What you said is correct. Accept facts as they are. Bose failed to achieve Purna Swaraj & it doesn't mean we are disrespectful to him. Many freedom fighters wanted RāmaRājya, they all failed in achieving it. It's a fact. It doesn't mean we are disrespect to those freedom fighters.
@@shantanuroy8462 nothing personal here but as an Indian you should respect the wise. so please it's a little suggestion to call Abhijit Chavda sir as "sir" , If you had understood the facts then you got the answer within.
@@Aritra_Tozo Bro nothing personal but please come out of the colonial slave mentality, sir was an honor given by the crown to control whom they like and whom to respect, you can respect someone even without refering to them as SIR
@@shantanuroy8462 truth but I guess I misunderstood your opinion and now you have given me back the same shit. Anyway it's alright 👍 Follow whatever you want and have your own cognitions.
"One individual may die for an idea, but that idea after his death would reincarnate itself into a thousand lives" - Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose the Great.
Lets work towards making Subhash Ji dream of Bharat come true.🙏🇮🇳 After 25 years when we celebrate 100 years of independence we should be the greatest country in the world and the greatest superpower.🇮🇳🙏
Bro it's practically impossible please study some economics . We are a poor country in the world currently as per gdp per capita.we ,ay become a middle income country till 2047 but not great or something 😢
@@prateekagarwal3789 that's why we have greatest respect for Bose ji .... But sometimes you need leave see things without emotions so we can learn from it, yes he failed his idea of independence was totally different and better but we can learn from mistakes and always improves
Wonderful. I got enlightened by this explanation. Yes, our mental standards need to be raised. If we are a BOSE at heart, then we must inculcate all the values, standards and realism that he embodied
I completely agree with Mr. Abhijit, there is no disrespect meant to Netaji in saying that Netaji failed. Don't live in an emotional lalaland....if Netaji truly succeeded, India would've been a superpower by now and we would have had Pakistan and Bangladesh in our grasp.
"It's better to get hurted by TRUTH than getting comforted by a LIE". Not only Netaji, All our ancestors from past 1000-1200 years failed. One thing we can learn is When you fail You will start from scratch.
If you say 1000-1200 years, I doubt you don't have any knowledge about Indian history of that time... India was THE power then... Make yourself correct
@@_Satyamevjayate lol arabs conquered Sindh in 7th century and in later 12th century islamic invaders already captured many parts in North India, Revise your history kid.
@@Smarty-tz1jt yes i will edit it its not completely but they failed is ultimate truth.Yes we can practice freely our traditions no doubt still we get mocked for that in the name of modernism. but still Hyenas are waiting patiently to establish their territory.
@@hiddendagger7291 yes bro shivaji maharaj was indeed successful.If today we Hindus are free to practice our religion, maximum credit goes to shivaji maharaj 🙏.But still we have lots of Hyenas in the nation.
MR.BOSS DIDN'T FAIL, WE FAILED HIM. We didn't work for his ideas, we accepted the slavery of an new royal family set up by the British (the Gandhi family).And the old British institutions.😔
I knew this was going to be your argument... I love Subhas Bose same as I love India...but this is true that he had failed. It's hard to accept but a truth is a truth.we can't be emotional.
Nailed it! To this day I have trouble with Indians all over the world - they are thankful for having received anglicized education, for being able to work globally, etc. At what cost? At the cost of their self-esteem? I used to be one of those since my education and English language skills allow me to work with people from all over the world. That is a great ability but not the be all and end all. There is so much more to life. The greatest change happened to me when I started looking in the mirror - take a good look at yourself and see how you are faring by the standards of your own culture - not the ones that were imposed upon you. We've got to be better than glorified slaves. Abhijit Ji's views are always spot on and the young are very lucky to be able to glean some wisdom from these videos. Jai Bharat! 💪🙏🕉
I stand by your Mr. Chavda, I idolize Netaji as the one of the greatest heroes of this nation and whatever he did was phenomenal. On the other hand this is also true that Netaji who was afterwards known as Gumnami Baba was not satisfied with himself and he himself has said that he failed to truly liberate India.
#AskAbhijit Greetings, Sir. I am a student of business administration & I was planning to go out to the west for further studies. Fortunately for me, I am the curious one & started reading about how West plundered & robbed us of our treasury, knowledge & glory(Shameful act). Now, by looking at how my country needs the youth to stay here, support it & make it prosperous from the very roots of it I started preparing for Civil Services Examination. But to my surprise it's a whole different world. Sir, It hurts me to the core to see how anglophilic & left-biased things we'll have to study to be able to take an attempt at one of if not the most prestigious exams in our country(Teachers tell you that britishers did good to & for us & you have to subscribe to an utterly left-biased newspaper to even start preparing for it, The Hindu lol). Sir, Why are we, our government or any other related organization doing something about it? Why is it happening in the first place? What can we do on our level to have a better & brighter future in this context? I mean, what is a country if even it's administration is not nationalist but anglophilic & left-biased?
Watch J Saideepak ji speech about this question. We should study to get into the system but not be affected by it. Think of it as just a vessel to clear the exam and that's all
@@ehmneh5841 Absolutely, My Friend. That's Exactly What I'm Going To Do. But Let's Say, It's Me Or Maybe A Few More People Who'll Understand This Assignment & It Just Doesn't Feel Right For The Herd That Follows, It Just Converts Them Mentally. So, I Just Want Mr. Abhijit To Put Some Light On This Issue & Give Us A Clear Viewpoint. Hope You Understand.
