Discus Rim Weights | Whats the Difference & Which One Will Fly Farther | Nelco Discus Review

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 99

  • @matthewantin4728
    @matthewantin4728 5 років тому +63

    When he said beginners throw between 160-180' i almost died inside. Rip my 115' throw (im a sophmore tho in HS)

    • @sebastianhendricks8235
      @sebastianhendricks8235 5 років тому +3

      Mantin same here. I’m a sophomore and my best is 109’”10. How long have you done it ?

    • @matthewantin4728
      @matthewantin4728 5 років тому

      Sebastian Hendricks I started this year but I practiced in the summer before the season

    • @SuperGuerillaGamplay
      @SuperGuerillaGamplay 5 років тому

      @@matthewantin4728 yeet, rip all our throws (136')

    • @ajbomgaars2413
      @ajbomgaars2413 3 роки тому

      Threw 86 freshman year, (soph cancelled), then 124 this year

    • @braysensagert583
      @braysensagert583 3 роки тому

      I’m a seventh grader and I can throw 100”

  • @jilldavenport2364
    @jilldavenport2364 Рік тому +6

    I have been watching your videos and sharing with my daughter. This will be her second year throwing discuss and shot. She is excited about eclipsing the 100' mark in the next couple of weeks. Right now her PR is 95'3" after throwing for just 3 months last year. Looking for a banner year this time! We will keep checking your website for upcoming camps and clinics!

    • @aretethrowsnation
      @aretethrowsnation  Рік тому +1

      keep up the good work and keep us posted. always fun to crack the 100’ barrier.

  • @donlethredge
    @donlethredge 3 роки тому +4

    I love your videos. they are so helpful. I'm 71 years old and throwing discus, shot and javelin in Senior games along with golf, pickle ball and other stuff. I played sports all my life and always loved track and field though I played football at Clemson in the day. I'm throwing a 75 % rim weight and only throwing 125-130 ft. I'm 6-1 250 and should be throwing 150 or more . Not sure what the problem is except speed and strength and technique. The internet is my only coach. My goal is to finish top three in nationals next May in all three disciplines. I need to be throwing 140 - 150 in both discus and javelin. I hold the state record in the javelin my best event. But have a lot of potential I am not realizing. I'm throwing 40 ft. in shot but need five more feet at least. I now have easy access to weight room so am excited about lifting for the first time in my life.. It is all doable. I'm devouring your video's so thanks a bunch. Can seniors go to throws camps?

    • @aretethrowsnation
      @aretethrowsnation  3 роки тому

      Hello Don. Thanks for taking the time comment and provide all the info. Be sure to take a look at our Throwing chain reaction system. And yes. We have master that attend our camps. Be sure to visit our website for more info.

  • @johnbrist
    @johnbrist 5 років тому +3

    Excellent and understandable information on disc weight distribution and spin, etc. Very helpful. Thanks.

    • @aretethrowsnation
      @aretethrowsnation  5 років тому

      John Bristol you’re welcome.

    • @ajaycricketer2234
      @ajaycricketer2234 3 роки тому

      @@aretethrowsnation sir it can be available I want sit iam from India 🇮🇳

  • @jacobbrouse1564
    @jacobbrouse1564 5 років тому +4

    I’d be down for a disc. Currently throwing in the mid 140’s and really want to push my numbers to the next level. I go to a small school and we don’t have great discs, and one of these would be awesome. Great video!

  • @thomassmith6865
    @thomassmith6865 5 років тому +4

    Signed up, as a coach of Middle & High School throwers I am always looking for good info. We are a small school, with only a few athletes competing in the discus, this video is very helpful. Thanks, I am now looking to purchase a Nelco.

  • @AJW166
    @AJW166 5 років тому +4

    The ultimo is my favorite disc to use...flows smoothly through the spin and throw

  • @mikethies3690
    @mikethies3690 4 роки тому +4

    When I saw this link, I had a little nostalgia remembering the Saturn Pacer I had back in the early 90's after looking at a somewhat similar design in the video. I think Saturn was the first company to use the complete fiberglass (or whatever material) plates with no metal disk in the middle. The plates would literally invert 100% and you would have to step on it so it would re-invert pop back into place. It would eventually crack so bad at the screw hole that you could no longer use it. What a nightmare... I totally 100% assumed that the industry had certainly worked the bugs out after 30 years. I almost fell over when you started talking about plate damage. To quote the classic cliche: "We can put a man on the moon and we can't get the plate thingies worked out"? I am not poking fun at the quality of any of the brands, I just find this humorous 30 years later from my vantage point.

