooxanthellas that already thrive without problems even in the worst bleaches - Durusundium, Cladocopicum-C1, C15, C3,... Even within an almost identical group, they can have different tolerances, and more and more resistant are developing. Understand that scientists can't just say that corals will survive even if they have sufficient results. Scientists must always have an open conclusion, and thus alarmism will always get out of the discussion through these holes. You can never be 100 percent sure.
once you're sufficiently concerned with the environment, one will naturally seek the information on co2, specifically its "greenhouse gas" properties. then, once you follow the math to see just how dire the situation is for yourself, you notice how utterly trivial it is. less than 1% temp differences from co2's heat retention properties. co2, even if it was 100% of the atmosphere, could not increase the temps on earth more than 1%, thats simply the physics on how much heat it can "hold" (bad way to say it but thats the nomenclature of today). do your own research
The Hunga Tonga volcano in January 2002 put a significant amount of water into the stratosphere. A 10% increase which is expected to persist for several years. Nature has done a number of articles on this, otherwise ignored, event.
Nature predicted that the water vapor would cause an average temperature increase of around 1.5 C. That effect would persist for some years.
The key article can be found in the Jan 2022 publication of Nature.
Why would she describe coral that had bleached because the living organisms that build it and colour it had left? ua-cam.com/video/WHv5qxC927s/v-deo.html
Based 👍
Like people old ones die and new ones are born.
Thank you for sharing much appreciated
Isn’t truth refreshing.😊
This lady is not only beautiful but she is intelligent and intellectual. What a combination. Any chance of a date 🌹🌹❤❤
nice work. Keep it up.
I swear, you are quickly becoming my hero.
No more fear porn. Thank You!
HORSESHIT. It's not "fear" it's reality, and hiding the truth of that reality is the lie and makes for angry upset kids who grow up and overthrow governments.
Oil company shills say "nothing to see here" - continue to makes us billionaires at the expense of the planet.
Concerns about Eastern Australia's Great Barrier Reef, Western Australia's Ningaloo Reef and All Australia's Coastal/River Marine Environments is Based on More than Just the Condition of the Coral.
Australian's, Including Native Australian's Love to Fish for and Eat Fish, Sharks, Turtles Etc.
Plus Australians are Very Good at Fishing and been Fishing for Hundreds of Years, Thousands of Years for the Natives. At Times Australia has Mostly Accidentally, Damaged the Coral when Fishing.
Hence the Constant Reminders to Care for the Marine Life Including Coral is to Allow the Marine Life to Recover Before They go Extinct.
But Bigger Picture Issues of Possible Ocean Rises and Increased Temperature is Also a Concern.
Good Topic.
Go dive the coral triangle, you’ll see the same coral in waters so hot you can’t use a wet suit.
@mal4821
Fair Point, Tasmania and Melbourne get only a Few Hot Days per Year.
Most Days Mild or Cold.
Let's cherry pick and say that everything is cool and normal. Embarrassed boomers love this.
60,000,000 years? Really 😮 please explain how you arrived at that number. Before that no coral? Just evolved like us humans and blueberries. When did blueberries first appear, 60,000,000? Why not the evolution genie can do anything.
You can use coral growth like tree rings. Secondly various mountains have fossilised coral in the rock.
Not hard.
Saved to my HIStory Is A Set Of Lies Agreed Upon.
Well hate to disagree with you but the reefs in the Florida Keys are definitely dying and the fish are gone
☠️
🤑
How much did it cost to sell your soul linnea?
You have obviously lost your own "soul". She is right. There are MANY top scientists saying the same things, but they are being silenced. There are many channels dedicated to the truth, Tom Nelson for example. You need to wake up to the misinformation about the fictitious "climate catastrophe", and understand the sinister reasons behind the lies.
Why are you watching all her videos and make the same comment/s. Instead of looking like a complete idiot why do you not post something, anything to refute her claims?
Not sure about linnea, but what did you pay to get into the cult?
Physics is not a cult
@@tobyradenbaugh8965 Climate alarmism is certainly a cult. A very dark cult indeed.
It's always been about profit and control. It was never about the climate.
Yep. No different than the anti oil and gas lefties. They claim that we're running out of these resources. However, once dried up deposits are revisited several years later, only to find they are full again. Oil and gas are not "fossil" fuels. They are naturally produced substances of the earth, and I would argue that if we don't continue using it there will be more problems like unwanted tar pits. But I would never get a grant with ideas like that.
☠️
Loving all the shorts you guys are putting out! Going to make countering talking points so much easier.
Holy heckers batman, this woman will make someone a wonderful wife. Thanks for being so real and telling it how it is! Refreshing!
Thank you Dear Linnea Lucken and all Heartland Institute. I will add this video to Climate Realism playlist.
Thanks Linnea, keep up the good work.
Thank you for speaking truth. Kind regards.
For what it's worth, coral of the coast of the Red Sea is as pristine as anything at Great Berrior and The Red Ssea is as HOT as bath water. GO figure.
what a breath of fresh air you are
What a beautiful young lady these videos should be played in every school on the planet.. instead of that scaremongering dropkick Al Gore..👏👏👌..
Very very weak and incomplete, how many rings equal 60,000,000? Fossils in mountains? How and when did fossils climb up into the mountains? I bet there were millions of sea shells in the mountains too! Hmm 🧐 Common sense or as I call it God’s sense is a thing of the past. So sorry you can’t see creation in anything. It’s everywhere in everything you only need common sense, faith and heart. God Bless
Amazing how many times scientists keep getting it wrong, And still got the absolute gaul to keep telling us where still going to cook too death😡
this channel is nothing but a propaganda machine for the rich
I've been watching the coral story and this video appeared in my timeline. Thank you, it sets the record straight in so many ways. Also love the website that goes with it. It is also a great resource. 👍
Any UA-cam video like this that comes with the blue "warning" band is well worth watching. I learned that during Covid. They're usually the best resources on the internet.
Thanks
😘🌹 Linnea)
Great video but please can you post it without the awful, distracting background music, please? 🙏
could it be decades of radioactive water being dumped into the ocean by Japan?
The water they are releasing into the ocean has one seventh of the radiation allowed in drinking water.
A few years ago these same people would probably have been telling you folks that smoking doesn't kill ya.
Balance is the key to this measured enlightenment.
Your references 12 and 13 don't work.
Gee, wunder the fuck why?
@@mrunning10 🤣
☠️
☠️