@@DuttajiOfficial Yes brother current government has also failed to do anything about it. You know what institutions related to education are still having monopoly of bureaucrats who hate this civilisation. Sadly intellectuals like neeraj atri, meenakshi jain who try to show truth are sidelined and don't have a say. I think when common people get more and more aware of the antiquity and profoundness of our civilisation, they will gradually decolonise the institutions.
First of all, turn off the caps lock. Now to answer your question, Netaji's activities forced them to speed up the process of transfer of power. What happened in 15th August 1947 was inevitable. It might have happened a few years later if not for Netaji but It would have happened for sure. The british completed the process in a hurry because they had to made sure that the "independnce" happened at their terms.
You dont understand what he is saying ..mr bose wanted purn swaraj no partition akhand bharart his main objective was these... constitution which should be according to civilization of india ... with no fake history no fake secularism what he is saying... ek bharat srasth bharat .... in which netaji failed ... we didnt get freedom in our terms.. we got freedom in the terms of britishers...
I agree with what you said here sir totally India really needs to increase it's standards should not be offended it's not going to take us anywhere for a good cause rather conflicting will keep us narrowed and egos comes in between which is one of the major reasons to cause a war either physically or psychologically. The one's who is being offended should know that there is a thing called "Optimism" beyond positivity and negativity. Your words gives me chills sir! You're the inspiration for our generation to question everything. Thanks for such powerful content. Keep fighting sir the one who knows the worth of your words of wisdom will be on your side as I am.
Netaji failed tactically but succeeded to make the British fear another 1857 revolt which was enough to give up the Raj. If India is still dependent on any foreign power then it's our mistake. Netaji was the catalyst to independence. We can't be sure of what exactly sampoorna swaraaj exactly meant.
Netaji was a legend. He was intellectual, fearless, and selfless. All these qualities are rarely present in an individual. To see the impact of Netaji, one needs to see the unbiased opinion of British leaders during that time. Netaji's contribution was immense and to say anything otherwise is stupidity.
Sir 1 question.... I preparing for UPSC exam...one of history teacher ( from famous online coaching institute 🔥) explain me that if we will give independence through military action then military coup will normal in our country 🇮🇳 like Africa now...and Gandhi realise it and sideline Mr Bose...what your thoughts sir???( My hero is Netaji so i leave him and preparing by own)
America got independence through armed struggle as well and so do many countries which are in developed category right now. Ask this to your teacher in next class. Your teacher is superimposing his belief in the name of causality..he decided the reason first and molded the incidents according to it. A History teacher must be factual otherwise he is a politician using history to build a narrative. BEWARE!
This argument is as stupid as it can get. This is a standard one though, if it comes in exam, write the same...but don't accept it as truth. Marathas revolted against the Adil Shahis and established their empire. Every state is built upon other state. No one just hands over power. So, the state you are living is built upon other states. This is the natural law, and no bullshit argument about "peaceful" Satyagraha being solely responsible for India's independence can whitewash truth. By that logic, people who were involved in 1857 War of Independence (including Rani Laxmi Bai, Kunwar Singh, Nana Saheb, Tatiya Tope, Mangal Pandey etc.) should also be censored and their sculptures removed. Americans won their independence from British, French removed their monarchy, and Britain itself achieved its democracy in a violent manner. But these are legitimate states today, aren't they?! Power and stability deriving out of it is the only legitimacy, arguments don't fight wars! Also, it was because of INA and later RIN and other mutinies that British packed up their bags so fast! And Army can designed or structured in a manner that coup is not the norm. Checkout US, UK etc. They have strong military, but that doesn't seize power from democratic form of governance.
We must answer in a language which the enemy understands. If someone from family use kindness and words. If enemy country use force then you use force.🇮🇳🙏
We r actually fed up with this type of Islami-Marxist teacher..... How we will fight to stop brain 🧠 washing our youth's??? That type of teachers always explain that Hinduism,buddism are inferior and our kings also and when they explain about Islam omg 😱 they are mahan sultans and prophet Muhammad for establishing peace from chaotic situations in pre-islamic Arabia established Islam 🤣..... Hypocracy ki v koi seema hoti hai They will not explain that prophet Muhammad's family+ Quraish tribes religion was pagan god's ( specially Hubal - similar to our lord Shiva)... Allah also a moon deity of pagan religion.... Ferista ( angel's) took from Christianity.... When prophet Muhammad attack Macca and destroy 300+ pegan god's statue 🗿 and called then boothh (Saytan) and from here the idea came to destroy hindu gods in India 🇮🇳... Then will not explain it... How we will stop 🛑 them???
I have been wondering and don't understand why India is in British Commonwealth Countries(Is it only for sporting events) along with so many other countries of the world.
Same goes for B.R. Ambedkar. He never wanted any kind of reservation as it directly goes against his philosophy of equality amongst all castes. But the arya samaj and congress didn't like that philosophy. As a desperate last attempt, he built the reservation system to give some rights to the scheduled castes and tribes. There is an interview of him and and English reporter on UA-cam. You can clearly see the disappointment and hopelessness in his face. He was in the 50s yet he predicted everything that's happening today. He knew that democracy will fail, simply because we are divided based on all kinds of things and vote based on that, instead of the credibility of the politician. Like Bose, he didn't get the independence he wish India got. The only true independence was for the Congress who got a piece of land to rule.
You dont understand what he is saying ..mr bose wanted purn swaraj no partition akhand bharart his main objective was these... constitution which should be according to civilization of india ... with no fake history no fake secularism what he is saying... ek bharat srasth bharat .... in which netaji failed ... we didnt get freedom in our terms.. we got freedom in the terms of britishers...
