Next up: Why is Christian Zionism Evil? But we won't get that episode. I wonder why. Edit: Although the title of this video has now been changed to "How to Combat Rising Christian Antisemitism", the original title of the video when it was uploaded was "Why is Christian Antisemitism Evil?"
Bcz it's a part of Theology now,since Schofield Bible 1890 it's become a Standard Belief System, that Whatever Aparthide it commits that nation is God Chosen One🤣🤣🤣
I support the State of Israel and for its citizens to live in peace and to prosper That makes me a Zionist. You call it evil because you have an evil heart. You hate Jews.
Why can’t Christian’s or non Christian’s be critical of Israel as a nation and its policies let’s say. Or why can we critique Judaism without being called anti Semitic? No one seems offended by similar criticism of the Islamic faith and or Islamic nations. There needs to be an clear distinction between hate and disagreement for example
Ok but do you think there could be no acceptable conditions upon which criticism is warranted? That’s a cop out answer. Basically stating it’s just an undercover way to be hateful.. again why is it distinct for only one group?
This episode was such a shame to watch as someone who was brought back to the Catholic Church in part due to Trent’s writings and Lila’s podcast. “Antisemitism” has become the new “racist.” The church teaches to love and not to hate. It is not hateful to reject the religion of Judaism because it is false. It is not hateful to acknowledge and strongly oppose the strangle grip that the state of Israel has over our entire political system. And NO it is not hateful to acknowledge that a lot of people feel a strong sense of affinity and loyalty to their own ethnicity. According to numerous studies, blacks, Asians, Hispanics and Jews (with the noticeable absence of whites) have a strong preference for their own people and tend to stick together. That is NOT HATEFUL to acknowledge. It breaks my heart to see two of the people that I used to so admire who aided in my arrival back to my faith, fall into the same nonsensical leftist talking points that have been used to destroy the church and our country. Shame on the both of you for your cowardice
Lila would you cover where 400 Jewish organizations came out after Roe. V Wade was overturned and said that abortion is a fundamental Jewish right? Is that acceptable?
@Tom_McMurtry Have you done thorough research on this topic? Go read the Talmud, which is a very important book in Judaism, regarding what it says about Jesus and Mary. It also doesn't recognize that life begins at conception, it denies that the fetus is a person. It has all sorts of demonic teachings in it. It also has practical tips on how to subvert Christianity as conversos... I could go on and on. There's a reason why Paul said that the Jews (not all Jews) killed the prophets, killed Jesus and are enemies of all mankind. Apparently there's been a pattern in the leadership before Jesus (killing prophets) during Jesus's time (killing him) and after his time with the Talmud being written down by the successors of the Pharisees... the people who hated Jesus most. I can provide you Jewish scholars that admit the Jews have been behind the subversion of Catholicism for 2000 years by using different tactics. It seems the most common is through backing heretical movements (like the Hussites). This is not coming from me, this is from them...
Where are Jews saying they hate Christians? There are plenty of people of every race, color, and creed who hate Christians… are you holding the same standard for every people group?
@ Judaism, specifically rabbinical, Talmudic Judaism stemming from the Pharisees of the New Testament is a unique religion in that it explicitly rejects Christ (both Islam and Hinduism venerate Christ as Holy). In this way, Christians and Jews hold oppositional belief systems.
@ Judaism, specifically rabbinical, Talmudic Judaism stemming from the Pharisees of the New Testament is a unique religion in that it explicitly rejects Christ (both Islam and Hinduism venerate Christ as Holy). In this way, Christians and Jews hold oppositional belief systems.
@ Judaism, specifically rabbinical, Talmudic Judaism stemming from the Pharisees of the New Testament is a unique religion in that it explicitly rejects Christ (both Islam and Hinduism venerate Christ as Holy). In this way, Christians and Jews hold oppositional belief systems.
I’m so sick of the way Israel has such a chokehold on even some of the most intelligent Christians. You can love and bless Israel without having to turn a blind eye to what their government has done. Criticizing and questioning what their government is doing now and what they’ve done in the past is NOT antisemitism. Most of us do the same to the American government, so I guess that makes us ALL anti-American according to that logic…
Antisemitism is prejudice or hatred against Jewish people based on their ethnicity or religion. It involves negative stereotypes, discrimination, or violence against Jews simply because they are Jewish. Example: Saying all Jews control the media or are responsible for global events is antisemitism, because it targets Jewish people as a group based on their identity. Criticizing Israel refers to expressing opposition to the policies or actions of the Israeli government, much like criticizing any country's government. This is not antisemitic unless it crosses into denying Israel’s right to exist or targeting Jewish people as a whole for actions taken by Israel. Example: Calling out Israel’s treatment of Palestinians in Gaza is a form of political criticism, not antisemitism, as long as it's focused on policies, not on Jewish people themselves. Criticizing Judaism is about questioning or challenging the religion itself, like any other religion (Christianity, Islam, etc.). Disagreeing with religious beliefs is not inherently antisemitic. Example: Arguing that Jesus was the Messiah, which conflicts with Jewish belief, is religious criticism, not antisemitism, as it’s aimed at a theological point, not at Jews as a people. Summary: Antisemitism = Hatred or prejudice against Jews. Criticizing Israel = Opposing Israeli government policies (not antisemitism unless it denies Israel’s right to exist or targets Jews as a group). Criticizing Judaism = Disagreeing with Jewish religious beliefs, which is not the same as hating Jews. Understanding the difference is important to avoid confusing political or religious criticism with racism or hatred against an entire group of people.
it’s not at all antisemitic to criticize israeli govt policies, politicians, idf actions, etc. if it was, then the HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS of israelis protesting their govt in the streets would be “antisemitic.” however, a problem arises when people use “the zionists” as a euphemism for jews, or when people defend hamas committing genocidal massacres
@ I agree we shouldn’t call ALL Jews “zionists”, or defend any genocide in general. But that’s what their government is actively pushing for. When we say “the zionists”, we mean their government and all those who support what they’re doing. The problem is that they’re always crying “antisemitism” whenever someone criticizes their government. They make it seem like we hate Jews just because we felt bad seeing videos of innocent children starving and getting blown up.
Another dissapointing video on Israel. 1. Even if 99% of all critics of Israel or of Jewish individuals are antisemitic, it still doesn't mean that you cannot have the capacity to criticize without being antisemitic. 2. It has nothing to do with hating Jews by their ethnicity. For many yes, but not for ALL critics. Nobody is saying that Jews are inherently evil. But for both Christian and Jewish Zionism are not beyond scrutiny. 3. So if two other nations had similiar conflicts such as the Israelli palistinian conflict, you are telling me that everybody will side with the nation similar to Israel? The only reason people criticize Israel is because it is Jewish? So people being forcefully removed their land isn't a big deal?
I am jewish. I have had people both on the internet and in person tell me jews are inherently evil. In real life it was usually black hebrew Israelite. Online it was usually anti israel christians. Or at least claimed to be Christian I'd like to believe most Christians are better than that. But it definitely exists.
The obsession with Israel is what is an issue here LOL, have you heard of the Assyrians, the Kurds, the Druze, have you heard about the Coptics? And even more recent, the Yazidi?
@@AlexCPauwels85 Yes, they're all various ethnic groups of peoples in that region. As far as I know, there are none of them in high level positions of government or media promoting LGBT and abortion and trying to enshrine these as legal rights in America and around the world but I could be wrong.
@@AlexCPauwels85No the Real Obsession is with Evangelicals for Worshipping Israel over Mistaken Identity by Believing East European Caucasians to be Biblical Hebrews😂😂
First off, you gotta define the term. Is it a set of people, a set of behaviors, or a set of national policies, or is the term used as a blanket for all those things, so that anyone who opposes any one of those things gets lumped into the same pool?
Were the Council Fathers at Lateran 4 wrong when they all agreed, in a formal ecumenical council, to declare that Jews should be banned from public office? Was Pope Paul IV likewise "anti semitic" when he did even more to restrict Jewish "rights" in Cum Nimis Absurdum? Trent and Lila like to pretend that we cant just read what Holy Mother Church taught in its Magisterium over the last 2,000 years.
Antisemitism is prejudice or hatred against Jewish people based on their ethnicity or religion. It involves negative stereotypes, discrimination, or violence against Jews simply because they are Jewish. Example: Saying all Jews control the media or are responsible for global events is antisemitism, because it targets Jewish people as a group based on their identity. Criticizing Israel refers to expressing opposition to the policies or actions of the Israeli government, much like criticizing any country's government. This is not antisemitic unless it crosses into denying Israel’s right to exist or targeting Jewish people as a whole for actions taken by Israel. Example: Calling out Israel’s treatment of Palestinians in Gaza is a form of political criticism, not antisemitism, as long as it's focused on policies, not on Jewish people themselves. Criticizing Judaism is about questioning or challenging the religion itself, like any other religion (Christianity, Islam, etc.). Disagreeing with religious beliefs is not inherently antisemitic. Example: Arguing that Jesus was the Messiah, which conflicts with Jewish belief, is religious criticism, not antisemitism, as it’s aimed at a theological point, not at Jews as a people. Summary: Antisemitism = Hatred or prejudice against Jews. Criticizing Israel = Opposing Israeli government policies (not antisemitism unless it denies Israel’s right to exist or targets Jews as a group). Criticizing Judaism = Disagreeing with Jewish religious beliefs, which is not the same as hating Jews. Understanding the difference is important to avoid confusing political or religious criticism with racism or hatred against an entire group of people.
They answered this quite clearly. It’s okay to be critical of Israel, but are you unfairly critical, or hyper fixating on Israel while ignoring the same wrongs elsewhere?
@@GaserBeam-hi4ez We focus on Israel more because America finances them and sends them the bombs used to blow civilians up. We focus on it more because it causes the entire Arab world to hate America and attack us (Read what Osama Bin Laden said about why he did 9/11). We focus on it more because Israel controls US politics and stops our politicians from blindly writing cheques to Israel.
My unpopular opinion is that antisemitism doesn't carry the same weight it had before. It's thrown around so much, and it changes as it sees fit. Now, it's been pushed into laws in some states. This is why many see it as a problem. You criticise a state, as we are allowed to when we see wrong doing, BUT it's not allowed when it's towards Israel. In order to really understand the state of Israel (not Jewish people), you have to learn about it. To argue about this without understanding the background is foolish, and it doesn't carry a backbone to your argument. Saying... I heard, or I saw, or I think, doesn't mean anything. It only shows that you're not well-read on the issues.
You are so full of crap. How often do you "we only criticise Israel" people say a word against the truly vicious nations? Against the REAL genocides? Against Hamas, Iran, Sudan? Do you EVER attack the Muslim countries that murder Christians? NO YOU DO NOT.
Were the Council Fathers at Lateran 4 wrong when they all agreed, in a formal ecumenical council, to declare that Jews should be banned from public office? Was Pope Paul IV likewise "anti semitic" when he did even more to restrict Jewish "rights" in Cum Nimis Absurdum? Trent and Lila like to pretend that we cant just read what Holy Mother Church taught in its Magisterium over the last 2,000 years.
I'm seeing people online just blame everything on Jews and call people they don't like Jewish. They are acting as a Catholic persona online but I'm unsure if they actually are
Antisemitism is prejudice or hatred against Jewish people based on their ethnicity or religion. It involves negative stereotypes, discrimination, or violence against Jews simply because they are Jewish. Example: Saying all Jews control the media or are responsible for global events is antisemitism, because it targets Jewish people as a group based on their identity. Criticizing Israel refers to expressing opposition to the policies or actions of the Israeli government, much like criticizing any country's government. This is not antisemitic unless it crosses into denying Israel’s right to exist or targeting Jewish people as a whole for actions taken by Israel. Example: Calling out Israel’s treatment of Palestinians in Gaza is a form of political criticism, not antisemitism, as long as it's focused on policies, not on Jewish people themselves. Criticizing Judaism is about questioning or challenging the religion itself, like any other religion (Christianity, Islam, etc.). Disagreeing with religious beliefs is not inherently antisemitic. Example: Arguing that Jesus was the Messiah, which conflicts with Jewish belief, is religious criticism, not antisemitism, as it’s aimed at a theological point, not at Jews as a people. Summary: Antisemitism = Hatred or prejudice against Jews. Criticizing Israel = Opposing Israeli government policies (not antisemitism unless it denies Israel’s right to exist or targets Jews as a group). Criticizing Judaism = Disagreeing with Jewish religious beliefs, which is not the same as hating Jews. Understanding the difference is important to avoid confusing political or religious criticism with racism or hatred against an entire group of people.