    • @aretethrowsnation
      @aretethrowsnation  4 роки тому

      Mike Thies AHaha. Hard Arizona ground. So durability here is an issue for sure. The Nelco’s are very durable. Very good discs.

    • @paulbuschman
      @paulbuschman 2 роки тому

      I threw my PR of 185-5 22 years ago with a Pacer Saturn II. I loved that discus.

  • @winsecho951
    @winsecho951 5 років тому +8

    Signed up. My school only has 3 so hoping to get some 😂

  • @tallahassee4187
    @tallahassee4187 4 роки тому +2

    signed up, thanks for the information! Vids are very entertaining too.

  • @Careybear92
    @Careybear92 6 років тому +3

    Hi Coach...I have signed up on the website and also shared the video on Facebook. I love my Nelco...best money I spent last year on my Nelco Olympia Superspin..got my PB with it. I hope I win a discus!!

    • @aretethrowsnation
      @aretethrowsnation  6 років тому

      Carey Hollick sweet. They really are nice discs.

    • @Fabiokovach
      @Fabiokovach 4 роки тому

      How much did you release and how much did you improve?

  • @chriswoods1120
    @chriswoods1120 6 років тому +3

    Thank you! Hope you guys had a good time in Australia! Happy New Year!!

  • @gregcameron5649
    @gregcameron5649 6 років тому +2

    Great instructional video. Keep up the great work. Im a father of three and am starting to get my two daughters and son into throwing. Would love a brand new disc to teach them with.

    • @gregcameron5649
      @gregcameron5649 6 років тому

      All we have are rubber and plastic molded discs. They are all 1.6. Would love a 1kg to let my daughters give it a try.

  • @stevespyder
    @stevespyder 5 років тому +1

    hello from a master class athlete from canada, learning discus and javelin for pentathalon. signed up for minicourse, using cheap practice implements for now...

  • @saurabhsubham5584
    @saurabhsubham5584 5 років тому +3

    I throw 40-43 meater
    Which discuss I have to use????

  • @emmgotjams7513
    @emmgotjams7513 6 років тому +2

    I just signed up! I don't have my own discus, and I would really love to have my own! The ones I have been using belong to my school. Even over past summers when I went to camps I took the school's.

  • @calebchambers2722
    @calebchambers2722 6 років тому +1

    I'm helping coach at a high school that only has 3 discs for about 10 throwers. I signed up on the website, we could really use the disc!

  • @davidlawler3339
    @davidlawler3339 Рік тому +1

    I threw a little BUT zero coaching, no weight room and just lime on dirt ring.managed only 145-150 foot.the Crouser dynasty was started then in Portland Oregon area.

  • @edwardmoore7408
    @edwardmoore7408 3 роки тому

    Subscribed to your sight for my high school freshman son. Throwing in the 119 ft range without spinning before throw. Standing throw.. Just beginning . Trying to help all I can

  • @nickorf1099
    @nickorf1099 6 років тому +2

    Great insight and analysis! Looking forward to start the season, hope I win a new Nelco!

  • @mikethies3690
    @mikethies3690 4 роки тому

    I am not sure if Erik agrees, but for those of you who are saying you only have access to rubber discs I would find a way to get a metal one. My highschool had crappie ones so I just got my own via Christmas present requests from my parents. Even the generic cheapies would be better than using the rubber ones. I bought one a couple of years as a gift for $34 and It was decent. One issue was that quality tolerances was not great and there was a tiny gap between the plates and the rim and a little grass would get stuck there. I was going to fix this by getting a little tube of car bondo and run it around the seams using a putty knife, but he had to quit due to an injury so I never got around to it. I did use rubber ones in 8th and 9th grades, and they are certainly better than nothing at all. Later, the only thing I really kept a rubber one around for was to screw a strap onto it to use when I was doing dry throws. Now, when I got hit in the head in the 8th grade I certainly wish that disc had been rubber ;-)

  • @guitarslinger213
    @guitarslinger213 2 роки тому

    If I could go back to my high school self, I would tell myself to buy something fancy with whatever rim weight pros use. If you're throwing

  • @James-gq4tb
    @James-gq4tb 6 років тому +1

    Great vid. I have signed up on the website.