Madamji,jo bhi log ww2 main american+ aliance ke khilaf lade the uske upar america+ country ne war criminal ka charge lagaya tha...aur british empire ke dwara sedision ka charge lagaya jata...aur ye desh india ke upar bose ko handover karne ka pressure banate aur us samay par hamari koi aukat nahi thi ki ham uk aur usa ko mana kar paye,aur mana bhi karte to bahot sara economic nukshan bhugtana padta..aur shayad unko fansi hoti... Bose saheb hamare liye hero the par unke liye criminal the...it's all about perspactive...
There is a video of Anuj Dhar on this. You can see the interview on TRS and this channel. The main reason was if he had revealed himself post independence he feared there would be riots and political clashes in the country especially in Bengal.
That way it would be correct to say he succeeded and failed. Although he failed to meet all the objectives he had set for a free India, but still succeeded making a significant contribution for an independent India. Just like we fail to check all the points of a checklist but still achieve what we intend to. Some are happy with the outcome and some think it could have been better. Its sad that most of us fall in the first category and are happy with what we achieved so far.
Even I wasn't agreed with what you said about failing of Bose but this video gave me the clarity that what you really meant. Thanks for clearing things out.
My thoughts about subash ji are same as you sir❤ My father since my childhood used to say stories,struggles , and achievements of bose ji. I admire him alot. But in school i was rounded up by my classmates that i support him. Whne i was in 4th there was a debate competition everyone was preaparing for topic freedom fighters, maximum students only spoke about gandhi, and i was the only one who spoke about Subash Chandra Bose. I got consulation but that was an inspiration for me ❤ Thank you sir for tour unbiased sessions and replies 🎉
Agree with you. We need to be raise our Standards; avoid heresay and research for ourselves from primary sources to truly understand where we actually stand as a Nation today.
Great video again sir, people are too emotional that they can't see reality. Saying Bose failed isn't a disrespect towards him, but it's a fact that he wasn't able to achieve his goals, and his failure should also be attributed to British stooges like Gandhi and Nehru.
Failed or succeed do not work in black or white situation. He did not achieved what he wanted but he had an impact on Britishers mindset so we got so called independence
You're right in saying so as Netaji himself in his later part of life as Bhagwanji was depressed regarding the state of affairs in our country and that we were not an independent nation in true sense. Still, without lowering standards I will say that he did his job as planned, the onus was on the leadership here to maintain or uplift their standards to the level of Bose and continue whatever remained left after him. Sadly, they all cheated him. So while doing his part, he did not fail. But of course he as well as we should have deserved a bit better from history. 🙏
We Indians are too much in our feelings. Hardly anyone can introspect when faced with facts. They react. That's one of the reasons it has been so difficult for me to have good conversations with people.
Well Said Abhi. We don't stand a chance to even be 2nd world country. Bose dreamt of a fully conscious unified state of Bharath. He indeed failed and so do his predecessors who had similar thoughts.
I am grateful for your factual information to enlighten our understanding to True Indian Hero Subhash Bose. I am proud to have you in our Life 💖💘😇💐🌹🌹🌹🌹💝🙏🕯️🌺🪔🇮🇳🌎
It's point of view along with fact.Fact is Netaji lost the war but pont of view is he succeded even after his death in drving out British by his significant contribution .
I strongly agree with Abhijit ji. We are still not independent. Taking forward the western legacy could not be considered as independence. Many things changed but nothing changed. If something which needs to be changed, that is our own mindset and and as Abhijit ji said the standards.
@AskAbhijit We still have British era Laws like the Indian Police Act, Indian Archalogical Act and numerous others which favoured British Govt. Still these were not changed after 1947. Would you comment?
So which circumstances would have led to Netaji's Success . And what could he have done to avoid his failure and what can we learn from his and many other great freedom fighters failures to implement in our lives for self betterment and then the betterment of the nation
Namaste 🕉🙏🕉🙏:::This Independence Day, let’s take a pledge to cover the peace and concinnity of great nation of our ancestors,,Happy Independence Day. Freedom is commodity that plutocrat can’t buy, it’s the result of the struggles of our ancestors and numerous Bravehearts. Let us recognize these moment and always. Happy Independence Day 2022.,,🕉🙏🕉🙏jai hind 🕉🙏🕉.
i have read about subhash chandra bose and also noticed that he is very much celebrated in bengal..but many bengalis do praise him but no nothing about him,they just adore him for being bengali but his idea and mindset was not beyond this thinking and none of his ideas actually followed in bengal neither in their politics
Bose set in motion a series of events which led to the exit of British in India. But, you are 100% correct that 1947 was a transfer of power from the British to the allies of the British. The same system of exploitation and extraction continued without any change. This is the reason why there's such extreme poverty and extreme distribution of power and wealth in India.
Absolutely true. We have no standards . We allowed the thugs to ruin us till recently , forgetting everything that is Indian and carrying the GMT mindset. I love Bose and I want India to take his path.
#AskAbhijit Sir, I have been noticing that a lot of people especially some Indians think that India helped Bangladesh in 1971 war because of purely humanitarian ground. Was it the most dominant reason or were there other political ideas?
Hitler subjected Amin Al-Husseini, The Grand Mufti of Jerusalem (Al-Aqsa Mosque) to physical racial profiling and after getting satisfied with the findings that the later belongs to his choice of racial stock, had agreed for a meet. But in case of Subash Babu it was different, and rather 'Fuhrer' was evidently pleased to meet Netaji, as one can see the warmth from the then taken Photographs of meet. Hitler's observation on Indians was inferior as per Mein Kampf, but had he written the same book after meeting Bose the opinion could have been contrast. This clearly shows the 'Karisma' Subash Babu weilded on Global Leadership of those times. Clearly Netaji gave an impetus and made India leap decades ahead in it's sojourn, to which we all are indebted. ua-cam.com/video/EEhF2D1kUcQ/v-deo.html
I highly support #educationreform in india. Why don't we taught about these at our schools. Why we get to knows these things when we became graduates from our colleges.