There is a lot of growing antisemitism that is NOT just criticism of Israel - mainstream voices saying the H*locaust was greatly exaggerated, the Jews are behind the death of JFK, that’s a lot different than saying “I disagree with this specific thing the IDF did.”
I have yet to hear any real antisemitism from media within my lifetime beyond the movies… I don’t even know where this is coming from. It’s okay to critique a country or a mafia. Calling normal critique racist or antisemitic is ridiculous…
I think the confusion arises when we include symbolic action (eg speech) in the definition. Personally, I prefer emphasizing common human dignity, & the universal call to holiness.
@@beccalovescrafts the Jewish mafia. It’s ridiculous that it’s not even acknowledged that there is a Jewish mafia just how there was/is? an Italian mafia. The simple acknowledge isn’t a testament to ALL Italians or ALL Jews. We basically live in a clown world acting as if all Jews are angels and don’t fall into the same sin the rest of the world does. And it is simply NOT Biblical.
Reading these comments is heartbreaking. I’m a Syrian-Catholic. I grew up in the west, was raised Muslim, but converted to Catholicism when I met my lovely husband. People in the west don’t understand the kind of persecution people in the Middle East face living under oppressive regimes. Yes, Gazans are dying. And this is because of the fundamentalist regime they were living under. Israel was backed into a corner. To look at the Middle East and compare it to how we live in the west is simply ignorant. Not to mention the fact that as Christians, we face so much persecution. I’m truly horrified for Christians right now in Syria. My heart breaks for them. When I compare Syria to Gaza people say it’s different and this is absolutely incorrect. This means you simply don’t understand the political situation. I was flat out cut off and ostracized from my family for converting to Catholicism. And this, sadly, was getting off easy. I can't visit the middle east because I'm an apostate, and we don't fair well. I wrote an article for Times of Israel, "Why are so many feminists Supporting Ab'siv' men?" The amount of hate I received was horrifying. I wish that on no one. “None of this means anything!” I’m told. Actually it’s everything. It’s a small window in to the kind of silencing and oppression Arabs face. Especially Arab Christians. But also Arab Muslims forced to live under fundamentalist regimes. I know it's hard to look at the images you're seeing. But lay blame in the proper direction. It IS anti semitic to be anti zionist because Israel rightfully exists and if you don't believe that you don't know your history and you have bought into anti semitic propaganda. Read proper historical books that teach proper history. My family would gladly unalive me for converting to Catholicism. And the above article I wrote was icing on the cake for them and justified that they were correct. That I am a “heathen.” My life was up ended because of an opinion piece that makes a very basic point. I LIVE in the WEST. I was BORN in the west. IF you think people in the Middle East have freedom, you’re lying to yourself. Seriously. I live in the west and I’m a doctor and I was truly afraid for my life after I wrote ONE article that was aimed at feminists. Please have empathy for the Christian Arabs stuck between a rock and a hard place. Do your due diligence and actually look at the history of Israel and how it was formed. It is anti semitic to be anti Zionist and this is simply a FACT. I didn’t want to write another article because the first one went so poorly in terms of the response. But reading these comments makes me realize that WOW - we have a LONG way to go. I can’t believe so many people have fed into the lie. This breaks my heart.
people in the west (at least in this generation) are so used to peace that they will never understood the brutal suppression they can be under the Islamic rule. They consider Islamic demographics as just another group of people. It's true that you should take into account the existence of peaceful Muslims but if you are not aware of the danger Islam demographics pose then you are inviting a danger that you or your future generation would never be able to get of.
Explain how it is anti-Semitic to be anti-Zionist. If it is, "...simply a FACT," as you claim, then it should be very simple to demonstrate, no? All you've done is make some specious connection between thinking Israel shouldn't exist, and being opposed to Zionism, which in no way demonstrates that either of those positions have any connection to anti-Semitism. One Catholic convert to another, I am interested, but a bit confused at this.
Why would you write a book Lila? you don’t have comprehensive history of that region. You just regurgitated media talking points. You lost me. Please look into how Israelis treat Christian Palestinians. It’s not about religion, it’s about land.
i§rael is the only middle eastern country where the christian population is growing....and have it the best in i§rael...can u find better excuse to hate i§raelis...
Antisemitism is prejudice or hatred against Jewish people based on their ethnicity or religion. It involves negative stereotypes, discrimination, or violence against Jews simply because they are Jewish. Example: Saying all Jews control the media or are responsible for global events is antisemitism, because it targets Jewish people as a group based on their identity. Criticizing Israel refers to expressing opposition to the policies or actions of the Israeli government, much like criticizing any country's government. This is not antisemitic unless it crosses into denying Israel’s right to exist or targeting Jewish people as a whole for actions taken by Israel. Example: Calling out Israel’s treatment of Palestinians in Gaza is a form of political criticism, not antisemitism, as long as it's focused on policies, not on Jewish people themselves. Criticizing Judaism is about questioning or challenging the religion itself, like any other religion (Christianity, Islam, etc.). Disagreeing with religious beliefs is not inherently antisemitic. Example: Arguing that Jesus was the Messiah, which conflicts with Jewish belief, is religious criticism, not antisemitism, as it’s aimed at a theological point, not at Jews as a people. Summary: Antisemitism = Hatred or prejudice against Jews. Criticizing Israel = Opposing Israeli government policies (not antisemitism unless it denies Israel’s right to exist or targets Jews as a group). Criticizing Judaism = Disagreeing with Jewish religious beliefs, which is not the same as hating Jews. Understanding the difference is important to avoid confusing political or religious criticism with racism or hatred against an entire group of people.
This video is about racism against J*ws. Why did your mind jump to the conclusion that it’s about the nation of Israel? I don’t criticize countries in Africa on videos about anti-black racism … 🤨
A conversation that needs to come is ya'll and Candace Owens. Would be a helpful discussion on the topic because Candace has been saying many important facts about what is really going on.
Trent did a video using Candace as an example of a holocaust denier. It appears he and Lila are not open to discussing this with her at all. It is disappointing to say the least because these are two people who have argued tooth and nail about truth and virtue. If they want the truth, stop ignoring the war crimes on Palestine.
@@Ana_Cecilia615Exactly! I dont think they would speak to Candace. Lila said in the interview to Trent to not give them a platform to those “antisemites” basically.
Antisemitism is prejudice or hatred against Jewish people based on their ethnicity or religion. It involves negative stereotypes, discrimination, or violence against Jews simply because they are Jewish. Example: Saying all Jews control the media or are responsible for global events is antisemitism, because it targets Jewish people as a group based on their identity. Criticizing Israel refers to expressing opposition to the policies or actions of the Israeli government, much like criticizing any country's government. This is not antisemitic unless it crosses into denying Israel’s right to exist or targeting Jewish people as a whole for actions taken by Israel. Example: Calling out Israel’s treatment of Palestinians in Gaza is a form of political criticism, not antisemitism, as long as it's focused on policies, not on Jewish people themselves. Criticizing Judaism is about questioning or challenging the religion itself, like any other religion (Christianity, Islam, etc.). Disagreeing with religious beliefs is not inherently antisemitic. Example: Arguing that Jesus was the Messiah, which conflicts with Jewish belief, is religious criticism, not antisemitism, as it’s aimed at a theological point, not at Jews as a people. Summary: Antisemitism = Hatred or prejudice against Jews. Criticizing Israel = Opposing Israeli government policies (not antisemitism unless it denies Israel’s right to exist or targets Jews as a group). Criticizing Judaism = Disagreeing with Jewish religious beliefs, which is not the same as hating Jews. Understanding the difference is important to avoid confusing political or religious criticism with racism or hatred against an entire group of people.
were talking about a group thats been kicked out of 109 countries 1032 times .. the idea that its because of anti semitism and not thier own behavior is crazy
What behaviour would this be? Living in ghettos as virtual prisoners, subject to pogroms every time the rulers want a scapegoat or the locals feel like letting off steam? Or is it working hard to try to make a decent life? Bigot.
What behaviour is that? Living in ghettos as virtual prisoners, subject to pogroms whenever a ruler wants a scapegoat for his failures or the locals feel like letting off steam? Or is it working hard to build a better life? Or lending money to people who don't want to repay their debts? Where is your evidence for Jews being ejected from that many countries? The history of the Jews is ESCAPING from countries.
The methods used to come to those numbers are very loose. What's was considered kicked out or banished? Small province like governments counted as countries. If you look through history for all the times Christians were banished from countries and apply the same standards it ends up being pretty similar. Christians were banished from many parts of Asia and the Middle East as well as most communist regimes. Is this also proof that Christians were wrong and deserved this treatment?
A very incomplete list of times Christians were banished from countries. japan 1612, china 1705, Mexico cristero war, most communist countries, roman empire 313 edict of milan, Persia during the Sassanian empire, and the many islamic conquests throughout history ranging from Spain to Africa.
It doesn't mention Mary because she wasn't in the old testament plus it's commentary which means multiple rabbis give different commentaries so clearly you're lying
@@native00 If one rabbi has an opinion, that's just his opinion but if you attack this rabbi for his opinion, you're actually attacking all Jews. Got it!
But who cares? Why hate a people because they don't believe what you believe? Ephesians 4: 29 Let no evil talk come out of your mouths, but only what is useful for building up, as there is need, so that your words may give grace to those who hear. 30 And do not grieve the Holy Spirit of God, with which you were marked with a seal for the day of redemption. 31 Put away from you all bitterness and wrath and anger and wrangling and slander, together with all malice, 32 and be kind to one another, tenderhearted, forgiving one another, as God in Christ has forgiven you. Luke 6: 32 “If you love those who love you, what credit is that to you? For even sinners love those who love them. 33 If you do good to those who do good to you, what credit is that to you? For even sinners do the same. 34 If you lend to those from whom you hope to receive, what credit is that to you? Even sinners lend to sinners, to receive as much again. 35 But love your enemies, do good, and lend, expecting nothing in return. Your reward will be great, and you will be children of the Most High; for he is kind to the ungrateful and the wicked. 36 Be merciful, just as your Father is merciful. You can disagree with them, pray for them, try to change their mind, but you CANNOT hate them. There are a lot of Christians out there that genuinely hate Jewish people. There's a lot of Christians that hate others for various other reasons too.
@@native00 Wrong! The Babylonian Talmud does mention Jesus, Mary and Joseph (very derogatorily). This demonic book was written at the end of the 5th to the beginning of the 6th century AD by a pharisaic off-shoot to debunk Christianity as the continuation of the Old Testament scriptures . It also distorts the Old Testament to dismiss Christ as the prophesied Messiah. Do your research!
@@holdintheaces7468 Do you really believe that "anti semitism" is based on "Jews rejecting Christ"? If this were true, wouldn't Christians be Anti Every Other Religion? You never hear these claims. Muslims reject Christ as the Messiah. But hatred of Muslims rose significantly after 9/11 and it wasn't because of their rejection of Christ as being the Messiah and Son of God.
She was speaking to Piers Morgan the other day and stated the issue plainly. Judaism is a religion, Israel is a country. We are allowed to be critical of a country that's commiting genocide against a group of people (and are being told to target children). Both Lila and Candace are Catholic and I think would have a very rich conversation about all of this.
@@heatherdembkowski4782to use the word genocide about Gaza is insulting to the the Jews of WW2 who actually experienced genocide. There is no genocide happening in Gaza. The numbers and the intent do NOT qualify for genocide. You should really stop that shit. Also, Candace Owens is OUT OF CONTROL with her demonization and utter lies about Israel. She’s become so toxic it’s almost beyond comprehension.
candace the one he said that stalin was jeush and he unalived many christians? candace the one who said german nas si experiment were propaganda? or candace the one who said that ataturk was jeush and something something Armenian ginoside? candace the fake christian grifter who said that german nas si book burning was justified? candace who thinks that all those examples of her being antisemetic i gave, is not about jeuw hatred but criticism of i§aels war in gaza...and something to do with palestinian children? by the way, there is no credible evidence for stalin or ataturk being jeush...not even the germans belived stalin was jeush...
basically catholic are not anti semitic...on the contrary they love jews because Jesus, Mary Joseph , Peter and so on are all jews...... IMHO criticizing Israel actions for killing innocent civilians especially Christian is not anti semitism.....