  • @lcangelnm9314
    @lcangelnm9314 5 років тому +1

    Signed up, very helpful information!

  • @lookininfamous2575
    @lookininfamous2575 6 років тому +1

    Just signed up! Thanks for the tips.

  • @kellyfest222
    @kellyfest222 9 місяців тому

    Very informative!

  • @justinjstanford5853
    @justinjstanford5853 6 років тому +1

    Thanks for the video. Nelco seem very reasonable priced for the value.

  • @austinlundquist5309
    @austinlundquist5309 5 років тому +2

    I just signed up! Thank you!

  • @sunildahiya1511
    @sunildahiya1511 3 роки тому

    Which discus is best
    Low spin.
    Super spin
    Gold

  • @MrRobertIsaac
    @MrRobertIsaac 6 років тому +1

    Just registered. Thanks for all the tips!

  • @haylandj.6755
    @haylandj.6755 5 років тому

    I may have missed it but what is the difference in the challenger disc

  • @jacksonfries8453
    @jacksonfries8453 2 роки тому +1

    What type of disc do you recommend for a 103’ disc thrower?

  • @michaelsawarynski2846
    @michaelsawarynski2846 5 років тому +1

    Our school has like 5 rubber discs that are completely chipped and like 20 throwers

  • @IRunSoSick
    @IRunSoSick 5 років тому

    thanks for the info, very informative.

  • @bjf5027
    @bjf5027 2 місяці тому

    High rim weight increases rotational inertia which minimizes nutation thus leading to a more stable flight. Of course, this is only possible if the thrower can put enough spin into the disc in the first place.

  • @69bulwinkle
    @69bulwinkle 5 років тому

    Hey, I'm throwing 40-43m and I want to try a higher rim weight what do u think I should go, using a 70% rim weight

  • @rosebray9101
    @rosebray9101 5 років тому

    Awesome advice, Thanks :)

  • @OakQueso
    @OakQueso 6 років тому +1

    What rim weight do you recommend I use if I'm a 155-170ft thrower?

    • @James-gq4tb
      @James-gq4tb 6 років тому

      OK SO use 70-high 80s in rim weight. Try them in that range and see what ones you throw farther with. It’s a preference

    • @OakQueso
      @OakQueso 6 років тому

      @@James-gq4tb yeah just got an 83% disc that I'm about to try out tomorrow. I might end up getting another one with a little lower rim weight and see what works out best (Because the 155-170 was hopeful thinking for this season because im really 150-160 on my best throws smh)

    • @aretethrowsnation
      @aretethrowsnation  6 років тому

      I would say 80%.

    • @OakQueso
      @OakQueso 5 років тому

      @@aretethrowsnation Alright thanks babe

    • @OakQueso
      @OakQueso 5 років тому

      @@aretethrowsnation Do have a specific 80% rim disc you recommend? Especially one that can get a rough rim for good grip

  • @mace_stampede9245
    @mace_stampede9245 2 роки тому +1

    Still a chance to win a disc. lol just got into the program.

    • @aretethrowsnation
      @aretethrowsnation  2 роки тому

      we sure to register for those members only workshops. welcome to the program 💪👍

  • @robbsantos7050
    @robbsantos7050 5 років тому

    Available in Thailand?

  • @cobbler88
    @cobbler88 Рік тому

    The best one is the best one you can afford. Buy what you can, keep an eye out for second hand, and train to maximize your ability to throw it effectively.

  • @chriswoods1120
    @chriswoods1120 6 років тому +1

    Where do I sign up for a discus? I don't see the link.

    • @jennjo9920
      @jennjo9920 6 років тому

      HI Chris, it's Mrs Arete.... You can sign up on our homepage- aretethrowsnation.com/ . thanks so much!

  • @daddyfixit5188
    @daddyfixit5188 2 роки тому

    Just coming back to discus after 35 year break 😃 am now wealthy enough to buy real throw shoes but I have big wide size uk 12 feet. Where can I buy big man shoes as I’m about to go barefoot out of frastration. Please help. Surely all the big guys who throw don’t all have size 9 skinny feet. I would even consider having some made if I knew where. Thanks for your help 👍👍

    • @paulbuschman
      @paulbuschman 2 роки тому +1

      You might want to check EBay. I could not find size 15s in any of the usual places but found some new Nike Zoom Rotationals size 15 on EBay from a seller in Lithuania. I’m getting back into it after 22 years away.