Love u sir ❤❤❤ , sir plz Hindi m bhi content dijiye bohot saare Indian ko ye sb pata hona chahiye, pr English ki wajeh se unn tk ye pohoch nhi payegi, plzzzzz aur apki channel ki view bhi bohot Inc ho jayegi
BOSE didn't failed it's we failed to achieve Freedom that's why we got Dominion in name of Freedom BOSE didn't ask anything for himself Rather he gave himself for India. He didn't loose he gave Everything When not all but many didn't
Netaji failed and Gandhi succeeded? Then why did the British Prime Minister Atlee who signed independence to India later said they gave India independence because of "Chandra Bose". They were very scared that there will be many armed rebellions by Indian army against the British people who were in India once the Indian army finds out the details of the Netaji's military efforts using Indian army POWs. British already started seeings signs of that and that got scared. They knew Indian army can kill the British army in India like an elephant can kill an ant because the Indian army vastly outnumbered British soliders in India. Atlee said British were not scared of Gandhi at all and so Gandi was not the reason British left. This relevation came straight from Atlee. So, now tell me who succeeded and who failed? Who gave us India's independence? Not Gandhi and Nehru.
Indian youth should realize this - We gave away 33% of Bharat to just 25% of Indian population (Muslims who created Pakistan exclusively for themselves) with hope that the Hindu civilization can survive and there would be peace. But today we still get a Kanhaiyya being beheaded and a Nupur Sharma going into hiding for the rest of her life for no fault of theirs. What did the partition achieve when neither a top politician nor an ordinary tailor is safe from being murdered by the Jihadis, who decide collectively whom to target? True freedom is when EVERY person who identifies with the Bharatiya civilization is equal in every way and 100% free from fear & hate irrespective of which god he prays to. How can there be peace when 80% of Indians are treated as Kafirs and Mushriks by a violent minority, which wants no peace till the 80% is annihilated?
In my opinion, Subhash Chandra Bose failed at personal level, because he did not get the necessary support he expected from the axis powers in world war two. Each of them obviously had their individual objectives to pursue, and did not care much to aid Subhash Chandra Bose in his attempts to start an armed struggle for securing independence for our country. Hence his failure has to be logically expected. But his single minded approach, supreme personal sacrifices, and selfless efforts would definitely have inspired thousands of Indian soldiers in the british army and motivated them to rise in mutiny, forcing the british to realise the ungovernability of India, without the disciplined cooperation of Indian soldiers in their army.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
What you said is correct. Accept facts as they are. Bose failed to achieve Purna Swaraj & it doesn't mean we are disrespectful to him. Many freedom fighters wanted RāmaRājya, they all failed in achieving it. It's a fact. It doesn't mean we are disrespect to those freedom fighters.
Nobody is disrespect anyone, he is just saying that Netaji failed and even Netaji would agree that he failed
@@shantanuroy8462 nothing personal here but as an Indian you should respect the wise. so please it's a little suggestion to call Abhijit Chavda sir as "sir" , If you had understood the facts then you got the answer within.
@@Aritra_Tozo Bro nothing personal but please come out of the colonial slave mentality, sir was an honor given by the crown to control whom they like and whom to respect, you can respect someone even without refering to them as SIR
@@shantanuroy8462 truth but I guess I misunderstood your opinion and now you have given me back the same shit. Anyway it's alright 👍
Follow whatever you want and have your own cognitions.
"If it offends you so be it" 👍
That's the confidence we need.
Respect 🙌
"One individual may die for an idea, but that idea after his death would reincarnate itself into a thousand lives"
- Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose the Great.
Lets work towards making Subhash Ji dream of Bharat come true.🙏🇮🇳
After 25 years when we celebrate 100 years of independence we should be the greatest country in the world and the greatest superpower.🇮🇳🙏
Bro it's practically impossible please study some economics . We are a poor country in the world currently as per gdp per capita.we ,ay become a middle income country till 2047 but not great or something 😢
He tried his level best to bring Real Freedom to india through force.. it's sad he failed
But the impact was High.
We "WON" independence right after INA battle with British , navle mutiny , army rebels took place.
Its not always about win or lose its all about your ethics vision and commitment towards motherland thats what it matters
@@prateekagarwal3789 that's why we have greatest respect for Bose ji .... But sometimes you need leave see things without emotions so we can learn from it, yes he failed his idea of independence was totally different and better but we can learn from mistakes and always improves
Well people supported the wrong guy not Bose.
Thanks to USA bombing Japan...😡
Independence is certainly not a happy word, but it conveys a special political significance which is easily understandable.
-Subhas Chandra Bose
@@mb59621 Bose The Untold Story of an Inconvenient Nationalist by Chandrachur Ghose . Page 128
@@jitendrasaverker bruh I am still stuck at India's Biggest Cover-up..... it's a hard read...but going through it anyway
Wonderful. I got enlightened by this explanation. Yes, our mental standards need to be raised. If we are a BOSE at heart, then we must inculcate all the values, standards and realism that he embodied
"One individual may die for an idea, but that idea will, after his death, incarnate itself in a thousand lives."
-Subhas Chandra Bose
I completely agree with Mr. Abhijit, there is no disrespect meant to Netaji in saying that Netaji failed. Don't live in an emotional lalaland....if Netaji truly succeeded, India would've been a superpower by now and we would have had Pakistan and Bangladesh in our grasp.