The Talmud is a collection of Jewish teachings and discussions, and any references to Jesus (Yeshu) are minimal, often ambiguous, and not focused on attacking Christianity. They reflect historical context, not hate. The Talmud doesn’t contain disrespectful statements about Mary. Jewish beliefs simply differ from Christian ones, particularly regarding the virgin birth and Jesus' divinity. Disagreement ≠ Hatred: Criticizing religious beliefs is normal, but hatred of people based on those beliefs is unacceptable. The Talmud’s religious differences with Christianity do not justify antisemitism or discrimination. Jesus' Teachings: Jesus taught love and forgiveness, and Christians are called to follow those principles, not justify hatred. Modern Interfaith Relations: Today, Jews and Christians work together for peace and understanding, and modern Christian leaders have condemned antisemitism. Religious disagreements are not an excuse for hatred.
I gave you a like and thank you for this comment because in jakob Lorbers scriptures Jesus the one true god clearly said that all heavens of all nations are full of people but just the heaven of the jews is empty SO in fact it’s the complete opposite of what the jews tell in the talmud where they say that Jesus in hell fire for eternity no absolutely not it’s the jews who are there because with them is always WAR time and by the way i habe great respect for jakob lorber because he is a jew i‘m not antisemitic but my greatest respect goes out to the one true GOD Jesus Christ and he is not the god of the jews! He is the god of ALL!!!
I think an episode on “where to draw the line on antisemitism” with Nick Fuentes or Candace Owens is more interesting than this You don’t have to agree with them but you should still have a conversation with them
I love this video. Far right people will use Israel to sneak in their antisemitism. “Ohhh I’m just pointing out how Jews are more liberal… RACE IS REAL AND RACE IS DESTINY! WE NEED TO HAVE IDENTITY IN RACE” like just say you watch Candace Owen’s and Nick Fruentes. I love that mainstream conservatives reject this racism
The Talmud is a collection of Jewish teachings and discussions, and any references to Jesus (Yeshu) are minimal, often ambiguous, and not focused on attacking Christianity. They reflect historical context, not hate. The Talmud doesn’t contain disrespectful statements about Mary. Jewish beliefs simply differ from Christian ones, particularly regarding the virgin birth and Jesus' divinity. Disagreement ≠ Hatred: Criticizing religious beliefs is normal, but hatred of people based on those beliefs is unacceptable. The Talmud’s religious differences with Christianity do not justify antisemitism or discrimination. Jesus' Teachings: Jesus taught love and forgiveness, and Christians are called to follow those principles, not justify hatred. Modern Interfaith Relations: Today, Jews and Christians work together for peace and understanding, and modern Christian leaders have condemned antisemitism. Religious disagreements are not an excuse for hatred.
@@beccalovescraftsJews and other non believes aren’t our enemies. That is not a good mindset for Christians to apply collective motivation to other groups.
Which nation is responsible for 40000 plus deaths in the last year? Deaths of innocent children, elderly, medics, sick people etc? What did Jesus say, that we must love our neighbour. It is in the ten commandments that both Jews and Christians are commanded to follow. Thou shall not kill, thou shall not steal etc.
It's not like Israel went there and started blasting without a cause. I'm not fond of Israeli government but Palestinians are not innocent in the conflict.
"That others may become holier than I, provided that I may become as holy as I should, Jesus, grant me the grace to desire it." That line of the prayer also stands out for me.
@@d3adp94 You totally missed the whole point. It's not a criticism of *race* it's a criticism of their beliefs and actions which nobody (including Jews) are above.
Antisemitism is prejudice or hatred against Jewish people based on their ethnicity or religion. It involves negative stereotypes, discrimination, or violence against Jews simply because they are Jewish. Example: Saying all Jews control the media or are responsible for global events is antisemitism, because it targets Jewish people as a group based on their identity. Criticizing Israel refers to expressing opposition to the policies or actions of the Israeli government, much like criticizing any country's government. This is not antisemitic unless it crosses into denying Israel’s right to exist or targeting Jewish people as a whole for actions taken by Israel. Example: Calling out Israel’s treatment of Palestinians in Gaza is a form of political criticism, not antisemitism, as long as it's focused on policies, not on Jewish people themselves. Criticizing Judaism is about questioning or challenging the religion itself, like any other religion (Christianity, Islam, etc.). Disagreeing with religious beliefs is not inherently antisemitic. Example: Arguing that Jesus was the Messiah, which conflicts with Jewish belief, is religious criticism, not antisemitism, as it’s aimed at a theological point, not at Jews as a people. Summary: Antisemitism = Hatred or prejudice against Jews. Criticizing Israel = Opposing Israeli government policies (not antisemitism unless it denies Israel’s right to exist or targets Jews as a group). Criticizing Judaism = Disagreeing with Jewish religious beliefs, which is not the same as hating Jews. Understanding the difference is important to avoid confusing political or religious criticism with racism or hatred against an entire group of people.
@@SonOfThineHandmaid Those in power equate the two as the same and although you are correct, you will suffer for it (i.e. lose your job, have the media doxx your address and encourage crazies to come attack you).
I live in Israel and have been a big fan of this channel and it is a breath of fresh air that you get it Lila!!! So many ppl on the right are turning against us
Thank you so much Lila and Trent for addressing and condemning the resurgence of antisemitism. This sort of garbage has no place among and should be repugnant to any group of decent and intellectually honest people. (Particulary us conservatives.)
Lils Rose is a great interviwer. I will give her that. I came in with my biases, Iam one of those Christians, who left the evangelical church bse of their love for Isreal . My spirit just couldnt look away from some of the evil things they do. For me the critisism of Isreal has gotten me back to Faith. Bse finally i believe God has no favourites . And Christ is the truth. I dont hate any people and all evil should be called out from which ever group.
As a Catholic, I try to be charitable, especially toward other Brothers and Sisters. Trent did a video defining anti-Semitism and also slandering Candace Owens. It didn't go so well for him. It was truly disappointing. What’s evil is slandering and smearing someone's character. Under Trent's definition of antisemitic, I'm antisemitic and so is my husband and lots of people who are faithful Catholics with no hatred or prejudice in our hearts toward any group of people. I'm critical of the state of Israel just as I am any country. I'm critical of the Cuban government and all communist countries. That doesn't mean I hate Cubans and people from communist countries just because I critique the government. Benjamin Netanyahu is a thug and a criminal. The state of Israel is committing genocide on the Palestinian people. There are no labels you can call me that would ever make me coward down to justify the murder of children. Starving kids, cutting off their water and electricity. Call me ALL the names. The truth is the truth and God knows everyone's hearts no one can hide from our Lord. I only fear God and His judgment, not other people's judgments. I can't believe so many Christians are justifying the genocide Israel is committing because we have been so brainwashed to hold the state of Israel as if it's a false idol. Please seek out the truth. In Israel right now there is an open investigation against Benjamin Netanyahu about fraud regarding the attack on Oct 7th. To me, it's incredibly obvious he knew of the attack and allowed it. God bless everyone, peace be with you all. Christ is King 👑✝️🕊️
@@gabenorman747 So What exactly is "antisemitism"? Were the Council Fathers in Lateran 4 "antisemitic" when they advised in a canon that Jews need to wear distinguishing clothing and should be banned from public office? Was Paul IV "antisemitic" when he placed heavy restrictions on Jews in Cum Nimis Absurdum? You, Trent and Lila throw around a fake term that has no real definition. You are captured by Jewish control and influence. Read up on what Holy Mother Church has taught in its 2,000 year history.
@@Wolfschanzeful Bingo. Was St. Paul anti semitic when he said in 1 Thessalonians 2:15 that the Jews killed the prophets, killed Jesus Christ and are enemies of all mankind?
Israel denies the Armenian genocide, they are definitely hypocrites. And Armenians are the 1st Christian country but Christians fight for Jews more than Armenians. Israel is not a strong ally as many believe. Most 🇮🇱are very liberal while Armenians are Orthodox Christian. And still, Christians defend 🇮🇱 more than the 1st Christian country. I don’t hate them, I just wish they will recognize the hypocrisy
Trent and Lila who are both faithful Catholics are both woefully ill informed on this subject and need to do a lot of research to confront their preconceived biases before breaching this subject. They just sprout their normie con talking points at each other to confirm their own biases. I pray constantly for mainstream Catholics like these two, to show some humility and reach out to their fellow brothers and sisters in Christ like E Michael Jones, Nicholas Fuentes, Candace Owens and Pinesap to seek truth and gain some understanding. But I'm afraid they'll continue to sit on their thrones of arrogance while talking down to their fellow brothers and sisters in Christ.
The Stones will Cry out would provide the context they need on the subject it details the effect of Zionism on Palestinian Christians from multiple perspectives ua-cam.com/video/YwRaWhX_rd4/v-deo.html
Disheartening to see Trent misrepresent our position at 50:00 - 50:35. No one believes he's in a "cabal", we believe that Jews have a very strong ethnic identity due to their history and that makes it difficult to understand their deep rejection of God when you identify as part of that group.
Romans 11 The Remnant of Israel 1 I ask then: Did God reject his people? By no means! I am an Israelite myself, a descendant of Abraham, from the tribe of Benjamin. 2 God did not reject his people, whom he foreknew. Don’t you know what Scripture says in the passage about Elijah-how he appealed to God against Israel: 3 “Lord, they have killed your prophets and torn down your altars; I am the only one left, and they are trying to kill me”[a]? 4 And what was God’s answer to him? “I have reserved for myself seven thousand who have not bowed the knee to Baal.”[b] 5 So too, at the present time there is a remnant chosen by grace. 6 And if by grace, then it cannot be based on works; if it were, grace would no longer be grace. 7 What then? What the people of Israel sought so earnestly they did not obtain. The elect among them did, but the others were hardened, 8 as it is written: “God gave them a spirit of stupor, eyes that could not see and ears that could not hear, to this very day.”[c] 9 And David says: “May their table become a snare and a trap, a stumbling block and a retribution for them. 10 May their eyes be darkened so they cannot see, and their backs be bent forever.”[d]
Is St. Paul an anti semite for saying in 1 Thessalonians 2:15 that the Jews (not all Jews) killed the prophets, killed Christ and are enemies of all mankind?
@@jacobwoods6153G😂😂d Question. But by jews St.Paul never meant Ashkanazis people that have very Insignificant percentage of Levantine DNA,whom entire Evangelical Churchs Refer to as Biblical Israelites from 1890 onwards ❓️❓️❓️❓️❓️
@@jacobwoods6153Jewish high priests and people that new Christ and new the old testament well did indeed reject God knowing full well plenty of things. Jewish people today mostly do not know Christ and the connections.
50:25 I guess 'antisemitism' is not a meaningless term unlike 'racism'. Why didn't Trent Horn feel the need to go on a preamble about unclear definitions?
Lila, if you get the opportunity to invite Candace Owens could the discussion be about the Catholic Church's teaching on the Jewish people? She has stated she has an interest in understanding what the relationship between Christianity and the Jewish people is. Jimmy Akin would probably be the best Catholic to speak with her or Joe Heschmeyer.
The Catholic church does not have anti-semitism but it is anti-Zionist (rightly). The State of Israel is not the Jews of the Old Testament that Christians revere. I think Trent and Lila's Protestant beginnings are showing here.
Assuming you're already a Christian (forgive me if I am wrong) but is it anti semitic for St. Paul to say in 1 Thessalonians 2:15 that the Jews killed the prophets, Jesus Christ and are enemies of all mankind?
The New Testament was written (in terms of human authorship) almost exclusively by Jewish men, at times depicts some Jewish women in a better light than some of the men, and has a lot to do with fascinating arguments between Jewish people. I would hate for you to miss it.