  • @bctiger86
    @bctiger86 Рік тому

    Sign the link... would love a 1k high spin discus for my daughter!

  • @Flakzor123
    @Flakzor123 Рік тому

    As a middle aged former youth discus thrower slowly getting interested again I love comparisons like this but I really feel the need to be a smartass about some of your explanations about the effects of rimweights and rpm (It's a characterflaw I really can't help myself). 1) higher rim weight will increase gyroscopic stability AND also make it harder to increase spin on the disc translating to less wobble on less than perfect releases as well as a more stable flight in choppy winds. 2) higher rim weight will NOT yield more rpm on the discus at launch but apart from the benefits mentioned previously the fact that we essentially "reverse" the spin on the discus from windup to release the stored energy in the discus with the higher rimweight essentially ends up "bracing" the discus slightly against our effort to "spin it" which "I imagine" allows for slightly more force to be directed into the throw itself.

    • @aretethrowsnation
      @aretethrowsnation  Рік тому +1

      if you can apply spin you’ll benefit from higher rim weight. if you can’t (as you indicated) you wont benefit. since we made this video (4years ago) we created an entire program “Flight School” dedicated to teaching how to hold, spin, and fly the discus. so yes. pretty good assessment from a former youth thrower💪

    • @Flakzor123
      @Flakzor123 Рік тому

      @@aretethrowsnation back in the day I had a decent pop at the end to put some spin on it but my footwork was garbage (mental image: "torso on stilts"). I took out my 2kg discus for the first time in 2 decades last weekend and to the surprise of absolutely no-one my footwork is still garbage but the "pop" at the end is long gone =). I'm counting the fact that all my throws were in the sector a big win.

  • @jadynancz
    @jadynancz 5 років тому

    Is there a video on “how to spin the disc”

  • @Imjq400
    @Imjq400 5 років тому +1

    I just signed up!!!

  • @omkarshete4484
    @omkarshete4484 5 років тому +1

    Hi.arte.you.are.great.man.legend

  • @trilliemiyxhofficial
    @trilliemiyxhofficial 5 років тому

    Filled my name out.

  • @jethrobaptiste
    @jethrobaptiste 3 роки тому

    I sign in

  • @bctiger86
    @bctiger86 3 роки тому

    I signed up in the link

  • @jadynancz
    @jadynancz 5 років тому

    Signed up!

  • @BigSkyCurmudgeon
    @BigSkyCurmudgeon 6 років тому +1

    our school does use a lot of nelcos. good value for beginning and intermediate throwers. our girls use the 80% RW a lot. the better intermediate uses the 83% Ultimo. fragile body plates is a problem tho. buying replacement plates--finding them- has plagued us. i do not like nelco flight characteristics for our elite throwers. they primarily use Denfi and Gill Pacers. all 85%+RW the nelco 80s are in the elites bag for the days they aren't cranking the revs....our school 400 students 40+ throwers--girls and guys safe estimate of 70+ discus' on hand. Corvallis Montana

    • @aretethrowsnation
      @aretethrowsnation  6 років тому

      I think the newer discs are more durable now. We have hard ground and they are holding up strong.

    • @BigSkyCurmudgeon
      @BigSkyCurmudgeon 6 років тому

      @@aretethrowsnation where can replacement body plates be purchased? i probably have 7-8 out of action, and 4-5 using mismatched plates.

    • @aretethrowsnation
      @aretethrowsnation  6 років тому

      paul m i would contact Bruce Caldwell at nelcoUSA.com. They did redesign the discs in the last few years so you can contact him and he would be able to help you figure it out.

    • @BigSkyCurmudgeon
      @BigSkyCurmudgeon 6 років тому

      @@aretethrowsnation ...thanks. i will do that.

  • @paulhb
    @paulhb 3 роки тому

    Clear as mud. Beginners do not throw 160’. Some of these videos are frustrating.

  • @thewhited-rose668
    @thewhited-rose668 5 років тому

    I entered

  • @vetrivel3698
    @vetrivel3698 6 років тому

    Cost is too high

    • @aretethrowsnation
      @aretethrowsnation  6 років тому

      vetri vel super high quality. And maybe the best priced high end discs. Comparable high end discs cost more. But hopefully you find it helpful.

  • @dinkarpradhan1218
    @dinkarpradhan1218 5 років тому

    Made in India

  • @layhd6934
    @layhd6934 5 років тому +1

    Thank a lot coach. I just signed up.