Netaji himself would say he failed
@@mahendrakhati4732 exactly, the most correct term would be 'he was backstabbed'
@@dbmp1995 yeH and we know who was that stabber
"It's better to get hurted by TRUTH than getting comforted by a LIE".
Not only Netaji, All our ancestors from past 1000-1200 years failed.
One thing we can learn is
When you fail
You will start from scratch.
No not all again wrong history shivaji succeed, many others succeed currently modi is successful
If you say 1000-1200 years, I doubt you don't have any knowledge about Indian history of that time... India was THE power then... Make yourself correct
@@_Satyamevjayate lol arabs conquered Sindh in 7th century and in later 12th century islamic invaders already captured many parts in North India, Revise your history kid.
@@Smarty-tz1jt yes i will edit it its not completely but they failed is ultimate truth.Yes we can practice freely our traditions no doubt still we get mocked for that in the name of modernism. but still Hyenas are waiting patiently to establish their territory.
@@hiddendagger7291 yes bro shivaji maharaj was indeed successful.If today we Hindus are free to practice our religion, maximum credit goes to shivaji maharaj 🙏.But still we have lots of Hyenas in the nation.
Truth cannot be stated more aptly than that. Huge respect for you sir.
What Abhijit sir has said is absolutely right. We need to raise our standards in th Country level and also personal level as well.
MR.BOSS DIDN'T FAIL, WE FAILED HIM. We didn't work for his ideas, we accepted the slavery of an new royal family set up by the British (the Gandhi family).And the old British institutions.😔
Yeah I get it now. We are under the illusion that India is a free country but it truly isn't.
Some people have real trouble accepting truth and seeing things from a unbiased perspective. Glad that you are here to make them realise that
I knew this was going to be your argument... I love Subhas Bose same as I love India...but this is true that he had failed. It's hard to accept but a truth is a truth.we can't be emotional.
He is ready to keep his image, reputation on stake for our freedom..he didn't care if his image reputation got destroyed in his fight
Nailed it! To this day I have trouble with Indians all over the world - they are thankful for having received anglicized education, for being able to work globally, etc. At what cost? At the cost of their self-esteem? I used to be one of those since my education and English language skills allow me to work with people from all over the world. That is a great ability but not the be all and end all. There is so much more to life. The greatest change happened to me when I started looking in the mirror - take a good look at yourself and see how you are faring by the standards of your own culture - not the ones that were imposed upon you. We've got to be better than glorified slaves.
Abhijit Ji's views are always spot on and the young are very lucky to be able to glean some wisdom from these videos. Jai Bharat! 💪🙏🕉
Let's all accept the brutal reality and Improve our standards.
I stand by your Mr. Chavda, I idolize Netaji as the one of the greatest heroes of this nation and whatever he did was phenomenal. On the other hand this is also true that Netaji who was afterwards known as Gumnami Baba was not satisfied with himself and he himself has said that he failed to truly liberate India.
Freedom is not given
It is taken
- Subhash Chandra Bose
#AskAbhijit Greetings, Sir. I am a student of business administration & I was planning to go out to the west for further studies. Fortunately for me, I am the curious one & started reading about how West plundered & robbed us of our treasury, knowledge & glory(Shameful act). Now, by looking at how my country needs the youth to stay here, support it & make it prosperous from the very roots of it I started preparing for Civil Services Examination. But to my surprise it's a whole different world. Sir, It hurts me to the core to see how anglophilic & left-biased things we'll have to study to be able to take an attempt at one of if not the most prestigious exams in our country(Teachers tell you that britishers did good to & for us & you have to subscribe to an utterly left-biased newspaper to even start preparing for it, The Hindu lol). Sir, Why are we, our government or any other related organization doing something about it? Why is it happening in the first place? What can we do on our level to have a better & brighter future in this context? I mean, what is a country if even it's administration is not nationalist but anglophilic & left-biased?
Watch J Saideepak ji speech about this question. We should study to get into the system but not be affected by it. Think of it as just a vessel to clear the exam and that's all
@@ehmneh5841 Absolutely, My Friend. That's Exactly What I'm Going To Do. But Let's Say, It's Me Or Maybe A Few More People Who'll Understand This Assignment & It Just Doesn't Feel Right For The Herd That Follows, It Just Converts Them Mentally. So, I Just Want Mr. Abhijit To Put Some Light On This Issue & Give Us A Clear Viewpoint. Hope You Understand.
@@DuttajiOfficial hurt the core nations who fund these left ecosystem
@@DuttajiOfficial Yes brother current government has also failed to do anything about it. You know what institutions related to education are still having monopoly of bureaucrats who hate this civilisation. Sadly intellectuals like neeraj atri, meenakshi jain who try to show truth are sidelined and don't have a say.
I think when common people get more and more aware of the antiquity and profoundness of our civilisation, they will gradually decolonise the institutions.
Nehru also needed god se
SIR A QUESTION ARISE IN MY MIND AFTER THIS LINE , MY QUES IS -
*IF NETAJI FAILED WHY CLEMENT ATTLEE SAID THAT IT WAS NETAJI WHO MADE INDIA FREEDOM* ?
First of all, turn off the caps lock.
Now to answer your question, Netaji's activities forced them to speed up the process of transfer of power. What happened in 15th August 1947 was inevitable. It might have happened a few years later if not for Netaji but It would have happened for sure.
The british completed the process in a hurry because they had to made sure that the "independnce" happened at their terms.