There is no "anti-semitism in the Church" - individuals perhaps, but not "the church". The Church speaks the truth about the State of Israel and has always had the same opinion, which is now bizarrely considered "anti-semitism". Protestants who are Zionists have cognitive dissonance on this topic from brainwashing just like Mary, real presence in the Eucharist, communion of Saints, etc. This is a geo-political issue more than a religious issue as The State of Israel isn't even a religious country anymore.
There has been, since more than 20 years, pointing fingers to that people for bringing them down. Even if all those blaming were wrong, how could it be that the military involvement of the US has caused 23 years later that they have taken all the neighbors I mean, its statistically impossible that those fingers were wrong. Just look at the results. The same with benjamin franklin
Viewing some of the comments indicates that antisemitism is alive and kicking and that young Jews will have to contend with this. Our grandparents and their parents hoped the hatred would disappear and it has among many individuals but it continues and so we have no choice but to be strong and courageous.
Romans 11 Ingrafted Branches 11 Again I ask: Did they stumble so as to fall beyond recovery? Not at all! Rather, because of their transgression, salvation has come to the Gentiles to make Israel envious. 12 But if their transgression means riches for the world, and their loss means riches for the Gentiles, how much greater riches will their full inclusion bring! 13 I am talking to you Gentiles. Inasmuch as I am the apostle to the Gentiles, I take pride in my ministry 14 in the hope that I may somehow arouse my own people to envy and save some of them. 15 For if their rejection brought reconciliation to the world, what will their acceptance be but life from the dead? 16 If the part of the dough offered as firstfruits is holy, then the whole batch is holy; if the root is holy, so are the branches. 17 If some of the branches have been broken off, and you, though a wild olive shoot, have been grafted in among the others and now share in the nourishing sap from the olive root, 18 do not consider yourself to be superior to those other branches. If you do, consider this: You do not support the root, but the root supports you. 19 You will say then, “Branches were broken off so that I could be grafted in.” 20 Granted. But they were broken off because of unbelief, and you stand by faith. Do not be arrogant, but tremble. 21 For if God did not spare the natural branches, he will not spare you either. 22 Consider therefore the kindness and sternness of God: sternness to those who fell, but kindness to you, provided that you continue in his kindness. Otherwise, you also will be cut off. 23 And if they do not persist in unbelief, they will be grafted in, for God is able to graft them in again. 24 After all, if you were cut out of an olive tree that is wild by nature, and contrary to nature were grafted into a cultivated olive tree, how much more readily will these, the natural branches, be grafted into their own olive tree!
I like Trent, but I don’t find him as knowledgeable about the nuances and sensitive issues re: Israel v Palestine as Brett Weinstein. He would be a very very good interviewee on how to view the conflict. ❤
Trent Horn's "The Emptiness of 'Political Christianity" is one of my favorite videos of the year. Trent Horn will be very missed if he retires. I have to think of a Trent Horn quote on the level of "Wax on, Wax Off"...ever since seeing the movie as a kid, I've thought of that quote during the day. I think I've seen all the original 4 Karate Kid movies...yeah, but I did....but I think I thought Drunken Master was the best martial arts movie, and...I saw Bruce Lee movies! Regarding the bombings, Lila, could you do a follow up episode on people tempted to use ends-justify-the-means morality when things get difficult such as tempted toward vigilantism? (If you get Trent on again, I bet he will bring up Batman) And regarding models...Father Mike Schmitz is my favorite man in current media (he almost played Robin in Batman Forever!) and you Lila Rose are my favorite woman. Happy December 20th Day of Advent Freedom Faith-over Fear Funny Friday, Lila and everybody here! Hope you have a light-filled peaceful blessed Merry Christmas full of comfort and joy!
I'M SO SORRY THIS IS OFF TOPIC: Lila - what brand of makeup do you use? I know you use Nimi skincare! I've just gotten back into wearing some makeup to church and getting dressed up :) Feels good. You have beautiful skin and thought I'd ask you! Thank you for this video & for all you do. HUGE fan here! I am inspired to start my own pro life movement in my small town in Ontario, Canada :)
@@gabenorman747 Trent Horn is half Jewish by ethnicity. It wasn't an issue until he decided to make it one by accusing someone of X and then declaring that he wouldn't debate them because it's not worth his time and finally declaring certain topics to be off limits.
@@gabenorman747 By ethnicity, he's half you know what and it was never an issue until he started attacking others and then refusing to engage in a debate over those accusations. Then he declares that he won't discuss these topics because it isn't worth his time.
Lila, you better read about the history of Palestine (and the Levant) to know why it’s unfair to say “oh just give them a little piece of land”. Why does people of your country think you have to right to decide who’s land you give away or not? This whole conversation with Trent about antisemitism is not Christian at all, because it shows you have a prejudice against Arabs and Muslims (the way you say antisemites are with Jews), I wish you grow in charity with people of other countries. This comes from a great fan of yours and your prolife work! I hope you read this…
A strange and inappropriate video. You dont even discuss the Anti-Christian and Anti-White sentiments all over the world specifically in the Western world.
Romans 11 All Israel Will Be Saved 25 I do not want you to be ignorant of this mystery, brothers and sisters, so that you may not be conceited: Israel has experienced a hardening in part until the full number of the Gentiles has come in, 26 and in this way[e] all Israel will be saved. As it is written: “The deliverer will come from Zion; he will turn godlessness away from Jacob. 27 And this is[f] my covenant with them when I take away their sins.”[g] 28 As far as the gospel is concerned, they are enemies for your sake; but as far as election is concerned, they are loved on account of the patriarchs, 29 for God’s gifts and his call are irrevocable. 30 Just as you who were at one time disobedient to God have now received mercy as a result of their disobedience, 31 so they too have now become disobedient in order that they too may now[h] receive mercy as a result of God’s mercy to you. 32 For God has bound everyone over to disobedience so that he may have mercy on them all.
Is Paul a Nazi for saying that the Jews killed the prophets, killed Jesus and are enemies of all mankind in 1 Thessalonians 2:15? Is Jesus a nazi for calling the Pharisees (who being Jews were leaders of the Jewish people) father the devil in John 8? Is it anti semitic to call Jews these things for evil behavior?
@GaserBeam-hi4ez not inmune, but how its possible that notable people from all over the world and different times have warned us and we believe we know better
1. Looking great Trent ! Have you lost weight ? 2. I miss Laura’s channel so much!! Please do a podcast or book or something ! I miss her online wholesome Catholic mom presence in my life! 3. Are you guys not homeschooling anymore ?
Exactly, both used romance to scam people, but only Nala is worthy of forgiveness to cuckservatives like trent, even though they both repudiate their past.
The Tates make themselves easily hated. If they wanted to be liked, they would act like actual men. Instead, they act like slightly conservative, atheistic (hidden behind a loose faith), materialistic, and hedonistic social media influencers. Trent and Lila have not done any "simping" for that Nala girl. Celebrating someone coming to Christ is something that all Christians should do. If she is authentic about her faith or not is up to her. I would argue that most of the Whatever podcast need a LOT of work on their faith life (Brian and Andrew included).
I love Trent Horn!! I love The Council of Trent! Keep up the good work, Tent! I know our Lord is guiding you. And yes, you are slam dunking it! How can I donate to your show! Lyla , same thing for you too! You are amazing!! Thank you for being our advocates!!
By putting up their pictures, it would invite more interest and demand to bring these people on to discuss things and since Candace Owens and Nick Fuentes are eloquent and speak quite openly and passionately about their views, it would be risky that more people might find them reasonable.
@@theurzamachineby blatantly ignoring them it shows the cowardice of Catholic Media into address tuff issues and will draw more people to that loud minority. Whatever your position is on this issue. Everyone should be disappointed with Trent for not engaging with the other side…
What is up with the comments? 🫣 Father Mike Schmitz has had a beautiful reflection on advent being a season to prepare for our death on the Ascension app
Next up: Why is Christian Zionism Evil? But we won't get that episode. I wonder why.
Edit: Although the title of this video has now been changed to "How to Combat Rising Christian Antisemitism", the original title of the video when it was uploaded was "Why is Christian Antisemitism Evil?"
Bcz it's a part of Theology now,since Schofield Bible 1890 it's become a Standard Belief System, that Whatever Aparthide it commits that nation is God Chosen One🤣🤣🤣
ironic that Lila Rose, the poster child for anti-abortion, is sympathizing with a group that pushes abortion.
I support the State of Israel and for its citizens to live in peace and to prosper That makes me a Zionist. You call it evil because you have an evil heart. You hate Jews.
I thought judaism/jewishness had nothing to do with zionism?
what does antisemetism has anything to do with zionism or i§rael?
Why can’t Christian’s or non Christian’s be critical of Israel as a nation and its policies let’s say. Or why can we critique Judaism without being called anti Semitic? No one seems offended by similar criticism of the Islamic faith and or Islamic nations. There needs to be an clear distinction between hate and disagreement for example
Because Zionists give big bucks to christian orgs and have for years.
I have found that it is hard to distinguish between the two when disagreement/criticism is employed to disguise discrimination.
@anniewhaley2287 Probably because bad actors suppress and silence valid arguments and only allow the crazies to flourish.
Came here to say the same thing!
Ok but do you think there could be no acceptable conditions upon which criticism is warranted? That’s a cop out answer. Basically stating it’s just an undercover way to be hateful.. again why is it distinct for only one group?
This episode was such a shame to watch as someone who was brought back to the Catholic Church in part due to Trent’s writings and Lila’s podcast.
“Antisemitism” has become the new “racist.” The church teaches to love and not to hate. It is not hateful to reject the religion of Judaism because it is false. It is not hateful to acknowledge and strongly oppose the strangle grip that the state of Israel has over our entire political system. And NO it is not hateful to acknowledge that a lot of people feel a strong sense of affinity and loyalty to their own ethnicity.
According to numerous studies, blacks, Asians, Hispanics and Jews (with the noticeable absence of whites) have a strong preference for their own people and tend to stick together. That is NOT HATEFUL to acknowledge.
It breaks my heart to see two of the people that I used to so admire who aided in my arrival back to my faith, fall into the same nonsensical leftist talking points that have been used to destroy the church and our country. Shame on the both of you for your cowardice
You're very misguided. Maybe purposely. You are drowning in hatred🫤🫤
Lila would you cover where 400 Jewish organizations came out after Roe. V Wade was overturned and said that abortion is a fundamental Jewish right? Is that acceptable?
Those don't represent the majority of religious Jews however
@@Tom_McMurtry does antisemitism represent the majority of Christians?
@@Tom_McMurtryyes it does. Most religious Jews are liberal
@Tom_McMurtry
Have you done thorough research on this topic? Go read the Talmud, which is a very important book in Judaism, regarding what it says about Jesus and Mary. It also doesn't recognize that life begins at conception, it denies that the fetus is a person. It has all sorts of demonic teachings in it. It also has practical tips on how to subvert Christianity as conversos... I could go on and on. There's a reason why Paul said that the Jews (not all Jews) killed the prophets, killed Jesus and are enemies of all mankind. Apparently there's been a pattern in the leadership before Jesus (killing prophets) during Jesus's time (killing him) and after his time with the Talmud being written down by the successors of the Pharisees... the people who hated Jesus most. I can provide you Jewish scholars that admit the Jews have been behind the subversion of Catholicism for 2000 years by using different tactics. It seems the most common is through backing heretical movements (like the Hussites). This is not coming from me, this is from them...
@@Tom_McMurtry ok? religious jews dont represent the majority of jews either.
Shouldn’t Christians be against that which is anti-Christ? Love your enemies doesn’t mean you can’t acknowledge those who are opposed to you.
so u hate everyone who is not christians? jeus, muslims and arabs in general or only jeus?
Where are Jews saying they hate Christians? There are plenty of people of every race, color, and creed who hate Christians… are you holding the same standard for every people group?
@ Judaism, specifically rabbinical, Talmudic Judaism stemming from the Pharisees of the New Testament is a unique religion in that it explicitly rejects Christ (both Islam and Hinduism venerate Christ as Holy). In this way, Christians and Jews hold oppositional belief systems.
@ Judaism, specifically rabbinical, Talmudic Judaism stemming from the Pharisees of the New Testament is a unique religion in that it explicitly rejects Christ (both Islam and Hinduism venerate Christ as Holy). In this way, Christians and Jews hold oppositional belief systems.
@ Judaism, specifically rabbinical, Talmudic Judaism stemming from the Pharisees of the New Testament is a unique religion in that it explicitly rejects Christ (both Islam and Hinduism venerate Christ as Holy). In this way, Christians and Jews hold oppositional belief systems.
I’m so sick of the way Israel has such a chokehold on even some of the most intelligent Christians. You can love and bless Israel without having to turn a blind eye to what their government has done. Criticizing and questioning what their government is doing now and what they’ve done in the past is NOT antisemitism. Most of us do the same to the American government, so I guess that makes us ALL anti-American according to that logic…
Antisemitism is prejudice or hatred against Jewish people based on their ethnicity or religion. It involves negative stereotypes, discrimination, or violence against Jews simply because they are Jewish.
Example: Saying all Jews control the media or are responsible for global events is antisemitism, because it targets Jewish people as a group based on their identity.
Criticizing Israel refers to expressing opposition to the policies or actions of the Israeli government, much like criticizing any country's government. This is not antisemitic unless it crosses into denying Israel’s right to exist or targeting Jewish people as a whole for actions taken by Israel.
Example: Calling out Israel’s treatment of Palestinians in Gaza is a form of political criticism, not antisemitism, as long as it's focused on policies, not on Jewish people themselves.
Criticizing Judaism is about questioning or challenging the religion itself, like any other religion (Christianity, Islam, etc.). Disagreeing with religious beliefs is not inherently antisemitic.
Example: Arguing that Jesus was the Messiah, which conflicts with Jewish belief, is religious criticism, not antisemitism, as it’s aimed at a theological point, not at Jews as a people.
Summary:
Antisemitism = Hatred or prejudice against Jews.
Criticizing Israel = Opposing Israeli government policies (not antisemitism unless it denies Israel’s right to exist or targets Jews as a group).
Criticizing Judaism = Disagreeing with Jewish religious beliefs, which is not the same as hating Jews.
Understanding the difference is important to avoid confusing political or religious criticism with racism or hatred against an entire group of people.
it’s not at all antisemitic to criticize israeli govt policies, politicians, idf actions, etc. if it was, then the HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS of israelis protesting their govt in the streets would be “antisemitic.” however, a problem arises when people use “the zionists” as a euphemism for jews, or when people defend hamas committing genocidal massacres
@ I agree we shouldn’t call ALL Jews “zionists”, or defend any genocide in general. But that’s what their government is actively pushing for. When we say “the zionists”, we mean their government and all those who support what they’re doing. The problem is that they’re always crying “antisemitism” whenever someone criticizes their government. They make it seem like we hate Jews just because we felt bad seeing videos of innocent children starving and getting blown up.
@@spennywise Not all massacres are genocidal.
Another dissapointing video on Israel.
1. Even if 99% of all critics of Israel or of Jewish individuals are antisemitic, it still doesn't mean that you cannot have the capacity to criticize without being antisemitic.
2. It has nothing to do with hating Jews by their ethnicity. For many yes, but not for ALL critics. Nobody is saying that Jews are inherently evil. But for both Christian and Jewish Zionism are not beyond scrutiny.
3. So if two other nations had similiar conflicts such as the Israelli palistinian conflict, you are telling me that everybody will side with the nation similar to Israel? The only reason people criticize Israel is because it is Jewish? So people being forcefully removed their land isn't a big deal?
I am jewish. I have had people both on the internet and in person tell me jews are inherently evil. In real life it was usually black hebrew Israelite. Online it was usually anti israel christians. Or at least claimed to be Christian I'd like to believe most Christians are better than that. But it definitely exists.
Did you not watch the video? Also nobody was removed from their land before 1948 when Arabs started a war of annihilation against the jews.
The obsession with Israel is what is an issue here LOL, have you heard of the Assyrians, the Kurds, the Druze, have you heard about the Coptics? And even more recent, the Yazidi?
@@AlexCPauwels85 Yes, they're all various ethnic groups of peoples in that region. As far as I know, there are none of them in high level positions of government or media promoting LGBT and abortion and trying to enshrine these as legal rights in America and around the world but I could be wrong.
@@AlexCPauwels85No the Real Obsession is with Evangelicals for Worshipping Israel over Mistaken Identity by Believing East European Caucasians to be Biblical Hebrews😂😂
First off, you gotta define the term. Is it a set of people, a set of behaviors, or a set of national policies, or is the term used as a blanket for all those things, so that anyone who opposes any one of those things gets lumped into the same pool?
Were the Council Fathers at Lateran 4 wrong when they all agreed, in a formal ecumenical council, to declare that Jews should be banned from public office? Was Pope Paul IV likewise "anti semitic" when he did even more to restrict Jewish "rights" in Cum Nimis Absurdum?
Trent and Lila like to pretend that we cant just read what Holy Mother Church taught in its Magisterium over the last 2,000 years.
Antisemitism is prejudice or hatred against Jewish people based on their ethnicity or religion. It involves negative stereotypes, discrimination, or violence against Jews simply because they are Jewish.
Example: Saying all Jews control the media or are responsible for global events is antisemitism, because it targets Jewish people as a group based on their identity.
Criticizing Israel refers to expressing opposition to the policies or actions of the Israeli government, much like criticizing any country's government. This is not antisemitic unless it crosses into denying Israel’s right to exist or targeting Jewish people as a whole for actions taken by Israel.
Example: Calling out Israel’s treatment of Palestinians in Gaza is a form of political criticism, not antisemitism, as long as it's focused on policies, not on Jewish people themselves.
Criticizing Judaism is about questioning or challenging the religion itself, like any other religion (Christianity, Islam, etc.). Disagreeing with religious beliefs is not inherently antisemitic.
Example: Arguing that Jesus was the Messiah, which conflicts with Jewish belief, is religious criticism, not antisemitism, as it’s aimed at a theological point, not at Jews as a people.
Summary:
Antisemitism = Hatred or prejudice against Jews.
Criticizing Israel = Opposing Israeli government policies (not antisemitism unless it denies Israel’s right to exist or targets Jews as a group).
Criticizing Judaism = Disagreeing with Jewish religious beliefs, which is not the same as hating Jews.
Understanding the difference is important to avoid confusing political or religious criticism with racism or hatred against an entire group of people.
They answered this quite clearly. It’s okay to be critical of Israel, but are you unfairly critical, or hyper fixating on Israel while ignoring the same wrongs elsewhere?
@@GaserBeam-hi4ez We focus on Israel more because America finances them and sends them the bombs used to blow civilians up. We focus on it more because it causes the entire Arab world to hate America and attack us (Read what Osama Bin Laden said about why he did 9/11). We focus on it more because Israel controls US politics and stops our politicians from blindly writing cheques to Israel.
@ Considering how much of my tax money goes to support Israel, I feel like I can criticize Israel as much as I feel like.
My unpopular opinion is that antisemitism doesn't carry the same weight it had before. It's thrown around so much, and it changes as it sees fit. Now, it's been pushed into laws in some states. This is why many see it as a problem. You criticise a state, as we are allowed to when we see wrong doing, BUT it's not allowed when it's towards Israel.
In order to really understand the state of Israel (not Jewish people), you have to learn about it. To argue about this without understanding the background is foolish, and it doesn't carry a backbone to your argument. Saying... I heard, or I saw, or I think, doesn't mean anything. It only shows that you're not well-read on the issues.
You are so full of crap. How often do you "we only criticise Israel" people say a word against the truly vicious nations? Against the REAL genocides? Against Hamas, Iran, Sudan? Do you EVER attack the Muslim countries that murder Christians? NO YOU DO NOT.
Were the Council Fathers at Lateran 4 wrong when they all agreed, in a formal ecumenical council, to declare that Jews should be banned from public office? Was Pope Paul IV likewise "anti semitic" when he did even more to restrict Jewish "rights" in Cum Nimis Absurdum?
Trent and Lila like to pretend that we cant just read what Holy Mother Church taught in its Magisterium over the last 2,000 years.
I'm seeing people online just blame everything on Jews and call people they don't like Jewish. They are acting as a Catholic persona online but I'm unsure if they actually are
Antisemitism is prejudice or hatred against Jewish people based on their ethnicity or religion. It involves negative stereotypes, discrimination, or violence against Jews simply because they are Jewish.
Example: Saying all Jews control the media or are responsible for global events is antisemitism, because it targets Jewish people as a group based on their identity.
Criticizing Israel refers to expressing opposition to the policies or actions of the Israeli government, much like criticizing any country's government. This is not antisemitic unless it crosses into denying Israel’s right to exist or targeting Jewish people as a whole for actions taken by Israel.
Example: Calling out Israel’s treatment of Palestinians in Gaza is a form of political criticism, not antisemitism, as long as it's focused on policies, not on Jewish people themselves.
Criticizing Judaism is about questioning or challenging the religion itself, like any other religion (Christianity, Islam, etc.). Disagreeing with religious beliefs is not inherently antisemitic.
Example: Arguing that Jesus was the Messiah, which conflicts with Jewish belief, is religious criticism, not antisemitism, as it’s aimed at a theological point, not at Jews as a people.
Summary:
Antisemitism = Hatred or prejudice against Jews.
Criticizing Israel = Opposing Israeli government policies (not antisemitism unless it denies Israel’s right to exist or targets Jews as a group).
Criticizing Judaism = Disagreeing with Jewish religious beliefs, which is not the same as hating Jews.
Understanding the difference is important to avoid confusing political or religious criticism with racism or hatred against an entire group of people.
There is a lot of growing antisemitism that is NOT just criticism of Israel - mainstream voices saying the H*locaust was greatly exaggerated, the Jews are behind the death of JFK, that’s a lot different than saying “I disagree with this specific thing the IDF did.”
I have yet to hear any real antisemitism from media within my lifetime beyond the movies… I don’t even know where this is coming from. It’s okay to critique a country or a mafia. Calling normal critique racist or antisemitic is ridiculous…
I think the confusion arises when we include symbolic action (eg speech) in the definition. Personally, I prefer emphasizing common human dignity, & the universal call to holiness.
What mafia?
@@beccalovescrafts the Jewish mafia. It’s ridiculous that it’s not even acknowledged that there is a Jewish mafia just how there was/is? an Italian mafia. The simple acknowledge isn’t a testament to ALL Italians or ALL Jews. We basically live in a clown world acting as if all Jews are angels and don’t fall into the same sin the rest of the world does. And it is simply NOT Biblical.
Reading these comments is heartbreaking. I’m a Syrian-Catholic. I grew up in the west, was raised Muslim, but converted to Catholicism when I met my lovely husband.
People in the west don’t understand the kind of persecution people in the Middle East face living under oppressive regimes. Yes, Gazans are dying. And this is because of the fundamentalist regime they were living under. Israel was backed into a corner.
To look at the Middle East and compare it to how we live in the west is simply ignorant.
Not to mention the fact that as Christians, we face so much persecution. I’m truly horrified for Christians right now in Syria. My heart breaks for them. When I compare Syria to Gaza people say it’s different and this is absolutely incorrect. This means you simply don’t understand the political situation.
I was flat out cut off and ostracized from my family for converting to Catholicism. And this, sadly, was getting off easy. I can't visit the middle east because I'm an apostate, and we don't fair well. I wrote an article for Times of Israel, "Why are so many feminists Supporting Ab'siv' men?" The amount of hate I received was horrifying. I wish that on no one.
“None of this means anything!” I’m told. Actually it’s everything. It’s a small window in to the kind of silencing and oppression Arabs face. Especially Arab Christians. But also Arab Muslims forced to live under fundamentalist regimes.
I know it's hard to look at the images you're seeing. But lay blame in the proper direction. It IS anti semitic to be anti zionist because Israel rightfully exists and if you don't believe that you don't know your history and you have bought into anti semitic propaganda. Read proper historical books that teach proper history.