You dont understand what he is saying ..mr bose wanted purn swaraj no partition akhand bharart his main objective was these... constitution which should be according to civilization of india ... with no fake history no fake secularism what he is saying... ek bharat srasth bharat .... in which netaji failed ... we didnt get freedom in our terms.. we got freedom in the terms of britishers...
@@abhishekbhowmik7102 yes u r right bro ,
@@lautheimpaler4686 Also due to world war Britishers were left with very little funds and without funds they cannot run a country.
I agree with what you said here sir totally India really needs to increase it's standards should not be offended it's not going to take us anywhere for a good cause rather conflicting will keep us narrowed and egos comes in between which is one of the major reasons to cause a war either physically or psychologically. The one's who is being offended should know that there is a thing called "Optimism" beyond positivity and negativity. Your words gives me chills sir! You're the inspiration for our generation to question everything. Thanks for such powerful content. Keep fighting sir the one who knows the worth of your words of wisdom will be on your side as I am.
Nice analysis. Young generation really need to know it. 🇮🇳👌🙏
Netaji failed tactically but succeeded to make the British fear another 1857 revolt which was enough to give up the Raj.
If India is still dependent on any foreign power then it's our mistake.
Netaji was the catalyst to independence.
We can't be sure of what exactly sampoorna swaraaj exactly meant.
lokks like a statement of denial and delusion
His idea of independence didn't included partition of India
@@hiddendagger7291 I don't know of any valid sources of his idea being that. If you can point me one valid source, I am sold.
@@amvkarthik he was against federal india
He wanted every bit of land not in parts
Netaji was a legend. He was intellectual, fearless, and selfless. All these qualities are rarely present in an individual. To see the impact of Netaji, one needs to see the unbiased opinion of British leaders during that time.
Netaji's contribution was immense and to say anything otherwise is stupidity.
Sir 1 question.... I preparing for UPSC exam...one of history teacher ( from famous online coaching institute 🔥) explain me that if we will give independence through military action then military coup will normal in our country 🇮🇳 like Africa now...and Gandhi realise it and sideline Mr Bose...what your thoughts sir???( My hero is Netaji so i leave him and preparing by own)
Vietnam also had a milary coup against usa.. is vietam not devloping.. amercia got independence by military coup . AMERICA IS A SUPERPOWER..
America got independence through armed struggle as well and so do many countries which are in developed category right now.
Ask this to your teacher in next class.
Your teacher is superimposing his belief in the name of causality..he decided the reason first and molded the incidents according to it.
A History teacher must be factual otherwise he is a politician using history to build a narrative. BEWARE!
This argument is as stupid as it can get. This is a standard one though, if it comes in exam, write the same...but don't accept it as truth.
Marathas revolted against the Adil Shahis and established their empire. Every state is built upon other state. No one just hands over power. So, the state you are living is built upon other states. This is the natural law, and no bullshit argument about "peaceful" Satyagraha being solely responsible for India's independence can whitewash truth. By that logic, people who were involved in 1857 War of Independence (including Rani Laxmi Bai, Kunwar Singh, Nana Saheb, Tatiya Tope, Mangal Pandey etc.) should also be censored and their sculptures removed.
Americans won their independence from British, French removed their monarchy, and Britain itself achieved its democracy in a violent manner. But these are legitimate states today, aren't they?!
Power and stability deriving out of it is the only legitimacy, arguments don't fight wars!
Also, it was because of INA and later RIN and other mutinies that British packed up their bags so fast!
And Army can designed or structured in a manner that coup is not the norm. Checkout US, UK etc. They have strong military, but that doesn't seize power from democratic form of governance.
We must answer in a language which the enemy understands.
If someone from family use kindness and words. If enemy country use force then you use force.🇮🇳🙏
We r actually fed up with this type of Islami-Marxist teacher..... How we will fight to stop brain 🧠 washing our youth's??? That type of teachers always explain that Hinduism,buddism are inferior and our kings also and when they explain about Islam omg 😱 they are mahan sultans and prophet Muhammad for establishing peace from chaotic situations in pre-islamic Arabia established Islam 🤣..... Hypocracy ki v koi seema hoti hai
They will not explain that prophet Muhammad's family+ Quraish tribes religion was pagan god's ( specially Hubal - similar to our lord Shiva)... Allah also a moon deity of pagan religion.... Ferista ( angel's) took from Christianity.... When prophet Muhammad attack Macca and destroy 300+ pegan god's statue 🗿 and called then boothh (Saytan) and from here the idea came to destroy hindu gods in India 🇮🇳... Then will not explain it... How we will stop 🛑 them???
Happy independence day sir , i just love your videos and the way you explain things , love from Dibrugarh Assam
Jai Hind 🇮🇳
You are absolutely right. Beautifully articulated.hats off to you.
I have been wondering and don't understand why India is in British Commonwealth Countries(Is it only for sporting events) along with so many other countries of the world.
Same goes for B.R. Ambedkar. He never wanted any kind of reservation as it directly goes against his philosophy of equality amongst all castes. But the arya samaj and congress didn't like that philosophy. As a desperate last attempt, he built the reservation system to give some rights to the scheduled castes and tribes. There is an interview of him and and English reporter on UA-cam. You can clearly see the disappointment and hopelessness in his face. He was in the 50s yet he predicted everything that's happening today. He knew that democracy will fail, simply because we are divided based on all kinds of things and vote based on that, instead of the credibility of the politician. Like Bose, he didn't get the independence he wish India got. The only true independence was for the Congress who got a piece of land to rule.
Thank u for ur guidance. More Power to you Abhijit ji 💪
Om Namah Shivay 🙏🔱
You dont understand what he is saying ..mr bose wanted purn swaraj no partition akhand bharart his main objective was these... constitution which should be according to civilization of india ... with no fake history no fake secularism what he is saying... ek bharat srasth bharat .... in which netaji failed ... we didnt get freedom in our terms.. we got freedom in the terms of britishers...