My family would gladly unalive me for converting to Catholicism. And the above article I wrote was icing on the cake for them and justified that they were correct. That I am a “heathen.” My life was up ended because of an opinion piece that makes a very basic point. I LIVE in the WEST. I was BORN in the west. IF you think people in the Middle East have freedom, you’re lying to yourself. Seriously. I live in the west and I’m a doctor and I was truly afraid for my life after I wrote ONE article that was aimed at feminists.
Please have empathy for the Christian Arabs stuck between a rock and a hard place. Do your due diligence and actually look at the history of Israel and how it was formed. It is anti semitic to be anti Zionist and this is simply a FACT.
I didn’t want to write another article because the first one went so poorly in terms of the response. But reading these comments makes me realize that WOW - we have a LONG way to go. I can’t believe so many people have fed into the lie.
This breaks my heart.
people in the west (at least in this generation) are so used to peace that they will never understood the brutal suppression they can be under the Islamic rule. They consider Islamic demographics as just another group of people. It's true that you should take into account the existence of peaceful Muslims but if you are not aware of the danger Islam demographics pose then you are inviting a danger that you or your future generation would never be able to get of.
People in the west have their heads in the sand. They have no concept of Muslim brutality.
Thanks for sharing your story. It seems so hard to understand what's going on with propaganda on both sides. Do you have any resource recommendations?
Explain how it is anti-Semitic to be anti-Zionist. If it is, "...simply a FACT," as you claim, then it should be very simple to demonstrate, no? All you've done is make some specious connection between thinking Israel shouldn't exist, and being opposed to Zionism, which in no way demonstrates that either of those positions have any connection to anti-Semitism.
One Catholic convert to another, I am interested, but a bit confused at this.
@@keymaker2112you need a mirror
Why would you write a book Lila? you don’t have comprehensive history of that region. You just regurgitated media talking points. You lost me. Please look into how Israelis treat Christian Palestinians. It’s not about religion, it’s about land.
Anywhere in Israel the jews control the Christian population has gone up. Anywhere the Arabs control the Christian population plummeted.
it is about religion.. you just dont know what you talking about..
i§rael is the only middle eastern country where the christian population is growing....and have it the best in i§rael...can u find better excuse to hate i§raelis...
Antisemitism is prejudice or hatred against Jewish people based on their ethnicity or religion. It involves negative stereotypes, discrimination, or violence against Jews simply because they are Jewish.
Example: Saying all Jews control the media or are responsible for global events is antisemitism, because it targets Jewish people as a group based on their identity.
Criticizing Israel refers to expressing opposition to the policies or actions of the Israeli government, much like criticizing any country's government. This is not antisemitic unless it crosses into denying Israel’s right to exist or targeting Jewish people as a whole for actions taken by Israel.
Example: Calling out Israel’s treatment of Palestinians in Gaza is a form of political criticism, not antisemitism, as long as it's focused on policies, not on Jewish people themselves.
Criticizing Judaism is about questioning or challenging the religion itself, like any other religion (Christianity, Islam, etc.). Disagreeing with religious beliefs is not inherently antisemitic.
Example: Arguing that Jesus was the Messiah, which conflicts with Jewish belief, is religious criticism, not antisemitism, as it’s aimed at a theological point, not at Jews as a people.
Summary:
Antisemitism = Hatred or prejudice against Jews.
Criticizing Israel = Opposing Israeli government policies (not antisemitism unless it denies Israel’s right to exist or targets Jews as a group).
Criticizing Judaism = Disagreeing with Jewish religious beliefs, which is not the same as hating Jews.
Understanding the difference is important to avoid confusing political or religious criticism with racism or hatred against an entire group of people.
This video is about racism against J*ws. Why did your mind jump to the conclusion that it’s about the nation of Israel? I don’t criticize countries in Africa on videos about anti-black racism … 🤨
Thank you for this episode, Lila. You and Trent are both amazing. May Our Good Lord continue to Bless both of your's work.
A conversation that needs to come is ya'll and Candace Owens. Would be a helpful discussion on the topic because Candace has been saying many important facts about what is really going on.
She's a grifter 😮
Ew, no. Candace is stupid. Please stop letting her indoctrinate you.
@@jaimeteran4067 Lila would destroy her. Candace is an ignoramus
Trent did a video using Candace as an example of a holocaust denier. It appears he and Lila are not open to discussing this with her at all. It is disappointing to say the least because these are two people who have argued tooth and nail about truth and virtue. If they want the truth, stop ignoring the war crimes on Palestine.
@@Ana_Cecilia615Exactly! I dont think they would speak to Candace. Lila said in the interview to Trent to not give them a platform to those “antisemites” basically.
criticism ≠ anti-Semitism
Antisemitism is prejudice or hatred against Jewish people based on their ethnicity or religion. It involves negative stereotypes, discrimination, or violence against Jews simply because they are Jewish.
Example: Saying all Jews control the media or are responsible for global events is antisemitism, because it targets Jewish people as a group based on their identity.
Criticizing Israel refers to expressing opposition to the policies or actions of the Israeli government, much like criticizing any country's government. This is not antisemitic unless it crosses into denying Israel’s right to exist or targeting Jewish people as a whole for actions taken by Israel.
Example: Calling out Israel’s treatment of Palestinians in Gaza is a form of political criticism, not antisemitism, as long as it's focused on policies, not on Jewish people themselves.
Criticizing Judaism is about questioning or challenging the religion itself, like any other religion (Christianity, Islam, etc.). Disagreeing with religious beliefs is not inherently antisemitic.
Example: Arguing that Jesus was the Messiah, which conflicts with Jewish belief, is religious criticism, not antisemitism, as it’s aimed at a theological point, not at Jews as a people.
Summary:
Antisemitism = Hatred or prejudice against Jews.
Criticizing Israel = Opposing Israeli government policies (not antisemitism unless it denies Israel’s right to exist or targets Jews as a group).
Criticizing Judaism = Disagreeing with Jewish religious beliefs, which is not the same as hating Jews.
Understanding the difference is important to avoid confusing political or religious criticism with racism or hatred against an entire group of people.
Denying the h*locaust and placing blame for it on j*ws, blo*d libels, cabal accusations = antisemitism
were talking about a group thats been kicked out of 109 countries 1032 times .. the idea that its because of anti semitism and not thier own behavior is crazy
What behaviour would this be? Living in ghettos as virtual prisoners, subject to pogroms every time the rulers want a scapegoat or the locals feel like letting off steam? Or is it working hard to try to make a decent life? Bigot.
What behaviour is that? Living in ghettos as virtual prisoners, subject to pogroms whenever a ruler wants a scapegoat for his failures or the locals feel like letting off steam? Or is it working hard to build a better life? Or lending money to people who don't want to repay their debts?
Where is your evidence for Jews being ejected from that many countries? The history of the Jews is ESCAPING from countries.
Right! If I one gets fired from 109 jobs, one might think it’s a me problem other than blaming the Employers.
The methods used to come to those numbers are very loose. What's was considered kicked out or banished? Small province like governments counted as countries. If you look through history for all the times Christians were banished from countries and apply the same standards it ends up being pretty similar. Christians were banished from many parts of Asia and the Middle East as well as most communist regimes. Is this also proof that Christians were wrong and deserved this treatment?
A very incomplete list of times Christians were banished from countries.
japan 1612, china 1705, Mexico cristero war, most communist countries, roman empire 313 edict of milan, Persia during the Sassanian empire, and the many islamic conquests throughout history ranging from Spain to Africa.
Oh great! I bet Trent is going to talk about Talmud and the many verses that blaspheme the Blessed Virgin Mary or Christ!
It doesn't mention Mary because she wasn't in the old testament plus it's commentary which means multiple rabbis give different commentaries so clearly you're lying
@@native00 If one rabbi has an opinion, that's just his opinion but if you attack this rabbi for his opinion, you're actually attacking all Jews. Got it!
But who cares? Why hate a people because they don't believe what you believe?
Ephesians 4: 29 Let no evil talk come out of your mouths, but only what is useful for building up, as there is need, so that your words may give grace to those who hear. 30 And do not grieve the Holy Spirit of God, with which you were marked with a seal for the day of redemption. 31 Put away from you all bitterness and wrath and anger and wrangling and slander, together with all malice, 32 and be kind to one another, tenderhearted, forgiving one another, as God in Christ has forgiven you.
Luke 6: 32 “If you love those who love you, what credit is that to you? For even sinners love those who love them. 33 If you do good to those who do good to you, what credit is that to you? For even sinners do the same. 34 If you lend to those from whom you hope to receive, what credit is that to you? Even sinners lend to sinners, to receive as much again. 35 But love your enemies, do good, and lend, expecting nothing in return. Your reward will be great, and you will be children of the Most High; for he is kind to the ungrateful and the wicked. 36 Be merciful, just as your Father is merciful.
You can disagree with them, pray for them, try to change their mind, but you CANNOT hate them. There are a lot of Christians out there that genuinely hate Jewish people. There's a lot of Christians that hate others for various other reasons too.
@@native00 Wrong! The Babylonian Talmud does mention Jesus, Mary and Joseph (very derogatorily). This demonic book was written at the end of the 5th to the beginning of the 6th century AD by a pharisaic off-shoot to debunk Christianity as the continuation of the Old Testament scriptures . It also distorts the Old Testament to dismiss Christ as the prophesied Messiah. Do your research!
@@holdintheaces7468 Do you really believe that "anti semitism" is based on "Jews rejecting Christ"? If this were true, wouldn't Christians be Anti Every Other Religion? You never hear these claims. Muslims reject Christ as the Messiah. But hatred of Muslims rose significantly after 9/11 and it wasn't because of their rejection of Christ as being the Messiah and Son of God.
Please God move Lila's heart to have Candace Owens on her show.
@@wendyunknown8072 Palestinian supporters deserve less mercy grace than Only Fans whores according to these Catholics…
She was speaking to Piers Morgan the other day and stated the issue plainly. Judaism is a religion, Israel is a country. We are allowed to be critical of a country that's commiting genocide against a group of people (and are being told to target children). Both Lila and Candace are Catholic and I think would have a very rich conversation about all of this.
Candace also said that nazi medical experiments sounded like "wierd propoganda" and that jews kill Christians around passover. So literal blood libel.
@@heatherdembkowski4782to use the word genocide about Gaza is insulting to the the Jews of WW2 who actually experienced genocide. There is no genocide happening in Gaza. The numbers and the intent do NOT qualify for genocide. You should really stop that shit. Also, Candace Owens is OUT OF CONTROL with her demonization and utter lies about Israel. She’s become so toxic it’s almost beyond comprehension.
candace the one he said that stalin was jeush and he unalived many christians? candace the one who said german nas si experiment were propaganda? or candace the one who said that ataturk was jeush and something something Armenian ginoside? candace the fake christian grifter who said that german nas si book burning was justified? candace who thinks that all those examples of her being antisemetic i gave, is not about jeuw hatred but criticism of i§aels war in gaza...and something to do with palestinian children? by the way, there is no credible evidence for stalin or ataturk being jeush...not even the germans belived stalin was jeush...
basically catholic are not anti semitic...on the contrary they love jews because Jesus, Mary Joseph , Peter and so on are all jews...... IMHO criticizing Israel actions for killing innocent civilians especially Christian is not anti semitism.....
What did the Talmud say about Jesus again?
It indeed shows they hate the Son of God and thus God?
The Talmud is a collection of Jewish teachings and discussions, and any references to Jesus (Yeshu) are minimal, often ambiguous, and not focused on attacking Christianity. They reflect historical context, not hate.
The Talmud doesn’t contain disrespectful statements about Mary. Jewish beliefs simply differ from Christian ones, particularly regarding the virgin birth and Jesus' divinity.
Disagreement ≠ Hatred: Criticizing religious beliefs is normal, but hatred of people based on those beliefs is unacceptable. The Talmud’s religious differences with Christianity do not justify antisemitism or discrimination.
Jesus' Teachings: Jesus taught love and forgiveness, and Christians are called to follow those principles, not justify hatred.
Modern Interfaith Relations: Today, Jews and Christians work together for peace and understanding, and modern Christian leaders have condemned antisemitism.
Religious disagreements are not an excuse for hatred.