You are absolutely right.
Is it true that Subhash Chandra Bose lived in hiding as Gumnami Baba? If so, why?
Madamji,jo bhi log ww2 main american+ aliance ke khilaf lade the uske upar america+ country ne war criminal ka charge lagaya tha...aur british empire ke dwara sedision ka charge lagaya jata...aur ye desh india ke upar bose ko handover karne ka pressure banate aur us samay par hamari koi aukat nahi thi ki ham uk aur usa ko mana kar paye,aur mana bhi karte to bahot sara economic nukshan bhugtana padta..aur shayad unko fansi hoti...
Bose saheb hamare liye hero the par unke liye criminal the...it's all about perspactive...
There is a video of Anuj Dhar on this. You can see the interview on TRS and this channel. The main reason was if he had revealed himself post independence he feared there would be riots and political clashes in the country especially in Bengal.
That way it would be correct to say he succeeded and failed. Although he failed to meet all the objectives he had set for a free India, but still succeeded making a significant contribution for an independent India. Just like we fail to check all the points of a checklist but still achieve what we intend to. Some are happy with the outcome and some think it could have been better. Its sad that most of us fall in the first category and are happy with what we achieved so far.
Sir we really need these type of harsh infomative things about India from you so we can really aware about India past and do something for our nation
He was a veer, a captain. Failing is part of life. He fought for the right causes.
Well Said. 😊👍 Sir.
Even I wasn't agreed with what you said about failing of Bose but this video gave me the clarity that what you really meant. Thanks for clearing things out.
Yes, this perspective is apt. Keep going sir!!!!
My thoughts about subash ji are same as you sir❤
My father since my childhood used to say stories,struggles , and achievements of bose ji. I admire him alot. But in school i was rounded up by my classmates that i support him. Whne i was in 4th there was a debate competition everyone was preaparing for topic freedom fighters, maximum students only spoke about gandhi, and i was the only one who spoke about Subash Chandra Bose. I got consulation but that was an inspiration for me ❤
Thank you sir for tour unbiased sessions and replies 🎉
Agree with you.
We need to be raise our Standards; avoid heresay and research for ourselves from primary sources to truly understand where we actually stand as a Nation today.
GigaChad Abhijit sir vs Virgin delusionists.
Even being a Bose fanboi, I agree with Abhijit sir
Great video again sir, people are too emotional that they can't see reality. Saying Bose failed isn't a disrespect towards him, but it's a fact that he wasn't able to achieve his goals, and his failure should also be attributed to British stooges like Gandhi and Nehru.
Failed or succeed do not work in black or white situation. He did not achieved what he wanted but he had an impact on Britishers mindset so we got so called independence
I liked your courage and authenticity 👍
sir .. i am not agree with you ... Clement attlee openly said that We left india because of Netaji Bose
We can still achieve what we want just follow the right people like Abhijeet sir.
You're right in saying so as Netaji himself in his later part of life as Bhagwanji was depressed regarding the state of affairs in our country and that we were not an independent nation in true sense.
Still, without lowering standards I will say that he did his job as planned, the onus was on the leadership here to maintain or uplift their standards to the level of Bose and continue whatever remained left after him. Sadly, they all cheated him. So while doing his part, he did not fail. But of course he as well as we should have deserved a bit better from history.
🙏
We Indians are too much in our feelings. Hardly anyone can introspect when faced with facts. They react. That's one of the reasons it has been so difficult for me to have good conversations with people.
To the point and the main thing that every indian should listen ,
We have to accept truth but we still have true lob with netaji.
He tried his best not like taklu sitting in dharna
Want to make a correction: zamindari was abolished (after independence)and in some states the land was equally distributed.
Well Said Abhi. We don't stand a chance to even be 2nd world country. Bose dreamt of a fully conscious unified state of Bharath. He indeed failed and so do his predecessors who had similar thoughts.
In ARMY CANTT Many helicopters (30-40) are flying with flags , I'm Feeling very proud!!!! i love my india 🇮🇳i love my army🇮🇳
I am grateful for your factual information to enlighten our understanding to True Indian Hero Subhash Bose. I am proud to have you in our Life 💖💘😇💐🌹🌹🌹🌹💝🙏🕯️🌺🪔🇮🇳🌎
Love you sir u've said nothing wrong . Plzz guys listen to this he is telling the literal truth that what's going on in India for the past time
Yes. The education system hasn't changed. Also the bureaucracy that hampers smooth administration hasn't changed.
You are absolutely right sir!!
It's point of view along with fact.Fact is Netaji lost the war but pont of view is he succeded even after his death in drving out British by his significant contribution .
Sir spiting truth 🥺
I agree with you sir 🙏
I strongly agree with Abhijit ji. We are still not independent. Taking forward the western legacy could not be considered as independence. Many things changed but nothing changed. If something which needs to be changed, that is our own mindset and and as Abhijit ji said the standards.
@AskAbhijit We still have British era Laws like the Indian Police Act, Indian Archalogical Act and numerous others which favoured British Govt.
Still these were not changed after 1947.
Would you comment?
You are right we understand and respect what you and we will raise our standard to make India grow
You are absolutely right.
We can ensure his success...
completely agree....
Always loved this attitude of yours sir #respect
Totally agreed...!!!
You are 100 percent right 🔥🚀
So which circumstances would have led to Netaji's Success .