What did Paul say about being willing to give up his own salvation to save the Jews?
I gave you a like and thank you for this comment because in jakob Lorbers scriptures Jesus the one true god clearly said that all heavens of all nations are full of people but just the heaven of the jews is empty SO in fact it’s the complete opposite of what the jews tell in the talmud where they say that Jesus in hell fire for eternity no absolutely not it’s the jews who are there because with them is always WAR time and by the way i habe great respect for jakob lorber because he is a jew i‘m not antisemitic but my greatest respect goes out to the one true GOD Jesus Christ and he is not the god of the jews!
He is the god of ALL!!!
What@@beccalovescrafts
I think an episode on “where to draw the line on antisemitism” with Nick Fuentes or Candace Owens is more interesting than this
You don’t have to agree with them but you should still have a conversation with them
Yes they talk about people without being willing to converse with them.
I love this video. Far right people will use Israel to sneak in their antisemitism. “Ohhh I’m just pointing out how Jews are more liberal… RACE IS REAL AND RACE IS DESTINY! WE NEED TO HAVE IDENTITY IN RACE” like just say you watch Candace Owen’s and Nick Fruentes. I love that mainstream conservatives reject this racism
None of what you put in capitals are racist and none of those two you mentioned are racist.
a little ridiculous im sorry
Literally
@esthernencioni247 what's ridiculous?
For two intelligent well spoken Catholics this was a big nothing burger with a word salad on the side.
What about what the Talmud says about Jesus and Mary!
So, you are Muslim? Quran acknowledges Jesus and Mary ;-)
The Talmud is a collection of Jewish teachings and discussions, and any references to Jesus (Yeshu) are minimal, often ambiguous, and not focused on attacking Christianity. They reflect historical context, not hate.
The Talmud doesn’t contain disrespectful statements about Mary. Jewish beliefs simply differ from Christian ones, particularly regarding the virgin birth and Jesus' divinity.
Disagreement ≠ Hatred: Criticizing religious beliefs is normal, but hatred of people based on those beliefs is unacceptable. The Talmud’s religious differences with Christianity do not justify antisemitism or discrimination.
Jesus' Teachings: Jesus taught love and forgiveness, and Christians are called to follow those principles, not justify hatred.
Modern Interfaith Relations: Today, Jews and Christians work together for peace and understanding, and modern Christian leaders have condemned antisemitism.
Religious disagreements are not an excuse for hatred.
What does the Bible say about loving your enemies?
@@beccalovescraftsJews and other non believes aren’t our enemies. That is not a good mindset for Christians to apply collective motivation to other groups.
@@beccalovescraftsWe are loving them by calling them to conversion.
Which nation is responsible for 40000 plus deaths in the last year? Deaths of innocent children, elderly, medics, sick people etc? What did Jesus say, that we must love our neighbour. It is in the ten commandments that both Jews and Christians are commanded to follow. Thou shall not kill, thou shall not steal etc.
That is pure Hamas lying propaganda.
The IDF are accurate.
Now talk about Palestinians dying or are you only "prolife" for fetuses?
It's not like Israel went there and started blasting without a cause. I'm not fond of Israeli government but Palestinians are not innocent in the conflict.
Yes. This conversation didn't sit well with me either on this topic. Why are they not able to say that this blowout of Palestinians is wrong?
I like your channel so much Lila, I always learn so much.❤
Thanks so much for being here 💛
"That others may become holier than I, provided that I may become as holy as I should, Jesus, grant me the grace to desire it." That line of the prayer also stands out for me.
so sad to see two devout Christians bow down to not just the Jews, but the government of Israel. Christians need to wake up to what’s going on
Jesus was Jewish. 😂
Please educate us Christian’s on what’s goin on.
@@d3adp94
You totally missed the whole point. It's not a criticism of *race* it's a criticism of their beliefs and actions which nobody (including Jews) are above.
Antisemitism is prejudice or hatred against Jewish people based on their ethnicity or religion. It involves negative stereotypes, discrimination, or violence against Jews simply because they are Jewish.
Example: Saying all Jews control the media or are responsible for global events is antisemitism, because it targets Jewish people as a group based on their identity.
Criticizing Israel refers to expressing opposition to the policies or actions of the Israeli government, much like criticizing any country's government. This is not antisemitic unless it crosses into denying Israel’s right to exist or targeting Jewish people as a whole for actions taken by Israel.
Example: Calling out Israel’s treatment of Palestinians in Gaza is a form of political criticism, not antisemitism, as long as it's focused on policies, not on Jewish people themselves.
Criticizing Judaism is about questioning or challenging the religion itself, like any other religion (Christianity, Islam, etc.). Disagreeing with religious beliefs is not inherently antisemitic.
Example: Arguing that Jesus was the Messiah, which conflicts with Jewish belief, is religious criticism, not antisemitism, as it’s aimed at a theological point, not at Jews as a people.
Summary:
Antisemitism = Hatred or prejudice against Jews.
Criticizing Israel = Opposing Israeli government policies (not antisemitism unless it denies Israel’s right to exist or targets Jews as a group).
Criticizing Judaism = Disagreeing with Jewish religious beliefs, which is not the same as hating Jews.
Understanding the difference is important to avoid confusing political or religious criticism with racism or hatred against an entire group of people.
Big difference between anti semitism and anti zonist.
Maybe you see it that way but they equate the two as the same.
@@theurzamachine no because you can be antisemetic to arabs, akkadians, phoenians. in this perticular case is anti zionist.
@@theurzamachine maybe "they" equate the two as the same, but that doesn't mean the two are in fact equal.
Yes
@@SonOfThineHandmaid Those in power equate the two as the same and although you are correct, you will suffer for it (i.e. lose your job, have the media doxx your address and encourage crazies to come attack you).
I live in Israel and have been a big fan of this channel and it is a breath of fresh air that you get it Lila!!! So many ppl on the right are turning against us
What does this mean exactly? The right are not obliged to support you. They should not support your destruction as a people certainly.
Christian anti semitic rhetoric? Really an issue, don't deflect now.
Thank you so much Lila and Trent for addressing and condemning the resurgence of antisemitism. This sort of garbage has no place among and should be repugnant to any group of decent and intellectually honest people. (Particulary us conservatives.)
Lils Rose is a great interviwer. I will give her that.
I came in with my biases, Iam one of those Christians, who left the evangelical church bse of their love for Isreal . My spirit just couldnt look away from some of the evil things they do. For me the critisism of Isreal has gotten me back to Faith. Bse finally i believe God has no favourites . And Christ is the truth. I dont hate any people and all evil should be called out from which ever group.
As a Catholic, I try to be charitable, especially toward other Brothers and Sisters. Trent did a video defining anti-Semitism and also slandering Candace Owens. It didn't go so well for him. It was truly disappointing. What’s evil is slandering and smearing someone's character. Under Trent's definition of antisemitic, I'm antisemitic and so is my husband and lots of people who are faithful Catholics with no hatred or prejudice in our hearts toward any group of people. I'm critical of the state of Israel just as I am any country. I'm critical of the Cuban government and all communist countries. That doesn't mean I hate Cubans and people from communist countries just because I critique the government. Benjamin Netanyahu is a thug and a criminal. The state of Israel is committing genocide on the Palestinian people. There are no labels you can call me that would ever make me coward down to justify the murder of children. Starving kids, cutting off their water and electricity. Call me ALL the names. The truth is the truth and God knows everyone's hearts no one can hide from our Lord. I only fear God and His judgment, not other people's judgments.
I can't believe so many Christians are justifying the genocide Israel is committing because we have been so brainwashed to hold the state of Israel as if it's a false idol. Please seek out the truth. In Israel right now there is an open investigation against Benjamin Netanyahu about fraud regarding the attack on Oct 7th. To me, it's incredibly obvious he knew of the attack and allowed it.
God bless everyone, peace be with you all.
Christ is King 👑✝️🕊️
Except he never said you're antisemitic. You're lying about his definition.
@@gabenorman747there is no definition.
@@gabenorman747 So What exactly is "antisemitism"? Were the Council Fathers in Lateran 4 "antisemitic" when they advised in a canon that Jews need to wear distinguishing clothing and should be banned from public office? Was Paul IV "antisemitic" when he placed heavy restrictions on Jews in Cum Nimis Absurdum?
You, Trent and Lila throw around a fake term that has no real definition. You are captured by Jewish control and influence. Read up on what Holy Mother Church has taught in its 2,000 year history.
@@Wolfschanzeful
Bingo. Was St. Paul anti semitic when he said in 1 Thessalonians 2:15 that the Jews killed the prophets, killed Jesus Christ and are enemies of all mankind?
Israel denies the Armenian genocide, they are definitely hypocrites. And Armenians are the 1st Christian country but Christians fight for Jews more than Armenians. Israel is not a strong ally as many believe. Most 🇮🇱are very liberal while Armenians are Orthodox Christian. And still, Christians defend 🇮🇱 more than the 1st Christian country. I don’t hate them, I just wish they will recognize the hypocrisy
Trent and Lila who are both faithful Catholics are both woefully ill informed on this subject and need to do a lot of research to confront their preconceived biases before breaching this subject. They just sprout their normie con talking points at each other to confirm their own biases. I pray constantly for mainstream Catholics like these two, to show some humility and reach out to their fellow brothers and sisters in Christ like E Michael Jones, Nicholas Fuentes, Candace Owens and Pinesap to seek truth and gain some understanding. But I'm afraid they'll continue to sit on their thrones of arrogance while talking down to their fellow brothers and sisters in Christ.
If you're pro life, you'll agree that antisemitism is wrong. Otherwise you're not pro life by definition, since that's a contradiction.
@@gabenorman747100% but if we’re pro-life we also need to hold the countries we fund accountable if they’re causing the killing of people.
Nicholas Fuentes and the Groypers are actively threatening to grape the children and wives of their political opposition
😂😂😂😂😂😂
The Stones will Cry out would provide the context they need on the subject it details the effect of Zionism on Palestinian Christians from multiple perspectives ua-cam.com/video/YwRaWhX_rd4/v-deo.html
I loved this video!
Disheartening to see Trent misrepresent our position at 50:00 - 50:35. No one believes he's in a "cabal", we believe that Jews have a very strong ethnic identity due to their history and that makes it difficult to understand their deep rejection of God when you identify as part of that group.
Yes, he was strawmanning. And he says he steelmans his opponents…
Romans 11 The Remnant of Israel
1 I ask then: Did God reject his people? By no means! I am an Israelite myself, a descendant of Abraham, from the tribe of Benjamin. 2 God did not reject his people, whom he foreknew. Don’t you know what Scripture says in the passage about Elijah-how he appealed to God against Israel: 3 “Lord, they have killed your prophets and torn down your altars; I am the only one left, and they are trying to kill me”[a]? 4 And what was God’s answer to him? “I have reserved for myself seven thousand who have not bowed the knee to Baal.”[b] 5 So too, at the present time there is a remnant chosen by grace. 6 And if by grace, then it cannot be based on works; if it were, grace would no longer be grace.
7 What then? What the people of Israel sought so earnestly they did not obtain. The elect among them did, but the others were hardened, 8 as it is written:
“God gave them a spirit of stupor,
eyes that could not see
and ears that could not hear,
to this very day.”[c]
9 And David says:
“May their table become a snare and a trap,
a stumbling block and a retribution for them.
10 May their eyes be darkened so they cannot see,
and their backs be bent forever.”[d]
Great video! The anti-semitism I see & hear is absolutely disgusting. People are just mad their bigotry is being called out.
Is "Christian antisemitism more evil than antisemitism? " Pliz enlighten us on the similarities and differences.
Is St. Paul an anti semite for saying in 1 Thessalonians 2:15 that the Jews (not all Jews) killed the prophets, killed Christ and are enemies of all mankind?
Is St. Paul an antisemite for saying in 1 Thessalonians 2:15 that the Jews killed the prophets, Jesus Christ and are enemies of all mankind?
@@jacobwoods6153G😂😂d Question. But by jews St.Paul never meant Ashkanazis people that have very Insignificant percentage of Levantine DNA,whom entire Evangelical Churchs Refer to as Biblical Israelites from 1890 onwards ❓️❓️❓️❓️❓️
@@jacobwoods6153Jewish high priests and people that new Christ and new the old testament well did indeed reject God knowing full well plenty of things. Jewish people today mostly do not know Christ and the connections.
It is so disappointing. I appreciate Lila pro life position but you couldn’t be further from the truth on this topic. Please open your eyes.
Lila Rose talking to someone that supports Palestine challenge: impossible.
26:41 This topic Trent Mentioned is of great importance. Coherence ❤
34:26 Duly noted. While I keep watching, I am wondering if we'll get a similar statement about antisemitism.
50:25 I guess 'antisemitism' is not a meaningless term unlike 'racism'. Why didn't Trent Horn feel the need to go on a preamble about unclear definitions?
I love how Trent speaks of his wife 🥰
Lila, if you get the opportunity to invite Candace Owens could the discussion be about the Catholic Church's teaching on the Jewish people? She has stated she has an interest in understanding what the relationship between Christianity and the Jewish people is. Jimmy Akin would probably be the best Catholic to speak with her or Joe Heschmeyer.
Candace should read the Bible sometime. It would really be beneficial for her.
God Bless the both of you... Keep doing what you are doing... You're both making a huge difference. Love from Australia
Thank you for addressing this, Lila and Trent. Anti-semitism in the church is one of the biggest stumbling blocks to me becoming Catholic.
The Catholic church does not have anti-semitism but it is anti-Zionist (rightly). The State of Israel is not the Jews of the Old Testament that Christians revere. I think Trent and Lila's Protestant beginnings are showing here.
Assuming you're already a Christian (forgive me if I am wrong) but is it anti semitic for St. Paul to say in 1 Thessalonians 2:15 that the Jews killed the prophets, Jesus Christ and are enemies of all mankind?
The New Testament was written (in terms of human authorship) almost exclusively by Jewish men, at times depicts some Jewish women in a better light than some of the men, and has a lot to do with fascinating arguments between Jewish people. I would hate for you to miss it.
There is no "anti-semitism in the Church" - individuals perhaps, but not "the church". The Church speaks the truth about the State of Israel and has always had the same opinion, which is now bizarrely considered "anti-semitism". Protestants who are Zionists have cognitive dissonance on this topic from brainwashing just like Mary, real presence in the Eucharist, communion of Saints, etc. This is a geo-political issue more than a religious issue as The State of Israel isn't even a religious country anymore.
Are you serious?
Thank you for this video Lila!
Already was, just heard the Tates case being dismissed.
Ah! Those adorable porn-peddling Muslims who trick Christian girls into being whores. Doncha just love them?
There has been, since more than 20 years, pointing fingers to that people for bringing them down. Even if all those blaming were wrong, how could it be that the military involvement of the US has caused 23 years later that they have taken all the neighbors
I mean, its statistically impossible that those fingers were wrong. Just look at the results.
The same with benjamin franklin
Viewing some of the comments indicates that antisemitism is alive and kicking and that young Jews will have to contend with this. Our grandparents and their parents hoped the hatred would disappear and it has among many individuals but it continues and so we have no choice but to be strong and courageous.
No, you do not for the most part.
Great video thanks :))
Romans 11 Ingrafted Branches
11 Again I ask: Did they stumble so as to fall beyond recovery? Not at all! Rather, because of their transgression, salvation has come to the Gentiles to make Israel envious. 12 But if their transgression means riches for the world, and their loss means riches for the Gentiles, how much greater riches will their full inclusion bring!
13 I am talking to you Gentiles. Inasmuch as I am the apostle to the Gentiles, I take pride in my ministry 14 in the hope that I may somehow arouse my own people to envy and save some of them. 15 For if their rejection brought reconciliation to the world, what will their acceptance be but life from the dead? 16 If the part of the dough offered as firstfruits is holy, then the whole batch is holy; if the root is holy, so are the branches.
17 If some of the branches have been broken off, and you, though a wild olive shoot, have been grafted in among the others and now share in the nourishing sap from the olive root, 18 do not consider yourself to be superior to those other branches. If you do, consider this: You do not support the root, but the root supports you. 19 You will say then, “Branches were broken off so that I could be grafted in.” 20 Granted. But they were broken off because of unbelief, and you stand by faith. Do not be arrogant, but tremble. 21 For if God did not spare the natural branches, he will not spare you either.
22 Consider therefore the kindness and sternness of God: sternness to those who fell, but kindness to you, provided that you continue in his kindness. Otherwise, you also will be cut off. 23 And if they do not persist in unbelief, they will be grafted in, for God is able to graft them in again. 24 After all, if you were cut out of an olive tree that is wild by nature, and contrary to nature were grafted into a cultivated olive tree, how much more readily will these, the natural branches, be grafted into their own olive tree!
I like Trent, but I don’t find him as knowledgeable about the nuances and sensitive issues re: Israel v Palestine as Brett Weinstein. He would be a very very good interviewee on how to view the conflict. ❤
Trent Horn's "The Emptiness of 'Political Christianity" is one of my favorite videos of the year. Trent Horn will be very missed if he retires. I have to think of a Trent Horn quote on the level of "Wax on, Wax Off"...ever since seeing the movie as a kid, I've thought of that quote during the day. I think I've seen all the original 4 Karate Kid movies...yeah, but I did....but I think I thought Drunken Master was the best martial arts movie, and...I saw Bruce Lee movies! Regarding the bombings, Lila, could you do a follow up episode on people tempted to use ends-justify-the-means morality when things get difficult such as tempted toward vigilantism? (If you get Trent on again, I bet he will bring up Batman)
And regarding models...Father Mike Schmitz is my favorite man in current media (he almost played Robin in Batman Forever!) and you Lila Rose are my favorite woman.
Happy December 20th Day of Advent Freedom Faith-over Fear Funny Friday, Lila and everybody here! Hope you have a light-filled peaceful blessed Merry Christmas full of comfort and joy!
Hmmm, I wonder why they let the original attack happen? 🤔Maybe to justify something possibly?
Two of my favorite people to listen to!
I'M SO SORRY THIS IS OFF TOPIC: Lila - what brand of makeup do you use? I know you use Nimi skincare! I've just gotten back into wearing some makeup to church and getting dressed up :) Feels good. You have beautiful skin and thought I'd ask you! Thank you for this video & for all you do. HUGE fan here! I am inspired to start my own pro life movement in my small town in Ontario, Canada :)
Crazy but should be unsurprising Trent going back to his roots.
What does this mean?
@@gabenorman747 Trent Horn is half Jewish by ethnicity. It wasn't an issue until he decided to make it one by accusing someone of X and then declaring that he wouldn't debate them because it's not worth his time and finally declaring certain topics to be off limits.
@@gabenorman747I think the commenter is pointing out Trent's part Jewish lineage
The Gospel?
@@gabenorman747 By ethnicity, he's half you know what and it was never an issue until he started attacking others and then refusing to engage in a debate over those accusations. Then he declares that he won't discuss these topics because it isn't worth his time.
Lila, you better read about the history of Palestine (and the Levant) to know why it’s unfair to say “oh just give them a little piece of land”. Why does people of your country think you have to right to decide who’s land you give away or not? This whole conversation with Trent about antisemitism is not Christian at all, because it shows you have a prejudice against Arabs and Muslims (the way you say antisemites are with Jews), I wish you grow in charity with people of other countries. This comes from a great fan of yours and your prolife work! I hope you read this…
Great video!
🙏🔯✝️🌿🕊💞
A strange and inappropriate video. You dont even discuss the Anti-Christian and Anti-White sentiments all over the world specifically in the Western world.
They literally did around 1 hour in lmbo.
Romans 11 All Israel Will Be Saved
25 I do not want you to be ignorant of this mystery, brothers and sisters, so that you may not be conceited: Israel has experienced a hardening in part until the full number of the Gentiles has come in, 26 and in this way[e] all Israel will be saved. As it is written:
“The deliverer will come from Zion;
he will turn godlessness away from Jacob.
27 And this is[f] my covenant with them
when I take away their sins.”[g]
28 As far as the gospel is concerned, they are enemies for your sake; but as far as election is concerned, they are loved on account of the patriarchs, 29 for God’s gifts and his call are irrevocable. 30 Just as you who were at one time disobedient to God have now received mercy as a result of their disobedience, 31 so they too have now become disobedient in order that they too may now[h] receive mercy as a result of God’s mercy to you. 32 For God has bound everyone over to disobedience so that he may have mercy on them all.
Yay! Thanks for doing this!
Wow this topic sute brought out the Nazis
Is Paul a Nazi for saying that the Jews killed the prophets, killed Jesus and are enemies of all mankind in 1 Thessalonians 2:15? Is Jesus a nazi for calling the Pharisees (who being Jews were leaders of the Jewish people) father the devil in John 8? Is it anti semitic to call Jews these things for evil behavior?
Seriously!
How is it possible that martin luther, benjamin franklin, henry ford, walt disney and so many other greatest minds of humanity were wrong?
Most if not all of those guys were Masons
Are you saying people who do some good things are immune to being wrong?
@GaserBeam-hi4ez not inmune, but how its possible that notable people from all over the world and different times have warned us and we believe we know better
So weird that Horn's attitude seems to place his jewishness above his faith. I think Fuentes might have been right about him.
Proof?
@@gabenorman747 Right where I like it: in the pudding, nigga. 😎
1. Looking great Trent ! Have you lost weight ?
2. I miss Laura’s channel so much!! Please do a podcast or book or something ! I miss her online wholesome Catholic mom presence in my life!
3. Are you guys not homeschooling anymore ?
Lyla please stop interrupting your guests. Yikes this was hard to listen to due to the constant interruptions.
HAHAHAHA I’m *loving* Trent fanboying after Karate Kid LOL now he’s 1000% the best male role model (after Jesus ofc) I can think of, amazing! 😂
Yay! I love seeing Trent back ! He’s the best!
You should have Mike Winger on the show! He loves live action and what they're doing.
Comment for traction
Trent going full nerd about Karate Kid was priceless. 🤣
hi
I like Lila but she constantly interrupts Trent here. I wish Trent was allowed to finish his thought without Leila interjecting too often.
Both these fools hate Tates but will simp for Nala.
Exactly, both used romance to scam people, but only Nala is worthy of forgiveness to cuckservatives like trent, even though they both repudiate their past.
Tate is a human trafficker regardless of what you might like about him
The Tates make themselves easily hated. If they wanted to be liked, they would act like actual men. Instead, they act like slightly conservative, atheistic (hidden behind a loose faith), materialistic, and hedonistic social media influencers. Trent and Lila have not done any "simping" for that Nala girl. Celebrating someone coming to Christ is something that all Christians should do. If she is authentic about her faith or not is up to her. I would argue that most of the Whatever podcast need a LOT of work on their faith life (Brian and Andrew included).
I dislike them both.
@@d3adp94 same
I love Trent Horn!! I love The Council of Trent! Keep up the good work, Tent! I know our Lord is guiding you. And yes, you are slam dunking it! How can I donate to your show!
Lyla , same thing for you too! You are amazing!! Thank you for being our advocates!!
Pearl destroyed Trent horn
Sure she did Kyle.
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Incel
Pearl is a ginger Ann Coulter. 😅
The only thing Pearl is capable of destroying is her own credibility. She’s so unlikeable, I’m genuinely blown away that she still has a following.
Andrew Tate? Why not put Candace Owens or nick fuentes? the 2 of them openly praises the Naz people
Tate praised Yahya Sinwar, but Candace and Nick are both ignorant about Israel.
Are you an idiot?! When does she do that? Get help
By putting up their pictures, it would invite more interest and demand to bring these people on to discuss things and since Candace Owens and Nick Fuentes are eloquent and speak quite openly and passionately about their views, it would be risky that more people might find them reasonable.
If you think Candace did that, then you are rėtarded.
@@theurzamachineby blatantly ignoring them it shows the cowardice of Catholic Media into address tuff issues and will draw more people to that loud minority. Whatever your position is on this issue. Everyone should be disappointed with Trent for not engaging with the other side…
What is up with the comments? 🫣 Father Mike Schmitz has had a beautiful reflection on advent being a season to prepare for our death on the Ascension app