And what could he have done to avoid his failure and what can we learn from his and many other great freedom fighters failures to implement in our lives for self betterment and then the betterment of the nation
True sir!! Rightly said
now that you put it that way it kinda makes sense
Awesome.... स्वराज्य
Totally agreed with u sir
Agree with you completely
well said sir 🚩👌
Rule Under By His majesty , you Know. Read Indian independence act 1947.
Namaste 🕉🙏🕉🙏:::This Independence Day, let’s take a pledge to cover the peace and concinnity of great nation of our ancestors,,Happy Independence Day. Freedom is commodity that plutocrat can’t buy, it’s the result of the struggles of our ancestors and numerous Bravehearts. Let us recognize these moment and always.
Happy Independence Day 2022.,,🕉🙏🕉🙏jai hind 🕉🙏🕉.
i have read about subhash chandra bose and also noticed that he is very much celebrated in bengal..but many bengalis do praise him but no nothing about him,they just adore him for being bengali but his idea and mindset was not beyond this thinking and none of his ideas actually followed in bengal neither in their politics
Good argument sir
Absolutely Correct Sir......
Bose set in motion a series of events which led to the exit of British in India.
But, you are 100% correct that 1947 was a transfer of power from the British to the allies of the British.
The same system of exploitation and extraction continued without any change.
This is the reason why there's such extreme poverty and extreme distribution of power and wealth in India.
Absolutely true. We have no standards . We allowed the thugs to ruin us till recently , forgetting everything that is Indian and carrying the GMT mindset. I love Bose and I want India to take his path.
#AskAbhijit Sir, I have been noticing that a lot of people especially some Indians think that India helped Bangladesh in 1971 war because of purely humanitarian ground. Was it the most dominant reason or were there other political ideas?
Speculatively how could the existing established institutions be changed. What's the best way to do this by sudden revolution or slow reforms ?
Hitler subjected Amin Al-Husseini, The Grand Mufti of Jerusalem (Al-Aqsa Mosque) to physical racial profiling and after getting satisfied with the findings that the later belongs to his choice of racial stock, had agreed for a meet. But in case of Subash Babu it was different, and rather 'Fuhrer' was evidently pleased to meet Netaji, as one can see the warmth from the then taken Photographs of meet. Hitler's observation on Indians was inferior as per Mein Kampf, but had he written the same book after meeting Bose the opinion could have been contrast. This clearly shows the 'Karisma' Subash Babu weilded on Global Leadership of those times. Clearly Netaji gave an impetus and made India leap decades ahead in it's sojourn, to which we all are indebted.
ua-cam.com/video/EEhF2D1kUcQ/v-deo.html
He failed, but Atleast he tried and that is motivating us . Truth is truth. Similar to jatau tried to save sitamia.
I highly support #educationreform in india. Why don't we taught about these at our schools. Why we get to knows these things when we became graduates from our colleges.
Love u sir ❤❤❤ , sir plz Hindi m bhi content dijiye bohot saare Indian ko ye sb pata hona chahiye, pr English ki wajeh se unn tk ye pohoch nhi payegi, plzzzzz aur apki channel ki view bhi bohot Inc ho jayegi
BOSE didn't failed it's we failed to achieve Freedom that's why we got Dominion in name of Freedom
BOSE didn't ask anything for himself
Rather he gave himself for India.
He didn't loose he gave Everything
When not all but many didn't
Netaji failed and Gandhi succeeded? Then why did the British Prime Minister Atlee who signed independence to India later said they gave India independence because of "Chandra Bose". They were very scared that there will be many armed rebellions by Indian army against the British people who were in India once the Indian army finds out the details of the Netaji's military efforts using Indian army POWs. British already started seeings signs of that and that got scared. They knew Indian army can kill the British army in India like an elephant can kill an ant because the Indian army vastly outnumbered British soliders in India. Atlee said British were not scared of Gandhi at all and so Gandi was not the reason British left. This relevation came straight from Atlee. So, now tell me who succeeded and who failed? Who gave us India's independence? Not Gandhi and Nehru.
Not many know... but neta ji was a Dhimmi too when it's come to realising threat of Islam
Make a video on Dr.BR Ambedkar and his contributions and his constitution
Why do you think the Britishers left India in 1947? Not after and not before. I never got a clear answer for this. Can you please clarify?
Please, explain the Swampurna Swaraj in details..
Indian youth should realize this - We gave away 33% of Bharat to just 25% of Indian population (Muslims who created Pakistan exclusively for themselves) with hope that the Hindu civilization can survive and there would be peace. But today we still get a Kanhaiyya being beheaded and a Nupur Sharma going into hiding for the rest of her life for no fault of theirs. What did the partition achieve when neither a top politician nor an ordinary tailor is safe from being murdered by the Jihadis, who decide collectively whom to target?
True freedom is when EVERY person who identifies with the Bharatiya civilization is equal in every way and 100% free from fear & hate irrespective of which god he prays to. How can there be peace when 80% of Indians are treated as Kafirs and Mushriks by a violent minority, which wants no peace till the 80% is annihilated?
In my opinion, Subhash Chandra Bose failed at personal level, because he did not get the necessary support he expected from the axis powers in world war two. Each of them obviously had their individual objectives to pursue, and did not care much to aid Subhash Chandra Bose in his attempts to start an armed struggle for securing independence for our country. Hence his failure has to be logically expected. But his single minded approach, supreme personal sacrifices, and selfless efforts would definitely have inspired thousands of Indian soldiers in the british army and motivated them to rise in mutiny, forcing the british to realise the ungovernability of India, without the disciplined cooperation of Indian soldiers in their army.
Either HE FAILED OR LOST OR WON HE US MY IDEAL AND MY HERO INDEED